Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Asociaciones Entre Trastornos Musculoesqueléticos Relacionados Con El Trabajo, Calidad de Vida y Estrés Laboral en Fisioterapeutas
Asociaciones Entre Trastornos Musculoesqueléticos Relacionados Con El Trabajo, Calidad de Vida y Estrés Laboral en Fisioterapeutas
1
Department of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine, Samsung Medical Center, Republic of Korea
2
Department of Physical Therapy, Angelo State University, USA
3
Department of Bioengineering, University of Pittsburgh, USA
Abstract: This study was performed to determine the associations between work-related muscu-
loskeletal disorders (WMSDs), quality of life (QoL), and workplace stress among physical thera-
pists (PTs) in South Korea. Self-reporting questionnaires were given to 855 PTs. Variables exam-
ined included general characteristics, WMSDs, QoL, and workplace stress. Of the 788 PTs who
responded, 745 (94.5%) reported WMSDs affecting at least one body site. The most affected WMSDs
site was the shoulder (23.3%), and the most reported number of body sites affected by WMSDs was
one (50.9%). QoL was significantly improved (p < 0.05) among PTs over 39 years old, who had 10 – 15
years of professional experience, worked in general/university hospitals, and had only one site
affected by WMSDs. Factors influencing QoL included number of body sites affected by WMSDs,
presence/absence of WMSDs, working venues, workplace stress, and age. Factors affecting work-
place stress included number of body sites affected by WMSDs, QoL, work hours, and gender. The
results showed a high prevalence of WMSDs among PTs in South Korea, and this negatively affected
both QoL and workplace stress.
Key words: Physical therapist, Workplace stress, Quality of life, Work-related musculoskeletal disorders
Introduction muscle pain (23%). WMSDs are the main reasons for work
absences, and 40% of industrial accident compensation is
Work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs) related to WMSDs in some member countries3).
comprised 33.7% of all work-related disorders in 20021), Holder et al. (1999) reported that among 667 American
but have increased by 148.1%, and currently account for physical therapists (PTs) and physical therapist assistants,
49.6% of all work-related disorders2). In the USA, accord- 33.5% had WMSDs4). In a follow-up study, Campo et al.
ing to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, WMSDs resulted (2008) reported that among 8,882 American PTs, 57.5%
in 600,000 lost work hours. In addition, one-third of total had WMSDs5). In addition, 58% of 2,688 British PTs
compensation related to industrial accidents and diseases and 55.5% of 217 Australian PTs were reported to have
was due to WMSDs2). In the European Union, WMSDs WMSDs6 – 8). Moreover, Cromie et al. (2000) reported that
account for a high percentage of low back pain (25%) and 82.8% of 536 Australian PTs had WMSDs affecting at
least one body site9). In South Korea, one study reported
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. that 94.2% of 105 PTs had WMSDs, and another reported
E-mail: baeyhhhh@naver.com that of 125 PTs, 47% of males and 45.2% of females had
©2016 National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health experienced WMSDs during work or daily life10). More-
348 Y BAE et al.
over, PTs with WMSDs spend more time treating patients regarding intensity and duration of pain, or PT specializa-
than healthy PTs10 – 12). tion. Sahmyook University Ethics Committee provided
Workplace stress occurs in the workplace or work- approval. All subjects signed an informed consent form,
related organization, and is defined as “a harmful mental and the present study was approved by Sahmyook Univer-
and physical reaction coming from discordance between sity Ethics Committee.
employee’s ability, resources, and willingness and work
requirement”13). Medical expenses increased by 800% Study design
and economic loss exceeded 10% of the Gross National This was a cross-sectional study to evaluate WMSDs,
Product due to workplace stress in the USA14). The impor- QoL, and workplace stress among Korean PTs, and to
tant part of that study was related to workplace stress, the determine the associations between these variables.
resulting health effects, and their subsequent assessment.
A previous study reported that high-level workplace stress Outcome variables/instruments
harms the body and mind and consequently results in lazi- The outcome variables included subject characteristics,
ness, leaves of absence, job transfers, and exhaustion15). WMSDs, QoL, and workplace stress as described below:
According to previous studies, medical employees have
more workplace stress than nonmedical employees14, 15). In 1) General characteristics
particular, PTs have experienced an increasing incidence of The general characteristics evaluated included gender,
WMSDs and workplace stress due to excessive amounts of age, clinical experience, working pattern, hospital type,
work. This has a negative effect on the practice of physical working venue, working hours, and number of patients
therapy, resulting in lack of professional physical therapy managed.
services for patients, loss of professionally trained PTs,
and diminished quality of treatment14, 15). Therefore, man- 2) WMSDs
agement of WMSDs and resolution of workplace stress are Questions on WMSDs consisted of 34 questions from
required to effectively implement the task of an organiza- the Korea Occupational Safety and Health Agency
tion and may enhance the quality of life (QoL) of employ- (KOSHA) CODE H-30-2002, and evaluated the location,
ees. frequency, duration, and intensity of pain, in addition to
Little is known about the association between WMSDs, treatment of symptomatic areas in the neck, shoulder, arm-
QoL, and workplace stress in PTs. Therefore, this study elbow, wrist-finger, waist, and leg-foot10).
aimed to investigate the prevalence of WMSDs, and their
association with QoL and workplace stress in PTs in South 3) QoL
Korea. The Korean version of the World Health Organization
QoL assessment instrument was used and consisted of
Methods 26 questions, including 24 derived from four subdomains
(physical health, social relationship, environment, and
Subjects and procedures psychological) and two that dealt with general QoL and
The subjects in this study were PTs registered with the health16).
Korean Physical Therapy Association, and included PTs
working at rehabilitation centers, general/university hospi- 4) Workplace stress
tals, and secondary hospitals in Gyeong-gi do and Seoul, The workplace stress questionnaire used the Workplace
South Korea. The study was conducted from January to Stress Scale created by the American Institute of Stress.
May 2014. Purposive sampling was used for subject selec- The 10 questions evaluate how much job stress is pres-
tion. A total of 855 questionnaires entitled “Associations ent and how workers handle it. Participants were asked
between work-related musculoskeletal disorders, quality to rate their workplace stress on a 10-point scale ranging
of life, and workplace stress in physical therapists” were from “strongly disagree” to “strongly agree.” Each ques-
distributed for self-administration; 825 were returned tion was scored from 1 to 10. A total score of 10 to 30 indi-
(96.49%), and 788 were finally analyzed, with the excep- cated well-handled job stress, 40 to 60 indicated moder-
tion of 37 not essential for the analysis. All subjects were ately well-handled job stress, and 70 to 100 indicated that
PTs who treat patients directly, without limitations on job an employee was encountering problems that needed to be
position or working years. There were also no limitations addressed and resolved13).
Data analysis were 30 – 39, 3.4% were 40 – 49, and 0.4% were over
The mean and standard deviation for general character- 49. In addition, 87.4% of subjects had 1 – 5 years, 11.3%
istics and frequency (%) of WMSDs in PTs were calcu- had 5 – 10 years, 0.8% had 10 – 15 years, and 0.5% had
lated. Analysis of variance and an independent t-test were 15 – 20 years of work experience as PTs. Most participants
performed to assess the average difference in QoL and (68.9%) worked 8 hours a day, while 23.7% worked for
workplace stress for each PT, based on his or her general 9 hours, and only 7.4% worked for more than 9 hours a
characteristics and WMSDs. All variables were included day. Working venues included: 29.8% in general/university
in a stepwise regression test to evaluate their influence on hospitals, 8.4% in secondary hospitals, and 61.8% in reha-
QoL and workplace stress. We used SPSS version 21.0 bilitation centers (Table 1).
(SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL, USA) to perform the statistical Of 788 (94.5%) subjects, 745 had WMSDs. Among
analyses at p < 0.05. the subjects with WMSDs (n = 745), 401 (53.8%) had one
body site involved, 203 (27.2%) had two sites, 66 (8.9%)
Results had three sites, 40 (5.4%) had four sites, 25 (3.4%) had five
sites, and 10 (1.3%) had six sites. Duplicate responses for
1. General characteristics and WMSDs in PTs the site of WMSDs (n = 1,350) involved 23.3% for shoul-
Of the participating subjects, 51.8% were female and der, 22.7% for hand and wrist, 22.7% for back, 14.0%
48.2% were male; 59.1% were 20 – 29 years old, 37.1% for neck, 9.3% for arm, and 8.0% for hip, knee, or ankle
ber of pain sites appeared to be the most predictive vari- nance of the same posture, and working with a high num-
able influencing QoL, followed by presence or absence ber of patients24). Therefore, the higher rate of incidence of
of WMSDs, working venues, workplace stress, and age WMSDs of the shoulder may be due to the fact that most
(Table 3). The number of pain sites also appeared to be the of the subjects were rehabilitation center employees, and it
most predictive variable influencing workplace stress, fol- is a Korean PT’s responsibility to lift patients.
lowed by QoL, working hours, and gender (Table 4). Differences in QoL were highest for those over 49 years
of age, who had 10 – 15 years of clinical experience, and
Discussion worked at general or university hospitals. The QoL showed
significant differences according to the number of pain
This study aimed to investigate the prevalence of sites. The presence of WMSDs, working venues, work-
WMSDs, and to determine the association between place stress, and age also affected QOL.
WMSDs, QoL, and workplace stress among PTs in South Patients with low back pain and those absent from work
Korea. at least once had lower satisfaction with life than healthy
Most of the subjects were females aged 20 – 29 years, persons25). Moreover, Morken et al. (2002) reported that
with 1 – 5 years of work experience, who worked for less QoL in patients with WMSDs was significantly lower than
than 8 hours per day, and worked in a rehabilitation center; in healthy persons26). In particular, those with physical role
94.5% of the subjects had WMSDs involving at least one limitations and observable symptoms had a significantly
body site, which is higher than the results of a previous lower average QoL compared to the group that did not26).
study10). The margin of change in grade was higher than the change
In our study, the body sites most involved in cases of due to age, marriage, health, and working conditions.
WMSDs were the shoulders, hands, and back. This may Average weekly working hours were 41.9 for all subjects,
be because PTs usually adopt a standing position and rely but 42.0 hours for the WMSDs group, which indicates a
mainly on their upper limbs to treat patients. Babatunde generally high burden of work. Previous studies showed
et al. (2008) reported an incidence rate of 69.8% for lum- a lower average QoL in relation to site of pain and physi-
bar, 31.1% for neck, 22.2% for shoulder, and 20.6% for cal condition among shift workers, but also proved that
hand-wrist involvement among PTs in Ghana17). Yesim when weekly average work duration exceeds 40 hours,
(2004) reported a rate of 26% for lumbar and 18.2% for QoL can be lowered by length of work shift and duration
hand-wrist involvement, but also reported that the inten- of labor25, 26).
sity of WMSDs increased in the lumbar region due to work Workplace stress can be greatly affected by job speci-
related to moving patients18). However, in other studies, fications, role conflicts, personal relations, and employ-
rates of hand and wrist pain were highest, and were asso- ment instability, and can induce mental and physiological
ciated with repetitive use, as with manual therapy, which disability. Moreover, it can negatively affect the orga-
can cause an overuse syndrome3, 5, 19, 20). Bork et al. (1996) nization’s goal and cause economic losses due to lack of
reported that 45.0% of WMSDs affect the waist, 29.6% productivity22). In this study, workplace stress was signifi-
the hand and wrist, 28.7% the back, and 24.7% the neck cantly high for males, those with 5 – 10 years of working
in the USA20); Cromie et al. (2000) reported 62.5% affect experience, and those who worked less than 9 hours per
the waist, 47.6% the neck, 41.0% the back, and 33.6% day. On the other hand, the difference in QoL was based on
the thumb in the USA9). These studies showed compara- the existence of WMSDs and the number of pain sites. The
tively lower rates of WMSDs of the shoulder at 18.9% and predictive variable most influencing workplace stress was
22.9%, respectively. WMSDs of the shoulder occur when the number of pain sites, followed by QoL, work hours,
mundane tasks are repeated, as when the hand is raised and gender. In previous studies, male PTs had high work-
and outstretched often while moving, or when heavy lift- place stress, and younger physical therapists under the age
ing is necessary9, 20). This is thought to be due to com- of 30 with less than 5 years of work experience tended to
paratively different heights of treatment tables, repetitive have WMSDs, causing them to leave the profession9, 27).
upper extremity motion required for treatment, and treat- A study by Prochaska et al. (2001) supports the results of
ment performed in a bent position21 – 23). A previous study our research, showing that the hours of work lost during
indicated that WMSDs are possibly caused by repetitive ill health are too few to be considered as work stress, but
motion; WMSDs in physical therapists are strongly cor- the hours lost increase with the number of health issues,
related with repetitive motion patterns, long-term mainte- consequently resulting in increased workplace stress and
352 Y BAE et al.
Musculoskelet Disord 11, 116. [Medline] [CrossRef] qualitative analysis of risk factors and strategies for preven-
20) Bork BE, Cook TM, Rosecrance JC, Engelhardt KA, tion. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 12, 24. [Medline] [Cross-
Thomason ME, Wauford IJ, Worley RK (1996) Work- Ref]
related musculoskeletal disorders among physical thera- 25) Hincapié CA, Cassidy JD, Côté P (2008) Is a history of
pists. Phys Ther 76, 827 – 35. [Medline] work-related low back injury associated with prevalent low
21) Ektor-Andersen J, Isacsson SO, Lindgren A, Orbaek P back pain and depression in the general population? BMC
(1999) The experience of pain from the shoulder-neck area Musculoskelet Disord 9, 22. [Medline] [CrossRef]
related to the total body pain, self-experienced health and 26) Morken T, Riise T, Moen B, Bergum O, Hauge SH, Holien
mental distress. The Malmö Shoulder-Neck Study group. S, Langedrag A, Olson HO, Pedersen S, Saue IL, Seljebø
Pain 82, 289 – 95. [Medline] [CrossRef] GM, Thoppil V (2002) Frequent musculoskeletal symptoms
22) Karasek R, Brisson C, Kawakami N, Houtman I, Bongers P, and reduced health-related quality of life among industrial
Amick B (1998) The Job Content Questionnaire (JCQ): an workers. Occup Med (Lond) 52, 91 – 8. [Medline] [Cross-
instrument for internationally comparative assessments of Ref]
psychosocial job characteristics. J Occup Health Psychol 3, 27) Mierzejewski M, Kumar S (1997) Prevalence of low back
322 – 55. [Medline] [CrossRef] pain among physical therapists in Edmonton, Canada. Dis-
23) King P, Huddleston W, Darragh AR (2009) Work-related abil Rehabil 19, 309 – 17. [Medline] [CrossRef]
musculoskeletal disorders and injuries: differences among 28) Prochaska JO, Evers KE, Johnson JL, Castle PH, Prochaska
older and younger occupational and physical therapists. J JM, Sears LE, Rula EY, Pope JE (2011) The well-being
Occup Rehabil 19, 274 – 83. [Medline] [CrossRef] assessment for productivity: a well-being approach to pre-
24) Passier L, McPhail S (2011) Work related musculoskeletal senteeism. J Occup Environ Med 53, 735 – 42. [Medline]
disorders amongst therapists in physically demanding roles: [CrossRef]