Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development of Essential Oil-Based Arthropod Repellent Products
Development of Essential Oil-Based Arthropod Repellent Products
Other plant essential oil extracts qualify as “minimum risk” pesticides and
are exempt from registration as a result of EPA action under FIFRA, section
25(b) (18), on the basis that it is unnecessary to regulate the named substances in
order to prevent unreasonable adverse human health and environmental effects
for the intended use. Several factors were used by the EPA to assess the risk to
human health and the environment for the intended use as a pesticide, including
substances that are: 1) available to the general public (widespread) and have
not shown evidence of adverse effects, 2) common food items, 3) FDA GRAS
substances, 4) active via nontoxic modes of action, 5) no known data showing
significant adverse effects to humans or the environment, 6) use patterns with
negligible potential for incremental exposure, and 7) presumed to not persist
in the environment (19). Current actives listed as exempt from EPA pesticide
registration are provided in Table 1.
153
In Recent Developments in Invertebrate Repellents; Paluch, G., et al.;
ACS Symposium Series; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 2011.
Table 1.
Active Ingredients Exempt from EPA Registration [FIFRA 25(b)] (20)
Castor oil Linseed oil
Cedar oil Malic acid
Cinnamon and cinnamon oil Mint and mint oil
Citric acid Peppermint and peppermint oil
Citronella and Citronella oil 2-Phenethyl propionate
Cloves and clove oil Potassium sorbate
Corn gluten meal Putrescent whole egg solids
Downloaded by SUNY STONY BROOK on October 23, 2014 | http://pubs.acs.org
Publication Date (Web): December 13, 2011 | doi: 10.1021/bk-2011-1090.ch010
synergists (24), these represent some of the commonly pursued research, aimed
toward commercialization.
Patents may be a source for chemical and biological properties, including
biological activity of compounds or compositions, chemical synthesis
methodology, properties of chemical additives (carriers, stabilizers), test methods,
etc (26). Patents containing information on essential oil compositions potentially
offer information on the synergistic effects of individual compounds since
essentials oils are often mixtures of volatiles (example of complex mixtures from
commercially available essential oils provided in Table 2).
The technology used to develop today’s essential oil-based blends represent
advances from their historic uses to control arthropod pests, as evidenced by the
growing patent literature. Businesses that strive to develop such innovations look
for protection and value of their inventions, in addition to meeting requirements
for existing and emerging market opportunities. Other factors associated with
commercialization and investments in essential oil-based technologies are based
on the cost of product registration as well as the cost of production (27, 28).
155
In Recent Developments in Invertebrate Repellents; Paluch, G., et al.;
ACS Symposium Series; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 2011.
Table 2. Common primary constituents of commercially available rosemary
(Rosmarinus officinalis), cinnamon (Cinnamomum zeylanicum), and
peppermint (Mentha piperita) oils (%v/v) averaged from 30 samples (29)
Constituent Rosemary Oil Peppermint Oil Cinnamon Oil
α-Pinene 10.8 - -
Camphene 5.0 - -
β-Pinene 6.2 - -
3-Carene 0.4
p-Cymene 1.3 - -
d-Limonene 4.1 2.1 0.5
Downloaded by SUNY STONY BROOK on October 23, 2014 | http://pubs.acs.org
Publication Date (Web): December 13, 2011 | doi: 10.1021/bk-2011-1090.ch010
Linalool 1.2 -
Linalyl acetate 14.6 -
1,8-Cineole 37.8 5.1 -
Borneol 1.6 -
Camphor 7.9 - -
α-Terpineol 1.9 - -
Caryophyllene 3.0 1.0 1.7
Bornyl acetate 1.5 -
Cinnamaldehyde - 1.3 2.2
Pulegone - 1.9
Eugenol - 1.5 88
Menthone - 25.7 -
Menthofuran - 4.7 -
Menthyl acetate - 5.2
Menthol - 48.8 -
Humulene 0.6
Benzyl benzonate 3.8
Minor compounds 2.7 2.7 3.2
156
In Recent Developments in Invertebrate Repellents; Paluch, G., et al.;
ACS Symposium Series; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 2011.
Laboratory Trials To Screen EPA Exempt Minimum Risk Actives for
Repellency
compounds for attracting and repelling pollinators were investigated. The studies
identified benzyl acetone (attractant) and nicotine (repellent to reduce florivory
and nectar robbing) were important floral volatiles required to maximize wild
tobacco reproduction. Knowledge of such chemical interactions and ecological
roles play a major part in product development of repellents.
Identification of the essential oil active ingredient and the key properties
inherent to its individual components offers a challenge to formulation
development in the repellent product category. An important step in the process
is to establish a baseline of desired effects as they relate to performance standards
for commercial product repellents, and translate this into a blend quality or
composition standard. Further, establishment of the blend composition provides
added benefits for product development and assessing the supply of raw ingredient
essential oils. In some cases the complexity of the blend composition of essential
oil actives requires sourcing high quality materials that is cost-prohibitive.
However, high costs might be mitigated by improving such issues as plant
cultivation conditions, production and post-production practices, and shipping.
Future Outlooks
The complexity of plant essential oil blends creates a unique challenge to the
development of commercially acceptable arthropod repellents. Variability in the
oils due to source and processing procedures poses a challenge in the development
of a formulation and in the manufacturing process. Nevertheless, one could argue
that both the familiarity and inherent complexity of the blend composition and its
properties has helped to maintain interest over time, providing a large amount of
foundational research, particularly with respect to use of the same essential oils in
food and cosmetics.
The current trends in growth of essential oil-based repellent products highlight
the demand and market for green products. The future outlook for these types of
products is dependent on meeting industry guidelines that govern essential oil-
based repellent products and protect returns on investments. At a minimum, these
products should be labeled such that their safety and efficacy is made clear to
consumers seeking pest management or personal protection products.
159
In Recent Developments in Invertebrate Repellents; Paluch, G., et al.;
ACS Symposium Series; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 2011.
References
1. Moisander, J. Int. J. Consum. Stud. 2007, 31, 404–409.
2. Alder, J. Newsweek 2006, July 17, 42–52.
3. Kangun, N.; Carlson, L.; Grove, S. J. J. Public Policy Mark. 1991, 10, 47–58.
4. Martin, B.; Simintiras, A. Mark. Intell. Plann. 1995, 13, 16–23.
5. Todd, A. M. Ethics Environ. 2004, 9, 86–102.
6. Kim, H. Y.; Chung, J. E. J. Consum. Market. 2011, 28, 40–47.
7. Harris Interactive. ‘Green’ Issues and Professional Pest Services. Prepared
for the National Pest Management Association and presented at Going Green:
Marketing to the 21st Centry Consumer, Denver, CO, 2007.
8. Tripathi, A. K.; Upadhyay, S.; Bhuiyan, M.; Bhattacharya, P. R. J Pharm.
Downloaded by SUNY STONY BROOK on October 23, 2014 | http://pubs.acs.org
Publication Date (Web): December 13, 2011 | doi: 10.1021/bk-2011-1090.ch010
160
In Recent Developments in Invertebrate Repellents; Paluch, G., et al.;
ACS Symposium Series; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 2011.
26. Howerton, P. W. J. Chem. Doc. 1964, 4, 232–234.
27. Semmler, M.; Abdel-Ghaffar, F.; Al-Rasheid, K.; Mehlhorn, H. Parasitol.
Res. 2009, 105, 1483–1487.
28. Isman, M. B.; Miresmailli, S.; Machial, C. Phytochem. Rev. 2011, 10,
197–204.
29. Bradbury, R. 2010, unpublished report submitted to EcoSMART
Technologies, Inc.
30. Smith, J. B. N. J. Agric. Exp. Stn., Cook Coll. 1901, 542, 37–42.
31. Isman, M. B. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 2006, 51, 45–66.
32. Maia, M. F.; Moore, S. J. Malaria J. 2011, 10 (Supplement 1), S11.
33. Schultz, G. E.; Peterson, C.; Coats, J. Natural Insect Repellents: Activity
against Mosquitoes and Cockroaches. In Natural Products for Pest
Downloaded by SUNY STONY BROOK on October 23, 2014 | http://pubs.acs.org
Publication Date (Web): December 13, 2011 | doi: 10.1021/bk-2011-1090.ch010
161
In Recent Developments in Invertebrate Repellents; Paluch, G., et al.;
ACS Symposium Series; American Chemical Society: Washington, DC, 2011.