THE PULSE OF

THE MIDDLE EAST

• EGYPT
• GULF
• IRAN
• IRAQ
• ISRAEL‫ישראל‬
• JORDAN
• LEBANON
• NORTH AFRICA
• PALESTINE
• SYRIA
• TURKEYTÜRKİYE

• Trending:
• Iran-US tensions
• Islamic State
• Trump

• VIDEO
• MIDDLE EAST LOBBYING
• RUSSIA MIDEAST
• CULTURE
• WASHINGTON
• WEEK IN REVIEW

Turkey Pulse

Turkey's opposition parties call for dialogue with Assad

Sibel Hurtas February 18, 2020

•
•
•
•
• 
•
 Article Summary
Turkey's opposition parties have called on the Turkish government to engage in dialogue with
Damascus administration to prevent further Turkish casualties in Idlib.
 SANA/Handout via REUTERS
Syria's President Bashar al-Assad speaks during a meeting with heads of local councils, in Damascus, Syria, in
this handout released by SANA, Feb. 17, 2019.

As clashes in northwestern Syria bring the Turkish death toll to 14, Turkey’s opposition parties are lambasting
the ruling party for bypassing parliament in the decision-making process on Idlib, calling for a dialogue with
Syrian President Bashar al-Assad’s government.

The clashes between Turkey-backed Syrian rebels and forces loyal to Assad in Syria’s last rebel bastion topped
the country’s agenda as the Turkish death toll climbed. Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said 45
soldiers were wounded in the fighting.

The number of casualties suffered between Feb. 3-10 has led many to wonder why Turkey is involved in the
Idlib escalation. The Turkish public is questioning why Turkish troops are in an area far from Turkey's border.

Turkey's parliamentary opposition parties, which represent some 50% of the population, raised similar
questions. Worried that the number of Turkish deaths will rise, the main opposition party invited Erdogan to
parliament and called for a plenary session to brief the general assembly and discuss the course of events in
Idlib. Yet ruling party members rejected the motion of the Republican People's Party (CHP).

Also read

The Good Party — the CHP’s nationalist ally — made a similar call one week later, only to have lawmakers
from the Justice and Development Party (AKP) strike down the notion.

Instead of a comprehensive debate, Erdogan bypassed the general assembly and declared his stance. Addressing
AKP lawmakers Feb. 12, he threatened the Syrian regime that Turkey would “hit anywhere” should Turkish
troops on the ground suffer further harm.

Opposition lawmakers saw Edrogan's remarks as a declaration of war. Many lawmakers chastised Erdogan and
his government for treating the Idlib escalation like an internal party matter.

Erdogan’s remarks drew strong criticism from the opposition ranks.

“The president has to brief the parliament. Idlib is not an internal matter of the AKP,” said Engin Altay, the
CHP’s deputy chair, in addressing the general assembly Feb. 11. “It is not the AKP that represents the 82
million people living in Turkey, it’s the parliament.”

Apart from fears of more casualties, the opposition criticism has focused on the Turkish government's policy
toward Syria.

According to Altay, Turkey's policy on Syria has been ill-guided from the get-go. He sees the cooperation deals
between Moscow and Ankara, which were designed to prevent deadly clashes in Idlib, as doomed to fail.

“Our soldiers might not be dead now” if not for the Turkish intervention in Idlib, Altay said. “Turkey made
ridiculous promises.” He was referring to the two agreements Turkey signed with Russia to set up a
demilitarized zone in Idlib and to root out radical jihadis from the ranks of the Syrian opposition.

“It promised to remove radicals from the modest opposition. Is this even possible?" Altay said. "There is no way
to distinguish these from each other.”

Altay said Turkey’s support for rebels in Idlib, including fighters affiliated with Hayat Tahrir al-Sham —
deemed a terrorist organization by Turkey and the international community — contradicts its policy to defend
Syria’s territorial integrity. Altay described the discrepancy as a “diplomatic scandal.”

The Good Party leveled similar rebukes, with its party chair stating that Turkey has not fulfilled its
commitments in Idlib. “Turkey said it would disassociate modest elements from the radicals, but it couldn’t do
it," Ahmet Kamil Erozan said during the same parliamentary session. "It promised to clean out and open M4
and M5 highways, but it couldn’t open them. Most recently, the cease-fire agreement reached with Russia
couldn’t be implemented.”

The government’s Idlib venture has provided rare common ground for the nationalist Good Party and the pro-
Kurdish Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP). “Idlib has become a nest for all jihadists. It has turned into a trouble
spot for Turkey and the whole world,” said HDP lawmaker Necdet Ipekyuz. “And who is protecting these
jihadists? Who is safeguarding them?”

Altay said Turkey wasn’t even able to medevac its wounded soldiers because Russia denied it use of airspace.
Instead, Turkey transferred the wounded by road with ambulances. “If Turkey cannot medevac its soldiers from
a distance within earshot of its borders, it means Turkey cannot be an actor in Idlib,” Altay said.

What is the solution, according to the opposition?

Turkey’s major opposition parties have long advocated for Turkey's engagement in direct dialogue with
Damascus.

The pro-Kurdish HDP has urged the government to initiate dialogue with Syrian Kurdish groups, which Turkey
considers threats to national security.

However, with the AKP's nationalist allies talking about “invading Damascus,” this prospect seems far-fetched,
at least in the short run. “The Turkish nation must walk into Damascus along with the Turkish army,” Devlet
Bahceli, the leader of the Nationalist Movement Party, told his parliamentary group Feb. 11, after Assad's forces
killed eight Turkish soldiers in a shelling.

Found in:Idlib

Sibel Hurtas is an award-winning Turkish journalist who focuses on human rights and
judicial and legal affairs. Her career includes 15 years as a reporter for the national
newspapers Evrensel, Taraf, Sabah and HaberTurk and the ANKA news agency. She
won the Metin Goktepe Journalism Award and the Musa Anter Journalism Award in
2004 and the Turkish Journalists Association’s Merit Award in 2005. In 2013, she
published a book on the murders of Christians in Turkey. She is currently editor-in-
chief of www.halagazeteciyiz.net and Ankara bureau chief of Artı Tv.

Next for you

 NEVER MISS
ANOTHER STORY
Sign up for our Newsletter

enter email address 

Recommended Articles:

Pentagon says US will not retaliate for Turkey in Syria

Turkey

Turkey launches Operation Spring Shield against Syrian forces

Turkey

Syrian Kurds ponder Afrin’s recapture in shadow of Idlib crisis

 Russia / Mideast

Will Russia, Turkey go to war over Syria's Idlib?

Turkey

Deciphering Turkey’s darkest night in Syria

Turkey

Turkish losses rise in dangerous escalation over Syria's Idlib

MORE LIKE THIS

Washington

Pentagon says US will not retaliate for Turkey in Syria

Turkey

Turkey launches Operation Spring Shield against Syrian forces

Turkey

Syrian Kurds ponder Afrin’s recapture in shadow of Idlib crisis

Turkey

Will Russia, Turkey go to war over Syria's Idlib?

Turkey

Deciphering Turkey’s darkest night in Syria

Contact Us 
• Support and Contact Info
• Advertise

Terms of use 
• Visitor Agreement
• Privacy Policy
• Submissions and Discussions Policy

About Us 
• Our Story
• Mission
• Careers
• Team
Newsletters 
• Subscribe
• Week in Review

PODCAST VIDEOS  

©2020 Al-Monitor. All rights reserved.

The website uses cookies and similar technologies to track browsing behavior for adapting the website to the
user, for delivering our services, for market research, and for advertising. Detailed information, including the
right to withdraw consent, can be found in our Privacy Policy. To view our Privacy Policy in full, click here. By
using our site, you agree to these terms.

Accept