Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Management of Cracked Tooth Syndrome in Dental Practice
The Management of Cracked Tooth Syndrome in Dental Practice
In brief
Explains the features of cracked tooth. Describes diagnostic techniques and outlines Introduces a novel diagnostic and immediate
treatment options. management technique.
Cracked tooth syndrome is a commonly encountered condition in dental practice which frequently causes diagnostic and
management challenges. This paper provides an overview of the diagnosis of this condition and goes on to discuss current
short and long-term management strategies applicable to dental practitioners. This paper also covers the diagnosis and
management of this common condition and aims to inform clinicians of the current thinking, as well as to provide an
overview of the techniques commonly used in managing cracked tooth syndrome.
Introduction or root) or to the pulp chamber (culminat- described technique to assist with the
ing in apical periodontitis), a diagnosis of a diagnosis, immediate management and sub-
Cracks in teeth are exceedingly common. complete fracture may apply. Complete and sequent treatment of CTS.
Some may be become problematic and can incomplete fractures may be subdivided into
lead to symptoms, cracked tooth syndrome those that take a vertical or oblique direction.3 CTS
and tooth loss. Incomplete fractures of posterior teeth are
A ‘crack’ may be defined as a ‘line on the commonly (but not always) associated with Epidemiology and aetiology
surface of something along which it has split the condition of cracked tooth syndrome, Cracked tooth syndrome appears to typically
without breaking apart’, while a ‘fracture’ may frequently abbreviated to CTS. Patients pre- affect adult patients that are past their third
be considered to be ‘the cracking or breaking of senting with CTS often complain of symptoms decade, often affecting teeth that have pre-
a hard object or material’ (www.oxforddiction- of sharp pain on biting and thermal sensitiv- viously received restorative intervention,
aries.com).1 Cracks on teeth may range from ity particularly during the consumption of although not exclusively.8 A possible reason
innocuous craze lines limited to the enamel cold foods and beverages.4 The intensity of includes older teeth having more restorations
layer, to a split tooth to one that may display the perceived pain on biting is often propor- and may thus experience increased lateral
the presence of a vertical root fracture. The tional to the magnitude of the applied force.5 occlusal load due to the possible loss of anterior
term ‘incomplete fracture’ is used to describe a Additional symptoms that are less frequently guidance over time.
fracture plane of unknown depth and direction reported include: the perception of pain on Mandibular molar teeth seem to be most
passing through tooth structure that may, if release particularly when fibrous foods are commonly involved, followed by maxillary
not already doing so, progress to communicate eaten, (a phenomenon termed ‘rebound pain’), premolars, maxillary molars and mandibular
with the pulp or periodontal ligament’.2 Where pain elicited by the act of tooth clenching premolars. In a recent clinical audit, man-
the fracture plane may progress to the external or grinding or by consuming sugary sub- dibular first molar teeth were most commonly
surface of the tooth (either the clinical crown strates and less commonly by heat stimuli. affected by CTS possibly due to the wedging
Sometimes, patients suffering from CTS are effect of the opposing prominent maxillary
1
Programme Director, MSc Aesthetic Dentistry, Senior Clini- also able to accurately locate the affected tooth. mesio-palatal cusp onto the mandibular molar
cal Teacher, 2Senior Clinical Teacher, Deputy Programme The precise cause of the symptoms associated central fissure.9
Director, MSc Aesthetic Dentistry; 3Professor, Consultant,
Programme Director Fixed and Removable Prosthodontics with CTS is unknown.6,7 The aetiology of CTS is multifactorial.
*Correspondence to: Dr Shamir B. Mehta The aim of this article is to provide an Causative factors include: previous restorative
Email: shamir.mehta@kcl.ac.uk
overview of the condition of CTS as well as procedures, occlusal factors, developmental
Refereed Paper. Accepted 16 February 2017 to appraise traditional management strate- conditions/anatomical considerations, trauma
DOI: 10.1038/sj.bdj.2017.398
gies including the description of a recently and miscellaneous factors (such as an ageing
Symptoms Signs
Listen to the patient Look with illumination and magnification
Pain – sharp and localised Fracture line(s) – inspection with probe, transillumination, location Tests
Pain on biting/release ? Tooth wear – check occlusal contacts and disclusion Cold test
Thermal sensitivity, especially to cold Restorations – weaken teeth, hide fractures Bite test
DCS
Diagnosis of CTS
Exclude: periodontal/periapical causes, galvanic action, Immediate protection
facial pain, exposed dentine, post-op pain Splinting – DCS, bands
DCS excludes apical pathology Assess pulp status - ?RCT needed ? Intrude
Canine riser or splint needed?
Diagnosis of CTS
The diagnosis of CTS (Fig. 1) is often based
on the reporting of a history of cold sensitivity
and sharp pain on biting hard on fibrous food,
with an alleviation of symptoms on the release
of pressure. However, the perceived symptoms
may display variation in accordance to depth
and orientation of the crack.11 The visual
detection of a crack, often aided with the use of
a sharp explorer probe ideally with magnifica-
tion, may help to confirm a suspected diagnosis;
however, not all cracks are symptomatic. The
application of point load testing devices to apply Fig. 2 An example of a trial localised supportive composite splint
a force to a suspected fracture is risky, due to the
possibility of fracture of the tooth, restoration or
the opposing tooth and therefore the authors do
not recommend their use. orange lights may be of greater value than blue exist over a precise diagnosis, which may prove
Hypersensitivity to an applied cold stimulant light. However, blue lights are more readily frustrating to all concerned, often necessitating
(indicative of pulpal inflammation) may also available. Figure 1 includes a flow diagram specialist attention.12
help to confirm a diagnosis of CTS. Affected which may be used to assist with the diagnosis The above is accounted for by there being
teeth are however seldom tender to percussion, and management of CTS. several other conditions that may yield similar
by virtue of the absence of a complete fracture Consensus opinion would suggest that the symptoms to those of CTS, including some
and the absence of irreversible pulpitis. The presence of a history of symptoms as noted commonly encountered conditions such as
taking of radiographs to see a coronal crack above, hypersensitivity to cold and a positive occlusal trauma, acute periodontal disease,
can be of a limited diagnostic benefit, as cracks bite test are likely to indicate the presence of dentine hypersensitivity, galvanic pain, post-
may run parallel to the plane of the film. The an incomplete tooth fracture. However, in operative hypersensitivity, fractured restora-
use of a light to transilluminate a tooth can the opinion of the authors it is common for a tions, to less frequently diagnosed conditions
be helpful. It has been suggested that yellow/ misdiagnosis to occur or indeed ambiguity to such as trigeminal neuralgia and atypical
Table 1 A summary of some commonly used acute splints for the management of CTS in general dental practice18-21
Can be effective Not always at the disposal of a GDP Must be well adapted circumferentially
Skills & knowledge required to enable
Economical Contoured appropriately
correct placement.
1. Copper rings & stainless steel Must not interfere with the existing
Minimally invasive Placement may prove uncomfortable
orthodontics bands12,18 occlusal scheme
Endodontic treatments may be performed
Poor aesthetics Should remain in situ for 2 to 4 weeks
while in situ
Can help to establish a definitive diagnosis Food trapping with orthodontic bands
Can provide an effective means of immo- Time consuming to prepare; undue delays
bilisation may result in fracture progression
2. Provisional crowns/overlays19 Most general dental practitioners will be
Biologically invasive, with risks of pulp
confident and competent with clinical
tissue trauma20,21
techniques
facial pain.13 Establishment of an accurate economic, predictable and biologically con- form of tooth preparation, where some bio-
diagnosis may also be compounded by the servative means of treating this condition. logical compromise is likely to be incurred.20,21
lack of sensitivity offered by the clinical tests While some advocate the removal of the Table 1 provides a summary of the traditional
described above and also by virtue of the pre- affected cusp, followed by restoration of the protocols used for the immediate management
senting symptoms often displaying diversity residual defect or subtractive occlusal adjust- of CTS.
and inconsistency (which may also relate to ments,15 the consensus approach for the man-
the exact depth and direction of the crack).9 agement of incompletely fractured posterior Direct intra-coronal restorations
The authors have recently described a useful; teeth would generally appear to involve the When using an intra-coronal restoration to
clinically quick and easy way to establish or immobilisation or splinting of the affected tooth, treat an incompletely fractured posterior
confirm a diagnosis with the use of a ‘trial’ so as to prevent the independent movement of tooth, the objective is to anchor the chosen
localised supportive composite splint.9 Here, the fractured portions upon occlusal loading. dental material to the cavity walls at either
the suspected tooth exhibiting CTS symptoms Immobilisation in this manner may also side of the fracture plane. This would help to
of pain upon release is isolated using cotton prevent further progression of the fracture not only prevent the independent movement
wool rolls. Resin composite is placed onto the plane.16,17 of the portions either side of the fracture plane,
dried occlusal surface of the suspected tooth Where removal of the fractured cusp is to but also aid in restoring the intrinsic fracture
without any etching or bond application to a be undertaken, it should be performed with toughness of a tooth.
thickness of 1.0 to 1.5 mm and wrapped across extreme caution, as there is a risk of attenua- The use of adhesively retained silver
the external line angles of the tooth extending tion of the fracture plane. Subtractive occlusal amalgam restorations has been described for
onto the (palatal/lingual and buccal) axial walls adjustment is invasive and will not help to the successful management of CTS.22 However,
by 2-3 mm. No effort is made to contour the avoid the continual flexure of the tooth upon the evidence is very limited.
material. Once the material has been cured, loading when an occlusal load is applied.8 Cusp There is some evidence to support the
the un-bonded resin overlay has the potential reduction to overlay it with a protective restor- short-term prescription of direct, resin bonded
to serve as an occlusal splint. The patient is ative material may be required: composite 2 posterior composite restorations to treat cases
warned that the tooth will feel proud and then mm, gold and other alloys 1 mm. of CTS.23 Opdam et al. evaluated the efficacy
asked to bring this tooth into contact with It is also important to check the anterior of direct composite intracoronal resin restora-
its antagonist and asked to bite and slowly guidance when providing care. If necessary, tions (to treat painful, cracked posterior teeth
increase the pressure as a repeat of the initial thought may be given to the ‘building up’ of where there were pre-existing silver amalgam
‘bite’ test. The absence of any pain upon release any worn anterior teeth to increase the level restorations). Cases were followed up for a
of the pressure may help to confirm a suspect of disclusion. period of seven years; an annual failure rate of
diagnosis of CTS. An example of a trial splint 6% was reported. This compared less favour-
is shown by Figure 2. Immediate management of CTS ably to where a second sample had received
Traditionally, unless the affected cusp has been directly bonded resin overlay restorations. It
Management of CTS splintered off during the removal of an existing was suggested that the inferior success of the
A number of differing protocols have been restoration when undertaking exploratory intracoronal approach might relate to the pro-
described in the contemporary literature for procedure, acute management has generally gressive breakdown of the adhesive interface
the successful management of CTS.14 There been provided using immediate extra-coronal (between the tooth and restoration) with
is however, only limited data available docu- circumferential splints (such as copper rings, cyclical functional loading. The latter would
menting the relative merits and drawbacks of orthodontic bands or provisional crowns)18,19 thereby hamper the longer-term ability of
each. In the opinion of the authors, the selected or by the application of direct (intra-coronal or the restoration to effectively splint the crack.
protocol should offer an effective, efficient, extra-coronal splints) usually involving some This may be of particular concern among
Placement of DCS in supra occlusion without bonding on tooth Pain still present and/or not completely resolved upon release of DCS
No pain on biting and release on DCS Inadequate bone support Assess pulpal status +/- endodontic
treatment Consider splinting without
increasing OVD Consider specialist referral
Review at 1 week and periodically during occlusal equilibration Pain and/or discomfort
No symptoms
Occlusion equilibrated
Replace DCS with definitive restoration
Fig. 6 The separation of the teeth is shown here following Fig. 7 Upon right lateral excusrion, the posterior teeth (along with
placement of the DCS the splinted tooth) are no longer in occlusal contact. Guidance to
mandibular movement is being provided by the lower right canine
tooth (canine guidance)
Fig. 9 The flat surfaced DCS has been replaced with a direct
Fig. 8 The teeth have now re-established contact in the intercuspal composite onlay with an appropriate occlusal anatomy to
position and the symptoms are resolved from the lower right second minimise lateral loading following resolution of symptoms and
molar tooth reestablishment of the occlusion
• The occlusal surface should to remain ‘flat’ and management of CTS in a predictable and 19. Gutherie G C, Difiore P M. Treating the cracked tooth
with a full crown. J Am Dent Assoc 1991; 122: 71–73.
with the absence of any contact during minimally invasive manner. However, there is a 20. Saunders W P, Saunders E M. Prevalence of periradicular
any excursive mandibular movements. need for further research into this technique as periodontitis associated with crowned teeth in an adult
Scottish subpopulation. Br Dent J 1988; 185: 137–140.
In certain instances a canine rise may be well as into alternative forms of management as
21. Cheung G S, Lia S C, Ng R P. Fate of vital pulps beneath
added in composite to achieve this discussed above, in order to support (or indeed a metal ceramic crown or a bridge retainer. Int Endod J
• Composite to be polished contraindicate) the notion of any one approach 2005; 38: 521–530.
22. Bearn D, Saunders E, Saunders W. The bonded amalgam
• The patient should be reviewed within (inclusive of a given dental material and or restoration – a review of the literature and report of
in one week to confirm alleviation of restoration form) being superior to another. its use in the treatment of four cases of cracked tooth
syndrome. Quintessence Int 1994; 25: 321–326.
symptoms, followed by a periodic review 23. Opdam N J, Roeters J J, Loomans R A, Bronkhorst E.
1. Crack – definition of crack in English from the Oxford
every two weeks until all other tooth dictionary. Available at: www.oxforddictionaries.com Seven year clinical evaluation of painful, cracked teeth
(accessed April 2017). restored with a direct composite restoration. J Endod
contacts are re-established 2008; 34: 808–811.
2. Ellis S G. Incomplete tooth fracture-proposal for a new
• Substitution of the composite splint with a definition. Br Dent J 2001; 190: 424–428. 24. van Dijken J W V, Pallesen U. A randomized controlled
3. Silvestri A, Singh I. Treatment rationale of fractured three year evaluation of ‘bulk-filled’ posterior resin
definitive adhesive restoration once other restorations based on stress decreasing resin technology.
posterior teeth. J Am Dent Assoc 1978; 97: 806–810.
tooth contacts reestablished. Remove 4. Cameron C E. The cracked tooth syndrome: additional Dent Mater 2014 30: e245–e251.
canine rise restoration if required. findings. J Am Dent Assoc 1976; 93: 971–975. 25. McGuirk C, Hussain F, Millar B J. The effect of a bulk-fill
5. Signore A, Benedicenti S, Covani U. Ravera G. A 4 to 6 base on the clinical survival of direct posterior composite
year retrospective clinical study of cracked teeth restored restorations. Eur J Prosthod Rest Dent 2017 - in press
While further work is needed to fully support with bonded indirect resin composite onlays. Int J 26. Hodd J A A. Biomechanics of the intact, prepared and
Prosthodont 2007; 20: 609–616. restored tooth; some clinical implications. Int Dent J
this approach, the use of a DCS restoration has 6. Davis R, Overton J. Efficacy of bonded and non-bonded 1991; 41: 25–32.
the potential (where careful case selection is amalgams in the treatment of teeth with incomplete 27. Davis R, Overton J. Efficacy of bonded and non-bonded
fractures. J Am Dent Assoc 2000; 131: 496–478. amalgams in the treatment of teeth with incomplete
applied) to provide a conservative, effective, 7. Dewberry J A. Vertical fractures of posterior teeth, Lieve fractures. J Am Dent Assoc 2000; 131: 496–478.
predictable, efficient and economical approach F S (ed). Endodontic therapy, 5th edition. pp 71-81. St 28. Chana H, Kelleher M, Briggs P, Hopper R. Clinical evalu-
Louis: Mosby, 1996. ation of resin bonded gold alloys. J Prosthet Dent 2000;
to the short to medium term management of 83: 294–300.
8. Hiatt W H. Incomplete crown-root fractures in pulpal
CTS. It may be particularly appropriate where periodontal disease. J Periodontol 1973; 44: 369–379. 29. Brunton P A, Cattell P, Burke F J T, Wilson N H F. Fracture
9. Banerji S, Mehta S B, Kamran T, Kalakonda M, Millar resistance of teeth restored with onlays of three contem-
there may exist a doubt over the exact diagnosis.
B J. A multicentered clinical audit to describe the porary tooth-coloured resinbonded restorative materials.
An extrapolation of this approach may involve efficacy of direct supra-coronal splinting – a minimally J Prosthet Dent 1999; 82: 167–171.
the placement of indirect adhesive onlays in invasive approach to the management of cracked tooth 30. Casciari B J. Altered preparation design for cracked
syndrome. J Dent 2014; 42: 862–871. teeth. J Am Dent Assoc 1991; 130: 571–572.
supra-occlusion as a means for the long-term 10. Lynch C, McConnel R. The cracked tooth syndrome. 31. Krell K, Rivera E. A six year evaluation of cracked teeth
management of incompletely fractured teeth in J Can Dent Assoc 2002; 68: 470–475. diagnosed with reversible pulptitis; treatment and
11. Geurtsen W, Schwarze T, Gunay H. Diagnosis, therapy prognosis.
an ultra-conservative manner, where there is and prevention of the cracked tooth syndrome. Quintes- J Endod 2007; 33: 1405–1407.
little doubt over the diagnosis. sence Int 2003; 34: 409–417. 32. Tan I, Chen N N, Poon C Y, Wong H B. Survival of root
12. Banerji S, Mehta S B, Millar B J. Cracked tooth syndrome. filled cracked teeth in a tertiary institution. Int Endod J
With the advancement of CAD-CAM tech- Part 1 : aetiology and diagnosis. Br Dent J 2010; 208: 2006; 39: 886–889.
nology the fabrication of the proposed onlay 459–463. 33. Dahl B, Krungstad O, Karlsen K, An alternative treatment
13. Turp C, Gobetti J. The cracked tooth syndrome: an elu- of cases with advanced localised attrition. J Oral Rehab
can now be produced at the chairside once the 1975; 2: 209–214.
sive diagnosis. J Am Dent Assoc 1996; 127: 1502–1507.
diagnosis has been established. 14. Banerji S, Mehta S B, Millar B J. Cracked tooth syndrome. 34. Dahl B, Krungstad O. Long term observations of an
Part 2 : restorative options for the management of increased occlusal face height obtained by a combined
cracked tooth syndrome. Br Dent J 2010; 208: 503–514. orthodontic/prosthetic approach. J Oral Rehabil 1985;
Conclusion 15. Agar J R, Weller R N. Occlusal adjustments for initial 12: 173–170.
treatment and prevention of cracked tooth syndrome. J 35. Poyser N, Porter R, Briggs P, Chana H, Kelleher M. The
Prosthet Dent 1988; 60: 145–147. Dahl concept: past, present and future. Br Dent J 2005;
The diagnosis and management of CTS in 16. Griffin J. Efficient, conservative treatment of symptom- 198: 669–676.
dental practice can sometimes prove to be atic cracked teeth. Compendium 2006; 27: 93–102. 36. Hemmings K, Darbar U, Vaughn S. Tooth wear treated
17. Liebenberg W H. Partial coverage indirect tooth coloured with direct composite at an increased vertical dimen-
highly taxing on the operator. There is a restorations; steps to clinical success. Am J Dent 1999; sion: results at 30 months. J Prosthet Dent 2000; 83:
need for an effective technique to provide 12: 201–209. 287–293.
18. Ehrmann E H, Tyas M J. Cracked tooth syndrome: diag- 37. Gerasimidou O, Watson T, Millar B J. Effect of placing
immobilisation. The DCS restoration may nosis, treatment and correlation between symptoms and intentionally high restorations: randomized clinical trial.
have considerable merits for the diagnosis post-extraction findings. Aust Dent J 1990; 35: 105–112. J Dent 2016; 45: 26–31.