`EN BANC

G.R. No. L-4663 October 9, 1909  

THE UNITED STATES,Plaintiff-Appellee, vs. PEDRO CABOLA, ET

AL.,Defendants-Appellants.

Wade H. Kitchens and J. Ostrand, for appellants.

Office of the Solicitor-General Harvey, for appellee.

MORELAND, J.:

The defendants, (1) Pedro Cabola, (2) Urbano Ramos, (3) Claro Ramos, (4)
Rafael Apostol, (5) Perdo Ramos, (6) Gregorio Ramos, (7) Agustin Castro,
(8) Martin Soriano, (9) Blas Ramos, (10) Genaro Sison, (11) Domingo
Macaraeg, (12) Carlos Caguioa, (13) Domingo Caguioa, (14) Antonio
Romero, (15) Fabian Rosario.

(1) Inocencio Torio, (2) Nicolas Abalos, (3) Roman Prado, (4) Diego Cansino,
(5) Ricardo Fernandez, (6) Francisco Fernandez, (7) Eugenio Lomibao, (8)
Ciriaco Verzosa, (9) Domingo Archangel, and (10) Celedonio Ramos, were
charged with the crime of violating section 4 of Act no. 292 of the Philippine
Commission, enacted for the purpose of punishing those who should enter
into a conspiracy to destroy the Government of the United States in the
Philippine Islands.   chanroblesvirtualawlibrary chanrobles virtual law library

The defendants were tried in the Court of First Instance of the Province of
Pangasinan and were, with the exception of (1) Nicolas Abalos, (2) Martin
Soriano, (3) Blas Ramos, and (4) Domingo Caguioa, on the 15th day of
January, 1908, declared guilty of the crime charged and sentenced to
various terms of imprisonment.   chanroblesvirtualawlibrary chanrobles virtual law library

From the judgment of conviction and the sentence imposed thereunder the
defendants Celedonio Ramos and Inocencio Torio appealed to this court.
None of the other defendants appealed to this court. None of the other
defendants appealed and the judgment of the court below is being executed
against them.  
chanroblesvirtualawlibrary chanrobles virtual law library

It appears from the proofs that in or about the month of August, 1907, in
the pueblo of Lingayen, in the Province of Pangasinan, Pedro Cabola, in
conjunction with other individuals, by means of the pacto de sangre,
organized a Katipunan Society, which had for its object the destruction by
force of the Government of the United States in the Philippine Islands and
the establishment by said defendants of another government in the form of
a military organization in which Pedro Cabola should figure as supreme
head,

Urbano Ramos as a lieutenant-colonel,

Claro Ramos and Rafael Apostol as comandantes,

Pedro Ramos as secretary,

Gregorio Ramos, Agustin Castro, Martin Soriano, Genaro Sison, Domingo

Macaraeg, Carlos Caguioa, Domingo Caguioa, Antonio Romero, Fabian
Rosario, Inocencio Torio, Nicolas Abalos, Roman Prado, Pedro Miranda,
Diego Casino, and Ricardo Fernandez as captains,

Francisco Fernandez, Eugenio Lomibao, and Ciriaco Verzosa as lieutenants,

Domingo Archangel as military governor of the pueblo of San Carlos and

Celedonio Ramos as military governor of the pueblo of Lingayen.

Under this government the Province of Pangasinan was divided into six
zones or military districts.   chanroblesvirtualawlibrary chanrobles virtual law library

The evidence clearly and indubitably shows the existence of such society and
the seditious character of its purposes. It shows that most of the defendants
attended various meetings of said society, at which Pedro Cabola made
revolutionary and seditious speeches; and that many of the defendants
signed a document or documents seditious in character, their clearly
indicated purpose being the destruction of the Government of the United
States in the Philippine Islands. Many of the defendants were found in
possession of commission from Pedro Cabola appointing them officers in his
military organization.

Several of the defendants confessed their guilt to the public officials and
related facts connecting many of the other defendants with the society in
question.  
chanroblesvirtualawlibrary chanrobles virtual law library

As to the appellant Celedonio Ramos, he was present at a meeting of the

Katipunan Society held on the 23d day of August, 1907, in the barrio of
Taloctoc, at which Pedro Cabola made an inflammatory and seditious speech
and at which it was resolved to construct in an isolated place a shelter for
25,000 soldiers who should be furnished with guns and ammunition, which,
according to the orator, had already been landed at Binangonan by the
Japanese. It also appears that Ramos was elected to the office of military
president of the pueblo of Lingayen at a meeting of the society held in the
month of August, 1907, near the home of said Ramos.   chanroblesvirtualawlibrary chanrobles virtual law library

As to the appellant Inocencio Torio, it appears from the evidence that he was
a member of the Katipunan Society above referred to and that he knew of its
seditious and revolutionary character; that he was present at said meeting in
the barrio of Taloctoc on the 23d of August, 1907, when Pedro Cabola
pronounced the seditious discourse already referred to; that he was a
captain in organization; and that he signed Exhibit A-4, a document
admittedly of a revolutionary and seditious character.   chanroblesvirtualawlibrary chanrobles virtual law library

A careful reading of the proofs adduced at the trial, briefly outlined above,
induces the conclusion is irresistibly that the appellants are guilty of the
crime charged.  chanroblesvirtualawli brary chanrobles virtual law library

The judgment of the lower court is, therefore, affirmed with costs against
the appellants.chanroblesvirtualawlibrary chanrobles virtual law library

Arellano, C. J., Torres, Johnson and Carson, JJ., concur.