Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Media Plan - Phillips Johnson Helms
Final Media Plan - Phillips Johnson Helms
Final Media Plan - Phillips Johnson Helms
1a. Within the $30,000 budget, create awareness and increase market share of Tom’s of
Maine Silly Strawberry Children’s Toothpaste and Silly Strawberry Children’s
Anticavity Mouth Rinse in Benton, Washington, Crawford and Sebastian Counties using
local newspapers, TV, retail and digital advertising. About 39% of residents in these
counties are ages 25 to 54 (FS-Fay TVB, 2018). About 68% of households in these
counties are family households (PF-AD, 2019). This media plan will run from Monday,
August 10 through Sunday, August 16, 2020, because about 62% of parents spend more
money on back-to-school shopping than any other time of the year (“Parents,” 2019).
In order to increase market share, using intrusive media such as television is an effective
way to reach consumers who don’t know the brand (p. 29).
Target Market
b. Target advertising to male and female parents ages 25 to 44 (153, 120) with children up
to age 14. These parents have household incomes of $60,000 or more (121), and
graduated college (156) or earned a postgraduate degree (151), and work in management,
business and financial (121) or professional (162) occupations. Their lifestyle interests
include news (BBC, 154), business and financial news (Forbes, 149), travel/outdoor
adventure (Airbnb, 211), and entertainment (BuzzFeed, 173; MRI-TU, 2018). Parents
and children of all races are targeted including African Americans, Asians, Caucasians,
Hispanics/Latinos, and Native Americans.
c. The baseline is 300 GRPS with a reach of 75 and a frequency of four among the target
market. The proposed plan has 607 GRPS. Use a 75 reach because brands usually stay in
the 66 to 80 percent range and rarely set their reach goals less than 50 (p.96). Set the
frequency at four because this exceeds the minimum basis for effective frequency and
consumers do not remember an ad unless they see it at least three times (p.96). The point
at which advertising becomes effective or motivating is using a frequency of 3.0+ (p.96).
2b. Advertise on the local KHOG 5:00pm newscast on Monday, August 10, and Tuesday,
August 11 because 76% of Americans have a great deal of trust in their local television news
(Poynter, 2018). Place two :30-second ads in Bachelor in Paradise on Monday, August 12,
because it has a rating of 1.1 among adults ages 18-49 (Welch, 2019a). Bachelor in Paradise has
a stickiness index of 116 which indicates loyal, engaged users (CS-TV20Eng, 2019). Place one :
30-second ads in Jimmy Kimmel Live Monday, August 10 at 10:35pm because it is popular
among adults ages 18-49 and entertainment is one of the key lifestyle interests of the target
Advertise on the local KSFM 5news broadcast at 6:00 pm on Monday, August 10, Wednesday,
August 12, and Thursday, August 13. Place two :30 second ads on each broadcast because the
average number of hours of local TV news on weekdays is 5.9 hours and local TV news is the
leading source of offline news in the U.S. (Watson, 2019). Place one :30 second advertisement
on NCIS Tuesday, August 11 at 8:00 pm because it has 4.6 million viewers (NT10-NetTV,
2019). NCIS is ranked third in broadcast TV engagement with a stickiness index of 138 (CS-
TV20Eng, 2019). A high level of stickiness indicates loyal, engaged users (Ziadi, 2017). NCIS
had a 0.6 rating in adults 18-49, drawing 3.87 million viewers (Rejent, 2019). Place one :30
prime broadcast network TV (NT10-NetTV, 2019). Also 60 minutes makes Nielsen's weekly
Top 10 nearly every week and still averages nearly 11 million viewers (“About us,” 2019). The
average audience for a 60 Minutes broadcast is 50% higher than those of the network morning
Advertise on KNWA’s Today Show Monday, August 10 and Tuesday, August 11 at 7am
because it has been the number-one morning show for 49 consecutive months (Ratings: TODAY
is #1 for 49 Straight Months, 2019). Place 3 :30-second ads in America’s Got Talent Tuesday,
engagement among broadcast TV shows (CS-TV20Eng, 2019). Also, it has a rating of 1.6 within
adults ages 18-49 (Welch, 2019a) and draws in 9.4 million viewers (NT10-NetTV, 2019).
3a. Use newspaper advertising because they have broad reach and are published
frequently, resulting in continuous impressions. Newspaper readers tend to be college
graduates with incomes of $100,000 or more and 24% of monthly newspaper readers are
aged 21-34 (“Newspapers deliver,” 2016). Advertise on Sunday in both Arkansas
Democrat Gazette and Fort Smith Times Record papers because U.S. Sunday newspapers
have an estimated total circulation of 30.8 million (Pew-NFS, 2019). Advertise on
weekdays in both papers because U.S. daily papers have an estimated total circulation of
28.6 million (Pew-NFS, 2019).
b. Advertise in the Arkansas Democrat Gazette (ADG) because it can reach 62% of adults
in the four-county metro area (“Reach Arkansas,” 2019). Place one black-and-white, 1/4 page ad
in the ADG Entertainment section on Monday, August 10, because consumers divide the
newspaper up into its sections and only read what they want (Bruce, 2015) and the target
audience is interested in entertainment (MRI-TU, 2018). Place one black-and-white, 1/4 page ad
in the ADG Business section on Wednesday, August 12, because the target audience is interested
in business topics (MRI-TU, 2018) and the Sunday state edition paper reaches more than
Place advertising in Fort Smith Times Record (FSTR) because it reaches 70,200
residential and business readers on weekdays and 85,100 readers on Sundays (“Advertise,”
2019). Fifty-seven percent of FSTR readers are ages 18-54 and 67% college educated (“Media
kit,” 2019). Place one black-and-white, ⅛ page ad in the FSTR Business section on Monday,
August 10, and one black-and-white, ⅛ page ad on Tuesday, August 11 because there are more
than 70,200 daily residential and business readers and business and financial news is one of the
key lifestyle interests of the target segment (“Advertise,” 2019). Place one black-and-white, 1/8
page ad in the FSTR Lifestyle section on Sunday, August 16, because the target audience is
interested in travel which is included in the Lifestyle section of the newspaper (MRI-TU 2018).
In addition, 65% of FSTR readers have a HHI of $50,000 and up and 57% are families with
4a. Use digital advertising because about 78% of Americans are connected to the internet on
average for about nine hours a day (p. 194). Advertisements can reach people in various
ways digitally including news searches and personal interests, as well as on social media
and entertainment (p. 194). Also, digital advertising allows you to reach the right people
with the right message at the right time that will effectively resonate and impact them
(Standberry, 2019). Digital advertising is a rapidly growing market that is comprised of
49% of all advertising revenue (Pew-DNFS, 2019). Digital advertising outlets have
several options for reaching their consumers, including apps, newsletters, and podcasts
which will allow a greater reach (Pew-DNFS, 2019). One hundred percent of people ages
18-29 and 97% of people ages 30-49 use the internet (PEW-IBFS,2019).
monthly visitors and 50,000 or more e-newsletter subscribers (“Advertise- AB,” 2019). Use this
site because the target audience for Tom’s of Maine is interested in business. Place the ad in
Today's News and Northwest Arkansas sections to target consumers in the region who are
college education and 29.5% have incomes over $75,000 (“Razorback Sports,” 2014). Also, 50%
$75,000 and the average audience age is 32. Over 80% of their audience is interested in
entertainment, travel, and business (“Advertise- AT,” 2019). GOOD-ANY OTHER DATA?
average household income of $75,000 and a median age of 35 that aligns with Tom’s of Maine's
target audience household income of $60,000 or more (“Advertise- CA,” 2019). This magazine
has content related to local businesses, travel, entertainment and lifestyle, which are the key
Place a rectangle digital advertising unit on nwaonline.com because it averages over 1.1
million views each month. They have sections that focus on entertainment, business, and
lifestyle. This site reaches educated, at-work adults with disposable income and who have a
strong buying power which aligns with Tom’s of Maine's affluent and educated target audience
more than 131,000 unique visitors each month and their readers are highly educated with a high
income (“Advertise- TR,” 2019). Sixty-seven percent of their readers are adults ages 18 to 54
and 65 and up and have household incomes of $50,000 or more (Times Record Media Kit,
2018). Fifty-seven percent of their readers are families with children in the home so it has the
opportunity to reach parents with young children who could use Tom’s of Maine (Times Record
Media Kit, 2018). Place advertisements in the business and entertainment sections of Times
station that targets NWA residents and consumers, and 37% of U.S. adults prefer to get their
local news from the news stations website (“Nearly as,” 2019). Place the advertisement in the
health section because Tom’s target audience is more likely to be interested in the health of the
Place a rectangle digital advertising unit on 4029tv.com because it is a local news station
that targets local NWA residents. It will gain the attention of the local marketplace, and will
provide the details and interactivity necessary to acquire new customers (“Advertise with,”
2019). Also, about 58% of American adults often get news on mobile devices and about 39% get
news on a desktop or computer, so placing advertising on 4029tv.com will tap into this group of
consumers (Fedeli & Matsa, 2018). Place the advertisement in the BHealthy or local news
section because Tom’s of Maine’s target audience is conscious about the health of their children
and Travel sections on Monday, August 10 through Sunday, August 16 because CNN’s cross-
platform audience reaches 53% of all millennials in the U.S. monthly across TV and digital
(CNN, 2019). Also, CNN is ranked second for the total minutes viewed by affluent adults in the
general news category (VAB-GF, 2018). Place the ad on CNN’s Original Series section because
it reaches a younger, high-quality affluent audience that is more likely to be engaged and
receptive to advertising (CNN, 2019). CNN Original Series viewers are 40% more likely to be
college graduates and they are 26% more likely to have a household income of $100,000 or
higher (CNN, 2019). Advertise on CNN Business because 22% of affluent Americans ages 18
and up work in business, management, or financial jobs, and 60% consider their work to be a
career and not just a job (VAB-GF, 2018). Advertise on CNN Travel because affluent Americans
spent over $6,000 on foreign and domestic vacations in the last 12 months (VAB-GF, 2018).
5a. Use retail advertising because about 75% of brand choices are made in-store and
about half of the total purchases at grocery stores are spent on items consumers
were not planning to purchase (p. 201). With retail advertising, register sales data
is available, making it easier to connect exposures to sales (p. 202). This is
effective because 75% of consumers are more likely to buy from a retailer that
recognizes them by name, recommends options based on past purchases, or
knows their purchase history (“Statistics about retail,” 2018).
because it is the number one retail pharmacy chain with a 23.8% market share (DDN-5, 2018).
Forty-one percent of consumers that earn $75,00 to $99,000 and 44% of consumers that earn
$100,000 or more shop at CVS (Mintel-DSR-RS, 2019). Thirty-seven percent of consumers aged
25-34 shop at CVS and 39% of consumers aged 35-44 shop at CVS (Mintel-DSR-RS, 2019). An
advantage to placing advertisements in CVS is the wide range of locations across the country
d. Place an end cap display in all cities because it is developed for a consistent look aligned with
CVS pharmacy guidelines and it is easily updatable (POP-D, 2019). End cap displays are often
some of the first displays customers see when they enter the store and are highly customizable
(Mcintyre, 2018). End caps can highlight a featured product and offer the opportunity to
showcase specialty products. They can also increase brand recognition because it sets your brand
apart from others in the same category (BDSmktg, 2016). Of the thousands of shopper
transactions in a store, 29% of shoppers pass any given end cap, twice the number of shoppers
who go down any given aisle of the store (Wade, 2016). Place the CVS end cap in the
pharmaceutical area of the store within the oral hygiene section. Place in this section toward the
back of the store because endcaps in the rear of the store see less shopper traffic but generate
better absolute shopper takeaway than end caps in the front of the store (Wade, 2016). Use a
white display covered in photos of bright, fresh strawberries to emphasize the natural ingredients
in Tom’s of Maine. Give the strawberries “silly” facial expressions to attract the attention of
children and tie in the name of the oral care flavor. Feature the benefits of using Silly Strawberry
toothpaste and mouthwash “fluoride free” and “cavity protection”. Place both products on
6a. Use out-of-home (OOH) advertising because it reaches potential customers close
to the point of sale, allows for easy repetition in high-traffic areas, and can enable
quick and simple communication. OOH is effective because 70% of the
consumer’s time is spent out-of-home (OFM-MK, 2019). OOH offers the
potential to reach 75% of the U.S. population each week, with a high frequency of
20 or more times a day (OFM-MK, 2019). Adults ages 16-34 are the demographic
most engaged with OOH advertising (Lamar research, 2019). Also, when OOH is
added to the media mix, it increases search’s return on ad spend by 40%, drives
nearly four times more social and digital activations, and allows for consumers to
be 48% more likely to interact engage with a mobile ad after being exposed to the
same OOH ad first (OFM-MK, 2019).
b. Use billboard advertising because they give your message a long-term presence and
have tremendous visibility by vehicular traffic because they are located on key highways,
intersections and integral choke points. They are located in the top 50 markets and provide
around-the-clock visibility (OFM-MK, 2019). They command your audience's attention with
creative three-dimensional designs, moving parts and extensions (“Digital billboards,” 2013).
Use digital billboards because they allow messages to be quickly changed, are much more visible
and engaging, and they can provide an interactive experience (p. 187). Digital billboard
advertising allows message changes easily and frequently with no extra production costs
(“Digital billboards,” 2013). Place digital billboard advertisements in all 10 recommended major
metropolitan areas to reach a large volume of targeted consumers with a high frequency. Show a
happy child brushing their teeth with Tom’s of Maine Silly Strawberry toothpaste with animated,
personified, silly strawberries hopping around the billboard. Use a slogan such as “make
brushing silly” to grab the attention of children. Mention the benefits of using Silly Strawberry
Boston because buses circulate in the busiest areas of major metropolitan cities, and bus
advertising offers exposure to local commuters, drivers, and pedestrians (“Moving billboards,”
2019). Transit advertising provides repetition and continuous exposure day and night (p. 188).
Buses are rolling billboards that reach densely populated areas (OFM-MK, 2019). Buses target
specific demographics based on route and deliver exposure where other out-of-home advertising
may be prohibited (“Moving billboards,” 2019). Feature strawberries covering the display,
appearing to hang out of the windows, similar to the themes of the billboard and the end cap.
Include The Tom’s of Maine logo, pictures of the Silly Strawberry products, and a list of the
product benefits.
7a. Use social media because 72% of the public uses some type of social media
(Pew-SMFS, 2019). In 2019, 90% of people ages 18-29 use social media and 82%
of people ages 30-49 actively use at least one social media site (Pew, SMFS,
2019). Social media supports and encourages interaction (p.208). Social media
advertising is also used to build communities of users focused on the brand, and
in turn, they develop positive word-of-mouth for brands (p. 208).
Stories every day and 1/3 of the most viewed stories are from businesses (“Instagram stories,”
2019). Also, stories make use of the full mobile screen, providing a beautiful, distraction-less
canvas (“Instagram stories,” 2019). Stories encourage awareness, recall, purchase lift, and sales
(“Instagram stories,” 2019). Instagram offers advanced and detailed options to specifically
choose the target audience through customizing the location, age, gender, interests and behaviors
of users which will allow Tom’s of Maine to effectively reach their target audience (“Instagram
stories,” 2019). The Instagram Story features a picture of the product with the option to “swipe
8a. Use influencer advertising because nearly half of social media users say they
have a favorite influencer and 39% of users feel personally connected to them (MII-ES,
2019). Fifty-nine percent of social media users who follow an influencer they do not
know have learned about a product or service from the influencer’s social media account,
while 45% have purchased a product they have seen on social media (MII-ES, 2019).
Influencers create an engaging story that attracts followers who voluntarily opt to follow
them and are eager to see their content (“Most attractive,” 2019). Brands can identify
their target audience and find an influencer that has expertise and favor within that
audience (“Most attractive,” 2019).
Use Instagram influencer, @AlexaJeanBrown, because she has 767,000 followers and is
a mom of three with a big following of parents. She is a fitness enthusiast and uses her
platform to help mothers and families live healthy lifestyles. She makes multiple posts
about her day-to-day life, showing other moms what products she uses with her children.
She posts healthy recipes with natural ingredients, as well as hair and hygiene products
such as Living Proof that are natural-based products. She takes frequent trips with her
family, appealing to the target demographic’s interest in travel. (“Alexajeanbrown,”
2019).
b. Use @alexajeanbrown’s general and fitness accounts as both feature her young children
and target moms interested in a healthy family lifestyle. The post for her general account
features her children in front of the bathroom mirror before bed brushing their teeth with Silly
Strawberry toothpaste. For her caption, she includes the health benefits for the product and ways
to make kids’ bedtime routine fun. For her fitness account, a new post with her kids using Silly
Strawberry mouthwash is posted. This is in the morning and in the form of a “mirror selfie”.
Alexa takes a photo of the kids in the bathroom mirror while spending time with them before her
workout. She mentions the benefits and include multiple photos of her kids’ white smiles and
excitement about using the Silly Strawberry products. If Tom’s of Maine offers a discount code,
Alexa Jean Brown also mentions that in her caption and provides her followers with some
percentage off of their purchase. Another powerful way to reach her followers is to post a
sponsored Instagram story, sharing it to her general page and her fitness page. It is a short video
using Instagram’s Boomerang effect of her kids brushing their teeth. This shows the children’s
positive emotions and caters to those who pay more attention to stories rather than staying up to
9 of the most attractive benefits of social influencer marketing (2019). Shane Barker. Retrieved
from https://shanebarker.com/blog/biggest-benefits-social-influencer-marketing/
50 statistics about retail marketing and consumer shopping trends (2018). V12 Data.
Retrieved from https://v12data.com/blog/50-statistics-about-retail-marketing-and-
consumer-shopping-trends/
Advertising & media kit (2019). Northwest Arkansas Democrat Gazette. Retrieved from
https://www.nwaonline.com/advertising/
End cap displays: Benefits of this prime piece of retail real estate (2016). BDSmktg.
Retrieved from https://www.bdsmktg.com/9580-2/
Fedeli, S. & Matsa, K. (2018). Use of mobile devices for news continues to grow,
outpacing desktops and laptops. Pew Research Center. Retrieved from
https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/07/17/use-of-mobile-devices-for-news-
continues-to-grow-outpacing-desktops-and-laptops
Lakshmanan, I. (2018). Finally some good news: Trust in news is up, especially for local
media. Poynter. Retrieved from https://www.poynter.org/ethics-trust/2018/finally-some-
good-news-trust-in-news-is-up-especially-for-local-media
https://landing.gatehouseads.com/media-kit-fortsmith-ar/
Nearly as many Americans prefer to get their local news online as prefer the TV set.
(2019). Pew Research Center- Journalism & Media. Retrieved from
https://www.journalism.org/2019/03/26/nearly-as-many-americans-prefer-to-get-their-
local-news-online-as-prefer-the-tv-set/
Newspapers deliver across the ages (2016). Nielsen Insights. Retrieved from
https://www.nielsen.com/us/en/insights/article/2016/newspapers-deliver-across-the-ages/
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (2019). World Population Review. Retrieved from
http://worldpopulationreview.com/us-cities/philadelphia-population/
Rejent, J. (2019). TV Ratings Saturday: ‘NCIS’ rerun leads an inflated night, ‘Dateline’
rerun ticks down. Zap2It TV By The Numbers. Retrieved from
https://tvbythenumbers.zap2it.com/daily-ratings/tv-ratings-saturday-august-24-2019/
TV News Desk. (2019). Ratings: Today is #1 for 49 straight months in key demo.
Broadway World TV. Retrieved from
https://www.broadwayworld.com/bwwtv/article/RATINGS-TODAY-Is-1-For-49-
Straight-Months-In-Key-Demo-20191002
Welch, A. (2019b). Late-night ratings: ‘Jimmy Kimmel Live!’ grows. Zap2It- TV By The
Numbers. Retrieved from https://tvbythenumbers.zap2it.com/weekly-ratings/late-night-
ratings-nov-11-15-2019-jimmy-kimmel-live-grows/
Your complete guide to an effective end cap display (2018). Mcintyre Displays. Retrieved
from https://mcintyredisplays.com/blog/end-cap-display-guide/
Ziadi, M. (2017, July 7). Exploring on Industry Terms: Retention, Churn, and Stickiness.
Verto. Retrieved from https://vertoanalytics.com/retention-churn-stickiness/