Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Analisis de Rodiozonato
Analisis de Rodiozonato
Analisis de Rodiozonato
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
Recently it was found that under-potential deposited (upd) layers of Pb, Tl and Bi
on Pt improve markedly the reversibility of some redox systems, such as quinhydrone
and pyrocatechol/o-benzoquinone [l], adrenaline/adrenalinequinone [2], o-benzo-
quinone dioxime/o-dinitrosobenzene [3] and ascorbic acid/dehydroascorbic acid
[4]. The standard potentials of these systems are very similar to the potential range
of the platinum oxide formation, and there are different views about the catalytic
role of the adatoms. Sakamoto and Takamura attributed the enhanced catalytic
activity of the Pt electrode for the oxidation of adrenaline [2] and ascorbic acid [4]
to the catalytic role of M,, (M = Pb, Tl and Bi) in providing increased coverage of
OH 0
(HHB) (THO) (RDZ)
(RDZ.2 H,O)
The anodic behaviour of RDZ has so far not been studied either on mercury or
on other solid electrodes.
In this paper we describe the catalytic effect of the upd of Pb, Tl and Bi on Pt on
the oxidation of RDZ and the reduction and oxidation processes of THQ in acid
solutions. The study was carried out employing cyclic voltammetric, rotating disc
and ring-disc techniques.
EXPERIMENTAL
The experimental procedure and the equipment used have been described previ-
ously [1,3]. Disc and ring-disc measurements were performed using Tacussel
rotating electrodes, type EDI-Pt and EAD 1OCKKl Pt-Pt. Pretreatment of the
electrodes consisted of mechanical polishing with diamond paste followed by
electrochemical activation by applying a continuous sweep between hydrogen and
137
just before oxygen evolution in aqueous 0.5 M perchloric acid solution. The
roughness factor of the electrodes was about 1.15, which was estimated by integra-
tion of the hydrogen adsorption-desorption current-potential curves, assuming that
210 PC cm-’ of hydrogen is adsorbed on a perfectly smooth Pt electrode. A Pt sheet
with a roughness factor of about 1.35 was also used for the cyclic voltammetric
experiments. The electrode potentials, E,, given in this paper are referred to a SHE.
All measurements were carried out at T = 298 K except where stated otherwise.
The supporting electrolyte was prepared from triply distilled water and HClO,
(Merck, suprapure). Sodium rhodizonate (puriss p.a.) and THQ (puriss p.a) were
from Fluka and were used without further purification. The other reagents used
were of suprapure or GR grade quality (Merck). Perchloric salts were prepared from
the respective oxides or carbonates and perchloric acid. Before the beginning of
each experiment, the solution was deaerated with purified nitrogen. During the
measurements a nitrogen stream was passed above the solution.
Oxidation of RDZ .2 H,O on Pt and Pt surfaces covered by Tl, Pb and Bi upd layers
.O-
‘i
-fl
5 1-E
1
pl a5Jg.0
‘6 2
.o- 0.5
3’
‘*oI; ( , ,
Fig. 1. Current density-potential curves for RDZ.2 Hz0 (lo-’ M sodium rhodizonate) oxidation on a
Pt rotating-disc electrode in 0.5 M HClO4 in the absence ( -) and presence (- - -) of 5 X lo-’
M Bi(ClO4)s. ldE/drJ =lO mV s-l. Rotation frequency/ Hz: (1) 12.5; (2) 18.3; (3) 25; (4) 35; (5) 50;
(6) 75. Inset: Limiting diffusion current density id vs. w1j2 (w = 2rrf).
138
a
0 0
4x
OH OH
Ho 0
OH - (2e-+2H+) OH H,O
OH OH - hydration products (3)
HO 0
OH OH
0 0
0.8
-0.8
I i i 8 ,
Q/V
Fig. 2. TafeI plots for RX-2 Hz0 oxidation on Pt and Pt/Bi(upd~ in 0.5 M HCIO, obtained from the
rotating disc data of Fig. 1. Rotation frequency f = 35 Hz.
RDZ -2 H,O concentrations higher than 10e3 mol 1-r. This presumably is due to
the competitive adsorption of the organic molecules which, as we shall see below, is
responsible for the pure reversibility of the oxidation process on bare platinum.
In order to determine the reaction order on Pt/Bi(upd), the following equation
has been used [12,13]:
i = k[RDZ * 2 H,O]”
i
%$
1 m
where k is the rate constant, m is the reaction order and [RDZ +2 H,O] is the
concentration of RDZ a2 H,O in the solution. By plotting logi vs. log (i, - Q/id at
different rotation rates and different potentials, the slope M can be determined.
Such plots, corresponding to the polarization curves of Fig. 1, are shown in Fig. 3.
They give m = 0.68 (average value) on Pt and m = 0.96 on Pt/Bi(upd). The value
m = 0.68 on Pt is in excellent agreement with that calculated from the Tafel plots,
while m= 0.96 on Pt/Bi(upd) is very close to unity.
The Tafel slopes and reaction orders provide strong evidence that the upd of Bi
hinders the adsorption of the reacting molecules, thus leading to the change of the
reaction mechanism from an “inner sphere” mechanism, involving adsorbed inter-
mediates on bare platinum, to an “outer sphere” one without complications from
140
Pt/Bi (upd)
-0.41 , , , , , 1
-1.4 -1.2 -1.0 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2
log id - i
id
Fig. 3. Reaction order plots for RDZ.2 Hz0 oxidation on Pt and Pt/Bi(upd) in 0.5 M HC104. Data
obtained from Fig. 1.
the adsorption of the reacting molecules, which favours faster electron exchange at
the electrode-solution interface.
Different behaviour is detected on Pt/Tl(upd) and Pt/Pb(upd). As seen in Fig. 4,
the polarization behaviour of RDZ .2 H,O on Pt/Tl(upd) is characterized by the
appearance of two well-separated oxidation waves. (The increase of the anodic
current density at the end of the potential sweep is due to the onset of the reaction
Tl+ + T13+ + 2 e-.) Similar behaviour is observed on Pt/Pb(upd). However, it is
hard to accept that these waves represent two steps in the reaction mechanism. The
relative height of the first wave decreases at high rotation frequencies and at high
concentrations of RDZ * 2 H,O. This behaviour may be interpreted in terms of the
assumption that in both waves an overall two-electron process is operating. In the
first wave the oxidation occurs on Pt/M(upd) surfaces without complications from
the adsorption of the reacting molecules, while in the second wave the oxidation
proceeds with an overvoltage as on bare platinum owing to the adsorption of the
reacting molecules following anodic desorption of the upd layers. This behaviour is
141
2.0 -
1.5 -
;
E
i l.O-
‘G
0.5 -
0 I 1
0.6 1.o 1.4
EH/V
Fig, 4. Current density-potential curves for RDZ’2 Hz0 (lo-’ M sodium rhodizonate) oxidation on a
Pt rotating-disc electrode in 0.5 M HClO, in the presence of lo-’ M TlClO,. Id E/dr 1= 10 mV s-l
Rotation frequency f Hz: (1) 12.5; (2) 18.3; (3) 25; (4) 35; (5) 50; (6) 75.
Fig. 3. Current density-potential curves for THQ (5 X IO-’ M) reduction and oxidation on a Pt
rotating-disc electrode in 0.5 M HClO, in the absence (I) and presence (2) of lo-’ M TlClO,
IdE/dtj =I0 mV s-l; rotation frequency f = SOHz.
oxidation wave of RDZ - 2 H,O on Pt/Tl(upd) (Fig. 1) owing to the inductive effect
of the hydrated carbonyl groups.
The upd effect of Tl, Pb and Bi on the reversibility of the HHB/THQ and
THQ/RDZ redox couples on Pt was studied under potent~~yn~~ conditions.
Figure 6 presents the cyclic vol~~o~ams of THQ, in the absence and presence of
10v3 M Tl’ in the solution, as a function of the potential scan rate. Similar cyclic
voltammograms were also recorded in the presence of 5 x 1O-5 it4 Pb*+ and Bi3+
ions. The cathodic peak of THQ corresponds to an anodic peak of equal height
upon scan reversal, while the anodic peak has no corresponding cathodic peak at
scan rates lower than 0.2 V sei. This is obviously due to the rapid hydration of
RDZ. The anodic and cathodic current peaks of THQ on Pt and Pt/Tl(upd)
electrodes vary linearly with the square root of the scan rate (Fig. 6, inset),
indicating single effusion-controlled type reduction and o~dation processes.
As shown in Fig. 6, the upd of Tl markedly improves the reversibility of the
THQ/HHB redox system and the oxidation of THQ. This is readily verified by
comparing the peak potentials on Pt~~~upd) with those on bare Pt. Furthermore,
while the peak potentials on bare Pt depend linearly on logu, on Pt/Tl{upd) they
remain constant at all potential scan rates. This is evident from the E,-logu plots of
the reduction and oxidation wave of THQ (Fig. 6, inset). Also, on Pt/Tl(upd) the
difference between the peak potential and the half-peak potential for both the
cathodic and anodic branches of the cyclic voltammograms for the system
THQ/HHB and the oxidation of THQ is =c30 mV at all potential scan rates. This
143
1.5 I
I ’ 1
1.2
-0.3
7
6 -0.6
a:
E 0.6
1 I I I I
0 0.4 0.8
%I/”
Fig. 6. Cyclic voltammograms of THQ (10m3 M) on a Pt sheet in 0.5 M HCIO, in the absence (A) and
presence (B) of lo-’ M TlClO,. Scan rate 0 mV s-‘: (1) 50: (2) 100; (3) 200; (4) 300: (5) 400. Insets:
Plot of I vs. u*‘* for THQ reduction (C) and oxidation (C’) in the absence (1) and presence (2) of
TlCIO,. {lot of Ep vs. logu for THQ reduction (D) and oxidation (D’) in the absence (1) and presence
(2) of TlClO,.
144
30 0.3
6
--.
disc
5 ‘\ ring
--\ \ 0.2
4
---_ ‘4
1 1 \\
---\\\I
L--_
.\I \2
1 \
---_ 0.1.2
L\
\
s
"ring' 0.50 v
f
4
E -0.1
\
2
Q/V
Fig. 7. Ring-disc measurements for THQ (5 x 10e4 M) reduction and oxidation on Pt in 0.5 M HCIO,
in the presence of 10m3 M ‘lIC10,. Id E/dt 1= 10 mV s- ‘. Rotation frequency / Hz: (1) 12.5; (2) 25; (3)
35; (4) 50; (5) 75; (6) 100.
value is in good agreement with the theoretical value of 28.2 mV for a two-electron
reversible process calculated from the equation of Nicholson and Shain [18].
The hydration kinetics of RDZ have been studied by Moiroux et al. [9] from
cyclic voltammetric experiments of THQ on mercury. They found that between pH
2 and 3, THQ is oxidized yielding RDZ*- followed by a pseudo-first-order
hydration reaction (rate constant k = (8 f 3) X lo5 [H’]’ s-l). k could not be
determined at pH -z 2 because the anodic current of THQ was masked by the
oxidation of mercury. Cyclic voltammetry on Pt/Tl(upd) does not help either, since
very high scan rates are required for this determination and at these scan rates
capacitive currents become too large.
The rotating ring-disc electrode is ideally suited for the study of EC processes
[19]. The oxidation of THQ to RDZ follows this type of mechanism. The improve-
ment of the reversibility of the oxidation wave of THQ by upd monolayers allows
ring-disc measurements on upd-modified Pt surfaces. Ring-disc experiments for
THQ oxidation and reduction on Pt/Tl(upd) are shown in Fig. 7. The ring potential
was kept at 0.45 and 0.50 V (vs. SHE), respectively, where the reduction of RDZ
(the oxidation product of THQ) and the oxidation of HHB (the reduction product
145
of THQ) are under diffusion control. The ring current was recorded as a function of
the disc potential.
The currents observed on the ring electrode when the disc potential is on the
plateau of the first anodic wave are much smaller compared to those obtained when
the disc potential is on the plateau of the reduction wave of the THQ. This is due to
the hydration of RDZ on its way from the disc to the ring electrode. As noted
above, the hydrated RDZ (RDZ * 2 H,O) is reduced at much more negative
potentials. No current is detected on the ring electrode when the disc electrode is at
potentials on the plateau of the second anodic wave, which is in agreement with
ring-disc experiments performed with RDZ - 2 H,O.
The rate constant of RDZ hydration (reaction 2) can be determined by means of
the equation
proposed by Albery and Bruckenstein [20]. In this equation, N, is the kinetic and N
the ordinary collection efficiency of the ring-disc electrode and k is the rate
constant. Figure 8 shows a plot of l/N, against l/w (w = 2?~f) for the system
THQ/RDZ at E = 0.7 V. The intercept agrees with the experimentally determined
value of N = 0.20 for the electrode from the ring-disc data of the system THQ/HHB
which is free of chemical complications. This value is very close to the value (0.21)
calculated according to Albery and Bruckenstein [21] from the geometric data of the
electrode (ri = 0.20, r2 = 0.22 and r3 = 0.24 cm). Values of N, corresponding to
rotation frequencies f between 70 and 35 Hz were taken. At f < 35 Hz, the ring
currents were too small to be determined accurately. At f > 70 Hz, parameter K,
defined [20] as K = (0.51)-‘/3(v/D)‘/6( k/w) ‘12, takes values lower than 3.5. As
120
80
Fig. 8. Plot of l/N, vs. l/o (w = 2nf) for the system THQ/RDZ on Pt/Tl(upd).
146
TABLE 1
RDZ hydration rate constants at different temperatures
a Y is the kinematic viscosity of water. D values at different temperatures were calculated by means of
the Einstein-Stokes equation using the value of D = 4.8 X 10m6 cm* SC’ for T = 298 K.
suggested by Albery and Bruckenstein [20], values of K between 0.5 and 3.5 must be
avoided in order to be able to treat the results theoretically. From the slope
d(l/N,)/d(l/w) of different plots (one of them being presented in Fig. 8) from five
independent experiments at T = 298 K, the mean value of the hydration rate
constant was determined; it was found that k = (2.8 f 0.2) X lo* s-l *. This value
is more than one order of magnitude smaller than the value calculated for pH = 1
from the relation k = 8 X lo5 [H’]* proposed by Moiroux et al. [9] for pHs
between 2 and 3. This is not unexpected since it is reasonable to assume that this
relation does not hold at pH < 1 where RDZ undergoes hydration in the non-ionized
form, while at pH > 2 the hydration of the rhodizonate dianion predominates.
Values of k at different temperatures were also determined and are summarized
in Table 1. The analysis, taking into account the Arrhenius equation, resulted in a
value of the activation energy of RDZ hydration E, of = 9000 cal mall’.
The dependence of the kinetic collection efficiency on the potential at a constant
rotation rate may be used as an approximate indication of the effect of the situation
of the modified electrodes at different potentials on the kinetics of the hydration
reaction and the probable relation of the acceleration of this reaction with the
catalysis of THQ oxidation. Such effects caused by upd monolayers of Pb, Tl and Bi
on the hydration of dehydroascorbic acid and the hydroxylation of adrenaline
quinone following the oxidation of ascorbic acid and adrenaline were reported by
Sakamoto and Takamura [2,4]. The catalytic role of M(upd) adatoms on the anodic
oxidation of the above substances was attributed to the fact that M(upd) adatoms
increase the coverage of OH radicals which take part in the acceleration of the
subsequent chemical reactions. However, our results contradict this explanation. It
was found that the ratio i,/i, has constant values in the potential range between
0.6 and 0.8 V, where the oxidation of THQ to RDZ occurs on the Pt/M(upd) disc.
This suggests that the probable change in coverage of OH radicals on M(upd)
(M = Pb, T’l and Bi) does not affect in any way the rate of the hydration reaction
following the electron transfer. This behaviour and the fact that upd monolayers
l For this determination, the value D = 4.8 x 10e6 cm* s- ’ was taken. This value, reported for RDZ.2
H20 [8], was also used for RDZ.
147
also improve the reversibility of the redox reactions of the system THQ/HHB
(occurring in the absence of chemical complications at sufficiently negative poten-
tials, where adsorption of OH radicals both on Pt and Pt/M(upd) does not come in)
support the view of one of the present authors [l], i.e. that the improvement of the
reversibility of redox reactions by upd monolayers may be interpreted in terms of
the change of the reaction mechanism from an “ inner sphere” mechanism involving
adsorbed intermediates on bare Pt to an “outer sphere” one without complications
from the adsorption of the reacting molecules on the Pt/M(upd) surfaces. The
mechanism proposed by Motoo and Watanabe [22] based on the bifunctional theory
in electrocatalysis (i.e. the origin of the catalytic effects caused by upd foreign metal
submonolayers is the increased oxidation rate of organic molecules by oxygen-con-
taining species co-adsorbed on the adatoms) can be regarded as a satisfactory
explanation for the catalysis of the oxidation of some organic fuels which on Pt
leads mainly to kinetic currents due to the production of self-poisoning inter-
mediates. However, it does not seem to be operative for faster electrode redox
reactions exhibiting diffusion-controlled currents on platinum.
REFERENCES