Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Arslan - 2007 - Shear Strength of Reinforced Concrete Beams With Stirrups
Arslan - 2007 - Shear Strength of Reinforced Concrete Beams With Stirrups
!*+*,-*./ 0 %12,3 4556 7 %++*18*./ 90 :;<=;2> 4550 7 ?=@3,AB*. C<3,<*/ 4D E*@2=;2> 4550
!"&)F 4550
6.%&$#,& ’B,A A8=.> 12*A*<8A ;38*2<;8,-* AB*;2 *H=;8,C<A IC2 @*;MA N,8B AB*;2 A1;< 8C .*18B
A82*<G8B 12*.,+8,C< *H=;8,C<A IC2 2*,<IC2+*. +C<J 2;8,CA K 7!L @*8N**< 9OZ ;<. 4OZ ;2* ;3AC +C<A*2J
+2*8* K!(L @*;MA N,8B A8,22=1AO ’B* AB*;2 -;8,-* N,8B ; 3CN*2 ( U 8B;< %(" S9D ;<.
A82*<G8B ,A +CM1CA*. CI 8B* +C<82,@=8,C< CI 8B* ’YZ55O VCN*-*2P NB*< 7! 2;8,CA *W+**. 4OZ K@C8B
<CM,<;3 AB*;2 A82*<G8B 12C-,.*. @> A8,22=1A ;<. <C2M;3 ;<. B,GB A82*<G8B +C<+2*8* @*;MALP %("
8B* <CM,<;3 AB*;2 A82*<G8B 12C-,.*. @> +C<+2*8*O S9DP ’YZ55 ;<. 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<A G,-* A,M,3;2
EC2 8B* +C<+2*8* +C<82,@=8,C<P +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 ( U -;3=*O
A82*<G8B -;3=*A *A8,M;8*. @> %2A3;<RA *H=;8,C<A
;2* ;3MCA8 A;M* 8BCA* C@8;,<*. N,8B %(" S9D 8"50)$-% !*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* [*;MA
A,M13,T*. *H=;8,C< ,< 8*2MA CI +C*IT+,*<8 CI KA=11C28AL (2;+Q,<G YB*;2 A82*<G8B Y1;<J
-;2,;8,C< K( ULO VCN*-*2P M*;< -;3=*A *A8,J .*18B 2;8,C Y8,22=1A
M;8*. @> %(" S9D 8*<. 8C @* MC2* +C<A*2-;8,-*
+CM1;2,<G 8C 8B* M*;< -;3=*A C@8;,<*. N,8B
%2A3;<RA *H=;8,C<AO ’B=AP IC2 8B* +C<A,.*2;8,C< CI 9 :’&$)-1,&+)’
+C<+2*8* +C<82,@=8,C< 8C AB*;2 A82*<G8BP %2A3;<RA
*H=;8,C<A ;2* =A*.O ’C C@8;,< 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B \*A,G< 12C+*.=2*A 12C1CA*. IC2 2*G=3;8C2> A8;<J
CI !( @*;MAP AB*;2 A82*<G8B 12C-,.*. @> A8,22=1A .;2.A ABC=3. @* A;I*P +C22*+8 ,< +C<+*18P A,M13* 8C
,A ;..*. 8C 8B* +C<+2*8* AB*;2 A82*<G8B *A8,M;8*. =<.*2A8;<.P ;<. ABC=3. <C8 <*+*AA;2,3> ;.. 8C
@> %2A3;<RA *H=;8,C<AO !*A=38A CI *W,A8,<G SSX *,8B*2 .*A,G< C2 +C<A82=+8,C< +CA8AO ’B*A* 12C+*J
@*;M AB*;2 8*A8A ;2* =A*. 8C ,<-*A8,G;8* BCN .=2*A ;2* MCA8 *II*+8,-* ,I 8B*> ;2* @;A*. C<
;++=2;8* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C< *A8,M;8*A 8B* AB*;2 2*3;8,-*3> A,M13* +C<+*18=;3 MC.*3A 2;8B*2 8B;<
A82*<G8B CI !( @*;MAO E=28B*2MC2*P %(" S9D ;<. C< +CM13*W *M1,2,+;3 *H=;8,C<A ]9^O V*<+*P M;<>
’YZ55 12C-,A,C<A ;2* ;3AC +CM1;2*. 8C 8B* ;IC2*J *H=;8,C<A B;-* @**< 12C1CA*. 8C *A8,M;8* 8B*
M*<8,C<*. 8*A8 2*A=38AO "8 ,A IC=<. 8B;8 12C1CA*. =38,M;8* ;<. +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI 2*,<IC2+*.
+C<+2*8* K!(L @*;MA ]4P S^O YCM* CI 8B*M ;2*
_A=88>RA ]‘^ *H=;8,C<P .*.=+*. @> M=38,13* 2*G2*AJ
#O %2A3;< K L A,C< ;<;3>A,Aa [;b;<8RA ]Z^ *H=;8,C< K.*2,-*. @>
Y82=+8=2;3 )<G,<**2,<G \,-,A,C<P (,-,3 )<G,<**2,<G [;b;<8 ;<. c,MLP 8;Q*A ,<8C ;++C=<8 8B* A,b*
\*1;28M*<8P E;+=38> CI (,-,3 )<G,<**2,<GP d 3. b
*II*+8 @;A*. C< <C<J3,<*;2 I2;+8=2*A M*+B;<,+Aa
’*+B<,+;3 e<,-*2A,8>P [*A,Q8;AP "A8;<@=3 S‘S‘XP
’=2Q*> ()[JE"? ]6^ MC.*3 +C.* *H=;8,C<P ,<82C.=+*.
*JM;,3/ ;G=2;>f>,3.,bO*.=O82a G=2;>;2A3;<f>;BCCO+CM *M1,2,+;33>a 8B* IC2M=3; CI :;1;< (C<+2*8*
99‘ F;8*2,;3A ;<. Y82=+8=2*A K455DL ‘9/99Sg944
"<A8,8=8* ]0^P MC8,-;8*. @> h*,@=33 8B*C2> ,< *H=;8,C<A ]SP ‘P Xg9S^ B;-* @**< 12C1CA*. 8C
NB,+B 8B* I;,3=2* ,A ;AA=M*. 8C C++=2 2,GB8 ;8 8B* *A8,M;8* 8B* =38,M;8* ;<. +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B
,<,8,;8,C< CI ; M;+2CA+C1,+ +2;+Q ;<. 8B* A,b* CI !( @*;MA N,8BC=8 A8,22=1AO
*II*+8 ,A ;AA=M*. 8C @* +;=A*. @> 2;<.CM<*AA CI ’B* %(" S9D [=,3.,<G (C.* 2*+CMM*<.A ;<
3C+;3 M;8*2,;3 A82*<G8Ba %(" S9D [=,3.,<G (C.* *H=;8,C< IC2 AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI A3*<.*2 @*;M
]D^ *H=;8,C<P @;A*. C< *W1*2,M*<8;3 2*A=38A CI N,8BC=8 A8,22=1AP A=@i*+8*. C<3> 8C AB*;2 ;<.
<=M*2C=A @*;MAO j*W=2*P ;A IC33CNA ]D^P
#*<*2;33>P 8B* <CM,<;3 AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !( " #
@*;MA N,8B A8,22=1A ,A +CM1CA*. CI 8NC +CM1CJ 9 ! "& ! !
$# ! %# " 945 5 S %# $ !! # 4 Z%
<*<8A/ 8B* 2*A,A8;<+* CI A8,22=1 2*A=38,<G I2CM 8B* 0 ’&
82=AA ;+8,C< ;<. 8B* +C<+2*8* 2*A,A8;<+*O %++C2.,<G $9%
8C 8B* %Y()J%(" ‘‘Z ]9^ 2*1C28P AB*;2 .*A,G<
+C.*A 2*H=,2* ; A,M13* M*;<A CI +CM1=8,<G ; NB*2* $ ,A 8B* +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI +C<+2*8*
2*;3,A8,+ " 8*2MP ;..,8,C<;3 +C<+2*8* +C<82,@=8,C< ,< F?;P % ,A 8B* +CM12*AA,-* A82*<G8B CI +C<+2*8*
;A ; I=<+8,C< CI 8B* AB*;2 A82*AA 3*-*3O ’B,A ACJ+;33*. ,< F?;P ,A 8B* 3C<G,8=.,<;3 2*,<IC2+*M*<8 2;8,CP
+C<+2*8* +C<82,@=8,C< ,A ,M1C28;<8 ,< 8B* .*A,G< CI ! ,A 8B* *II*+8,-* .*18B ;<. ’ ,A I;+8C2*.
@*;MA NB*2* 8B* I;+8C2*. AB*;2 IC2+* ,A <*;2 8B* MCM*<8 C++=22,<G A,M=38;<*C=A3> N,8B 8B* I;+J
-;3=* CI 8B* AB*;2 IC2+* 2*H=,2*. 8C 12C.=+* 8C2*. AB*;2 IC2+*P " P ;8 A*+8,C< +C<A,.*2*.O
.,;GC<;3 8*<A,C< +2;+Q,<GO ’B,A 8*2M ,A <*+*AA;2> ’B* +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !( @*;M
IC2 8B* *+C<CM,+ .*A,G< CI @*;MA ;<. A3;@A N,8B N,8BC=8 A8,22=1A ,A 8>1,+;33> A,M13,T*. ,<8C 8B*
3,883* C2 <C AB*;2 2*,<IC2+*M*<8O "< 8B* 12*-,C=A IC33CN,<GP
A8=.> ]S^P %2A3;<RA +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B *H=;J
8,C<A 1*2IC2M*. ;3MCA8 ;A N*33 ;A %(" S9D A,M13,J 9!
$# ! %# $ !! # 4 Z% $4%
T*. *H=;8,C< ,< 8*2MA CI +C*IT+,*<8 CI -;2,;8,C< 6
;<. 8B* +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B 12*.,+8*. @> %(" ’B* +=22*<8 %(" S9D [=,3.,<G (C.* ;AA=M*A 8B;8
S9D 8*<. 8C @* MC2* +C<A*2-;8,-* 8B;< 8B;8 AB*;2 A82*<G8B ,A *AA*<8,;33> 12C1C28,C<;3 8C % O
C@8;,<*. N,8B %2A3;<RA *H=;8,C<A ,< 8*2MA CI M*;< %++C2.,<G 8C %2A3;< ]4P S^P +2;+Q,<G AB*;2
-;3=*O "< 8B,A A8=.>a %2A3;<RA +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MA N,8BC=8
A82*<G8B *H=;8,C<A ;2* =A*. 8C 8;Q* 8B* +C<+2*8* A8,22=1A ;2* K2*I*2 8C %11*<.,W IC2 .*8;,3AL
+C<82,@=8,C< ,<8C ;++C=<8 ;<. 8B* +C<82,@=8,C< CI
A8,22=1A ,A ;..*. 8C 8B* +C<+2*8* +C<82,@=8,C< 8C
$# ! 5 9Z$%# %5 Z " 5 54$%# %5 6Z
C@8;,< 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !( @*;MAO ’B* $S;%
12C1CA*. *H=;8,C< ,A i=A8,T*. +CM1;2,<G 8C 8B* KEC2 <C2M;3 A82*<G8B +C<+2*8*P $Y(L
2*A=38A CI *W,A8,<G SSX AB*;2 8*A8A +;22,*. C=8 N,8B
!( @*;MA N,8B A8,22=1AO [;A*. C< 8B* *W,A8,<G 8*A8 $# ! 5 94$%# %5 Z " 5 54$%# %5 6Z
$S@%
2*A=38AP ,8 ,A +C<+3=.*. 8B;8 8B* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<A KEC2 B,GB A82*<G8B +C<+2*8*P VY(L
*A8,M;8* 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B MC2* ;++=2;8*3> 8B;<
%(" S9D ;<. ’=2Q,AB Y8;<.;2. *A1*+,;33> IC2 8B* ’B* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<A ;2* +CM1;2*. I;-C2;@3>
@*;MA N,8B A1;< 8C .*18B 2;8,C K 7!L @*8N**< 9OZ N,8B 8B* 2*A=38A CI B,GB A82*<G8B +C<+2*8* KVY(L
;<. 4OZ ,< 8*2MA CI ( UO VCN*-*2P IC2 A3*<.*2 @*;MA N,8B +CM12*AA,-* A82*<G8B CI % ! ‘9O‘
@*;MA KK 7!L ! 4OZL 8B* ( U -;3=*A C@8;,<*. IC2 F?; K6555 1A,LP ;<. <C2M;3 A82*<G8B +C<+2*8*
12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<A ;<. +C.* 12C-,A,C<A K%(" S9D K$Y(L @*;MA N,8B 3CN*2 % -;3=*A 2*1C28*. ,< 8B*
;<. ’YZ55L ;2* -*2> +3CA*O 3,8*2;8=2*O
)W8*<A,-* 2*A*;2+B B;A @**< +;22,*. C=8 C< 8B* ’B* IC33CN,<G 12C+*.=2* C=83,<*A 8B* G=,.*J
@*B;-,C2 CI !( @*;MA N,8BC=8 A8,22=1AO F;<> 3,<*A 2*+CMM*<.*. @> %Y() ‘46 ]9‘^ ,<
F;8*2,;3A ;<. Y82=+8=2*A K455DL ‘9/99Sg944 99Z
C2.*2 8C .*8*2M,<* 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !( > !"#$ %&$"’(&! )* $"+’*)$,"- ,)’,$"&" %7"’-"$
@*;MAO ’B* GC-*2<,<G *H=;8,C< I2CM %(" S9D ."#/%
[=,3.,<G (C.* A8;8*A 8B;8 8B* AB*;2 +;1;+,8>
M=A8 *W+**. 8B* AB*;2 .*M;<. ;A ABCN< ,< )H=;8,C< KS;L ;<. KS@L ;2* =A*. IC2 8;Q,<G 8B*
)HO K‘LO +C<+2*8* AB*;2 A82*<G8B ,<8C ;++C=<8 A,<+* 8B*
2*A=38A CI 8BCA* *H=;8,C<A ;2* ,< ; GCC. ;G2**M*<8
!$( # $& $‘% N,8B *W,A8,<G 8*A8 2*A=38AO %..,<G 8B* AB*;2
’B* <CM,<;3 AB*;2 A82*<G8B ,A .*2,-*. I2CM 8NC A82*<G8B +C<82,@=8,C< CI A8,22=1A 8C )HO KSLP 8B*
+CM1C<*<8A/ +C<+2*8* ;<. A8,22=1AO ’B*A* <CM,<;3 AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI A3*<.*2 @*;MA ,A
2*3;8,C<AB,1A ;2* G,-*< ,< )HO KZLO *W12*AA*. ;A IC33CNAP
& ’
$( ! $# " $) $Z% $( ! 5 9Z$%# %5 Z " 5 54$%# %5 6Z " * %+*
?+(@ ; (CM1;2,AC< CI
*W1*2,M*<8;3 AB*;2
A82*<G8B -;3=*A ;<.
12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8B
CI )HO KXL IC2 -;2,C=A
AB*;2 A1;< 8C .*18B 2;8,CA
?+(@ = (CM1;2,AC< CI
*W1*2,M*<8;3 AB*;2
A82*<G8B -;3=*A ;<.
12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8B
CI )HO KXL IC2 -;2,C=A
A8,22=1A <CM,<;3 A82*<G8B
;+8,C< ;<. AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI +C<+2*8*P 3*;.,<G 8C +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI ABC28 @*;MA N,8BC=8
8B* IC33CN,<G *W12*AA,C</ A8,22=1A ;2* -*2> 3,M,8*. IC2 7! k 5ODP
+C<A*H=*<83> I=28B*2 2*A*;2+B ,A 2*H=,2*. 8C
$# ’ $S Z & 4 Z !!% $95% -*2,I> 8B* 12C1CA*. )HO K95LO E,<;33>P <*N
_A=88>RA *H=;8,C<P =A,<G 8B* M=38,13* 2*G2*AA,C< .*A,G< *W12*AA,C<A ;2* 12C1CA*. IC2 8B*
;<;3>A,AP N;A 12C1CA*. 8C .*8*2M,<* 8B* +;3+=3;8,C< CI AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI ABC28 @*;MA
2*3;8,C<AB,1 @*8N**< 7! ;<. +C<+2*8* AB*;2 @;A*. C< 8B* %2A3;<RA *H=;8,C<A IC2 A3*<.*2
A82*<G8BP 3*;.,<G 8C 8B* IC33CN,<G *W12*AA,C< IC2 @*;MA @> 8;Q,<G 8B* ;2+B ;+8,C< ,<8C
ABC28 @*;MA/ +C<A,.*2;8,C<O [> A8;8,A8,+;3 2*G2*AA,C<P 8B*
;=8BC2 T<.AP ;A IC=<. @> _A=88>P $ +;< @*
$# ’ $4 Z!! % $99% ;AA=M*. 8C @* 12C1C28,C<;3 8C K4OZ!7 L 8C
,.*<8,I> M*;< ;2+B ;+8,C< ;<. +C<A,.*2,<G 8B,A
"< 8B,A A8=.>P ; 2*G2*AA,C< ;<;3>A,A ,A =<.*28;Q*< 2*A=38 IC2 ;2+B ;+8,C<P 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !(
8C ,.*<8,I> 8B* ,<j=*<+* CI 7! C< 8B* +2;+Q,<G ABC28 @*;MA N,8B A8,22=1A ,A G,-*< @> 8B* IC33CN,<G
AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !( ABC28 @*;MA N,8BC=8 A8,22=1A *H=;8,C<A/
;<. 8C .*T<* ;2+B ;+8,C< ,< +;3+=3;8,<G 8B* AB*;2
A82*<G8B CI !( ABC28 @*;MA =A,<G 8B* 2*A=38A CI & ’" 4 Z #
5Z 5 6Z
*W,A8,<G 6‘ *W1*2,M*<8;3 AB*;2 8*A8A ]95P 4‘P 4XP $( ! 5 9Z$%# % " 5 54$%# % " * %+*
!!
‘0gZ9^O ’B* -;2,;8,C< CI 8B* 2;8,C CI *W1*2,M*<8;3
KEC2 <C2M;3 A82*<G8B +C<+2*8*P $Y(L
+2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI ABC28 @*;MA N,8BC=8
A8,22=1A K$ L 8C +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI $9S;%
A3*<.*2 @*;MA K)HOKSLL +;< @* *W12*AA*. ;A & ’" 4 Z #
IC33CNAP $( ! 5 94$%# %5 Z " 5 54$%# %5 6Z " * %+*
!!
$#",-), 4 ‘D KEC2 B,GB A82*<G8B +C<+2*8*P VY(L
! $94%
)HO $S% !!
$9S@%
’B* *II*+8 CI 97K 7!L C< 8B* 2;8,C $ 7)HO KSL ,A
,33=A82;8*. ,< E,GO ZO ’B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !( EC33CN,<G ,A .,A+=AA,C< C< 8B* *II*+8 CI +CMJ
ABC28 @*;MA N,8BC=8 A8,22=1A N;A 2;2*3> 12*AA,-* A82*<G8B CI +C<+2*8* K% LP AB*;2 A1;< 8C
,<-*A8,G;8*. ,< 8B* 1;A8O ’B* 8*A8 2*A=38A CI 8B* .*18B 2;8,C K 7!L ;<. <CM,<;3 A82*<G8B CI A8,22=1
K % L C< 8B* 12C1CA*. )HO K9SLO
E,G=2* 6 +CM1;2*A 8B* 12C1CA*. )HO K9SL N,8B
8B* *W1*2,M*<8;3 AB*;2 A82*<G8B -;3=*A C@8;,<*.
I2CM 8*A8A IC2 <C2M;3 A82*<G8B +C<+2*8* @*;MA
]4SP ‘DP Z4^ N,8B B,GB A82*<G8B +C<+2*8* @*;MA ]94P
SDP Z4^O
E,G=2*A 0gX ABCN 8B* *22C2A NB,+B ;2* ,<.=+*.
@> 8B* .,A+2*1;<+> CI 7!P % ;<. % @*8N**<
8*A8 ;<. 12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8BO ’B* 2;8,C CI
*W1*2,M*<8;3 8C 12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8B ,A <C8
A,G<,T+;<83> ,<j=*<+*. N,8B ,<+2*;A,<G 7!P %
;<. % @=8 AB*;2 8*A8 .;8; ;2* <C8 BCMCG*<*C=A
+CM1;2,<G 8C .;8; CI A3*<.*2 @*;MAO
?+(@ A )II*+8 CI 97K 7!L C< +2;+Q,<G AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !( ’B* 12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8B *H=;8,C< B;A @**<
ABC28 @*;MA N,8BC=8 A8,22=1A +CM1;2*. N,8B 8B* (C.* 12C-,A,C<A K%(" S9D ;<.
99D F;8*2,;3A ;<. Y82=+8=2*A K455DL ‘9/99Sg944
!
(%
?+(@ H (CM1;2,AC< CI
*W1*2,M*<8;3 AB*;2
A82*<G8B -;3=*A ;<.
12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8B
CI )HO K9SL IC2 -;2,C=A
A8,22=1A <CM,<;3 A82*<G8B
?+(@ G (CM1;2,AC< CI
*W1*2,M*<8;3 AB*;2
A82*<G8B -;3=*A ;<.
12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8B
CI )HO K9SL IC2 -;2,C=A
+CM12*AA,-* A82*<G8B CI
+C<+2*8*
F;8*2,;3A ;<. Y82=+8=2*A K455DL ‘9/99Sg944 99X
’YZ55L ;<. 2*A=38A ;2* 8;@=3;8*. ,< ’;@3* 9O EC2 =<,IC2M,8> ,< 8B* 12*.,+8,C< ;<. 8B* 3CN*2 8B*
8B* 7! 2;8,C B,GB*2 8B;< 4OZP 8B* 12C1CA*. ( UP 8B* @*88*2 8B* 12*.,+8,C< +;1;@,3,8> CI 8B*
*H=;8,C< G,-*A M*;< -;3=* CI 9OS‘ ;<. +C*IT+,*<8 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<AO %A ,8 ,A A**< I2CM ’;@3* 4P
CI -;2,;8,C< K( UL CI 5O4S IC2 $Y(O F*;<NB,3*P 8B* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C< IC2 AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI !(
IC2 VY( M*;< -;3=* ;<. ( U ;2* 9OS‘ ;<. 5OS‘P @*;MA N,8B A8,22=1A ,A @*88*2 8B;< 8B* C8B*2AP ,<
2*A1*+8,-*3>O VCN*-*2P 8B* M*;< -;3=* ;<. ( U 8*2MA CI ;++=2;+> ;<. =<,IC2M,8> CI 12*.,+8,C<O
C@8;,<*. IC2 $Y( N,8B %(" S9D 12C-,A,C<A ;2*
9O‘9 ;<. 5O4SP 2*A1*+8,-*3>O EC2 VY(P %(" S9D
12C-,A,C< >,*3.A M*;< -;3=* CI 9O4X ;<. ( U CI
E I)’,71%+)’%
5OS‘O ’=2Q,AB Y8;<.;2. 12C-,A,C<P )HO KDLP 12CJ
-,.*A M*;< -;3=* CI 9O90 ;<. ( U CI 5O4S IC2
’B* IC33CN,<G +C<+3=A,C<A +;< @* .2;N< I2CM 8B*
$Y( ;<. M*;< -;3=* CI 9O56 ;<. ( U CI 5OSS IC2
2*A=38A CI 8B,A A8=.>O
VY(O "8 +;< @* +C<+3=.*. 8B;8 8B* 12C1CA*.
*H=;8,C<A IC2 A3*<.*2 !( @*;MA 1*2IC2M*. # ’B* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<A IC2 A3*<.*2 !( @*;MA
;3MCA8 ;A N*33 ;A %(" S9D [=,3.,<G (C.* ;<. 1*2IC2M*. ;3MCA8 ;A N*33 ;A %(" S9D [=,3.,<G
’=2Q,AB Y8;<.;2. 12C-,A,C<A ,< 8*2MA CI ( UO (C.* ;<. ’=2Q,AB A8;<.;2. 12C-,A,C<A ,<
EC2 K 7!L k 4OZP 8B* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<A ;2* 8*2MA CI +C*IT+,*<8 CI -;2,;8,C< K( ULO
+CM1;2*. ,< ’;@3* 4 N,8B *W,A8,<G 8*A8 2*A=38AO
’B* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<A +C22*3;8* M=+B @*88*2 # ’B* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<A IC2 AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI
N,8B 8*A8 2*A=38A 8B;< 8B* ’Y Z55 ;<. %(" S9D ABC28 @*;MA N,8B A8,22=1A >,*3. MC2* ;++=2;8*
[=,3.,<G (C.* 12C-,A,C<AO EC2 ,<A8;<+*P 8B* M*;< 2*A=38A 8B;< 8B* ’=2Q,AB Y8;<.;2. ;<. %(" S9D
-;3=* CI 8B* 2;8,C CI 8B* *W1*2,M*<8;3 AB*;2 [=,3.,<G (C.* 12C-,A,C<A ;<. ;3ACP =<,IC2M,8>
A82*<G8B 8C 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B 12C-,.*. @> %(" CI 12*.,+8,C< ,A @*88*2O VCN*-*2P @*+;=A* 8B*
S9D [=,3.,<G (C.* ,A 9OD‘ ;<. 8B* ( U CI 8B,A 8*A8 .;8; IC2 B,GB A82*<G8B +C<+2*8* ABC28
2;8,C ,A 5O49 IC2 $Y(P 9OS5 ;<. 5OZZ IC2 VY(P @*;MA ;2* -*2> 3,M,8*. I=28B*2 2*A*;2+B ,A
2*A1*+8,-*3>O ’B* M*;< -;3=* CI 8B* 2;8,C CI 8B* 2*H=,2*. 8C -*2,I> 8B* 12C1CA*. *H=;8,C<AO
*W1*2,M*<8;3 AB*;2 A82*<G8B 8C 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B
12*.,+8*. @> ’=2Q,AB Y8;<.;2. ,A 9O6S ;<. 8B* # ’B* 2;8,C CI *W1*2,M*<8;3 8C 12C1CA*. AB*;2
( U CI 8B,A 2;8,C ,A 5O44 IC2 $Y(P 9O94 ;<. 5OZ‘ A82*<G8B ,A <C8 A,G<,T+;<83> ,<j=*<+*. @>
IC2 VY(P 2*A1*+8,-*3>O ( U ,A 8B* ,<.*W CI ,<+2*;A,<G 7!P % ;<. % IC2 @C8B A3*<.*2
J#.7" 9 U*2,T+;8,C< CI 12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8B IC2 A3*<.*2 !( @*;MA =A,<G *<8,2* .;8;@;A*
% $ ‘9O‘ F?; K$Y(L % l ‘9O‘ F?; KVY(L
)W1O7?2C1O )W1O7’Y Z55 )W1O7%("S9D )W1O7?2C1O )W1O7’Y Z55 )W1O7%("S9D
J#.7" ; U*2,T+;8,C< CI 12C1CA*. AB*;2 A82*<G8B IC2 ABC28 !( @*;MA =A,<G *<8,2* .;8;@;A*
% $ ‘9O‘ F?; K$Y(L % l ‘9O‘ F?; KVY(L
)W1O7?2C1O )W1O7’Y Z55 )W1O7%("S9D )W1O7?2C1O )W1O7’Y Z55 )W1O7%("S9D
;<. ABC28 @*;MA @=8 AB*;2 8*A8 .;8; IC2 ABC28 M*;A=2* ;++=2;8*3> 8B* 8*<A,C<JACI8*<,<G @2;<+B
@*;MA ;2* <C8 BCMCG*<*C=A +CM1;2,<G 8C 8*A8 ,< ; 13;,< +C<+2*8* 8*<A,C< 8*A8 =<.*2 ; 3C;.J
.;8; CI A3*<.*2 @*;MAO +C<82C33*. 12C+*.=2*O Y,<+* ,A *W12*AA*. @>
8B* M,<,M=M 2*,<IC2+*M*<8 2;8,C 2*H=,2*. 8C
M;,<8;,< +C<A8;<8 A82;,< ;8 8B* +2;+QP 8B* +C22*J
A1C<.,<G 3,M,8 -;3=* IC2 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B
622"’-+KLB%&+/#&+)’ )* ,)’,$"&" ,)’&$+.1&+)’ +;1;+,8> CI 8B* .,;GC<;3 8*<A,C< +2;+Q CI A3*<.*2
&) %!"#$ %&$"’(&! @*;MA +;< ;3AC @* ,<8*212*8*. ;A *H=;3 8C O
Y=@A8,8=8,<G 8B*A* *H=;8,C<A ! ,<8C $ #.", ! S %, 09 P N*
4
94O YB,< YJhP &** cJYP FCC< :P #BCABP Yc K9XXXL YB*;2 <C2M;3 ;<. B,GBJA82*<G8B +C<+2*8*O %(" Y82=+8 :
A82*<G8B CI 2*,<IC2+*. B,GBJA82*<G8B +C<+2*8* @*;MA X9K4L/9‘5g9‘X
N,8B AB*;2 A1;<J8CJ.*18B 2;8,CA @*8N**< 9OZ ;<. 4OZO S5O F+#C2M3*> :(P (2*;2> \[P !;M,2*b :% K9XX6L ’B*
%(" Y82=+8 : X6/Z‘XgZZ6 1*2IC2M;<+* CI *1CW>J+C;8*. AB*;2 2*,<IC2+*M*<8O
9SO !*@*,b cY K9XXXL YB*;2 A82*<G8B 12*.,+8,C< IC2 %(" Y82=+8 : XSKZL/ZS9gZS0
+C<+2*8* M*M@*2AO : Y82=+8 )<G 94ZKSL/S59gS5D S9O dCC< dP (CCQ h\P F,8+B*33 \ K9XX6L F,<,M=M AB*;2
9‘O %Y()J%(" ‘46 K9X0SL ’B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI 2*,<IC2+*M*<8 ,< <C2M;3JP M*.,=MJP ;<. B,GBJA82*<G8B
2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* M*M@*2AO ?2C+ %M YC+ (,-,3 +C<+2*8* @*;MAO %(" Y82=+8 : XSKZL/ Z06gZD‘
)<G XXKY’6L/95X9g99D0 S4O _;2;2,A ?VP ?;1;.;Q,A # K9XXXL "<j=*<+* CI 8B*
9ZO [;b;<8 _?P d= p K455SL \*A,G<,<G ;G;,<A8 A,b* *II*+8 ;22;<G*M*<8 CI 2*,<IC2+*M*<8 C< 8B* AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI
C< AB*;2 A82*<G8B CI 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MA N,8BC=8 !( @*;MAO ?2C+**.,<G CI 8B* 9S8B V*33*<,+ (C<I*2*<+*
A8,22=1AO "’" !*1C28P A=@M,88*. 8C %(" (CMM,88** ‘‘ZP C< (C<+2*8*P !*8B>M<C<P #2**+*P 11 995g99X
YB*;2 ;<. ’C2A,C<a -*2A,C< ;3AC A=@M,88*. IC2 SSO c;2;>,;<<,A (#P (B;3,C2,A () K9XXXL )W1*2,M*<8;3
1=@3,+;8,C< ,< : Y82=+8 )<G ,<-*A8,G;8,C< CI 8B* ,<j=*<+* CI A8,22=1A C< 8B* AB*;2
96O ’YJZ55 2*H=,2*M*<8A IC2 .*A,G< ;<. +C<A82=+8,C< CI I;,3=2* M*+B;<,AM CI 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MAO
2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* A82=+8=2*AP 4555O ’=2Q,AB ?2C+**.,<G CI 8B* 9S8B V*33*<,+ (C<I*2*<+* C<
Y8;<.;2.A "<A8,8=8*P %<Q;2; K,< ’=2Q,ABL (C<+2*8*P !*8B>M<C<P #2**+*P 11 9SSg9‘9
90O [2*A3*2 [P Y+C2.*3,A %( K9X69L YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI S‘O %<G*3;QCA \P [*<8b )(P (C33,<A F? K4559L )II*+8 CI
2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MAO Y*2,*A 955P "AA=* 9SP +C<+2*8* A82*<G8B ;<. M,<,M=M A8,22=1A C< AB*;2
Y82=+8=2*A ;<. F;8*2,;3A !*A*;2+BP \*18O CI (,-,3 A82*<G8B CI 3;2G* M*M@*2AO %(" Y82=+8 : XDKSL/4X5g
)<G,<**2,<GO e<,-O CI (;3,IC2<,;P [*2Q*3*> S55
9DO &*C<B;2.8 EP h;38*2 ! K9X64L Y+B=@-*2A=+B* ;< SZO #C<b;3*b E[ K4554L VC2M,GC<*A +C< ;2,.CA 2*+,+3;.CA
),<I*3.2,*G*< Y8;B3@*8C<J[;3Q*< M,8 =<. CB<* 12C+*8*<.*A .* .*MC3,+,C<*A/ .CA,T+;+,C<*AP
Y+B=@@*N*B2=<G b=2 )2M,883=<G .*2 Y+B=@ 12C1,*.;.*A M*+;<,+;A > +CM1C28;M,*<8C *A82=+8=2*;
82;GI;qB,GQ*,8 =<. .*2 @*2*< Y+B=@A1;<<=<GAG2*<b*O ; +C28;<8*O ’*A,A .C+8C2;3 .,2,G,.; 1C2 ?2CIO E*2<;<.C
V*I8 9Z9P \*=8A+B*2 %=AA+B=AA I=q2 Y8;B3@*8C<P hO F;28,<*bP )’Y)((? .* 3; (C2=<;P e<,-*2A,.;. .* 3;
)2<A8 =O YCB<P [*23,<P 6D 11 (C2=<;
9XO [2*A3*2 [P Y+C2.*3,A %( K9X66L YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI S6O &><G@*2G [Y K9X06L e38,M;8* AB*;2 2*A,A8;<+* CI
2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MA g Y*2,*A """O !*1C28 $CO 6ZJ 1;28,;33> 12*A82*AA*. 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* "J@*;MAO
95P Y82=+8=2*A ;<. F;8*2,;3A !*A*;2+BP \*18O CI (,-,3 %(" : ?2C+**.,<GA 0SK‘L
)<G,<**2,<GP e<,-O CI (;3,IC2<,;P [*2Q*3*> S0O !C33*2 ::P !=AA*33 V# K9XX5L YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI B,GBJ
45O [;B3 $Y K9X6DL e q @*2 .*< ),<j=r .*2 [;3Q*<BCqB* ;=I A82*<G8B +C<+2*8* @*;MA N,8B N*@ 2*,<IC2+*M*<8O %("
.,* Y+B=@82;GI;qB,GQ*,8 -C< ),<I*3.2,*G*< Y8;B3@*8C<J Y82=+8 : D0K4L/9X9g9XD
[;3Q*< M,8 =<. CB<* Y+B=@@*N*B2=<GO ?B\ SDO cC<G ?d&P !;<G;< [U K9XXDL YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI B,GBJ
\,AA*28;8,C<P e<,-*2A,8;q8 Y8=88G;28P #*2M;<>P 94Z 11 1*2IC2M;<+* +C<+2*8* @*;MAO %(" Y82=+8 : XZK6L/600g
49O ?3;+;A %P !*G;< ?) K9X09L YB*;2 I;,3=2* CI 2*,<IC2+*. 6DD
+C<+2*8* @*;MAO %(" : 6DK95L/06Sg00S SXO !;B;3 c$P %3JYB;3*B cY K455‘L F,<,M=M 82;<A-*2A*
44O YN;M> !$P %<.2,C1C=3CA %\ K9X0‘L (C<82,@=8,C< CI 2*,<IC2+*M*<8 ,< 6Z F?; +C<+2*8* @*;MAO %(" Y82=+8 :
;GG2*G;8* ,<8*23C+Q ;<. .CN*3 IC2+*A 8C 8B* AB*;2 959K6L/D04gD0D
2*A,A8;<+* CI 2*,<IC2+*. @*;MA N,8B N*@ ‘5O %.*@;2 ?P (C33,<A F? K9XX6L YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI
!*,<IC2+*M*<8O YB*;2 ,< !*,<IC2+*. (C<+2*8*P Y?J‘4P M*M@*2A N,8BC=8 82;<A-*2A* 2*,<IC2+*M*<8O (;< :
%("P E;2M,<G8C< V,33AP F,+BOP 11 94Xg966 (,-,3 )<G 4S/S5g‘9
4SO F;88C+Q %VP h;<G _ K9XD‘L YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI ‘9O ’;< cP cC<G EP ’*<G YP h*<G & K9XX0L )II*+8 CI N*@
2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* M*M@*2A A=@i*+8 8C B,GB ;W,;3 2*,<IC2+*M*<8 C< B,GB A82*<G8B +C<+2*8* .**1 @*;MAO
+CM12*AA,-* A82*AAO %(" Y82=+8 : 99KSL/4D0g4XD %(" : X‘KZL/Z04gZD4
4‘O F1BC<.* %#P E2;<8b #( K9XD‘L YB*;2 8*A8A CI B,GBJ ‘4O b+*@* #P )2AC> eP ’;<Q=8 ’ K9XXXL )-;3=;8,C< CI
;<. 3CNJA82*<G8B +C<+2*8* @*;MA N,8BC=8 A8,22=1AO %(" M,<,M=M AB*;2 2*,<IC2+*M*<8 2*H=,2*M*<8A IC2 B,GB*2
: D9K‘L/SZ5gSZ0 A82*<G8B +C<+2*8*O %(" Y82=+8 : X6KSL/S69gS6D
4ZO )3b;<;8> %VP $,3AC< %VP Y3;8* E K9XD6L YB*;2 ‘SO (3;.*2; %P F;2, %! K455ZL )W1*2,M*<8;3 A8=.> C<
+;1;+,8> CI 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MA =A,<G B,GB B,GBJA82*<G8B +C<+2*8* @*;MA I;,3,<G ,< AB*;2O )<G
A82*<G8B +C<+2*8*O %(" : 6ZK9L/4X5g4X6 Y82=+8 40/9Z9Xg9Z40
46O :CB<AC< FcP !;M,2*b :% K9XDXL F,<,M=M AB*;2 ‘‘O )8W*@*22,; FP F;2, %!P U;bH=*b ) K455SL )A8=.,C
2*,<IC2+*M*<8 ,< @*;MA N,8B B,GB*2 A82*<G8B +C<+2*8*O *W1*2,M*<8;3 .* 3; 2*A,A8*<+,; ; +C28;<8* *< -,G;A .*
%(" Y82=+8 : D6K‘L/S06gSD4 BC2M,GC< .* ;2,.CA 2*+,+3;.CAO ?B\ 8B*A,AP
40O %<.*2AC< $YP !;M,2*b :% K9XDXL \*8;,3,<G CI A8,22=1 e<,-*2A,.;. ?C3,8*+<,+; .; (;8;3=<;
2*,<IC2+*M*<8O %(" Y82=+8 : D6KZL/Z50gZ9Z ‘ZO (C33,<A F?P c=+BM; \ K9XXXL VCN A;I* ;2* C=2 3;2G*P
4DO Y;2b;M cEP %3JF=A;N, :FY K9XX4L YB*;2 .*A,G< CI 3,GB83> 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MAP A3;@A ;<. ICC8,<GAt
B,GBJ ;<. <C2M;3JA82*<G8B +C<+2*8* @*;MA N,8B N*@ %(" Y82=+8=2;3 :C=2<;3 X6K‘L/‘D4g‘X5
2*,<IC2+*M*<8O %(" Y82=+8 : DXK6L/6ZDg66‘ ‘6O E*<N,+Q !(P ?;=3;> ’ K9X6DL F*+B;<,AMA CI AB*;2
4XO s,* dP %BM;. YVP d= ’P V,<C YP (B=<G h K9XX‘L 2*A,A8;<+* CI +C<+2*8* @*;MAO : Y82=+8 )<G %Y()
YB*;2 .=+8,3,8> CI 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MA CI X‘K95L/4S4Zg4SZ5
944 F;8*2,;3A ;<. Y82=+8=2*A K455DL ‘9/99Sg944
‘0O (BC YJV K455SL YB*;2 A82*<G8B 12*.,+8,C< @> MC.,T*. ZSO cB=<8,; FP Y8Ci;.,<C-,+ [ K4559L YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI
13;A8,+,8> 8B*C2> IC2 ABC28 @*;MAO %(" Y82=+8 : 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* @*;MA N,8BC=8 82;<A-*2A*
955K9L/95Zg994 2*,<IC2+*M*<8O %(" Y82=+8 : XDKZL/6‘Dg6Z6
‘DO B :JcP YB,< YJh K4559L YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI 2*,<IC2+*. Z‘O )2AC> eP q b+*@* # K4559L [*8C<;2M*O )-2,M
B,GBJA82*<G8B +C<+2*8* .**1 @*;MAO %(" Y82=+8 d;> <*-,P "A8;<@=3
: XDK4L/96‘g90S ZZO $,3AC< %VP h,<8*2 # K9XX9L \*A,G< CI +C<+2*8*
‘XO F;8B*> !#P h;8A8*,< \ K9X6SL YB*;2 A82*<G8B CI A82=+8=2*AO F+J#2;NJV,33 "<8*2<;8,C<;3 ).,8,C<A
@*;MA N,8BC=8 N*@ 2*,<IC2+*M*<8O %(" : 65K4L/9DSg45D Z6O ?;=3;> ’P ?2,*A83*> F:$ K9XX4L Y*,AM,+ .*A,G< CI
Z5O ’;>3C2 ! K9X65L YCM* AB*;2 8*A8A C< 2*,<IC2+*. 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* ;<. M;AC<2>O h,3*>P $*N dC2Q
+C<+2*8* @*;MA N,8BC=8 AB*;2 2*,<IC2+*M*<8O F;G Z0O (;22*,2; \:P (B= c K9XD6L Y82*AAJA82;,< 2*3;8,C<AB,1
(C<+2*8* !*A 94KS6L/9‘Zg9Z‘ IC2 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* ,< 8*<A,C<O %(" : DSKSL/49g4D
Z9O c;<, #$: K9X66L [;A,+ I;+8A +C<+*2<,<G AB*;2 I;,3=2*O ZDO F;AA,+C88* [P )3N, %)P F;+#2*GC2 :F K9XX5L
%(" : 6SK6L/60Zg6X4 ’*<A,C<JA8,II*<,<G MC.*3 IC2 13;<;2 2*,<IC2+*.
Z4O (3;2Q % K9XZ9L \,;GC<;3 8*<A,C< ,< 2*,<IC2+*. +C<+2*8* M*M@*2AO : Y82=+8 )<G %Y() 996K99L/S5SXg
+C<+2*8* @*;MAO %(" : ?2C+**.,<G ‘DK4L/9‘Zg9Z6 S5ZD