Chapter
BASIC TECHNIQUES OF
LEGISLATIVE DRAFTING
GENERAL
Good legislative drafting is an art rather than a science and the constraint
imposed by the drafting environment many a times present situation
that require deviation from accepted drafting conventions. But as a
general rule the legislative drafter must follow accepted norms while
drafting a legislation. Legislative drafting is, therefore, a skill acquired
by the drafter through years of experience obtained through painstaking
labour and work. This skill consists in using a proper language which
establish an instant rapport with the people or citizen who are the
subject-matter of the legislation. It is the paramount duty of the drafter
to see that the legislative intent and policy is easily understood by the
citizen and common man.
The drafter is an important link between the Executive Government and
the Legislature or Parliamenc of the country. The legislation is the
document which signifies the policies of the Government in power and
once assented to by the Head of the State becomes the law of the land
till it ig modified, changed or repealed by successive Governments
through Legislature. The drafter’s job is, therefore, to transmit the
legislative policies of the Executive into the draft legislation which is
then introduced in Parliament for discussion and debate and passed as
an Act, The drafter has, therefore, to take utmost care in drafting the
legislation and has to take into account the Constitution of the country,
Bill of Rights or the provisions relating to the fundamental rights, the
general laws of the land and socio-economic aspirations of the society
for which the law is being enacted. The drafter should never forget the
fact that the draft once it becomes an Act, is interpreted by various bodies
a
Scanned with CamScannerand individuals such as lawyers, courts, international institutions,
Parliamentary committees and other legal fora. In order to achieve the
excellence that is needed from him the drafter must equip himself with
certain necessary tools and learn certain techniques to produce a draft
legislation which will be acclaimed by Parliament, the Government and
the society for whom the legislation is made.
The drafter before undertaking the task of preparing the draft
legislation—
(1) must acquire thorough knowledge of the Constitutional Law
of the country;
(2) should have complete familiarity with the Statute Book of the
country;
(3) must be well versed in the precedents with reference to
anatomy of financial, corporate or socio-economic legislation;
(4) should get himself acquainted with the Interpretation Acts (The
benefits of shortening particular enactment by general
interpretation provisions of the Interpretation Act or the General
Clauses Act can not be lost sight of by the drafter and for
appropriate and definite interpretation of the provisions of the
statute he should always make use of the country’s
Interpretation Act)';
(5) should give meticulous attention to details and a clear
systematic approach to the problem at hand;
(6) must acquire an analytical mind which is very much essential
to good drafting;
(7) must always be prepared to accept the criticism with tolerance
and good humour and must be ready to modify and improve
the legislation to meet genuine criticism;
(8) should undertake, before drafting of legislation, extensive
research on the subject and should understand the scope of
the problems with which he has to deal with.
As already stated above the drafter must take into consideration the
judicial decisions on the subject, specially—
(a) ambiguities revealed by judicial decisions on the analogous
provisions so that these ambiguities are removed while drafting
the intended legislation;
Scanned with CamScanner(b) settled interpretation of words and expressions used in the
existing legislation, by the courts and follow them to minimise
the litigation and improve the clarity of the legislation.
Where necessary the drafter must provide new interpretations for words
and expressions to override the judicial decisions where narrow
interpretation is given.
Scanned with CamScanner