Comment Sheet

#REF! #REF! DCS Ref. : #REF!

5427PC
#REF!
048- #REF! Date : 09-03-2020
Receipt
ETU-
Date
000-: #REF! KSEBL Previous DCS : #REF!
Drawin
SYD-
g/
SRI- Rev. Approval Code Document / Drawing Title
Docum
S5020-
ent No.
SL-
0002 RO AC LT SINGLE LINE DIAGRAM (AC-DC)
5427PC
048-
#REF! #REF!
VIZ-
000-
SYD-
Sl NO KSEB COMMENTS GE REPLY ON 09.07.20
SRI-
S5020-
SL-1 Feeder no 1- sheet no 01-load is
0002 100kW, by calculation 100kW Noted & Updated in our revised submission.
load will draw 148A max, but the
feeder MCCB rating is 125A only -
2 Sheet
Change nothe
1- All
MCCB MCCB and MCB
rating
Tripping
accoridingCurve to be mentioned Noted & Same will be reflected in vendor drawings.
the load
in the SLD Noted & Complied.
Sheet no 2- Please Ensure All DC
3 MCB and
Sheet no 1-MCCB's
EOT craneare to be DC
Feeder no
rated We confirm that rating of EOT crane is less than 5 KW.
14- 5KW is seems insufficient
4 Sheet no 1- Air Condition -Feeder
Noted & Updated in our revised submission.
27-10KW is seems insufficient and
5 pleaseno
Sheet furnish the sizing
1- Welding Plug point
be 3 no - 2 no inside the GIS Please note that each welding receptacles plug point are able to connect 3-4
calculation
shall
welding sockets by Loop-in & Loop-out arrangement and it`s a general
room and One number in the
industrial practice followed in all projects.
yard.
6 Sheet no 1- A Distribution Kiosk
shall be erected in the Yard for Noted but Same is not reflecting in our BPS schedule and will be supplied with
extending supply( from feeder no suitable implications.
1) for oil filtering purpose and the
7 Sheet no 2- Cable from Battery
kiosk have 3/1 phase industrial
Charger to Battery shall be Kindly note that there is no line item in LOA for 2C x 35 Sq.mm cable. We have
sockets and one welding point
armoured cable only, and provide considered 2 runs of 1C x 35 Sq.mm PVC FRLS PVC Copper Cable as per line
2x35mm2 cable for each battery item : 70 as per supply BOQ. Same is of armoured cable only.
bank
8 Sheet 2- An automatic change
over for DC light shall be Noted & Same shall be shown in DC Lighting panel vendor drawings.

9 included
Sheet 1- Star Rating of
Noted and Incorporated.
Distribution Transformer may be
10 shown
51G in the SLD
protection is statutory for LT
power sources above 63KVA We clarify that there is no such statutory requirement for 51G and even KSEB
rating. Hence 51G has to be specification doesn`t ask for the same. Further, we havn`t provided for KSEB
provided with NCT rating not package - 1 also. Hence kindly accept the same.
less than 1/5th of line CT rating at
11 400A, MCCBs are to be
250KVA,11/0.433kV of 4pole as
Transformer.
per clause 5.3 of Tender Noted and incorporated in notes. Regarding protection`s same will be reflected
specifications. Also MCCBs in respective vendor drwaings.
should have inbuilt
12 As per tender specification there
protection(3OC+1EF).
is provision for sub DBThese
panel
protection We clarify that there is no specific line item for new lighting panels/DB`s in
other than rating
MLDB.has to be shown
in the drawing. either KSEB supply BOQ / work order BOQ. But as a general practice we had
16A, SP,
considered Lighting & power distribution panels in our illumination layout
MCB is found to shown in main
which be billed seperately alongwith 3 phase junction box used for outdoor
ACDB. Rating of 16A,MCB has to
lightings. Note that RCCB is already considered in the outogings of lighting
be checked with bus bar fault
panels (Refer lighting layouts). Further, we suggest to have a lighting
level. It is advisable to provide
transformer for better isolation purpose in MLDB`s & ELDB`s.
seperate subDB with 100mA,
ELCB for 16A, MCB feeders.
13 63A, TPN, MCB for MLDB&
ELDBs have to be replaced with Note that RCCB is already considered in the outogings of lighting panels (Refer
30mA, ELCB. Also TPN, MCB for lighting layouts). Further, we suggest to have a lighting transformer for better
welding power plug, EOT crane , isolation purpose in MLDB`s & ELDB`s. Also note that all other equipment`s
FFPH, HVAC, Airconditioner like welding plug, EOT crane, FFPH, HVAC, Airconditioner feeders will be
feeders have to be replaced with provided with MCCB/MCB only as ELCB not operate for
ELCBs overcurrent/overload protection.

14 KW rating of Battery charger Noted & we clarify that battery charger KW rating is considered based on its
circuit will have to be sufficient to rectifier transformer rating.
meet 10H initial charging current
15 Provide
rating. a facility for paralleling
two DC DB BUS bar for reliable Noted and considered. Further, addition of feeders in DCDB with respect to
DC supply supply billing price schedule will be supplied with suitable implications.

16 As per Technical Specification

clause 1-chapter 18- “The AC
distribution Boards shall be Noted and same will be routed to SCADA through Aux Panel.
SCADA compatible and shall
transmit status of incoming
breaker , Incoming current and
voltages through IEC 61850
compatible communication 1
devices”-status of incomer
breaker shall be extended to
17 This approval of KW ratings is
subject to confirmation after Noted.
receiving the sizing calculation of
downstream loads/Equipments

2
 Comment Sheet

#REF! #REF! DCS Ref. : #REF!

#REF! #REF! Date : 09-03-2020

Receipt Date : #REF! KSEBL Previous DCS : #REF!

Drawing / Document No. Rev. Approval Code Document / Drawing Title

5427PC048-ETU-000-SYD-SRI-S5020-SL-0002 RO AC LT SINGLE LINE DIAGRAM (AC-DC)

5427PC048-VIZ-000-SYD-SRI-S5020-SL-0002
#REF! #REF!

Sl NO KSEB COMMENTS GE REPLY ON 09.07.20

1 Feeder no 1- sheet no 01-load is 100kW, by calculation 100kW load will draw 148A max, but
the feeder MCCB rating is 125A only - Change the MCCB rating accoriding the load Noted & Updated in our revised submission.

2 Sheet no 1- All MCCB and MCB Tripping Curve to be mentioned in the SLD
Sheet no 2- Please Ensure All DC MCB and MCCB's are to be DC rated Noted & Same will be reflected in vendor drawings.
Noted & Complied.

3 Sheet no 1- EOT crane Feeder no 14- 5KW is seems insufficient

4 Sheet no 1- Air Condition -Feeder 27-10KW is seems insufficient and please furnish the sizing
calculation
5 Sheet no 1- Welding Plug point shall be 3 no - 2 no inside the GIS room and One number in
the yard.
We confirm that rating of EOT crane is less than 5 KW.
Noted & Updated in our revised submission.
Please note that each welding receptacles plug point are able to connect 3-4
welding sockets by Loop-in & Loop-out arrangement and it`s a general
industrial practice followed in all projects.

6 Sheet no 1- A Distribution Kiosk shall be erected in the Yard for extending supply( from
feeder no 1) for oil filtering purpose and the kiosk have 3/1 phase industrial sockets and one Noted but Same is not reflecting in our BPS schedule and will be supplied with
welding point suitable implications.

7 Sheet no 2- Cable from Battery Charger to Battery shall be armoured cable only, and provide
2x35mm2 cable for each battery bank Kindly note that there is no line item in LOA for 2C x 35 Sq.mm cable. We have
considered 2 runs of 1C x 35 Sq.mm PVC FRLS PVC Copper Cable as per line
item : 70 as per supply BOQ. Same is of armoured cable only.

8 Sheet 2- An automatic change over for DC light shall be included

Noted & Same shall be shown in DC Lighting panel vendor drawings.

9 Sheet 1- Star Rating of Distribution Transformer may be shown in the SLD

Noted and Incorporated.
10 51G protection is statutory for LT power sources above 63KVA rating. Hence 51G has to be
provided with NCT rating not less than 1/5th of line CT rating at 250KVA,11/0.433kV We clarify that there is no such statutory requirement for 51G and even KSEB
Transformer. specification doesn`t ask for the same. Further, we havn`t provided for KSEB
package - 1 also. Hence kindly accept the same.

11 400A, MCCBs are to be of 4pole as per clause 5.3 of Tender specifications. Also MCCBs
should have inbuilt protection(3OC+1EF). These protection rating has to be shown in the Noted and incorporated in notes. Regarding protection`s same will be reflected
drawing. in respective vendor drwaings.

12 As per tender specification there is provision for sub DB panel other than MLDB.
16A, SP, MCB is found to shown in main ACDB. Rating of
We clarify that there is no specific line item for new lighting panels/DB`s in
16A,MCB has to be checked with bus bar fault level. It is advisable to provide seperate
either KSEB supply BOQ / work order BOQ. But as a general practice we had
subDB with 100mA, ELCB for 16A, MCB feeders.
considered Lighting & power distribution panels in our illumination layout
which be billed seperately alongwith 3 phase junction box used for outdoor
lightings. Note that RCCB is already considered in the outogings of lighting
panels (Refer lighting layouts). Further, we suggest to have a lighting
transformer for better isolation purpose in MLDB`s & ELDB`s.

13 63A, TPN, MCB for MLDB& ELDBs have to be replaced with 30mA, ELCB. Also TPN, MCB
for welding power plug, EOT crane , FFPH, HVAC, Airconditioner feeders have to be Note that RCCB is already considered in the outogings of lighting panels (Refer
replaced with ELCBs lighting layouts). Further, we suggest to have a lighting transformer for better
isolation purpose in MLDB`s & ELDB`s. Also note that all other equipment`s
like welding plug, EOT crane, FFPH, HVAC, Airconditioner feeders will be
provided with MCCB/MCB only as ELCB not operate for
overcurrent/overload protection.

14 KW rating of Battery charger circuit will have to be sufficient to meet 10H initial charging Noted & we clarify that battery charger KW rating is considered based on its
current rating. rectifier transformer rating.
15 Provide a facility for paralleling two DC DB BUS bar for reliable DC supply
Noted and considered. Further, addition of feeders in DCDB with respect to
supply billing price schedule will be supplied with suitable implications.

16 As per Technical Specification clause 1-chapter 18- “The AC distribution Boards shall be
SCADA compatible and shall transmit status of incoming breaker , Incoming current and
voltages through IEC 61850 compatible communication devices”-status of incomer breaker Noted and same will be routed to SCADA through Aux Panel.
shall be extended to SCADA

3
17 This approval of KW ratings is subject to confirmation after receiving the sizing calculation of
downstream loads/Equipments Noted.