Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 13

New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics

ISSN: 0028-8306 (Print) 1175-8791 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/tnzg20

Age of metamorphism and uplift in the Haast


Schist Group at Haast Pass, Lake Wanaka and Lake
Hawea, South Island, New Zealand

C.J. Adams & J.E. Gabites

To cite this article: C.J. Adams & J.E. Gabites (1985) Age of metamorphism and uplift
in the Haast Schist Group at Haast Pass, Lake Wanaka and Lake Hawea, South Island,
New Zealand, New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics, 28:1, 85-96, DOI:
10.1080/00288306.1985.10422278

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00288306.1985.10422278

Published online: 02 Feb 2012.

Submit your article to this journal

Article views: 168

View related articles

Citing articles: 14 View citing articles

Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at


http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=tnzg20

Download by: [Monash University Library] Date: 16 December 2016, At: 22:51
New Zealand Journal 01 Geology and Geophysics, 1985, Vol. 28: 85-96 85
0028-8306/85/2801-0085$2.50/0 © Crown copyright 1985

Age of metamorphism and uplift in the Haast Schist Group at


Haast Pass, Lake Wanaka and Lake Hawea, South Island,
New Zealand

C. J. ADAMS amounts in the chlorite zone greenschist facies


rocks. Graphical display of the K and 4°Ar (radi-
J. E. GA BITES ogenic) contents of the K-poor and K-rich mineral
Institute of Nuclear Sciences phases suggests that the excess argon was uni-
Department of Scientific and Industrial Research formly distributed throughout the rocks during an
Private Bag isotopic rehomogenisation event 12 ± 5 Ma aga
Lower Hutt, New Zealand (Miocene-Pliocene). This young age must reftect
the time of the last uplift of the Haast Schist near
the Alpine Fault during the formation ofthe South-
Abstract Potassium-argon ages are reported for ern Alps. It is suggested that this uplift phase during
mineral and total-rock sampies from the progres- the Kaikoura (Miocene-Recent) orogeny was
sively metamorphosed Haast Schist sequence in the sufficiently rapid and localised to cause some heat-
Haast valley, Haast Pass, Lake Wanaka, and Lake ing during shearing, and consequent radiogenic
Hawea areas of Otago, South Island. These rocks argon loss from micas, and re-incorporation under
extend from low-grade (chlorite zone greenschist a high argon partial pressure into coexisting K-poor
facies) near Lake Hawea, through medium-grade phases such as plagioclase and hornblende.
(biotite and gamet zone greenschist facies) in the
Haast valley, to high-grade (amphibolite facies) near Keywords South Island; Haast Schist Group;
the Alpine Fault. The ages of total-rock and micas Jurassic; Cretaceous; Cenozoic; K/Ar; dates; meta-
show a general eastwards decrease from the Alpine morphic rocks
Fault in three zones. (I) More than 25 km east of
the fault, the ages increase steadily from 120 to I 73
Ma near Lake Hawea. These ages are interpreted
as a cooling age pattern resulting from continued
slow uplift, which began after the main (Rangitata) INTRODUCTION
metamorphism at least 173 Ma aga (mid Jurassic) Geosynclinal sediments of Permian-Cretaceous age
and which continued until at least 120 Ma aga (mid form a very large part of the South Island, New
Cretaceous). (2) In a transitional zone, between 15 Zealand, and were folded and metamorphosed
and 25 km from the fault, the mineral and total- during a Jurassic-Cretaceous (Rangitata) orogeny
rock ages increase rapidly eastwards from about 20 (see the general review by Reming 1970). Within
Ma to 120 Ma. It is possible that these ages may this fold-belt, the medium-high-grade metamor-
also be a cooling age pattern, reftecting the contin- phic rocks form aschist arc, extending from Marl-
uation of uplift at a much slower rate throughout borough in the northeast (Marlborough schists),
the late Cretaceous and Cenozoic, but it is more then southwestwards in a narrow, 25 km zone along
probable that the ages represent a section in the the Southern Alps (Alpine schists) (Hutton &
metamorphic sequence where only partial accu- Turner 1936; Mason 1962), into a much broader
mulation of argon has taken place while buried at northwest-southeast-trending region across Otago
depth. (3) In a narrow 10 km zone adjacent to the (Otago schists) to the east Otago coast near Dune-
fault, the mica and total-rock ages are very young din (Fig. I). The three schist areas are termed the
(12-30 Ma) but the coexisting hornblende and pla- Haast Schist Group (Suggate 1961). In Canterbury
gioclase ages are very widely discordant (40-1600 and northeast Otago, the Haast Schist grades east-
Ma). This indicates that excess argon is definitely wards and northeastwards into a nonschistose,
present in the plagioclase and hornblende and pos- Carboniferous-Cretaceous, greywacke suite, the
sibly throughout the rocks as a wh oie. Amounts of Torlesse facies, wh ich is usually at zeolite facies,
excess argon in the high-grade schists are 1-4 nljg, prehnite-pumpellyite or pumpellyite-actinolite
and they decrease westwards to less than 0.5 nljg metamorphic facies. In South Otago, the Haast
in the biotite zone greenschist facies and to zero Schist grades into nonschistose sediments of Per-
mian-Jurassic age ofthe Caples and Hokonui facies,
wh ich are normally at or below prehnite-pumpel-
Received 28 OClober 1981. accepled 8 June 1984 Iyite metamorphic grade.
86 New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics, 1985, Vol. 28

(Kaikoura) orogeny, during the formation of the


Southern Alps, inftuenced the uplift and hence the
K-Ar age pattern.
~ Haast Schist Group
In this paper, we examine in more detail the
lu>J Igneous plutons transition between the two age patterns suggested
1.1 Post-Rangitata Orogeny
terrestrial sediments
by Harper & Landis (1967) in the classic geological
profile across a progressively metamorphosed
sequence of Barrovian type in western Otago, in
the region of Lake Wanaka and Lake Hawea, near
Haast Pass, and the lower Haast valley, Otago (Fig.
I) (see Turner 1968, pp. 29-34; Miyashiro 1973,
pp. 382-386). This forms part of a broader study
of age profiles across the schist are. In a previous
study ofthe Haast Schist terrane in northeast Otago,
completely remote from the Alpine Fault region,
Adams et al. (in press) reported a simple age pat-
tern, extending continuously from about 200 Ma
Dunedtn (earliest Jurassic) to about 150 Ma (latest Jurassie),
from a metasedimentary sequence ranging from
I
\ very low grade Torlesse facies into lower greensch-
\ 100km ist facies Haast Schist. They ascribed this pattern
L..--...J
!ß,,"tlt. entirely to long-continued uplift and cooling of the
" schist arc during the Jurassie (and part of the Cre-
taceous) after the very early Jurassie (Rangitata)
Fig. I Elements of the New Zealand Geosyncline in the regional metamorphism.
South Island, New Zealand, with the location ofthe Haast
Pass study area (see detail in Fig. 2 and 3). The predom-
inantly medium-high-grade metamorphic area of the
Haast Schist Group with the subareas ofthe Alpine schists
(A), Otago schists (0), and Marlborough schists (M) is GEOLOGICAL OUTLINE
separated by the Median Tectonic Line (MTL) from the
predominantly igneous plutons of the Foreland terrane The progressively metamorphosed sequence of the
(F) to the west and the low-grade metamorphic Permian- Haast Schist in the southern part of the Southern
Jurassic rocks ofthe Hokonui terrane (H) and Caples ter- Alps, from Mt Cook southwards to the Haast River
rane (c) to the south. To the east of the Haast Schist are valley and to Lake Wanaka, is a classic profile of
low-grade metamorphic, Carboniferous-Jurassic sedi- its type (Turner 1968). The schists are quartzofeld-
ments of the Torlesse terrane (T).
spathic metasediments of (?)permian-Triassie age
with minor basic horizons (Mason 1962; Cooper
1972, 1980) and they grade eastwards, in the far
east of the study area, into nonschistose Permian-
Age studies ofthe metamorphie rocks within the Triassie Torlesse sediments (Fig. 2).
schist are have shown that the mineral and total- The schists are structurally complex and the ear-
rock ages range very widely from I to 200 Ma liest fold phase formed recumbent nappes during
(Mason 1961; Hurley et al. 1962; Harper & Landis lower greenschist facies metamorphism. A new
1967; Sheppard et al. 1975; Adams 1981; Adams phase of folding then formed steeply plunging folds
et al. 1984). Harper & Landis (1967) first suggested and associated axial-plane schistosity, synchronous
that the ages followed two patterns: (I) more than with the main phase of greenschist-amphibolite
25 km east ofthe Alpine Fault, the ages ofthe Haast facies metamorphism. In the last structural phase,
Schist and immediately adjacent rocks ranged from these metamorphie isograds were then gently folded.
about 100 Ma to about 140 Ma (mid-early Cre- The detailed structural geology of the Southern
taceous), and because they were inversely corre- Alpine region is given by Grindley (1963), Cooper
lated with metamorphie grade, they must represent (1974), and Findlay (1979). In the Haast valley,
cooling ages of the schists during postorogenic there are (?)Cretaceous lamprophyre dikes (Cooper
(Rangitata) uplift; (2) in a narrow, 25 km zone & Wellman 1971) that cut across the metamorphie
immediately east of the Alpine Fault, the ages are isograds, but are parallel to the latest fold axes.
very much younger, down to less than 10 Ma, and The metamorphie zonation was established in
these are directly correlated with distance from the local mineralogical and textural terms by Hutton
fault. It was suggested that horizontal and vertical & Turner (1936) and extended and modified in
movements on the fault during the Miocene-Recent detail by Mason (1962) and Cooper (1972, 1974).
~

3
'"Ra
~
~.

o
l
...,
3
o
ji;'
3
o
.a::r
;;; .
44°15'8 44°15'8
.3
::z::
Cl
New
'"
~
-e:
Z".'d} • K-Ar age (Ma) ~
b= biotite
h = hornblende
fistUdY m = muscovite
y~rea t= total rock

44°30'8 44°30'8

o 5 10 5 10
I " " I I
o
" " I I I
km km
169°30'E 169°30'E

Fig. 2 Geological sketch map of the Haast Pass, Lake Wanaka, Fig.3 Geological map as in Fig. 2, showing the ages ofthe biotite,
and Lake Hawea area, Otago, showing the location of the sam pIes muscovite, hornblende, and total-rock sampIes but excluding all
dated in this study in relation to metamorphic zones in the Haast plagioclase and hornblende ages that are very old owing to large
Schist Group, taken from the 1:250 000 geological map of New 00
concentrations of excess argon (see text). -.J
Zealand (also shown are the textural subdivisions of the chlorite
zone (1-4) ofthe greenschist facies.
00
Table 1 Potassium-argon age da ta of Haast Schist at Haast Pass, Lake Wanaka, and Lake Hawea, South Island. 00

ROL:!';: type Location Grid re.f. K wt% 40 Ar /}6 Ar 40 Ar /)b Ar 40 Ar (rad) Age Ma t
INS R no.* Fi-"ld no. Mesh e Ol
x 10 5 xl O} nIL!> cE total

}464TR ADHl5 -422+211 Riotite schist, First roadside bluf'f', 587/894057 2.58 8.25 1. 6') 2.88 82.0 28.5.!.0.2
Garnet-oligoclase Haast ()10 mi). 5.12 1.14 2.91 74.0 28.8±.0.2
facies.
}464PI -211+104 0.175 0.76 1.45 1.8} 79.7 25 1±.2
1. 20 2.16 1.85 86.3 Z5 4±,2
3464Bi 6.01 6.45 0.908 3.89 67.5 1('. 6+0.1
3465TR AD186 -422+211 2.80 8.27 1.99 3.91 85·2 35.7±:0.3
3465PI 0.6)6 0.213 0.561 4.21 47.) 163+1
2.41 2.74 4.40 89.2 17 0±:'
3465Bi 5.81 (,.49 0.130 2.65 59·5 11. 7.±.O. 1
}465Mu 5.06 0.9 17 0.}82 3.24 22.5 16.4+0.1
2. JO 0.517 3.33 42.9 16.9+0.1
3466TR AD187 _422+211 Big Blu.ff, Haast 2.47 5.30 1.38 ).44 78.6 35.5±:0.)
() 10.2 mi).
}',66pl 0.574 2"" 85 2.16 2.49 86.} 111 + 1
)466Bi 6.61 2.8) 0.56) 4.27 47.5 16.5:;0.1
6288TR HP12 Leucocratic bi-mu Rig Blur1, Haast. S~7/895098 2.89 3.59 0.936 3.52 68.4 31.1+0.2
schist. 5.45 1.26 3.50 76.6 30.8±:0.2 Z
0.436 1.25 1.48 2.82 80.1 0
6288PI '59±.'
1.47 1.70 2.84 82.6 160+ 1 ~
(288Bi 7.)2 8.52 1.1) 4.89 73.9 17.1+0.1 N
6288Mu 7.21 4.94 0.722 4.24 59.1 15.1'';0.1 0
~
L.19 0.819 4. 1 5 63.9 14.8+0.1
6289TR HP13 Garnet-biotite 0.280 0.869 0.664 0.81 ') 5. ') 7 2 .9±:0.5
6i
;:3
greenschist. 0.
(,289pI 0.058 0.155 0.533 0.61 44.5 25' ±.2 '-
6289Hb 0.4)6 2.29 1. 15 1.11 74.2 64. 1 +0. 5 0
2.26 ,. 15 1.1) 74.4 65. 5±:0. 5 C
6289Gar ;I
3467TR AD188 _422+111 Gneissose biotite Thomas Blu:f:f, 587/9)4037 3.04 1:'.98 1.95 2.14 84.8 18. '±.O. 1 e:.
~chist, garnet- Haast River.
oligoclase .facies.
0...,
3467Ri 1'.93 5.26 0.692 3.5 C 57.) 1).2±.0.1
1.25 1).2±.0.1
12.03 3. ')0 76.3 a
0
3468TR AD189 -422+211 1.99 12.0 1.RO 1.70 83. "J 21.8+0.2 0
3468Bi 5.94 9.69 1.2H 6.28 76.8 12.2+0.1 5'
_422+211 587/983007 ).08 1').02 2.6) 3.27 88.8 26.5±:0.2 (JQ
341.9TR AD 190 Garnet-oligoclase '<:
semischiet with
~
biotite. ;:3
14L98i 6.57 6.99 1. 28 6.2S 7L.8 24.4+0.2 0.
3470TR AD 19 ' 3.16 7.75 1.47 ).27 79.9 26.4+0.2
3470Bi L.58 2.24 0.1,01 L. 12 50.8 23.8-:;0.2 a
1.3S (;,.22 24.2-:;0.2 0
7.86 78.7 0
3471TR AD192 Biotite-garnet- E end 01 Hallway 2.14 7.13 1. 5) 2.32 80.7 27. R±0.2 '0
oligoclase semi- Blull, Haast R. ::r
'<:
schist.
)471PI _211+104 0.579 3. 10 1.13 1.07 74.0 46.8+0.J (=i'
'"
)4718i 6.62 4.59 0.786 4.83 L2.4 18.7±:0.1 JI'
3472Bi AD193 6.56 4.68 0.836 5. '7 64.6 20.2+0.2
7.71 1.21 5.) 1 75.6 20.7±:0.2 \0
Biotite-feldspar Nea r Depot Ck. 0087/019025 2.52 5. 12 1.09 2.67 72.9 27. '±.O. 2 00
3413TR AD194 VI
semischist. Baast R.
3413PI 0.103 2.23 2.92 0.83 89.9 19 6±.'
347)Bi 7.39 7.24 1.13 5.80 73.8 20.1+0.1 <
0
}4748i AD19'5 7. 12 6.07 0.94 '5 S. 19 68.7 18.7-:;:-0.2 !"""
J476TR ADl97 _422+211 quartz-feldspar- Near Falls, H.:last R. 087/021028 1.76 ).30 0.940 2.JS 1.8.6 3 4 .O±:O.2 N
hlot ite schist. 00
Table I (conlinued) ;..
0-
~
INS R no. Field no. Mesh ~m Rock type Lücation Aga Ma
t 3
Grid ref. K wt% 40 Ar (rad)
. 40 Ar /,6 Ar 40 Ar /,6 Ar
x 10 5 x 10' nl!g % total '"~
,47vPl -211+125 0.175 0.40 0.660 1.08 55·, 15 2.±,1
,476Bi 7.21 3.54 0.631 4.66 1
'j'. 1v. 6+0.1 a
v286TR HP10 -422+211 Blotite-feldspar- 500 m W Mossy Ck, S87/0270,4 1.02 42.6 ~
2.45 0.515 ,.59 37. 4:;::0.2
oligoclase-earnet Haast R. 3. 6 8 1.05 ,.44 72. 0 ,5. 8.±,0.2 9':
gneiss. ~
6286p] 0.08 0.251 1.41 2.,7 79.1 6 SO.±,5
-
6286Bi 7.)6 7.92 1.18 5-. GO 74.9 19. 5.±.O. 1
'"I
6287TR HPll -422+211 H{)rnblende-biotite- 1.37 1.22 0.780 3·70 62.1 bIO. 4.±,0. 5 ;..
(JC1
oligoclase gneiss. ~
6287Pl 0.04 0.1" 1.12 1. 55 73.5 847+6
6287Bi -422+178 '<..89 0.,2 0
1.77 7.79 8,., 40.6:;::0.2 ...,
5.,0 1.53 7.75 80.7 40.4.±,0.3
6287Hb 0.568 3.36 4. 16 4.46 92.9 19 2.±,2 3
~
6477TR GWG71 -422+211 Coarse foliated 0.4}6 1.52 0.769 0.93 61. v 54.0.±,0.4 ~
hornblende gneiss. 1. 59 0.755 0.90 61.9 52. 2.±,0. 4
3
6477Pl
6477Hb
0.09
0.586
0.621 0.819 0.50
1. ,0
63.9 142+ 1
-0
1.56 0.805 63.3 56 .3!:0.4
6478TR GWG71 X Coarse loliated 1.91 1.50 0.6,4 2.95 53.4 39. 3.±,0. 3 .a::r
bioti te schist.
V;'
6478Pl 0.139 1. 36 2.70 1.67 89.0 286+2
u4788i 7.09 7.33 1.25 6.,0 76.4 22.7~O.2 3
,477 Bi AD198 Quar t z- fel d spa r- 18 Mile Blut!, 587/050046 7.29 5.52 0.988 l-.24 70.1 21.9.±,0.2
biutite semisctlist. Haast R. ::r:
Biotite schist, 1 mile past Douglas 1>0
3478TR AD199 :;87/ 128026 2.79 7.08 ,.01 7.,1 90.2 ('6.1.:t.0 • 2 ~
Bioti te facies. Slurf, Haast R.
,478Bi 7.27 2.70 1.26 17.6 7(,.5 61. 3.±,0. 4 '"
[/)
)478Chl 2.7 1 12.8 5.49 7.50 94.6 69. 8.±,0. 5 n
)479TR AD200 Biotite-epidote 0.669 0.285 0.414 1.90 28.7 71.7.±,0.5
-::T
greenschist. fa'
)479Pl -211+ 1O'; 0.008 0.071 1.34 0.80 77 .9 160}+ 11
0.0)1 0.740 0.78 60.1 1 'i74:;:: 11
0.027 0.665 0.76 55. 6 11)44.±.11
}4798i -422_211 5.71 4.8) 2.01 1).9 85.3 61.).±,0.4
}.29 1.47 1).9 79.9 61.6+0.4
)521TH GB76/240 Biutite schist 2.22 ).45 1. 71 6.18 82.7 70. 4!:0.5
( .... eathered ).
}521Pl 0.02} 0.1} 0.94 0.78 68.5 7 11 .±,5
0.20 1. }1 0.81 77.4 7J2.±,5
)521Bi 6.29 12.8 4.56 14.4 9).5 57.9±0.5
)480TR AD201 Chlorite schist, Bluff E c;' 3urvey S87/ 16901O ).0) 5.58 }.25 11.0 90.9 90. 6.±,0. 6
Chlorite IV. FIat, Haast R.
6285TR HP9 Quartzofeldspathic Clarke' s Blu fI , S87/177008 1.74 J.4'3 2.27 6.85 87.0 98. 6.±,0. 7
schist, chlorite IV. Haast R.
6285Pl 0.106 1.51 1.64 0.65 82.0 15 1.:!:.1
3482TR AD20) Sericitic quartz 1 mlle S Pleasant 598/125935 1.70 2.76 1.90 G.7'J 84. j 99.).±,0.7
schist, chlorite IV. Valley Flat Bridge. 1.71 1.28 6.65 86.9 98.2.±,0.7
)48)TR AD204 Dark argillite, 2.G7 '3.41 1.74 7.71 8}.1 7J.0.±,0.5
chlorite IV.
3484TR AD205 2.53 }.40 1.83 7.82 8).8 77. 5.±,0. 'j
}486TR AD207 Schist Gates or Haast Brjdg~ 59H/142926 2.78 5.)9 4.00 1 J. C 92.( 117.±,1
chlorite IV. Haast Pass.
3487TR AD208 Srhist, Above gates of S98/147918 2.00 7.)8 5.67 9.92 94.8 124.±,1
chlorite IV. Haast Bridge
}488TR AD209 1.18 3.98 }.16 5.77 .90.6 122+1
)489TR AD210 3.12 7. 0 5 5.62 16.1 94.8 128+1
)490TR AD211 Above gates 01 598/14,910 1. » ).)4 2.66 6.44 88.9 120!:1
Haas t,12 mi above 00
previous 1 sampIes. -.0
(conlinued nexl page)
Table 1 (continued) \0
o

INS R no. * Field nO. Mesh 11m Rock type Location (~rid re 1". K wt9;' 40Ar/JUAr 40,\r/ 3C\r 40 Ar( rad) Age Ma t
x 105 :..103 nl/g % total
6284TR HP8 _4;!J+~1 1 Phylilte, chlorite l~Hlghway 6 at Cross l'IYltO 2.01 3.27 2.31 1 0.5 89.5 l30±l
Ck, Haast Pass.
6283TR HP7 Chloritic schist, 1. 62 5. :17 4 .43 3.48 93.3 130U
chlor ite IV.
6282TR HP5 Quartzofeldspathic Fish Ck, Haast Pass. 598/113832 1.89 4.88 ·3.82 9.30 92.3 12·3.fl
schist, chlorite IV.
628lTR HP4 Fissile slate, 2.2) 1.98 1.79 11.6 83. 5 l.?R.±.'
chlorite IV.
6280TR HP3 Schist, chlorite IV. Quarry at Sawrnill S98/036727 1.50 4.61 3.83 7.87 92.3 13 0 i. l
Flat, in Mt Aspiring
National Park.
6279TR HP2 Schist, chlorite IV. Baat landing ramp, 5107/985582 0. 0 4 0.404 1.16 0.60 74. ') '\ 40 i. 2
N end L. Wanaka.
6278TR HPI Scr.ist, Highway 6, head of 1.42 0.477 3.49 (J.48 91. 5 1 14i. 1
qUd.f1 zofeldspathic, L. Wanaka.
ch:orite IV.
349lTI\ AD212 SChlst, garnet- The Neck, between S107/990439 1.05 3. 6 8 3.00 8.26 90.1 121).±.1
chlvrite-feldspar L. Wanaka & Hawea.
chlorite IV.
zo
3492TR AD213 Sl;·te, Roadcut 2.5 km E of S107/020421 3.U2 6.97 6.15 17.3 95.2 142i.l ~
clll<I['i te 111. the Neck, beside
L. Hawea. ~
6276TR LH6 Greenschist, Highway 6 roadside E Pl
5107/024419 1.82 3.72 3.42 10.4 91.4 142i.l
chlorite 111. of the Neck, beside 6>
::l
L. Hawea. P-
3493TR AD214 Sla te, High~ay 6 at Halls 5107/031415 2.52 5. 0 3 4.57 14.6 143i.l
93.5 '-
chlorite 111. Ck, L.Hawea. o
6493TR LH100 Schi st, L.Hawea, W side. 5107/033415 0.490 0.599 0.760 2.60 61.1 ~
1 31,:!:1
chlorite 111. :3
6493Pl 0.246 0.306 0.538 1.33 45.0 134+1 e:.
b494TR LH101 Phyll te, 2.01 5.03 4.55 11. 6 93.5 14 3:±:1
chlor te 111. o....,
6275TR LH5 Pelit c schist, S107/038408 2.88 6.05 5.24 16.1 94. 4 138i.l
chlor te 111. a
o
6274TR LH4 Fine grained semi- Highway u, L.Hawea, 5107/041152 1. 93 0.1:.26 0.855 11.8 65.5 15 1i. l o
schist, chlorite 11. near lookout.
3494TR AD215 Schist, Rest area 9 km N S115/041352 1.34 4.44 4.10 7.81 92.8 144i.1
chlorite 11. OI Hawea. ~
Pl
L273TR LH3 Phyllite, Beside highway 6, S115/040271 2 96 0.286 0.556 18.4 46.8 15Ji. l
chlorite 11. J km N Hawea. ::l
LH2
P-
6272TR 1. 50 1.29 1.42 8.89 79.2 147+1
6271TR LH 1 At control dam, 5 11 5/04623 1 1.68 8.86 9.45 11.4 96.9 173:±:1 a
Hawea. o
6290TR DLI Schist, Track to Diamond SI15/79717) 3.R6
o
7.54 4.66 15. 1 93.6 9 8 .0i.0 .7 '0
chlorite IV. Lake, Matukituki ::T
Valley road. '<
V>
;:;.
Sampies are listed in northwest-southwest order of Fig. 2. i.e. along Stal:e ~Iighway 6 from north to south (except 6290). Y'
TR = total rock (200-400 um sizc); bi = biotite; mu = museovite; hb = hornblende; pI = plagioelase; gar = garnet; \0
Analysts: C .. l.A. and J.E.G. 00
-9 -1 -lO -J v.
Decay eons1~nts Potasslum-40· Aß = 0.4962.10 yeM A 0.531.10 yea"
e
Abundanee K/K: 0.01167 ", (atomie). <
~
Errors are one standard deviation.
N
00
Adams & Gabites-Age of metamorphism, Haast Schist 91

The high-grade metamorphic schists near the Alpine sam pIe numbers are shown on Fig. 2). In Fig. 4 the
Fault are subdivided into an oligoclase zone age data are shown on a horizontal profile, approxi-
(equivalent to·the staurolite zone and based on the mately east-west; the sam pIes are located in terms
disappearance of albite) in the amphibolite facies, of distance (kilometres) east of the Alpine Fault.
and agamet, biotite, and chlorite zone in the This diagram also shows the age variation with
greenschist facies. The chlorite zone of the respect to metamorphic facies and, in the chlorite
greenschist facies is further subdivided into tex- zone of the greenschist facies, the various textural
tural zones (1-4) on the basis of the development subdivisions.
of schistose foliation. The textural and mineral- Similar to the age pattern described in the much
ogical classifications are not uniquely related at the broader age study by Harper & Landis (1967), the
low-metamorphic grades, and, for example, biotite ages on the Haast-Wanaka profile in Fig. 3 increase
may sometimes occur in the upper chlorite zone at eastwards from the Alpine Fault from 12 to 173
different levels offabric development. The isograds Ma (excluding the plagioclase and hornblende age
and the textural zones in Fig. 2 are thus shown only data). However, within this general trend, the ages
to demonstrate the general trend of the metamor- fall into three groups. (I) A "young" zone lies within
phic gradient in relation to the sam pIes collected 15 km of the Alpine Fault (i.e. entirely within the
for dating. higher-grade schists). The mica and most total-rock
Throughout most of the profile, the main lith- ages are in the range 10-40 Ma and do not see m
ology collected was a fine-medium crystalline to increase with distance eastwards from the fault.
quartzofeldspathic schist or gneiss, that is, quartz- In this zone, the ages of coexisting hornblende, pla-
plagioclase (albite or oligoclase)-biotite ± chlorite gioclase, and a few total-rock sam pIes are very
± muscovite ± epidote ± gamet ± amphibole widely discordant (from 45 to 1600 Ma) and the
(hornblende or actinolite). In the medium-Iow- latter ages in particular seem very im plausible in
grade rocks, many slaty and phyllitic rocks were a regional geological context. (2) A "transitional"
collected (quartz-sericite-chlorite). In the high-grade zone is between 15 and 25 km east of the fault.
amphibolite facies gneisses, several amphibolitic The mica and total-rock ages increase rapidly east-
horizons (metabasic) were sampled (Cooper 1972). wards from about 45 Ma to 120 Ma. (3) An "older"
zone lies beyond 25 km east of the Alpine Fault.
EXPERIMENT AL METHODS The total-rock ages increase eastwards much less
rapidly, from about 120 Ma to 173 Ma near Lake
52 rocks were collected for potassium-argon dating Hawea, 72 km from the fault and in the lowest
along the profile shown in Fig. 2., in relation to the metamorphic grade of Haast Schist. In this zone;
mineralogical metamorphic isograds and the tex- the total-rock and plagioclase ages are concordant.
tural subdivisions of the chlorite zone of the
greenschist facies. Where possible, biotite andjor
muscovite or chlorite or plagioclase or hornblende Ages in the older zone
were separated for dating, otherwise total-rock The total-rock age pattern is similar to, and over-
sam pIes were prepared. laps that of, the Haast Schist in eastern Otago
Sam pIes were crushed for about 30 s in a stain- (Adams et al. in press), where there is a sequence
less steel swing-mill and sieved, washed, and dried transitional from Torlesse metagreywacke sedi-
to retain a 200-400 J.Im size fraction (except for ments at prehnite-pumpellyite' facies into Haast
plagioclase, 100-200 J.Im size). Minerals were sepa- Schist of lower greenschist facies. There, the total-
rated by standard magnetic and heavy liquid rock ages extend from 199 Ma in the prehnite-
techniques. pumpellyite facies to about 150 Ma in the
Potassium-argon dating methods are essentially greenschist facies, and it is concluded that the main
the same as those described by Adams (1975). The regional metamorphism occurred about 200 Ma aga
primary argon standard used was atmospheric (early Jurassic) followed by a long period of uplift
argon. The sam pIe details, analytical data, and ages and cooling of the schists throughout the Jurassic.
are listed in Table 1. The errors quoted there are Ouring this uplift phase, progressively higher-grade
those at the 67% confidence limits. The decay con- schists were cooled below the temperature thresh-
stants and atomic abundances used in this work are old at which accumulation of radiogenic argon
those recommended by Steiger & Jäger (1977), and could begin. The ages of the older zone, in the
the time-scale used is that of Harland et al. (1982). chlorite zone greenschist facies schists near Haast
Pass, Lake Wanaka, and Lake Hawea, are part of
a similar trend which indicates: (1) the age of meta-
RESULTS
morphism of the schists here occurred at least 173
The mineral and total-rock ages listed in Table Ma ago (mid Jurassic), and (2) these rocks were
are shown on a geological map in Fig. 3 (note that then uplifted and cooled gradually during the period
92 New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics, 1985, Vol. 28

Fig. 4 A horizontal profile east-


Q)
(/)
Q) wards from the Alpine Fault,
showing variation of total-rock
(/)
ca ca
Ü a; Ü a; $ $ $ and mineral ages from the Haast
0
E 0 c: .~
e.-o .Q ~~ Schist sampies in Fig. 2 and 3 with
.g:l .§~ .~~
ca ~ ~ I
200 CJ 0 CJ m
ü-
-1:1 ~~ respect to distance from the fault
-
.<:~

.p ü ü o = total-rock, t:,= micas, + =


hornblende, 0 = plagioclase. Sev-
0
eral very old hornblende, plagio-
I
0
0 c1ase (and one total-rock) ages,
150 0
f- 0 0 0
0
- greater than 300 Ma are omitted.
0
~,C For reference only, the mineral-
08 0 8 ogical and textura I (tz) zones of
0 the Haast Schist are also shown.
0(1
0
0
100 f- 0
-
p

§
0 8
0
+
50 f- oF -

g ~
fj § ~
o '" I 1 I I .1 .1
o 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Distance from Alpine Fault (km)

173-120 Ma (mid Jurassic to mid Cretaceous the young zone. (3) The ages of these sam pies are
times). the resuIt of a partial degassing of the rocks, which
The age trend discussed above follows the had a similar age trend originally to those of the
regional trend throughout the South Island, as older zone, but were affected by a later event in the
shown by Sheppard et al. (1975, fig. 5) and Adams young zone.
(1981, fig. 3). These authors suggest that the major, The interpretation (1) agrees generally with the
post-Rangitata uplift phase occurred both east and evidence for long-continued, but declining, uplift
west of the Alpine Fault and also, importantly, in in the schist arc in the Cretaceous-Cenozoic period.
the narrow zone of the Southern Alps. It is con- From the early Cretaceous there was a gradual
duded therefore that the region of the higher-grade marine transgression onto the schist arc in the South
schists of the greenschist-amphibolite facies were Island (Aeming 1962). Thus, mid Cretaceous sedi-
also uplifted by a similar amount during the Jur- ments (Kyeburn Formation) transgress onto
assic-Cretaceous uplift phase to that in the lower greenschist facies Haast Schist rocks in eastern
greenschist facies rocks (and below). Otago and a little later near Dunedin (Henley For-
mation). The encroachment onto the schists reached
Ages in the transitional zone a maximum in the Oligocene (Aeming 1962), and
The interpretation of the ages in the transitional Oligocene limestone occurs in the Lake Wakatipu
zone could be made in three ways. (I) The ages area about 50 km south of the Lake Wanaka and
form a "cooling" age pattern, similar to that of the Lake Hawea. The oldest sediments overlying the
older zone but with a very much reduced uplift schists in the Lake Hawea area are early Miocene.
rate, during the mid Cretaceous-Oligocene. (2) The The regional pattern of this transgression suggests
ages of these sam pies are spurious and come from that the uplift rate gradually diminished during the
a narrow band within the schist sequence which Cenozoic and the phase ended in the Oligocene,
was held at depth until the Late Cenozoic at a tem- when there must have been almost complete marine
perature dose to that of argon retention but slightly transgression. So, the total-rock age pattern in the
higher. Thus, the sam pies only partly retain the transitional zone seems entirely in accord with the
argon as it is generated in the rocks. The propor- geological evidence.
tion of argon retained would decrease with increas- The interpretation (2) mayaiso be possible
ing depth of burial (i.e. at the higher metamorphic because there is an appreciable temperature range
grades), and hence the ages become younger towards through which rocks would have to cool in order
Adams & Gabites-Age of metamorphism, Haast Schist 93

to go from a situation of complete argon loss to potassium contents, such as hornblende. and pla-
complete argon retention. An accurate caIculation gioc1ase. These effects c~n be obs~rved ~smg ~ 4°Ar
of the temperature range over which one might (radiogenic) versus K dIagram (FIg. 5), m wh Ich all
expect transitional ages is very difficult to make the Haast Schist total-rock and mineral age data
because one requires a detailed knowledge of dif- are plotted and subdivided according to ~he vari-
fusion characteristics of the various minerals, and ous mineralogical and textural metamorphlc zones.
their variation with grain size, and the cooling rate In this diagram, the total-rock and mineral ~ge .data
(see, e.g., discussions by Dodson 1973, 1979). To for a single rock sam pie are connected by tIe-lmes.
then apply this transitional temperature range to On such a diagram, the conventional K-Ar age may
the observed metamorphic sequence requires a be caIculated from the slope of the line joining any
knowledge of the metamorphic temperature gra- point to the origin. Any tendency for tie-Ii~es not
dient during the uplift phase after metamorphism. to extrapolate to the origin, and for low-K mmerals
The uncertainties in all these parameters make any to plot c10se to the vertical axis, indicates the pres-
caIculation virtually useless. However, we can ence of excess argon, at least in the low-K minerals
observe that, because the transitional age zone spans which then yield very high and discordant ages.
the metamorphic sequence from the upper part of From the data, the excess argon is c1early greatest
the chlorite zone to the upper part of the gamet in hornblende and plagioc1ase from the highest
zone of the greenschist facies (a temperature range grade rocks of the upper greenschist and amphi-
of about 300-400°C-see Turner (1968), fig. 8.6), bolite facies. The maximum excess argon value for
then the temperature range from complete argon hornblende and plagioc1ase from this zone is more
loss to complete argon retention is no more than than 4 nl/g from the sampie c10sest to the Alpine
150°C. Fault (sampie 3465, Table I); others nearby to the
A similar transition zone to that described above east range from I to 2 nlJg. From the age discor-
would be produced during the superimposition of dancies between biotite, total-rock, and plagioc1ase
a younger thermal event upon the rocks near to the sampies in the transitional and older zones, the
Alpine Fault (interpretation (3) above). The tran- excess argon concentration in the plagioc1ase in the
sitional ages would rellect those sam pIes that were biotite zone of the greenschist facies is 0.1-0.5 nlJg
partly affected by the younger event and lost so me and essentially zero in the chlorite zone where
of their accumulated radiogenic argon. Such an schists, both K-poor and K-rich, yield similar ages.
interpretation depends on the reality of such an
event, derived from the age data in the young zone There is, however, one exception-a chlorite zone
(see below). schist (sampie 6279) that has very low potassi~m
(0.04%) and a higher age (340 Ma) than schlsts
Ages in the young zone nearby and hence the possibility of about 0.5 nlJg
excess argon. However, the general pattern is for a
The very young biotite (and some total-rock) ages gradual decrease eastwards in the ex.cess argon con-
in this zone, 12-40 Ma, suggest that these higher- centrations. In the higher-grade schlsts c10se to the
grade rocks near the Alpine Fault were either held Alpine Fault there is also the possibility that. excess
at depth (i.e., at a temperature above that fot argon argon may be distribut~d a~ongst al.l mmerals,
accumulation) for more than 130 Ma after meta- inc1uding the micas. Thls mlght explam the rela-
morphism or they were reheated (i.e., at a tem- tively large age variation in th.e ~ica~ from the
perature sufficient to cause argon expulsion) at a young zone (i.e., 12-40 Ma). Wlthm thls zone ~he
later time in the late Cenozoic. However, the age ages do not vary with distance from the Alpme
interpretation is complicated by the very discor- Fault nor with metamorphic grade. Although the
dant plagioc1ase and hornblende ages from the same gamet zone greenschists and oligoc1ase zone
rocks which suggest that "excess" argon is present amphibolite facies rocks are gently folded aft~r
(i.e., radiogenic 4°Ar that is not produced by in situ metamorphism (hence these zones are repeated m
decay of 4°K but is incorporated into the mineral the profile in Fig. 4), the agtl pattern does not follow
from some external source). accordingly. This suggests that the age p~ttern was
impressed upon the rocks after the foldm~ of the
isograds. The age pattern in the young zone I~ muc~
simplified if we assume that excess argon IS UDl-
EXCESS ARGON IN THE HAAST SCHIST formly distributed throughout the rocks ~ated. The
Excess argon usually occurs in mine~als that have tie-lines in Fig. 5 may then be treate~ as Isochro~s,
a lattice structure capable of absorbmg gas mole- and the age at which argon was umformly red.ls-
cules and have at some stage in their history bee.n tributed through the rocks can be caIcula~ed. Wlth
subjected to a high partial press ure of argon. Thls one exception that is c10sest to the Alpme Fault
is most easily detected in minerals that have low and yields a negative or zero age (sam pie 3465),
94 New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics, 1985, Vol. 28

Fig.5 Isochron diagram (4DAr


versus K) ofthe age da ta from the
20
Haast Schist in this study. Tie-
lines join coexisting mineral and
total-rock data for the same sam-
pie. Solid symbols are from the
gamet zone greenschist and oli-
goclase zone amphibolite facies
schist and gneiss; half-solid sym-
bols are biotite zone greenschist
facies rocks; open symbols are
chlorite zone greenschist facies
rocks. 0 = total rock, {; = micas,
+ = hornblende, 0= plagioclase.

K (wt()())

the isochron ages that are obtained for all the high- the Southern Alps during the Kaikoura Orogeny.
grade schists are 12 ± 5 Ma (iate Cenozoic). Within At this time, there was development of a shear zone
this group, all the isochrons are subparallel but yield at the Alpine Fault with a 100-300 m mylonite
dilfering amounts of initial or excess argon (0.8-2 zone. Near the Alpine Fault, the sehists are intensely
nljg). Because thlt argon was redistributed amongst sheared, and the late struetures are inftueneed by
minerals in a closed system and the sam pies were the reeent horizontal and vertieal movements on
not totally degassed, the rocks must have been sub- the Alpine Fault. Sibson et al. (1979) and Adams
jected to a high argon partial pressure at this time. (1981) have estimated the thermal elfeet near the
The source of the argon was most likely the K-rich Alpine Fault during movement and have shown
minerals in the rock. This in turn suggests that the that, within 20 km of the fault zone, the temper-
rocks originally must have cooled sufficiently for ature inerease may have been 50-100°C, suffieient
argon to have accumulated over a long period. If to eause argon loss from biotite and museovite and
this is eorreet, then the interpretations (I) and (2) reineorporation into plagioclase and hornblende.
for the transitional zone are not valid, and inter- This event must have been fairly low grade, such
pretation (3) is more probable. that retrogressive metamorphic elfeets are not seen
The eause ofthe argon redistribution 12 + 5 Ma in the high-grade schists. Situations similar to this
ago is diffieult to assess. There is no clear-miner- oceur in other areas of the world where high-grade
alogieal evidenee in the high-grade sehists for a metamorphic rocks are close to major shear zones
seeond metamorphie reerystallisation that might be (e.g., Brewer 1969; Wanless et al. 1970; Wilson
related to the young ages. However, the most 1972; Adams et al. 1982). In all these, there is clear
obvious geologieal faetor inftueneing the sehists at evidenee for exeess argon being ineorporated into
this time was the Mioeene-Reeent development of hornblende, biotite, and muscovite during shearing.
Adams & Gabites-Age of metamorphism, Haast Schist 95

SUMMARY Brewer, M. S. 1969: Exeess radiogenie argon in meta-


morphic micas from the eastern Alps, Austria.
The age pattern in the Haast Schist Group is inter- Earth and planetary science letters 6: 321-331.
preted as the reftection of two geological events. (I)
The long-continued cooling and uplift of the lower Cooper, A. F. 1972: Progressive metamorphism of meta-
basie rocks from the Haast Schist Group. Journal
metamorphic grade sector of the Haast Schist oi petrology 13: 457-492.
during the mid-Iate Jurassic and early-mid Cre-
taceous, after a regional metamorphism during the - - - - 1974: Multiphase deformation and its relation-
ship to metamorphie crystallisation at Haast River,
Rangitata Orogeny (probably in early Jurassic South West land, New Zealand. New Zealand jour-
times), produced the age pattern (120-173 Ma) nal of geology and geophysics 17: 855-880.
more than 25 km eastwards from the Alpine Fault.
- - - - 1980: Retrograde alteration of chromian kyan-
(2) The extensive shearing and slight reheating of ite in metaehert and amphibolite white-schist from
the high er-grade sector of the Haast Schist near the the Southern Alps, New Zealand, with impliea-
Alpine Fault (within 15 km), during the formation tions for uplift on the Alpine Fault. Comriburions
of the Southern Alps in the Kaikoura (Miocene- to mineralogy and petrology 75: 153-164.
Recent) Orogeny, and the associated large-scale Cooper, A. F.; Wellman, P. 1971: Potassium-argon age of
horizontal and vertical movements at the Alpine some New Zea1and lamprophyre dikes near the
FauIt 12 ± 5 Ma ago, had an isotopic elfect on the Alpine Fault. New Zealand journal of geology and
higher-grade schists, such that radiogenic argon geophysics 14: 341-350.
previously accumulated in these rocks was dilfused Dodson, M. H. 1973: C10sure temperature in cooling geo-
out of K-rich minerals (such as biotite and mus- ehronological and petrological systems. Comribu-
covite) and redistributed uniformly throughout aB tions to mineralogy and petrology 40: 259-274.
the minerals. This led to large quantities of excess - - - - 1979: Theory of eooling ages. Pp. 194-202 in:
argon in K-poor minerals (such as hornblende and Jäger, E.; Hunziker, J. C. ed. Lectures in isotope
plagioclase). In an intermediate transitional zone, geology. Berlin, Springer Verlag.
about 15-25 km from the Alpine Fault, the ages Findlay, R. H. 1979: Summary of geology of Haast Schist
are the result of partial degassing of the rocks during terrain, central Southern Alps, New Zealand:
the younger event. Before this, the age pattern of Implication ofstrueture for uplift and deformation
these rocks foBowed that of the lower-grade rocks within the Southern Alps. In: Walcott, R. 1.; Cres-
swell, M. M. ed. The origin of the Southern Alps.
to the east. Bulletin ofthe Royal Society oi New Zealand 18:
113-120.
F1eming, C. A. 1962: New Zealand biogeography: A
paleontologist's approach. Tuatara 10: 53-108.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS - - - - 1970: The Mesozoie of New Zealand: Chapters
This paper benefitted greatly from an energetie but highly in the history of the Circum-Pacific Mobile Belt.
eonstrueti ve anonymous review of an earlier draft of the Quarterly journal of the Geological Society oi Lon-
manuseript. don 125: 125-170.
Grindley, G. W. 1963: Strueture of the Alpine schists of
South Westland, Southern Alps. New Zealand
journal of geology and geophysics 6: 872-930.
REFERENCES Harland, W. B.; Cox, A. V.; Llewellyn, P. G.; Pickton, C.
Adams, C. J. D. 1975: New Zealand K-Ar age list - 2. A. G.; Smith, A. G.; Walters, R. 1982: A geological
New Zealandjournal of geology and geophysics 18: timescale. Cambridge University Press. 131 p.
443-468.
Harper, C. T.; Landis, C. A. 1967: K-Ar ages from region-
- - - - 1981: Uplift rates and thermal structure in the ally metamorphosed rocks, South Island, New
Alpine Fault Zone and Alpine Schists, Southern Zealand, and some tectonic implieations. Earth and
Alps, New Zealand. Pp. 211-222 in: McClay, K. planetary science letters 2: 419-429.
R.; Price, N. J. ed. Thrust and nappe tectonics.
Geological Soeiety of London. Hurley, P. M.; Hughes, H.; Pinson, W. H. Jun.; Fairbairn,
H. W. 1962: Radiogenie argon and strontium dif-
Adams, C. J.; Gabites, J. E.; Grindley, G. W. 1982: Oro- fusion parameters in biotite at low temperatures
genie history of the eentral Transantaretie Moun- obtained from Alpine Fault uplift in New Zealand.
tains: New· K-Ar age data on the Precambrian- Geochimica et cosmochimica acta 26: 67-80.
Lower Paleozoic basement. Pp. 817-826 in: Crad-
dock, C. ed. Antarctic geoseienee. Madison, Wis- Hutton, C. 0.; Turner, F. J. 1936: Metamorphie zones in
consin, University of Wiseonsin. north-west Otago. Transactions ofthe Royal Society
Adams, C. J.; Bishop, D. G; Gabites, J. E. (in press): of New Zealand 65 : 405-406.
Potassium-argon age studies of a low-grade, pro- Mason, B. 1961: Potassium-argon ages of metamorphie
gressively metamorphosed greywacke sequence, rocks and granites from Westland, New Zealand.
Dansey Pass, South Island, New Zealand. Journal New Zealand journal oi geology and geophysics 4 :
of the Geological Society of London 142. 352-356.

Sig. 7
96 New Zealand Journal of Geology and Geophysics, 1985, Vol. 28

- - - - 1962: Metamorphism in the Southern Alps of Steiger, R. H.; Jäger, E. 1977: Subcommission on geo-
New Zealand. Bulletin o/the American Museum 0/ ehronology: convention on the use of deeay con-
Natural History 123: 217-248. stants in geochronology and eosmochronology.
Earth and planetary science letters 36: 359-362.
Miyashiro, A. 1973: Metamorphism and metamorphic Suggate, R. P. 1961: Rock stratigraphie names for the
belts. London, Allen & Unwin. 492 p. South Island sehists and undifferentiated sedi-
ments of the New Zealand geosyncline. New
Zealand journal 0/ geology and geophysics 4 : 392.
Sheppard, D. S.; Adams, C. J.; Bird, G. W. 1975: Age of
metamorphism and uplift in the Alpine Schist Belt, Turner, F. J. 1968: Metamorphie petrology. New York,
New Zealand. Geological Society 0/ America bul- McGraw-Hill. 403 p.
letin86: 1147-1153. Wanless, R. K.; Stevens, R. 0.; Loveridge, W. D. 1970:
Anomalous parent-daughter relationships in rocks
Sibson, R. H.; White, S.; Atkinson, B. H. 1979: Fault rock adjacent to the Grenville Front near Chibougamu,
distribution and structure within the Alpine Fault Quebee. Eclogae geologicae Helvetiae 63: 345-364.
zone: A preliminary account. In: Walcott, R. 1.; Wilson, M. R. 1972: Excess radiogenic argon in meta-
Cresswell, M. M. ed. The origin of the Southern morphic amphiboles and biotites from the
Alps. Bulletin o/the Royal Society 0/ New Zealand Sulitjelma region, central Norwegian Caledonides.
18: 55-66. Earth and planetary science letters 14: 403-412.

You might also like