Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Natural Durability of Borassus Aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) Against Macrotermes Sybhylinus Termites
Natural Durability of Borassus Aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) Against Macrotermes Sybhylinus Termites
Natural Durability of Borassus Aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) Against Macrotermes Sybhylinus Termites
Research Article
Investigation of variation in density and the natural resistance of B. aethiopum wood was carried
out using samples along (top, middle and base) and across (inner and outer) the bole of the tree.
Samples collected were oven dried, weighed and subjected to field termite exposure test for a
period of 52 weeks, after which, they were withdrawn, cleaned, dried and re-weighed. The result
of this study showed variation in density of B. aethiopum across and along the bole of the tree
with an average density of 806.495 kg/m3 which falls within the high-density wood classification.
The result of the field exposure test showed a moderate correlation with the density. The
gravimetric weight loss assessment showed that the inner portion had higher weight loss than
the outer portion of the wood, revealing a higher resistance to termite attack. In order to ensure a
higher reliability of B. aethiopum wood in service, cant sawing method should be used to separate
the less durable inner portion of the wood from the outer portion.
Keywords: Borassus aethiopum; density; durability; field test; termites; weight loss.
INTRODUCTION
Wood is a natural polymer consisting primarily; cellulose, shifted to lesser known and lesser used wood species
hemicellulose, lignin in a matrix and extractive compounds especially those that are naturally durable.
that can protect the wood; these are the principal source
of decay resistance in all species (Scheffer, 2003; Termites, one of the enemies of wood, are endogenic
Nascimento et al., 2013). The decay resistance among exopterygotous insect which belongs to the order Isoptera
woods vary between and within individual trees (Martti et and it is one of the numerous organisms that inhabit the
al., 2003; Owoyemi and Olaniran, 2014). Woods with a soil. They are social insects living in colonies and are
high degree of natural resistance have a relative high polymorphic social insects that live in self-constructed
percentage of biocidal extractives. The total extractive mounds called Termitarium (Ayuke et al., 2004; Robert et
content of some wood species can be as high as 20 to al., 2007). They are soft-bodied, moderate to small size
30%. Examples of naturally resistant wood with high insects with biting mouthparts. The wings in termites are
extractive contents are Cedars and Redwood (Davies et temporary, long and slender and in two pairs that are
al., 2014). Termiticidal resistance of wood species varies similar to each other (Robert et al., 2007). They are
depending on many factors including natural durability, deciduous and are quickly shed with a single flick when the
density, extractive types and quantities; and position of the swarming termites find a new nest site, pair up and dig in
extractives within the wood cells either in the cell wall or
cell lumen (Syofuna et al., 2012; Tascioglu et al., 2012). *Corresponding Author: Ebenezer A. Iyiola, School of
Extractives from naturally durable species can be isolated Forestry, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New
and utilized to increase the durability of non-durable and Zealand. Email: ebenezer.iyiola@pg.canterbury.ac.nz
non-refractory wood species (Thevenon et al., 2001; Co-Author 1Email: jmowoyemi@futa.edu.ng
Owoyemi et al., 2016). Due to the decline in supply of 2
Email: oluwatozyn@gmail.com
matured indigenous wood species, effort is gradually being 4
Email: adesogatobi@gmail.com
Natural Durability of Borassus aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) against Macrotermes sybhylinus Termites
Owoyemi et al. 90
to form a new colony (Ekpo and Onigbinde, 2007). to ASTM D2395-14 (2014). The weight of the oven-dried
Termites mostly feed on dead plant material and cellulose, samples were taken and recorded using a weighing
generally in the form of wood, leaf litter, soil, or animal balance and the volume of the oven dried wood samples
dung. Termites are major detritivores, particularly in the were taken using a digital venier calliper. The values
subtropical and tropical regions, and their recycling of recorded were used to calculate the density of the wood
wood and plant matter is of considerable ecological using EQUATION 1.
importance (Inward et al., 2007; Coastal et al., 2013). In 𝑚𝑎𝑠𝑠 𝑜𝑓𝑜𝑣𝑒𝑛 𝑑𝑟𝑖𝑒𝑑 𝑠𝑎𝑚𝑝𝑙𝑒
𝐷𝑒𝑛𝑠𝑖𝑡𝑦(𝑘𝑔/𝑚3 ) = (1)
𝑣𝑜𝑙𝑢𝑚𝑒
some cultures, they are used as food by various animals
……E EEEEquatii…
including man and have been identified to have a highly
Field exposure test
nutritious value (Katayama et al., 2008; Arhin et al., 2018).
An active timber graveyard at the Federal University of
B. aethiopum belongs to monocot group; from the family of
Technology, Akure, Ondo State, Nigeria was used for
Arecaceae (Bosch et al., 2002). It is an unbranched palm
termites’ resistance test. The sites was cleared and
growing up to 20 meters tall (Salako et al., 2018). B.
sprinkled with wood shavings to induce termite’s activities.
aethiopum are abundant and characteristic in all types of
The untreated stakes of B. aethiopum wood with a known
savannah of the region. It is widespread across much of
oven dried weight were buried at a depth of 150 mm below
tropical Africa from Senegal to Ethiopia, south to northern
the ground surface and at a spacing of 1000 mm by 1000
south Africa, Nigeria, among others (Owoyemi et al., 2015;
mm according to their position in the tree (i.e. top, middle
Falade and Owoyemi, 2018). The tree species isfrequently
and base, also middle and outer) for ease of assessment
used as posts and for construction of bridges, other
(PLATE 1).
products including door frames, roof materials, tool
handles and drums (Salako et al., 2018). Recent studies
on the wood have shown its excellent usage in
constructions because of its comparable strength
properties with Khaya ivorensis and Mitragyna ciliata
(Owoyemi et al., 2015). Also, Ngargueudedjim et al. (2015)
made it known that the thermal conductivity of B.
aethiopum wood depends on its anatomical structure,
indicating that the inner part of the wood are insulating.
Due to the use of B. aethiopum wood for construction,
there is necessity to investigate the durability of the wood
which gave rise to this study. The objective of this study is
(i) to determine the variation in density of the stand of B.
aethiopum longitudinally and transversely, (ii) to evaluate
the resistance of untreated B. aethiopum wood to termites’ Plate 1. B. aethiopum wooden stakes at the timber
attack and (iii) to investigate the relationship between the graveyard.
density and rate of termite attack.
Visual rating assessment
MATERIALS AND METHOD The B. aethiopum stakes were inspected weekly for a
period of 52 weeks (one year) for visual assessment using
Wood samples a visual rating assessment table (TABLE 1). This weekly
observation was conducted using a gravimetric method to
Wood samples of B. aethiopum were collected from three assess the level of termites’ damage and the samples
standing B. aethiopum trees obtained from Iwo, Osun were rated as specified in standard American Wood
State, Nigeria, West Africa. The trees were felled and sawn Protection Association, AWPA E1-09 (2009) as stated
into bottom, middle and top at 25%, 50% and 75% portions below:
respectively. Further sawing into sample sizes was done
in the Wood Workshop, at the Department of Forestry and Table 1. Visual rating assessment table (AWPA, 2009).
Wood Technology, in the Federal University of
Type of attack Ratings
Technology, Akure, Ondo state, Nigeria. The B. aethiopum
of attack
billets were sawn into 35 x 35 x 300 mm sample sizes,
Sound, surface nibbles permitted 10
ovendried at 103 ± 2°C until constant weight was
Light attack 9
achieved. These were subjected to termite attack at the
Moderate attack penetration 7
timber graveyard for natural durability test. Also, another
Heavy attack, 30 – 40% of the wood cross 4
set of samples were sawn into 20 x 20 x 60 mm and oven
section eaten up by termites
dried at 103 ± 2°C for 24 hours until constant weight was
Failure, over 50% of the wood cross-section 0
achieved. These were used to determine the density
eaten up by termites
distribution along and across B. aethiopum bole according
Natural Durability of Borassus aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) against Macrotermes sybhylinus Termites
Int. J. For. Wood Sci. 91
Termites’ identification
Figure 1. Density of B. aethiopum wood longitudinally and
Materials for termite’s identification include microscope, transversely.
chloroform, cotton wool, conical flask and digital camera.
The identification was carried out by collecting sample of The result of analysis of variance (ANOVA) (TABLE 2)
termites at the timber graveyard. Species of solider showed that there was significant difference (p obtained =
termites were collected and placed in the conical flask with 0.00 and 0.00) at p<0.05 in the longitudinal and transverse
cotton wool. Chloroform was added to the termites in the direction while there was no significant difference in the
conical flask for preservation and ease of identification. interaction between the longitudinal and transverse
Identification was done under the digital microscope. direction. The follow up test carried out on the density of
B. aethiopum in the longitudinal direction showed that was
Data Analysis no significant difference (p<0.05) between the base and
middle portion while there was significant difference
The study was conducted in a 2 x 3 factorial experiment in between the top and middle portion as well as the top and
Completely Randomized Design (CRD). The data base portion (TABLE 3).
obtained was analysed using Statistical Package for Social
Science (SPSS V21). The descriptive statistics and Table 2. Meandensity of B. aethiopum in the study area.
Pearson correlation were carried out to determine the Source Sum of Df Mean F cal P-
relationship between the density of wood and its natural Square square value
durability. Longitudinal 466275.932 2 233137.966 11.664 0.00*
direction
Transverse 1755527.93 1 1755527.93 87.831 0.00*
RESULTS direction
Longitudinal* 204717.44 2 102358.72 5.121 0.08ns
Density of Borassus aethiopum Transverse
Error 1678964.43 84 19987.67
There was significant variation in the density of B. Total 4105485.73 89
aethiopum wood from the bottom to the top, and from inner *significant at 5% probability
to outer. The density was higher at the bottom, followed by
the middle portion and low at the top; it was higher at the Table 3. Follow up test for density of B. aethiopum in the
outer portion than the inner portion. Longitudinally, the longitudinal direction.
density from the outer portion ranges from 910.70 kg/m 3 to Longitudinal direction Mean value
999.10 kg/m3 while the density from the inner portion Base 873.92a
ranges from 502.78 kg/m3 to 748.6 kg/m3. The result Middle 838.82a
revealed that the density of wood from the base (outer) has Top 706.74b
the highest density value with 999.10 kg/m 3 while the top Alphabets with the same letters show that there is no
(inner) had the least density value with 502.78 kg/m 3 significant difference.
(FIGURE 1).
Natural Durability of Borassus aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) against Macrotermes sybhylinus Termites
Owoyemi et al. 92
Natural resistance of Borassus aethiopum wood to The ANOVA for the weight loss in TABLE 5 showed that
termites there was significant difference at p<0.05 in the
longitudinal direction while there was no significant
The results of visual assessment of termites’ attack on B. difference at the transverse direction as well as the
aethiopum wood samples longitudinally and transversely interaction between the longitudinal and the transverse
for a period of 52 weeks showed that showed that termites’ direction. The follow up test carried out showed that there
attack started from the second week of exposure on the was significant difference between the top and the middle,
wood samples from the Top Inner and Base Inner. For the while there was no significant difference between the top
Top Outer, termites’ attack started from the sixth week of and the base, as well as at the middle and base (TABLE
exposure while termite attack started on the twenty fourth 6).
week of exposure for Base Outer and Middle Inner while
there was no termite attack on the Middle Outer for the Table 5. Mean weight loss of B. aethiopum in the study
period of exposure. Wood samples from Base Outer (BO), area.
Middle Outer (MO) and Inner Outer (IO) have a greater
Source Sum of Df Mean F cal P-value
resistance to termite’s attack when compared to the inner
Square square
portion of the wood samples. At the end of 52 weeks, the
Longitudinal 749.17 2 374.59 2.50 0.028*
Top Inner has the highest rate of termite’s attack while the
direction
Middle Outer has the lowest rate of termite attack. FIGURE
Transverse 10.93 1 10.93 0.073 0.788ns
2 showed the graphical representation of the mean values
direction
for the visual rating of B. aethiopum wood samples
longitudinally and transversely for a period of 52 weeks. Longitudinal* 355.57 2 177.79 1.19 0.310ns
Transverse
Error 12590.83 84 149.89
Total 13706.51 89
*significant at 5% probability
ns not significant at 5% probability
Natural Durability of Borassus aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) against Macrotermes sybhylinus Termites
Int. J. For. Wood Sci. 93
Natural Durability of Borassus aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) against Macrotermes sybhylinus Termites
Owoyemi et al. 94
accordance with the study by Thacker (2002) where most Variations of Borassus aethiopum. Archives of Applied
pest species under favourable conditions have a high Science Research. 5(6): 6-19.
reproductive rate and thus may cause habitat destruction Ayuke FO, Raam MR, Swilt MJ, Oponda-Mbai ML.
when ensuring their own survival. (2004). Assessment of Biomass Transfer from Green
Manure to Soil Macrofauma in Agro-ecosystem Soil
Macrofauma Biomas. In: Managing Nutrient Cycles to
CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVES Sustain Soil Fertility in Sub-Shara African, Andre, B.
(Ed.). Academy of Science, Nairobi, pp: 411-422.
This study affirmed the natural durability of B. Bosch CH, Siemonsma JS, Lemmens RHMJ, Oyen LPA.
aethiopum wood but varied longitudinally and (2002). Plant Resources of Tropical Africa. Basic list of
transversely. The outer part had higher density than species and commodity grouping. PROTA Programme,
the inner part of the studied wood. The natural Wageningen, the Netherlands. 341 pp. ISBN 90-77114-
durability of the wood was due to the thick vascular 01-7.
bundles that was not attacked by the termites. This Costa L, Ana M, Haifig I. (2013). Termite Communication
material was concentrated in the outer portion of the during Different Behavioral Activities in
wood (with higher density) than the inner portion (with Biocommunication of Animals. Springer
lower density) there by rendering the outer portion to Netherlands. 161–190.
be less susceptible to termite attack. The juvenile Davies NT, Wu H, Altaner CM. (2014). The Chemistry and
wood had lower density compared to the outerwood Bioactivity of Various Heartwood Extracts from
making the wood to be less durable and susceptible to Redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) against Two
termite. This study proved that the outer portion of the Species of Fungi. New Zealand Journal of Forestry
wood is durable and can stay longer in service in an Science. 44: 17-28
area exposed to biodegradating agents. For proper Ekpo KE, Onigbinde AO. (2007). Characterization of Lipids
utilization, cant sawing method should be used during in Winged Reproductives of the Termite Macrotermes
conversion to separate the outer portion from the less bellicosus. Pakistan Journal of Nutrition. 6(3): 247- 251.
durable inner. In future, the research can be oriented Falade OE, Owoyemi JM. (2018). Preliminary Assessment
by using preservatives or modifications in order to of Natural Resistance of Borassus aethiopum Mart.
improve the properties of the less durable inner portion Wood to Termite Attack. Journal of Sustainable
of B. aethiopum wood. Environmental Management. 10: 1-9. ISSN: 2141 –
0267.
Inward D, Beccaloni G, Eggleton P. (2007). Death of an
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT Order: A Comprehensive Molecular Phylogenetic Study
Confirms That Termites Are Eusocial Cockroaches.
No potential conflict of interest was reported by the Biology Letters. 331–335.
authors. Jean-Baptise SA, Augustin AA, Florence BN, Didier S,
Brise KM, David V, Jean-Luc P, Seraphin K, Nadine A.
(2016). Wood Natural Durability Study Source of
REFERENCES Biomolecules: Case Study of Dicorynia guianensis
Amsh. Heartwood. Proceedings IRG Annual Meeting
Acheampong JB, Kwaku A, Achana EW. (2019). (ISSN 2000-8953) (C) 2016. The International
Comparative Evaluation of Moisture Content and Research Group on Wood Protection. IRG/WP 16-
Natural Durability within two Borassus aethiopum Mart. 10871.
against Termites. International Research Journal of Katayama H, Yamamoto A, Mizushima N, Yoshimori T,
Engineering and Technology (IRJET). Vol: 06. Pp Miyawaki A. (2008). GFP-like Proteins Stably
1108-1115. Accumulate in Lysosomes. Cell Structure and Function.
ASTM: American Society for Testing Materials (2014). 33: 1–12.
Standard Test Methods for Density and Specific Gravity Martti V, Anni H, Pirjo K, Hannu V, Hanna N. (2003).
(Relative Density) of Wood and Wood Based Materials. Variation in the Decay Resistance and its Relationship
Book of Standard Volumes. Pp 1 – 31. with other Wood Characteristics in Old Scots Pines.
AWPA: American Wood Protection Association. (2009). Annals of Forest Science, Springer Verlag (Germany).
Standard Method for Laboratory Evaluation to 60 (5):409-417.
Determine Resistance to Subterranean Termites (E1- Miranda I, Sousa V, Pereira H. (2011). Wood Properties of
09). 2012Book of Standards. Pp 1 - 11 Teak (Tectona grandis) from a Mature Unmanaged
Arhin E, Captain-Esoah M, Berdie BS. (2018). Economic Stand in East Timor. Journal of Wood Science. 57: 171-
Importance of Termites and Termitaria in Mineral 178.
Exploration. In: Termites and Sustainable Nascimento MS, Santana ALBD, Maranhao A, Oliveira LS,
Management, Springer. 1: 241-254. Bieber L. (2013). Phenolic Extractives and Natural
Asibe AO, Kwasi FM, Albert DN. (2013). Assessment of Resistance of Wood. InTech: Biodegradation - life of
The Effects of Density on the Mechanical Properties science. http://dx.doi.org/10.5772/56358. 349-370.
Natural Durability of Borassus aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) against Macrotermes sybhylinus Termites
Int. J. For. Wood Sci. 95
Ngargueudedjim KE, Doroko H, Bassa B, Ntamack GE, Schimleck L, Anthony F, Dahlen J, Moore J. (2018). Wood
CharifD’ouazzane S. (2015). Determination of Thermal and fibre quality of plantation grown conifers: a
and Physical Properties of Palmyra Wood summary of research with an emphasis on Lobally and
(Borassusaethiopum Mart.) From Malfana in Chad. Radiata Pine. Journal of Forests 298 (9); 1-16
International Journal of Advanced Research in Shanbhag RR, Sundararaj R. (2013). Physical and
Engineering and Technology, 6(12). pp. 49-58. chemical properties of some imported woods and their
Ogunsanwo OY, Ojo AR. (2017). Evaluation of Natural degradation by termites. Journal of Insect Science.
Durability of the Wood of Borassus aethiopum Mart. at 13(63): 1-7
Different Ecological Zones against Subterranean Stergios A, Costas P, Elias V. (2007). Strength Properties
Termite (Macrotermes Bellicosus. Smeathman) in of Juvenile and Mature Wood in Black Locust (Robina
Nigeria. Journal for Worldwide Holistic Sustainable pseudoacacial). Wood and Fiber Science. 39(2): 241-
Development. Vol. 3. Pp 35-45. 249.
Owoyemi JM, Olaniran OS. (2014). Natural Resistance Of Syofuna A, Banana AY, Nakabonge G. (2012). Efficiency
Ten Selected Nigerian Wood Species to Subterranean of Natural Wood Extractives as Wood Preservatives
Termites’ Attack. International Journal of Biological against Termite Attack. Maderas. Ciencia y tecnologia.
Sciences and Applications. 1(2) Pp 35-39 14(2): 155-163
Owoyemi JM, Oyebiyi OI, Ogunrinde OS. (2015). Tascioglu C, Yalcin M, de Troya T, Sivrikaya H.
Assessment of Physico-mechanical Properties of (2012). Termiticidal Properties of Some Wood and Bark
Borassusaethiopum (Mart.); A Lesser-Used Species. Extracts Used as Wood
Journal of Sustainable Environmental Management. 7: Preservatives. BioResource. 7(3): 2960-2969.
105-113. Thacker JRM. (2002). An Introduction to Arthropods Pest
Owoyemi JM, Adiji AO, Aladejana JT, Olawale OE, Control. The press Syndicate of the University of
Oladapo OD. (2016). Termiticidal Effect of Bitumen and Cambridge.94-97.
Creosote Oil Treatments on Selected Nigerian wood Thevenon MF, Roussel C, Haluk JP. (2001). Possible
Species. The International Research Group on Wood Durability Transfer from Non-durable Wood Species.
Protection. IRG/WP/ 16-30689. The case study of teak wood. The International
Owoyemi JM, Adiji AO, Aladejana JT. (2016). Resistance Research Group on Wood Preservation. Document No:
of Some Indigenous Tree Species to Termite Attack In IRG/WP 01-10392.
Nigeria. Journal of Agricultural and Urban entomology. Zobel BJ. (1997). Genetics of wood. An overview. Paper
33(1): 10-18. presented at the Timber management toward wood
Owoyemi JM, Eniabiire OM, Emmanuel UO, Fuwape JA. quality and end-product value. CTIA/IUFRO
(2020). Efficacy of Commonly Used Wood International Wood Quality Workshop. Quebec,
Preservatives Against Subterranean Termites in Canada. Genetics of Wood Production. 98-125.
Akungba-Akoko, Ondo State, Nigeria. Journal of
Research in Forestry, Wildlife and Environment. 12(1):
111-121.
Peralta RCG, Menezes EB, Carvalho AG, Aguiar-
Menezes EDL. (2004). Wood consumption rates of
forest species by subterranean termites (Isoptera)
under field conditions. RevistaÁrvore. 28(2): 283-289.
Regina CG, Euripedes BM, Euripedes BM, Acacio GC,
Elen AM. (2004). Wood Consumption Rates of Forest
Species by Subterranean Termites (Isoptera) Under
Field Conditions. Receibido para publicacao. 30-34.
Robert OE, Frank UO and Agbonsalo OS. (2007). Accepted 24 June 2020
Influence of Activities of Termites on Some Physical
and Chemical Properties of Soils under Different Land Citation: Owoyemi JM, Falade OE, Iyiola EA, Oladapo OD
Use Patterns: A Review. International Journal of Soil (2020). Natural Durability of Borassus aethiopum (Mart.)
Science. 2: 1-14. Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa)
Salako KV, Moreira F, Gbedomon RC, Tovissode F, against Macrotermes sybhylinus Termites. International
Assogbajo AE, Glele-Kakai RL.(2018). Traditional Journal of Forestry and Wood Science, 7(2): 089-095.
Knowledge and Cultural Importance of Borassus
aethiopum Mart. In Benin: Interacting Effects of
Sociodemographic Attributes and Multi-Scale
Abundance. Journal of Ethnobiology and
ethnomedicine. 14:36-52. Copyright: © 2020 Owoyemi et al. This is an open-access
Scheffer TC. (2003). Natural Resistance of Wood to article distributed under the terms of the Creative
Microbial Deterioration. Annual Review of Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted
Phytopathology 4(1): 147-168. use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
provided the original author and source are cited.
Natural Durability of Borassus aethiopum (Mart.) Wood Grown in Iwo, Osun State (Nigeria, West Africa) against Macrotermes sybhylinus Termites