Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Christopfser Steven Fidler: Tfto Degree of Westers of Architecture
Christopfser Steven Fidler: Tfto Degree of Westers of Architecture
BY
Christopfser Steven Fidler
A THESIS
ARCHITECTURE
Westers of A r c h i t e c t u r e
Chairman of Committee
|ACC?£PTEtf
••^^'?*fl
May, 1999
Mteaata
r3
Arch ^ 5 6 ^ ;
Christopher Fidler
Preface
Table of Contents
Abstract
Endnotes
TAKE
s^
The following program addresses the adaptive reuse of vociferously combat the disproportionately exponential
prototypical retail warehouse space, specifically outdated growth of waste for the euphemized purpose of 'land-
K-Marts that have been abandoned. This adaptive reuse filling,' architects must equally examine the byproducts
project will redesign an old, unused K-Mart building into of our profession.
an entertainment complex which will include movie
theatres, sensory interactive games, a restaurant and ban- It is readily apparent that not all buildings are built with
quet hall. The purpose of this is to transform an other- the same life expectancy in mind. Some exist for centu-
wise useless building into an economically viable busi- ries, while others may be created only to be demolished,
ness that also serves the community. An abandoned K- or for one mere event. In stark contrast to the unseen so-
Mart in Lubbock, Texas, will be used as the prototypical cietal consumer waste stashed beneath our feet, aban-
test facility, which will be redesigned into a multi-use doned structures of yesteryear litter the urban landscape
complex. This will be accomplished through analyzing and offers only disgust to the onlooker. This is exempli-
and resolving specific spatial conflicts that are inherent fied by the observance of avoidance. Derelict structures
when changing facility types of building. The thesis of engage innate feelings of foreboding in the passerby, on-
this paper is that not only is the makeover of this facility looker, and adventurous inhabitant.
type possible, but recommended because it will limit
waste, transform an architectural eyesore and economi- The retail warehouse has achieved megatrend status to
cally rejuvenate the surrounding community. the point that its physical presence is manifest wherever
the market will bear it. Like all trends, this one is cycli-
This program represents the synthesis of research sur- cal. What was sufficient space for a particular function
rounding the issue of adaptive reutilization. It shall be years ago has been replaced by ever larger and some-
clearly illustrated throughout this report that the contem- times over-extravagant area. The old has been aban-
porary corporate culture predominant throughout the doned, thrown away. This is the essence of consumer-
United States has evolved in a parallel manner to that of ism. The architectural profession must rise to the occa-
its citizens - toward consumerism. Consumerism is a sion by not merely condenming the problem, but search-
form of mentality and not merely a set pattern of spend- ing for solutions to this oft demeaning element in the ur-
ing behavior. This mentality has manifested itself into a banscape.
society of disposability. Just as environmental engineers
iHii
The following suggests a solution for the beautification
and revitalization of the byproducts of the modem mega-
trend superstore: a retrofit entertainment complex.
Xahle of Gotten^
<* ;;-J7,"J.VI;J; '.'.•^•'.''^•^ifft rAy.!.'=ivvs^iv r i " .••V'j'fiv f;o^*-:.-:;,' '-•«•; ;<i -J^c z-ir.rfV;7}:r<tn
Context 48
Overview 49
Goals and Objectives 50
Site Analysis 51
Site Issues 53
Building Analysis 54
^tmm
Abstract
are assessed for the purpose of possible expansion. Part
of this assessment includes additional services from other
market segments. For example, a smaller K-Mart will
have your typical department store retail items, such as
clothes, appliances and electronics. After several years,
a financial assessment is done and it is determined that
the marketplace in that community can handle the expan-
sion of the K-Mart. The new store will include addi-
tional retail goods, such as food, garden supplies, salons,
banking, video rentals, etc. At this point, the original K-
Mart is abandoned, and a new Super K-Mart is con-
structed.
-'•**«s
M i ^ ^ iMHUttii
^ndnotd
» iilWIW w i ^ w — » — I — ^ j ^ H ^ i H
Supporting Theory
Architectural Issues
Potential Design Response
Case Studies
Endnotes
^**JSi.i:
$
''' ''Mir.*"
Throughout the United States there are thousands of va- out considering the impact to surrounding areas. Unfor-
cant structures amounting to an epidemic of abandon- tunately, it is a purely economic decision. Their duties
ment and neglect. Such deterioration of our nation's are to maximize profits and returns to investors, not to
buildings perhaps signifies how a society feels about its the general welfare of the public. These greedy interests
architecture: it tolerates squalor alongside its icons. compromise the economical, physical and mental health
Architects are the incumbent torch bearers in the battle of the majority. Architects, on the other hand, through
for the recognition, rehabilitation or preservation of ex- the plan offered in this proposal, can turn the vacant
isting facilities. This responsibility extends to clients, building into one that is an asset to the community, as
public and private, as well as society in general to find well as a profitable business venture. Simply stated, this
possible uses for discarded facilities which may also sat- proposal brings together the ideal and the practical: the
isfy changing functional needs currently in demand. ideal of transforming ugliness to beauty with the practi-
Those able to apply creative solutions will become the cal need to make money.
leaders of our profession.^
In the case of vacated Wal-Marts and K-Marts which
The Timeliness and Significance of this Research stand derelict across the United States, with minimal re-
The adaptation of antiquated buildings with contempo- sources these corporations should assist in the design of a
rary technology is an ancient process. Vitruvius cited the prototypical facility types to rehabilitate their litter with
conversion of wooden buildings into stone by his ances- utility and life. This would exhibit responsible actions
tors.^ In the contemporary context, Wal-Mart and K- toward the communities which supported the organiza-
Mart are two companies that build small retail structures tion economically during its initial market success. It
when first entering a particular urban marketplace before would also retain the obligations that the companies have
discarding them later (if the venture has been economi- to their fiduciaries. The solution is a win-win situation
cally successful) to build a larger shopping environment. "* as the participating parties cooperate in the new business
Consequently, the original commercial places are left va- venture.
cant without function - without life.
Economic Feasibility of Adaptive Reuse
Even though communities may disagree with such acts of Throughout the history of architecture, specific nartow-
abandonment, these corporate decisions are made with- use designs such as airbases and shipyards were rehabili-
iAKt
5uppori\nq Vne
tated when their useful days are over. Political, military tail space on the first and second floors. The architec-
and govenmiental facilities are well known for discover- tural design included recapturing the hotel's I920's ambi-
ing "second lives." Recently, creative solutions to other ance and charm which aided in the hotel gaining histori-
antiquated residuals have emerged at the forefront of cal registry status. The result has been a resounding suc-
adaptive reuse designs. Baltimore Harbor project, for cess. Not only does the hotel serve a purpose to its resi-
example, under the imaginative leadership of developer dents and patrons, but the surrounding neighborhood has
James Rouse, transformed a depressed and dilapidated been revitalized. A domino effect started where other
river front area of Baltimore, Maryland, into a financial businesses slowly opened up in the neighborhood to cater
successful. This was done by designing the Harbor proj- to the new influx of people. Where once stood a vacant
ect to meet the needs of the community and visitors by hotel in disrepair, contributing nothing to it's community,
creating a beautiful recreational area that can be enjoyed now stands a vibrant, multi-use structure with historical
by all. The numerous attractions and shops at the harbor value that has revitalized the entire area. Such is the
are diverse enough to cater to all, especially tourists, and power when developers and architects use their vision
pumps millions of dollars into the city. This unique and creativity by applying the adaptive reuse approach to
marriage of beauty and practicality should be the goal for existing structures.^
the architect and developer and is at the very heart of the
theoretical approach to adaptive reuse. This thesis, however, is not dealing with a riverfront or
hotel, but wishes to transform a warehouse structure into
Another example of adaptive reuse can be seen in a theatre/entertainment complex. The major advantage
Abilene, Texas. The Windsor Hotel, in Abilene, was in this thesis, a retrofit project, is the econcMnic incentive
built in the 1920's during the oil boom. It was a grand for both theater and building owners. For building owner
hotel with big ballrooms that catered to the wealthy. In it allows an economic resurrection of a building which is
the 1950's it was modernized, but eventually fell into a cmrently a hindrance.
disuse and became vacant, creating an eyesore in an al-
ready economically depressed area of the city. In 1993, To come to a determination if an abandoned building is
through creative funding and inventive adaptive reuse de- economically and architecturally feasible to retrofit to a
sign, the hotel was transformed into federally funded re- movie theater, the owners must evaluate both the advan-
tirement housing on the third through ninth floors and re- tages and disadvantages. While impediments exist to this
' ^ % 3 ^ ,
^^^.
goal, the benefits, discussed above, are far reaching. In age of building, it does not comply with ADA standards,
order for that benefit to become a reality, though, three hence the entire building will need to be brought up ADA
central issues need to be addressed: I) the challenge of standards^ and 3) building may not be up to current life
imposing new space and functional requirements onto an safety codes (fire, plumbing, electrical, structural, etc.).
existing structure; 2) resolving the impediments to spe- The immediate advantage is parking. The existing park-
cific provisions, i.e. regulatory agencies, required within ing lot has more than ample parking spaces to meet code
the new spaces and 3) analyzing the implications of the requirements. Access to public streets and traffic pat-
design on the community, investors, and patrons. terns have already been established. All utilities have al-
ready been brought to site.
1. Imposing new space andfunctional requirements
Retrofitting a movie theatre complex to prototypical K- 3. Implications of design
Mart has inherent spatial conflicts: 1) existing roof joists The design encompasses ten (10) movie houses, a cigar
too low to accommodate stadium seating and second lounge, restaurant and banquet hall, interactive game
level projection room; 2) column spacing too close for area or "virtual reality" games and a child care facility.
large movie theatre houses; 3) problems with noise trans- This multi-use facility was designed to address the cur-
mission between the three areas (theatres, game rooms rent cultural trend of "the big night out" where one sees
and restaurant/banquet area) and 4) possible asbestos in a movie, dines and enjoys the evening, all in one loca-
building (which requires an expensive removal process). tion. The facility is designed to meet the needs of pa-
The main advantage, however, is that a complete ware- trons in allowing them to be more socially interactive and
house structure is already in place, that include truck have multiple entertainment options under one roof It
docks, roofing, existing mechanical, electrical and also accommodates the current societal needs regarding
plumbing, etc. The huge building, or shell, is conducive children by providing entertainment for them as well as
to be retrofitted for the intended new design. an onsite childcare facility for the convenience of par-
ents. The structure itself will aesthetically pleasing be-
2. Specific regulatory code compliance resolution cause it will be designed in the I920's motif and give that
The disadvantages to note in this area are 1) zoning prob- feeling of "the big show." To conclude, by meeting the
lems with the site because the K-Mart Lubbock site is cultural and societal needs of the patrons, the surround-
zoned for commercial retail and the new facility will re- ing community is upliftedfinanciallyand aesthetically by
quire rezoning for commercial entertainment;^ 2) due to its success and the investors will profit from their invest-
ment.
Cox\cep\ye>
Mission Statement: Performance Requirement:
Create an adaptable prototype capable of retrofit in facili-
To turn prototypical warehouses into successful multifunc- ties throughout the nation of similar size of form.
tional entertainment complexes, while returning to the 1920's
movie theatre nostalgia.
Goal;
Goal; Utilize the latest construction techniques to retrofit exist-
Fit a new function into an existing structure which was de- ing facilities.
signed and erected for differing purposes.
Steel beams removed Opoi web joists added
->
K
\ '^a^^^**^
v'Saasp?^
Performance Requirement:
Remove obtrusive vertical structural members and replace
with long-span reinforced roofing members.
Goal:
Reinforce die " Big Evenf concept for patrons.
Goal;
Enhance the physical ornamentation and fanfare. If the prototype goals can be realized successfully they
can be adopted across the nation.
^^•fe,.
N'chiedmva
Specialized Structural and Mechanical Requirements Acoustical considerations include the reverberating and
sound transmission qualities of the existing type of con-
Among the unique elements encountered when designing struction as well as possible control methods it requires.
a theater include accommodations for the disabled. This Staggering the studs in partition walls is a common prac-
can be particularly difficult when redesigning an existing tice for the reduction of sound transmission, yet in many
facility which has been constructed prior to the current buildings it may not be possible to retrofit in this maimer.
building codes. These include the Texas Accessibility The alternative is to add sound absorbing insulation the
Standards Act of 1992, the Americans with Disabilities walls
Act of 1991, and other regional, state codes and stan-
dards, mandated by the appropriate legislative authori-
ties.
'*•*:,«•
Potential Ve Pe
Facilitv Demand: Multi-level stadium seating Solution: Instead of placing the projection room
over the promenade, which is standard
Issue/Conflict: Roof too low to accommodate procedure in movie theatres the prome-
nade will be moved away from the projec-
Solution: The concrete slab is broken and reformed- tion room, so that its floor can be lowered
below grade, generally 5 feet. This solu- to accommodate the low roof elevation
tion is economically attractive because the without compromising the space below.
level of structural impact in making struc-
tural alterations to accommodate new roof Facilitv Demand: Accommodation of the disabled
members, weatherproofing the existing
roofing composition plus compromising Issue/Conflict: Stadium seating, multi levels not able to
the existing surety bond. accommodate an elevator
Auditorium oiecition
om
FLOOR OF PROJECTION ROOM
CEILING OF PROMENADE
J Promena
U"'
Construction began in October 1929, and the new theater gie Hall. The design of the auditorium and balconyflooren-
was ready for occupancy by 1930. The auditorium, sured a great viewfromevery seat in the house. Even with a
lobby, and mezzanine (balcony) were completely fire reduction of a little over four hundred seats, the initial design
protected. A heating and cooling system was installed to holds, and the Paramount offers the finest lines of sight.
maintain a constant temperature of 72 degrees.
On Tuesday, June 10, 1930, the Middletown Time Her-
One of the most important aspects of design for the new ald published a Special Paramount Edition on the Para-
theater was the painstaking attention paid to acoustics mount Publix corporation and its new theater.
and sight lines. Great care was taken to make the theater Middletown merchants ran special sales and took out ads
acoustics perfect. To this day, they remain thefinest,vir- in the paper not only announcing their sales, but welcom-
tually comparable to Came
18
Ca'^e 5budi(^5
ing the theater. Paramount Publix shot special film foot- crowd enjoyed this part of the entertainment." After a
age of Middletown and its citizens, to be shown on open- musical and dancing number by the U.S. Indian Reserva-
ing night. tion Band and a political comedy, the main feature
played," The Big Pond," staring Maurice Chevalier and
On Wednesday, June 11, 1930, Mayor Clarence Van Claudette Colbert, billed as " A Paramount all talking
Fleet threw the switch that illuminated the huge electric motion picture."
sign over the theater. On Thursday, June 12, a parade
was held at noon which included the police, fire depart- Across the street, on Paramount's opening night, stood
ment, sixty-two new automobiles entered by fourteen car the State theater. The State, built in 1921, showed Will
dealers, some floats, and the American Legion Band. At Rogers, Irene Richem, and Maureen 0-Sullivan in the
6pm the same day, the Paramount Theater opened its movie "So This is London."
doors to the general public. Approximately 2000 resi-
dents of Middletown and the surrounding areas attended The 1502 seat Paramount theater remained open until
the two opening shows, presented at 7pm and 9pm. The 1978. In 1959, Middletown Savings Bank had bought the
first audience included several hundred special guests. State theater and tumed it into a parking lot. In Febmary
The line in columns of four for the second show ex- 1979, the City of Middletown took ownership of the
tended from the ticket booth (located where the two cen- Paramount in lieu of back taxes. The Arts Council of Or-
ter doors are now) to Franklin Square, and halfway down ange County bought and restored the theaterfromthe
the block on Main Street. City which formally opened in September 1985 as a per-
forming arts theater. To tum the old movie theater house
Both programs consisted of a film welcome by Charles into a performing arts center, the stage had to be en-
Rogers (one of the stars of the first Best Picture Academy larged. The enlargement of the stage and the reduced
Award, " Wings"), a musical selection by the Paramount balcony seating dropped the number of seats in the thea-
Symphony Orchestra, Paramount News ("The eyes and ter from 1502 to 1104. Even with the reduced seating the
ears of the world"), a short feature of Middletown and Paramount is still one of the largest performing arts thea-
some of its best known citizens, including the Mayor, ters in Orange County, and certainly larger than its sister
Chief of Police, and Fire Chief The Times Herald theater, built three years later by Paramount Publix,
stated, " Judging by the applause... the opening nights Peekskills-Paramount theater Performing Arts Center.
Of note the sight lines," Big Event" , and ornate din-
The theater is a fine example of landmark restoration ning area are successful examples which will be incor-
supported by the community. Nevertheless, over the past porated into the design of the entertainment complex
ten years as the economy experienced setbacks, so did of this type of design.
the Paramount. At the same time the fortune of the Para-
mount waned, Middletown's downtown area was on the
rise. Led by Mayor Joseph DeStafano, the city, con-
vinced that this fine old theater is an important part of the
downtown revival, took action through the IDA to ac-
quire ownership of the Paramount.^ Today it is still suc-
cessful.
r o n Fii_M
TX.T SCRGCN
BACK e v OisiE
MA1.F- OF-
tfKJOEC-riOM
AIVOLC WMEr<<
P«OJCCTtOM Arsic»l.e
e x c c e o s IB- " ^ ' ^
Ai-COW ROOM F O «
ACOUSTICAl. TREATMEMT
SCWECfNi SMOWrsI
lAKE
•'-yiS o o S^'
^:i§ 22 m
Theatre and entertainment complex designs through his-
tory are significant. The desire of a society at large to be The 1930s introduced a new era to motion pictures. The
entertained instigated its birth, a desire to have entertain- appearance of sound changed many aspects of theatre de-
ment within the boundaries of the common family and sign for the years to come. This introduction removed the
separate from the live theatres of Broadway while en- "art gallery" aspect of advertising to the screen. The rise
compassing a part of the live theatrical experience. It is a in the number of movie theatres resulted in sound becom-
place for society to see themselves separated from their ing one of the major distinguishing factors in competition
everyday toils. and most of the nation's theatres were wired for sound.
With the depression, theatres were threatened with bank-
In the early 1900s when the movie theatre was bom, it mptcy, movie producers abandoned the self-imposed
became an inclusive event comprising a host of outside moral restraints reinforced culture's changing morality
live performances, chats in its smoking room, gatherings partly driven by the economic crisis.
in vast galleries accented with extravagant tables, and
shopping areas where retail subtly intermingled. Comple- By the 50s, the same movie content from the 1930's was
menting an age of glamour, the movie " palace" an- still being applied to a society whose industry and audi-
swered the call of society mirtoring the proper, elegant ence had changed. To change the growth of the televi-
and extravagant value and tastes of the richer classes, sion, it became increasingly important to provide an ex-
omate flourished in these places of affluence congrega- perience unavailable in front of the ' ectronic hearth.
tion. By the mid-1920s, the movie palace craze hit its This meant change was necessary to theatre design. Sev-
prime, even the movie posters and the glittering stars eral aspects of recording and reproduction were experi-
were considered art forms and an important part of thea- mented with in order to enhance the theatre sound and
tre design. The movie theatre became new phenomenon distinguish it from the home setting. Speaker configura-
in its role of advertising. Through they advertised flam- tion and " stereo" sound were some of the elements ex-
boyantly, their purpose remained directed at the tastes perimented with. This lead the theatres into an economic
and sensibilities of the family audience. It was generally dilemma to save on the cost of sound others postulated
agreed that no motion picture should lower the standards that the screen color displace all other aspects of the film
of the public nor direct audience sympathies to crime, experience, that the whole of the cinema could be re-
evil or sin. duced to the screen alone. This lead to the popularity of
the drive-in movie theatre. This type of theatre rose in gardless of context. As a result of this economic high of
numbers from 820 in 1948 to 3,775 in 1954 even though the 90s, 23,689 screens exist regardless of the demand.
their sound characteristics were far from pleasant (the Overpopulation of these replica theatres once again
cars on the back rows saw what was happening before proves distasteftil in the public's eye. There is a call for
they heard the accompanied sound). the restoration or adaptation of the old 1920s theatres
from people wanting more than an environmental step up
The 1960s had a more liberal atmosphere. The ethics of from their home living room. Regarless of their architec-
this culture changed again and the role of the movie thea- tural integrity. These recreated palaces, have become ur-
tre followed suit. It was not enough for a movie to con- ban tools. They are proving to be popular ventures as cor-
tain stars, the movie theatre became a place to view ex- nerstones for urban revitalization. New theatres are in-
treme science fiction removing thoughts from the imper- corporating game rooms (relating to the glitz of the past),
fect fabric of society. Fantasy blockbusters initiated a retail areas, and even restaurants. Examples of this are
new era in speaker usage. Surround sound appeared with cinema grill in Whitefish Bay, Milwaukee, or the Alamo
the movie Star Wars and for the first time, audio senses Draft house cinema in Austin, Texas. These integrated
became most acknowledged in this setting. The surround approaches to theatre design are in response to the pub-
sound system created sounds coming separately from the lic's holistic desires.
sides, or from the front. It exemplified an attack of ten-
sion building scene. Furthermore, the new sound systems
involves not only the eyes, ears and the brain but created
a relationship with the whole body, shaking the body
when a huge spaceship rumbled across the screen.
*''*j
24
Pacilitii Anali|5i^
7^^5 sideration will be given to areas which will not allow
ng environment for en- easy visibility by theater staff, modifications will then be
1 /
young, and old alike introduced.
IJ •^^'^(/j food and restaurants.
Performance Requirement:
The design will minimize dark areas, both interior and exterior,
/
y by having a minimum of IFc on the site and in the complex's
corridors.
o the complex:
omote and facilitate the
/ 7 / . , Performance Requirement:
' a fiill service modem
p-v.o
I X The corridors will not be dead end corridors nor have
bends where someone could be hiding unobserved.
f e n m mn EM^-^ m.-m
Inexpensive and prototypical retrofit:
Ehict work within theatre shall be oversized to allow the same
During schematic design, and design development, repe-
amount of air toflowthrough the ducts, at a reduced speed,
therefore reducing the noise level for the THX certification. All titious and multi-use spatial formations shall be prefer-
other areas will use recommended duct sizes. able. The objective of these considerations is to facilitate
the widest applicability of the design solution to other fa-
Performance Requirement; cilities desiring adaptive reuse solutions. As more stmc-
Lighting within the theatre will be reduced as patrons tures are adaptively reused with this prototypical design
moves from the public areas to the theatre house allow- fewer man-hours, material, and chronological resources
ing their eyes to adjust slowly to the change in light. All will be required. This design solution shall be optimized
other areas will follow the recommended light levels at every opportunity without compromising the quality or
stated in the activity and spatial analysis section of this integrity of the facility in the protection of the health,
document. safety, and welfare of the occupants.
TAKE
I 2^
Performance Requirement:
Where an item or assembly is reproduced multiple times,
this process shall be done in the factory and shipped to
the site, a process allowing higher degrees of accuracy
and speed.
Performance Requirement:
The omamentation used on the exterior and interior of
the complex shall be of appropriate materials that reject
anticipated abuse from the environment, such as weather- Figure 8: Sculpture atop the Butterfly Theater
ing and air pollution from extended exposure to cigarette
and cigar smoke and vandalism
26
Ca^^e 5ixidu
Albertson's Supermarket - Albuquerque, New Mexico After analyzing this project in retrospect, I feel that the
removal of the floor was unnecessary and not economi-
Albuquerque is the home of many Albertson's Supermar- cal. A more economical solution would have been to
kets. One such store began to decline in it's revenue gen- raise the projection port approximately eight feet above
erating capabilities, and was subsequently abandoned. the theatre floor to allow the projection of the movie to
The Architecture firm of Partners in Architecture (P.A.) be shown slightly above the patrons heads. This ap-
was commissioned by United Artist movie theatres. I proach would have required less floor to be removed,
previously was employed by P.A. and personally worked thereby, avoiding an expensive procedure. Also, the
on this particularly project. length of the exiting ramps for the disabled would have
been substantially shorter, thereby, alleviating the exist-
Problems were encountered throughout the course of the ing existing problems for the disabled.
facility's design including the provision of appropriate
exiting from the individual theaters through adjacent
spaces and the accommodation of disabled patrons
through compliance with applicable accessibility laws.
The primary problem encountered in this retrofit was the
height of the roof joists were too low to allow a second
story projection level. The solution used to solve this
problem was to remove ninety percent (90%) of existing
finished floor and lower the floor from two - five feet.
This expensive procedure allowed for a second story to
be constmcted.
27
"Entertainment as a project segment has evolved to in-
clude other disciplines such as retail, hospitality, and Light levels in the restaurant shall be between 5-10 Fc,
education."^ through semdirect lighting.
The motif will be one that brings back memories of the 1920
movie theatres, with their grand smoking rooms and omate Figure 9 : Semidirect Lighting Diagram for Restaurant /
decorations.
Bar
According to Graphic Standards, 16 sq.ft. per person is
required for restaurant/bar activities. In addition to the ^5r worn
seating and circulation areas for the patrons, additional
workspace behind the bar for the employees.
^ WOf^ f
Figure 11: Adjancency Diagram for Stadium Seating Theatres Figure 13 : Typical Wall Construction for THX
Theatres 12
TAKE
Acti Spatial AnalL|5i$
TOP OF ROOF
-*-
'2zM^m<M^,., 2 l ' - 0 " MINIMUM
CEILING HEIGHT ^
P rojecpio n
R o0mp
^ < ^ ^
I A u d ito riu m
^mm n=:^
P ro m e|i ad e
^ ^
riNlSHED FLOOR ^
o
o
F3
<o
:^
^ M o
^_J£'
H
> e
"" X
1/13
U
H—(
__^_^ w
o o
H
Q ^-1
<
<r-
^1
hi
TAiOE
Activitii & spatial hc\A\\5\e>
Child Care Area
Rest rooms will be located in four areas, the lobby, the i$5r worn
promenade area, the child care area and the restau-
rant/bar area.
Child Care Adjacency
For calculations of the number of rest rooms for this type
of facility, the total occupant load is not used in the thea-
tre area. Instead the occupant load of the largest theatre ^$r worn "^^•^wom
house is used. '^ The restaurant/bar area total occupant
load will be used to calculate the number of restrooms in
this space.
The materials used in the rest rooms shall be of high du- Lobby Adjacency Restaurant /Bar Adjacency
rability and vandal resistant quality, such as ceramic tile
for walls and flooring, and pressure injected epoxy for
counter tops.
M
Activitil & spatial Anali|$i5
Men s Rest Rooms
TAKE .„
Activity &
Figure 18 : Direct Lighting Diagram for Restrooms Figure 19: Typical Rest room Lay-out
TAKE
56 ^B
Box Office
Figure 20: Adjancency Diagram for Box Office Figure 21: Typical Box Office lay-out
TAKE
^7 -
Lobby
Entrance Vestibule
58 If-
The lighting will be indirect and between 5-7 Fc.'* This
\IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIII IIIUIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
allows patrons to view games without receiving glare off
'IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIII
glass or video screens.
It is a waiting area for movie theatre patrons that consists The manager s office is approximately 600 sq.ft.
of video games and pinball machines.
, tfVKE
'., SSi
SL-
:i ^
^^aaaam
Concession Area
Work Area
The large volume of patrons using the concession area
requires four work stations in the lobby and two in the This is a storage area for concession equipment as well
promenade. Each work station will have a candy counter, as a space for minimal amount of food preparation
cash register, butter dispenser, soda dispenser, three pop- needed for the concession stands.
com poppers, two nacho dispensers, and two hot dog and
bun warmers. The area required for the operation and The lighting will be direct and light levels between 20-30
placement of the equipment for each station will be ap- Fc.2«
proximately 50 sq.ft.
Floors and all walls to a height of 54" abovefinishfloor
To accommodate handicap workers, one of the conces- shall be tiled, there will be floor drains installed to allow
sion work areas will be lowered to meet their needs. ease of cleaning.
Lighting will be direct and light levels between 20-30 The work area is approximately 300 sq.ft.
Fc.'^
iJ2M
mtM mmaam
^
JUUUL \ \ unnc junui: V \ juuun
m hmoi^ S m rJBBIoloi I Jlfc«w<l I I I J
m
CONCESSION AREA
"T r
^71 ^
rJ L_rx i \
I I
\ L _ ^ LOJ
-D [L,
WORK ROOM
-3;!-
/ \
/ \ >i I ! Kl td
m
CONCESSION AREA
< WC?0( ROO^
I I'
^
innnr / / innn,
\
Figure 23 : Adjancency Diagram for Concession Area T^^xt 24 : Typical Concession and Work Room Area Lay-out
TAKE
41
Promenade Projection Room
The promenade is a large room connecting all the houses This area will be at the back of each theatre house in or-
with the lobby area and the restaurant/bar. The room's der to project movie onto screen. The projection equip-
width will accommodate emergency exit requirements. ment requires a minimum of 10'-6" of space from projec-
tion window to the back wall. The movie reels require a
The flooring, walls, and ceiling materials will have a to- 6' square floor area next to the projector. Due to the fa-
tal sound absorption coefficient of at least 0.90, to pre- cility type and existing building restrictions, each projec-
vent noise produced from theatre patron traffic traveling tion room will serve two theatre houses instead of one
to other houses. projection room serving all theatre houses.
The lighting will be indirect with light levels in the thea- The lighting will be indirect with light levels between 2-3
tre between 2-3 Fc, to allow patrons eyes to adjust and Fc, so that light does not bleed into adjacent theatre
also to buffer the lobby lighting to the theatre house houses.''
lighting.^'
Due to the specialized activity in area, access to space
The promenade area is approximately 2,000 sq.ft will be limited.
TAKE
42
MM^ lytAM IveAM MAM MAM
Figure 25 : Adjacency Diagram for Promenade Figure 26 : Adjacency Diagram for Projection Room
TAKE
4^'
CAUL KINO
* T ALU
^ > - - ':^m'
"yy////
v///////:' ;-^v>y'; ;;
Auditorium Auditoriub
44
Kitchen
oex.D r o o o »>f»epi*"ATiON A R C A -
CArCTC«IA/«ANQyCT
TAKE
45
Stairs Electrical Room
Due to the size of each projection room, two exit stairs The electrical room needs to be a minimum of 3'-5" wide
are not required. Therefore, five stairwells of 150 sq.ft. to accommodate the electrical panel with a minimum 3'-
each will be provided. 0" clearance from panel to wall.
The stairwells totals approximately 750 sq.ft. Additional cooling is needed in area due to heat gener-
ated from electrical panels.
Janitorial Closets
Electrical room is approximately 150 sq.ft
Each closet will contain a large trash can and supplies
used by cleaning crews for theatres. Closets need not be
larger than 25 sq.ft. each. There will be one closet in Storage Room
every theatre house so that cleaning crews do not disturb
patrons using other theatre houses.
There will be two storage rooms, one to store non-
Ten janitorial closets total approximately 250 sq.ft. perishable kitchen items and the other to store non-
perishable concession items.
46
tx\Ax\ck£^^
23
'Pete Ed Garrett, "Practice Q and A," Texas Architect. Ibid., 50
(July/August 1998): 19.
'" THX is not a type of sound but an over all sound experi-
ence with requirements ranging from the amount of background to
the proper position of the speakers in the theatre house.
" Ibid., 50
" Ibid., 50
^ Ibid., 50
^* Ibid., 50
^ Ibid., 50
TAKE
47
Overview
Goals & Objectives
Site Analysis
Contextual Requirements
TAKl-;
The major contextual elements to this new theater in-
clude the abandoned structure, the site's residential
neighbors to the north and a relatively few commercial
tenants to the east and west.
TAKE
49 I
Neighborhood beautification
Beautification of the site and neighboring community is a
primary concern in the process, design, and implementa-
tion of this adaptive reutilization design response.
Profitability
Optimal use of space and solid market review are re-
quired to make this facility a viable project. Further, the
success demonstrated here may have far reaching impli-
cations for other similar facilities seeking an economic
revitalization.
An abandoned structure originally constructed for a K-
Mart store will serve as the facility for this project. The
facility's site is situated at the northeast comer of 19th
Street and West Loop 289, duly parceled at the Lubbock
County Recorder's Office as 5802 19th St.; Lubbock,
Texas. Approximate size of the lot is 7.25 acres with
195' on 19th St., 600' on Frankfort and 500' abutting a
residential area. The site is predominantly fiat (Figure
30) and completely paved. Adjacent uses include a resi-
dential development at the north end and light commer-
cial at the east and west sides. There are three site en-
trances- one at the 19th St. abutment and two on the
Frankfort Ave. Property side. Figure 30: Facility and southern parking lot as
pictured facing north.
Utilities for this facility are located on the north side of
the site, with the main connections located off of Frank-
fort.
$it^ Ana
"J
-J
arir^Aw'" oycdMNvtu i i s ^ 1^
> *.
^r -I
t i *
.J' --i< ftfl
y
SillTTBTTD t - & •
1 ^ i't.a-
I ft
,|.-|xx.--<^
1 '-f-
V' ' • ••\-—^—rrr-'^-''" —'. v v ; -Iv—•-* A^
X
•»V'» r*
I-
,^g^^^:^i
hi
TAKE
Vehicle Access Parking Lot
The location of the curb cuts on the site does not allow As seen in the preceding pictures there is ample parking
easy access from loop 289 or eastbound 19th Street. Ve- in front of the building. This vast amount of parking was
hicles coming from these directions have to wait at a needed to meet the zoning codes of the city of Lubbock.
light to tum onto a residential road which takes them However, the zoning codes for a movie theatre/restaurant
alongside the site before allowing them to enter. are not the same as those for a retail store. Therefore,
the removal of some of these parking spots would be ac-
A possible solution to this is a new curb cut that would ceptable in order to allow raised cmbs with shrubs.
be located mid-way through the site. This will allow
enough room for the traffic at the light to back up while Also, due to the change of peek usage at the site, it will
not blocking the entrance to the site. Also, moving the be necessary to place additional site lighting to meet ap-
main entrance for vehicles will allow them to view the propriate levels for the patrons.
entire buildingfromthe front instead offromthe side.
Drop-off Areas
At the present time the site does not allow an area where
vehicles can stop and drop off patrons with out stopping
traffic flow infrontof the building.
Description ofInterior
The floor consists of a 5" thick concrete slab covered Figure 34: North Elevation of Building
with 12" vinyl composite tiles throughout the building.
-tj
1,851.25
Entrance vestibule 750 750
Concession Area 300
200
500
Kitchen 1,500 1,500
Work Area 300 300
lAKt
6^8 %
\(9(?m ' ab\}\aim
Room Name Number of Rooms Square Feet / Room Total Square Feet
Manager s Office 1 600 600
Stairs 5 150 750
Lobby 1 3,500 3,500
Game Room 1 1,000 1,000
Janitorial Closet 10 25 250
Promenade 1 2,000 2,000
Projection Room 5 500 500
Electrical Room 1 150 150
Storage Room 2 1,500 1,500
Usable Square Footage * Gross Square Footage Factor = Gross Square Footage
Patron 2,050
60 jv
. I .1.1.I'll!' 'III. J l U J l
Pinal Voc\mex\iakJ\ox\
Conceptual Basis Of Design Solution
Hierarchy of Spaces
Controlling Factors
TAKE
61
• •> •••.^^•rf'T'in.'aiT.m''Biw
$duti(9n
The conceptual basis for this project is the adaptive reuse
of a prototypical retail warehouse space, specifically an
outdated K-Mart that has been abandoned. This adaptive
reuse project redesigned an old, unused K-Mart building
into an entertainment complex which included movie
theatres, sensory interactive games, a restaurant and ban-
quet hall. The piupose of this was to transform an other-
wise useless building into an economically viable busi-
ness that also serves the conununity.
Exterior
A major section of the conceptual basis dealt with trans-
forming the exterior of the old K-Mart into something
new and different. This was accomplished conceptually
in stages. The first stage was to examine the front eleva-
tion and remove the stigma of a big concrete box. This
was done by contrasting different exterior portions of the
stmcture. Therighthand side was made to appear Figure 37: Proposed Improvements To K-Mart
Cor]cep{ua\ \^ae>\5 of Ve^lo/n 5o\ui\on
massive and heavy while the left hand side appeared
lighter. This was accomplished by removing large sec-
tions of the wall on the left side and moving the exterior
facade back. The main entrance was also changed from
a small store front entrance to a large over-hanging can-
opy. The height of the entrance was also raised by ex-
tending the space framing into the air. Basically, the
front entrance was opened up, widened and pulled out to
accommodate a drop off area.
Interior
The interior was transformed by changing ceiling
heights, creating new spaces within the stmcture and put-
ting in creative lighting that also visually effected the in-
terior. Again, the purpose of which was to remove the
connotations that the building was once a K-Mart.
Architectural
The issue here was that the ceiling height of the building
was too low to accommodate stadium seating. As part of
the design program, it was imperative to include stadiimi
seating because the whole conceptual theme behind the
facility design was to take out the old and bring in the
new. The newest trend in movie houses is stadium seat- Figure 44: Proposed Movie Theatre
ing. It is the very reason why many people are returning
to movie houses, in that these theatres have become more
comfortable and convenient. It adds to the feeling of created that provided enough space for the equipment to
movie patrons that this is a new place that is fun to go to. be placed. This problem was resolved by elevating the
But accommodating stadium seating creates certain ar- roof in this specific area.
chitectural challenges, such as ceiling heights need to be
higher than standard theatre seating. To resolve this 3. Accommodation for the disabled
problem, sections of the floor were removed and the
floor elevation was lowered. This was an issue because incorporating stadium seating
created multi-level problems and problems related to the
2. Elevated projection room disbursement of handicap seats throughout the movie
house. The reason it's a problem is because the floor ele-
This was an issue because the existing roof stmcture did vation in stadium seating increases too rapidly to accom-
not allow enough space to accommodate the equipment modate ramps. This was resolved by having handicap
necessary for the projection room. A design had to be seats in the front and back of the movie house. The front
5$U(^5 \()ieeY^\f\ed In P
seating was accessed through the main entrance, while
the rear seating was accessed from the projection room
via an elevator.
Site
1. Vehicle Access
3. Parking Lot
2. Drop-off Areas
This was an issue because the amount of parking re-
This was an issue because at the present time the site did quired by zoning codes for a movie theatre/restaurant are
not allow an area where vehicles can stop and drop off more than those required by code for a retail store (previ-
patrons without stopping traffic flow in front of the ous K-Mart). Even though there was a vast amount of
building. The solution was to increase the width of the existing parking space, the site could not comply with
sidewalk in front of the building, while at the same time current zoning codes. Twenty more parking spaces were
adding drop off lanes. needed to comply. To date, this issue has not been re-
solved. It would be necessary to go in front of the zoning
board and request a variance.
^k?>a«^GrjLKJ>Ll,IJLH
Hi(^rarchi| of^
SPACES (hierarchy from view of patron) B. Restaurant entrance
Also, another limiting factor was the size of the lot itself
and it's ability to accommodate the required number of
parking spaces.
t:a#,yAi:^uj^fm„fSm,
latMmiUJWxwaagi
Resources and Evidence of Research Method Bibliography
The research methods used for this academic endeavor
Pete Ed Garrett, "Practice Q and A," Texas Architect.
have included the accumulation of case studies, personal (July/August 1998):
interviews, professional exposure to and participation in
similar warehouse modernization projects for the accom- Architectural Graphic Standards. Eight Edition, The Ameri-
modation of movie theaters. The disciplines of architec- can Institute of Architects, Sumerset, N.J.
ture, urban plarming, and engineering are integrated
United Artistes Corporation. Department of Construction,
herein with those of business, management, marketing, 1992.
andfinancialmanagement. An understanding to all sides
of this complex interaction between the interests of com- Partners in Architecture, Professional architectural firm Dal-
munity, corporations, the public, as well as market forces las, Texas
that effect the commercial constmction, entertainment,
Young .Stewart, Maijabelle. Executive Etiquette. Copy-
and movie patronage industries lay at the foundation of right 1979; St. Martin's Press; New York, NY. Page 11.
this research. In order for a project of this type to be
successful, it is imperative that all of the above- Vitruvius, The Ten Books of Architecture trans. Morris
mentioned factors be taken into consideration. Hickey Morgan (NY: Dover Publications, Inc., 1960; reprint, Cam-
bridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1914; original written in the
first century B.C.), 38-41.
Evidence of Research Method
K-Mart Corporation, Detroit, Michigan
Accompanying documentation should be sufficient to Kathryn Ladoulis, Good Fulten & Farrel, Dallas, TX.
demonstrate the substantive nature of the research
sources for this report and investigation. Videos, photo- Lubbock Zoning Code.
graphs, and taped interviews have been included to fill
any gaps which may appear in the course of these facility American Disabilities Act, 1991, U.S. Department of Justice
(Washington, DC).
and contextual reviews.
Texas Accessibility Standards Act, 1992.
—®
—®
li.DJJJJU.UIlH
Upper Level Floor Plan
< 3 @ ® ^ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ® 0 0 0 0 0 0 © ©
In I c h-
T& --©
T~7r _[l ^]
^
[- |i_J i-^-i
rv-T-
I 11! n! ! •3^C= Ll_l *>**«
i^ki I iss --©
-11 Saoaitygfl
UBIH ' --©
--©
T
--©
1 --©
r^
4^ --®
AREA 10 B£ fC'> ..
TT
TKUCXIXX3C
- U I M M U W CKKIRS i FRAMES
le 7f 7r 7r
ExiSnMC FLOOftNC -
•-ewsTiNC r o o T t i c EXISTMC F X I M C ^ EnSIWC fOOTNC
l4kAAA£
|i.k UUkA/UkAT->e> ^ ^ 3
W B^SS^^SSi^^S
NEW ROOF STPUC ss^ gS^^^2
i.l ^— EXISTING ROa NEW Jl-J I.AY-II
_ ^ — S E * ; x 4 t k * - i N cEiLWG i :nsTiNG ROOT -^
FMSH flOOfi EUV. 'lin
I-SCREEN I
SPEAKER PlATfOPM J |
- EXiSTWC FLOORING EWSTINC aOOfiWC -
•4H 'CTAl PtAN FLOOfiING
Building Section
tfH mmrssswBKrmfrwn
« oo >9 ® 9 <? q>9
•iMaRW
I I
f-
SM I I I I
ILJIJ II
h—\—^-l \ H— _.^._ I i— H i h- r
3=i-iC L - ^
hi 4i ii'i
l_^^^„ rp{r-----;-ij^r bi: iii S^
j |^^~j-----j^r-"--~,:.;."»T ;jv^^.^SSSt^^^l'-^V : ^. .......
i jr;]^jf^3^; m --lr^=^=i^=^
H^te9!!^^iITT
iM'j?:;::f::::;::^l [1i::::::::;|::::::::{ri!l
i" ' i
\ M \ \
'; i i n i i
pd-^-h-I f
•-i----^ y. i i; ii • I — I — J r^:::::::Tp:. l^:::::::::.|x::
S~ i
i! 1 1 r n — [ •
€>--
^
s
o
s
o
U
B^
mm
HnNHAV CraOiDINVM
r Nl
GARDEN AREA
1IIH11 J
1 68,337
too
TRUCK 1 TRUCK WELL
K-MART
TOTAL S.QF.T
CM
DOCK
< f
:t
U^
ct
iBi»«csF^aac3uaiH
fl
West Elevation
South Elevation
^wTWK^tfmmmi^am^Keva^s^^aBm
East Elevation
Aerial View
Entrance
Entrance
Restaurant Entrance
Lobby Entrance
Lobby Entrance
Concession Stand
Restaurant
Restaurant
Movie Theatre
Movie Theatre
mm