Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SFO Principles of REACH - Airport PDF
SFO Principles of REACH - Airport PDF
SFO Principles of REACH - Airport PDF
The Principles of
R.E. A.C.H.
REVENUE ENHANCEMENT AND CUSTOMER HOSPITALITY
A majority of the document is devoted to recognizing and highlighting the values which
are important to the airport. It applies these values and lessons about different types of
customers to areas found in every terminal which are referred to as ‘journey moments.’ At
each journey moment, current and future trends are addressed with the goal of ensuring
that designers are thinking about the evolution of airport design and customer experience.
This document is meant to orient the reader to the goals and aspirations of SFO. It is not
a rigid set of guidelines nor a prescriptive design direction but rather, an informational
and inspirational perspective that seeks to inform designers and consultants about SFO’s
unique point of view, existing conditions, and dynamic passenger demographics.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
168 Plazas
180
Concourse
Concessions
42
52
Locality & Sense of Place
Revenue Generation
240 Bibliography
62 Convenience & Hospitality 242 Footnotes
112 Sustainability
132 Technology
ALSO KNOWN AS T1, includes Boarding Area B (B/A B) and T2, also known as Boarding Area D (B/A D). T3, includes Boarding Area E (B/A E) and ITB, includes Boarding Area A (B/A A) and
Boarding Area C (B/A C) Originally known as the “Central Terminal,” Boarding Area F (B/A F). Also known as the Boarding Area G (B/A G). The BART stop is
it used to be SFO’s main airport terminal. United Airlines hub. located adjacent to Boarding Area G.
TOTAL NUMBER 32 (23 gates in B/A B, 9 gates in B/A C) 14 36 (9 gates in B/A E, 25 gates in B/A F) 28 (13 gates in B/A A, 15 gates in B/A G)
OF GATES
TOTAL PASSENGERS 5.4 million passengers 3.5 million passengers 7.7 million passengers 5.5 million passengers
IN 2012
TOTAL REVENUE $53 million $49 million $98 million $165 million
GENERATED IN 2012
1 BACKGROUND
INFORMATION 2 THE PASSENGER
EXPERIENCE 3 SFO
VALUES 4 JOURNEY
MOMENTS
Stages of the
1 2 3
SFO VISION LOCALITY &
A narrative which explains SFO’s vision, focusing in Passenger Journey SENSE OF PLACE
particular on SFO’s aspiration to become the top airport APPROACH TICKETING CHECKPOINT
in customer satisfaction and provide passengers with the
REVENUE
best possible airport experience. DEPARTING
PASSENGERS
ARRIVING
PASSENGERS
GENERATION
4 5 6
FIVE YEAR STRATEGY RECOMPOSE PLAZAS CONCOURSE
CONVENIENCE &
In 2011 SFO developed a 5-year strategy and this is the
HOSPITALITY
summary of that strategy. CONNECTING
PASSENGERS 7 8 9
WAYFINDING CONCESSIONS WAITING PLAY AREAS
WHAT IS R.E.A.C.H.?
& LOUNGE
A breakdown of The Principles of R.E.A.C.H
Passenger Typologies
10 11 12
TIME &
SFO IN NUMBERS EFFICIENCY
To gain a better understanding of SFO, this is a RESTROOMS PASSENGER ARTS & EXHIBITS
compilation of data about the various terminals, from LEISURE ASSISTED AMENITIES
ARTS &
total area to amount of revenue generated. PASSENGERS PASSENGERS CULTURE
13 14 15
HEALTH & MEET & GREET BAGGAGE CLAIM ARRIVALS
WELLBEING CURBSIDE
BUSINESS UNIQUE
PASSENGERS PASSENGERS
SUSTAINABILITY
16
CONNECTORS &
LOOK TUNNELS
FAMILY
& FEEL
PASSENGERS
TECHNOLOGY
SFO has the opportunity to connect passengers with the culturally rich aspects of
San Francisco. While the city has well-established landmarks, it is also important
to look at what makes San Francisco truly unique: the technology, the cuisine, the
appreciation of the outdoors and the neighborhoods. SFO strives to integrate a
local sense of place and reflect a truly authentic experience of the Bay Area.
SFO truly cares about the customer experience and is committed to delivering a
unique experience for every passenger.
Strategy
for the airport. As a result, the airport assembled task forces
to help achieve the goals and SFO’s overall future aspiration,
“Reaching for #1.”
1 Customer/
Passenger 2 Airlines/
Aircraft/
Routes 3 Non-Airline
Revenue 4 Employees &
Organization 5 Environmental
Sustainability 6 Safety/
Security 7 Infrastructure 8 External
Relations
Be ranked #1 by passengers in Ensure SFO can meet passenger As part of maintaining average Be ranked one of the Bay Area’s Be one of the first airports to To be an airport innovative As part of maintaining average Support awareness among
customer satisfaction as a U.S. traffic growth in the next five years cost per enplaned passenger below best employers in San Francisco mitigate its carbon footprint and leader in safety and security cost per enplaned passenger below government entities of SFO as
international gateway airport by and improve airlines’ on time $18.90, increase non-airline Business Times’ annual list. maintain it thereafter. and implement at least two $18.90, strategically invest in a successful enterprise that is
two industry specific surveys. arrival performance. revenues & per passenger spending. new industry leading security capital projects. well managed and a valuable
Be known for innovation, Continue to reduce baseline programs in the next five years. asset to San Francisco and the
Be considered a world-class airport Ensure competitive air service. expertise, and management Greenhouse Gas emissions from Minimize overall life cycle Bay Area communities.
by customers. excellence in the aviation industry. SFO–controlled operations. Maintain SFO’s airfield in costs of facilities.
Increase current international as safe as possible condition Develop and maintain productive
Be nimble about meeting passenger traffic. Increase solid waste recycling rate. through the use of technology, Maintain the airport’s relationships with government
passenger demands and needs for procedures, inspection and infrastructure in agencies and local cities & counties.
services. continual evaluation of airfield optimal condition.
Maintain average cost per Achieve LEED Gold certification in
best practices. Increase local business
enplaned passenger below $18.90 all new buildings.
Be the airport of choice for in constant fiscal year 07-08 Continue to invest in capital participation with SFO.
premium passengers. dollars in order to maintain and Be the least vulnerable US projects that make the airport
attract airline service. airport to terrorist activity environmentally sustainable. Develop and maintain a model
and possess the best integrated employment development program
Have the most efficient airport
response capability. for the benefit of the communities
ground transportation system in Implement projects that will
the country. generate net revenue to the extent that SFO serves.
Coordinate the sharing of possible, while meeting the
information and planning airport’s mission.
among all federal and local
law enforcement agencies
to ensure all the dots are
continually connected.
SFO in
TERMINAL 3 TERMINAL 1
Numbers
The San Francisco International Airport
is made up of four terminals, each with its
INTERNATIONAL own distinct personality. Terminals 1,2,
and 3 service domestic passengers while the
TERMINAL International Terminal services primarily
International passengers. All terminals are
connected by walkways and AirTrain. Bay Area
Rapid Transit (BART) sits adjacent to the the
International Terminal.
ALSO KNOWN AS 2012 TOTAL PASSENGERS YELP RATING ALSO KNOWN AS 2012 TOTAL PASSENGERS YELP RATING
A Mixed Bag
Terminal,” it used to function as
1954
TOTAL NUMBER OF GATES TOTAL CONCESSIONS AREA TOTAL CONCESSIONS AREA innovative approaches to passenger
natural light and its granite columns amenities makes T2 a favorite
32 23 gates in B/A B
9 gates in B/A C 27,258 ft 2 give the terminal a more classic feel.
It serves more passengers per square 29,286 ft2 place to fly to and and from. From
interactive children’s play areas
foot than any other terminal. The TOTAL NUMBER OF GATES designed with local artists to excellent
terminal feels ready for an update.
14
concessions and expanded, high end
restroom facilities, T2 has had a real
impact on setting the standard for
premium passenger experience.
ALSO KNOWN AS 2012 TOTAL PASSENGERS YELP RATING ALSO KNOWN AS 2012 TOTAL PASSENGERS YELP RATING
Active &
adjacent to Boarding Area G.
DATE OPENED
$93 million $165 million Iconic &
Businesslike
DATE OPENED
1979 TOTAL CONCESSIONS AREA 2000 TOTAL CONCESSIONS AREA
Dramatic
One of the busiest terminals, it’s
87,775 ft
The International Terminal in the
TOTAL NUMBER OF GATES
54,596 ft 2 not surprising that this terminal is
TOTAL NUMBER OF GATES
2 Main Hall has the greatest volume of all
36
often crowded. Dressed in blues and terminals, with very tall ceilings. Most
9 gates in B/A E
28
grays, it has a more traditional feel of the space is compartmentalized as the
18 gates in B/A F 13 gates in A
than the rest of the terminals. 15 gates in G hold rooms are on the Arrivals level and
9 Frontal Gates
the concessions are on the Departure level.
$165M 87K
44M
DOMESTIC 7.7M
PASSENGERS T3
$14 22
$98M 54K $12 60 T2
T3
$53M
$50M 29K
27K
3.5M
T2
4.6M $9 86
INTERNATIONAL 5.4M
PASSENGERS T1 T1
ITB T1 T2 T3 ITB T1 T2 T3
REVENUE GENERATED IN FT DEVOTED TO CONCESSIONS
2
TOTAL PASSENGERS IN 2012 PASSENGERS PER DOLLARS SPENT
EACH TERMINAL IN 2012 IN EACH TERMINAL TERMINAL IN 2012 PER EMPLANED PASSENGER
In 2012, the International Terminal ...and has the greatest area dedicated However, SFO primarily ...and of its domestic ...but Terminal 2
generated the most revenue... to concessions. services domestic terminals, Terminal 3 generates the greatest
passengers... had the highest number spend per domestic
of passengers... passenger.
There are many different types of passengers that travel through the
airport. In light of this, interviews were conducted at SFO regarding the
passenger experience. Using this data, five major passenger typologies
were identified as follows: Leisure, Business, Family, Assisted and Unique
Passengers. Their fictional journeys are described in the following pages in
order to help identify areas of opportunity for SFO.
24 T H E PR I NCI PL E S OF R .E . A .C .H. 25
Different Types
of Travel
The passenger journey is comprised of
three major kinds of airport experiences:
departing, connecting and arriving. While
all passengers will depart and arrive, not all
will connect. Additionally some passengers
might experience SFO from only one of the
vantage points.
Departing and Connecting Passengers
typically spend the longest time at the
airport and will have greater and more DEPARTING PASSENGER CONNECTING PASSENGER ARRIVING PASSENGER
This is the first sequence of a passenger The shortest of all sequences, the arriving
varied needs than the Arriving Passenger. The main concern for the connecting passenger
experience and likely the one where the is navigation through the airport, particularly passenger usually zips through the airport to
Differences in each of these stages are passenger has the most concerns. The departing if it’s a new location and time is of the essence. the exit as quickly as possible, particularly if
passenger is typically at the airport 1-2 hours in Connecting times can vary as little as a few loved ones are meeting or picking them up.
important to understand as they impact the advance of their boarding time. minutes to several hour. Amenities on the arrivals level should be seen as
overall passenger experience. Anxiety about baggage handling, security, Making wayfinding clear and easy is extremely
an underutilized opportunity. Also consider the
importance of the meet and greet areas for these
delays, and lengthy queues are typically high on important for the connecting passenger who passengers. Basic necessities such as restrooms
the worry list during the departure sequence. is trying to board their next flight quickly. For should not be ignored.
international passengers who may experience
longer layovers due to time zone differences,
having a wide variety of amenities and activities
is important.
1
children and sometimes with grandparents. The type of Keeping track of all members of the group and
PASSENGERS higher frequency during winter and summer breaks. COMMON FRUSTRATIONS:
Dealing with many things at once. Having to juggle
Family passengers responsible for the group are typically
family members and baggage with security and other
more tense than the average leisure traveler as they have to
needs, like bathroom breaks.
Leisure passengers travel for pleasure, which can range TYPICAL NEEDS: corral family members. make sure everything is in order,
from adventure to relaxation. Some people like to travel in Having an enjoyable time and not missing that and see that they all get where they need to be on time.
groups, while others may enjoy more independent travel. flight to somewhere special!
4
Leisure passengers can include retirees, luxury seekers,
ASSISTED
budget travelers, and honeymooners. They can be found in all COMMON FRUSTRATIONS:
terminals and while most begin their journey at SFO, many are Lines are a waste of time. The security line in
PASSENGERS
connecting passengers. According to a survey conducted in particular is a big downer and a source of anxiety
2012, over 40% of passengers flying through SFO are traveling but beyond that, leisure passengers are ready to
for pleasure. have a good time. International travelers may be
frustrated with navigation through an airport
Many leisure passengers are excited to be traveling, but are Passengers with special needs can include customers with TYPICAL NEEDS:
trying to make connecting flights. Another
frequently less experienced fliers and may have even higher physical, hearing, visual or cognitive disabilities, and Getting to and from the boarding area. Orienting to
frustration can be the lack of amenities that
levels of anxiety than other passengers. While this group they often require assistance while traveling. Assisted new areas and locating accessible amenities.
appeal to their interests.
may be more relaxed once past security, their inexperience passengers may be in a wheelchair or have impaired vision
can cause anxiety, especially when navigating the front-end and/or hearing. COMMON FRUSTRATIONS:
experience of arrivals, ticketing and checkpoint. Being singled out due to their disability
There are also passengers with developmental disabilities,
or being unable to navigate independently because
such as autism spectrum disorder. These passengers face
of a lack of ADA facilities can cause frustration
challenges in the entire journey and may have difficulty with
and embarrassment. Assisted passengers may also
2
the screening process.
experience frustration with the extra waiting that
BUSINESS occurs as a result of needing assistance (e.g. waiting
for wheelchair assistance at the gate,
5 UNIQUE
Business passengers account for 33% of the total number of TYPICAL NEEDS:
passengers flying through SFO—a number that has steadily Getting to their destination on time and being able
PASSENGERS
increased over the past three years. to work while traveling.
As technology has become ubiquitous in everyday life, today’s
COMMON FRUSTRATIONS:
business passenger is likely to be connected via varying forms
Not enough outlets available to recharge mobile
of technology while traveling. As a result, airports need to be Unique passengers are those who don’t necessarily fit into TYPICAL NEEDS:
devices. Cramped, noisy seating areas. Business
more connected both in software (e.g. available Wi-Fi, social the other categories. They may require special assistance, Getting to the boarding area without creating
passengers have little patience with anyone or
media, apps and websites) as well as hardware applications not due to any disability, but because of their status a disturbance or too much attention.
anything that impedes the process of getting to
(e.g. adequate power outlets available for passengers). (celebrities or high profile politicians) or because they
their ultimate destination, most of all flight delays. COMMON FRUSTRATIONS:
are traveling with animals. This group can also include
passengers who have phobias of flying, or speak very little Disorientation in a new place, anxiety at not
English, all of which may also require assistance. knowing where to go.
2
THE SAME! HOW DO
WE FIND JANE?
I CAN’T BELIEVE
WE’RE FINALLY OFF! I WONDER IF
APPROACH
1
THERE ARE GOING
TO BE LONG LINES.
Don & Carol take the
airport shuttle to
PLANNING SFO and are dropped WHAT’S THE
FLUSTERED
4
Don, Jane
GOSH, I BROUGHT
5
TOO MUCH SHAMPOO.
WHERE DO WE GO
AFTER THIS?
CHECKPOINT
& Carol
Get in line at the security
RECOMPOSE checkpoint. Take out liquids
Sit down and put shoes to go through x-ray.
back and stuff everything
back into carry-on bags. UNCOMFORTABLE
GLAD TO HAVE A PLACE
AT THE AIRPORT WHERE
RELIEVED
LEISURE PASSENGERS
YOU CAN MEET
THESE PEOPLE DIFFERENT PEOPLE.
ARE REALLY
Don, Jane, and Carol are all in their early 40’s and traveling FRIENDLY.
to Los Cabos for a two week vacation. As leisure passengers,
they’ve waited all year for this vacation and the party starts
PLAZAS &
the minute they’ve left their homes.
6 CONCOURSE
Arrived early enough to
WAITING/
7
have some time to relax.
What They Want Opportunities for SFO GOOD!
LOUNGE HAPPY I JUST WISH
POSITIVE VARIETY Just checking in to THERE WAS SOME
INTERACTION
People make the place and
Consider having a variety
of services and concessions that
make sure we have
the right gate.
OUTDOOR SPACE.
8
having helpful, friendly can appeal to different types of
people around makes all travelers.
NEUTRAL
CONCESSIONS
the difference! Take a look at the different
ENTERTAINMENT
TECHNOLOGY
Add wait time technologies 9 concessions. Go to Cat Cora
for some appetizers and
Being on leisure travel at security checkpoints. look for a fun place to have
a drink.
means they have time and
a desire to be entertained. COMMUNITY SPACE 10 WAITING/ FINALLY!
30 T H E PR I NCI PL E S OF R .E . A .C .H. 31
PASSENGER TYPOLOGIES BUSINESS PASSENGER
THANK GOODNESS
I REMEMBERED TO
2 REALLY GLAD MY
CHECK-IN!
1
COMPANY IS PAYING
IT’S NICE TO APPROACH FOR CLEAR.
KNOW MY CAR
WILL BE HERE
WHEN I GET HOME
Takes a shuttle from
long term parking
3
PLANNING
COMFORTABLE CHECKPOINT
Checks in to flight and
downloads mobile boarding Gets through quickly
pass 24 hours prior. thanks to CLEAR.
ANXIOUS PLEASED
DID I GET
EVERYTHING?
WALLET, WATCH,
PHONE, CHECK 4
RUSHED
PLAZAS 7
Mark is in his early 30’s and works in advertising. He’s GOODNESS I BROUGHT
MY JETPACK.
traveling to Seattle for business and flies there every couple
Checks cell phone for flight
of months. As a frequent flier, he’s got his airport routine UGH, ANOTHER
information. Looks for gate FLIGHT DELAY.
down pat so the only thing that can produce delays in his information displays. CONCESSIONS
journey is the weather.
CONCERNED 6 Buy coffee and look for
CONCOURSE a place to plug in and
What Mark Wants Opportunities for SFO Finds out flight has been
check emails.
32 33
PASSENGER TYPOLOGIES FAMILY PASSENGER 2
WHERE IS
EVERYONE’S CONCOURSE I DON’T KNOW
HOW SINGLE
3
PASSPORT?
Walk down to PARENTS DO THIS...
1
WHAT ARE WE Customs & Border
GOING TO DO FOR
Protection before we
THE NEXT FIVE
HOURS? head to our BAGGAGE
WAITING/ connecting flight CLAIM
LOUNGE IMPATIENT Juggling the two kids
Just arrived from with luggage. Luckily
Vietnam. Have a few there are two of us!
hours before we board our ARE THEY GOING FRUSTRATED
flight to New York. TO MAKE ME THROW
LESS BURDENED
AWAY THE KIDS’
SNACKS? 5
CONNECTORS +
4
Kevin
TUNNELS
I WISH THERE WAS Get kids through the
MORE ROOM. I’M
WORRIED WE ARE
security checkpoint. RESTROOMS
Trying to quiet down the
GOING TO LOSE Need to change
baby who started screaming.
SOMETHING. the baby.
6
IMPATIENT
FAMILY PASSENGER PLEASED
SO HAPPY
Kevin is in his late 40’s and is traveling with his wife and two
kids (one age 4 and the other a newborn) to Vietnam to visit
CHECKPOINT THIS IS
FOR THESE
NURSERIES!
Sit down and put shoes SUCH A
8
family for two weeks. As a family passenger, there is more WHERE’S CIRCUS!
back on kids and self. GATE 45?
stress involved with traveling because there are multiple Stand by luggage while
travelers and everyone has different needs. wife nurses baby in the
mother’s nursery.
7 RESTROOMS
What Kevin Wants Opportunities for SFO PLAZAS &
The kids need to use
CONCERNED
CONCOURSE the restroom again.
KID-FRIENDLY FAMILY NEEDS
Make a beeline for the gate
Just being able to sit still Consider various sizes and OVERWHELMED
to set everything down.
is a treat so having space needs of families when planning
for a group of four to rest out queuing and waiting spaces, WE’RE SO CLOSE
and collect themselves is e.g. stroller sizes, entertainment
important. Also, child- for kids.
friendly areas are a welcome
LOVE THIS. BALANCING THESE
addition that provide TECHNOLOGY CARROT STICKS ON
10
WISH THERE
peace of mind in a busy WERE MORE! MY KNEE IS A LITTLE
Consider integration of DAUNTING
environment, especiallly
technology to enrich the
when there are activities THIS WASN’T THE
9
passenger experience for
to keep the kids distracted
kids and adults. BOARD & 12
DRINK I WAS
THINKING OF.
PLAY AREA WAITING/
during long waits.
TAKEOFF 11 Take the kids to the
play spot so they can
LOUNGE
Find seating for 4,
SECURED BELONGINGS Walk back to hold burn off some energy. get out the snacks,
Not only does Kevin have
to coordinate people, but
room and gather CONCESSIONS sit down and the kids
family. Board first. STOKED
Take Tommy for a walk to start squirming.
also belongings. Keeping
an eye on the bags and READY TO TAKE ON pass the time. Buy juice at FRUSTRATED
making sure everyone has it
THE NEXT PHASE a juice counter.
OF THE JOURNEY
together after security and GLAD THEY HAVE
A KID FRIENDLY
before boarding becomes a HEALTHY OPTIONS
TABLE WOULD
more difficult task. BE NICE!
34 35
PASSENGER TYPOLOGIES UNIQUE PASSENGER I’M FINALLY
VISITING MY I WONDER IF I HAVE 2
1
GRAND DAUGHTER! TO CHECK IN WITH
THE AIRLINE FOR MY
ASSISTANCE?. APPROACH I HOPE THE
3
Take the AirTrain from ASSISTANT IS
Bart to Terminal 1 FRIENDLY TODAY.
PLANNING Ticketing counters
Read through the DOT
New Horizons document. ANXIOUS TICKETING
Call to pre-arrange Check-in baggage at
wheelchair service to the Ticketing. Waits for
aircraft. Get dropped off wheelchair & assistant
at BART in Walnut Creek. to arrive.
NERVOUS
ANXIOUS
I’M GLAD I HAVE
SOME EXTRA HELP
4
GETTING THROUGH
SECURITY.
Roberta EVERYONE IS
RUSHING! 5
CHECKPOINT
Goes to the front of the
line at secuirty. Passes
through with no delay.
RELIEVED
ASSISTED PASSENGER RECOMPOSE
Needs assistance to collect
Roberta is an energetic 67 year-old but needs wheelchair I REALLY
her carry-on bags and find
assistance when walking long distances. Today she is flying her gate.
APPRECIATE HOW
6
ROOMY THESE
to visit her granddaughter in Florida for one week. Though RESTROOMS ARE.
the trip has been planned for several months, being uncertain FLUSTERED
who will assist her at the airport makes Roberta nervous.
I WISH THERE WERE EASY
RESTROOMS FOOD OPTIONS I COULD
What Roberta Wants Opportunities for SFO Arrive with plenty of time
TAKE ON THE FLIGHT.
8
NOW I CAN GET
important that all services TECHNOLOGY EXCITED ABOUT ANNOYED
and spaces are accessible. Consider integrating
private booths with voice
10 GOING TO FLORIDA!
another. She has come to language to either an airline EXCITED Wheeled to the PLEASED
greatly appreciate when or airport representative. boarding area with
she is kept informed of plenty of time to spare.
any changes or obstacles RELIEVED
by someone who is calm,
friendly and informed.
36 37
PASSENGER TYPOLOGIES ASSISTED PASSENGER
READY TO SEE MY
FAMILY AND RELAX
2
1
FOR A FEW DAYS.
I WISH ROCKY
APPROACH DO I HAVE ALL
3
WOULD STOP THE MEDICATION
BARKING. Get dropped off at FOR ROCKY?
the terminal.
PLANNING
Get a ride from a
EMBARRASSED TICKETING
friend to the airport. Check-in baggage.
Normally would carry-
ANXIOUS
on but have dog carrier
to board with.
SCATTERED
THANK GOODNESS
4
ROCKY DOESN’T HAVE
SHOES TO TAKE OFF.
Mitch
OK, NEED TO GET THINGS
TOGETHER QUICKLY SO I CHECKPOINT
CAN ATTEND TO EVERYTHING
Get in line at the security
BEFORE MY FLIGHT.
checkpoint. Struggle with
Rocky and other belongings.
5
OVERWHELMED
8
be the first step in giving difficult or large luggage and
people choices.
10
private areas for public figures.
PHEW, MADE IT.
PRE AND POST BUT ROCKY SEEMS
SECURITY RESTLESS AGAIN.
Having a variety of spaces BOARD & CONCESSIONS
TAKEOFF
available pre- and post-
security and on the arrivals
EXCITED
9 WAITING/
...buying snacks for the flight
and purchasing a magazine.
level is important. Helpful
LOUNGE BEGINNING
areas might be pet relief TO RELAX
areas or different types With just enough time
to spare, arrives at
of concessions.
gate to board.
SLIGHTLY
NERVOUS
38 39
T
hrough interviews and
workshops with SFO employees
and executives, certain values
surfaced as the most important principles
that guide the airport in their goals.
These values form the Value System which
addresses key issues at the airport that
all future design and services should
address. These values surface at every
moment of a passenger’s journey through
the airport and strive to inform not only
programmatic concerns, but conceptual
comforts as well (such as healthy building
design, mental wellbeing, adjacencies
The Value
to the arts, etc.)
System
The airport experience can be stressful Local products and local flavor is
and SFO wants to minimize this stress. Strongly important at the airport as a reflection
tied to Sustainability, Arts & Culture, and of the city. This value permeates the
Locality & Sense of Place. airport experience and, as a result, is
closely linked to nearly every other value
Customers want maximum access to service Having a cohesive look and feel that
in the value system.
and convenience. Having friendly people around reinforces the brand identity of the
can ensure a meaningful and memorable airport is important. Related to Locality
experience. Related to Revenue Generation & Sense of Place and Art & Culture.
and Locality & Sense of Place.
San Francisco is rich in its arts Shopping, dining, and special services are Setting up and encouraging good The Bay Area is known for technology and The transportation industry is centered Wayfinding becomes extremely
and culture. As an added bonus, art all part of the airport experience. Closely practices goes a long way at the airport. SFO should reflect this. Tied to Locality & around time & efficiency. Getting people important when you need to get
has been shown to ease stress. Closely related to Locality & Sense of Place and Related to Locality & Sense of Place, Look & Sense of Place, Convenience & Hospitality, to the right place on time is critical. Closely tied somewhere, and at the airport, everyone
related to Locality & Sense of Place and Convenience & Hospitality. Feel, and Health & Wellbeing. and Time & Efficiency. to Wayfinding and Convenience & Hospitality. is trying to get somewhere. Goes hand
Health & Wellbeing. in hand with Time & Efficiency.
T WHAT KIND OF
o most people, an airport and concentrated activity, the airport Saarinen’s TWA Terminal at JFK singular to the airport experience is
conjures the image of a tends to become its own mini-world and, more recently, the international that once past security, you remain
characterless space, a kind PLACE IS THE and marketplace. It is a transitional airports in East Asia and the Persian there until either boarding a plane
of maze they must try to navigate. In
rare cases, people recall fond airport
AIRPORT? zone from the passenger’s point of
view as well. People going through the
Gulf. More often, airports reflect
a global or cosmopolitan impulse -
or leaving the building all together.
These features tend to be disorienting
experiences: the old Santa Barbara The airport is a highly specialized airport are in-between places and have “gateways to the world” – yet with an but are also necessary and universal
terminal open to fresh air, the green place, fit for a specific purpose. As a left behind for a time their own homes increasing desire to be “local.” to airport design. The question is, on
walls and interesting retail at the hub of transit set apart from the city, and everyday habits. the one hand, how to make the passage
Airports are buildings of considerable
Portland International Airport, the the airport is a place of transition. through these spaces easier and more
Airports are also inherently volume. This aspect of scale paired
museum and resting spaces placed It bridges its own region with the enjoyable and, on the other, how to
innovative, often pushed in that with the complexities of security and
beneath relaxing ambient films world, and while the airport’s sense distinguish SFO from other airports.
direction by the need to keep pace with check-in generate two main kinds of
in Amsterdam’s Schiphol airport. of place is largely informed by the changing business models, aircraft, spaces: knots of high density at check-
In general, however, the airport area to which it belongs, it is like no and operational needs and technology. in, security, gates, and baggage claim,
remains etched in our memory by the place else — except other airports. As a cultural type, they are sometimes and vast corridors that link these and
deprivation of place. Owing to both its isolated location consciously futuristic - as with Eero other crucial journey moments. Also
PROXY,
how to showcase known icons in an
mimicking what already exists.
unexpected or unique way.
HAYES VALLEY, 4 5
SAN FRANCISCO TENANT DESIGN EMOTIONAL DESIGN
Temporary engagement in a By recognizing the efforts that Anticipate the emotional state of the
permanent location Revenue Development has made in passenger at each point in the journey.
balancing national brands while Design a response to these states
partnering with local business, through the filter of your concept as
Hayes Valley has now become a must-do for any visitor to San
consider how the design might be much as possible.
Francisco and has also become the home to a temporary two-
able to take these ideas further.
block project filled with shipping containers called Proxy.
Can the experience of Fort Mason
Proxy allows the city to explore different urban uses such as be translated to the airport
food, art, retail and events while also serving as a transition to environment? How about having
more permanent housing in the future. a pastry from Tartine Bakery on
the grassy hillside of Dolores Park?
The shipping containers currently house a cafe, biergarten, and
Additionally, consider moments
ice cream shop.
between tenant lease spaces to
carve out unique and memorable
experiences. These can support
the existing and evolving tenant
leases such as a variety of seating
environments or places for parents to
relax with their children.
ROBIN
CHIANG
ROLE AT AIRPORT: Member of the DRC, Principal at Robin Chiang and Co.
Revenue Generation
Convenience & Hospitality
Wayfinding
Time & Efficiency
Arts & Culture
Health & Wellbeing
Sustainability
Look & Feel
Technology
A T
s one of the busiest constantly searching for ways to raise he Food and Beverage leases is based on an adjustable and beverage concepts in an airport
international airports in the standard and provide innovative program at SFO is a leader in Minimum Annual Guarantee (MAG) environment. While there remains
the US, SFO has made a solutions that will make SFO unique. its field. True to the nature or tiered percentage rent. Essentially, a conceptual connection between
commitment to providing an excellent For the Revenue Development of San Francisco, the SFO Revenue the greater the sales tenants generate, this food and beverage tenant and
passenger experience which can be team, customer experience is the Development team has prioritized the more rent the tenant pays. Food the overall terminal, it also feels like
tied to the concessions program. number one priority. Getting the working with local businesses, and Beverage rent is set at the initial a unique destination due in part to a
Non-airline revenue generation at passenger onto the plane happily and supporting local community and stage of the competitive process to feeling of authenticity. Early critics
SFO can be broken down into three expeditiously is of utmost importance. bolstering a unique sense of place at have potential companies focus on worried, though, that the market
main categories: Food and Beverage, It is the job of Revenue Development the airport. In 2003, the airport began their proposed concepts, operation, hall model wouldn’t apply to the
Retail, and Services and is overseen to ensure the passenger has what a domestic program that focused on business plan and customer service. airport passenger and expressed
by the Revenue Development group. they need and also provide the type of outreach to the local community in This program has been enormously concern about the location - close
Other revenue generation, such as concessions that make the experience an effort to encourage the presence successful, with revenue increasing by to the security checkpoint and not
parking — SFO’s largest source of exciting, unique and memorable. of more local vendors at SFO. 150% in the first 8 years. within easy gazing distance of gates.
revenue — is overseen by a separate However, Napa Farms continues to
Virtually every Food and Beverage In addition to encouraging more
group, Aviation Management. The outperform other food and beverage
establishment at SFO has a storefront local businesses at SFO, the Revenue
SFO Revenue Development team is concession at SFO - earning, along
in the city of San Francisco. This Development team has also pushed
with Lark Creek Grill, 43% of the total
program also worked with small 'mom innovative food and beverage concepts
revenue generated at T2. This exciting
and pop’ restaurants to establish lease at the airport. Napa Farms Market
outcome reinforces that working with
conditions under which they could and Deli in Terminal 2 is an excellent
local business and taking chances on
flourish. Rent for Food and Beverage case study regarding innovative food
unique concepts pays in the end.
R
etail is more nationally to fill their subleases with local shops While the average domestic passenger
brand-focused than Food to help provide an enhanced passenger spend is approximately $10 per
and Beverage, with the experience. The addition of a 'pop person, some international passengers
largest drivers of revenue being the up’ shop, meant to be a short-term, see the airport, and specifically duty
major newsstands. In an effort to rotating lease for locally owned San free shopping, as an opportunity to
TERMINAL 1 TERMINAL 2
provide a locally driven passenger Francisco retailers, will be making do some serious shopping. In an effort
F&B $34.7M $6.44 F&B $34.2M $9.76 experience while still gaining the it’s appearance at B/A E in 2014. to provide duty free shops with the
total per person total per person benefits these large names bring, SFO This type of new retail experience is space and resources they need, while
has started a program that pairs the crucial in evolving the conversation continuing to strive for balance, SFO
RETAIL $18.4M $3.41 RETAIL $15.6M $4.46 national brands with local companies. and providing experiences that requires duty free shopping to have
total per person total per person The large retailers have a mix of foster surprise and delight while a certain number of Disadvantaged
competitive MAG’s and percentage concurrently bolstering the Bay Business Enterprises in their
DFS $84.6K $1.02 DFS -- -- leases and are encouraged Area economy. subleases as well as demanding a
total per person fiercely competitive MAG.
S
ervices can be loosely defined widely and are uniquely tailored to experience and requires tenants to
as the revenue generating the individual service. It is important source hormone-free naturally raised
entities that don’t fall into for designers to take into account meats and vegetables. Many of these
TERMINAL 3 INTERNATIONAL TERMINAL the Food and Beverage or Retail the variety of physical spaces these types of precedents were started
categories and include luggage cart services require. during the renovations at Terminal
F&B $65.9M $8.53 F&B $34.4M $6.25 rentals, wi-fi services from customers’ 2 but have now become a standard at
total per person total per person Sustainability
selected cellular provider, pay phones, SFO. This type of innovation is what
SFO has also been a leader in
shoeshine, baggage storage, luggage makes SFO stand out as a leader in
RETAIL $31.5M $4.07 RETAIL $36.9M $6.70 wrap, travel agency, business center integrating sustainable requirements outstanding passenger experience.
total per person total per person into its leases - particularly in
services, banking and Rental Cars—
requiring Food and Beverage tenants
with the Rental Cars being the largest
DFS $589K $1.80 DFS $94M $21.95 generator of revenue under the to compost and provide disposable
total per person total per person compostable materials. In addition
management of concessions. These
to materials, SFO encourage
leases and relationships with SFO vary
food preparation to be part of the
emplaned passengers per year (millions)
REVENUE GENERATION
DIFFERS BY TERMINAL LOOKING TOWARDS THE FUTURE
Each terminal is different in terms of revenue generation. It’s important to make Creating a synergy among the various vendors at SFO is the necessary component
the distinction between revenue volume and dollars spent by passengers. T3 for a successful concessions program. Location, look and feel, operations and the
might be a money maker in terms of overall revenue, but the passenger spend experience of the vendor all play a huge role in doing this successfully. Designers
for food and beverage and retail is lower than that of passengers at T2. In the have the opportunity to shape space in a way that maximizes the successes of
International Terminal, duty free shopping brings in tremendous revenue but concessions without detracting from the overall airport experience. Terminal
is low elsewhere. International passengers, especially those from Asia, spend a 2 has been successful with its unconventional planning and decisions about
lot more at airports with a focus on luxury goods purchased from duty free shops leaseholds. By pulling concessions away from the exterior walls it has created an
(DFS), hence the high passenger spend on DFS in the international terminal. open, market-like atmosphere in which passengers have a range of quality options
within gazing distance of gates. Attention to customer hospitality will not only
serve to make passengers happier but will also allow the airport to continue to
enhance revenue generation.
HEATHROW
AIRPORT, 4 5 6
LONDON TOWN CENTER DESIGN DIGITAL SHOPPING APPROACH TO BRAND
Ranking #1 in retail
Balance natural elements with Digital shopping technologies are Manage advertisements in a curatorial
built elements. Use exhibits and beginning to pop up everywhere. manner to avoid the 'Times Square’
In an April 2013 article in Forbes Magazine looking at the Whether it ‘s a great user interface on effect. Manage tenant signage to
educational elements to reflect the
world’s best airports, London Heathrow ranked at the top in the www.flysfo.com or an actual digital maximize exposure and visibility
region and build a sense of place.
category of shopping. shopping wall in the holdrooms where in a way which reinforces overall
Ensure that tenant concessions fit
within the overall architectural customers can use their smart phones environmental quality and calm.
Seating for waiting passengers is located amongst restaurants,
look and feel. to purchase products in the airport,
cafes and retail shops rather than by the airfield. FIDs are found
digital experiences can enhance
throughout the space with updates noting boarding times. As
revenue for airport retailers and
soon as a boarding time is listed, passengers proceed to their
create a buzz among customers.
gate, and not a minute before.
NANETTE
HENDRICKSON
ROLE AT SFO: Former Senior Principal, Property Manager
CAN YOU GIVE US A LITTLE HOW CAN BUSINESSES AT WHERE DO YOU SEE
BACKGROUND ON THE SFO INCREASE REVENUES? REVENUE GENERATION
CONCESSIONS REVENUE The #1 priority is the Customer
GOING?
PROGRAM AT SFO? Experience. We need to satisfy There needs to be more synergy
There are three main categories for customer needs first. between retail and food.
revenue generation at SFO:
WHAT ARE SOME ASPECTS Circulation is a key factor for revenue
1. Retail OF THE CITY THAT CAN generation and certain areas of the
2. Food & Beverage BE CELEBRATED AT THE airport have great circulation (where
3. Services everything is visible) while other spaces
AIRPORT? struggle. You need to be able to see
Food and Beverage is very local driven.
There’s the Bay and the Marin everything everywhere.
Retail has more of a national brand focus
Headlands. We talk a lot about greenery
and Duty Free is a whole other animal.
and trees but it would be great to
Services include advertising, ATMs,
incorporate some of the water as well.
SmartCartes and rental cars. Rental cars
are our #1 source of revenue. San Francisco has a coolness factor with
all their different neighborhoods, there’s
HOW DO THE CONCESSIONS a lot of diversity in such a small place.
AT SFO DIFFER FROM OTHER
AIRPORTS?
SFO is the leader in getting local
businesses involved. We started a
program in 2003 to get some of the
smaller businesses involved and it has
increased revenue by 150%.
R
educing passenger communication. For instance, an visual elements that are necessary
stress and anxiety is of elderly passenger might be much more or desired in the airport should be
utmost importance for comfortable speaking with someone recognized and planned for. Signage,
fulfilling the goals of providing an at an information booth while a young furniture, millwork, kiosks, etc. will
efficient, convenient and service tech employee might prefer to navigate translate better to the passenger’s
oriented experience at SFO. Good entirely using her mobile device. By consciousness if they are consistent
communication is the key element establishing a multi-tiered approach throughout and maintain the same
to any great service experience and to communication that ranges from visual hierarchy. For instance, loose
needs to be oriented towards not only totally mobile to in person, SFO has trash bins scattered without attention
providing essential information, the opportunity to provide an excellent to placement will result in confusion
but doing so in a way that considers level of service to these different for the passenger and may end up
the mental and emotional needs of passenger demographics. interfering with other elements
passengers. Fine hotels are adept at in the environment such as art or
this. The customer is never left in
In addition to the types of
communications listed above,
ADA accessible signage. Terminal SIGNAGE, FURNITURE,
confusion - wondering where they
should go or what they should do.
another aspect that is of equal
2 has done an excellent job at this,
with many necessary elements, MILLWORK AND KIOSKS WILL
Instead their questions are answered
importance is architecture and the
design of interiors. The nature of the
like trash bins, being integrated in POSITIVELY IMPACT THE
before they are even asked. Often
this type of dynamic customer
interior space should communicate
millwork. The designers also worked
with advertising vendors and SFO’s PASSENGER’S CONSCIOUSNESS
service is the direct result of a robust
to the customer that special
attention was given to passenger
marketing department to ensure that IF THEY ARE CONSISTENT
staffing ability and quality customer
service training. Different passenger
experience and comfort in the design
advertisements were given clear and
delineated space, existing cohesively THROUGHOUT AND MAINTAIN
types require different kinds of
process. Secondly, the hierarchal
organization and consistency of
in their larger context. THE SAME VISUAL HIERARCHY.
P
roviding a hospitable suggest that there are two types the environment, at least not very PHYSICAL ENVIRONMENTAL PERCIEVED INDIVIDUAL
environment is challenging of basic behaviors influenced by easily. Here the servicescape directly DIMENSIONS SERVICESCAPE BEHAVIORS
because of the many required environment, categorized as approach inhibits the accomplishment of the
components. A large part of the job and avoidance. In essence, uplifting customer’s goal.” Consequently, it Ambient Conditions INTERNAL HUMAN Approach
falls upon the employees providing environments stimulate the approach can be assumed that by providing a Temperature RESPONSES Affiliation
Air Quality Exploration
service. SFO has implemented a reaction from individuals. Mary Jo quality servicescape a whole range of
Noise Cognitive Stay Longer
customer service training program in Bitner uses the term ‘servicescape’ factors can be influenced. In employee Music Commitment
Beliefs
an effort to provide a consistent level to describe the varied elements of behavior, a positive 'approach’ Odor Categorization Carry Out Plan
of service built upon a single model. the user experience and reactions response to a quality environment Symbolic Meaning Loyalty
However, many of the employees to it. “Approach behaviors include can manifest as expressions of Space Function
Layout Emotional Avoid
that passengers come in contact all positive behaviors that might be commitment, affiliation, exploration,
Equipment Mood Dissociation
with are not SFO employees but work directed at a particular place, such and - as a result of this - an enhanced
Furnishings Attitude Overlook
for tenants, TSA and other third as desire to stay, explore, work, and delivery of customer service. For
Leave quickly
party organizations. Without direct affiliate.” Bitner goes on to specifically customers, these enhanced positive Space, Symbols, and Artifacts Physiological Indifference
control over these individuals and cite airport environments as the internal responses manifest as Signage Pain
their respective companies’ service type of servicescape that inhibits entering a space, lingering, spending Personal Artifacts Comfort
models, SFO must rely on secondary approach behavior.“ For example, money and building loyalty. This is Style of Decor Physical Fitness
and tertiary means to affect their assume that a traveler enters an perhaps best expressed at SFO by the Art and Museum
behaviors. While the evidence is airport and is confused because he greatly increased revenues of T2 - with
somewhat anecdotal, it is widely or she cannot find signage giving the highest per passenger spend for
accepted, especially among marketing directions to the assigned gate and non DFS retail and Food and Beverage.
experts, that by providing a higher is emotionally distressed because
quality environment, employee and of crowds, poor acoustics, and high
customer satisfaction is increased. temperature. The traveler is unable
Environmental psychologists to carry out the purpose for entering
CHANGI AIRPORT,
SINGAPORE
A way to experience the city during a layover
4 5 6
STRATEGIZE FOR EASE ENVIRONMENTAL HOSPITALITY AMENITIES
Ever been in an airport on a long layover for a connecting flight
wishing you could see more of the city? Changi airport has When planning, continually check The environmental design of a space Consider new and innovative ways
the ideal solution, allowing passengers to register for a 2-hour to ensure that no major obstacles and the overall quality has a major to incorporate amenities that are
sightseeing tour of Singapore. or conflicts are occurring in the impact on customers and employees thoughtful, welcoming and create a
passenger journey. (Is that restroom alike. It is important to frequently better customer experience. Perhaps
Passengers with a long layover (at least 5 hours) must register at
wall blocking the customer’s line of check back in with the ‘big picture’ Arrivals would benefit from some
least an hour in advance with tour times listed on the airport’s
vision to customs? Is the beautifully during the design process. From amenities that haven’t been considered
website. Options include a Heritage Tour, which covers some of
designed light fixture causing glare major architectural moves to the type for exiting customers or consider
Singapore’s most famous sights, or a City Lights tour, which is a
on all the FID screens?) Additionally, of tile in the restrooms, each design temporary spaces for
great way to experience the vibrant culture of the city.
consider the possibilities that new decision matters. Consider how even rotating amenities.
technologies provide. Would it the more temporary elements of a space
be possible to use mobile tablet have a major impact. The lounge style
technology to speed up any necessary furniture in T2 transformed the way
journey moments or provide people interact with each other as well
entertainment for guests? as the overall feeling of the terminal.
INFO BOOTH
the counter, with huge tears in her eyes, daughter was so upset and fearful that TSA pre-check, Global Entry, Emirates
she clasped my hands gently and told me her mother might get lost, I decided to go Lounge (just because it’s awesome).
that I was her “angel” and without me she find her myself. It turned out the mother
would not have been able to make it back had disembarked and stayed at the gate,
CHUCK
to see her son who is dying of cancer. as though expecting someone to meet
STAFF
Yup…that moved me! her. I introduced myself and the two of The Art Shop, where they store and stage
us walked back to the information desk art exhibits at the airport. The control
where her daughter was now sobbing tower. The heating and air conditioning
CHUCK plant. Basically, all the places behind the
with relief. It felt good to reunite mother
An 80-year-old lady from New Zealand and daughter and send them on their scenes that make the airport run.
who had slept in the Airport all night. way. The daughter was so appreciative
STAFF: Lisa, Chuck, Gloria, & Amma She came to the desk to ask where she of my help. It confirmed why I enjoy my GLORIA
could find the Air New Zealand desk. I volunteer assignments at the airport.
informed her that they were closed and The Aviation Museum, Terminal 2, Ride
AMMA GLORIA on the Air Train.
TOP 3 QUESTIONS would not be open that day because they
YOU RECEIVE AT THE 1. “How do I get to the rental cars?” A dinner date were not flying that day. She began to cry. WHAT’S THE MOST
INFO BOOTH 2. “Where is the BART station?” What was she to do? I found out she had INTERESTING, PREVIOUSLY AMMA
3. “How do I get to my hotel?” AMMA arrived the night before and her United UNKNOWN FACT ABOUT SFO The Aviation Museum, the AirTrain,
LISA plane was late because of a mechanical THAT YOU’VE DISCOVERED? Medical Clinic, Travel Agency, Aquarium
(Is there a shuttle bus? “May I use your phone?”
problem. She was too late to make her Air exhibit, Reflection Room, all of the
It does depend which terminal you Are there shared vans?) Not an unusual request but an unusual
New Zealand plane. United Airlines had LISA current exhibits in each terminal, and
are in, as the questions do change as outcome. An Asian man’s first encounter
failed to find her a room because all the There is a “garden”! Outside the Air Traffic Control tower.
far as which is asked more frequently. GLORIA with a US answering machine. Three
airport hotels were full with some local International Terminal A, in the
However, these are generally my top: 1. “Where do I pick up my rental car?” calls and three “disconnects” later we
convention. I asked the lady for patience courtyard area…there is a little lush
figured out what was going on at the other
1. “Where are the restrooms and ATM?” 2. “Where is the BART station?” as I researched her problem. While tropical garden with patio and chairs
WHAT ARE SOME THINGS
end of the phone - he didn’t realize he
2. “How to get to rental car and BART?” 3. “What’s the best way to go to
was speaking to an answering machine
talking to her, I found out that she lived sitting under the trees. I found it YOU WOULD DO TO THE
3. “How to get to hotel?” San Francisco?” close to my mother in New Zealand. I got AIRPORT TO ENHANCE THE
and couldn’t understand why the person interesting as it’s very difficult to get a
(both local and in downtown) Chris Birch involved – he began talking breath of “fresh air” if you have a long PASSENGER EXPERIENCE?
at the other end wasn’t offering to pick
WHAT IS THE him up and kept hanging up on him. The
to Air New Zealand and I started looking layover.
CHUCK ODDEST REQUEST gentleman’s interpreter tried to explain
for reasonably priced hotels. Eventually, LISA
All three relate to finding something, for YOU’VE EVER RECEIVED? we found a hotel for her for that night. Transportation post-security to each
to him what an answering machine was.
example, “Where is… How do you find… The Air New Zealand flight the next day CHUCK
To this day, I’m still not sure he ever terminal, Signs/Banners displayed
How do you get to…” And these all vary LISA was full and Chris got them to finagle a The whole airport is designated as at end of each aisle (both sides) in
realized what was really going on. A true
by terminal. Common Request: seat for her. I called her at her hotel that a museum. International Terminal for each airline
cultural and language gap.
Starbucks post security and mailbox night to let her know she had a seat for when they open, Observation deck,
Terminal 1 the next day and to make sure she was all
Oddest Request: DO YOU HAVE AN SFO GLORIA Business Services in domestic terminals
1. “How do I check in for United?” right. When she finally got home to New (computer/fax/printer).
Wanted to buy a men’s suit (not that it’s STORY THAT HAS MOVED Zealand, she wrote a nice letter to Chris That we are the first airport in the nation
2. “I can’t find my United gate.” odd to request, but it is rare and unusual) to provide Travelers Aid/Information
YOU IN SOME WAY? and to my mother! What fun!
3. “Where is Delta domestic?” Service established by Mrs. William CHUCK
(can’t see the sign from the desk) CHUCK LISA Randolph Hearst. Expand Customer Service. The more
4. “I have a flight that leaves from T1, GLORIA
It involved LAN airlines, set of keys, a Wow, you’d think I’d have them rolling off help I can give people, the better I like it.
I can’t find my airline?” crying wife and kid who wanted me to my tongue as it seem almost each time I A marriage proposal that took place at
AMMA
“That is because it is leaving from get her husband off a LAN flight, the work I am moved in some way! I’d have the International Terminal. Because I
found out before the proposal took place, I toured the SFO Communications GLORIA
the International Terminal.” police and FBI, the station manager to say though the one I always remember
I was able to capture the moment with Center. The entire airport, inside and Better signage, more eating facilities in
for LAN Airlines and Customer Service is when LAN first came to SFO and there
Terminal 2 the camera on my phone. The young outside, is totally monitored - it really is pre-security area.
(Chris Birch and Linda Rhoades). The were many AA domestic connections to
man was so nervous and worried about impressive. I had no idea how expansive
1. “How do I get to rental cars?” passenger was taken off the plane by the LAN International flights. An elderly
the outcome, he forgot all about taking and comprehensive that effort was.
2. “How do I get to Bart?” Police and FBI for causing a ruckus and lady traveling by herself, could only AMMA
held incommunicado with the only set of speak Spanish and she could not figure pictures; they were grateful to have the
3. “Where is AA or VS?” Design and print a handout for
car keys for their car. She had no money out how to get from AA in Terminal pictures and invited me to the wedding! IF YOU WERE GOING TO passengers to take with them that
Terminal 3
for a locksmith. The passenger was 2 to her connection in International GIVE A TOUR OF SFO, contains a map of the airport that
1. “Where is the United Club?” released to fly on the next flight two days Terminal for LAN. I tried to tell her in AMMA WHERE WOULD YOU GO? includes airline ticket counters,
2. “What gate am I leaving from?” later and reunited with the wife about 3 Spanish, but it was very obvious because
A daughter came to meet her mother, terminals, restaurants, bars, shops,
3. “Where is any gate between 20-39?” hours later. My job was to keep the wife of her age that there was no way she
who had slight dementia. Concerned that LISA and restrooms. If not a printed guide,
calm while Customer Service worked in would make her connection in time given All the information booths, Museum
the mother would get lost between the because we are green, an app that can be
International Terminal the background and for security reasons what she was going to have to go through
gate and the meeting area, the daughter (and T3 gallery), reflection room, the downloaded to iOS and Android devices.
1. “Where is my Airline?” they could not tell me what was going to get there. I took her by the hand yoga room, the children’s area in T2 near
asked for my guidance. I directed the
2. “I am leaving on an International on. The couple left for home (Antioch) and led her personally to LAN in the 58B, hydration stations, USO, Freshen
daughter to the meeting area but after 30
flight, why can’t I find it?” happy. Fun Stuff! International Terminal (although it was a Up, Harmony Pharmacy, Xpress Spa, SF
minutes the mother had yet to appear so
slow long walk for her). When I left her at Moma, Napa Farms, Vina Volo, ClearMe,
3. “Where is ground transportation?” the daughter came back to find me. The
Wayfinding
Time & Efficiency
Arts & Culture
Health & Wellbeing
Sustainability
Look & Feel
Technology
T “Wayfinding is a
he term “wayfinding” is used
to describe a user’s ability to
orient themselves in a built
environment. Kevin A. Lynch, an consistent use
American urban planner and the first
to use the term in an architectural
and organization
context, articulates it this way:
“wayfinding is a consistent use and
of definite
organization of definite sensory cues
from the external environment”. The
sensory cues
challenge with spatial orientation and
wayfinding in airports often has to
from the external
do with a poor signage program and a
lack of architectural character.
environment.”
–KEVIN LYNCH, URBAN
PLANNER AND AUTHOR
T
not an easy one. The difficulty with immeasurable new opportunities that the human capacity to take
he sensory cues we take from the character needed for it to become
signage is its inherent inflexibility in for dynamic signage. While the information in is limited. Visual
our environment include a real place in our mind. At SFO it
an ever-changing world of canceled behind the scenes organization and clutter is distracting and problematic
signage and spatial and visual is important to consider this in the
flights, rerouted planes, lost baggage, implementation of the dynamic in the airport environment. Some
elements. Consider how directions design. While cohesion and clarity
inclement weather conditions, etc. portion of this is challenging, the examples of problematic clutter are
are given—rarely without reference are of utmost importance, it certainly
Further, the limitations of a single ability to change signage content digital displays cycling promotional
to major landmarks or geographical doesn’t mean that character needs to
language or set of icons also restricts is tremendous in an environment material and advertisements,
elements (“head west toward the be sacrificed. Architecture and art
the ability of a signage system to where change is the only thing that’s competing advertisement and
ocean”, “turn right on Jefferson, two are both excellent ways to help people
function cross-culturally. Placement guaranteed. It is of utmost importance marketing posters, ad hoc sign holders
blocks past the capitol building”). orient themselves. A special ceiling
is of supreme importance and should that signage is NOT an afterthought to from airlines and concessionaires
When architecture becomes clinical concept or a hanging art installation
always be at key decision points. design. Designers need to work closely —even plants placed too close to
and repetitive it loses the ability both have the power of individuality
Passengers shouldn’t need to actively with the SFO signage team early on critical signage. T2 solved for some
to create a way for people. It is the and character to say to someone “Hey!
look for signs. in the design process to guarantee of this by delegating homes for visual
difference between urban sprawl, You’ve been here already, you’re going
passengers know where to look for information like advertisements and
with buildings lined up and barely in circles!” Regardless of scale, simple
signs in the first place. amenities, allowing people to process
distinguishable from one another, and cues can really have an impact.
that information separately. The result
a city street that has been evolving
is a clean, modern design that feels
and developing for years, building
calming rather than overwhelming.
CHANGI AIRPORT
SINGAPORE
Providing ease in airport navigation
THINKING IN LAYERS OTHER WAYFINDING do it yourself model while the 'want to’
One successful signage strategy
is to think of a signage hierarchy
DEVICES
Besides intuitive wayfinding and
experiences of shopping, dining and
leisure will grow. Helping passengers SHANGHAI
that is consistent throughout all
the terminals and ancillary spaces.
signage, a third element that will
make a great difference to passengers
orient their experience through
digital information sharing is TOWER,
Similarly to graphic design, signage
can function in a hierarchy using
are other wayfinding devices.
Specifically, the “Flight Deck” that
extremely important.
CHANGING TENANT
SHANGHAI
color, size, typographic stylings is being developed for B/A E has not
and composition. By thinking only wayfinding maps and directions,
LOCATIONS An example of excellence in wayfinding
volumetrically this hierarchy can be but access to information about the Tenant leases are flexible and will
articulated even further. Imagine concessions in the boarding area, change during the life span of With over 540,000 square meters of office space, high-
if all categories of signage had a allowing people to orient not only an interior environment. It is end retail, a luxury hotel, cultural venues, and the world’s
height range—for instance, all their path to gate, but their experience important that the signage and highest non-enclosed observation deck, the building
directional signage might sit at the as well. As digital becomes the new branding associations with any presents an unprecedented mixed-use program that
top of the customer view range, while normal, passengers expectations tenant remain flexible in kind. All requires a sophisticated signage and wayfinding system.
concessions might be delegated to are shifting. The 'have to’ airport tenant design, including signage is
subject to DRC approval. Design principals emphasizing overall program efficiency,
something lower. If done throughout, experiences of checking in, bag check
technological innovation, and a connection to the culture of
this type of consistent visual and boarding will move towards the
Shanghai were established to guide the overall signage and
organization begins to build a more
wayfinding solution.
WHILE COHESION AND CLARITY
robust way-finding system that relies
on the human compulsion to make Scheduled for completion in 2014, the Shanghai Tower will
sense of patterns and organize their ARE OF THE UTMOST IMPORTANCE, be a beacon of China’s future.
SUNDSTROM
ROLE: Airport Signage Coordinator, San Francisco International Airport
1 2 3
ARCHITECTURAL PROPER
WAYFINDING HIERARCHY PLACEMENT
IDEALLY, WHAT DOES SFO DO YOU THINK SENSE OF intuitive as far as an airport is concerned?
WANT WAYFINDING TO BE? PLACE PLAYS INTO IT? For some people, it’s having ground
transportation on one level…we have it on Architecture should create a natural It’s important to follow SFO’s Ensure that signage and wayfinding
HOW DOES THIS SYSTEM If you’re experienced with the space, two levels. flow for passengers to progress from guidelines for visual hierarchy that elements are placed at natural
INTEGRATE WITH THE GUEST yes. If you’re not experienced with one process to the next. Consider how establishes rules that distinguish pause points and in the appropriate
EXPERIENCE? the space, no. When you do signage and wayfinding, you
challenging some of the conventions between wayfinding, art, circulation paths. One example is
need to make it simple for the experienced
Signs should always be placed at decision as well as the very infrequent traveler. You of traditional airport planning might advertising and concession and placing FID’s in an easy to see location
points. At an airport, the appropriate WHO MAINTAINS THE need to make sure the level of information be beneficial for passenger comfort. amenity identification. right after the security checkpoint
level of signage makes for a pleasant INFORMATION? needed is available at those critical In partnership with the signage in the recompose area. This is a
and calming journey—people are more decision points. program, designers need to include natural pause and decision point
This is quite the conversation. We
likely to stay calm if the directions are
maintain the system, but we’re always signage design in early planning to for passengers. Provide message
clear to them.
looking for ways to make it better. We’re better encourage self-direction and continuity so guests are assured they
Like any system, we need flexibility not living in an ideal world yet. In an ideal intuitive wayfinding. are on the right path.
because needs and operations constantly world we would have resources to maintain
change. For example, the international this information. To keep better pace with
terminal has domestic flights. We have a technology, we’d create an API which
building where things change constantly,
even airlines change. People still need to
get to their flights, transfer flights between
allows other systems to integrate with our
system which would allow for uniform
information all across systems that push
4 5
terminals, get their baggage, etc. As much data to various users.
USE COLOR MOCK IT UP
as we can automate and plan for it, we don’t
know what’s going to happen. WHAT WOULD YOU TELL AN
ARCHITECT, WHO IS GOING Consider how color and materiality When in doubt, consider mocking
The biggest issues when it comes to can influence positive wayfinding up certain elements and testing
signage, is actually making the signage TO WORK ON A TERMINAL,
THEY NEED TO THINK experiences. Color can be a them in place to understand an
work in tandem with the building. This is
a challenge in existing buildings, but also a ABOUT? powerful tool in helping people element’s performance.
challenge in major renovation projects. In orient themselves in an
T2 for example, a big wayfinding challenge There’s no such thing as intuitive unfamiliar environment.
is when you come from baggage claim, wayfinding. I grew up in Hong Kong and
passengers have difficulty finding the India and grew up with everything on the
vertical connection to the AirTrain. right. Here, on the first day on the job, we
have arrows on the left and read from left
In signage, you’re never going to get 100% to right. They do everything on the left,
to use your system. The industry standard we do everything on the right. What is
is that 80-90% use the signs. In a recent
SFO survey, we found over 90% use our
signage system. We recognize that we still
need to make that experience even better,
and need to use multiple means to reach all
passengers. You can have a paper map or
an interactive map. I like the ideas of apps
a lot, but content management
and the ability to maintain the apps
is an issue. We’re not nimble as an
organization to keep up with changes,
especially new technology.
TOM
HORTON
ROLE: Senior Associate, Environmental Graphic Design, Gensler
WHAT ARE SOME BASIC WHAT ARE SOME PLACES WHAT IS INTUITIVE WHAT ARE SOME EXCITING
WAYFINDING PRINCIPLES? WITH GREAT WAYFINDING? WAYFINDING? NEW TECHNOLOGIES
Planning for effective wayfinding begins The J. P. Getty Museum in Los Angeles Intuitive wayfinding is accomplished
AND FUTURE TRENDS IN
with identifying navigation routes has an intelligent, adaptable wayfinding through incorporation of non-signage WAYFINDING?
through spaces; where will users look for program. The modular system is designed features that guide users through complex The future of wayfinding is through
information and need to make decisions? to accommodate change over time based areas. A good example of intuitive integrated technologies that allow the
Concentrate wayfinding information upon visitor feedback and the evolving wayfinding is the path to baggage claim airport operator, airlines and the user
at decision points along those routes, nature of a museum environment. through the Marketplace area in SFO to create a more tailored wayfinding
organizing directional information from The simple, elegant gray and white Terminal 2. As deplaning passengers experience. Digital airport sign messaging
macro to micro by providing just enough signage features pictures of artwork approach the exit to baggage claim from and interactive directories can respond
information to lead to the next decision and symbology to quickly orient visitors the main concourse, it is not immediately to real time airport activities and adjust
point. Utilize a variety of different visual and provide direction to the collections. apparent that the doors are off to one side. wayfinding information accordingly. Hand
cues; color, symbology, written messages, A bronze tabletop scale model of the To augment the overhead directional signs, held mobile devices allow users to access
arrows, patterns and simple map diagrams museum campus engages arriving users, a contrasting gray floor pattern leads airport maps, search amenities and flight
help users orient themselves and feel including sight-impaired visitors who toward the doors—passengers instinctively information, and follow destination routes
confident in their navigation choices. can touch to understand the layout of follow this floor pathway toward the exit. enabled by customized indoor GPS systems.
Effective wayfinding relies on more than the buildings.
just signs. People build a mental map of HOW DOES WAYFINDING
their surroundings through observing an WHAT ARE SOME OTHER RELATE TO THE AIRPORT
environment’s colors, lighting, textures WAYS TO HELP GUIDE USERS PASSENGER?
and architectural forms. The designer/ THROUGH SPACE?
architect should look for ways to integrate An airport user’s wayfinding experience
spacial cues into their environments Designers often use technology, color, often begins pre-arrival. Passengers will
that will aid wayfinding. Use of bright pattern and lighting as a way to draw often go online to look at an airline or
colors, distinctive shapes, change in attention to certain areas, pathways or airport website, review a map in an inflight
floor patterning or accent lighting can decision points to aid wayfinding. For magazine or search information on their
call attention to an important entry, example, using an airline’s brand color handheld device. The graphic style and
passageway or destination as effectively as on signage or architecture can help content of these pre-engagement tools
a sign. Collaboration early in the design distinguish between different hold areas. should match the on-airport wayfinding
process between the client, architecture, Accent lighting, or bold patterning can program. Their wayfinding experience
interiors and signage teams can greatly be used to accentuate a path or highlight doesn’t end until they board their flight or
reduce the number of signs by building an entry/exit opening. Dynamic displays are on transportation leaving the airport.
intuitive wayfinding cues into the design of or messaging engage users and allows The airport wayfinding system and the
an airport’s spaces. wayfinding systems to adapt to many information touchpoints along the
changing conditions. way are the continuum between these start
and end points.
modern pleasure.” excessive waiting times for elevators. FRUSTRATING, many people dread.
After an analysis of how elevator
service might be improved, it was
DEMORALIZING, It is important that all support goes
initially to doing the basics right. The
–ALDOUS HUXLEY, AUTHOR AGONIZING,
suggested that mirrors be installed Harvard Business Review has this
OF BRAVE NEW WORLD near where guests waited for elevators.
The natural tendency of people to
AGGRAVATING, to say: “First, delighting customers
doesn’t build loyalty; reducing their
customers have at SFO are reflected to improve customer experience. EXPENSIVE reduce customer service costs, and
decrease customer churn”. Like a good
in numerous ways, from customer While it is assumed that SFO and its
food pyramid, the basics live at the
satisfaction (as seen in reviews and vendors will address the mathematical
bottom—with customer service and
complaints) to the memories and and logistical aspect of improving
good communication in the middle
stories of experiences, and even in queuing efficiency, a focus on
and those special extras truly being
the decisions to spend – or not. The improving the experience of waiting
the cherry on top.
specific triggers that cause waiting is also required.
COPENHAGEN
AIRPORT,
COPENHAGEN
Rated the best at security processing 4 5
PROVIDE ACTIVITIES PLAN FOR LESS WALKING
In an international Skytrax survey, passengers rated the
Copenhagen airport as having the best and most friendly
Consider what passengers might be When possible in the planning
security process.
doing if they weren’t at the airport process, minimize walking distances.
Not only are staff friendly, but queues are also efficient which and allow them a way to do it. Long walking distances and lack of
results in shorter wait times. In 2012, average wait time was Working, exercising, resting, relaxing, linearity can add to an impression of
measured at 3.5 minutes. shopping, eating, socializing, inefficient space and waste of time and
exploring and learning are some energy and generally contributes to a
great places to start! poor level of service.
TERENCE
YOUNG
ROLE: Senior Designer, Gensler
WHAT TIPS WOULD HOW DO YOU SEE AIRPORT HOW DO YOU THINK WHAT IS UNIQUE
YOU GIVE TO SOMEONE PLANNING EVOLVING IN THE DESIGNERS CAN MAKE THE ABOUT SFO?
DESIGNING AN AIRPORT? SHORT TERM FUTURE? CUSTOMER JOURNEY MORE San Francisco is a rare community to
1. Any designer working with the 1. Greater reliance on passenger
TIMELY? MORE EFFICIENT? design for: I view it as a privilege to work
traveling public has to balance many self service, at least in the 1. Craft spaces that allow space for with this municipality and operator. The
design inputs for both the operators domestic market passengers traveling with bags in client group communicates well with the
and the public and create unfamiliar surroundings. design team, has a vision of the airport’s
a priority list. 2. Greater need for airports to de- future that is grounded in values of
institutionalize their retail and 2. Craft elegant and beautiful spaces quality, sustainability….both core values
2. Craft an emotional journey that truly activate their public spaces as but try not to complicate the that I share. The SF team has been
can change each time a traveler cultural and community centers senses so that signage is obscured collaborative throughout our projects
visits the building. At any one time or difficult to understand due to and has been a partner in the design of
the passenger might be suffering 3. Consider public / alternate
the space. each solution. I find that the leadership
from any combination of fatigue, transportation to and from the
is directive without being prescriptive
stress, fear, hunger and thirst, or airport to reduce passenger car 3. Efficiency is about clarity and about the design solutions…meaning
anger. Seek to create a calming, traffic and parking spaciousness. the airport is open to exploration and
inspirational journey. 4. Non airport uses being integrated innovation in both planning and design.
A
rt and Culture at SFO is at SFO Museum
the heart of place-making SFO Museum grew out of a
and in fostering a humane collaborative effort between the SF
and interesting experience. Airport Commission and the San
Francisco Museum of Fine Arts in
SFO Arts Commission
1980. Its charge is to offer rotating
SFO’s Arts program is created by two
exhibitions to humanize the airport
distinct bodies: the San Francisco
environment, and reflect the cultural
Arts Commission and SFO Museum. A UNIQUE PLACE FOR ART
life of the Bay Area. Currently,
In 1977, the San Francisco Arts
A
the museum hosts twenty galleries
Commission, a public agency created
throughout the airport’s terminals, s a public space experienced installation pieces directly into the the unique character of SFO. The
in 1932, spearheaded the arts program
as well as the Aviation Library and by over 40 million architecture. Artworks also function airport’s collection is also tightly
at SFO during the construction of
Museum and an aquarium. Exhibits travelers each year, design as landmarks orienting passengers linked to the rich artistic institutions
Terminal 3, to bring the public into
cover a wide range of themes, all consultants have many opportunities along their journey between gates, of San Francisco including the De
contact with the cultural landscape of
providing a venue for the 40 million to incorporate art in unique ways passageways, baggage claim, and Young and Asian Art Museums.
San Francisco. The commission was
annual passengers to explore history, during the upcoming expansions exits. As an example, the netted By increasing the links with local
and has been involved in developing
art, science and culture. and renovations of terminal spaces. installation of Janet Echelman’s museums, galleries, and schools,
the infrastructure and overseeing The Commission and Museum’s “Every Beating Second”, placed under the airport serves as an unmatched
the aesthetics of the city. The Arts In 1999, SFO became the first art distinguishes SFO from other a skylight in the ceiling of SFO’s T2, artistic venue for the region in putting
Commission continues its role as museum within an airport to receive airports, fostering an authentic sense marks a recompose and plaza space the global community of travelers into
curator of the permanent art on accreditation from the American
of place, while providing passengers within the terminal. While it serves as dialogue with the city’s local heritage
display throughout the airport. Its Alliance of Museums, and has become
with visual stimulation, education, a landmark, the sculpture shifts the and culture. At the same time, the
collection of sculptures, paintings, a leading model for how museums and diversion from the stress of perception of space, creating an awe infusion of both world-class and local
mosaics, and environmental artwork operate in public spaces. their journeys. In addition to more inspiring moment in the passenger artistic expressions marks and brands
encompasses over 75 pieces, 60 of traditional gallery type exhibits, journey. Through the inclusion of SFO both regionally and globally.
which are currently on display. the large scale of space creates the artwork made by Bay Area artists,
possibility for integrating large the SFO Arts program strengthens
BLAKE
SHOWN TO HAVE RESTORATIVE
EMOTIONAL AND MENTAL EFFECTS,
TO EASE BOTH FATIGUE AND
RESTLESS BEHAVIOR.
SUMMERS
ROLE AT AIRPORT: Director & Chief Curator of SFO Museum
T
he primary concern of The beneficial healing effect of helps ease the stress of travel. Offering
ARTS PROGRAM AT SFO? DESIGN PRINCIPLES FOR PLACES THAT YOU WOULD
any traveler is to reach a art has been proven. Behavioral meaningful experiences, art inspires The arts program at SFO is divided into
ART SPACES? RECOMMEND A FRIEND
destination; so the ease scientists have found that art, like a whole range of people in unexpected two main groups: Light levels are extremely important,
VISIT:
and efficiency of this process is the nature, has restorative emotional and ways and enhances the journey. you need to control the lighting when 1. A visit to the DeYoung museum
1. The Public Art program, which is
purpose and priority of every airport. mental effects, to ease both fatigue displaying art. Also some cases need to be
headed by Susan Pontious and the SF 2. Lunch at the Moss room in the
There are many ways in which art and restless behavior. Another ART Public Arts Commission
climate controlled.
California Academy of Sciences
and culture can aid in uplifting
the passenger experience. Besides
study completed by psychologists
found that viewing visual art while
INSTALLATIONS 2. SFO Museum which is responsible WHAT ARE SOME AREAS 3. Visiting the Asian Art Museum
specific artwork at the airport. architecture and displayed in exhibits, SPACE. website (http://www.flysfo.com/web/page/ WHAT ARE SOME OF YOUR
sfo_museum/) and we’re incorporating
different types of technology to display our
FAVORITE MUSEUMS?
programming and art. Prado for the art, the Louvre, and
the California Academy of Sciences
We have an Info Terrace being planned
for the spaces.
which will have digital displays, takeaways
with mobile technology and blue dot
technology with navigations.
96 T H E PR I NCI PL E S OF R .E . A .C .H. 97
ARTIST INTERVIEW ARTS & CULTURE ARTIST INTERVIEW ARTS & CULTURE
JANET KENDALL
ECHELMAN
ROLE: Visual artist BIRTHPLACE: Tampa, FL MEDIA: Public Art & Sculpture
BUSTER
ROLE: Sculptor BIRTHPLACE: Selma, AL MEDIA: Sculpture
YOUR WORK FOR SFO WAS WHAT WAS THE IF YOU COULD CREATE A WHAT WAS THE
SMALLER SCALE THAN SOME INSPIRATION FOR YOUR WORK IN ANY PLACE IN THE INSPIRATION FOR YOUR
OF THE LARGER SCALE WORK AT SFO? AIRPORT, WHERE WOULD IT WORK AT SFO?
URBAN WORK THAT YOU’VE Visually, the sculpture evokes the contours
BE?
I was interested in designing a form
DONE, WHAT WERE SOME OF and colors of cloud formations over the Right where it is. that evoked associations with both
THE CHALLENGES? Bay. Aesthetically, the sculpture looks topographical maps and cloud formations.
both backwards and forwards—it draws IF YOU WERE A PASSENGER I wanted a very ephemeral presence, a
Integrating within the architecture of the
its color from the heyday of psychedelic large bold form that was not heavy and that
terminal is about finding the right scale—
music, the Summer of Love, and San
GOING THROUGH SFO, WHAT
reflected and refracted light. So I used
not too big and not too small. As a team, I
Francisco’s prominence in the beat WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE OR a lightweight armature covered in semi-
think we found the sweet spot. DO?
poetry movement. It also references transparent scrim. I am always interested
the contemporary bay area as a hub of in ways in which my sculptures can
I’d like a bean bag chair underneath the
innovation and interconnectivity for the converse with the particulars of a given
sculpture where I could look up through
world of technology. architectural space and so I was drawn
the round skylight, with people passing by
to the opportunity to site the sculpture
on all sides, but I’d be in an oasis of calm
on either side of the mezzanine entrance
contemplation.
walkway. I hoped that the work would read
as if the segments that make the form
WHAT IS THE TITLE AND had drifted apart, that the two distinct
WHERE DOES IT COME groupings on either side of the walkway
FROM? were part of a single form.
4
INCHEON AIRPORT, OTHER ARTS
W
Post Security
hen it comes to
considering health
THE MAIN
and wellbeing in the STRESSORS CAN
airport experience, many factors are
important, but paramount to them all
BE DIVIDED
is the reality and consequences of an INTO THREE
unusually high level of stress that the
airport experience causes for many
DISTINCT CAUSES:
people. Stress is cited as a common WAITING, STRESS
reality for travelers with more than
a third of travelers believing travel is
CONCERNING At Ticketing
worse than work and nearly a quarter LOGISTICS, AND
think it is as stressful as moving
STRESS FROM During Security
WHERE IS
house. The research, which surveyed
2,000 British travelers and was THE BUILT THE MOST STRESS?
conducted by credit card insurer CPP,
also cites that nearly 9% of people
ENVIRONMENT
avoid flying altogether because of
know intuitively the answer to this
airport stressors. Most people find
question and we will undoubtedly
that anxiety increases exponentially
be in part correct, there is a
up to checkpoint, where it skyrockets, Pre Security
tremendous amount of complexity
and is then dramatically reduced
to answering – and addressing – the
immediately after. For many
question holistically. If we begin
travelers, the stress might be most
to break down the main stressors,
intense at the security checkpoint
they can be divided it into three
but it will remain a constant presence
distinct causes: stress from waiting,
until they are seated on the plane.
stress concerning logistics and
Though it may seem an obvious interpersonal interaction with
question, it is one that still needs services, and stress from the built
to be asked: “Why the intense environment and the physical
stress?” Though we may think we and abstract elements therein.
104 SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL AIRP ORT THE PRINCIPLE S OF R.E.A.C.H. 105
CREATING A NATURALLY
HEALTY AND HARMONIOUS
ENVIRONMENT CAN REDUCE
STRESS SIGNIFICANTLY
Capturing some the lush vegetation that Southeast Architects and designers have the An important part of the passenger It is important for designers,
Asia is known for, Changi is able to infuse nature into unique opportunity at SFO to propose experience has much to do with consultants and airport employees
the airport environment with various garden spaces and execute innovative wellness our non visual senses. The quality to be constantly asking, “How do I
forming the Nature Trail. The Butterfly Garden is just programming. The SFO Yoga room of air, ambient noise and tactile reduce stress at the airport?” This
one of these spaces which allows passengers to learn and has proven to be extremely popular variety are all design elements that key element is the most essential
explore in an environment full of wonder and delight. with passengers and has re-framed are often under-considered, but component in driving a better
Gardens such as this serve not only as a welcome respite the conversation about the airport that greatly impact the passenger passenger experience. Productive
for passengers who just need to take a breath of fresh air, experience. Considering food and experience. Thinking about ways to wait times, communicating clearly
but as an educational environment for children as well. beverage tenants who provide fresh, increase the quality of delivered air, and accurately as much as possible,
locally produced goods creates an provide natural indoor elements, incorporating amenities that
atmosphere that is not only healthier, decrease the cacophony of audio alleviate or minimize stress and
but is also a genuine reflection of distraction and provide rich textural ensuring that spatial ambiance and
San Francisco values. There are variations in materiality will quality are at the highest standard
also opportunities for exercise benefit the overall experience. are some, but not all of the techniques
NAPCAB ROOMS, programming such as walking paths. designers, consultants and SFO
employees can use to address the
AIRPORT
A place to relax in Munich 4 5 6
Long layovers can be a nuisance, particularly
CLARITY AND HEALTHY BUILDING NATURE
WAYFINDING CONCEPTS
when traveling through multiple time zones
and getting into places at odd hours.
A chief strategy to alleviating Buildings today have advanced in Natural elements give the brain a
Munich Airport (MUC) has reached the perfect passenger stress is clear wayfinding, both materiality and construction. break. Essentially, visual clutter
solution by offering an area for sleeping, relaxing particularly for travelers new to Specific building elements that are overwhelms the human brain. Just
and chilling. Included in this space are Napcab the airport. Having clear signage important include integrating views by looking at nature, the negative
rooms to catch up on sleep or relax with good that assists navigation is one of to nature, having indoor greenery, effects of over-stimulation are
music, which can be rented out by the hour. the most important elements in incorporating natural lighting, mitigated and the brain has time
Adjacent to this area is a section filled with airport planning. Additionally, introducing low velocity air and to reset, decreasing stress and
greenery and a variety of seating types for comfort, consider including intuitive using natural materials. Another allowing for better mental clarity.
relaxation and lounging, coupled with plenty wayfinding elements like unique aspect of a healthy building is to
of outlet spaces to recharge mobile devices. All architectural and art elements, use have spatial and visual diversity
in all, it’s a perfect place to recharge not only of color and views to the outside. to make it pleasing to occupants.
mobile devices but the mind and body as well! For reference, check the San
Francisco Green Ordinance.
108 SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL AIRP ORT THE PRINCIPLE S OF R.E.A.C.H. 109
INTERVIEW HEALTH & WELLBEING
DENISE AUDREY
PIERI LAWRENCE /
ROLES AT AIRPORT: Wellness Coordinator & Manager, Safety, Health and Wellness
HOW DOES SFO WHAT ARE SOME OTHER WHAT ARE SOME OF THE
PROMOTE HEALTH AND WAYS HEALTH AND REQUESTS YOU’VE HEARD
WELLBEING FOR GUESTS WELLBEING CAN BE REGARDING HEALTH AND
AND EMPLOYEES AT THE INTEGRATED AT THE WELLBEING?
AIRPORT? AIRPORT?
• Sleep Pods
SFO actively promotes health and The Airport continuously strives to
• Wellness and Exercise Classes
wellbeing through a wellness model that provide a balanced wellness program for
consists of four components: physical, its employees and traveling guests which • Group Activities
emotional, spiritual and financial. The encourages living a healthy lifestyle. A
Airport Commission provides employee few ways wellbeing can be integrated at • Fitness Center
workshops, health fairs, and a number the Airport:
• Farmers Market
of activities that support our wellness
mission. SFO has consistently been • A par course around the terminals
We are listening! The Airport continues
ranked as one of the top 10 Healthiest where passengers can stretch
to encourage guests and employees
employers in the Bay Area by the San and exercise while waiting for
to communicate through our various
Francisco Business Times. their flight.
modes of communication. Our guests are
• A walk around the terminals will welcome to provide comments at:
To better serve our traveling guests we
have a Recompose Area and Yoga room allow guests and employees to view
• Information booths located
located in Terminal 2, past the security art exhibits, purchase healthy food
throughout the Terminals
checkpoint. Here, guests have the or watch the latest construction
opportunity and space to comfortably projects . One lap around the airport • Visit flysfo.com
repack their belongings, stretch and is approximately one mile!
relax before heading to the gates areas • Another idea is to have a play room/
for their flight. If guest are traveling play area for children to watch
with children they are invited to visit children videos and have fun before
our “Kid’s Spots” play areas, located post their flight.
security in Terminal 2 and Terminal 3.
• Place a piano in one of the terminals
where students from local music
conservatories and programs come
to play.
Sustainability
Look & Feel
Technology
SUSTAINABILITY AT SFO
Sustainable Leaders pass through the airport every year. gestures that affect behavior (e.g. the As the first terminal of its kind in the architect strategizing about creating
S
imilar to how the Bay Area This notion of engaging with the hydration stations,) all efforts must United States to achieve LEED Gold sustainable environments at SFO.
has proven itself a leader in people who are touched by the airport be focused on providing an improved, certification, SFO’s Terminal 2 has Designers should partner with the
the tech sector and health environment has the potential to reliable, innovative and delightful set the new standards for building SFO community to take into account
and wellbeing, the region is also a affect personal behaviors and shape human experience. It is important and construction at SFO. In the ideas about sustainability - and
leader in sustainability, creating and expectations around the topic of to recognize what efforts and future, new buildings and upgrades especially life cycle costs - as part of
enforcing the highest standards of sustainability, creating a ripple effect, innovations the airport is currently will be expected to meet LEED Gold the decision making process. Building
environmental policy and guidelines the impact of which is difficult to pursuing and also to continue seeking requirements and should strive a sustainable environment is about
as well as striving to innovate and measure but impossible to discount. new and exciting opportunities that to exceed them. While the LEED much more than checking off green
inspire future generations. The make legitimate environmental and system is useful for setting a course requirements and should be seen as an
Sustainability can be realized
airport, an extension and reflection social impacts, while keeping in for successful sustainable building, exciting and inspiring opportunity for
through both large and small efforts.
of the city of San Francisco and the mind the airport’s high level goals it should by no means be the only not just today but the future as well.
Whether it’s innovative systems
Bay Area, has the unique opportunity of treading as lightly as possible on standard of measurement. The Living
(e.g. displacement ventilation at
to be not only a leader in sustainable the earth and positively influencing Building Challenge is an even more
T2), large scale implementation
practices but also set an example human behavior. rigorous set of standards and can
(e.g. reduction of Green House Gas
for the millions of passengers who be a useful tool for any designer or
Emissions) or hospitality inspired
S
FO has been pioneering new ways to manage
and conserve the natural resources in what
is, ultimately, an incredibly demanding
environment. SFO has already begun to move
towards the city of San Francisco’s GHG reduction
goals of 25% by 2017. With an overall reduction
of 19% as of 2010, SFO continues to work with
their operations to decrease emissions and offers
financial and physical facility support for GHG
reduction by SFO enterprises.
WATER
Efforts in water conservation include, but are not
limited to, installing low flow fixtures, eliminating
unnecessary hydrant flushing and replacing old
or leaky pipes. SFO has reduced its potable water
usage by 14% from 2004 to 2010. It is essential that
SFO and its partners continue towards reducing
THE HUMAN STORY OF SUSTAINABILITY potable water usage as well as considering the best
systems to deal with greywater.
I
n addition to encouraging different The goal of reducing waste (all those configurations. Designers should also
types of sustainable practice, single use plastic bottles) was met consider the opportunity for social ENERGY
engaging the customer in the in a fun, engaging way that allows sustainability and human health. By In 2010, the airport had over 49 electrical energy
sustainable story is of great value passengers to take part in the solution. designing sustainable spaces at the efficiency projects implemented and had reduced
to SFO. By making environmental The design mantra for this type of airport, designers have the opportunity its electricity consumption by 6.3% compared to
stewardship personal and imbuing inclusion would be 'make it easy and to not only make an environmental 2004 electricity use. By implementing lighting
a sense of ownership into each and make it fun’ and the opportunities impact, but also positively impact the improvements, including requirements about
every passenger who moves through for these types of elements are many everyday lives of millions of people. efficient fixture types, HVAC efficiency and SFO
the terminal spaces, SFO has the – especially with the implementation Ultimately the message from the SFO Information technology energy saving measures,
unique opportunity to impact social of new and more plentiful passenger sustainability leadership is to engage SFO has eliminated the needless waste of energy
behavior in a serious way. An example amenities like amenities alcoves, the customer, continue innovating and created a greener campus. For the future,
of a sustainable and engaging element children’s play areas, museum spaces sustainable practices and test drive designers might consider more opportunities for
are the hydration stations at SFO. and market like concessions’ spatial new ideas! photo voltaics, daylight harvesting and greener
transportation.
OMEGA CENTER 4 5 6
FOR SUSTAINABLE AIR QUALITY BEHAVIOR + COMMUNITY MATERIALITY
WHEN DID THE WHAT IDEAS WOULD YOU LIKE WHAT ARE SOME WHAT ARE THE TOP 10 WHAT ARE SOME BEST
SUSTAINABILITY PROGRAM TO SEE IMPLEMENTED IF IT OPPORTUNITIES FOR WAYS AIRPORTS CAN BE PRACTICE EXAMPLES FROM
START AT SFO? WAS NO HOLDS BARRED? FUTURE DESIGNERS AND GREENER? FOREIGN AIRPORTS THAT
In 1993 when we were working on the Ban the sale of bottled water in concession
ARCHITECTS AT SFO? 1. Eliminate red list chemicals as much
CAN BE INTEGRATED IN
airport master plan, SFO had to address and instead sell cups and water containers SFO is good efficiency-wise at energy as possible AMERICAN AIRPORTS?
issues of construction and how to deal to make the hydration stations ubiquitous. conservation but operationally, there Outdoor spaces integrated into the airport,
2. Efficient plane taxi-ing/take-off/
with hazardous materials. That’s when The weight of transporting water can still be some improvements. For especially in lobbies and transition areas.
landing to minimize fuel waste
compliance to regulations really began. contributes to the cost of water and yet we example, the natural light in Terminal 2
have the best water quality in the country. is great but operationally we still need to 3. Vertical axis wind turbines along
In 2008, SFO was recognized with an runways (and any other windy areas) WHAT ARE THE MOST
keep the lights on.
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) We’d also like to have one day a week where SUSTAINABLE PRACTICES
4. Make taking public transit to/from
Award for its Environmental Programs. it’s an all vegetarian concession. It would Encourage employees, tenants and
airport free/very low cost
YOU’VE SEEN IN AIRPORTS
It was at that time we thought about slowly introduce the idea of the energy it other stakeholders to also participate AROUND THE WORLD?
carbon neutrality and zero waste and with takes to produce certain meals to the public. in sustainable practices. Take a look at 5. Make the wayfinding to public
Terminal 2, we were able to implement Adam Grant’s philosophy (professor at transportation VERY clear and easy to 1. Daylighting!!
some of these ideas. It would also be great to encourage follow and make the ticket purchasing
Wharton and author of Give and Take: A 2. Natural ventilation
community and have family activities VERY easy
Revolutionary Approach to Success), you
through things like the waterfall wall 3. On-site renewable energy generation
WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO in Boarding Area E. There are exercise
get more rewards from people. 6. Pay a living wage to all employees
SEE IMPLEMENTED AS PART bikes that generate energy to produce 7. Make landscape around airport into a
4. Healthy and organic food options
OF THE SUSTAINABILITY waterfalls. It’s a way for the public to feel valuable ecosystem, with storm water 5. Water bottle refilling stations
PROGRAM THAT HASN’T good about participating in sustainable retention
ALREADY BEEN INCLUDED? practices for energy.
8. All to-go ware required to be
We’d like to see landfill containers smaller compostable and have compostable
than recycling or compost containers to collection, right alongside garbage
encourage the public to recycle & compost. and recyclable collection.
9. Since airports are typically 1-2 stories,
We’d also like to see low flush urinals get
PV on roof surface has potential to
implemented to reduce water usage.
provide a significant percentage of
energy needed.
10. Perform ongoing commissioning of
energy and water consuming systems.
T
he look and feel at SFO is Civic Minded Design
determined by the vision Looking toward conceptually driven,
and collaboration of design human-centric design in successful
consultants, SFO’s design and modern civic buildings, SFO strives
construction teams and executive to pair excellent programming with
management. By understanding the appropriate spatial volume, optimal
greater aesthetic vision of SFO for the daylight and conceptual drivers
future, designers can move collectively that are fresh and authentic. The
towards an aesthetic in which all International Terminal and Terminal
terminals can share a similar but still 2 have both become iconic buildings
unique design language. for SFO. Though very different,
both buildings have expansive
SFO has many different design
glazing that helps bring light to the
aesthetics from many different eras
interior, helping save on energy THE CHANGING AIRPORT LANDSCAPE
in its portfolio of buildings. A helpful
costs and creating an environment
analogy to understand the desired
that feels fresh and airy. Volumetric
make up of the future SFO campus Programming security recompose area, creating implications, but studies show that
and varied interior space planning,
is to consider that all terminals Major airport planning trends change congestion at the end of security these mobile passengers are happy to
modern, clean finishes and atypical
speak different dialects of the same as safety concerns, technological with less able passengers struggling rely on self check, tag, bag and board
furniture specifications inspired by
language. Designers and architects advancements and human behavior to put themselves back together. but expect enhanced amenities in
high end hotels are found at T2 and
should consider the shared vision of evolve. Even in the brief history of These types of changes have a major the airport terminals. Considering
have become the new standard for
the overall SFO campus. the past twenty years, airports have impact on the development of interior that the airport of the near future
interior design at SFO. It is helpful
Airport design, with its feet firmly undergone radical changes. Before planning. Poorly considered may be entirely consumer driven,
for designers to recognize these
planted in the civic arena, is as 9/11 the pre- and post-security divide outcomes of these spaces can result with self check, self bag and tag
successful design infrastructures and
much about the city and local pride was virtually non existent. Since then, in frustrated passengers. and self board becoming the norm,
interpret these ideals to help SFO grow
as it is anything else. New trends in airports have been required to add designers will need to be cognizant
into the well-positioned future campus Behavior
civic design have an optimistic and large scale security areas with an array of not only the spatial implications
it desires to be. It’s important for designers to
transparent directive. This type of of changing equipment and staffing of new technologies but also the
consider the way that human behavior physical housing of the technologies
architecture conveys to users that they needs. Most of these spaces had not
is changing. Today, many consumers themselves. It is important that these
are in a place that encourages open been originally planned for and a
navigate their world relying almost elements be consistently designed with
communication and are happy being tremendous number of new elements
exclusively on mobile technology. a look and feel that is cohesive and
'seen’. This should be considered in had to be absorbed into existing
What opportunities exist to enhance recognizable, terminal to terminal.
the design of spaces, particularly in layouts. As consumers well know,
their experience? It might be
large public areas and the entrance many airports don’t have sufficient
assumed that this doesn’t have spatial
and exits to the building. space to offer a legitimate post-
JACKSON HOLE
AIRPORT, WYOMING
AMBIANCE MATERIALITY SCALE
Everyone has a favorite restaurant, Finishes may vary from terminal to Often airport design is meant to
hotel, bar, park or public space that has terminal but favoring neutral colors “wow”. With enormous interior
“just the right ambiance.” Ambiance and materials is desired, especially in spaces and grand formal gestures, Sophisticated yet approachable design
is an abstract concept, but a solid permanent installations and public architectural grandeur can instill in
realty that is easily detected when areas. Trendy materials might strike the passenger a sense of excitement
The Jackson Hole Airport might not be the first place that pops
done well. Ambiance comes from the a design fancy but are better suited for about their journey and a respect for
into mind when people talk about major aviation projects, but
harmony of all the design elements. concessions or short term lease spaces the city. This type of sensibility is
as far as look and feel goes, Jackson Hole has excelled. The
Spatial volume, light and air, finishes, that can be easily and readily a noble goal, but needs to be paired
materiality and design concepts capture perfectly the rural
furniture and art all work towards refreshed. It is also important to with a human-centric approach to
Wyoming feel without being kitschy. The finishes used on the
creating an ambiance that enhances consider the sustainable aspects of design, at both the architectural
project convey a sense of place and the end result is a warm,
the experience of a place. the material, not only for its recycled and the interior level. Ensuring that
approachable space that still feels sophisticated—perfect for
content, but also for the intrinsic, human comfort is met and hopefully
an idyllic resort town.
human qualities, durability and exceeds expectations is a prime goal
life cycle. for SFO. It is important for designers
to understand how human scaled
experiences impact the design. Will
people feel comfortable waiting for
their flight under enormously tall
ceilings? How are the acoustics in
these spaces? What about ventilation
and glare? How do the many
concessions’ needs, including proper
ventilation, loading and unloading
of goods, and branding, fit within the
architectural envelope? Too often
these elements must be retrofitted MADRID BARAJAS
into the design after completion.
Poorly conceived and implemented AIRPORT,
‘fixes’ end up distracting greatly from
the original architectural intent. SPAIN
Breathtakingly beautiful architecture
FOR DESIGNERS TO ceiling, also begins to enhance the space with a look and feel that
is atypical of most airports.
UNDERSTAND HOW
HUMAN SCALED
EXPERIENCES IMPACT
THE DESIGN.
JEFF
HENRY
ROLE: Principal and Design Director, Gensler FOCUS: Retail and Hospitality
WHAT HAS YOUR ROLE BEEN WHAT ARE SOME OF DO YOU HAVE ANY
IN PROJECTS AT SFO? THE SIMILARITIES AND WORDS OF ADVICE FOR
I served as Design Director for the DIFFERENCES TO THE FUTURE DESIGNERS?
interiors for T2. I’ve also played that role VARIOUS PROJECTS YOU’VE Make sure they have an understanding
for the Boarding Area E and currently the BEEN INVOLVED WITH? of what the major trends of the time are
T3 East Expansion project. I was also an and it’s important to not just go there and
In Terminal 2, we looked at Bay Area
adjunct member to the Design Review stop. It needs to have longevity beyond
neighborhoods and the micro-climates,
Committee when the concessions planning those trends. Be mindful of Gen X and
but rather than take the San Francisco
and buildout was occurring for T2. Gen Y who will be passengers and think
neighborhood concept literally, we looked
at it conceptually with ceiling heights and about how they use and want to experience
WHAT WAS THE compression of spaces coming together. the space.
INSPIRATION FOR Do something that can be adapted,
YOUR WORK AT SFO? For Terminal 3’s Boarding Area E, we
took a topographic approach. There was a morphed, changed, without ripping into
I realized I was not an Aviation and real connection to the landscape and the tons of infrastructure. Once the physical
Transportation designer which I thought airfield in that project. So it made sense to manifestation of that concept came into
was a good thing. I tried to bring a fresh tie it to the landscape and create more of a being, we’d have a longevity that would be
set of eyes with my retail and hospitality topographic approach. fresh even fifteen, twenty years from now.
experience. From that standpoint, I tried That is the key—to create a design that
not to think of how airports typically In thinking about concepts for T3, we captures the spirit of the moment but will
get built out. Typically they have a more wanted to do something different than the also have a life well beyond that.
corporate, institutional feel. Based topographic approach for B/A E. It made
on what I was hearing from SFO, it was sense that it was more of an atmospheric
time to think about the airport in approach. It was a little more ethereal.
different ways.
WHAT’S IT LIKE WORKING
Instead, I tried to think about the project WITH SFO?
as a retail, hospitality and education
project rather than a typical corporate SFO is a wonderful client to work for. They
project, blending all the different practice have a goal of Reaching for #1 and they’re
areas together. very committed to that. The relationship is
very forward thinking.
WHAT INSPIRES YOU?
Nature, Museums, Graphic Design,
Artists (Bay Area Figurists)
KOLEINI
ROLE AT SFO: Principal Architect, Chair of the Design Review Committee (DRC) TENURE AT SFO: 27 years
1 2 3
PLAN FOR CHANGE SPATIAL VOLUME COLOR + MATERIALITY
HOW HAS THE AIRPORT WHAT ARE SOME AREAS It is important that designers Rather than revisiting the typical Materiality should be an extension
CHANGED OVER THE YEARS? OF THE AIRPORT THAT acknowledge impermanence and formal world of airport interior of concept rather than a decision
Airports really have to make money. They NEED MORE ATTENTION? remain flexible concerning the many design with a main concourse flanked based purely on aesthetic or durability
are taking over all airport activity with There needs to be more emphasis on changes and evolutions in the world of by concessions, consider new and considerations. Consider, too, the
the exception of flying the planes. In the the checkpoint. aviation. Consider these changes interesting ways to shape space by many possibilities of adding color.
case of Schiphol airport, it started as a in the design. designing freestanding concessions When done with discretion, color can
shopping area first. Concessions have now WHAT ABOUT THE that create a more varied landscape enliven an otherwise dull space.
moved from pre-security to post-security.
AMENITIES? in the terminals. A variety of spaces,
WHERE HAVE YOU SEEN {Designers} need to think about amenities from those that encourage exploration
THE BEST DESIGN? as a part of the original architecture. to those that are efficiently driven,
That’s why it’s worked so well in T2. Right will ensure passenger satisfaction.
Singapore’s Changi airport has been able now we have inherited all these facilities
to incorporate greenery with a relaxing and figure out where things go after.
atmosphere. Having nature at the airport
is good for edgy, stressed-out passengers. WHAT OTHER AMENITIES
WOULD YOU LIKE TO
4 5
WHAT ROLE SHOULD DESIGN
SEE AT THE AIRPORT?
PLAY AT THE AIRPORT?
SFO used to have a hair salon and they
Design should calm people down. It couldn’t make it work in the end but I
needs to create a soothing, harmonious always thought it was a good idea. A salon FURNITURE PROGRAMMING
atmosphere. You can do this with greenery, might need to be integrated with another
lighting, and sounds. concession or service to help it. Tandem seating is the ‘go to’ furniture While much of the program at the
It would be great to have a place to nap, type for airports. However, lounge airport is set, there still remains
a sleeping pod, that one can rent for a and work furniture should be added plenty of opportunities for new
couple of hours. to enhance the passenger experience. programming possibilities. The yoga
SFO has adopted the T2 furniture room, for instance, is the home of
program as their new standard. Find a future secure connector but has
opportunities to provide a variety received widespread praise and
of waiting, working and lounging appreciation from passengers.
seating configurations!
Technology
Behind the Scenes Technologies recompose areas and concessions.
Technology should not be thought of Conversely, self boarding units are large
as an end, but rather a tool that has and may affect seat counts in hold room
REPLACE
the power to enable SFO to deliver a areas. Understanding and facilitating
premium passenger experience. Long these new operational components will
recognized as a leader in the tech become important in the future at SFO.
field -- with Silicon Valley and the Psychological Comfort
Bay Area delivering the most cutting
As touched upon in the health and
edge technologies so many of us now
wellbeing chapter, psychological
take for granted -- SFO is in a prime
comfort is a key component of passenger
position to utilize its local resources
satisfaction. Technology has the
and deliver outstanding technological
unique advantage of being a flexible,
services as well as memorable
changeable tool that, with the right
additions to the passenger journey.
infrastructure, can do tremendous
work in mitigating passenger stress.
SELF SERVICE
In the very near future, the airport environment
could be almost entirely self service. Self check,
bag and board are being implemented seperately
or together all over the world with varying degrees
of success. SFO supports the self check process
IN PERSON seamlessly and is beginning to work with some
In-person communication is crucial, airlines to incorporate self boarding into the
especially for passengers whose needs aren’t holdroom layout. Designers should be aware of the
addressed elsewhere, passengers unfamiliar implications these new systems have on space.
with technology, and passengers who require COMMON USE SELF SERVICE UNITS
special assistance.
As freestanding, SFO-operated check-in units at
TRADITIONAL COMMUNICATIONS SFO, the Common Use Self Service (CUSS) kiosks
Most people who travel through SFO will rely, provide basic technologies for checking into a flight.
at least somewhat, on traditional wayfinding The aesthetics should be cohesive campus-wide.
devices such as directional signage and gate WI-FI
numbers. Additionally, signage for amenities
PHYSICAL TECHNOLOGIES Not always considered an operational element,
and unexpected elements that a passenger
free and fast wi-fi is now a must-have. Passengers
SFO provides a number of physical didn’t realize were available may add delight
expect the wi-fi to not only be free and accessible,
elements that assist in communicating to to the journey.
but have the capacity to stream video and music
the passenger and aiding them on their
without difficulty.
journey. This sector is growing and SFO
is unveiling a new “Flight Deck” -- a new BEHIND THE SCENES
platform for providing fun and engaging The airport relies on a variety of technologies to
experience for passengers through cutting function. Consider the amount of hardware and
edge technologies. coordination for security screening throughout
all the spaces alone. It’s important that designers
remember these technologies and consider them
in renovations and new construction.
C
through the e ntire journey.
onsider that passengers coming from all over
the world have very different communication
modalities. Culturally, we read signage differently,
walk on different sides of the street and say hello and
goodbye in thousands of different ways. It is important to
note where the users are visiting from or going to and to
understand these nuances in order to provide a positive SFO
experience for all.
SMARTPHONE
SHOPPING WALL
FRANKFURT INTL.
Innovative Technology
CHECKPOINT OF
THE FUTURE, IATA
TECHNOLOGY AND THE PASSENGER EXPERIENCE
WADE ALAN
/
Strategies for implementing Technology
FORST SHIMOIDE
ROLES: Director, Emerging Experiences & Senior Technical Architect, Razorfish
1 2 3
WAIT TIME TECHNOLOGIES MOBILE ACCESS ENGAGING TECHNOLOGIES
WHAT ARE SOME TRENDS WHAT ABOUT TECHNOLOGY There’s opportunity at the front of the
IN TECHNOLOGY LOOKING AND ADVERTISING? airport for inbound passengers. Data is
Adding wait time technologies at It is important to recognize that Engaging technologies could
getting smarter and faster and as a result,
FIVE YEARS OUT? You need to consider context and place. linger times may decrease. security checkpoints will help detract mobile access is the way of the future manifest in so many different ways.
1. There will be more technology In the example of Clear Channel, they from the discomfort of the security and more and more passengers will As the airport continues to undergo
wanted to use bathroom mirrors for For outbound passengers, it’s important process and engage the passenger rely on their mobile device to complete renovation, consider how technology
in public spaces.
advertisements. It might have worked if to increase the understanding of rental
in the positive portion of their the basics of travel. They will also can act as a tool of engagement and
2. There will be more computer vision car information and information about
it said it was sponsored by Dove soap... journey. Adding walk time to gates at look to mobile technology to provide make the passenger journey more
and augmented reality, with a reliance the city.
you need to think of how you advertise as
on big data. recompose areas will help passengers content supplementing the leisure pleasant, unique and memorable.
opposed to just advertising space. There Another opportunity is to have
3. Consumers will have more should be subtle advertising. plan their journey to the gate and parts of their journey.
customized wayfinding -- how to get
wearable computing. understand better whether they have
baggage and get to certain transportation.
HOW ELSE CAN time to stop off at a concession.
4. Being able to retreat from technology
will be equally as important.
TECHNOLOGY BE HOW DO YOU DESIGN FOR
INTEGRATED IN THE
5
THE FUTURE?
5. There will be greater profiling,
everyone will be collecting data on you.
PASSENGER EXPERIENCE?
Imagine if you had to have a full body scan
You make mistakes. Give yourself
room to fail.
4 6
WHAT ABOUT TECHNOLOGY at the airport for security but that data can SELF SERVICE DYNAMIC SIGNAGE BIG DATA
AND RETAIL? then be sent to Nordstrom’s to tell them
the perfect fit of jeans for you.
Retail will change though maybe not Technology is reshaping the Dynamic signage will undoubtedly A leading technology trend now
so much at the airport. It’s all about The security line is a captive audience, operations and customer service change the face of wayfinding and is the tracking of big data for the
convenience, service, make it more wait times can be used for impulse buys, experience at airports world wide. signage systems at SFO and elsewhere. customization of advertisements and
of a destination and provide (Caveat: I think they did this at Target too Check in, bag tag and boarding are While it should not be done for the customer experiences. This type of
destination content. where they lined the queue with product. It
all trending toward self service. sake of being done and should ideally customization will begin showing up
failed horribly and they changed the lines
Retail personnel will now become the only be used at places where content with increasing frequency.
back to just being a line. )
empowered associate, you won’t need to changes regularly, it is important to
queue up anymore...you’ll be able to tap
ensure that the placement and housing
a magazine and purchase it. But people
will always be there as experts and for these signs is in place.
holders of knowledge.
The Airport
Journey
3 7 8 12 13
Checkpoint Concessions 9 11 Arts &
14 15
2 6 16
Waiting & Exhibits Meet &
10
Play Areas Passenger Greet
Lounge Baggage
5
Amenities Arrivals
1 Ticketing Claim
Concourse
4
Curbside Connectors
Restrooms
& Tunnels
Approach Plazas
Recompose
OSE PLAZ
OMP AS
REC
CO
I NT NC
PO OU
E CK RS
H E
1
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Approach
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
Convenience & Arts & Locality & Time &
RR S
Wayfinding
A RB
RO
Hospitality Culture Sense of Place Efficiency
O
C
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
T
he Approach is the front door of the terminal transparency of function while supporting the customer’s
and sets the passenger’s first impression of SFO. needs for clear wayfinding. Frequent travelers can often
Visitors to the various airport terminals arrive whiz through this area but passengers new to the airport
via very different modes of transport: by taxi or private oftentimes rely on wayfinding in this area to take them to
car, by AirTrain after a journey from BART, from parking, Ticketing or Checkpoint. This is the first impression of the
from the rental car facility, or from one of the tunnels airport and therefore key in setting a standard for the rest
from connecting terminals. As a public transportation of the passenger experience.
hub, the exterior should impart a sense of civic pride with
Approach
Ticketing
Checkpoint
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits
Convenience THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim & Hospitality Arts & Culture □□ Connection to the City □□ Wayfinding
Consider the Approach as a connection to Establish a hierarchy of visual
Arrivals Curbside
Passenger stress is typically found San Francisco has a rich culture the city and a first impression of the airport. information and signage. Ensure
Connectors & Tunnels What message does it convey? visibility into the building from the
to be higher in the pre-security areas and the Approach is a link between
exterior, paying particular attention to the
and this begins with the Approach.
Care should be given to make it
the airport interior and the rest
of the city. Consider a unique,
□□ Key Entrances ease with which airlines can be located.
Consider the different means of Approach, i.e. Provide clear exterior terminal identification.
convenient for passengers. Providing distinguishable facade that
via car, taxi, train, or pedestrian approach
a welcoming entry, transparency of
the functions held within and clarity
harmonizes with the SFO campus.
There are also opportunities for
from another terminal. Identify the key □□ Daylighting
entrances especially as they relate to Examine how daylighting affects manned
of knowing where to go next in this commissioned art in this area as
wayfinding. How does the entrance set the spaces, such as curbside check-in. Provide
area can positively impact the design. it can act as a photo opportunity
tone for the overall experience? shading to mitigate direct sunlight on
and leave a lasting impression on a
monitors and screens.
passenger’s experience. □□ Technology
BUSINESS
PASSENGERS Locality & Consider interactive wayfinding. Are there
Efficiency
an easy gateway to the rest of the
The airport is such a distinctive
airport. Some experienced travelers
environment and one that is a point
go straight to Checkpoint.
of civic pride and a kind of handshake
SOME ESSENTIALS
It is crucial that passengers have a
FAMILY
from the city. Iconic architectural
clear path of approach to ensure an □□ Information Processing □□ Services
features such as the facade of the Individuals can only process six pieces Coordinate with Revenue Development for
PASSENGERS efficient and timely beginning to their
International Terminal and the newly of information at a time. What pieces of tenants such as Smarte Cartes and determine
journey. Essentially, make it as easy as
This is an important area for family constructed control tower all have information does the passenger need to know any special requirements for power.
passengers to transition into the possible for passengers to find and get
important placemaking abilities. at the Approach?
airport. Provide plenty of seating
options for them to gather.
to where they need to be.
□□ Additional Amenities
□□ Airline Regulations Additional amenities such as curbside check-
Coordinate with airlines for curbside check-in in counters, smoking areas, pet relief areas,
ASSISTED
PASSENGERS
Wayfinding kiosks. Balance airline branding with SFO- pre-security concessions and alternative
specific terminal exterior. seating should be considered in the Approach.
Every passenger’s journey in the
Assistance for Assisted Passengers
should be readily available in the airport begins with the Approach. □□ HVAC Systems □□ Electrical Lighting
Approach to help them through the From this point on the passenger Maintain positive/negative airflow at Ensure that there is proper evening light
rest of their journey. entry vestibules. levels at curb and building entry.
will need to navigate through
the architecture to get to their
destination. Facilitating a
UNIQUE seamless journey from the very
PASSENGERS
beginning is important.
Make Pet Relief and Smoking
areas easy to spot and access.
1 2
more than 50% of those passengers, stress tends t
Create The Airport as o be higher in pre-security areas, which aligns Jackson Hole
3 Transparency
to Activity
As a public institution and a transit
hub, the exterior of the Terminals
should have a civic spirit that conveys
transparency and supports passengers
needs for clear and easy wayfinding.
Seeing a glimpse of the process in the
building may also help reduce stress.
2
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Ticketing
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
Technology Time & Convenience &
I
Look & Feel
O
Efficiency Hospitality
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
T + ART
MEE S+
T
he early stages of a service experience are important designs to create a cohesive experience adds a level of
in determining customers’ perceptions of the sophistication appropriate for SFO. The proximity to
service encounter to follow, in what is called the security queuing adds another layer of complexity in this
“halo effect.”1 As a visitor’s first point of contact with the area, and the journey from ticketing to security should
airline, make sure Ticketing creates an intuitive experience be considered in the design. Accessible views, cohesive
that passengers can easily breeze through, setting a tone look and feel and access to information are all elements
for the rest of their airport experience. This zone is layered that make the passenger experience free of stress and
with a generous circulation path, a defined queuing zone, more enjoyable.
and the ticket counters themselves. Working with airline
Ticketing
Checkpoint
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits Time & THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim Technology Efficiency □□ Branding
Embrace and guide airline branding. Are
□□ Passenger Flow
Take into account the various methods of
Arrivals Curbside
Technology is perhaps the number Self service technologies have made there opportunities to make the brand more check in: standard check-in counters, self-
Connectors & Tunnels visible? Is the branding visible when you walk check-in, baggage wrap. How do each of these
one driver in terms of changing the the ticketing process essentially
Ticketing area. Ubiquitous use of optional, especially for passengers in the door so customers can quickly make get incorporated into the flow of the general
mobile devices such as smart phones who aren’t checking luggage. Self a decision about where to go? Examine the Ticketing area?
and tablets will decrease the need for amount of queue space. Is there ample space
physical check-in counter. Passengers
service in this area has made it
far more efficient and less time for the ebb and flow of different queues? □□ Flight Information
Provide locations for Flight Information
will become more adept at self-service
and as technology continues to reduce
consuming. The question remains
how this will evolve in the future.
□□ Stress Alleviation Displays (FIDs). Ensure that FIDs and BIDs
Think about opportunities to convey are appropriately located.
in size, the amount of space required Consider future flexibility of these
information to passengers such as expected
will as well. spaces in anticipation of more
wait times through security or airline □□ Space
changes. Keep passengers Allow ample space in the Ticketing lobby for
departure times. Ticketing can be a stressful
engaged and informed with wait people to orient themselves to their journey
Convenience
moment. What are some methods of
time technologies. and make initial decisions.
alleviating passenger stress?
& Hospitality
BUSINESS
PASSENGERS There is an increasing focus in air
Look & Feel SOME ESSENTIALS
ASSISTED
PASSENGERS
For passengers who need mobile
assistance, Ticketing is one of the
first areas in the airport where they
can seek wheelchair assistance.
1 2
Time Efficiency Greater Self
Equals Space Service & the
Efficiency DIY Experience
Electronic ticketing, electronic check- Self check-in, self bag tagging, self
in kiosks and boarding pass printing boarding are all processes that are
stations, are all designed to help leading to a self-service generation. As
passengers save time. Airlines’ use of a result of different applications and
these services not only means saved technologies available, the customer
time but also saved space. Ticketing and is able to determine the key physical
check-in areas will likely shrink in size touchpoints with airport services. Now
while others continue to grow (such as passengers who choose to do so can go
Checkpoint and Recompose areas).4 straight to Checkpoint by checking
in online and downloading their
Less area may be needed but greater
boarding pass to their phone. Airport
integration of techologies will need to be
technologies that support active
incorporated in the planning and design
interaction rather than following a
of these spaces.
fixed path will continue to be an asset.
3 4
Radio
Paperless Frequency
Travelers Identification DEPARTING changi departures hall
3
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Checkpoint
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
Convenience & Health & Technology Time & Efficiency
O
Hospitality Wellbeing
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
T
he Checkpoint is by far the most stressful point consultant should consider what elements such as lighting,
in the airport journey. While the Checkpoint is finishes and furniture can add a calming influence for
governed by TSA standards, the overall design the often stressful checkpoint experience. Additionally,
should work in concert with the adjacent design of pre- the design of this space should build anticipation for a
and post-security zones. It is especially important that welcoming post-security experience. Finishes and other
the TSA zone and the SFO zone are clearly defined so that elements can add a warmth and a calm feel to this area.
there is a mutual understanding of responsibility. SFO Impactful color and lighting at crucial points in checkpoint
goes above and beyond recommended TSA standards for fit and in spaces immediately after the Checkpoint, give
and finish of this zone to ensure a more cohesive passenger passengers something to look forward to during the
experience. Once the TSA requirements are met, the design Checkpoint experience.
Checkpoint
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits Convenience Health & THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim & Hospitality Wellbeing □□ Peak Periods
Utilization can fluctuate during different
□□ Security Equipment
Consider the footprint of security equipment
Arrivals Curbside
The Checkpoint is one of the most Stress levels are high while passengers times of the day, week and year. How can and TSA guidelines and standards in the
Connectors & Tunnels the Checkpoint area expand during peak design of the space. Be mindful of visually
stressful areas in the airport. The TSA wait in Checkpoint queues which can
currently offers expedited service by stretch during peak travel periods. moments? How can it contract? obstructive elements in the space that might
conflict with camera angles.
allowing airline passengers to leave Providing a view to what is beyond (a
□□ Flexibility and Adaptability
their shoes on, wear light outerwear
and keep their belts and laptops
light at the end of the tunnel) can help
invoke a sense of calm to passengers
Constant reorganization requires the space □□ Passenger Experience
to be incredibly flexible over time. How can Provide a comfortable, calm environment.
for a fee of $85. Consider ways of waiting to pass through.
future-proofing be achieved? How can change Think about different finishes, lighting,
integrating hospitality design into
be embraced? visibility and acoustic elements. How
this area. Consider expanding beyond
Time &
can psychological elements (i.e. music) be
the typical gray and blue palette □□ Customer Service incorporated? What amenities should
usually found in these areas to create
Efficiency
Consider the employee experience. How be provided?
BUSINESS a warmer, more inviting atmosphere. can the design have a positive effect on
PASSENGERS customer service?
Consider adding a ‘precompose’ area—
Ensure that checkpoints are a designated space where people can prepare
□□ The Queue
Business passengers often need to get
through lines quickly. Make sure there designed to provide sufficient capacity for the Checkpoint.
is a line for business class passengers
and that technology for electronic
boarding passes is readily available.
Technology for the amount of passengers serviced.
Proper planning can increase
Research the queuing process and how to
make it more enjoyable. For example, direct □□ Information Display
Provide locations for Flight Information
As technology continues to efficiency and decrease passenger views to the Recompose and Concessions
Displays (FIDs)
evolve, passengers now have the wait time. provide positive reinforcement of the
FAMILY option to check-in and download journey ahead. Combine with technology
PASSENGERS boarding passes on their mobile to provide grab and go pre-order or some
Children are often restless devices. Consider areas where new sort of entertainment.
and the line can seem endless. technologies can be integrated with
Provide entertainment either by
the overall queuing process to make
way of technology or through the
architecture to distract passengers it a more enjoyable experience. Digital SOME ESSENTIALS
from the length of the queue. displays and mobile technology
can provide information and
□□ TSA Regulations and Standards □□ Technical Criteria
Required elements should be coordinated Be mindful of heating and cooling loads.
ASSISTED entertainment for passengers to
with TSA and SFO. Verify that surveillance Carpeted areas must utilize carpet tiles
PASSENGERS make use of their idle time.
equipment is included and that TSA-required for maintenance and access to changing
Make this area as easy as possible for light levels are documented in the lighting plan. electrical needs in the floor.
Assisted Passengers to pass through.
Ensure circulation is wide enough for
wheelchairs to pass easily. Having a
□□ Airline Regulations □□ Security Constraints
Security constraints such as shoe removal
separate queue or priority placement
in line for Assisted Passengers
□□ Vendors can slow down the queue. Is there something
would be helpful. Also consider the Ensure room for branding and equipment for within the design of the environment that can
difficulties some passengers have third party vendors such as Clear, etc.
getting personal wheelchairs and help ease this process?
medical equipment.
1 2
Entertaining Technology Easing
Environmental Wait Time
Experience Frustrations
Rather than designing the Checkpoint as Waiting in the security line can be one of the
a straightforward queue, think of ways to biggest stress factors when traveling. Look
entertain and inform the passenger. The queue for different strategies to help mitigate these
can be an environmental experience beyond frustrations such as Trak-a-Line, which is a
just being a security requirement. The Las service that emails passengers when there’s
Vegas airport entertains and informs queuing a change in the Security Checkpoint wait
passengers with videos featuring prominent times or Blue Eye Video which provides data
Las Vegas performers demonstrating what’s on the checkpoint line to reduce checkpoint
to come in the Security Checkpoint. This is queues and waiting times. Consider too how
a great opportunity to let passengers know to improve the checkpoint queue experience.
about concessions—possibly allowing them This is a wonderful opportunity to provide
to pre-order--shopping and entertainment. information about art exhibits, shopping
Amusement parks like Disneyland or Magic and dining.
Mountain design an experience for queuing
visitors. Signage can communicate how long
the wait is from a certain location which helps
the passenger judge the amount of time it will
take to get to their destination. SFO T2 security
CONNECTING
3
checkpoint
Provide different finishes and materials PASSENGERS
in the Checkpoint area to define it. Allow
adequate space and views to areas beyond The Checkpoint can be considered the one
to put passengers at ease.
4
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Recompose
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
Health & Wayfinding Look & Feel Arts & Culture
O
Wellbeing
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
T
he Recompose zone is located immediately past The purpose of the Recompose area is to create a passenger
post-security. The concept of providing a physical mind-shift from “have to” (getting through Checkpoint)
space to regroup after the checkpoint experience to “want to” (being able to shop, dine and relax.) This area
evolved out of a practical need for passengers to have a should incorporate uplifting approaches to materiality,
place to collect personal items. The larger goal, however, access to daylight, overall lighting, furniture and art.
is to make this area a moment where passengers can Incorporating a FID location and hydration station with
psychologically regroup and begin to take in the delightful moments of surprise and delight help define the intended
aspect of the airport experience to come. experience of this zone.
Checklist
Checkpoint
Values
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits
Health & THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim Wellbeing Wayfinding □□ Circulation □□ Passenger Experience
Consider circulation flow from Checkpoint Acknowledge the psychological shift from
Arrivals Curbside
Creating a space to mentally shift One of the first things a passenger to Recompose to other areas of the airport. the Checkpoint area to the recompose areas
Connectors & Tunnels What are the needs in the Recompose area? (e.g. passengers are significantly less stressed
passengers from the Checkpoint area will do after they’ve passed through
is not an easy task. Consider this area Checkpoint is look for the Flight How should boundaries be established to after checkpoint.) How can the Recompose
to be a calm zone, where people have Information Display (FID) to verify define the zone? area make passengers feel at ease? Can the
space challenge assumptions? (e.g. implement
ample space and time to re-arrange
themselves and their belongings.
their gate location and determine
how much time they have before
□□ Wayfinding Flight Deck— see page 133)
Incorporate wayfinding in the Recompose
Terminal 2 highlights this area with
access to the airport’s Yoga Room.
boarding. Make sure this information
is readily available and visible for
area. Allow for easy orientation and visibility □□ Finishes & Fixtures
to concessions. Are there opportunities to Incorporate elements which can humanize
passengers, without interfering with
incorporate interactive maps to different the experience; comfortable seating, lighting,
the circulation. Also consider the
concessions and gates? artwork, plants, impactful finishes and
implementation of wayfinding maps,
materials. How do these elements work
Look & Feel concessionaire maps and a new SFO
flight deck.
□□ Lighting
Think about the lighting of the area. How can
together in the design? Consider slightly
higher seating to facilitate the needs of
Look & Feel can add to the overall natural light be optimized? How can it set the elderly travelers.
ambiance of the space, particularly in mood for the space?
reinforcing the idea of a quiet, calm
Arts & Culture □□ Information Display
area. Finishes and furniture should be □□ Ad Space & SFO Marketing Opportunies Provide locations for Flight Information
comforting and comfortable. Consider Outline areas where advertising can be Displays (FIDs).
Recompose is an excellent location
elements such as a raised ceiling with integrated into the overall planning of
for implementing commissioned art
natural light (if applicable), adjacency the space.
pieces. Because it is an important
to restrooms, and floor finish as a
visual boundary. Provide an element
wayfinding and decision touch point, □□ Lighting
the addition of an art ‘landmark’ would Use natural light to intuitively guide
LEISURE that is unexpected at an airport, be it be welcome.
PASSENGERS passengers towards the gates ahead.
art, architecture or lighting--a moment
This area is full of opportunities of surprise & delight and visual
for the Leisure Passenger to gather
themselves and see what amenities
relaxation. SOME ESSENTIALS
are available in the airport before
they need to board their flight. □□ TSA Regulations and Standards □□ Space Constraints
Most existing airport terminals do not
□□ Airline Regulations include adequate space for a Recompose area.
FAMILY
PASSENGERS □□ Flight Deck How can the architecture integrate both the
Recompose area after Checkpoint? Consider
Consider integration of the new Flight Deck in
For a large family, this area is integrating a ceiling element for visual effect
the Recompose area.
particularly useful as a waiting area with minimal space impact.
for everyone to gather while others
are still going through security, using
the restroom, or putting themselves
and their belongings back together.
1 2
Amenities SFO TERMINAL 2
RECOMPOSE AREA
Expanding Related to Provide clear views of the
Areas Recompose
Recompose area from the
Checkpoint to give passengers
a sense of ease about what’s
to come. Use art installations
The Recompose area is a relatively new The Recompose area sits adjacent to
and comfortable seating to give
area to airports and has evolved from the the Checkpoint and either Concourse
passengers a moment of respite.
expansion of the Security Checkpoint or Concessions areas. As such, it can
area since 9/11. The first Recompose area contain programming that begins to
at SFO was in Terminal 2; it creates a blend the two adjacencies. Yoga rooms,
space that passengers can decompress meditation rooms, business lounges,
and recompose themselves and their restrooms, and hydration stations are
luggage after going through Checkpoint. all different types of programming
Expect to see increased areas allocated to to consider when planning the
Checkpoint and Recompose areas. Recompose area.
3 4
Decrease
A Respite from Stress through
Technology Art & Nature
While technology continues to advance Art decreases stress and increases
and astound us, creating spaces that socialization and sense of
provide a haven from technology is community. It can also be used as a
important. Consider the Recompose area way to entertain and engage people. DEPARTING &
as such a space -- giving passengers a sense
of calm as they gather themselves. Limit
Similarly, natural elements have
been shown to have a calming effect. CONNECTING
the integration of technology to necessary
information boards that will help
After the stressful experience of the
Security Checkpoint, consider how to
PASSENGERS
passengers orient themselves, such as FIDs incorporate these elements into the
It can be said that the beginning of the passenger
and digital applications that entertain, recompose area.
journey is more anxiety-producing, thus having
rather than overwhelm, passengers. This
a relaxing, stress-free area, void of queues
might be a great opportunity for a flight
and restrictions, is important for the overall
deck, but not a good opportunity for digital
passenger experience.
advertisements or promotions.
Provide views to the Recompose area from the
Checkpoint for all passengers to feel at ease.
Introduce an element of fun through social spaces
that can appeal to all.
5
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Plazas
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
Wayfinding Look & Feel Arts & Culture Revenue
O
C
Generation
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
P
lazas mark major circulation intersections within should also be considered. Specifically, cafes with unique
the airport. They are an opportunity to make an seating areas could engage and activate adjacent circulation
impactful, memorable experience for passengers. zones and blur the division between spaces, enhancing the
Each plaza should be designed as a unique experience in overall flow. Unique FID enclosures, along with enhanced
order to reinforce its primary role as a wayfinding element. wayfinding signage are further examples of ways to
The scale of these spaces can lend themselves to a design distinguish these spaces.
approach not dissimilar from a grand urban space in a
Consider plaza nodes as major wayfinding decision points.
major city. Daylighting, enhanced electrical light, art and
Like the terminals, the plazas should be unique, with
dynamic architectural features should be considered.
individual characteristics, while still relating to one another.
Unique approaches to adjacent areas such as Concessions
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits
Wayfinding Look & Feel THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim Wayfinding is extremely important The physical attributes of Plazas
□□ Wayfinding □□ Finishes & Fixtures
Establish a hierarchy of visual Incorporate elements that can delight
Arrivals Curbside in the Plaza. Passengers in this space can serve as special moments in
information and signage. Does each passengers through their journey such
Connectors & Tunnels will be looking for the next point in a passenger’s journey. Each Plaza
Plaza have clear wayfinding? as natural light, high ceilings, greenery,
their destination so it is extremely should be visually distinct to decrease
artwork, and areas for rest. The space should
important to make the wayfinding confusion. □□ Circulation be grand, spacious and articulate a clear
clear and concise. Consider how circulation and cross- identity. Subtle cues in flooring materials can
circulation flows into and throughout Plazas. reinforce path of travel.
Revenue Where are key decision-making spots located?
□□ Integration of Art
Arts & Culture Generation □□ Approaches & Exits Determine early on the desire for
Consider the different approaches, i.e. commissioned art pieces and their impact on
Architectural cues to wayfinding, As key decision points and places of inbound versus outbound passengers. What the design (structure, lighting, etc.).
which can also be found in Recompose architectural interest, Plazas are a information needs to be conveyed? How do
areas, mark a shift of space. Consider great opportunity to add concessions manned exits, as well as the structure and □□ Interactive Displays
how large-scale art installations and services. technology needed for “self-exiting”, work Consider the inclusion of a Flight Deck in the
BUSINESS with the space? space (see page 133).
PASSENGERS in the Plaza space might serve as
Forecast
SFO serves not only as an originating airport
for many travelers but oftentimes as a
major connection as well, in particular for
passengers going to Asia from the East Coast
or vice versa.
1 2
Information Displays (FIDs) prominently
Decreasing Stress will help Connecting Passengers navigate as
Phoenix airport
Nature & the through Natural they pass through the Plaza. Consider listing The Changi Airport provides
different types of lighting and clear
airlines and terminal information to make
Great Outdoors Elements
wayfinding in the Plaza spaces.
the Connecting Passenger experience easier.
3 Info Booth
With only one information booth currently
operating past security in B/A F, including
4 Technology &
Self Service
Plazas can also be a great place to include
touch screen information kiosks that help
more in the Plaza locations could help ease passengers answer their own questions.
the stress of lost or confused passengers and Consider locating them near info booths
even reassure those who are confident they are as a way to aggregate the ‘help’ section of
going the proper way. the Plaza and provide a productive wait
time for passengers waiting to speak with
a representative.
6
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Concourse
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
Wayfinding Look & Feel Arts & Culture
O
C
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
T
he concourse is defined as the main circulation It is important for the design team to engage with signage
zone post security. This zone varies in layout from teams at the beginning of the design process. Organize
terminal to terminal. Sometimes it is set between architectural components, lighting, advertising, art,
concessions on one side and gates on the other side. Other gate signage, etc. to create a hierarchy and reduce visual
times retail spaces line both sides and sometimes it’s a mix distraction. Use space wisely to create more passenger
of gates and retail spaces. amenity zones and moments of surprise and delight. While
planning, keep in mind support spaces that compete with
FID devices are crucial in this zone, as are generous entry
the passenger experience and locate them appropriately.
areas to restrooms. Aside from these considerations, this
zone has the opportunity to have a hospitality-inspired
feeling, using lounge seating, artwork and enhanced
lighting to compliment the concession zones and gates.
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits Wayfinding Look & Feel THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim Typically supporting bi-directional Concourses can be overlooked as mere
□□ Wayfinding □□ Circulation
Provide clear and easy visual access to gate Avoid congestion of the space. Outline
Arrivals Curbside circulation, Concourses are often passageways but they also provide
and restroom signage. Utilize the architecture areas where passengers may be able to linger
Connectors & Tunnels
between the terminals and plaza an opportunity to have finishes and
to provide visual cues and establish a clear without disrupting the flow of passenger
spaces or gates. Wayfinding and materials that mark transitions
hierarchy of wayfinding signage (see page 72). traffic. Consider including resting points and
visual cues should be clearly between spaces.
shorter moving sidewalk segments (where
delineated at each end of the □□ Adjacencies required) to break up long concourses.
concourse to ensure that passengers Consider adjacencies when designing the
are going the right direction. concourse. Are there concessions close by? □□ Finishes & Fixtures
How can areas be outlined using different Incorporate elements which can delight
Revenue treatments of material finishes and lighting? passengers through their journey: greenery,
artwork, areas for rest. How can finishes and
□□ Passenger Experience
Arts & Culture Generation Create nodes of activity using art
lighting provide subliminal cues to facilitate
circulation? How can the space communicate
exhibits, children’s play areas, etc. to aspirational qualities (e.g. civic pride)?
Some of the most memorable airport As passengers pass through the
BUSINESS delineate space. Provide visibility to gates
art exhibits can happen in the Concourse on their way to their gates,
PASSENGERS and to the exterior airfield.
Concourse as many pass through this think about what concessions might
Have charging stations near area. Consider having art be part be best for quick visits—or substantial
the Concourse area available
for business passengers who
of the immersive experience. It can enough for passengers to return to SOME ESSENTIALS
be wall-based or ceiling-mounted, once they have checked their gate.
□□ Circulation Constraints
are on the go. Other amenities
such as ATM’s, shoeshines and depending on space available.
restroom facilities should be
Congestion can be a major issue. Ensure
located along major circulation
paths for easier access. that the concourse remains a transitory part
of the journey, ensuring flow of passengers
to their destinations.
LEISURE
PASSENGERS Convenience
Having rotating art exhibits in the
space can invigorate the Concourse,
such as the exhibits which can be
& Hospitality
found in SFO T3. Consider that the Concourse can act
as more than just as straight shot to
the gates. If planned appropriately,
FAMILY the Concourse can create a
PASSENGERS hospitality-like atmosphere. Consider
Safety first! Make sure people welcoming finishes, respites of lounge
movers or moving walkways are
or cafe seating and opportunities to
safely installed and are organized
to help rather than hinder overall rest along the way.
circulation flow.
1 Integration
of Nature
With an increased focus on sustainability
2 Using Art as
Landmarks
Consider breaking up the monotony
and the environment, consider ways of of a long concourse with art. T3 at
integrating nature into a Concourse space. SFO has a great example of this,
providing views to the airfield as
Seoul’s Incheon Airport (ICN) has wide
well has housing a first class rotating
concourses, brightly illuminated with
exhibit that provides a treat to both
daylight. Glazing is continued in the
new visitors and seasoned travelers.
boarding areas, blending the spaces.
Consider all architectural elements
when thinking of integrating art.
Madrid-Barajas Airport (MAD) has
a fantastic sculptural ceiling with
3
brightly colored columns that convey
Transportation the creative expression of a large
architectural canvas.
via Different
Modes
In some SFO Concourse spaces, there
are currently people movers which help
passengers efficiently get across long
spans of space.
CONNECTING madrid bajaras
Airport
7
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Concessions
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
Locality & Revenue Look & Feel Sustainability
A RB
RO
I
Sense of Place Generation
O
C
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
T
he retail environment has an important influence layouts in favor of dining that focuses on the passenger
over the creation of a quality passenger experience. experience. Food and beverage tenants should be integrated
Passengers often rank the retail environment as the into the entire experience, easily accessible to gates. The
most positive part of their airport experience.7 designs should reflect that of higher-end restaurants and
cafes. Retail interiors should project a high standard of
The primary goal of the concession experience at SFO is
design commensurate with the quality of interiors found in
to be engaging, enjoyable and informal, featuring local
upscale lifestyle shopping centers. Careful consideration
culture and sustainable cuisine. Concessions are divided
should be given to storefront closure systems, primary and
into three categories; retail, food and beverage, and
secondary signage, and finishes and fixtures.
services. SFO has shifted away from traditional food court
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits Locality & Revenue THINGS TO CONSIDER
Sense of Place Generation □□ Sense of Place □□ Circulation
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim
Consider the identity of San Francisco and Think about creating different circulation
Arrivals Curbside
The airport is like a welcome mat to Providing a great passenger the local culture in the design. How can routes to allow passengers to both linger or
Connectors & Tunnels the Concessions give passengers a lasting walk through. Be strategic about balancing
the city and as such is oftentimes experience is key to revenue
a passenger’s first impression of generation at the airport. At SFO, impression of San Francisco? the need for visibility of the Concessions
and the view of the Gates. Consider
San Francisco. The concessions
program at SFO is intrinsically
revenue generation is tied to bringing
local businesses and providing a sense
□□ Authenticity orientation and visual cues and their
Consider the secondary and tertiary impact on passengers.
linked with local vendors, bringing of the Bay Area culture.
characteristics that make San Francisco
the unique culture of San Francisco
to the airport.
unique (i.e. food culture, art, outdoor □□ Passenger Experience
activities such as cycling, climbing and Provide choice and stretch out the
hiking.) How can these be incorporated Concessions zone, as it is the prime source of
into the Concessions area? revenue. Consider adjacencies to other spaces
such as Concourses and Waiting + Lounge
□□ Visibility areas when planning Concessions.
BUSINESS Allow visibility to Gates.
PASSENGERS
Look & Feel Sustainability
Business passengers familiar
with the airport should have easy
SOME ESSENTIALS
The airport is such a distinctive It is crucial that passengers have a
access to newsstands and Wi-Fi
access. Other amenities to help environment and one that is a point of clear path of approach to ensure an □□ Linger time □□ Concession Design Guidelines
in their business travel such as civic pride and a kind of handshake of efficient and timely beginning to their Passengers are typically either in motion or Refer to SFO-provided guidelines
electronic accessories or gift
shops are helpful. the city. Iconoic architectural features journey. Essentially, make it as easy as glued to the gate. How can the Concessions for design tenants.
such as the facade of the International possible for passengers to find and get space be enticing for passengers to linger?
Terminal and the newly constructed to where they need to be.
LEISURE control tower all have important □□ Space constraints
PASSENGERS placemaking abilities. Square area is limited in the Concessions area.
UNIQUE
PASSENGERS
Unique passengers also have
unique needs. Make sure to have
a variety of concessions available
to appeal to different interests
and tastes.
1 2
SFO International Terminal
for creating an enjoyable starting point for the Natalie’s Candy Jar is one of the highest
journey. Consider using other methods of social revenue-generating concessions at SFO
Say Goodbye to A Link engagement such as social media or technology to Terminal 2 and it’s easy to see why. Large
jars of candy and a colorful, well-designed
add another layer of adventure in travel.
the Generic to the City environment gives passengers a moment of
delight in their journey.
3 4
Connecting
Through New Planning
Technology Typologies
Consider how technology has changed Concessions have traditionally been
the way we do things and how this can be located separately and away from the
integrated in the airport experience. New holdrooms. However, by integrating
York’s John F Kennedy Airport (JFK) has the two, concessionaires have an
a concierge service that allows passengers opportunity to be folded into the fabric
to sit, log in to a central site and order of the waiting experience and anxious
food to be delivered to them at the gate, travelers who don’t feel comfortable
giving them an opportunity to have a leaving their gate don’t have to!
seat and keep track of their family and
baggage. Consider other ways technology
has changed the retail experience such as
the Apple store, with roving salespeople
who can provide information on demand
and help expedite transactions.
8
K PO OU
RS
EC E
H
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
JOURNEY MOMENT
ET
SS
CK
IO
TI
NS
Waiting &
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
Lounge
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
AS RE
K EY VA LUE S
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
I
U
Health & Wayfinding Look & Feel Technology
O
C
M
Wellbeing
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
T
hese areas, also referred to as 'hold rooms’, have a size growth and the trend in self boarding and the consequent
variety of issues to be considered in their planning. effects on seat counts. Hold rooms should be planned to
Seating quantity and proper circulation are the increase passengers’ visual connections to the gate and airfield
most important functional considerations. Circulation at beyond. This visual connection helps alleviate stress. Visual
aisles, between seating, and surrounding the gate podium access to FIDs is also desired. Other considerations include
and jet bridge entry is critical in a successful layout. moments of surprise and delight. For example, lounge chairs
Another consideration is maximizing the comfort and and bench seating create more options for passengers and add
variety of seating types. While the majority of seating visual excitement. Incorporation of art, technology, skylights
might be tandem style with powered tables placed in line etc. add additional layers of interest in the environment.
every 3-4 seats to facilitate appropriate seat counts, lounge Lastly, in an effort to afford the best customer experience
configurations and work counters with power access are possible and provide consistent, productive wait times,
welcome additions. ADA guidelines for work counters, integrating concessions into the hold rooms is a great way to
along with a percentage of space allowed for wheelchairs impact customer satisfaction and bolster revenue generation.
at the ends of tandem runs should be incorporated. Lastly,
planning should take into consideration the future fleet
186 S A N F R A NCIS C O I N T E R NAT IONA L A I R P ORT 187
Key Opportunities
J OU R NEY M OM ENTS
Approach
Ticketing
Checkpoint
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
1 2
Cues From
Hospitality The Restorative
Design Effect of Art
The possibility of meeting new people and A study on the impact of visual art on
learning new things can offset the stress waiting behavior found that visual
of travel when the environment is relaxing images correlated with a significant
and engaging. Having a variety of seating reduction in restless behavior 8 and an
and spaces at the Waiting + Lounge area increase in socialization. Integrating
is important for passengers who have art in waiting areas can have a
different ergonomic needs and desires restorative effect, combating travel
to socialize. fatigue and providing a measure of
mental relief.
3 Technology as
Distraction
A survey of 6,000 travelers by Carlson
4 New Service
Types
Consider new ways of providing
Wagonlit Travel (CWT) found that service to the holdrooms. One method
unpleasant surprises like flight delays and gaining popularity is food delivery—a
luggage loss were the highest triggers of service that brings orders from airport
stress. Their Travel Index also found that restaurants and concessionaires directly
frequent fliers get most stressed from
“lost time”.9 Consider how technology can
to a customer’s gate. This new service,
along with mobile restaurants and
DEPARTING &
be used to distract passengers from the digital innovations for entertainment CONNECTING
time spent waiting, make sure there are
plenty of outlets available for passengers
and shopping, promises many
opportunities for the future holdroom
PASSENGERS
to charge their mobile devices and Wi-Fi waiting experience!
Make sure there are a variety of spaces available
is readily accessible for passengers. At
in the Waiting & Lounge area. All passengers have
LAX, device to display interactivity is
different needs; some are traveling with pets, some
being introduced so that passengers can
need privacy and others need to feel reassured
use their mobile devices to interact with
before boarding a plane.
displays. In addition to being able to view
images and videos and listen to music, Regardless of who they are, having a variety
passengers can connect their device with of furniture types can help all passengers feel
digital signage, engaging in a multi- comfortable and at ease prior to take-off.
sensory experience.
9
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Play Areas
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
Locality &
A RB
Arts & Culture
RO
Look & Feel Health &
Sense of Place
O
Wellbeing
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
T + ART
MEE S+
P
lay areas at SFO are dedicated areas that allow go beyond the immediate entertainment goal. Play areas
children to have both active and quiet play prior must respond visually to all ages. Consider a balance, if
to boarding flights. These areas are ideally located required, between active and quiet play, particularly when
next to seating for adult supervision or food and beverage the play areas are located adjacent to Waiting + Lounge
concessions, based on available concourse square footage. areas. In some instances SFO may engage the SF Arts
Active play areas must have appropriate code mandated Commission to commission an artist to conceptualize the
fall zones and resilient flooring. These issues might require design. The design consultant shall assist the artist in the
a landscape architect to resolve. Play areas benefit from consideration of their solution in connection to the Play
being partially contained so as to not impact concourse Area design and its implementation. Play areas are an
circulation. Integrated seating provides another level opportunity to create a 'wow factor.’ Whether encouraging
of comfort and convenience and design consultants are quiet or active play, or both, these areas should be
encouraged to be creative in their response to these areas. inspiring to children and adults alike.
Due to the visibility of play areas at SFO, the design must
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits Locality & Arts & Culture THINGS TO CONSIDER
Sense of Place □□ Look & Feel □□ Choice
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim Many Play Areas in the airport are the
Put yourself in the shoes of a child. What Provide options for both active and quiet
Arrivals Curbside result of a collaboration with a local
Play Areas are a great opportunity would appeal to your inner child? What play. How can technology (e.g. touch screen
Connectors & Tunnels
artist. Incorporating art that is meant
to bring in local flavor or sense of would you like to discover? How can adults be devices) be integrated for both child and adult
to be played on or with is a way to
place. Collaborations with artists accommodated and delighted as well? interactive play?
incorporate beautiful and functional
facilitate this naturally, but consider
the favorite places to play for San
spaces throughout the terminals. □□ Adjacencies □□ Small Footprint Play
Consider the adjacent areas; provide noise Consider ways to engage children with a very
Francisco families as well. Places in
or visual buffers to limit disruption to small or no designated physical area. Some
San Francisco like the Exploratorium
other passengers. ideas might be a projected interactive game on
and the California Academy of
Sciences are designed to educate
Health & □□ Sense of Place
the floor or a scavenger hunt that plays on
and delight museum goers. Bring in
ideas from these local institutions
Wellbeing Consider place and locality. What are some
a handheld device.
FAMILY
PASSENGERS
Give parents a bit of respite with
Play Areas that can keep children
occupied while waiting to board their
plane. Making it educational as well
is always a plus.
3 Technology and
Children
Touch-pads and touch-screens have now
made technology incredibly accessible to
children of all ages, sometimes as young as
two years old. Consider ways to integrate
touch-screens in Waiting & Lounge
locations to preoccupy young minds.
BUTTERFLY WALL
DEPARTING &
CONNECTING
Play Areas can be educational—
engaging both mind and body.
PASSENGERS
This Butterfly Wall in SFO T2
teaches kids about kinetic energy.
10
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Restrooms
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
Health & Sustainability Look & Feel
A RB
RO
I
Wellbeing
O
C
M
S
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
R
estroom design at SFO should achieve a balance hospitality industry, incorporating elements that
between functional aspects and design aspects. will elevate the passenger experience. Consider the
Adherence to ADA guidelines and code-mandated four senses of sight, smell, sound, and touch when
requirements is the highest priority. From an experiential designing the restrooms. Lighting, materiality and
standpoint, the design should be influenced by the music are all key components.
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits Health & THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim Wellbeing Sustainability □□ Location □□ Sensory Design
Consider proximity to main circulation and Consider other sensory elements such as touch
Arrivals Curbside
In the restroom, sanitation is the Using hand dryers and automatic provide ample room for people to wait for (finishes and materials), audio (soothing
Connectors & Tunnels family and travel partners outside Restrooms. music), visual (color palette and accessories),
highest priority. Make sure the sight, shutoff faucets are just a small step
smell and sounds are all soothing toward environmental sustainability. Be mindful of queuing flow. and smell (air freshener).
for passengers. Also ensure there is
adequate circulation space for both ADA
Consider other products or devices
which can save energy and resources.
□□ Room for baggage □□ Availability
Consider baggage constraints. Is there Provide an adequate number of Restrooms
requirements as well as passengers who Low flow fixtures, energy efficient
ample space for carry-on baggage? Ensure and stalls throughout to comply with SFO’s
are toting around luggage. lighting and educational information
stalls are large enough to accommodate high level of service.
are some examples.
luggage and consider providing shelves in
stalls for small items. □□ Education
Consider ways to educate passengers how
□□ Hospitality Influence
Look & Feel Look to hospitality environments to inspire
sustainable practices yield quantifiable
reduction in natural resource use.
space planning amenities and finishes (e.g.
Some of the best restrooms can be
vanity, changing room, amenities).
found in the hospitality industry and
FAMILY
department stores. Look to these □□ Plan for High Traffic
environments when planning airport Ensure durability of partitions and hardware
PASSENGERS
restrooms to give passengers a sense for high traffic use of restrooms. Consider
Family members are often taking of convenience and service. hand-dryers in lieu of paper towels to promote
turns when visiting the restrooms to
ensure that baggage and children are sustainable practices.
taken care of. Having nursing rooms
available near restrooms can help
ease the balancing act.
SOME ESSENTIALS
□□ Signage □□ Location
Clearly delineate Men and Women’s Designers should provide nurseries and
ASSISTED Restrooms with universal signage. Companion Care Restrooms adjacent to
PASSENGERS
standard Restrooms.
Restrooms should always be
accessible to everyone. Ensuring
that all ADA requirements have been
met as well as providing roomier
stalls for passengers and their
luggage can improve the experience
dramatically. Locating Companion
Care restrooms adjacent to standard
restrooms is crucial.
1 2
Durability Encouraging
and Luggage Sustainable
Handling Behavior
One of the trickiest parts of navigating Hand dryers versus paper towel
through the airport is the negotiation of dispensers. Low flush urinals versus
luggage with other essential activities. regular flush toilets. These are all new
Nowhere is this more evident than in and different choices that are now
airport restrooms, where passengers available for Restrooms. Planning
traveling solo cannot leave baggage and design can encourage certain
unattended. As a result, consideration behaviors by directing the user’s
of spaces for luggage and durable attention to a more sustainable
hardware to hang luggage is extremely choice (e.g. placing hand dryers
important when planning out the closer to sinks). Continued focus on
design of the restrooms. sustainability and the environment
will prompt innovation of sustainable
products for the airport.
3 A Hospitality
Experience
Public restrooms can be unseemly places
4 Add Pet
Relief Areas
Post security pet relief areas are a
ALL PASSENGERS
Restrooms are important to all passengers, regardless of
their journey stage. It is a basic necessity that cannot
be ignored.
11
E CK RS
H E
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
JOURNEY MOMENT
ET
SS
CK
IO
Passenger
TI
NS
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
Amenities
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
K EY VA LUE S
AS
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
Convenience & Revenue Time & Look & Feel
RO
I
U
Hospitality Generation Efficiency
O
C
M
S
A
M
PA E
M SS NIT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
P
assenger amenities are defined as ancillary services path. The alcove should be designed to compensate for
that support and/or enhance the travel experience. the disparate designs of the amenities. For example, an
Included in this group are the following: ATM, immersive colored environment can provide a hierarchy in
newspaper vending, shoe shine, telephones, charging which competing elements can exist cohesively. Because
station, waste and recycling, meditation or yoga rooms, and Passenger Amenities areas are highly trafficked, durable
hydration stations. These amenities are often best located finishes are especially important.
together in an architecturally defined space like an alcove
n a highly visible zone adjacent to the main circulation
Checklist Values
Checkpoint
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits Revenue THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim Generation Look & Feel □□ Circulation □□ Aesthetics
Consider proximity to main circulation. Overall look and feel of the space should
Arrivals Curbside
Services such as shoeshines, ATMs, The look of Passenger Amenities Create easy access without creating be integrated with the architecture. How
Connectors & Tunnels obstructions to passengers in transit. Ease of will branding be integrated into the
Smart Cartes, and telephones make should blend with the overall look
up the Services portion of revenue and feel of the terminal, while access and operation as well as uniqueness of amenities offerings?
offering should be considered.
generation at the airport. Location of still distinguishing them from the
□□ Convenience
these amenities should be close to main
circulation so they are easy to find.
Concessions area.
□□ Unique Offerings Look for ways to incorporate amenities
Position and make available unique amenities passengers use in their daily lives at home and
that are not available at Concessions. (e.g. in their communities that they can now do
Time &
shoe shine, amenities alcoves) between security and boarding. What would
Convenience be a convenient addition to these areas?
LEISURE
PASSENGERS
It’s easy to forget small items when
you’re in a hurry to start your
vacation. Having small vending
machines with travel essentials for
leisure passengers who might have z
key items at home.
Forecast
passengers need access to basic amenities to make
travel as convenient and comfortable as possible.
1 2
allows passengers to proceed through their
3 The Influence
of Hospitality
There is an increasing focus on hospitality
in air travel and this includes the airport.
Provide services to passengers that
support their journey. Services such as
ATMs, mobile charging stations, and shoe
shines can add to the experience, ensuring
passengers feel prepared when they reach
their destination.
12
H E
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
JOURNEY MOMENT
IO
TI
NS
Arts &
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
Exhibits
ORS
P L AY A
NNELS
NECT
+ TU
RE
N
AS
C O
K EY VA LUE S
RE
AL E
ID
S
ST
RR S
A RB
R
V
OO
I
U
C
M
Arts & Culture Locality & Sense Look & Feel Time &
S
of Place Efficiency
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
+ ART
MEET S+
S
FO is the only airport in the USA that has an Permanent Collection
accredited art museum. This unique aspect has a The permanent collection consists of significant art
significant impact on the passenger experience. Two pieces purchased by the SF Arts Commission as well as
distinct programs have been implemented: temporary site-specific works commissioned specifically for select
exhibits that have an in-depth focus on a particular locations at the airport.
category and a permanent collection that is administered
Rotating Exhibits
by the SF Arts Commission. Planning for both programs
This category should be thought of as a destination
involves different challenges. What works for one, may not
unto itself, delineated by lighting, materials and
work for the other.
casework that provides an experience commensurate
with fine art museums. These exhibits may, by
necessity, be placed in circulation zones but should
reflect the qualities noted above.
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
UNIQUE
PASSENGERS
Additional amenities mean more
opportunities to integrate art.
Think about ways a pet area might
incorporate sculpture or how SFO
sleeping pods might feature local
muralists.
ASSISTED
PASSENGERS
It’s of great importance that all
exhibit cases and installations
remain accessible for everyone.
1 Consider the
City’s Culture
If the airport is a representative of the city
2 Appeal to
All Senses
Music, for one, is an art that can be
as a destination, consider the important overlooked when planning out a space.
aspects of culture that can be brought to the Austin is a city that has become widely
airport. Seoul Incheon Airport (ICN) has known for its music scene; musical
multiple galleries and museums displaying performances showcasing local bands
history, art, text and images from Korean at Austin Bergstrom Airport (AUS)
history. Cultural arts and crafts allow acknowledges the cultural significance
passengers to create artifacts to take home. of the region to popular music.
Traditional costumed performers parade
each hour through the concourse.
3 Exhibits of
Nature
Known for its gardens, the Singapore
4 Make an
Online Gallery
Consider sharing images of the
ALL PASSENGERS
There are so many great opportunities to incorporate art,
SFO International
Terminal
Large-scale murals can fill an empty
space with life. Consider art which
Changi airport’s (SIN) koi ponds exhibits online and making them not only into the general public environments at SFO, but reflects Bay Area culture and values.
and famous butterfly garden educate accessible from www.flysfo.com. This into children’s play areas as well. Kids’ Spot in Terminal 3
passengers about the flora and fauna of the allows passengers to plan their visit and both Play Areas in T2 connect with local institutions
island. Despite the noise of the adjacent around the exhibits they want to see and artists (Kids’ Spot partnered with the Exploratorium
air handling units and roadway hum, while also providing a taste of SFO and the musical wall at T2 was created by local artist and
the butterflies are fun. The California museums for those passengers who musician, Walter Kitindu).
Academy of Sciences in San Francisco (not would like to visit, but don’t have time.
to mention Golden Gate Park and some of Designers should remember that art at SFO is not
the great national parks in the Bay Area) exclusively relegated to the traditional museum or gallery
can provide inspiration as another great context and can be incorporated in unexpected ways!
example of how to display nature in a
dynamic, engaging way.
13
RS
E E
H
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
JOURNEY MOMENT
CK
IO
TI
NS
Meet
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
& Greet
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
AS RE
K EY VA LUE S
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
I
O
C
M
Wayfinding Look & Feel Convenience &
S
Hospitality
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
M
eet and greet is ideally located on the departure and beverage concession should be adjacent to it as well as
level, pre-security. This hospitality lounge restrooms. For arriving passengers, this space is often used
concept should include lounge seating, artwork as a backdrop for taking photos. This photo opp moment
and FIDs displaying arrival information. If possible, a food should be considered in the design.
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits
Wayfinding Look & Feel THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim The purpose of Meet & Greet is to Meet & Greet should have an
□□ Passenger Traffic □□ Information
Think about adjacencies and passenger traffic Provide easy access to the Information Booth
Arrivals Curbside give people a set place to greet their inviting look and feel. This is an
when planning out the Meet & Greet space. for guests to inquire about incoming flights.
Connectors & Tunnels
loved ones, friends and colleauges. area where people are likely taking
Consider the proximity of the Meet & Greet to
It is important that there is visual photos; it should incorporate
the Baggage Claim area when thinking about □□ Flight Displays
access both for deplaning passengers definitive architecture, art and Provide easy access to Flight Information
the flow of people and belongings in and out of
and greeters. Consider incorporating appropriate lighting. Lounge Displays (FIDs).
the airport.
expansive glazing to maximize sight furniture is desirable in this area.
lines and views. □□ Passenger Needs □□ Welcoming Space
Provide access to restrooms for guests who Consider this space to be a comfortable,
may be waiting for incoming passengers. welcoming area for people to wait. Also
consider that many people use this space to
□□ Art & Nature
Convenience Apply artwork or greenery to invigorate
take photos. Provide an inviting backdrop
to facilitate this.
1 2
Designing for
Groups Versus A Welcoming
Individuals Experience
“There’s stuff that is about groups and A welcoming feel is important for
there’s stuff happening that’s about heightening the passenger experience
individuals...it’s the way it’s set up to not when entering and reconnecting
deal with groups of people [that] is possibly with the world outside the airport.
why there’s a problem.”10 The Meet & Greet Essentially, a cold or sterile Meet &
area is utilized more often by groups, with Greet area is counter productive and
families and large tour groups that often makes the experience less pleasant.
convene in this area. As such, space should Consider hospitality-like finishes
be allocated to ensure this area is visible when designing the Meet & Greet.
but does not obstruct passenger traffic flow.
3 International
Versus Domestic
Additional consideration should be
4 Technology
What opportunities for engagement
ARRIVING
PASSENGERS
SFO Meet & Greet
How can art make the Meet & Greet
space special? Consider pieces that
would make a great backdrop for a
given to the Meet & Greet area in the do new technologies provide for people ‘welcome home’ photo!
Arriving Family Passengers often have
International Terminal, which has larger excited to reconnect with families and
large groups awaiting them in Meet &
crowds of passengers arriving from friends? From something as simple
Greet to help with the kids, see the baby
Customs and Immigration. Make sure as a digital photo booth to a more
for the first time and reconnect with their
there is adequate space for families who complicated integration of social
loved ones. It’s especially important to
are coming to greet their loved ones. media into a dynamic art piece, the
provide a variety of comfortable seating
opportunities are endless.
for those waiting. It’s also important to
incorporate necessary visual displays, e.g.
FIDs and visual paging.
15
E CK RS
H E
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
JOURNEY MOMENT
SS
CK
IO
TI
NS
Arrivals
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
Curbside
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
AS RE
K EY VA LUE S
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
R SI
AR RB
RO
I
O
C
M
S
Convenience & Time & Efficiency Technology Wayfinding
A
Hospitality M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
A
rrivals Curbside presents challenging wayfinding The utilitarian nature of this journey point should not
and driving issues. A driver picking up a passenger preclude creating a hospitality-like ambiance. As a major
or a pedestrian navigating to the exit where arriving civic building, all exterior zones should project a similar
passengers are arriving will have a tremendous amount of quality. Effective night lighting is essential from both a
visual input. It is essential to create a hierarchy of visual functional and aesthetic point of view.
information to ensure an efficient and stress-free experience.
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits
Time & THINGS TO CONSIDER
Efficiency Look & Feel □□ Transportation □□ Representing the City
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim
Different types of transportation Think about ways to integrate this transition
Arrivals Curbside should be considered, from personal space with the airport and the city.
Ensuring that passengers can The Arrivals Curbside area is, for
Connectors & Tunnels vehicles to taxis, shuttles and buses.
many passengers, the last place
navigate quickly out of the airport
they will touch before leaving
□□ Security
is important. It would be a shame to
have the last impression be one of the airport and should remain
□□ Traffic & Circulation Consider placement of security cameras
Create a strategy that complies with traffic atop vestibules or in tall spaces.
frustration. Signage and visibility a positive experience in their
standards and delineates pedestrian traffic
to the outside are all ways to cue memories. Consider ways to leave
a positive impression and make
versus vehicular traffic. □□ Protection
the passenger where he or she must Consider the need for adding covered areas to
go to exit. Ensure that ground the experience feel seamless. This
will likely be accomplished using
□□ Loading System protect passengers and their belongings from
transportation options and areas Provide ample space for passengers with the elements.
for pick up are clearly marked. signage and additional elements luggage for loading. Think about loading
Additionally, ensuring that the such as technologies that could times and how to keep people and luggage □□ Smoking
curbside sidewalk is as free of visual simultaneously inform and excite moving smoothly through the area. Provide designated smoking areas that
ASSISTED clutter and obstacles as possible will passengers about arriving in San neither isolate smokers nor interfere with the
PASSENGERS propel a speedy and efficient exit Francisco. Most importantly, □□ Curbside Waiting Areas experience of non-smoking passengers.
for travelers. provide comfortable waiting space, Consider seating for passengers who might
Assisted Passengers may have
different needs upon reaching ample seating, protection from the have a longer wait.
Arrivals Curbside. ADA elements—all within reasonable views
accessibility to all bus shelters
Technology
of the passing traffic.
and waiting areas is required and
additional signage for this helps
make SFO accessible for everyone. SOME ESSENTIALS
New services and applications
are making it easier for Wayfinding □□ Signage □□ Ad Space & SFO Marketing Opportunities
passengers to connect to their Make sure that it is easy to identify where to Advertising and/or SFO marketing
LEISURE It’s important to ensure that passengers
PASSENGERS ground transportation options. find transportation options and communicate opportunities may be required and should be
know where to go for appropriate
Recognizing and planning for pick-up locations. considered in the overall look and feel.
Leisure Passengers might ground transportation and understand
have large amounts of luggage these innovations could help
the rules for driver pick up. Arrivals
and people. Having space to increase efficiency at Arrivals
accommodate them is crucial. Curbside can be hectic, so being as
Curbside.
clear as possible is important. Making
physical and digital maps accessible
is an assist for passengers and those
FAMILY picking them up.
PASSENGERS
Make sure that families have a
safe and secure place to gather
and orient themselves to the
appropriate transportation.
1 Connection
to the City
The airport is a connection to the city
and the Arrivals Curbside can be a breath
a fresh air after a long day of traveling.
Present a good first impression of San
Francisco by considering the design of the
airport exit. In addition to making this
area comfortable and protected, make sure
it’s memorable!
2
Wayfinding
and Space
Constraints
At SFO, the Arrivals Curbside is more
narrow than the Departures Curbside
Mcclellan palomar
and passengers in this location are likely
eager to continue their travel to the city
ARRIVING airport, san diego
as quickly as possible. Provide very clear PASSENGERS From flying to surfing, ensure
that the arriving passenger
wayfinding for drivers who are picking up transition to the final destination
passengers. Ensure that safe sight lines for Arriving passengers new to the area typically don’t is as seamless as possible.
pedestrians and motion sensor cued lights have enough airport experience to seamlessly
for crossing are in place. navigate out of Arrivals Curbside. Making sure
that ground transportation signage is prominently
displayed and the areas are well lit with clear sight
lines is of extreme importance. Consider adding
extra information regarding transportation
options for these passengers at both the Arrivals
Curbside area as well as online at www.flysfo.com.
14
E CK RS
H E
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
JOURNEY MOMENT
SS
CK
IO
TI
NS
Baggage
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
Claim
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
AS RE
K EY VA LUE S
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
I
O
Convenience & Time & Wayfinding Locality &
M
S
Hospitality Efficiency Sense of Place
A
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
B
aggage Claim is an opportunity to create a great don’t have to be strictly utilitarian! Impactful lighting,
first impression of the city. It is also an opportunity lounge seating, artwork and bold graphics can create a
to create a positive lasting impression of SFO. The hospitality-like effect in this area. Due to the transitory
most important functional aspect of this journey point nature of Baggage Claim, the use of color can be a simple
is clear wayfinding. The comfort and convenience of way to make a great impression.
passengers must also be considered. Baggage Claim areas
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits
Convenience Time & THINGS TO CONSIDER
Meet & Greet
FAMILY
PASSENGERS
Groups of people need space to
gather and families are a prime
example. Have spaces for parents
to keep an eye on their kids while
gathering their luggage.
1 2
Baggage
RFID Delivery
Systems Services
The air transportation industry continues Different options for baggage
to explore different technologies, in delivery solutions are now available
particular when thinking about security. as an alternative to airline baggage
Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) fees. Startups like Lugless,
tags are just one of those systems that LuggageFree, LuggageForward and
airports are testing out as a way of locating even FedEx are offering passengers
both luggage and passengers. Misplaced an alternative for getting their
or lost luggage may not be an issue in baggage to their final destination at
the future, decreasing the space needed competitive prices. If this catches
for Lost & Found and other Baggage on, expect to see a decrease in the
Claim services. Instead, space and area needed for Baggage Claim as the
infrastructure will be required to support luggage system evolves. Availability
these new technologies. of adequate luggage carts will still be
a priority for passengers who opt not
3
to use these services.
Concessions
and Amenities ARRIVING
A lot of emphasis is put on the departing
PASSENGERS SFO TERMINAL 2 BAGGAGE
passenger experience. However, there is an CLAIM
There are a lot of moods and needs to moderate
express desire for arriving passengers to Brightly lit Baggage Claim areas can
in a family. What fun activities could be provided
have access to amenities and concessions invigorate passengers who’ve just
for children that might distract them from the
as well. Adding a coffee shop would be a exited a long flight. Consider finishes
sometimes tedious experience of waiting for bags? and materials that can make an
great way to tap into this need.
Is their a restroom with a nursery for nursing impact upon exit.
mothers? How about a seating area large enough
to accommodate the whole family? The important
thing to ensure in Baggage Claim, where wait times
are unpredictable, is activities and choice as well as
a harmonious built environment.
16
C
C
O
G
N
IN
CE
ET
SS
CK
IO
JOURNEY MOMENT
TI
NS
Connectors
ACH
+ LO
WA I
APPRO
UNGE
TING
& Tunnels
ORS
P L AY A
CON NNELS
NECT
+ TU
AS RE
K EY VA LUE S
RE
VA D E
LS
ST
I
RR S
A RB
RO
I
O
C
M
S
Wayfinding Locality & A
Sense of Place
M
PA E N
M SS IT
AI GE EN IE
CL GA GE S
G R
BA EXH
T IBITS
GREE
E T + ART
ME S+
C
onnectors are defined as areas that link one Tunnels are defined as conveyances connecting parking
terminal to another, facilitating connecting structures to terminals. The same practical and aspirational
passengers as well as aiding in general elements applied to Connectors are relevant in these areas.
circulation. Connectors are further defined as either Additionally, advertisements may be located in Tunnels,
“secure” (aiding post-security connecting passengers and careful consideration should be given to their inclusion.
or “non-secure” (aiding in general circulation for both Tunnels and Connectors, due to their transitory nature, are
passengers and airline employees). Clear and concise an opportunity to create energetic design that adds another
wayfinding signage is of prime importance. The design layer of surprise and delight to the passenger experience.
of these Connectors should be dynamic in character,
providing an opportunity for enjoyment and anticipation
as travelers move through the airport.
Values Checklist
Recompose
Plazas
Concourse
Concessions
Waiting & Lounge
Play Areas
Restrooms
Passenger Amenities
Arts & Exhibits
Locality & THINGS TO CONSIDER
Wayfinding Sense of Place □□ Wayfinding □□ Transportation + Marketing
Meet & Greet
Baggage Claim
Signage and wayfinding is extremely Consider the AirTrain waiting areas as
Arrivals Curbside
Connectors and Tunnels can be Connectors and Tunnels are a great important and should be clearly recognizable opportunities for passengers to learn more
Connectors & Tunnels for out-of-town visitors. Make maps (static about the airport and the different amenities
disorienting spaces. As such, opportunity to highlight memorable
wayfinding is a top priority. When Bay Area experiences. Art and exhibits or interactive) accessible to passengers upon that are offered.
possible, allow views to the outside are a natural answer, but consider approach to the airport.
and consider branding these areas
with a similar look and feel to the
other opportunities as well. Color
and materiality can go a long way in
□□ Visual Landmarks
Consider lighting, banners or some other
terminals they primarily connect conveying a special sense of place and
visual landmarks to indicate airport exits
to. Above all, ensure that wayfinding will help differentiate the Tunnels and
from the freeway.
signage is visible and reassures Connectors from one another.
passengers along their journey.
SOME ESSENTIALS
□□ ADA Accessibility □□ Urban Planning
These areas may require greater city
BUSINESS □□ Circulation Constraints planning efforts.
PASSENGERS
For Business Passengers new to San
□□ Traffic & Congestion □□ Life Safety Issues
Congestion can be a major issue. Ensure Exit paths for various modes of transportation
Francisco, Connectors & Tunnels
are essential in getting them to that the Connectors & Tunnels remain and fire/life safety issues need to be considered.
their final destination. Make sure a transitory part of the journey and
wayfinding is clear, both going to
and leaving the airport. discourage lingering.
FAMILY
PASSENGERS
Landing in a new location can be
exciting, particularly for kids.
Consider this space as the city’s
greeting to travelers. The passenger
experience should extend beyond
the airport walls.
1 Anticipation
of Travel
The romance of travel is not as it once
was, but Connectors and Tunnels can
and should be designed to exhilarate the
passenger and add to the anticipation of
air travel or of connecting to the city. The
TWA Terminal in New York City’s John
F. Kennedy Airport (JFK) has a simple
sculptural passageway that adds to the
passenger experience.
2 An Urban
Experience
Principles of urban design theory are
CONNECTING
PASSENGERS
SFO T2 Connector
being applied as a trend toward the airport For visitors new to the area, or those who The connector tunnel provides a varied
as a “city within a city.” Connectors and are unaccustomed to traveling, wayfinding experience from other terminals through
Tunnels can provide a physical reminder to and from the airport should be clear different finishes and lighting.
through large scale art and sculpture. The and easy, particularly for those looking
Los Angeles Airport has large scale light for their connecting flights. Being clear
sculptures that indicate the location of about designated areas can help ease any
the airport from the freeway. Consider nervousness or anxiety passengers experience
other urban design elements such as while they are traveling.
wayfinding, connecting boulevards, open
plazas and public art. Make sure there is
visual connectivity, organized spaces and
information is readily available.
240 SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL AIRP ORT THE PRINCIPLE S OF R.E.A.C.H. 241
FOOTNOTES GLOSSARY
TICKETING AOA FAA
1
Maister, D. (2005). The psychology of waiting lines. Retrieved from Air operations area Federal Aviation Administration
http://davidmaister.com. ACC GID
2
Myers, P. (Oct 18, 2012). Just how stressful is business travel? Retrieved from Airline Consultatative comittee Gate Information Display systems
http://www.reuters.com/assets/print?aid=USLNE89H01Q20121018.
ACSSP ITB
3
Hooper, B. (Aug 20, 2012). The airport of the future is about more than takeoff and Airline Carrier Standard Security Program International Terminal Building
landing. Fast Company. http://www.fastcoexist.com/1680367/the-airport-of-the-
future-is-about-more-than-takeoff-and-landing#1. Apron Level Journey Moments
Ground level accessible to airfield Spaces or activities that passengers using airport public
4
Futterman, E. (July 2005). Trends and developments in airport design. Facilities spaces pass through, engage with or spend time in
Management. http://www.facilitiesnet.com/facilitiesmanagement/article/ Arrivals Level
Airports-Flying-High--3088. For arriving passengers Landside
Pre security areas
5
Gaffney, G. (Interviewer) & Kraal, B. (Interviewee). (2012). Researching the Airside
airport of the future: An interview with Ben Kraal (Interview transcript). All areas after security checkpoint LEED
Retrieved from http://infodesign.com.au/uxpod/airport/. Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design
AIMS
CHECKPOINT Airport Information Management System PBB
5
Hanna, A. (Jan 24, 2013). Is one airport app for all a realistic possibility? Passenger boarding bridge
BHC
Retrieved from http://www.futuretravelexperience.com/2013/01/is-one-airport-
Baggage Handling System PVC
app-for-all-a-realistic-possibility/.
Polyvinyl Chloride
BICE
CONCOURSE
Building Inspection And Code Enforcement Precompose Area
6
Bernstein, F. You First. Retrieved from Gensler Dialogues Immediately prior to security reserved for passenger to
BIDS
compose themselves before the security check
CONCESSIONS Baggage Information Display System
Recompose Area
7
Livingstone, A., Popovic, V., Kraal, B.J., & Kirk, P.J. (2012) Understanding the BIM
Immediately post security reserved for passenger to compose
airport passenger landside retail experience. In Israsena, Praima, Tangsantikul, Building Information Modeling
Juthamas, & Durling, David (Eds.) DRS2012 Bangkok – Research: Uncertainty, themselves after the security check
Contradiction and Value, Department of Industrial Design, Faculty of Architecture, CalGreen
Secure Connector
Chulalongkorn University, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok . California Green Building Standards Code
Area of connection between post security areas of the airport,
WAITING + LOUNGE CID typically two terminals
Counter Information Display System
8
The Center for Health Design Research Coalition. (2011). Impact of Visual Art on Ticket Lift
Waiting Behavior in the Emergency Department. Houston, TX: Nanda, U. CEQA Boarding pass scanning device
California Environmental Quality Act
9
Myers, P. (Oct 18, 2012). Just how stressful is business travel? Retrieved from T1
http://www.reuters.com/assets/print?aid=USLNE89H01Q20121018. Concourse Terminal One
Post security circulation area
MEET & GREET T2
Concessions Terminal Two
10
Gaffney, G. (Interviewer) & Kraal, B. (Interviewee). (2012). Researching the
airport of the future: An interview with Ben Kraal (Interview transcript). Retrieved Breaks into two distinct catergories:
T3
from http://infodesign.com.au/uxpod/airport/. Food and Beverage (F&B) and Retail
Terminal Three
CONNECTORS & TUNNELS D&C
Terminal
Design and Construction
Futterman, E. (July 2005). Trends and developments in airport design. Facilities
11
The main building or structure. There are 4 Terminals
Management. http://www.facilitiesnet.com/facilitiesmanagement/article/ DRC at SFO. Terminal 1 Terminal 2 Terminal 3 and the
Airports-Flying-High--3088. Design Review Committee International Terminal
FIDS VOC
242 SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL AIRP ORT THE PRINCIPLE S OF R.E.A.C.H. 243
PHOTO CREDITS
INTRODUCTION ART AND CULTURE CHECKPOINT ARTS AND EXHIBITS
Gensler.................................................................................p. 5 Photo by Bruce Damonte.....................................................p. 93 Photo by Ken Power.......................................................... p. 156 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 210
Photo by Håkan Dahlström................................................. p. 11 Photo by Bruce Damonte.....................................................p. 95 Photo by Nic Lehoux.........................................................p. 160 Photo by Bruce Damonte................................................... p. 214
Photo by Bruce Damonte..................................................... p. 15 Photo by Bruce Damonte.................................................... p. 96 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 161 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 215
Photo by Gensler.................................................................p. 18 Photo by Grumblr on Flickr...............................................p. 100 RECOMPOSE MEET AND GREET
Photo by Bruce Damonte.................................................... p. 20 Photo by SK on Flickr........................................................p. 100 Photo by Bruce Damonte................................................... p. 162 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 216
Photo by Gensler................................................................ p. 20 HEALTH AND WELLBEING Photo by The Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore........... p. 166 Photo by Michael Townsend, Gensler................................p. 220
PASSENGER TYPOLOGIES Photo by Michael Townsend, Gensler................................ p. 103 Photo by Bruce Damonte................................................... p. 167 Photo by Bruce Damonte................................................... p. 221
Photo by Nic Lehoux...........................................................p. 24 Photo by Bruce Damonte................................................... p. 107 PLAZAS ARRIVALS CURBSIDE
LOCALITY AND SENSE OF PLACE Photo by Karsten1605 on Flickr.........................................p. 108 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 168 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 222
Photo by Tyler Kantzer via Flickr........................................p. 43 Photo by Amy Kwok, Gensler.............................................p. 108 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 172 Photo by John Edward Linden...........................................p. 226
Photo by Bruce Damonte................................................ p. 44-45 SUSTAINABILITY Photo by Brian Mossemenear............................................ p. 173 Photo by Gensler Lawrence Anderson Photography........... p. 227
Photo by Michael Townsend, Gensler.................................. p.46 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 113 CONCOURSE BAGGAGE CLAIM
Photo by Bruce Damonte..................................................... p. 47 Photo by Nic Lehoux....................................................p. 114-115 Photo by Mike Wiacek (mikewiacek.com........................... p. 174 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 228
Photo by InSapphoWeTrust on Flickr ..................................p. 48 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 116 Photo by Harry Purwanto.................................................. p. 178 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 232
Photo by Beau Trincia on Flickr ..........................................p. 48 Photo by Bruce Damonte....................................................p. 117 Photo by Robyn Lee........................................................... p. 179 Photo by Nic Lehoux......................................................... p. 233
Photo by Brewbooks on Flickr............................................ p. 88 Photo by The Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore........... p. 155
244 SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL AIRP ORT THE PRINCIPLE S OF R.E.A.C.H. 245
PROPERTY OF SAN FRANCISCO INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
Prepared by for the San Francisco International Airport
Version 1.0
Issued December, 2013
© 2013 San Francisco International Airport
Gensler SFO
Jeff Henry Judi Mosqueda
Melissa Mizell Rick Thall
Amy Kwok Kris Opbroek
Nicole Powell
David Mayman URS
Miriam Diaz Elissa Flandro
Meaghan Beever
Sue Yin
Nupur Sinha
Gary Brandau