Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review Article: The Neurobiological Approach To Premature Ejaculation
Review Article: The Neurobiological Approach To Premature Ejaculation
Review Article: The Neurobiological Approach To Premature Ejaculation
Review Article
ABSTRACT
Purpose: Data showing the neurobiological background of rapid ejaculation was reviewed. In
addition, new hypotheses to integrate clinical symptomatology, psychopharmacotherapy and
psychotherapy of rapid ejaculation with brain function are provided.
Materials and Methods: A computerized MEDLINE search, and manual bibliographic review
of cross-references and neurobiological animal studies were performed. These reports were
analyzed, summarized and compared with the studies performed by the author.
Results: The literature on premature ejaculation published between 1887 and 2001 was
reviewed. It appeared that the various psychological hypotheses and psychotherapies have not
adequately been investigated. In contrast, psychopharmacological treatment studies, animal
research data and stopwatch assessments in men with rapid (premature) ejaculation indicate
that lifelong rapid ejaculation is a neurobiological phenomenon related to central serotonergic
neurotransmission and likely influenced by hereditary factors.
Conclusions: Basic and clinical psychopharmacological studies suggest that premature ejacu-
lation is a not a psychological disturbance but a neurobiological phenomenon.
KEY WORDS: penis, ejaculation, serotonin, serotonin uptake inhibitors, sex disorders
Since the 1990s various psychopharmacological studies have as hyperesthesia of the glans penis or a foreskin frenulum
shown that serotonergic antidepressants may effectively delay that was too short, and on changes in the posterior section of
ejaculation in men with lifelong premature ejaculation. These the urethra, particularly at the verumontanum. Advocated
results and animal data make it likely that premature ejacula- treatment included prescription of an anesthetizing ointment
tion is not a psychological disorder but a neurobiological phe- to incision of the frenulum or total destruction of the veru-
nomenon. The consequences for understanding premature ejac- montanum by electrocautery.
ulation and its treatment are discussed. In 1943 Schapiro argued that premature ejaculation is a
psychosomatic disturbance caused by the combination of a
HISTORY psychologically overanxious constitution and “an inferior
ejaculatory apparatus as a point of least resistance for emo-
We can distinguish 4 periods in the course of the last tional pressure.”7 Schapiro described 2 types of premature
century1 and 2 partly contrasting approaches, namely a so- ejaculation, namely type B, representing a continuously
matic (urological or physiological) and a psychological (psy- present tendency to ejaculate rapidly from the first act of
choanalytic or behavioristic) approach.2 The current era is intercourse, and type A, which led to erectile dysfunction.
that of the neurobiological approach, characterized by evi-
Many years later the 2 types became distinguished as the
denced based animal and human psychopharmacological re-
primary (lifelong) and secondary (acquired) forms of prema-
search, and antidepressant treatment as the first choice with
ture ejaculation, respectively.8
psychotherapy only in cases of serious coping problems.1
The third period (1950 to 1990): learned behavior. In the
third period premature ejaculation was considered to be
CHRONOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION learned behavior. Rapid ejaculation associated with initial
The first period (1887 to 1917): rapid ejaculation. In rapid intercourse led to habituation and created performance
1887 Gross described what was presumably the first case anxiety. Support for this behavioristic view was sought in
of rapid ejaculation in the medical literature.3 In 1901 a physiological experiments, in which the phenomenon of anx-
report of von Krafft-Ebing followed that referred to abnor- iety was emphasized. Although behavioral therapy was still
mally rapid ejaculation but did not yet use the word prae- predominantly present in the literature, increasingly more
cox or premature.4 publications focused on psychoactive drugs as a treatment.
The second period (1917 to 1950): neurosis and psychoso- The third period (1990 to present): neurobiology and genet-
matic disorder. In 1917 Abraham described the syndrome of ics. The introduction of clomipramine and selective serotonin
rapid ejaculation, which he called ejaculatio praecox.5 During re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs) meant a dramatic change in
the early decades of the 20th century premature ejaculation treatment for premature ejaculation. The efficacy of these
was viewed as a neurosis related to unconscious conflicts, drugs in delaying ejaculation combined with the low side
especially in psychoanalytic theory.5, 6 Treatment consisted effect profile made them first choice agents for premature
of classic psychoanalysis. The somatic approach was primar- ejaculation on a daily as well as an on-demand basis.9 At the
ily urological, which focused on local anatomical causes, such same time animal and sexual psychopharmacological human
2359
2360 NEUROBIOLOGICAL APPROACH TO PREMATURE EJACULATION
studies10 attributed a serotonergic genesis11–13 and possible tacts in the back seats of a car or in places where detection
genetic etiology14 to the neurobiological view of premature was possible and by consequent performance anxiety.45
ejaculation. However, evidenced based data for this assumption has
never been reported. Briefly, until today no evidenced
based psychological study has been available in the liter-
CLASSIFICATION ACCORDING TO THE PSYCHOLOGICAL OR ature. Therefore, scientific knowledge about the funda-
MEDICAL APPROACH
mentals of the psychological approach remain to be eluci-
The psychological approach. According to the classic psy- dated. It is rather peculiar that despite some available
chological view premature ejaculation is considered a psycho- studies of the poor response of psychological treatment and
sexual disorder with a psychogenic etiology and pathogenesis insufficient study methodology37, 46 –50 the principles of the
that must be treated with psychotherapy.15 Initially uncon- psychological approach have never been altered and sub-
scious conflicts toward women were considered the core is- sequently tested. The methodological insufficiencies are
sue. However, since the article of Semans about the stop- serious. For example, no objective and accurate measures
start method,16 and particularly that of Masters and Johnson or clear definitions of ejaculation time, the number of
about the squeeze technique17 the pathogenesis was believed thrusts or satisfaction have been used. Men were only
to be learned because initial intercourse was assumed to asked about ejaculation latency without any quantifying
have been achieved hurriedly. In the psychological approach method. Furthermore, retrospective information was used
pathogenetic biological mechanisms remained unclear. instead of prospective baseline measurements of each coi-
Although a rapid ejaculation reflex was mentioned there was tus. Behavioral treatments were compared neither with
no information on the location of the neuronal circuitry of nonbehavioral treatment nor with random nonsense psy-
that particular reflex.16 Also, increased sensitivity of the chological treatment. Moreover, assessments were only
glans penis was suggested. However, penile vibratory studies made in men, whereas information from females about
provided conflicting data on primary pathogenetic penile hy- partner ejaculation time was completely neglected.
persensitivity.18 –20 The medical approach. Pharmacotherapy: Since the 1940s,
Not only the squeeze technique, but also all sorts of psy- case reports have occasionally been published about various
chotherapy, including thought stopping,21, 22 Gestalt thera- drugs with efficacy for delaying ejaculation. Physicians at-
py,23 transactional analysis,24 group therapy25, 26 and biblio- tempted to decrease penile sensation and delay ejaculation
therapy,27 have been suggested as treatment. Unfortunately by applying local anesthetics to the glans penis.7, 51–54 Others
the effectiveness of these therapies was only suggested in tried to influence the peripheral sympathetic nervous system
case reports but was never investigated in well designed by prescribing sympatholytic drugs, such as the ␣1 and ␣2-
controlled studies. However, of all of these treatments the adrenergic blocker phenoxybenzamine55–57 or the selective
squeeze method is said to give rise to short-term effective- ␣1-adrenergic blockers alfuzosin and terazosin.58 In the
ness. In 2 studies that were not well designed its initial 1960s case reports described the ejaculation delaying effects
effectiveness was confirmed but they also showed that the of some neuroleptics. Thioridazine59 – 62 and chlorprothix-
ejaculatory control initially attained was virtually lost after a ene63 delayed ejaculation by blocking central dopamine re-
3-year followup.28, 29 ceptors. In the same period case reports of the delaying
Definition of Premature Ejaculation: In the psychological effects of nonselective, irreversible monoamine oxidase inhib-
approach consensus on a definition of premature ejaculation itors, for example isocarboxazid64 and phenelzine,65 were
has never been reached due to conflicting ideas on the es- published. However, the use of these various drugs was often
sence of the syndrome. Masters and Johnson,17 and Kaplan30 contraindicated by their disturbing and sometimes quite se-
suggested qualitative descriptions, for example female part- rious side effects.
ner satisfaction or male voluntary control. Masters and In 1973 Eaton reported the first study of clomipramine as
Johnson defined premature ejaculation as male inability to effective treatment for premature ejaculation.49 Later case
inhibit ejaculation long enough for the partner to reach or- reports and double-blind studies43, 66⫺74 repeatedly demon-
gasm in 50% of intercourse episodes.17 It is important to strated the effectiveness of clomipramine at low daily doses
realize that based on their definition they claimed that the for delaying ejaculation. In 1993 Segraves et al reported the
squeeze method was highly effective treatment. However, it first double-blind placebo controlled study showing that 25 to
is obvious that their definition in terms of partner response is 50 mg. clomipramine can even be ingested on an on-demand
inadequate because it implies that any male partner of fe- basis approximately 6 hours before coitus.43 On-demand
males who has difficulty in reaching orgasm could be labeled treatment was replicated in later studies.73 Unfortunately
a premature ejaculator and also females should achieve or- similar to psychological studies, the majority of these initial
gasm on 50% of intercourse episodes. pharmacological studies were designed without a precise def-
Another way to define premature ejaculation is by quanti- inition of premature ejaculation and with a poor methodology
tative measures such as the duration of ejaculatory latency for quantifying the effects of treatment. The efficacy of clo-
or the number of thrusts before ejaculation. Definitions ac- mipramine was recognized by some sexologists but never
cording to the time before ejaculation varied from 1 to 7 reached an international consensus.75
minutes after vaginal intromission.31– 40 These cutoff points SSRIs: In 1994 Waldinger et al reported the first placebo
(1 to 7 minutes) were not derived by objective measurements controlled study of 40 mg. paroxetine daily for successfully
but were subjectively chosen by the various investigators. treating premature ejaculation.76 The efficacy of paroxetine
Premature ejaculation was a matter of many minutes and at daily doses of 20 to 40 mg. was replicated in independent
cases of ejaculation within seconds were considered serious. studies at a regular daily dose77– 82 and in an on-demand
Equally subjective cutoff points were proposed for the num- regimen.83 In addition, the efficacy of other SSR inhibitors,
ber of thrusts as a criterion for premature ejaculation, such as 50 to 200 mg. sertraline daily74, 78, 79, 84 – 86 and 20
namely ejaculation within 8 to 15 thrusts.41– 43 mg. fluoxetine daily,78, 87– 89 has been reported for delaying
Methodology of Psychological Studies: During the many ejaculation. There have only been 2 parallel group dose-
years in which the psychological approach prevailed, the response studies. Clomipramine at 25 and 50 mg. daily,71
proposed psychological hypotheses and psychotherapeutic and paroxetine at 20 and 40 mg. daily77 showed a trend,
treatments were not proved in any proper scientific although it was not statistically significant, toward further
study.12, 44 For example, Masters and Johnson argued that ejaculation delay when the dose was doubled.
premature ejaculation was conditioned by experiencing first In contrast to the insufficient methodology in psychological
sexual intercourse in a rapid way, such as by hurried con- studies and initial psychopharmacological studies, the well
NEUROBIOLOGICAL APPROACH TO PREMATURE EJACULATION 2361
described methodology of psychopharmacological studies in nists it became evident that the role of 5-HT2C receptors in
recent years is underlined. In last decade major methodolog- ejaculation seems rather crucial. In addition to 5-HT2C re-
ical improvements were developed. For example, in 1994 ceptors, a second subclass of 5-HT2 receptors, that is 5-HT2A
Waldinger et al operationally defined premature ejaculation receptors, has also been investigated but until now its role in
and introduced the intravaginal ejaculation latency time pa- ejaculation has not been identified.79 For example, in regard
rameter, defined as the time between the start of intravagi- to the 5-HT2C receptor male rat studies with d-lysergic acid
nal intromission and the start of intravaginal ejaculation, as diethylamide and quipazine, which are nonselective 5-HT2C
an operational measure of ejaculation time.76 In the same agonists, suggest that stimulating 5-HT2C receptors delays
study we also used the medical interview of the female part- ejaculation.98 However, 2,5-dimethoxy-4-iodophenyl-2-
ner as a comparative means for spouse estimation of ejacu- aminopropane, which equally stimulates 5-HT2A and
lation time. The stopwatch, which was originally introduced 5-HT2C receptors, also increases ejaculation latency,99
in 1973 as an accurate tool to measure ejaculation time,90 whereas the selective 5-HT2A receptor agonist 2,5-di-
was prudently reintroduced in 1995 by Althof et al.72 In 1998 methoxy-4-methylamphetamine does not have this effect.98
we introduced the baseline measurement of intravaginal Male rat studies have also shown the involvement of another
ejaculation latency time at each intercourse in a standard serotonin subtype receptor, namely the 5-HT1A receptor, in
period of 4 weeks with a stopwatch handled by the female the ejaculation process. Activation of postsynaptic 5-HT1A
partner.78 receptors by the selective 5-HT1A receptor agonist
Differential Efficacy of SSRIs for Delaying Ejaculation: 8-hydroxy-2-(di-n-propylaminotetralin) in male rats resulted
Using intravaginal ejaculation latency time, a stopwatch and in shorter ejaculation latency.98
4-week baseline assessment at each intercourse comparative Based on 5-HT2C and 5-HT1A receptor interaction data in
placebo controlled studies showed a difference for delaying animals Waldinger et al formulated the hypothesis that in
ejaculation in various SSRIs at equivalent doses. It was premature ejaculation in humans there is hyposensitivity of
noted that 20 mg. paroxetine daily and 20 mg. fluoxetine the 5-HT2C and/or hypersensitivity of the 5-HT1A recep-
daily resulted in strong delays, 50 mg. sertraline daily re- tor.100 The hypothesis that activation of postsynaptic 5-HT
sulted in moderate delay but 100 mg. fluvoxamine daily and receptors delays ejaculation was supported by 4 stopwatch
20 mg. citalopram daily caused only mild to moderate delay. studies in humans with different SSRIs.78 – 81 However, in
The mild delay of fluvoxamine compared with paroxetine was these studies it was not obvious whether similar receptor
replicated in a placebo controlled male rat study using a subtypes, that is 5-HT2C and 5-HT1A receptors, are also
chronic administration treatment model,91 whereas after involved in human ejaculation since SSRI treatment acti-
acute treatment such a significant difference was not ob- vates many different postsynaptic subtype receptors.11
served.92 Because explanations in terms of transporter occu- To find an answer 2 human studies with the 5-HT2C
pancy, pharmacokinetics, metabolism or active metabolites blocking antidepressants nefazodone and mirtazapine were
could be discarded, no adequate explanation can yet be of- performed.79, 81 In a comparative double-blind placebo con-
fered to explain these differential actions. However, it was trolled study with the 5HT2C/5-HT2A receptor antagonist
speculated that each SSRI enhances the amount of serotonin, and 400 mg. daily of the 5-HT/noradrenaline re-uptake in-
that is 5-hydroxytryptamine (5-HT), differentially and each hibitor nefazodone, nefazodone and placebo did not exert any
SSRI may also act differentially at different places in the ejaculation delay in contrast to a significant delay after 20
central nervous system, thereby, stimulating postsynaptic mg. paroxetine daily and 50 mg. sertraline daily.79 In a
5-HT receptors differentially.11, 12, 93 Moreover, the different similar study the 5-HT2C/5-HT3 receptor antagonist, and
modes of action of SSRIs should further be explained by the noradrenergic and specific serotonergic antidepressant mir-
evaluation of other mechanisms that are potentially involved tazapine did not induce ejaculation delay compared with the
in the mechanism of ejaculation. A likely candidate could be significant delay resulting from 20 mg. paroxetine daily.81 It
the neuropeptide oxytocin, which has shown to be involved in should be emphasized that in these studies in men with
human orgasm.81 premature ejaculation neither antidepressant delayed ejacu-
In a recent animal study the ejaculation delay induced by lation, while for 5-HT2C antagonism shorter ejaculation la-
fluoxetine was reversed by the administration of oxytocin.94 tency was expected. Therefore, further research is encour-
This finding suggests that fluoxetine induced delayed ejacu- aged to elucidate still undiscovered pharmacological
lation is related to inhibited oxytocin release. In another mechanisms underlying the ejaculatory process.
study it was observed that oxytocinergic neurons contain Since to our knowledge the role of 5-HT2A and 5-HT3
serotonergic receptors.95 In addition, in male and female receptors in ejaculation has not yet been identified in male
human orgasms oxytocin is released just before and during rats or humans, the lack of ejaculation delay associated with
orgasm.96, 97 these 5-HT2C receptor blocking drugs suggests that the
Therefore, we suggest that the differential effects of SSR 5-HT2C receptor is specifically involved in human ejacula-
inhibitors and other antidepressants on ejaculation may be tion and indirectly supports our hypothesis of 5-HT2C recep-
related to postsynaptic 5-HT receptors, which have differen- tor hypofunction in men with premature ejaculation.
tial influence on central oxytocinergic neurons intimately However, the exact identification of the specific 5-HT recep-
involved in the ejaculation process.81 Further studies are tor subtypes involved in premature ejaculation is only possi-
needed to investigate the presumed and intriguing role of ble by administering subtype selective 5-HT2C or 5-HT1A
oxytocin in antidepressant induced delayed ejaculation. receptor ligands. Unfortunately these agents are not yet
available for human use.
ANIMAL STUDIES
NEUROANATOMY
In contrast to the prevailing psychological approach to
premature ejaculation, neuroscientists were already investi- Most knowledge of the functional neuroanatomy of ejacu-
gating the role of central serotonin and dopamine neuro- lation is derived from male rat studies. In regard to male rat
transmission in ejaculation in the 1970s. However, the in- copulatory behavior one must distinguish among the brain,
triguing findings of basic neurosciences were hardly brainstem and spinal cord regions that become activated
integrated with clinical practice in those years. What we before and after ejaculation, when sensory information re-
have learned to date in animal studies is that serotonin 5-HT turns from the genitals (fig. 1). The medial preoptic area in
receptors are involved in the ejaculatory process. In addition, the rostral hypothalamus and nucleus paragigantocellularis
using highly selective 5-HT receptor agonists and antago- in the ventral medulla101, 102 are suggested to have impor-
2362 NEUROBIOLOGICAL APPROACH TO PREMATURE EJACULATION
FIG. 1. Central nervous system areas involved before, during and after ejaculation. Somatosensory fibers reach sensory cortex. Efferent
pathways run from hypothalamus down to sacral spinal cord and genitals. After ejaculation information is returned from genitals to various
areas in cerebrum. MEApd, posterodorsal medial amygdala. BNSTpm, posteromedial bed nucleus of stria terminalis. MPOA, medial preoptic
area. SPFp, medial parvicellular subparafascicular nucleus of thalamus. nPGi, nucleus paragigantocellularis.
tant roles in the process leading toward ejaculation. poorly understood. Interestingly a neurophysiological study
Electrical stimulation of the medial preoptic area promotes showed shorter latencies and greater amplitudes of somato-
ejaculation.103 It is hypothesized that ejaculation is tonically sensory evoked potentials from the glans penis in men with
inhibited by serotonergic pathways descending from the nu- lifelong premature ejaculation compared with matched nor-
cleus paragigantocellularis to the lumbosacral motor nuclei. mal controls.108 This series and those of sacral evoked poten-
The current hypothesis is that the nucleus paragigantocellu- tial41, 42, 109 suggest that men with premature ejaculation
laris is inhibited by inhibitory stimuli from the medial pre- have greater cortical representation of sensory stimuli from
optic area. Disinhibition of the nucleus paragigantocellularis the glans penis than normal controls. However, such a larger
is supposed to lead to ejaculation. The discovery of serotoner- somatosensory cortical representation has not yet been iden-
gic neurons in the nucleus paragigantocellularis and the tified. Brain imaging, for example positron emission tomog-
well-known ejaculation delay induced by serotonergic anti- raphy, is required in humans to unravel the neural sub-
depressants suggests an action of the SSRIs inhibitors on the strate, particularly the cortical substrate, of the ejaculatory
nucleus paragigantocellularis. However, to our knowledge process in men. Imaging may contribute to better under-
the precise location in the central nervous system on which standing of which part of the circuitry is disturbed in prema-
SSRIs inhibitors act to inhibit ejaculation has yet not been ture ejaculation.
identified.
On the other hand, brain areas activated as a result of 1 or
more ejaculations have been observed in several mam- EMPIRICAL OPERATIONAL DEFINITION OF PREMATURE
EJACULATION
mals.104 Using expression of the immediate early gene c-fos
as a marker for neural activity in male rats Coolen et al The American Psychiatric Association defines premature
detected distinct ejaculation related neural activation in sev- ejaculation as “persistent or recurrent ejaculation with min-
eral brain regions after ejaculation, namely the posterome- imal sexual stimulation before, upon, or shortly after pene-
dial bed nucleus of the stria terminalis, a lateral subarea of tration and before the person wishes it.”110 Until recently
the posterodorsal medial amygdala, and the medial parvicel- any scientific basis for the DSM-IV definition was lacking.
lular subparafascicular nucleus of the thalamus.105–107 All For instance, the meaning of persistent, recurrent, minimal
available evidence suggests that ascending fibers from the and shortly after is vague and certainly needs further qual-
spinal cord, which signal ejaculation, activate the medial ification. Therefore, our group introduced a stopwatch
parvicellular subparafascicular nucleus and the other brain method to determine an empirically operational definition in
areas mentioned. Since it has been shown that this cluster of a study including 110 consecutively enrolled men with life-
activated neurons are extensively interconnected, mostly re- long premature ejaculation.111 In this study the visibility of
ciprocally,107 a complete brain circuit related to ejaculation stopwatch assessments by female partners as well as the
seems to be involved. The functional significance of this ejac- outcome was studied after instructing the couples to use a
ulation subcircuit is still poorly understood but it may well be stopwatch at home during each coitus for 4 weeks (fig. 2).
that these areas have a role in satiety and, thus, in mediating This method was accepted and well performed by all couples
the post-ejaculatory interval. included in this study. Of these men 90% ejaculated within 1
These and many other animal studies have clearly shown minute of intromission, including 80% who ejaculated within
the existence of a neural circuitry for ejaculation in mam- 30 seconds. The age of the men and duration of the relation-
mals. This neural circuitry is partly elucidated but still ship were not correlated with ejaculation time. According to
NEUROBIOLOGICAL APPROACH TO PREMATURE EJACULATION 2363
these data we have shown that ejaculation time can be mon- relatives about ejaculation latency. These 14 men reported a
itored with a stopwatch. In cases of premature ejaculation it total of 11 first degree male relatives with information avail-
empirically appeared that ejaculation time was less than 1 able for direct personal interview. In fact, 10 relatives ful-
minute in more than 90% of episodes of sexual intercourse filled our strict defined criterion of an ejaculation time of 1
independent of age and the duration of relationship in those minute or less. In this small select group of men the calcu-
men who complained of lifelong premature ejaculation. Thus, lated risk of having a first relative with premature ejacula-
assessment by stopwatch revealed that premature ejacula- tion was 91% (CI 59 to 99). Therefore, the odds of family
tion is a matter of seconds and not minutes.2, 111 To our occurrence is much higher than the suggested population
knowledge that study is the first stopwatch study in a white prevalence rate of 4% to 39%. Moreover, the high odds ratio
Western European cohort. From a clinical point of view other indicates a familiar occurrence of the syndrome far higher
patient populations with complaints of rapid ejaculation than of chance alone. Based on this preliminary observation
should be investigated in regard to cultural differences and the influence of genetics formerly noted by Schapiro7 gains
associated behavior. For example, do men in other countries substantial credibility.
or cultures consider that they ejaculate prematurely when
they ejaculate within 4 minutes?
BIOLOGICAL VARIATION OF EJACULATION LATENCY TIME
FIG. 2. Intravaginal ejaculation latency time (IELT) measured with stopwatch in 110 men with lifelong premature ejaculation, of whom
90% ejaculated within 1 minute after vaginal penetration, including 80% within 30 seconds. Reprinted with permission.111
2364 NEUROBIOLOGICAL APPROACH TO PREMATURE EJACULATION
may become beneficial to support the man or couple in coping throughout their lifetime the speed of ejaculation had re-
with premature ejaculation. Therefore, psychology is a sec- mained as rapid as at the first sexual contacts in puberty and
ondary problem rather than the primary cause of premature adolescence, 23% reported that it had even become gradually
ejaculation. more rapid with aging and only 1% reported that it had
become slower.111 According to these data it is questionable
EJACULATION THRESHOLD HYPOTHESIS whether the fixed rapidity and even paradoxical shortening
of ejaculation latency time with aging should be considered
To understand the suggested biological variation of intra-
part of the pathogenetic process of premature ejaculation. We
vaginal ejaculation latency time in relation to the serotoner-
gic system, delaying effects of SSRIs and suggested genetics think of the phenomenon of rapid ejaculation as a biological
Waldinger and Olivier have proposed the existence of an variation and its paradoxical or fixed course through life as
intravaginal ejaculation latency time threshold.12 When pathological. Chronic premature ejaculation appears to be
there is a low threshold set point men can only sustain low the clinical syndrome of primary (lifelong) premature ejacu-
sexual arousal before ejaculation. Whatever these men do or lation. To date there is no real cure for lifelong premature
fantasize during intercourse any control of ejaculation re- ejaculation. Drugs may alleviate symptoms but only while
mains marginal and they ejaculate easily even when they are they are being administered.
not fully aroused. The assumption that men with premature
ejaculation ejaculate at lower levels of sexual arousal was
demonstrated by Spiess et al in a study comparing 10 men PREMATURE EJACULATION AND ERECTILE DYSFUNCTION
with premature ejaculation (ejaculation at less than 2 min- Some men with premature ejaculation may express their
utes) and 14 controls (ejaculation at more than 3 minutes) by complaint as an erectile disorder since penile detumescence
physiological (penis circumference) and self-report measures after ejaculation occurs rapidly. On the other hand, erectile
of sexual arousal.32 The low threshold is assumed to be dysfunction may be superimposed on lifelong existing prema-
associated with low 5-HT neurotransmission and probably ture ejaculation due to the efforts of these men to minimize
hypofunction of the 5-HT2C receptor, as mentioned. sexual excitement or to general causes of erectile dysfunc-
When there is a higher set point men experience more tion. One may wonder whether premature ejaculation is as-
control over ejaculation time. They can sustain more sexual sociated with an increased neurobiological risk for erectile
arousal before ejaculating. In these men 5-HT neurotrans- dysfunction. To our knowledge there is no evidence for such
mission varies around a normal or average level and 5-HT2C an associated risk to date. To study such risk longitudinal
receptor functions normally. To our knowledge the mean and prospective studies in men with premature ejaculation and
range values of the set points considered normal or average matched controls are necessary but they have not yet been
are not known. When there is a high or very high set point, performed.
men may experience difficulty in ejaculating or cannot It must be emphasized that the majority of men with
achieve ejaculation even when fully aroused sexually. At a lifelong premature ejaculation do not suffer from concomi-
high set point 5-HT neurotransmission is supposed to be tant erectile difficulties. Most of these men do not seek help
increased and/or 5-HT2C receptor sensitivity is enhanced. due to rapid ejaculation. However, since some men start to
According to this threshold hypothesis it appears that the seek help after they have erectile difficulties, it may bias the
level of 5-HT2C receptor activation determines the set point population with premature ejaculation that presents to a
and associated ejaculation latency time in an individual. In urology clinic.
men with premature ejaculation or any man on serotonergic In our studies we recruited men with premature ejacula-
antidepressants SSRIs and clomipramine activate 5-HT2C tion by advertisement. Of the respondents 75% had never
receptor and, therefore, change the set point to a higher level, sought help for premature ejaculation, mostly due to embar-
leading to a delay in ejaculation. The effects of SSRIs on the rassment, and 95% did not have erectile difficulties.111 In
set point appear to be individually determined since some contrast, many of these men reported rapid achievement of
men respond with an intense delay, while others only expe- erection. In 1943 Schapiro called this phenomenon erectio
rience slight delay at the same dose of the drug. Moreover, praecox7 but this term has never been quoted or referred to in
cessation of treatment results in uniform resetting of the set the literature. It may be speculated that aside from its rela-
point within 3 to 5 days to the lower, individually determined tionship to the central serotonergic system premature ejacu-
reference level, which is assumed to be genetically deter- lation is also related to increased oxytocin production. A
mined. speculated increase in oxytocin release may be related to
It is speculated that the threshold is mediated by serotonin ejaculatio praecox with erectio praecox. Animal studies show
neurotransmission and 5-HT receptors in the brainstem93 or that oxytocin stimulates ejaculation118, 119 and is a potent
spinal cord and may consist of serotonergic fibers that inhibit inducer of penile erection.120
neurons that convey somatosensory information from the SSRIs are well known for delaying ejaculation and to a
genitals. It is suggested that SSRIs enhance the inhibitory lesser extent for inducing erectile difficulties and the loss of
effects of these serotonergic neurons. However, the cerebral sexual desire. The precise mechanism by which SSRIs inter-
cortex may also mediate inhibitory impulses but currently fere with erectile function is not clear. The various SSRI
this finding has not been reported. In addition to the sug- treatment studies of premature ejaculation are characterized
gested SSRI induced increased inhibition of sensory input, by a low incidence of erectile difficulties. However, in clinical
SSRIs may also delay ejaculation by interfering with spinal practice SSRI treatment may give rise to complaints of
cord motoneurons of peripheral neurons that inhibit the in- slightly decreased rigidity of the erect penis.
ternal genitals. Further studies are needed to unravel this The proved effectiveness of SSRIs for serotonergic related
important and intriguing question.
disorders, such as depression, anxiety disorders, obsessive-
compulsive disorder and increased impulsivity, may raise the
COURSE OF RAPIDITY
question whether men with premature ejaculation are at risk
It is generally believed that aging delays ejaculation. This for these disorders. Our studies using a clinical interview and
assumption may be true in men with a normal or average the Symptom Check List with 90 items have repeatedly and
ejaculation time but to our knowledge it has never been clearly indicated that men with lifelong premature ejacula-
investigated in men with premature ejaculation. In a stop- tion are generally mentally and physically healthy, as
watch study of 110 consecutively enrolled men 18 to 65 years healthy as the average individual in the age matched general
old with lifelong premature ejaculation 76% reported that nonpsychiatric male population.
NEUROBIOLOGICAL APPROACH TO PREMATURE EJACULATION 2365
BEHAVIORAL THERAPY AND THE NEUROBIOLOGICAL 10. Waldinger, M. D. and Hengeveld, M. W.: Neuroseksuologie en
APPROACH seksuele psychofarmacologie. Tijdschr Psychiatr, 8: 585, 2000
Controversy over the most appropriate therapeutic ap- 11. Olivier, B., van Oorschot, R. and Waldinger, M. D.: Serotonin,
proach is nourished by the confusing use of surrogate and serotonergic receptors, selective serotonin reuptake inhibi-
clinically relevant end points when interpreting treatment tors and sexual behaviour. Int Clin Psychopharmacol, suppl.,
13: s9, 1998
results. For example, surrogate end points such as thrusting
12. Waldinger, M. D. and Olivier, B.: Selective serotonin reuptake
with multiple stops must be distinguished from clinically inhibitors (SSRIs) and sexual side effects: differences in
relevant ongoing successful thrusting. In contrast to the ben- delaying ejaculation. In: Fluvoxamine: Established and
eficial clinical effects of pharmacotherapy, clinical effects as a Emerging Roles in Psychiatric Disorders. Advances in
result of behavioral therapy still lack well designed investi- Preclinical and Clinical Psychiatry. Edited by E. Sacchetti
gation. Further behavioral studies of the squeeze technique and P. Spano. Milan: Excerpta Medica, vol. 1, pp. 117–130,
with baseline and prospective stopwatch and intravaginal 2000
ejaculation latency time assessment are imperative. The first 13. Waldinger, M. D. and Olivier, B.: Hersenonderzoek en farma-
choice of treatment for premature ejaculation is psychophar- cologie: serotonine, seks en agressie. In: Het Brein Belicht:
macotherapy. It should be underlined that couples should be Opstellen over Niet-Aangeboren Hersenletsel. Edited by
M. H. J. Wolters-Schweitzer and C. L. Beuger. Utrecht:
briefly informed about current knowledge on the neurobio-
Uitgeverij Lemma, pp. 55– 63, 2001
logical approach to premature ejaculation. On the other 14. Waldinger, M. D., Rietschel, M., Nothen, M. M., Hengeveld,
hand, psychotherapy is only indicated in men or couples who M. W. and Olivier, B.: Familial occurrence of primary prema-
cannot cope with or cannot accept rapid ejaculation.1 In con- ture ejaculation. Psychiatr Genet, 8: 37, 1998
trast to the classic psychological view, the purpose of psy- 15. St. Lawrence, J. S. and Madakasira, S.: Evaluation and treat-
chodynamic or cognitive psychotherapy is not to learn how to ment of premature ejaculation: a critical review. Int
delay ejaculation, but rather how to cope with rapid ejacula- J Psychiatr Med, 22: 77, 1992
tion.1 16. Semans, J. H.: Premature ejaculation: new approach. South
Med J, 49: 353, 1956
17. Masters, W. H., Johnson, V. E.: Human Sexual Inadequacy.
CONCLUSIONS Boston: Little, Brown & Co., 1970
Neurobiological research in the last decade has shown that 18. Rowland, D. L., Haensel, S. M., Blom, J. H. M. and Slob, A. K.:
the classic psychological view of lifelong premature ejacula- Penile sensitivity in men with premature ejaculation and
erectile dysfunction. J Sex Marital Ther, 19: 189, 1993
tion is no longer tenable. In contrast to the behavioristic
19. Xin, Z. C., Chung, W. S., Choi, Y. D., Seong, D. H., Choi, Y. J.
view, the neurobiological approach has gained support be- and Choi, H. K.: Penile sensitivity in patients with primary
cause of clinical and preclinical based evidence. According to premature ejaculation. J Urol, 156: 979, 1996
the latter view premature ejaculation should be considered 20. Paick, J. S., Jeong, H. and Park, M. S.: Penile sensitivity in men
part of normally distributed ejaculation latency time in the with premature ejaculation. Int J Impot Res, 10: 247, 1998
general male population independent of the natural course of 21. Ince, L.: Behavior modification of sexual disorders. Am J
aging induced ejaculation delay. Paradoxically ejaculation Psychother, 17: 446, 1973
latency remains similar or even becomes more rapid with 22. Wish, P.: The use of imagery-based techniques in the treatment
aging. Rapid ejaculation seems to be related to disturbed or of sexual dysfunction. Couns Psychol, 5: 52, 1975
maladaptive 5-HT2C receptor properties in specific brain 23. Mosher, D. L.: Awareness in Gestalt sex therapy. J Sex Marital
Ther, 5: 41, 1979
areas that can be restored by serotonergic agents. Cognitive
24. Waltzlawick, P., Weakland, J. H. and Fisch, R.: Change:
and emotional influences certainly interact with ejaculation Principles of Problem Formation and Problem Resolution.
but psychological disturbances must be considered a second- New York: Norton Publishing, 1974
ary reaction. Based on various methodologically well de- 25. Zeiss, R. A., Christensen, A. and Levine, A. G.: Treatment for
signed studies psychopharmacotherapy should be acknowl- premature ejaculation through male-only groups. J Sex
edged as primary treatment.121 A brief education on the new Marital Ther, 4: 139, 1978
neurobiological knowledge should accompany the prescrip- 26. Kaplan, H. S., Kohl, R. N., Pomeroy, W. B., Offit, A. K. and
tion of drugs. Although paroxetine and clomipramine are Hogan, B.: Group treatment of premature ejaculation. Arch
highly efficacious for delaying ejaculation, further develop- Sex Behav, 3: 443, 1974
ment of more rapidly acting drugs would certainly benefit 27. Lowe, C. J. and Mikulas, W. L.: Use of written material in
learning self control of premature ejaculation. Psychol Rep,
modern patient care.
37: 295, 1975
Drs. Dave H. Schweitzer and Berend Olivier reviewed the 28. De Amicis, L. A., Goldberg, D. C., LoPiccolo, J., Friedman, J.
manuscript. and Davies, L.: Clinical follow-up of couples treated for sexual
dysfunction. Arch Sex Behav, 14: 467, 1985
29. Hawton, K. and Catalan, J.: Prognostic factors in sex therapy.
REFERENCES
Behav Res Ther, 24: 377, 1986
1. Waldinger, M. D.: Klaar is Kees: Een Nieuwe Visie op Vroegtijdige 30. Kaplan, H. S.: The New Sex Therapy: Active Treatment of
Zaadlozing. Amsterdam: Uitgeverij de Arbeiderspers, 1999 Sexual Dysfunctions. New York: Brunner/Mazel, 1974
2. Waldinger, M. D.: When Seconds Count. Selective Serotonin 31. Cooper, A. J. and Magnus, R. V.: A clinical trial of the beta
Reuptake Inhibitors and Ejaculation. Thesis, Utrecht, The blocker propranolol in premature ejaculation. J Psychosom
Netherlands, chapt. 1, p. 11, 1997 Res, 28: 331, 1984
3. Gross, S.: Practical Treatise on Impotence and Sterility. 32. Spiess, W. F., Geer, J. H. and O’Donohue, W. T.: Premature
Edinburgh: Y. J. Pentland, 1887 ejaculation: investigation of factors in ejaculatory latency.
4. von Krafft-Ebing, R. F.: Psychopathia Sexualis, 11th ed. J Abnorm Psychol, 93: 242, 1984
Stuttgart: Publishing Hause Enke, 1901 33. Strassberg, D. S., Mahoney, J. M., Schaugaard, M. and Hale,
5. Abraham, K.: Ueber Ejaculatio Praecox. Zeitschr Aerztl V. E.: The role of anxiety in premature ejaculation: a psycho-
Psychoanal, 4: 171, 1917 physiological model. Arch Sex Behav, 19: 251, 1990
6. Stekel, W.: Impotence in the Male. New York: Liveright 34. Obler, M.: Systematic desensitisation in sexual disorders.
Publishing, vol. 2, 1927 J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatr, 4: 93, 1973
7. Schapiro, B.: Premature ejaculation: a review of 1130 cases. 35. Strassberg, D. S., Kelly, M. P., Carroll, C. and Kircher, J. C.:
J Urol, 50: 374, 1943 The psychophysiological nature of premature ejaculation.
8. Godpodinoff, M. L.: Premature ejaculation: clinical subgroups Arch Sex Behav, 16: 327, 1987
and etiology. J Sex Marital Ther, 15: 130, 1989 36. LoPiccolo, J.: Direct treatment of sexual dysfunction in the
9. Waldinger, M. D.: Use of psychoactive agents in the treatment couple. In: Handbook of Sexology: Selected Syndromes and
of sexual dysfunction CNS Drugs, 6: 204, 1996 Therapy. Edited by J. Money and H. Musaph. New York:
2366 NEUROBIOLOGICAL APPROACH TO PREMATURE EJACULATION