Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Automotive Traction Inverters: Current Status and Future Trends
Automotive Traction Inverters: Current Status and Future Trends
net/publication/330923147
CITATIONS READS
12 12,145
4 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by John Reimers on 22 October 2019.
Abstract—Traction inverters are crucial components of modern together to improve the power electronics systems subjected
electrified automotive powertrains. Advances in power electronics to aggressive targets for 2020 as a part of the technology
have enabled lower cost inverters with high reliability, efficiency roadmap. Regarding the inverter objectives, a 30 kW contin-
and power density, suitable for mass market consumer auto-
motive applications. This paper presents an independent review uous (55 kW peak) design is expected to achieve a power
of the state-of-the-art traction inverter designs from several density of 13.4 kW/L and a specific density of 14.1 kW/kg at
production vehicles across multiple manufacturers. Future trends a cost of $3.3/kW for 100 000 units. Delphi Technologies and
in inverter design are identified based on industry examples the DOE overcame some of the barriers and disclosed in a 55
and academic research. Wide bandgap devices and trends in kW peak traction inverter with 15 kW/L and 17 kW/kg [4].
device packaging are discussed along with active gate driver
implementations, current and future trends in system integration, However the cost remains the biggest challenge as the inverter
and advanced manufacturing techniques. reached $5/kW. Several OEMs have achieved a subset of the
goals as well, and traction inverter design will be discussed in
Index Terms—Automotive applications, Electric vehicles, Elec-
trified powertrains, Hybrid electric vehicles, Inverters, Power detail in the following sections. The DOE recently updated the
electronics, Traction motor drives, Transportation electrification objectives to accelerate the integration of EVs in the market
and defined new targets for 2025 [5]. For the inverter power
module composed of an inverter and, if applicable, a DC/DC
I. I NTRODUCTION boost converter, a 100 kW integrated design with 100 kW/L
at $2.7/kW is expected. This represents 18% cost reduction
E LECTRIFIED vehicles (EVs) are continuing to show
promise as more manufacturers announce plans to de-
velop electrified models in order to improve fuel economy
and 87% volume reduction compared to the 2020 goals. In
view of these new targets, major technological breakthroughs
are required.
and remain competitive as consumer demands shift towards
While previous reviews have either covered the entire elec-
efficient, cleaner vehicles. These include hybrid electric vehi-
trified powertrain [6] or focused on theoretical aspects of the
cles (HEVs), plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs), battery
inverter [7], the goal of this paper is to present a thorough re-
electric vehicles (BEVs), and fuel cell vehicles. At the heart
view of the production inverter implementations across several
of all electrified powertrains is one or more electric machines
vehicle manufacturers. In the following, a review of current
(EMs) which operate either in conjunction with an internal
production automotive traction inverters with a focus on BEVs
combustion engine (ICE) or replace it entirely. The EMs
and PHEVs is presented. BEVs and PHEVs tend to have
found in EVs today are most commonly of the AC permanent
higher power inverters and, as the industry trends towards fully
magnet (PM) or AC induction machine (IM) type [1, 2]. To
electric powertrains, the majority of traction inverters in the
drive them, a traction inverter is required to convert the direct
future will be in the 100-500 kW range compared to the 30-
current available from the battery pack to variable frequency
60 kW range found in HEVs today. Finally, future trends are
alternating current. In addition to the motoring mode, the
identified based on ongoing research and emerging industry
machines can also operate as generators, requiring the inverter
practices.
to act as a rectifier and return energy to the battery.
In 2012, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) initiated
a long term project called the ‘EV Everywhere Grand Chal- II. I NVERTER D ESIGN
lenge’ with the goal of defining a technology roadmap for cost- A. Topology
effective, powerful and reliable EVs that can compete with
Due to their high efficiency and low cost, the vast majority
conventional ICE vehicles [3]. National laboratories, original
of production EVs today utilize three phase voltage source
equipment manufacturers (OEMs), and suppliers are working
inverters (VSI) based on insulated gate bipolar transistors
Copyright
c 2019 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. (IGBTs). As shown in Fig. 1, the battery pack can be either di-
However, permission to use this material for any other purposes must be rectly connected to the inverter DC input (Fig. 1a), or a DC/DC
obtained from the IEEE by sending a request to pubs-permissions@ieee.org.
Manuscript received October 19, 2018; revised December 30, 2018; ac- boost converter can be used to step up the battery voltage and
cepted January 29, 2019. (Corresponding author: John Reimers) supply the inverter with a controlled DC voltage (Fig. 1b).
The authors are with the McMaster Institute for Automotive Re- In both circuits, a large DC-link capacitor Cdc smooths the
search and Technology (MacAUTO), McMaster University, Hamilton, ON
L8S 4L8, Canada (e-mail: reimerja@mcmaster.ca; dorngoml@mcmaster.ca; ripple current and voltage generated by the switching action
makcs@mcmaster.ca; emadi@mcmaster.ca) of the active devices. This ensures a nearly constant DC-link
AC output due to the high distortion of the line currents caused
by the switching action.
Battery
One advantage of the CSI is its capability of boosting the
Cdc a
pack b
c
input voltage to produce an AC output with a higher peak
value than the DC input voltage. This eliminates the need for
EM a separate DC/DC boost converter and extends the constant
power range of the EM by providing sufficient output voltage
(a) VSI. even as the machine’s back EMF rises above the DC-link [12].
While the significant reduction of the DC link capacitor can
improve the power density of the CSI, there is still a need for a
Lboost
DC-link inductor that is usually bulky and heavy in high power
Cdc a applications. Practically, the lower efficiency and higher cost
b
c compared to the VSI have prevented adoption of the CSI in
Battery
pack EM automotive traction applications [13].
2) Z-source inverter (ZSI): The ZSI combines some char-
(b) VSI combined with a DC/DC boost converter. acteristics of the VSI and CSI where either a voltage or
current source can be directly connected to its input terminals
Fig. 1: Standard inverter topologies used in the automotive [14]. The circuit uses six semiconductor devices that require
industry. unidirectional voltage blocking capability and bidirectional
current flow. With appropriate control of the switches, the ZSI
can operate as a buck-boost inverter since it is capable of
voltage and reduces the high frequency current harmonics. The producing an AC output voltage either higher or lower than
boost converter is commonly implemented with two switching the DC input source.
devices such that it is bidirectional and can return energy to
the battery during regenerative braking. The topology can be The ZSI could be a suitable alternative solution for elec-
scaled to higher power levels by paralleling multiple converter trified powertrain applications due to its buck-boost feature
phases, which has the benefit of reducing ripple if interleaving since DC sources, such as batteries, provide a widely varying
control is used. The VSI topology requires six switches which voltage range [15, 16]. The ZSI provides higher or similar
are modulated to generate a three phase sinusoidal output efficiency than the VSI and the combination of the VSI
current to the EM [8]. with a DC/DC boost converter respectively [17]. However,
Thanks to its single stage conversion, the architecture shown even though the number of active devices is low, the passive
in Fig. 1a is cheap, easy to manufacture and requires simple component requirements are higher in the ZSI. Hence, the cost
control of the switching devices. Moreover, the VSI has been and volume of this topology still prevents its adoption by the
intensively studied and widely used in the industry over the automotive industry.
past decades which makes this topology mature, robust, and 3) Three-level inverters: Over the past few years, three-
reliable. level inverters have gained interest in the industry as alternative
solutions to the standard VSI. Among the many topologies that
have been developed, the Neutral Point Clamped (NPC) and
B. Alternative candidates the T-type NPC (TNPC) are the most competitive solutions
Many alternative topologies have been suggested, however [18–20].
most of them require additional power switches and passive Advanced studies have highlighted several aspects of the
elements beyond the standard VSI which increases not only benefits of three-level inverters [21, 22]. An efficiency com-
the cost, but also the control complexity, volume and weight of parison for a wide range of switching frequencies has been
the system. Extensions of the two level VSI and accompanying conducted to compare the VSI, the NPC and the TNPC
modulation schemes have also been proposed such as the H8 inverters. Results show that the efficiency of the VSI is higher
architecture [9] and four-leg inverters [10]. These topologies only for low frequencies but drops significantly above 10 kHz.
can reduce the high frequency common mode voltage variation On the other hand, the TNPC is more efficient for medium fre-
within the EM which is known to cause bearing failure [11]. quencies between 10 kHz to 30 kHz, while the NPC becomes
1) Current source inverter (CSI): The CSI is a traditional slightly more efficient for frequencies above 30 kHz. Three-
inverter that converts power from a DC current source to an level inverters provide output voltages with lower harmonic
AC output [8]. A DC voltage source, such as a battery pack, distortion than the VSI, reducing the EMI filter requirements
can also be used if it is connected in series with a large and improving the efficiency of the motor. Nevertheless, the
inductor. The circuit is composed of six switching devices with capacitor banks for three-level inverters have a volume twice
bidirectional voltage blocking and unidirectional current flow that of the VSI and requires additional control to ensure
capability. Thus, symmetric thyristors or IGBTs in series with capacitor voltage balancing. Moreover, both topologies suffer
diodes are common solutions implemented in the industry. For from high cost and increased control complexity due to a high
motor drive applications, capacitor filters are required on the part count.
C. Modulation techniques EVs. Furthermore, power modules with high current capability
The AC output voltages produced by the inverter and or discrete devices connected in parallel have emerged as
feeding the EM are generated through pulse width modulation solutions in response to higher power demands.
(PWM) techniques that switch the power semiconductors in Gate drivers are greatly responsible for the efficiency of
a desired pattern. Closed-loop control is achieved by the the inverter as they influence the dynamic behavior of the
inverter through phase current and rotor position feedback, IGBTs and the freewheeling diodes. They are composed of
thus requiring at least two phase current sensors in the inverter integrated circuits (ICs) that transmit isolated control signals
and a suitable interface for a resolver or encoder from the EM. to switch the device and provide protective feedback. For high
1) Sinusoidal PWM (SPWM): SPWM is one of the most voltage applications, such as traction inverters, optocouplers or
classic techniques used in the industry due to its simplicity pulse transformers are typically used for isolation [30]. The
[23]. It was first developed with analog circuits but digital gate driver design needs to consider the factors influencing
implementation is now a standard procedure. One drawback the power device switching performance. Several approaches
of this modulation scheme is its limited use of the DC-link have been developed, from passive circuits using external gate-
voltage Vdc since the maximum amplitude of the fundamental emitter capacitors and gate resistors to closed-loop control that
output phase voltage is Vdc /2. Moreover, this method gen- adjusts the gate drive output based on the IGBT operation [31].
erates relatively high total harmonic distortion (THD) in the To implement the motor control software, a microcontroller
line voltages compared to other techniques, causing higher or DSP is included, typically on a dedicated control board
harmonic losses. within the inverter. Given the computational requirements of
2) Space Vector PWM (SVPWM): Despite its more inten- the motor control and modulation schemes, 32-bit floating-
sive computational requirements, SVPWM has gained popu- point processors clocked at over 100 MHz are the norm for
larity as the widespread adoption of digital signal processors traction inverters. As control algorithms continue to increase
(DSPs) and microcontrollers has enabled low cost implemen- in complexity and switching speeds rise, it has been suggested
tations [23, 24]. SVPWM achieves better performance by that field programmable gate array (FPGA) hardware be used
generating reduced THD compared to SPWM, improving the to implement the modulation while the DSP handles the motor
efficiency of the inverter as well as the EM. Furthermore, the control, in order to improve timing accuracy and reduce the
maximum DSP requirements [32, 33]. A position sensor is typically used
√ fundamental amplitude of the phase voltage is equal to determine the rotor angle of the EM. Most automotive
to Vdc / 3, which is about 15% higher than SPWM method
in the linear region [25, 26]. Hence, the SVPWM enables a applications use a resolver and a dedicated resolver-to-digital
better DC link utilization, which can be even further extended (R2D) chip is included on the inverter control board to provide
through six-step operation in the over modulation region. the necessary excitation signals as well as the analog to digital
3) Six-step modulation: Though it is challenging to confirm conversion of the resolver signal.
which modulation strategy is used for the traction inverters in Current sensors are used to measure the inverter’s AC ouput
every EV, it is believed that SVPWM is preferred due to its current, which is fed back to the DSP which implements the
performance superiority. For example, it has been reported in closed loop control. For automotive applications, open loop
[27, 28] that General Motors (GM) employs SVPWM for the Hall effect sensors are typically applied due to their relatively
linear modulation region and then applies six-step modulation low cost, high bandwidth and inherent isolation.
in the over modulation region. The DC-link capacitor is a crucial component of the inverter
The six-step mode, also known as square-wave modula- as it protects both the input source and the power devices
tion, is named after the six distinct steps the output phase from large current and voltage spikes. Hence, the proper
voltages take over a fundamental cycle [29]. During the six- selection is based on the ripple current requirements and
step mode, the DC link voltage utilization is maximized since the capacitance calculated from voltage ripple requirements
the fundamental amplitude of the phase voltage is equal to [34, 35]. Compared to electrolytic capacitors, film capacitors
Vdc . This improves the EM performance by increasing the have shown many benefits for inverter applications where high
torque capability in the flux-weakening region. On the other current ripple capability is a concern while high capacitance is
hand, this method raises some practical issues due to low-order less important. Indeed, a more power-dense, efficient, and low
current harmonics that make control of the torque challenging. cost design can be achieved with film capacitors, as shown in
The six-step modulation remains a complementary method [36]. Moreover, while the temperature variation affects both
combined with another PWM technique due to its lack of technologies, electrolytic capacitors are particularly sensitive,
output voltage amplitude control. with every 10 ◦C rise in operating temperature reducing the
lifetime of the capacitor by approximately half [37].
As power requirements for traction inverters continue to
D. Inverter components rise, heat dissipation has become a critical concern in inverter
IGBTs have been the predominant choice for traction in- design. In fact, high temperatures have been identified as the
verters compared to other switching devices. This is due primary source of failure and overheating dramatically reduces
to the maturity of the technology, its wide availability, low the reliability and lifetime of power converters [38, 39]. Hence,
cost, and sufficient power capability. Indeed, IGBTs with a thermal management systems, such as heat sinks, have become
blocking voltage of 650V to 1200V can easily handle today’s staple components and optimizing their design is a challenging
battery pack voltages which vary from 200V to 450V in most task as they require advanced loss and thermal models [40–
43]. Many cooling techniques have been studied over the
years [44]. Liquid cooling is usually preferred in high power 1
inverters since they efficiently dissipate more heat in a limited
space compared to forced air cooling. They also operate better
2
regardless of the ambient environmental conditions.
Busbars are commonly used in high power inverters due
to their superior current capability compared to printed cir-
cuit boards (PCBs) and higher power density compared to
the use of wires. Their design is a complex procedure that
requires many considerations such as the shapes of the DC- 3
link capacitor and power devices, the thermal management 4
system, the current density, and the operating environment.
Particular attention must be paid to minimize any parasitic 5
inductance introduced by the busbar connections which can
have a significant effect on surge voltages during switching
events [45].
1
IV. F UTURE T RENDS
2
The DOE has identified several potential strategies towards
3 achieving their 100 kW/L inverter target for 2025. Further
4 integration of the inverter subcomponents is considered nec-
essary, requiring advanced packaging capable of electrical and
thermal isolation, while enabling significantly higher switching
frequencies and power density. These tightly integrated com-
ponents will require advanced thermal management systems
5 and materials [5]. Several industry and research trends have
also been identified in the areas of component packaging,
gate driver design, system integration, and manufacturing tech-
6 niques. Replacing silicon (Si) power semiconductors with wide
bandgap (WBG) devices also brings significant opportunities
7 to overcome the challenges associated with designing the next
8 generation of traction inverters [63].
A. Topologies
9
It is expected the majority of automotive traction inverters
will remain conventional two level VSIs. Multiphase two
level inverters have been applied where high torque is a
requirement, such as in buses and other heavy equipment. TM4
Fig. 6: Tesla Model S inverter components 1) Control board has developed six and nine phase inverters and accompanying
2) Aluminium shield 3) Phase current sensor ferrite ring PM machines for these applications [64]. As DC-link voltages
4) Gate driver board 5) Phase busbars 6) Heat sinks 7) TO-247 increase, multilevel inverters become more attractive, however
package IGBTs 8) IGBT clips 9) DC-link capacitors. the cost of additional switching devices may make them
impractical for consumer automotive applications. Research
examples of multilevel traction inverters for heavy equipment
the DC-link capacitor which is at the bottom of the enclosure have been developed [65, 66]. Switched reluctance motors
furthest from the gearbox. Current sensing is providing by two (SRMs) have also received significant attention as a potential
Hall effect sensor ICs embedded in gapped soft ferromagnetic rare-earth material free traction machine. The conventional
rings which surround two of the phase cables. SRM is driven with an asymmetric bridge converter topol-
Unlike all other inverters surveyed, Tesla has opted for ogy, which while distinct from a two level VSI, has similar
paralleling TO-247 discrete package IGBTs to achieve the requirements for the inverter components. SRM drives have
required current ratings rather than using power modules. Six also been commercially applied for traction purposes in heavy
IGBTs are paralleled per switch for a total of 36 IGBTs. equipment [67].
TABLE I: Inverter power density and specific power in recent EVs
Chevy Volt PHEV (2014) [46] Dual inverter 180 17.3 21.7
Cadillac CT6 PHEV (2016) [48] Dual inverter 215 22.6 16.0
Dual inverter, boost converter and
Toyota Prius HEV (2016) [51] 162 23.7 13.6
APM
Nissan LEAF BEV (2012) [52] Single inverter 80a 7.1 4.7
BMW i3 BEV (2016) [55] Single inverter, charger and APM 125a —c 6.6
Audi A3 e-Tron PHEV (2016) [57] Single inverter and APM 75a 9.4 7.4
Tesla Model S 70D BEV (2015) Single inverter 193a,b 30.1 33.3
† Total power rating is typically reported for only the inverter(s) while the mass and volume is reported for all components contained in the inverter housing,
resulting in lower than actual estimates of power density and specific power. All values are peak output powers.
a Values are reported motor power in kW. Inverter kVA rating is likely slightly higher, resulting in lower than actual estimates of power density and specific
power.
b Motor power as previously reported by Tesla [62]
c Volume not reported
B. WBG devices which consist of a Si IGBT and SiC diode in one package. The
The application of WBG semiconductors for power elec- SiC diode has negligible reverse recovery loss compared to an
tronics including automotive traction inverters has been an Si diode which is shown to reduce the total loss by 30-40%
area of significant research attention and the DOE has invested [85, 86]. Recently, it has been revealed that the Tesla Model
heavily in their commercialization through the Advanced Re- 3 traction inverter is fully SiC MOSFET based with devices
search Projects Agency-Energy (ARPA-E) [68]. In fact, the from STMicroelectronics [87].
aggressive 2025 power density targets are reliant on replacing
traditional Si power transistors with WBG devices [5]. This is C. Component packaging
due to the fact that WBG devices have demonstrated numer- Multiple approaches can be undertaken to improve the
ous advantages over Si IGBTs including higher temperature packaging of switching devices, resulting in superior thermal
operation, higher breakdown voltages, and higher switching and electrical performance while reducing weight and size.
frequencies while reducing both losses and chip size. Currently Mitsubishi Electric launched a new IGBT module featuring a
Silicon Carbide (SiC) and Gallium Nitride (GaN) are the unified single layer insulated metal baseplate (IMB), providing
most promising WBG materials due to their characteristics both good insulation voltage and high thermal conductivity
and commercialization progress [69]. SiC in particular has [88]. Conventionally, ceramic substrates are used for their
been an attractive candidate for traction inverters due to its low thermal resistance in combination with aluminum nitride
superior high temperature operation which may enable system substrates that provide the electrical insulation. By using the
cost reductions through the unification of the inverter, EM, IMB technique, the single layer allows elimination of the
and even ICE liquid cooling loops [70]. bond wires between the substrates and the effective area for
The maximum DC-link voltage for BEVs is currently chip mounting can be increased by a reported 23%. The heat
around 400 V however further increases are expected. Porsche dissipation is also enhanced thanks to a reported 65% thermal
and Fisker have both announced 800 V architectures with resistance reduction.
the goal of enabling faster charging rates [71, 72]. While Si Reliability improvements can also be realized through im-
devices are capable of 800 V operation, increased switching proved packaging and advanced thermal design. This has
losses tend to reduce the efficiency making WBG devices an been achieved through innovations in the die attach process,
attractive solution for the traction inverter. In 2016, Toyota enhanced interconnections, and cooling methods such as DSC.
demonstrated a prototype SiC inverter for the Prius which Manufacturers have begun to move away from bond wires
was reported to achieve a 5% increase in fuel efficiency [73]. and soldered connections as they show limitations under high
Mitsubishi Electric has also developed a prototype SiC traction current and high temperature operation [89, 90]. Semikron has
inverter with a reported power density of 86 kVA/L [74]. developed their line of SKiM modules which use diffusion
Numerous research examples of WBG device based traction sinter connections to replace the thermal interface material,
inverters have been reported in [75–78] and reviews on the solder layers, and bond wires [91]. As a result, high reliabil-
status and applications of WBG devices to EVs have been ity and extended lifetime are achieved under cyclic thermal
conducted in [79–82]. While WBG devices offer many benefits stresses. Thermal management is also improved along with
over existing Si devices, the cost premium has been the the power density by extending the heat dissipation area of
primary barrier to adoption by automotive manufacturers. This the module. This is achieved with the DSC method that
cost is expected to continue to decline as manufacturing removes heat from both the top and bottom sides of the
techniques improve and the market expands [83, 84]. As module, which can reduce the footprint up to 45% compared
an intermediate step towards full WBG utilization, some to the conventional singled-sided cooling technology [92]. In
semiconductor manufacturers have introduced hybrid devices combination with DSC, bond wires for the top side of the chip
can be replaced by planar interconnections [93]. By doing dV/dt Feedback
so, the thermal resistance as well as the stray inductance
and parasitic resistance are reduced by 30%, 15%, and 75%
respectively. Hence, the reliability and thermal capability of
the system are increased along with the power density. The
DSC technique has been implemented in production inverters
by GM with Hitachi and Delphi Technologies modules, as well Gate
as by Toyota [57, 94, 95]. Dri ve r IC