4/6/2020 Jonathan Franzen: 'Egypt is the worst place to be a migratory bird' | Adam Welz | Environment | The Guardian

Jonathan Franzen: 'Egypt is the worst place to be a

migratory bird'
US author sounds warning over Egyptian trapping that kills millions of birds as they
migrate from Europe into Africa
Adam Welz
Fri 19 Jul 2013 14.04 BST

Next month the killing will begin in earnest. August marks the start of the annual migration of
millions of birds from their European breeding areas to their wintering grounds in Africa. Many
will fly across the eastern Mediterranean towards Egypt, where they will land, exhausted, on a
coast along which hundreds of kilometres of trappers' nets have been spanned to create almost
unbroken walls of death on the seaside dunes.

These nets will catch at least 140 million birds this year, according to one biologist's estimate,
more than one in twenty of the migrant birds leaving Europe for Africa. This number does not
include those killed along Egypt's coast by other means: trees shrouded in nets with north-
facing openings catch instinct-propelled, southbound migrants before they can head across
the Sahara, ingenious shade traps set on the ground snare birds seeking relief from the sun and
lime-coated sticks strategically placed in bushes bring birds to a sticky end.

Those birds that make it through the coastal gauntlet into the Western Desert face more
danger. Almost every oasis and isolated grove of acacia trees, 'magnets' for birds seeking shade

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/nature-up/2013/jul/19/jonathan-franzen-egypt-migratory-bird 1/6
4/6/2020 Jonathan Franzen: 'Egypt is the worst place to be a migratory bird' | Adam Welz | Environment | The Guardian

and rest during their strenuous desert crossings, is occupied by hunters who shoot at every
bird they see, say local conservationists.

"I think it's very safe to say that Egypt is the worst place to be a migratory bird," said the bird-
loving American author Jonathan Franzen, who visited the country last year to report on
threats to migrants across the Mediterranean for National Geographic. "For someone from the
western hemisphere, the scale of the killing of small birds is just totally shocking because we
really don't do that over here," he told me. "It was clear that I was up against a completely
different understanding of what a bird was."

"It's just like fishing, and we're not outraged by fishing," he continued, "by and large we accept
fishermen. 'They're just fish for god's sake! You pull 'em out, cut their heads off and you eat
'em!' And that was really the only way I had to wrap my mind around what I was seeing in
Egypt. And in a number of cases they were using the identical nets to both catch fish and then
to throw over a bush and catch birds, which really underlined that that's how it was for them."

Egyptians have caught migrant birds for subsistence since the time of the pharoahs, but in
recent years the intensity of the trapping and shooting has escalated to unprecedented levels
according to conservationists I interviewed. Birds are increasingly being killed purely for
recreation, and wildlife law enforcement, never strong, has become almost nonexistent in the
political turmoil that has enveloped the country since Hosni Mubarak was deposed in early
2011.

A line of nets erected on coastal dunes to catch migrating

Common Quail (Coturnix coturnix) along the Egyptian
Mediterranean seashore, autumn 2012. Photo by Holger
Schulz/NABU

A German wildlife TV crew working in Egypt last year estimated that continuous nets lined at
least 700km of the Egyptian Mediterranean coast during the autumn migration, the only
places not intensively netted being military bases and cities. The Egyptian coast is "the world's
biggest bird trap," they said, with nets running right through small towns and private gardens.
Franzen told me that he saw tourists squeezing their way through small gaps in nets to get
from their beach resorts to the sea.

The barrier-like nets erected on coastal dunes are set for common quail flying in across the
Mediterranean from Europe. Quail are traditional and legal quarry for Egyptian netters, and
although there has never been a strict bag limit, regulations limit the height of nets, stipulate
that they be spaced a certain distance apart and that non-target species ('bycatch') be released
unharmed.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/nature-up/2013/jul/19/jonathan-franzen-egypt-migratory-bird 2/6
4/6/2020 Jonathan Franzen: 'Egypt is the worst place to be a migratory bird' | Adam Welz | Environment | The Guardian

In recent years, as policing has evaporated, the nets have become taller and are no longer
spaced apart. Sometimes they're spanned three deep. New electronic bird calls placed under
the nets broadcast recordings of quail song, increasing the catch. The European population of
common quail suffered a decline in the twentieth century and no good data exist to quantify
what percentage of the population is being caught annually in Egypt, but it's likely to be
substantial. Quail, according to the German TV crew, can sell for as much as five euros each to
local restaurateurs, pricing them well out of reach of the average Egyptian and making
trapping profitable.

Bycatch species such as shrikes, wheatears and warblers are not released. Their wings are
typically broken and they're transported live and sold for pennies to local merchants, who later
slit their throats according to Muslim custom before butchering and selling them. The numbers
of bycatch species caught is poorly known because "nobody has investigated this in a
systematic way," says Franzen (the estimate of 140 million birds per year is a simple calculation
by the German conservation group NABU based on documented net catch rates in Cyprus,
which, like Egypt, is on the Eastern Mediterranean migratory flyway).

Some birds sold cheaply in Egyptian markets belong to threatened species that benefit from
expensive, taxpayer-funded EU conservation programmes.

Another species specifically targeted by hunters is the European golden oriole, which is known
throughout the Middle East as a 'natural Viagra', according to Franzen. There are no Egyptian
laws restricting the hunting of orioles, which are typically shot as they seek shade and rest in
isolated acacia trees in the desert, either by Bedouins who have traditionally laid claim to
particular trees or by young men spending 'guy time' away from their parents.

Sherif Baha El Din of Nature Conservation Egypt, a wildlife NGO, told me that remote acacia
groves had been hard to find and access in the past, but with GPS devices and fast SUVs being
easily available to wealthy youth, "now every tree has someone waiting with a shotgun or an
air pistol" during migration. There are even fist fights over trees, which can return a tidy profit
to enterprising shooters. (Franzen visited an oasis frequented by oriole hunters where he
reckoned at least 5,000 were shot in a single year.)

Dead orioles are sold to middlemen who transport them to consumers with sexual problems in
the Gulf states, presumably in refrigerated trucks. As with almost every aspect of the bird
hunting issue, conservationists don't understand the economics of and participants in the
trade very well.

Although bird hunting takes place on a massive scale, said Baha El Din, a minority of the
country's population is involved and most people know nothing about it. "If you just pick
some random Egyptian on the street or in the government, it just doesn't register with them."

Click here to see this video on YouTube.

The important first step, therefore, was to make migratory bird conservation an issue in Egypt
and around the world. "We need some pressure combined with assistance," he told me.
Concerned people around the world should contact their local conservation groups and
Egyptian embassies to raise the profile of uncontrolled hunting and trapping, because "these
are not just Egyptian birds, after all"; the species most affected by Egyptian hunters breed in
Europe and spend a large part of the year in sub-Saharan Africa.

The conservation community should take an integrated approach to the problem, he said,
combining research and persistent pressure with co-operative action that engages
communities and the government, taking care to avoid destructive conflict.
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/nature-up/2013/jul/19/jonathan-franzen-egypt-migratory-bird 3/6
4/6/2020 Jonathan Franzen: 'Egypt is the worst place to be a migratory bird' | Adam Welz | Environment | The Guardian

Jonathan Franzen cautioned that overly-strong outside pressure on Egyptians could backfire.
When addressing bird-trapping with Egyptians, as he has, "You run up against the
substantially legitimate resentment that many Egyptians feel towards the West." Westerners
seen as arrogantly telling Egyptians what to do could cause serious problems, so outsiders
should offer assistance to internal groups like Nature Conservation Egypt, he recommended.
Even though Egyptian laws make it very difficult for foreigners to support Egyptian NGOs
financially, they can help with such items as used binoculars and even moral support, he said.

A nascent Chinese bird conservation movement has recently emerged in the wake of the
publication of an affordable, quality Chinese-language field guide to the birds of China,
Franzen said. No equivalent, up-to-date book exists in Egypt that would allow locals to learn
about migrants, start to watch them and then build a larger community of local birders and
bird-conservationists.

"If there's ever going to be cultural change," he said, "it's going to come from Egyptians
themselves realising, y'know, there aren't as many birds as there used to be, maybe there's a
different way for us to interact with them." Such a change, said Franzen, "is probably going to
have to come from the bottom up because the Egyptian population has a very problematic
relationship with police and with regulation at this point.

"Unfortunately it's the long game — and the birds are declining at such a rate that it's
wrenching to play the long game."

Germany's largest wildlife conservation nonprofit, NABU, has drawn up a petition encouraging
the Egyptian government to act against uncontrolled bird slaughter. An English-language version
is available to sign here

For NatureUp blog and wildlife conservation updates, follow @NatureUpBlog on Twitter

We've got an announcement…

… on our progress as an organisation. In service of the escalating climate emergency, we have
made an important decision – to renounce fossil fuel advertising, becoming the first major
global news organisation to institute an outright ban on taking money from companies that
extract fossil fuels.

In October we outlined our pledge: that the Guardian will give global heating, wildlife
extinction and pollution the urgent attention and prominence they demand. This resonated
with so many readers around the world. We promise to update you on the steps we take to
hold ourselves accountable at this defining point in our lifetimes. With climate misinformation
rife, and never more dangerous than now, the Guardian's accurate, authoritative reporting is
vital – and we will not stay quiet.

We chose a different approach: to keep Guardian journalism open for all. We don't have a
paywall because we believe everyone deserves access to factual information, regardless of
where they live or what they can afford to pay.

Our editorial independence means we are free to investigate and challenge inaction by those in
power. We will inform our readers about threats to the environment based on scientific facts,
not driven by commercial or political interests. And we have made several important changes
to our style guide to ensure the language we use accurately reflects the environmental
emergency.

The Guardian believes that the problems we face on the climate crisis are systemic and that
fundamental societal change is needed. We will keep reporting on the efforts of individuals
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/nature-up/2013/jul/19/jonathan-franzen-egypt-migratory-bird 4/6
4/6/2020 Jonathan Franzen: 'Egypt is the worst place to be a migratory bird' | Adam Welz | Environment | The Guardian

and communities around the world who are fearlessly taking a stand for future generations
and the preservation of human life on earth. We want their stories to inspire hope.

We hope you will consider supporting us today. We need your support to keep delivering
quality journalism that’s open and independent. Every reader contribution, however big or
small, is so valuable. Support the Guardian from as little as $1 – and it only takes a minute.
Thank you.

Support The Guardian

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/nature-up/2013/jul/19/jonathan-franzen-egypt-migratory-bird 5/6
4/6/2020 Jonathan Franzen: 'Egypt is the worst place to be a migratory bird' | Adam Welz | Environment | The Guardian

Read our pledge

Topics
Environment
NatureUp
Jonathan Franzen
Birds
Wildlife
Conservation
Egypt
Fishing
blogposts

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/nature-up/2013/jul/19/jonathan-franzen-egypt-migratory-bird 6/6