Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Glaucoma and Short-Wavelength Light Sensitivity (Blue Light)
Glaucoma and Short-Wavelength Light Sensitivity (Blue Light)
1 Introduction
The present paper seeks a better understanding between the relation of short-
wavelength light sensitivity and glaucoma. We will start with the definition of glau-
coma, and, since there is some connection between glaucoma and retinal ganglion cells
damage, we will describe what we know so far. It seems that short-wavelength light has
an important role and for that same reason, we will explore the impacts of it in our
visual and non-visual systems. Then, we will remark the artificial light sources that we
are exposed all the time in our residences, workplace and so forth. Lastly, we will
evidence the major signs that are linked to glaucoma and have a relation with blue light,
such as, the impact in pupil size and sleep quality, since they are non-visual facts that
can jeopardizes the quality of life of those who suffer from glaucoma.
2 Literature Review
2.1 Glaucoma
First of all, we must clarify what Glaucoma is and how it appears. It all start with
alterations on the aqueous humor, the fluid that nourishes the tissues of the eye, in a
continuous circulation through the anterior chamber, and maintain the eyeball from
collapsing. Aqueous humor is produced by the ciliary body, which is located behind the
iris. It flows between the iris and the lens and nourishes the cornea and lens and then flows
out through the trabecular meshwork situated where the iris and cornea meet. (Fig. 1) [1]
Glaucoma is, in fact, a result of increased intraocular pressure (IOP), that can damage the
optic nerve cupping and then the damage spreads from one nerve cells to another creating
“blind spots” that start to appear in the visual field. Primarily it affects the peripheral field
of vision and afterwards the central visual, leading to a worse quality of life (Fig. 2). [2–4]
Fortunately, not all people that have high IOP level develop glaucoma. Recent studies
suggest that ipRGCs are damaged in glaucoma [4, 5].
processing information from the short-wavelength cones (S-cones) and represent 8-10%
of RGCs. Early glaucoma affects M-pathway but recent studies suggest that it may not be
so. Many of glaucoma patients have a decrease in short-wavelength sensitivity, which
suggests that there are degeneration of type-I and type-II P cells and K cells. Therefore, we
have to comprehend why the short-wavelength is so important in humans [2].
Fig. 6. Phototoxic action (apoptosis) spectrum on A2E-loaded RPE cells and morphological
changes of the REP cells. ***p < 0.001 as compared to control cells maintained in the dark [10].
performance levels. The ipRGCs are more responsive to short-wavelength light and this
reflects in the production of cortisol (stress hormone), by the adrenal gland (as response to
bright light) increases, and no production of melatonin (its antagonistic hormone, the dark
hormone, often associated with sleep) occurs. Along with cortisol production, serotonin
(mood hormone) is activated by light and have a positive effect on human, although over
the time its production decreases somewhat like 10% less per decade. IpRGCs have a
spectral sensitivity very similar to rods but need much brighter light for its activation
[19–21].
Fig. 7. Excessive blue light exposure can Fig. 8. Excessive blue light exposure can
permanently damage your eyes and retina: 10- permanently damage your eyes and retina:
year-old Human Eye [11]. 60–70-year-old Human Eye [11].
Fig. 9. Representative images of hematoxylin staining for retina section in control and [24]
LED-exposure mice. Light micrographs were taken from the mouse retinas. Sec-
tions of control and light-exposed retinas stained with hematoxylin. In control retinas
(A and B), the ONL shows the photoreceptor nuclei normally (B). The arrangement of
photoreceptor cells in the outer nuclear layer was slightly distorted and the thickness of
the outer nuclear layer was decreased after 2 weeks (C and D) and 4 weeks (E and F)
exposure. At 39 weeks after light exposure (G and H), with a significant reduction in
the thickness of the outer nuclear layer (G), and the photoreceptor cell loss is evident
(H). After light exposure, noted that the outer nuclear layer becomes thinner over time.
ONL, outer nuclear layer. Scale bars = 50 um [24].
Glaucoma and Short-Wavelength Light Sensitivity (Blue Light) 63
However, if we avoid blue light we will not have the advantages of it, such as
cognitive performance or a better mood and even a greater visual acuity (Fig. 10). So,
we cannot ignore these facts but we should balance the exposure to blue light, from
natural and artificial light, the best option that we have is manage the lighting systems
and try to, just like the daylight, vary during the day [23]. Another effect of blue light is
the increase of cortisol and serotonin production, which is a good thing, but only in the
right amounts. If we are under blue light too much time, the cortisol production, which
make us more energetic, will turn out in more nervous and stressful, and when this
levels are higher they promote the norepinephrine and epinephrine levels, which lead
us to the negative part of the stimulation curve.
Fig. 10. Colour photographs of four of the donor lenses [aged 18, 35, 63 and 76 years (from left
to right)] and the five intraocular implant lens (IOLs) IOLS [SA60AT, SN6/WF, Hoya-PS AF-a
(UY), EYECRYL. HFY 600, CT Asphina 404V (from left to right)] [23].
2.8 Workplace
Contemporaneous working places differs from the traditional ones because of the new
methods of work enhanced by technology. Interacting with technology improve human
productivity and encouraged new activities and functions; however, these new tools
demand different spatial layout configurations from which the development of a task in
a vertical and auto-illuminated plan emerge as one of the major changes and chal-
lenges. Despite the awareness of this reality, working places are still following tradi-
tional design principles. There is a significant progress with the ergonomic questions,
related to desks and chairs, the opposition of the computer, monitor and mouse;
questions related to the inclusion of individuals with limitations are being answered.
Yet, when considering the lighting design, it seems that the aesthetical demands come
together with the accomplishment of parameters of a data sheet, neglecting its effect on
human being particularly on the non-visual effects, which have a strong impact on
comfort and health of the user.
64 S. Preto and C. C. Gomes
Recurrently, the support for this reality is a push game between professionals from
different background, but the result is a deficient lighting solution for spaces oriented to
work.
Moreover, is important to highlight that a lighting design which neglects its impact
on user health and comfort, answering to numeric requirements that spot a quantity of
lux and lumens to an activity, and disregard the colour spectrum of the light contribute
to the increase of glaucoma incidents.
Furthermore, the ageing population is a reality that draft new challenges to build
environment and working places are not an exception, mostly when the retirement age
is changing for higher values. There is a natural relation between the emergence of
glaucoma and age that requires an answer from lighting designers.
It is a document fact that we spend 70% to 90% of our lifetime indoors [22, 25, 26]
in indoor spaces, like homes, and workplaces, where daylight only penetrates the
building for less than 4 h, especially in winter which have a negative impact on
individual mood (SAD, Seasonal Affective Disorder) and on neurocognitive processes.
Unfortunately, the lighting recommendations for indoors are based on visual cri-
teria [23, 27, 28]. SAD, for instance, improves under bright-light exposure. Exposure to
blue light/bright light in the morning and evening also improve alertness and pro-
ductivity; the lack of daylight exposure to whom spend many hours indoors, especially
in winter, may compromise health and wellbeing [28]. We must not forget that we are
outdoor animals, so it is in outdoors places that we feel balanced biological and
psychologically. There is a great difference between outdoor (2.000 and 100.000 lx)
and indoor illuminance, where norms suggests 200 and 500 lx. Moreover, in the last
two decades, we move from paper source (horizontal plane) to computer tasks (vertical
plane) [29]. Nevertheless, as already stated, older eyes need more time to adapt to
brightness differences due to the reduced elasticity of the iris. At workplaces, for
instance, dynamic artificial lighting, like the natural light, could help to prevent dis-
eases, disorders and promote employees’ productivity and performance, and mood,
which also protects our eyes from the blue light, since the extent of our exposure to it is
lesser [30].
3 Conclusions
It seems that short-wavelength light sensitivity has in fact relation with glaucoma,
however there are not certainties about how it occurs and what is the relation.
Although, K cells are involved with short-wavelength, rods have similar peak with
ipRGCs. There are more questions that emerge than answers. If ipRGCs are fewer it
makes sense that the melatonin levels are higher and this results in more melatonin
production, which makes us drowsier and sleepy. But, if pupil size decreases the light
that passes through the lens and reach the retina is also less, so it may not be the
ipRGCs that are less effective but the pupil size that allows less blue light to reach the
retina. Besides, the yellowing of the crystalline, also, avoids that blue light damage the
retina. Even though, the glaucoma initially affects the peripheral visual field (M cells),
but recent evidence suggest that may be not be so.
Glaucoma and Short-Wavelength Light Sensitivity (Blue Light) 65
It appears that the only certainty is that we must keep the aqueous humor circu-
lating within the eye, since it maintains the trabecular meshwork healthy. Another fact
is that RPE can help to control the lipofuscin and ROS formation, and in that way, we
can keep the eye well. There is, also, the need to continue to study the RGCs (Retinal
Ganglion Cells) role in the short-wavelength sensitivity since there is some evidences
that suggests that there is a cause-effect relation. Block the short-wavelength light must
not be the answer since we need it in order to maintain our circadian rhythms syn-
chronizes and all that concerns.
Considering the knowledge about the impact of short-wavelengths on human
beings a new consciousness must support indoors lighting design particularly work-
spaces. Working tasks require different types of light which usually are selected
regarding their intensity and energy consumption neglecting their impact on human
performance and well-being. Beside the segregation of the user requirements for the
selection of lighting sources it is also mistreated the shift from traditional forms of work
to the intensive use of digital equipment where monitors emerge as a new working
surface. Moreover, it is important to accept that population is ageing and retirement age
is increasing bringing along new challenges towards the lighting design.
4 Discussion
This paper aims to high spot the need to control one of the major causes of human
blind: glaucoma. The available information allows to relate this disorder with its cause:
and light contributes significantly to its emergence and development. However,
although the available information lighting design performs aesthetically remarkable
solutions, answering to established parameters that determine the amount of light
quantity required by different tasks, however, lighting design solutions overlook user
requirements, namely the ones related with user non- visual system, which, by the way
affect considerably human health and the sensation of comfort.
Thus, emerge the need to bring this subject to light towards a broader discussion
and to challenge professionals from different background towards innovative solutions.
Research is needed to confirm (or not) the available information once, as many other
aspects in science, there are different approaches, some antagonistic.
Experiences to orient an innovative path to the right lighting design, answering to
function as user requirements are needed. From these will be easier to achieve infor-
mation to support new data sheets to be accomplish in every lighting design project.
Professionals from architecture and design areas ought to be moved to new
approaches beyond the aesthetical or performative (traditional) ones.
References
1. Lighthouse International: What is Glaucoma? http://li129-107.members.linode.com/about-
low-vision-blindness/vision-disorders/glaucoma/
2. Karwatsky, P., Overbury, O., Faubert, J.: Red-Green chromatic mechanisms in normal aging
and glaucomatous observers. Invest. Ophthalmol. Visual Sci. 45(8), 2861–2866 (2004)
66 S. Preto and C. C. Gomes
23. Brøndsted, A.E., Lundeman, J.H., Kessel, L.: Short wavelength light filtering by the natural
human lens and IOLs – implications for entrainment of circadian rhythm (2013)
24. Peng, M., et al.: The influence of low-powered family LED lighting on eyes in mice
experimental model. http://www.lifesciencesite.com/lsj/life0901/072_8366life0901_477_
482.pdf
25. Hobday, R.: Healing Sun: Sunshine and Health in the 21st Century. Findhorn Press Ltd.
(1999)
26. Kuller, R.: Physiological and psychological effects of illumination and colour in the interior
environment. https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jlve/10/2/10_2_2_1/_article
27. Ámundadottir, M.L., Hilaire, M.A., Lockley, S.W., Andersen, M.: Modelling non-visual
responses to light: unifying spectral and temporal characteristics in a single model structure.
http://infoscience.epfl.ch/record/186074/files/Amundadottir_OP16_CIE2013_EPFL.pdf
28. Mills, P.R., Tomkins, S.C., Schlangen, L.J.M.: The effect of high correlated colour
temperature office lighting on employee wellbeing and work performance http://www.
biomedcentral.com/1740-3391/5/2/
29. Gooley, J.J., et al.: Melanopsin and rod-cone photoreceptors play different roles in mediating
pupillary light responses during exposure to continuous light in humans. J. Neurosci. 32(41),
4242–14253 (2012)
30. Braun, H.: Photobiology - the biological impact of sunlight on health & infection control
(2008). https://phoenixprojectfoundation.us/uploads/BioLight-Sunlight___Infection_
Control.pdf