Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER III IV and V
CHAPTER III IV and V
The use of combined cycle technology has been significantly rising for its improved
efficiency and reduced emission of waste into the atmosphere. This has been widely used by the
industry for base load power generation and installed where there is access to substantial
A combined cycle power plant, also called combined cycle gas turbine is a plant which
generates electricity using a gas turbine generator and recovers the waste heat to produce a steam
that can be used as an additional source of power. The major components of a combined cycle
power plant are the gas turbine, heat recovery system, and a steam turbine. This plant differs
from other electricity generating plant in terms of its components and working principle. A
simple cycle plant uses only gas turbine and the exhaust gas is release into the atmosphere.
Unlike the combined cycle power plant which utilizes the heat from the exhaust gas to produce
steam and uses a steam turbine to produced extra power. The efficiency of both gas and steam
cycle is combined with the same fuel source which makes the plant xelmore efficient than other
types.
Combined cycle power plant is known to be one of the most efficient type of electric
generating power plant as it further utilizes the waste product of the combustion in the gas
turbine by collecting the waste heat. Studies shows that the heat produced as waste in the
combustion process is capable of producing super-heated steam. These super-heated steam is
At the beginning of the cycle, the filtered and conditioned air enters the compressor that
is design to sustain the proper amount of air needed by the combustion process. Fuel nozzles
then injects and mixes the natural gas fuel to the compressed air in the combustion chamber.
After the combustion process, energy is released by the natural gas fuel which turns the gas
turbine into a fast spinning motions up to thousands of revolutions per minute. Since the load
demand for the power plant varies from time to time, the frequency of the turbine is monitored
and is regulated by the throttle valve for fuel supply. Gas turbine operates by following the
principle of Brayton Cycle, a thermodynamic process that involves uniform applied force per
area. It generally involves isobaric processes for the rejection and addition of thermal energy to
the system. In real application of the Brayton cycle, no transfer of heat is produced in
compressing the sucked air. Next is a constant pressure application for the accumulation of
thermal energy to the system. Next is another adiabatic process for the releasing of working
energy and increasing the volume of the fuel to the turbines. Lastly, an isobaric operation for the
As the waste product used in the gas turbine contains high potential in generating super-
heated steam to operate a steam turbine, a heat recovery steam generating unit is used to recycle
the heat energy and thus producing super-heated steam. Water tube heat exchangers are
commonly used in these steam generating units as the waste products of the gas turbine pass
these pipes producing the required steam to operate a turbine. After passing to the heat
exchanger, the exhaust of the gas turbine is released to the atmosphere using a chimney or smoke
stacks. Series of pipe system delivers the steam to the steam turbine for energy production.
16
Steam turbine commonly operates at a principle of Rankine cycle, a cycle used to operate
and predict the behaviour of the steam as is passes through the steam turbine. The four common
operations observed while operating the Rankine cycle are constant entropy for reducing the
volume of the air, uniform pressure for adding thermal energy in the system using heat
exchangers like the heat recovery steam generating unit for combined cycle power plant. Another
uniform entropy for releasing of working energy to turn the steam turbine and thus expanding the
volume. The final process is isobaric for the elimination of the heat produced to return the steam
into the working water using condenser. The cycle continuous as the plant continuously operates.
a) Gas Turbine
transform a combustible fuel into a usable mechanical energy. On the proposed power
plant, a Siemens 60 Hz SGT6-2000E gas turbine in design option 1 is used. This was
chosen due to its power output of 117 MW and its gross efficiency of 35.4 %. Also, it
develops a heat rate of 10,169 k J/ kWh and a pressure ratio of 12:1. The exhaust mass
flow and temperature are 386 kg/s and 532 ̊C respectively. In the design option 2, the 60
Hz SGT-A65 of Siemens was used. It can generate a power output of 70.8 MW and a
gross efficiency of 41.4%. Its heat rate is 8696 kJ/kWh with an exhaust mass flow and
temperature of 176 kg/s and 447 ̊C respectively. Also, a pressure ratio of 39.3:1 is
produced. For design option 3, the gas turbine model SGT-750 from Siemens with the
power output of 38.1 megawatts and a gross efficiency of 40.2% was used. Along with
the gross efficiency, it has a corresponding heat rate of about 8,953 kJ/kWh. The pressure
17
ratio of the said turbine is 23.8:1 and a limiting speed of 3,050-6,405 rpm. Also, the said
turbine has an exhaust temperature of 458 ̊C and a mass flow of 113.8 kg/s.
b) Steam Turbine
This type of turbine is driven by a superheated steam, the exhaust gas from the gas
turbine is utilized on the heat recovery steam generator to heat the circulating water and
transformed it into superheated steam. In design option 1 and 2, the steam turbine from
Siemens, SST-300 was the turbine used on the proposed design. It generates power
output up to 50 megawatts. It has an inlet pressure and temperature of 120 bars and 540 ̊C
respectively. With respect to the condensing pressure, it is limited to 0.3 bar / 4.4 psi
respectively. For design option 3, SST-400 turbine designed by Siemens was used. It has
a power output of 65 MW and an inlet pressure and temperature of 140 bar and 540 C. In
c) Combustion Chamber
A combustion chamber is a space of the combustion engine where the ignition is done.
The mixture of air and fuel is compressed until it leads to high pressure and temperature
of a certain parameter then it is ignited. It releases a gas to valve and the high pressure
and temperature gas drive the turbine. This chamber must be deftly designed to be
efficient.
d) Air Compressor
18
The air compressor is the provider of vast amount of pressurized-air to the engine. It
compresses the air and supply the engine to easily combust when mixing with fuel. The
A heat recovery steam turbine is a connection between gas turbine and steam turbine. It
recovers heat from the exhaust gas of turbine and utilized it to heat and transform flowing
purified water in tubes into steam. It is substantially used in combined-cycle power plant.
The produced steam is the driver for the blades of steam turbine to rotate. The mechanical
energy produced in the system is used to drive the generator coupled into it.
f) Condenser
A steam condenser is a device used to convert the low pressured steam released on the
turbine into condensed water. Through the cooled water contact from the bodies of water,
the removal of latent heat from the steam is done. And the converted liquid is circulated
g) Pump
The pump is essentially used to conveyed liquid from a source into a desired
distance. In the system it is used to pump the water that comes out in the condenser. Also,
it is used in pressurizing water in the system. The pump model used in the system is a
boiler feed pump, ES 6507. This pump has a capacity of 269 GPM on speed of 2900 rpm.
plants.
h) Flash tank
19
The flash tank acts as separator of condensate and the flash steam. It helps in
reducing the pressure of steam and allows the high-pressure to condensate. The reduction
occurs before the pressure supply back to the main stream line. This equipment is near
Natural gas is usually used to power a combined cycle power plant, although other fuels
such as synthetic gas, coal and fuel oil can be used. Solar radiation can also be used to power a
combined cycle power station to lessen the fuel cost and environmental impact. It is impractical
to build a gas pipeline to the places where the source of natural gas is not abundant that’s why it
is advisable to use renewable fuels for small-scale combined cycle plants. This includes biogas
Gas turbine usually uses natural gas and light oil. Some fuel, like crude oil, needs to
undergo some distillation process in order to remove the impurities and heavy metals that can
damage the components of the plant. Fuels that requires this treatment needs a separate system to
accurately monitor the fuel for good and low maintenance operation of the gas turbine.
Palawan
The performance analysis of 100MW combined cycle power plant in terms of efficiency
will be presented in the study. Each design option will be considered taking into consideration of
different parameters such as energy balance, work output and overall efficiency. The main
objective of this study is basically the determination of the best energy efficiency of the plant.
20
Better performance of the plant the higher the efficiency. But to achieve the high efficiency, each
design must consider the number of units and price of equipment to be used to be able to comply
with the efficiency requirement. Economic analysis has a big role for choosing the best design
option in the study. This will determine how long it would take to return the capital that will be
invested in each design. Thus, efficiency and economic analysis are both considered for choosing
Each design option in the study, the following formulas are used and evaluated;
2. Compressor Efficiency,
T2-Ta
nc=
Tb'-Ta
3. Entering and Leaving condition in Turbine,
k-1
T 3 P3
. = ( )
T 4 P4
k
4. Turbine Efficiency,
T3 - T4'
nt =
T3 - T4
21
mf x 3600 x Q
IHR =
IP
where,
BP
IP =
Mechanical Efficiency
where,
Electrical Output
BP =
Generator Efficiency
6. Wnet,
Wc = maCpa(T2'-T1)
Wc = maCpa(T2-T1)
Wt = mgCpg(T3-T4)
Wt' = mgCpg(T3-T4')
Wnet = Wt'-Wc'
Wp = v3 (change in Pressure)
22
Wpump (ms)
Wpump,actual =
ŋp
method of stoichiometry. Each molecule for different types of elements and compounds links to
its corresponding mass which is then calculated and analyzed to predict the possible amount of
product after combustion. For the main fuel of the combine cycle power plant which is the
natural gas, its chemical composition is analyzed and recorded to predict the products formed
after the process. Different component of gases constitutes the natural gas but with different
amount and percentage. Based on the observed main component of gas for natural gas, methane
occupies most of its volume percentage. Methane comprises ninety-five percent of the natural
gas. The remaining five percent constitutes for carbon dioxide, propane, ethane and nitrogen.
23
Methane, having a chemical formula of CH 4 is known to be a highly flammable gas containing
present in the equation has been balanced for complying law of conservation of mass. Adequate
To balance the equation, equivalent number of molecules must be present at the reactant
side and to the product side. Take an example for the molecule count of oxygen. At the
beginning of the process which is combustion, there are more molecules of oxygen in the product
side rather than the reactant. To balance the equation, a prefix of “two” is added to oxygen
molecule in the reactant to compensate the missing molecules required by the product.
Figure 6 shows the combustion equation for methane when there is an insufficient
amount of water used in the combustion. Balancing method is also used to comply the law of
conservation of energy by equating the molecules of the reactant side to the product side.
Unlike the properties of the complete combustion where only carbon dioxide and water
are present in the product side, there is an addition of carbon monoxide to the product side due to
24
insufficient amount of air for combustion. Carbon monoxide is known to be harmful especially
Complete combustion is assumed in calculating the predicted output mass of the product.
The molecular analysis and molecular mass computation of methane yields one molecule to
sixteen and five hundredths grams or 0.035384 pounds. For the molecular weight of carbon
dioxide, one molecule corresponds to forty-four and one hundredths grams or 0.097025 pounds.
Water on the other hand has a corresponding mass of eighteen grams or 0.039683 pounds. The
product side contains two molecule of water, thus having an equivalent molecular mass of thirty-
six grams or 0.079366 pounds. To summarize, sixteen and five hundredths grams of methane
during a complete combustion will yield to a product of forty-four and one hundredths grams of
The figure below shows the schematic and T-S diagram of design number one. In the
diagram, single shaft air compressor and gas turbine is used. The exhaust heat will be used in the
heat recovery steam generating units for production of superheated steam. Steam produced will
25
Figure 7. Schematic Diagram of Design Option No. 1
This figure 7 shows the process flow of the design option 1. The open heater for this
design option serves to increase the thermal efficiency of the plant. The design is expected to
have an overall thermal efficiency of 56.76275774% with an average energy output of
187.6057248 MW. The steam cycle composes of a regenerative cycle as the bleed steam is used
to raise the temperature of the feed water in the open heater vessel.
The figure 8 presents the T-S diagram of the design option 1. This serves as a path for the
actual process the brayton and regenerative cycle. The state points 1-5 are the points where the
brayton cycle starts, while the 6-12 state points represent the regenerative cycle.
26
Gas Turbine Specifications:
Model: 60 HZ SGT6-2000E
Frequency: 60 Hz
Power Output: Up to 50 MW
Generator Specifications
Frequency: 60 Hz
27
Efficiency: up to 98.9%
Condenser Specifications:
Tcwi = 37.78 °C
Tcwo = 59.97 °C
0.4
1.4
T 2 = (28+273) ( 12 )
T 2 = 612.2150399 K
P2 = 101.325 (12)
P2 = 1215.9 KPa
KJ KJ
h6 = 3454.4 ; s 6 = s 7 = s8 = 6.6209
kg kg-K
h9 = h f @ 0.03 MPa
KJ
h 9 = 289.23
kg
28
-3 m3
v 9 = v f = 1.0223 x 10
kg
KJ KJ
S, h,
kg-K kg
6.6007 2984.3
6.6209 h7 = 2995.782599
6.6438 3008.8
s 8 = x Sfg + Sf
KJ
6.6209 =x ( 6.8247 ) +0.9439
kg - K
x = 0.8318314358
h8 = x h fg + h f
h8 = 0.8318314358(2336.1) + 289.23
KJ
h8 = 2232.471417
kg
h10 = h 9 + W p1
KJ
W p2 =2.525081
kg
KJ
h10 = 291.755081
kg
29
h11 = hf @ 2.5 MPa
KJ
h11 = 962.11
kg
-3 m3
v 11 = v f @ 2.5 MPa = 1.1973 x 10
kg
KJ
W p1 =11.37435
kg
h12 = h 11 + W p2
KJ
h12 = 973.48435
kg
Figure 9 shows where the state point 4 from the gas turbine enters the heat recovery
steam generator and released heat energy to convert the stream of water flowing from state point
30
Figure 9. HRSG Mass Balance
This figure presents the mass balance from different equipment. The exhaust gas from the
turbine was conveyed and entered to state point 4 where the transportation of heat starts, then the
water flowing entered the state point 12 then it released in the HRSG at state point 6.
W net 117 MW
35.4% = =
QA QA
Q A = 330.5084746 MW
Table 4
Lower Heating Values of Fuels
Gas Gross Heating Value Net Heating Value
(Btu/ft3) (Btu/lb) (Btu/ft3) (Btu/lb)
Acetylene(ethylene)-C2H2 1498 21569 1447 20837
Benzene 3741 18150 3590 17418
Blast Furnace gas 92 1178 92 1178
Blue water gas 6550
Butane-C4H10 3225 21640 2977 19976
Butylene (Butane) 3077 20780 2876 19420
Carbon to CO2 14150 14150
Carbon to CO 3960 3960
Carbon Monoxide- CO 323 4368 323 4368
Carbureted Water Gas 550 11440 508 10566
Coal gas 149 16500
Coke Oven Gas 574 17048 514 15266
Digester gas (Sewage or Biogas) 690 011316 621 10184
Ethane – C2H6 1783 22198 1630 20295
Ethyl alcohol saturated with water 1548 12804
31
Methane- CH4 1011 23811 910 21433
Methyl alcohol saturated with water 818 9603
Naphthalene 5859 17298
Natural Gas (typical 950 19500 850 17500
11150 22500 1050 22000
Octane saturated with water 6239 20542 3170 10444
Pentane 3981 20908 3679 19322
Producer gas 2470
Propane-C3H8 2572 21564 2371 19834
Propane(Propylene)- C3H6 2332 20990 2181 19630
Propylene 2336 21042 2185 19683
Sasol 500 14550 443 13016
Sulphur 3940 4206
Toluene 4408 18129 239 17301
Water Gas (bituminous) 261 4881 4469
Xylene 5155 18410
Source: Engineering Toolbox, 2005
KJ
Q A = m f LHV ; LHV = 45 940
kg
m f =7.194350774 kg/s
m t = m a + mf
m a = 378.8056492 kg/s
T 3 = 1356.771183 K
Table 5
Exhaust Gas Parameters in Exhaust Temperature
T Ρ Cp μ*106 v*106
(°C) (kg/m3) (kJ/kgK) (Pas) (m2/s)
0 1.295 1.042 15.8 12.2
32
100 0.95 1.068 20.4 21.54
200 0.748 1.097 24.5 32.8
300 0.617 1.122 28.2 45.81
400 0.525 1.151 31.7 60.38
500 0.457 1.185 34.8 76.3
600 0.405 1.214 37.9 93.61
700 0.363 1.239 40.7 112.1
800 0.33 1.264 43.4 131.8
900 0.301 1.29 45.9 152.5
1000 0.275 1.306 48.4 174.3
1100 0.257 1.323 50.7 197.1
1200 0.24 1.34 53 221
Source: PipeFlowCalculation,
Interpolating using the table of specific heat constant at different exhaust temperature
500 1.185
532 CPg =1.19428
600 1.214
m t Cpg ( T4 - T5 ) = ms ( h6 - h 12 )
m s = 71.9105202 kg/s
The figure 10 shows the mass balance in the open heater in the design option no. 1.
33
Figure 10. Open Heater Mass Balance
In the figure above shows the masses from state point 7 and 10 entering the open heater and state
m s ( h 11 ) = m 1 ( h7 ) + (ms - m 1 )( h10 )
m 1 =17.82732262 kg/s
The figure 11 shows the mass balance in the condenser in the design option no. 1.
34
The figure above shows the mass 60.141 entering to the condenser and leaving at state point 9.
The entering temperature is 37.78 degree Celsius and the leaving temperature is 59.97 degree
Celsius.
m w =1131.172545 kg/s
W Turbine = m s ( h 6 - h 7 ) + (m s - m 1 )( h7 - h8 )
W Turbine = 74 261.72535 KW
W Pump1 + W Pump1
W Pump actual =
nP
W steam = 72 692.34048 KW
35
Computing the Overall Work of the Combined Cycle
W total =189.6923405 MW
W Total
n Thermal = x 100%
QA
189.6923405 MW
n Thermal =
330.5084746 MW
n Thermal = 57.39409276 %
EP = BP ( n Generator )
EP = 189.6923405 MW ( 0 .989)
EP = 187.6057248 MW
EP
n overall = x 100%
QA
187.6057248 MW
n overall = x 100%
330.5084746 MW
n overall = 56.76275774 %
Design Option 2
36
The figure 12 below shows the schematic and T-S diagram of design number two. In the
diagram, single shaft air compressor and gas turbine is used. The exhaust heat will be used in the
heat recovery steam generating units for production of superheated steam. Steam produced will
be utilized using a rankine cycle with single steam extraction. The design is expected to have an
MW.
37
Figure 12. Schematic Diagram of Design Option No. 2
The figure above shows a simple design of a combined cycle plant composing of an air
compressor, combustor, gas turbine, gas turbine generator, heat recovery steam generator, steam
38
Figure 13. T-S Diagram of Design Option No. 2
The figure above shows the brayton and simple rankine cycle. The pressure in the boiler is 40
Model: SGT-A65
Frequency: 60 Hz
Power Output: Up to 50 MW
39
Condensing Pressure: 0.3 bar
GENERATOR SPECIFICATIONS:
Model: SGen-100A-2P
Frequency: 60 Hz
Efficiency: Up to 98.9 %
CONDENSER SPECIFICATIONS:
Tcwi: 37.78 °C
Tcwo: 59.97 °C
k-1
T 2 P2
= ( )
T 1 P1
k
1.4-1
1.4
T 2 = 301K ( 39.3 )
40
T 2 = 859.2256321 K
P2
=39.3
P1
P2 = 3982.0725 kPa
P3
=39.3
P4
3982.0725 kPa
P4 =
39.3
P 4 = 101.325 kPa
W net
ƞt = x100%
QA
70.8 MW
41.4 = x100%
QA
Q A = 171.0144928 MW
Q A = m f LHV
kJ
Qh of natural gas = 45938.5
kg
kJ
171014.4928 kW= mf (45938.5 )
kg
mf = 3.72268343 kg/s
mt = ma + mf
41
176 kg/s = ma + 3.72268343 kg/s
ma = 172.2773166 kg/s
For T3:
QA = mt Cpg (T3-T2)
T3 = 1704.158897 K
kJ
h6 = 3307.1
kg
kJ
s6 = 6.9041
kg-K
kJ
s6 = s7 = 6.9041
kg-K
kJ kJ kJ
6.9041 = 0.9439 + x(6.8247 )
kg- K kg-K kg-K
x = 0.8733277653
h7 = hf + xhfg
42
kJ kJ
h7 = 289.23 + 0.8733277653 (2336.1 )
kg kg
kJ
h7 = 2329.410993
kg
h8 = hf at 0.3 bar
kJ
h8 = 289.23
kg
v8 = vf at 0.3 bar
v8 = 0.0010223 m3/kg
Wp = v8ΔP
Wp = 4.058531 kJ/kg
Wp = h9 – h8
h9 = h8 + Wp
kJ
h9 = 289.23 + 4.058531 kJ/kg
kg
h9 = 293.288531 kJ/kg
The mass balance of heat recovery steam generator is shown in figure 14 for design option
no. 2
43
Figure 14. Mass Balance at the Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG)
The figure above shows how the enthalpies enter and leave the HRSG. The mass balance will be
done in the HRSG to determine how much mass will circulated and will be transferred to the
open heater.
The properties of exhaust gases at certain temperature is shown in table 6 for design option no. 2.
Table 6
Properties of Exhaust Gases at Certain Temperatures
T ρ Cp μ*106 v*106
(°C) (kg/m3) (kJ/kgK) (Pas) (m2/s)
0 1.295 1.042 15.8 12.2
100 0.95 1.068 20.4 21.54
200 0.748 1.097 24.5 32.8
300 0.617 1.122 28.2 45.81
400 0.525 1.151 31.7 60.38
500 0.457 1.185 34.8 76.3
600 0.405 1.214 37.9 93.61
700 0.363 1.239 40.7 112.1
800 0.33 1.264 43.4 131.8
900 0.301 1.29 45.9 152.5
1000 0.275 1.306 48.4 174.3
1100 0.257 1.323 50.7 197.1
1200 0.24 1.34 53 221
Source: PipeFlowCalculation,2005
From the figure above, it shows the temperature of the exhaust and its corresponding density,
44
Mass Flow Rate
W net 117 MW
35.4% = = ; Q A =330.5084746 MW
QA QA
KJ
Q A = m f LHV ; LHV = 45 940
kg
m f =7.194350774 kg/s
m t = m a + mf
m a =378.8056492 kg/s
T 3 =1356.771183 K
Interpolating using the table of specific heat constant at different exhaust temperature
500 1.185
600 1.214
m s = 59.19545293 kg/s
45
Turbine Work
kg kJ kJ
Wsteam turbine = 59.19545293 (3307.1 – 2329.410993 )
s kg kg
W pump
Wpump, actual = ( ms )
ƞp
kJ
4.058531
Wpump, actual = kg kg
0.6082 (
59.19545293
s )
Wpump,actual = 395.0124643 kW
Wnet,steam = 57479.73114 MW
Wnet,total = 174.4797311 MW
W net,total
ƞthermal = x 100%
QA
174.4797311 MW
ƞthermal = x 100%
330.5084746 MW
ƞthermal = 52.79130325 %
46
Generator Efficiency = 98.9 %
EP = BP (ƞgenerator)
EP = 174.4797311 MW (0.989)
EP = 172.5604541 MW
EP
Ƞoverall = x 100%
QA
172.5604541 MW
Ƞoverall = x 100%
330.5084746 MW
Ƞoverall = 52.21059892 %
Design Option 3
The figure below shows the schematic and T-S diagram of design number three. In the
diagram, two single shaft air compressor and gas turbine is used. The exhaust heat will be used
in the heat recovery steam generating units for production of superheated steam. Steam produced
will be utilized using a rankine cycle with single steam extraction. The design is expected to
104.3175379 MW.
47
Figure 15. Schematic Diagram of Design Option No. 3
Model: SGT-750
Frequency: 60 Hz
48
Gross Efficiency: 40.2%
Model: SST-400
Power Output: 65 MW
GENERATOR SPECIFICATIONS:
Model: SGen6-100A-2P
49
Power Factor: 0.85
Frequency: 60 Hz
Efficiency: up to 98.9 %
CONDENSER SPECIFICATIONS:
Tcwi: 37.78 ̊C
Tcwo: 59.97 ̊C
50
k-1
T 2 P2 P2
( )
=
T 1 P1
k
P1
= 23.8
1.4-1
P2 = (101.325 kPa) (23.8)
1.4
T 2 = ( 28+273 ) K (23.8)
T2 -Ta
nc =
Tb'-Ta
T 2 - 301 K
0.8 =
744.516278 K - 301 K
T 2 = 655.8130224 K
T 2 = 655.8130224 K
Leaving Condition:
Where,
k-1
T 3 P3 P3
=
T 4 P4 ( )k
P4
= (23.8)
1.4-1
T 3 = ( 458+273 ) K (23.8)1.4 P 4 = (2411.535 kPa)(23.8)
51
Entering Condition in Gas Turbine
T 3 = 1808.110961 K
T3-T4'
ƞt =
T3-T4
1808.110961 K - 731 K
0.87 =
1808.110961 K - T4
T 4 = 570.0523851 K
mf x 3600 x Qh
IHR =
IP
BP
IP =
Mechanical Efficiency
Electrical Output
BP =
Generator Efficiency
50000 kW
BP =
0.989
BP = 50556.11729 KW
52
50556.11729
IP = , kW
0.87
IP = 58110.47964 KW
Therefore,
kg
mf = 3.145925693
s
Qa = mf x LHV
Qa = 144517.5345 kW
53
kg
mg =
58110.47964 KW- [ 3.145925693
kg.K
s
*1.0062kJ
* ( 655.8130224 K-301K ) ]
1.2177kJ 1.0062kJ
[ kg.K
* ( 1808.110961K -731K ) - ][
kg.K
* ( 655.8130224 K-301K ) ]
kg
mg = 59.69854387
s
ma= mg – mf
kg
ma = 59.69854387 kg/s – 3.145925693
s
ma = 56.55261818 kg/s
Actual Work:
Wc = maCpa( T2 '- T1 )
kg KJ
Wc = 56.55261818 x 1.0062 x ( 744.516278 K -301 K )
s kgK
Wc' = 25237.51517 KW
Ideal Work:
Wc = maCpa( T2 - T 1 )
kg KJ
W c ' = 56.55261818 x 1.0062 x (655.8130224 - 301) K
s kgK
Wc = 20190.01213 KW
54
A. For the Work of Gas Turbine:
Ideal Work:
Wt = mgCpg( T3 - T4 )
KJ
Wt = 59.69854387 kg/s x 1.2177 x (1808.110961 - 570.0523851 )K
kgK
Wt = 90000.56526 KW
Actual Work:
KJ
W t ' = 59.69854387 kg/s x 1.2177 x (1808.110961 -731)K
kgK
W t ' = 78300.49177 KW
Wnet = Wt'-Wc'
Wnet = 53062.9766 kW
EPg =53062.9766kW(98.9%)(87%)
Wnet
Wnet = 45656.97696 kW Thermal Efficiency=
Qa
45656.97696 kW
nth = *100%
144517.5345 kW
nth = 31.5926902 %
55
BOTTOMING CYCLE (STEAM CYCLE):
kJ
h1 = 3432.4
kg
kJ
s1 = 6.5289 = s2
kg-K
s2 = Sf + x Sfg
kJ kJ kJ
6.5289 = 0.9439 + ( x ) 6.8247
kg-k kg-k kg-k
x = 0.8183509898
h3 = hf at 0.3 bar
h3 = 101.04 kJ/kg
56
57
V3 = v at 0.3 bar
h4 = h3 + Wp
Wp = v3 (change in Pressure)
Wp = 14.007719 Kj/Kg
h4 = h3 + Wp
h4 = 115.047719 kJ/kg
For the isentropic efficiency of work of steam turbine 0.87 from manufacturer’s catalogue for
SST series:
kJ
3432.4 -h2
kg
0.87 =
kJ
3432.4 - 2184.362445 kJ/kg
kg
h2 = 2346.607327 kJ/kg
Figure 17 shows the mass balance of heat recovery steam generating unit of design option
no. 3.
56
Figure 17. Mass Balance at the Heat Recovery Steam Generator (HRSG)
The figure above enthalpies of state point 4 and 9 enters to the unit and exit as the
Table 7
Properties of Exhaust Gases at Certain Temperatures
T (°C) ρ (kg/m3) Cp (kJ/kg-K) µ*106 (Pas) v*106 (m2/s)
0 1.295 1.042 15.8 12.2
100 0.95 1.068 20.4 21.54
200 0.748 1.097 24.5 32.8
300 0.617 1.122 28.2 45.81
400 0.525 1.151 31.7 60.38
500 0.457 1.185 34.8 76.3
600 0.405 1.214 37.9 93.61
700 0.363 1.239 40.7 112.1
800 0.33 1.264 43.4 131.8
900 0.301 1.29 45.9 152.5
1000 0.275 1.306 48.4 174.3
1100 0.257 1.323 50.7 197.1
1200 0.24 1.34 53 221
Source: Pipeflowcalculations
The table above is used as the reference in computing the Cp of exhaust temperatures.
57
T Cp
400 1.151
458 X
500 1.185
x = Cpg = 1.17072 kJ/kg-K
mt(Cpg)(Td-145)
ms =
( 3499.25-391.13148 )
kg
113.8 (1.17072 kJ/kg-K)(458-145)K
s
ms =
3432.4 kJ
( kg
-303.480862 kJ/kg)
ms = 13.32739586 kg/s
Wpump (ms)
Wpump,actual =
ŋp
Wpump,actual = 306.9490566 kW
mw = 333.0464561 kg/s
Wt= ms[(h1-h2)]
58
Wt = 13.32739586 kg/s[(3432.4−2346.607327)]kJ/kg
Wt= 14470.78878 KW
14.007719
Wnet = [14470.78878 - (13.32739586)] kW
0.6082
Wnet =14163.83972 kW
EPg = 104.3175379 MW
W net
ƞ ths =
Qa
3432.4kJ
ƞ ths = 14163.83972KW / 13.32739586 kg/s [( - 115.047719 kJ/kg)]
kg
ƞ ths= 32.03642989%
ƞoverall = 53.50795005
59
CHAPTER IV
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
This chapter presents the economic analysis of the design options for the proposed 100
MW Combined Cycle Power Plant including the capital expenses, operating expenses, and the
total project cost. The Net Present Value, Payback Period and Rate of Investment will also be
presented.
A. Capital Expenditures
This refers to the expenses needed to start up the project. This includes the cost of the
land, installation of mechanical equipment and I & C Supply, civil and structural cost,
1. Land Costs
The plant location is at El Nido, Palawan. It has a total land area of 3 hectares.
This includes the gas turbine, steam turbine, generators, pumps, condensers,
material, structural steel supply and installation and buildings. Building cost is
approximately 33% of the equipment cost based on the “Power Plant Theory and
4. Electrical Costs
insurance costs, infrastructure connection cost and the contingency of the owner
cost.
B. Operation Expenditures
It refers to the expenses that can be sustained during the operation of plants and
the maintenance cost of the plant and the fuel cost that will be utilizing during
operation.
1. Fuel Cost
Natural gas will be using as the main fuel for the proposed combined cycle
power plant. In order to determine the fuel cost, fuel consumption over a year will
be computed then multiplied to the fuel rate per million metric British Thermal
Unit.
60
It consists of the staffing and monthly fees, bonuses, plant support equipment,
It consists of the raw water, waste and disposal of waste water, power purchase,
charges on the demand, related utilities, lubricants and consumable materials and
supplies. These are the expenses that vary with electrical generation.
C. Economic Indicators
1. Annual Revenue
This is the amount of money generated by the investment within the year.
2. Annual Cost/Depreciation
It refers to the decrease of power plant value within the useful life. The useful
life of a typical power plant has a range of 25-30 years according to Rajput book
entitled “Power System Engineering”. The power plant salvage value is assumed
In order to determine the net present value of the three different design options,
4. Payback Period
61
It refers to the time that the initial cash outflow of an investment is expected to
5. Rate of Return
6. Sensitivity Analysis
A. CAPITAL EXPENDITURES
LAND COST
The proposed 100 MW combined power plant has a total land area of 3 hectares or
Table 8
Mechanical Equipment
Components No. of Price/Unit Total Cost
62
Units ($) ($)
Black Start System 1 618,000 618,000
Gas Turbine and
1 65,000,000 65,000,000
Generator Assembly
Heat Recovery Steam
1 12,000,000 12,000,000
Generator (HRSG)
Steam Turbine Units 1 8,500,000 8,500,000
No. of Price/Unit Total Cost
Components
Units ($) ($)
Generator Step-up
1 2,000,000 2,000,000
Transformers
Auxiliary Transformers 1 500,000 500,000
Feed Water Pumps 2 8,000 16,000
Open Feed Water Heater 1 85,000 85,000
Main Condenser 1 5,500,000 5,500,000
Cooling Water Pumps 2 10,000 20,000
Instrumentation and
1 1,660,000 1,660,000
Control
Total 95,899,000
ELECTRICAL COSTS
OWNER COSTS
63
Owner Costs = 0.10 ($ 95,899,000 )
Table 9
Summary of Capital Expenditures
Land Cost $ 1,707,075
Mechanical Equipment $ 95,899,000
Civil and Structural Cost $ 31,646,670
Electrical Cost $ 19,179,800
Owner Cost $ 9,589,900
Total $ 158,022,445
B. OPERATION EXPENDITURES
FUEL COST
$ 1 MM Btu
Fuel Cost = 2.87 x x 187 605.7248 kW x 8760 hrs
MM Btu 293.3 kWh
Table 10
Fixed Operating Cost
POSITION QUANTITY LABOR RATE ($)
General Manager 1 222,485
Business Manager 1 89,672
Technical Manager 1 172,274
Performance Engineer 1 175,702
Instrumentation and Control
1 175,702
Engineer
Gasification Engineer 1 175,702
Syn Gas Engineer 1 175,702
Assistant Manager 1 95,612
Asset Scheduler 1 85,186
Contract Administration 1 83,479
Fuel and Bi-Product Manager 1 155,195
Procurement Manager 1 89,418
Accountants 1 77,226
64
EH & S Manager 1 152,373
Environment Specialist 1 84,800
Safety Specialist 1 117,027
Storeroom Manager 1 95,701
Maintenance Planner 2 256,391
Store Person 2 101,285
CMMS Technician 1 92,018
POSITION QUANTITY LABOR RATE ($)
Admin Support 3 198,531
HR Generalist 1 85,186
Billing Clerk 2 130,125
Plant Chemist 1 121,896
Lab Tech 2 148,539
Operation’s Manager 1 193,702
Assistant Operation Manager 1 186,701
Shift Supervisor 5 751,145
Control Operators 5 649,811
Auxiliary Operators 5 447,467
Control Operators (Gasifier) 12 1,559,546
Operations Coordinator 2 259,924
Auxiliary Operators
20 1,789,867
(Gasifier)
Auxiliary Operators (Water
12 1,073,920
Treatment)
Maintenance Manager 1 182,158
Plant Mechanics 8 813,280
I&C/DCS Specialist 8 839,045
Mechanical Supervisor 1 107,776
Electrical Supervisor 1 165,419
Mechanical Specialist 2 209,826
Contract Maintenance
1 118,414
Supervisor
Total 116 12,705,228
Table 11
Total Maintenance Cost
MAINTENANCE COST ANNUAL COST
Parts and Materials $ 23,400,000
Outside Labor $ 10,760,690
TOTAL $ 34,160,690
Table 12
Summary of Fixed Operating Cost
65
Labor Cost $ 12,705,228
Maintenance Cost $ 34,160,690
Total $ 46,865,918
Table 13
Variable Operating Cost
CONSUMABLES ANNUAL COST ($)
Gas Catalyst 5,698,848
Water Treatment Consumables 1,567,780
Power Block Consumables 487,500
TOTAL 7,754,128
Table 14
Summary of Operating Expenditures
Fuel Cost $ 16,081,258.26
Fixed Operating Costs $ 46,865,918
Variable Operating Cost $ 7,754,128
TOTAL $ 70, 701, 304.26
C. ECONOMIC INDICATORS
ANNUAL REVENUE
$1
Annual Revenue = Php 5.10 x ($ 187 ,605.7248 * 0.925)(8760 hr)( )
Php 52.7
ANNUAL COST
66
Annual Plant Depreciation = $ 5,004,044.092
1- 1.065 -30
(
Cash inflows = $ 147,113,147. 2 x
0.065 ) +($ 7,901,122.25)( 1.065)-30
1- 1.065-30
Cash outflow = $ 158,022,445+ $ 70,701,304.26 ( )
0.065
PAYBACK PERIOD
67
RATE OF RETURN
Ne t Annual Profit
Rate of Return = x 100 %
Capital Expenditure
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
1- 1.05 -30
Revenue p = $ 147,113,147.2 ( )
0.05
Revenue p = $ 2,261,489,651
1- 1.05-30
Operating p = $ 70, 701, 304.26 ( )
0. 05
Operating p = $ 1,086,852,337
68
Net Present Value = $ 1,160,384,197
A. CAPITAL EXPENDITURES
LAND COST
The proposed 100 MW combined power plant has a total land area of 3 hectares or
Table 15
Mechanical Equipment
No. of Price/Unit Total Cost
Components
Units ($) ($)
Black Start System 1 618,000 618,000
Gas Turbine and
1 65,000,000 65,000,000
Generator Assembly
Heat Recovery Steam
1 12,000,000 12,000,000
Generator (HRSG)
Steam Turbine Units 1 8,500,000 8,500,000
Generator Step-up
1 2,000,000 2,000,000
Transformers
Auxiliary Transformers 1 500,000 500,000
Feed Water Pumps 1 8,000 8,000
Main Condenser 1 7,000,000 7,000,000
Cooling Water Pumps 1 10,000 10,000
Instrumentation and
1 1,660,000 1,660,000
Control
Total 97,296,000
69
CIVIL AND STRUCTURAL COSTS
ELECTRICAL COSTS
OWNER COSTS
Table 16
Summary of Capital Expenditures
Land Cost $ 1,707,075
Mechanical Equipment $ 97,296,000
Civil and Structural Cost $ 32,107,680
Electrical Cost $ 19,459,200
Owner Cost $ 9,729,600
Total $ 160,299,555
B. OPERATION EXPENDITURES
70
FUEL COST
$ 1 MM Btu
Fuel Cost = 2.87 x x 172 560.4541 kW x 8760 hrs
MM Btu 293.3 kWh
Table 17
Fixed Operating Cost
POSITION QUANTITY LABOR RATE ($)
General Manager 1 222,485
Business Manager 1 89,672
Technical Manager 1 172,274
Performance Engineer 1 175,702
Instrumentation and Control
1 175,702
Engineer
Gasification Engineer 1 175,702
Syn Gas Engineer 1 175,702
Assistant Manager 1 95,612
Asset Scheduler 1 85,186
Contract Administration 1 83,479
Fuel and Bi-Product Manager 1 155,195
Procurement Manager 1 89,418
Accountants 1 77,226
EH & S Manager 1 152,373
Environment Specialist 1 84,800
Safety Specialist 1 117,027
Storeroom Manager 1 95,701
Maintenance Planner 2 256,391
Store Person 2 101,285
CMMS Technician 1 92,018
Admin Support 3 198,531
HR Generalist 1 85,186
Billing Clerk 2 130,125
Plant Chemist 1 121,896
Lab Tech 2 148,539
Operation’s Manager 1 193,702
Assistant Operation Manager 1 186,701
Shift Supervisor 5 751,145
Control Operators 5 649,811
Auxiliary Operators 5 447,467
Control Operators (Gasifier) 12 1,559,546
71
Operations Coordinator 2 259,924
Auxiliary Operators
20 1,789,867
(Gasifier)
Auxiliary Operators (Water
12 1,073,920
Treatment)
Maintenance Manager 1 182,158
Plant Mechanics 8 813,280
I&C/DCS Specialist 8 839,045
POSITION QUANTITY LABOR RATE ($)
Mechanical Supervisor 1 107,776
Electrical Supervisor 1 165,419
Mechanical Specialist 2 209,826
Contract Maintenance
1 118,414
Supervisor
Total 116 12,705,228
Table 18
Total Maintenance Cost
MAINTENANCE COST ANNUAL COST
Parts and Materials $ 20,538,000
Outside Labor $ 8,012,690
TOTAL $ 28,550,690
Table 19
Summary of Fixed Operating Cost
Labor Cost $ 12,705,228
Maintenance Cost $ 28,550,690
Total $ 41,255,918
Table 20
Variable Operating Cost
CONSUMABLES ANNUAL COST ($)
Gas Catalyst 5,698,848
Water Treatment Consumables 1,567,780
Power Block Consumables 487,500
TOTAL 7,754,128
Table 21
Summary of Operating Expenditures
Fuel Cost $ 14 791 602.08
Fixed Operating Costs $ 41,255,918
72
Variable Operating Cost $ 7,754,128
TOTAL $ 63,801,648.08
C. ECONOMIC INDICATORS
ANNUAL REVENUE
$1
Annual Revenue =Php 5.10 x ($172,560.4541 * 0.925)(8760 hr)( )
Php 52.7
ANNUAL COST
1- 1.065-30
(
Cash inflows = $ 135,315,228.3 x
0.065 )+ ($ 8,014,977.75)(1.065) -30
1- 1.065-30
Cash outflow = $ 160,299,555 + $ 63,801,648.08 ( ¿
0.065
73
Cash outflow = $ 993,464,599.5
PAYBACK PERIOD
RATE OF RETURN
Ne t Annual Profit
Rate of Return = x 100 %
Capital Expenditure
$ 135,315,228.3 - $ 63,801,648.08
Rate of Return = x 100 %
$ 160,299,555
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
1- 1.05-30
Revenue p = $ 135,315,228.3( )
0.05
Revenue p = $ 2,080,126,720
74
Salvage Value p = $ 8,014,977.75 (1.05)-30
1- 1.05-30
Operating p = $ 65,091,304.26 ( )
0. 05
Operating p = $ 1,000,612,887
A. CAPITAL EXPENDITURES
LAND COST
The proposed 100 MW combined power plant has a total land area of 3 hectares or
75
Land Cost = $ 1,707,075
Table 22
Mechanical Equipment
Price/Unit Total Cost
Components No. of Units
($) ($)
Black Start System 1 618,000 618,000
Gas Turbine and Generator
2 35,000,000 70,000,000
Assembly
Heat Recovery Steam Generator
1 12,000,000 12,000,000
(HRSG)
Steam Turbine Units 1 8,500,000 8,500,000
Generator Step-up Transformers 1 2,000,000 2,000,000
Auxiliary Transformers 1 500,000 500,000
Feed Water Pumps 1 8,000 8,000
Main Condenser 1 7,000,000 7,000,000
Cooling Water Pumps 1 10,000 10,000
Instrumentation and Control 1 1,660,000 1,660,000
Total 102,287,000
ELECTRICAL COSTS
76
OWNER COSTS
Table 23
Summary of Capital Expenditures
Land Cost $ 1,707,075
Mechanical Equipment $ 102,287,000
Civil and Structural Cost $ 33,754,710
Electrical Cost $ 20,457,400
Owner Cost $ 10,228,700
Total $ 168,434,885
B. OPERATION EXPENDITURES
FUEL COST
$ 1 MM Btu
Fuel Cost = 2.87 x x 104 317.5379 kW x 8760 hrs
MM Btu 293.3 kWh
Table 24
Fixed Operating Cost
POSITION QUANTITY LABOR RATE ($)
General Manager 1 222,485
Business Manager 1 89,672
Technical Manager 1 172,274
Performance Engineer 1 175,702
Instrumentation and Control
1 175,702
Engineer
Gasification Engineer 1 175,702
Syn Gas Engineer 1 175,702
Assistant Manager 1 95,612
Asset Scheduler 1 85,186
77
Contract Administration 1 83,479
Fuel and Bi-Product Manager 1 155,195
Procurement Manager 1 89,418
Accountants 1 77,226
EH & S Manager 1 152,373
Environment Specialist 1 84,800
POSITION QUANTITY LABOR RATE ($)
Safety Specialist 1 117,027
Stor`eroom Manager 1 95,701
Maintenance Planner 2 256,391
Store Person 2 101,285
CMMS Technician 1 92,018
Admin Support 3 198,531
HR Generalist 1 85,186
Billing Clerk 2 130,125
Plant Chemist 1 121,896
Lab Tech 2 148,539
Operation’s Manager 1 193,702
Assistant Operation Manager 1 186,701
Shift Supervisor 5 751,145
Control Operators 5 649,811
Auxiliary Operators 5 447,467
Control Operators (Gasifier) 12 1,559,546
Operations Coordinator 2 259,924
Auxiliary Operators
20 1,789,867
(Gasifier)
Auxiliary Operators (Water
12 1,073,920
Treatment)
Maintenance Manager 1 182,158
Plant Mechanics 8 813,280
I&C/DCS Specialist 8 839,045
Mechanical Supervisor 1 107,776
Electrical Supervisor 1 165,419
Mechanical Specialist 2 209,826
Contract Maintenance
1 118,414
Supervisor
Total 116 12,705,228
Table 25
Total Maintenance Cost
MAINTENANCE COST ANNUAL COST
Parts and Materials $ 26,750,000
Outside Labor $ 16,012,690
78
TOTAL $ 42 762 690
Table 26
Summary of Fixed Operating Cost
Labor Cost $ 12,705,228
Maintenance Cost $ 42 762 690
Total $ 55 467 918
Table 27
Variable Operating Cost
CONSUMABLES ANNUAL COST ($)
Gas Catalyst 5,698,848
Water Treatment Consumables 1,567,780
Power Block Consumables 487,500
TOTAL 7,754,128
Table 28
Summary of Operating Expenditures
Fuel Cost $ 8 941 930.051
Fixed Operating Costs $ 55 467 918
Variable Operating Cost $ 7,754,128
TOTAL $ 72 163 976.05
C. ECONOMIC INDICATORS
ANNUAL REVENUE
$1
Annual Revenue =Php 5.10 x ($ 104,317.5379 * 0.925)(8760 hr)( )
Php 52.7
ANNUAL COST
79
$ 168,434,885 - ( 0.05 ) ( $ 168,434,885)
Annual Plant Depreciation =
30
-30
1- 1.065
(
Cash inflows = $ 81,801,775.12 x
0.065 ) +($ 8,421,744.25)( 1.065) -30
1- 1.065-30
Cash outflow = $ 168,434,885 + $ 72,163,976.05( ¿
0.065
PAYBACK PERIOD
80
Payback Period =16.5 years
RATE OF RETURN
Ne t Annual Profit
Rate of Return = x 100 %
Capital Expenditure
$ 81,801,775.12 - $ 72,163,976.05
Rate of Return = x 100 %
$ 168,434,885
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
1- 1.05 -30
Revenue p = $ 1,801,775.12( )
0.05
Revenue p = $ 1,257,493,782
1- 1.05 -30
Operating p = $ 72,163,976.05 ( )
0. 05
Operating p = $ 1,109,337,188
81
Cash outflows = $ 1,118,279,118
82
83
CHAPTER V
ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
This chapter presents the Environmental Impact Assessment for each design option of the
project that contains the social-economic benefits; this will include the political, ethical and
social considerations. This chapter encompasses the environmental impacts resulting from
operation of the proposed 100MW combined cycle power plant. The health and safety
requirements will also be considered. During the building and operation of the plant, wastes that
will be generated are categorized and the implementation of the mitigation measures is applied in
order to reduce the unexpected environmental that may arise. This chapter also covers on
environmental assessment and risk management standards, atmospheric analysis standards, waste
impacts of a proposed project considering the human health and culture and socio-economic
aspects. According to UNEP, EIA is the method of identifying the impacts of a project whether it
able to find solution to reduce those unfavorable impacts in project planning and design, and to
form suitable and relevant development proposals that will be used in decision making.
Implementing of EIA, both aspects, socio-economic and environment, can be obtained. It will
The effects of the proposed project in the community are determined in socio-economic
impact assessment and change accordingly set by the government to the tolerable standards. Both
parties, community and proponent, should understand the situation for the proposed project.
Proponent must have a clear negotiation to the community to achieve social acceptability. They
ought to make public participation so that they can have feedback for their proposed project from
the people of community. Government serves as mediator and they are responsible to govern the
Socio-economic benefits of the proposed project are community will have improved
sources of energy, employment and livelihood of people will increase, plant will have an access
should be anticipated to prevent worsening situation. For sustainable development of the project
it requires good infrastructure that may bring to better growth. Rapid expansion takes a sufficient
infrastructure that leads to good socio-economic development. It will improve the way of living
A safe working environment should be observed and the safety of the employees should
be secured. The government agency that is accountable for the safety of the workplace and health
of the employees is the occupational safety and health administration. They provide safety
standards and guidelines to prevent accidents. They examine all the violations concerning safety
and ensuring all the hazards and dangerous are corrected. They conduct safety seminar or
orientation about hazards and how that hazards have will be prevented.
84
Workers and contractors during building and operation of the proposed plant should
implement strategies about risk management because they open to the elements of hazards.
Unforeseen accidents are unavoidable. Strategies that includes in risk management are working
site should be constrained and hazardous circumstances that are inevitable successfully with
restriction of site.
Each injury and disease happens the working site has a primary outcome of loss in
manpower and it affects the economy. There are some PPE (Personal Protective Equipment) to
be used to prevent accident or injuries during operation and construction of the plant are safety
shoes, earmuffs, hard hats, safety harness and gloves. Proper training with the operation and
procedures in maintenance is the solution to decrease accidents and extenuating their cause.
During building of the plant, there are wastes that will be generated like metal scrap,
excess materials, excess oil, packing waste, debris may also be generated. Hazardous wastes
To successfully avoid the generation of solid waste, at the time of construction there are
mitigation measures be followed they are: Different types of waste that will be collected should
be stored on and be segregated; Waste for disposal related shipment should be recorded the
information and their type should be indicated also; Disposal facilities, standards for storage
area, and management system, with related parties will be agreed; Accountable for solid waste
and other environmental aspects is the Engineer; Organized working site minimized management
risk; Hazardous material should be stored according to their characteristics and standards; All
storage vessels should be labelled; Hazardous waste should be separated from other waste and it
85
should have a emergency response plan; Employees should be trained about proper waste
management.
Monitoring the exhaust waste from the impurities, particulates, components of a power
plant is a must to ensure that the company is committed to produce quality energy and still
complying with the environment protection standards. Components in the exhaust like the carbon
emission, sulphur and nitrogen particulates are examined. Other impurities like dust, volatile
materials and other left constituents are recorded and analyzed for environmental protection
purposes.
Natural gas and fossil fuels normally emits carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, sulphur,
nitrogen and ash during combustion. Amount of its components depends on the percent volume
available in the fuel before combustion. Environmental standards must be complied at any cost
or the government will have the authorization to discontinue the operation of the power plant and
shut it down permanently for severe violation of these standards. Elaboration for the common
natural gas emission having the potential to harm the nature will be discussed further.
Carbon monoxide is produced when the combustion of the fuel in the engine is
incomplete or burns with insufficient amount of air. It is commonly the result of not good engine
design of deficiency or faulty air or fuel intake system. Failure in converting the fuel of
combustion in to carbon dioxide and water produce a bi-product that can be a serious problem if
not payed proper attention. Basically, a carbon monoxide concentration of two tenths per million
like what is commonly observed in the atmosphere is tolerable to the health and safety of the
people.
86
Carbon monoxide by nature is odorless and colorless, a major reason for the difficulty of
its early detection. Increased amount of carbon monoxide can be lethal to the health of person
that inhaled it and can cause death if not given proper medication. Specific device can detect the
presence of carbon monoxide in an area and its tolerable amount to human being but aside from
by improving the design of the engine for better fuel burning and complete fuel combustion.
Some engine design incorporates enhanced fuel and air intake system to ensure the complete
conversion of fuel to carbon dioxide and water. Periodical maintenance and checking can greatly
reduce the production of carbon monoxide as the common reason of its production is uncleaned
carbon monoxide in the environment is one method to determine if the exhaust products of the
Production of nitrogen oxide in the exhaust product used by the power plant is due to the
presence of unburned fuel, nitrogen and oxygen in the combustion process. Nitrogen Oxide when
exposed to the atmosphere can react to the elements and particulates randomly scattered in the
air and can form ozone that contributes to global warming or acid rain that can damage concrete
building and infrastructure. Global warming abruptly changes the pattern of climate and season
in a particular area that some of the organisms present in it cannot adapt to the changes and can
87
Amount of nitrogen oxide can be monitored by using the method Griess-Saltzman
Sulphur oxide is one of the component that can be found in the exhaust gas of a gas
turbine. Sulphur oxide in excessive amount can be dangerous if mixed to water as the production
of corrosive acid can be occur. Sulphur acid can corrode machine components as it weakens the
component of the assembly and eventually wearing it down. Presence of sulphur oxides in the
bodies of water can contaminate the life sustaining capability of the ecosystem, thus harming the
balance of ecosystem in a particular region. Good quality of fuel doesn’t contain large amount of
sulphur oxide as it burns. With the selection of optimal fuel for the power plant, production of
harmful sulphur oxide can be limited and meet the demand of the consumer without destroying
the environment.
One method of testing the sulphur oxide content is by using the West Gaeke method as it
The end product of combustion, the combust gas, emits particulate matter (PM), this
carbon (C), oxides (O2-) , and any uncombusted elements in the fuel. These particulates can be
Every particulate matter mainly depends on the grade of fuel ignites in the steam
generator. Generally, natural gas has the lower level of particulate matter than other type of oils.
Excerption of oils results to less degree of particulate emissions than residential oils. Particulate
level of burned fuel depends on the four fuel elements; sulfur(S), ash, carbon residue, and
88
asphalenes. These occurs in fuel oils, mainly in residual oils, and have a drastic effect on the
particulate emissions. By knowing the constituent degree of fuel, the estimation of the degree of
particulate matter emissions can be known. Controlling methods of particulate depends on the
different type and sizes of steam generator. The electroctatic precipitators, scrubbers, and
baghouses are mainly used for the control of the particulates. By switching from a residual to
distillate oil or by diverting from distillate oil to a natural gas. Also, through proper arrangement
of burner, modification, and proper maintenance, particulate emissions can be diminished, but
The table below shows the different ASTM standards that are to be used for the analysis
if the atmosphere.
Table 29
Atmospheric Analysis Standards
Designation Title
ASTM D1607- Standard Test Method for Nitrogen Dioxide Content of the Atmosphere
91(2011) (Griess-Saltzman Reaction)
Standard Test Methods for Sulfur Dioxide Content of the Atmosphere
ASTM D2914-15
(West-Gaeke Method)
Standard Test Method for Carbon Monoxide in the Atmosphere
ASTM D3162-12
(Continuous Measurement by Nondispersive Infrared Spectrometry)
ASTM D3608- Standard Test Method for Nitrogen Oxides (Combined) Content in the
95(2011) Atmosphere by the Griess-Saltzman Reaction
ASTM D7036-16 Standard Practice for Competence of Air Emission Testing Bodies
ASTM D1356- Standard Terminology Relating to Sampling and Analysis of
15b Atmospheres
ASTM D4490- Standard Practice for Measuring the Concentration of Toxic Gases or
96(2016) Vapors Using Detector Tubes
Source: ASTM International 2017
The ASTM’s environmental assessment and risk management standards provide the
distinguishing the conceivable biophysical, social, and other applicable effects on a specific
89
items and ventures may have on natural ecology, just as on the safety and health standards.
Different professions corresponding with the environmental evaluation and risk management
standards are valuable to ensure the prevention of the risk associated. The environmental
standards target to aid or control a designated use of a resource in an ecosystem, area or region.
The positive and negative effects on output brought by a project impact on the environment can
standards are constructed to protect human health and the ecological system itself. These
standards are based on the prevailing knowledge, environmental status, existing standards and
Table 30
Environmental Assessment Standards and Risk Management Standards
Designation Title
Standard Practice for Conducting Environmental
ASTM D6008 - 96(2014)
Baseline Surveys
Standard Practice for Environmental Site Assessments:
ASTM E1527 - 13
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Process
Standard Practice for Environmental Site Assessments:
ASTM E2247 - 16 Phase I Environmental Site Assessment Process for
Forestland or Rural Property
Standard Guide for Readily Observable Moisture
Affected Materials and Conditions Conducive to
ASTM E3026 - 15
Elevated Moisture in Commercial Buildings: Visual
Moisture Assessment Process
Standard Guide for Vapor Encroachment Screening on
ASTM E2600 - 15
Property Involved in Real Estate Transactions
Source: ASTM International 2017
methodology in establishing suitable tests and other evaluation procedures to determine and
characterized the possible impacts of a substances on the species and components of eco-system
90
in which the toxins were released into the environment. Also, it obtained either from natural or
synthetic pollutants.
Utilizing the liquefied natural gas as the fuel in the cycle can lessen the impacts of main
emission of particulate such as NOX, SO2, CO, and TSP. Also. It is expected from the LNG to
released a less emissions since it is a clean fuel. The department for environment and natural
resources has a required allowable limit of the emissions to be released in the natural ecology.
The project does not extract any heavy metal toxics like mercury(Hg) emitted by the combined
Elimination of product waste must always comply to the standards set by the government
for environmental compliance and protection. Improper disposal of waste can be detrimental to
the environment. Power plant waste must be disposed accordingly as the plant produces different
types of end product that require specific disposal methods. American Society for Testing
Materials provides set of standards that must be followed by every company to ensure
environment protection and conservation. Due to different types of waste products produced by
the power plant, different methods of utilizing waste are implemented by each company. Some
of these includes recycling the components that still have the value to be reused. Aside from its
environmental protection, health of human beings and aesthetics are considered when dealing
Republic Act of 9003 which deals to the proper disposal of solid waste management
tackles the proper approach on how to segregate wastes. These law emphasize the importance of
clean environment and greatly concerns about the health of the people around a designated
region. Proper process of dealing waste from collection, segregation, conveyance, removing of
91
harmful materials up to discharge is specified in the said republic act. It also encourages the
citizens to greatly use recycling materials for reduced waste production and eco-friendlier way of
living. Compliance to the republic act by the companies producing energy like power plants are
strictly observed and inspected as these infrastructures produce large scale amount of waste that
can be a primary problem to the environment and health concerns. An easy to follow instructions
is attached to the law for proper disposal as well as the sanction and penalties for those
Different methods of testing the quality of water from the process are used by the power
plant to ensure that the water disposed from the receiving bodies of water are safe and will not
disturb the marine ecosystem. Monitoring the presence of contaminants, discharge temperature
and water quality are obtained through series of lab experiments and testing. This is to ensure
that water disposed is well treated and safe for disposal. This is done for health and
environmental purposes. Failure to comply will result to corresponding sanction and penalties
and severe cases like imprisonment and permanent shut down for severe violations.
The ASTM standards are considered in assembly of the combined cycle power plant to
ensure that the proposed power plant complies with the environmental standards.
Table 31
Water Testing Standards
Designation Title
ASTM D859 - 16 Standard test Method for Silica in Water
Standard Test Methods for Acidity or
ASTM D1067 - 16
Alkalinity of Water
Standard Test Methods for Chromium in
ASTM D1687 - 12
Water
Source: ASTM International 2017
92
Design Option 1
35 x 1.13
SOx Emissions / MWh = ( )( 9638862.559)(0.5676275774)
26 x 10^6
12
NOx Emissions / MWh = ( )( 9638862.559)(0.5676275774)
26 x 10^6
116.9
CO2 Emissions / MWh =( )( 9638862.559)(0.5676275774)
1 x 10^6
Design Option 2
35 x 1.13
SOx Emissions / MWh = ( )(8242654.028)(0.5221059892)
26 x 10^6
93
12
NOx Emissions / MWh = ( )(8242654.028)(0.5221059892)
26 x 10^6
116.9
CO2 Emissions / MWh = ( )(8242654.028)(0.5221059892)
1 x 10^6
Design Option 3
35 x 1.13
SOx Emissions / MWh = ( )(8486255.924)(0.5350795005)
26 x 10^6
12
NOx Emissions / MWh = ( )(8486255.924)(0.5350795005)
26 x 10^6
116.9
CO2 Emissions / MWh = ( ) (8486255.924)(0.5350795005)
1 x 10^6
94