Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alican B. Karim - Maphilo Prof. Wrendolf C. Juntilla Advanced Epistemology
Alican B. Karim - Maphilo Prof. Wrendolf C. Juntilla Advanced Epistemology
KARIM - MAPHILO
ADVANCED EPISTEMOLOGY
ON HUMAN EXISTENCE
Introduction
In the realm of sensibility, in the scheme of beings the animals head that diversity of
species. Of the animals, human beings occupy the first rank of their heirarchy the superior
position. As it is universally claimed their superiority is very much indebted to their own
rational faculty that is naturally designed to their being an imprint character in their nature
and thus they are called rational animals because of that instrinsic quality. Their ability to
reason fro certainly proper actions determines what they really are and ought to be ways of
being, orientations and valuations as superior in the animal species. As existent beings the
natural process proper to their inclination such as to be fully humans must always be their
striving as human. They can only possibly realize that desired fullness through the creativity
Contact with other beings within the scheme is inevitable, it is fundamental to existence,
to be with other beings. This interdependence is a proof of members’s finitude. Of all beings
only humans through their rationality are able to realize the richness of that encounter.
in Being. In the process of knowing what is sought by reason’s stern test and affirmation in
the search primarily for the fullness of human existence is claimed to be as knowldege.
Reason itself gives name to or authenticates knowledge as such. It is even claimed that when
the fullness of existence especially human existence is sought in knowldege, such pursuit is
Philosophy is an activity of man in his inexhaustible search for worldview that gives him
meaningful existence, fullness of being. This reality makes philosophy as the basic enterprise
of man. It is constitutive to the mode of his being , to be a man of fullness and authenticity.
In all fields of thought, Nietzsche considers science as the only legitimate field for it can
indubitably justify its claims through its method but “Nietzsche was aroused from dogmatic
slumber by Darwin as Kant had been by Hume a century earlier and again it was a question
of creating a new picture of man in reply to the true but deadly nihilism from beyond the
channel”. when it comes to the concept of man science and Charles Darwin are inseparable
for the claim of Darwin is the paradigm of science. When Nietzsche was aroused from his
dogmatic slumber by science or Darwin’s picture of man he had to find ways to change
science’s picture of man. For him the claim is an insult or a scandal to the greatness of man in
relation to his essential dignity and worth. He wants to give man an empirically noble picture
According to science theory of evolution, species are moving closer and closer to
perfection all the time. No less, all living things behave essentially the same in that process of
perfection. As part of that theory, what Nietzsche finds seriously problematic is science’s
doctrine concerning the distinction between man and the animals behavioral pattern.
Factually the animals are governed by the dictates of theor impulse thus they seek to satisfy
themeselves to the extent of struggling or competing with each other in order to survive to
Man for Nietzsche, as tradition has always conceived him to be is a rational animal.
What distinguishes him from animals is not that he conclusively has rationalitybut on how we
will cultivate that potential its creativity and technicity in undertaking the task of raising
himself above the beasts. If man is to behave like the way which the animals do in view of
the theory of evolution, terrible destruction will surely to occur for he can use the greatness of
his intellectual ability in the great competition for self preservation. Man must use his
greatness constructively which gives him essential dignity and worth and not destructively
In his pursuit for an empirically noble picture of man by finding ways of rejecting
science’s claim, Nietzsche considers presenting the picture or status of what would man be in
the presence of God. According to Nietzsche “as soon as we imagine someone who is
responsible for our being…. and therefore attribute to him the intention that we should exist
and be happy or wretched, we corrupt for ourselves the innocence of becoming. We then
have someone who wants to achieve something through us and with us”.
Again, nietzsche faces another scandal when becomes the ground and final end of
everything especially with that of man. Man, in the presence of God, is a dependent man. He
cannot posit himself as an end he can only be a means. He does not beling to himslef he is
just used up. In other words, man is just a mere puppet. The puppet works through and for the
master. For Nietzsche, if man is limited to a mere puppet this idea is a rape or perversion of
what man can greatly make for himslef. In his regard of science’s justification process, not
only that God’s existence can not be scientifically demonstrated but also His presence loss
what man can greatly make for himself. For this reason, Nietzsche strenously proclaims the
death of God.
In sum, Nietzsche’s empirical picture of man is a rational man. The greatness of his
rationality is conclusively not what distinguishes him from the animals but rather he may use
it constructively in realizing the distinction between him and the animals that gives him
essential dignity and worth. His greatness, so to speak his essential dignity and worth must
be fully accounted to himself not to anybody else. He must be free in giving himself dignity
and worth through the best of his ability, thus, such pursuit is a personal task.
The Superman
According to science, though man is a rational animal he is still not different from the
from Nietzsche’s concept of man he recognizes man’s animal nature. But to behave and act
without thought and control to the extent of destroying others is an animal characteristic.
Upon descovering the greatness of the will to power in man’s rationality as a necessary
condition of his existence in the ever changing world that greatness must not be dissolved to
his animal nature but he must use it in living not the way which the animals do that gives him
essential dignity and worth. Man must take a distinction between him and the animals. Man
must express the greatness of the will to power in his reason to overcome his animal nature.
Science thus, dissolves the greatness of man completely to his animal nature. For Nietzsche,
mun must live and pursue for perfection by exhausting the best in him in a dignified and
In the pursuit for knowldege, no knowledge can transcend the methodical knowledge of
the empirical science but, in Nietzsche’s examination about the legitimacy of science to claim
for the truth, he unmask science’s pretensions through the impossibility of self definition or
self reflection. In his further inquiry he ha sfound out reason’s dependency on the senses.
science such as the belief in the truth of the judgements of the senses. Reason is dependent on
what our senses can perceive. It function solely to interpret the multiple sensations and
impressions. The value of the worl then lies on how we put order on these appearing and
changing things according to our interpretations of them for our practical purposes.
If reason is dependent on the senses, truth is really impossible in science but what
science can only have are its interpretations of all appearing and changing things. For
Nietzsche, what manifest reason in its pursuit for all appearing and changing things is not
truth but will to power such as man’s desire to be in power over these things for his practical
ON HUMAN EXISTENCE
Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche abhors the traditional notion of knowledge. He still quite
skeptical about knowledge as such, thus, we are vain to suppose that we can know the truth.
Almost throughout history, men have been chained to knowing the truth wanting the world to
conform perfectly to their way of thinking in the belief that reason can exhaust the truth in its
entirety such as a world that is perfectly understandable and behaves in perfect ways. For
Nietzsche, no matter how much we want to exhaust the truth, it never will.
No less in the process of his pursuit, Nietzsche has discovered the will to power as the
basic principle of reason in it desire to master everything, and he then proceeds to extend this
principle of explanation to organic life in general and finally, to the world as a whole. All
appearing and changing things are no less than the manifestations of this primal force. The
constant struggle and change in the world is the activity of the will to power in overcoming.
Its self-overcoming in its manifestations. Of all its manifestations, reason is its highest form
of manifestation. But reason is dependent on the senses which are also will to power’s
manifestation. Though it is dependent on the sense reason interprets what the senses can
perceive and imposes order on the multiple sensations and impressions for man’s practical
purposes. Reason’s imposition of order on the ever changing world is no less than will to
power’s activity of self-overcoming because reason and th world are variants of this primal
force or man’s activity of overpowering all appearing and changing things for his practical
purposes is also will to power’s self-overcoming because man and all things are but
According to Nietzsche, the pursuit of science in all appearing and changing things is its
existence thus, man’s abstarction and simplification of all things is man’s desire to overpower
the ever changing world for his practical purposes such as to make his life possible and to
realize whatever objective he has for his life. Though reason is the highest manifestation of
the will to power, it needs the senses for it to have an access to the world and to exhaust its
greatness fully to make man’s existence possible in the ever changing world.
Summary and Conclusion
The preciousness or greatness of Nietzsche’s intention regarding his pursuit for man in
relation to his essential dignity and worth is no less than his noble lie. If reason is only
capable of interpretation, it then follows that everything which comes out from Nietzsche’s
mouth is interpretaion. If he claims that reason is only capable of interpretaion, it must also
be his interpretation thus, whatever he claims is a defeat against him. As an honest avowal,
the researcher finds the necessity of branding Nietzsche’s pursuit as self-defeating. Though
this is the status of Nietzsche’s philosophy as the reseacher views it, its offer of a noble way
of life such as to live an essentially dignified and worthy life not animalistic is always
wanting.
Many readers abhors Nietzsche beacuse of the interpretations of his philosophy to them.
They picture Nietzsche’s superman as if a notoriously powerful man who has killed even God
Currently, many people suffer from impaired self-esteem they need tor work on being
proud of themeselves. Nietzsche might serve as a living reminder to the people of today.
Significantly, on this paper Nietzsche is remindingus once again that knowledge is power.
Life can be decadent if we live passively, we must challenge ourselve because true maturity
means discovering or creating an identity for ourselves such as wholesome identity not
fullness of human existence is a sought in the meaningful totality of beings. If the world is
viewed as the manifestation of the will to power the world and the individual then form a
continuum that cannot be set apart. If the overpowering or imposing of order on the ever
chaning world for man’s practical purposes as a necessary condition of his existence aims not
to be animalistic, Nietzsche’s superman is the great attendant for the preservation and
continuity of Being.
REFERENCES
Nietzsche, F. (1954). The Portable Nietzsche (W. Kaufman, Ed. & Trans.) New York: The
Viking Press
Nietzsche, F. (1999). Beyond good and evil (W. Kaufaman, Trans). In Curry, B., the
http://www.pitt.edu/~wbcurry/nietzsche.html.