Hilina Enriched Foods Processing Center Plc

Bid Analysis Sheet

for
Production Hall's Floor Epoxy Work
Tender no: ,Opining date: 25/07/2012, Evaluation date:03/09/2012

I.TECHNICAL EVALUATION
Contractors
No Parameter
TDC AB HAM SIKA
Pass/ Pass/ Pass/
Fail Fail Fail
1 Proposed Material Grade
POLYPOXY NITROFLOR SIKAFLOOR
Self leveling p p p
SL 40 SL2000 263SL

Ante skid ramp POLYPOXY p NITROFLOR p SIKAFLOOR p

FC TF 5000 263SL(BB)
2 Brand Origin
Self leveling Germany p England p France p
Ante skid ramp "" p "" p "'" p
3 Total layer thickness
Self leveling 3mm p 2mm p 2mm p
Ante skid ramp 0.1mm ? >2mm p >2mm p
4 compression strength
Self leveling 75N/mm2 50N/mm2 50N/mm2
Ante skid ramp >65N/mm2 85N/mm2 >50N/mm2

Overall Technical Evaluation pass pass pass

 II.FINANCIAL EVALUATION
Contractors
No Work item Qty [m2] TDT AB HAM SIKA EMPIRE
Offer[Birr]
up total up total up total
Epoxy floor work using
proper material and
1 application methodology
most recommended for world
class;
1.1 Self leveling 755 655.00 494525.00 480.00 362400.00 1908.00 1440540.00
1.2 Ante skid 195 195.00 38025.00 750.00 146250.00 2278.00 444210.00
rampTotal ETB 532,550.00 ETB 508,650.00 ETB 1,884,750.00
15% VAT ETB 79,882.50 ETB 76,297.50 ETB 282,712.50
Gtand Total ETB 612,432.50 ETB 584,947.50 ETB 2,167,462.50

III. SUMMARY SCORE

TDT AB HAM SIKA EMPIRE
TECHNICAL PASS PASS PASS

FINANCIAL 2nd 1st 3rd

TECHNICAL+FINANCIAL 2nd 1st 3rd

*Therfore, as per overall score AB-HAM is recommended to undertake the contract

Evaluated by : PROJECT OFFICE

Date:
 Signature:

to the managing director

from projectoffice
subject: referes to production hall's floor epoxy work contract
sed on the maintainance budget of the the companY for the fisical year 2005(EC)