Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rapid Identification of Plant-And Chemical-Dyed Cotton Fabrics Using The Near-Infrared Technique
Rapid Identification of Plant-And Chemical-Dyed Cotton Fabrics Using The Near-Infrared Technique
Rapid Identification of Plant-And Chemical-Dyed Cotton Fabrics Using The Near-Infrared Technique
Abstract
Plant dye is a promising dyestuff to be used in textiles due to its unique environmental compatibility. However, currently
there is no effective method for the identification of plant-dyed and chemical-dyed textiles. In this study, near-infrared
(NIR) spectroscopy combined with three kinds of pattern recognition methods, namely soft independent modeling of
class analogy (SIMCA), partial least squares (PLS) regression and principal component regression (PCR), were applied to
identify cotton fabrics dyed with plant and chemical dyes. A total of 336 plant dye and chemical dye dyed cotton fabrics
were prepared and the NIR spectra were collected; 267 samples were used as the calibration set, while the remaining
69 samples were used as the validation set. After pretreatment with the Savitzky–Golay first derivative, the calibration
model was constructed. In the SIMCA model, the correct recognition rate values of the calibration and prediction sets
were 100% and 98.55%, respectively. The PLS model showed that the number of principal components (PCs) and the
correlation coefficient (R2) were 8 and 0.9978, respectively, and the results of PCR were PC ¼ 10, R2 ¼ 0.9937. Both
methods were satisfactory for the predicted results. The overall results indicated that NIR spectroscopy could be used
for rapid and nondestructive identification of plant-dyed cotton fabrics and chemical-dyed cotton fabrics.
Keywords
near-infrared, plant dye, chemical dye, cotton fabric, identification
Chemical dyes are obtained by reacting primary chem- attention.7–9 With the public’s enhanced cognizance to
ical substances separated from petroleum derivatives eco-safety and health concerns, plant dyes are favored
with high temperature and high pressure, which has and respected by people for their excellent environmen-
been developed for more than 160 years since its inven- tal compatibility and health care functions and are
tion. Chemical dyes are attractive as textile colorants widely used in the preparation of a variety of high
due to their complete spectrum, low cost and high col- value-added textiles.5,10,11 Textiles dyed with plant
orfastness, providing colorful fabrics and garments for dyes retain the unique medicinal and aromatic
human beings and occupying an important position in
the national economy.1–4 Natural dyes imply and refer
to all the coloring materials derived or extracted from
nature, that is, of plant, animal, mineral and microbial 1
State Key Laboratory of Bio-Fibers and Eco-Textiles, Qingdao University,
origins.5,6 Nowadays, along with the social develop- China
2
ment and the improvement of people’s living standards, College of Textile & Clothing, Qingdao University, China
3
the significance of textiles has been from warmth to Dezhou Hengfeng Textile Co., Ltd, China
fashion, environmental protection and other functions.
Corresponding author:
The pollution of chemical dyes to the environment has Xianbo Li, Qingdao University, Ningxia Road NO.308, Qingdao,
become increasingly prominent, and its potential harm Shandong 266071, China.
to the human body has also begun to attract Email: fann@public.qd.sd.cn
2 Textile Research Journal 0(00)
components of plants, which have superior human and prediction sets sample was used for the evaluation of
environmental safety.12 the model.
Due to the massive price difference between chemical
and plant dyes, textiles using chemical dyes to fake
plant dyes dyed fabrics can be found in the market, Materials and methods
leading to an active demand to distinguish fabrics
dyed with chemical and plant dyes.13 Since both chem-
Sample preparation
ical- and plant-dyed fabrics are similar in their compos- The samples were all obtained by dyeing bleached
ition and physical texture, the identification of the two cotton fabrics with six types of dyes. The bleached
fabrics is currently still a problem, and there is no cotton fabrics and chemical dyes were provided by
standard in this area. Some studies have been per- Fuyuan Textile and Dyeing Company (Weifang,
formed to establish an identification method in the Shandong, China). The plant dyes were obtained
recent years. The chemical stripping method was used from Dezhou Hengfeng Textile Co., Ltd (Dezhou,
to determine yellow plant-dyed wool fabrics.14 Raman Shandong, China); the red, yellow and blue dyes were
spectroscopy successfully identified natural indigo dyed extracted from sappan, turmeric and radix isatidis,
silk fabrics and chemical indigo dyed silk fabrics.15 respectively. The bleached cotton fabrics underwent
However, the methods are not adaptable to other the dyeing process using the standard dyeing method.
dyed fabrics and market quality supervision because There were 45 chemical-dyed red fabrics (CR), 45 che-
of the disadvantages of being time-consuming, destroy- mical-dyed yellow fabrics (CY), 45 chemical-dyed blue
ing samples and lacking of versatility. Therefore, effect- fabrics (CB), 72 red plant-dyed cotton fabrics (PR), 72
ive and reliable analytical technologies that can identify yellow plant-dyed cotton fabrics (PY) and 57 blue
plant-dyed and chemical-dyed fabrics are demanded plant-dyed cotton fabrics (PB) prepared in this study.
urgently. Each sample was obtained from different dyeing condi-
The near-infrared (NIR) technique is a modern tech- tions to ensure the diversity and independence of the
nique that provides fast quantitative and qualitative sample. In the modeling process, 36 CR samples, 36 CY
analysis, which has the advantages of easy operation, samples, 36 CB samples, 57 PR samples, 57 PY samples
high speed, low cost and no sample consumption.16–18 and 45 PB samples were used for constructing the
NIR spectroscopy has recently gained popularity in models. The remaining samples were used to validate
many fields, such as pharmaceutical and clinical medi- the performances of the established models.
cine, environmental science, food industry, wood testing
and the petrochemical industry.19–22 Principal compo-
nent analysis (PCA), partial least squares discriminant
Infrared spectra and near-infrared spectra collection
analysis (PLS-DA), soft independent modeling of class The bleached and six different dyed cotton fabrics were
analogy (SIMCA), linear discriminant analysis (LDA), investigated with Fourier transform infrared spectros-
the support vector machine (SVM) and artificial neural copy (FT-IR, Thermo Fisher Scientific NICOLET
networks (ANNs) have all been used to deal with clas- 5700, Waltham, MA, USA) in a wavenumber range
sification issues. Our previous study successfully used of 4000–500 cm1. Each spectrum was an average of
the NIR modeling technique to classify natural 16 scans. The NIR spectra were collected using a
fibers,23 different fabrics that are constructed using dif- PerkinElmer Frontier spectrometer. The wavenumber
ferent fibers.24 The quantitative analysis of different range was selected as 10,000–4000 cm1 and the spec-
wood chemical composition was also studied.16,25–27 tral resolution was 4 cm1. Each spectrum was mea-
Therefore, using NIR spectroscopy to classify chemical- sured from an average of 32 scans with air as the
and plant-dyed fabrics is feasible and should be internal reference. Three reduplicative spectra were col-
investigated. lected for each sample and averaged as the final spec-
The objective of this study is to explore the feasibil- trum of the sample. In total, 336 spectra of six different
ity of the identification of cotton fabrics dyed with sample species were acquired. Before analysis and
plant dyes and chemical dyes using NIR spectroscopy during the measurements, constant relative temperature
combined with pattern recognition methods. In particu- (25 2 C) and humidity (57 2%) were maintained.
lar, we choose three primary colors respectively for the
two dyes in order to verify the universality of our
models. Therefore, we adopt SIMCA, partial least
Spectral pretreatment and classification method
squares (PLS) regression and principal component In addition to the sample information, the raw NIR
regression (PCR) methods to build qualitative and spectra also had baseline drift and a large noise in the
quantitative models. The correct recognition rate spectra. Prior to modeling, all of the spectra collected
(CRR) of the models for the calibration sets and the were pretreated using the Savitzky–Golay first
Li et al. 3
derivative (SG 1st-Der). The pretreatment can effect- The colors of the six samples were different, but it
ively eliminate the influence of baseline drift, reduce was hard to identify the chemical-dyed and plant-
noise and enhance the spectral features. SIMCA, dyed samples visually. Traditionally, FT-IR is used to
PCR and PLS regression were applied to all the pre- distinguish different samples with different chemical
processed data. bonds and functional groups. In our research, it was
SMICA is a supervised discriminant analysis method obviously to find that the main peaks of the FT-IR
based on PCA. For each class of sample, a PCA model spectra of the six samples were similar to those of the
is established and then the residual variance of the bleached samples, and there were no characteristic
model class with the residual variance of the unknown peaks for dyes with either chemical and plant species
samples is compared to determine which category the in the spectra. Theoretically speaking, the dye informa-
sample belongs to.28,29 The internal recognition rate tion should be presented in the spectra. However, the
represents the identification capability of the model contents of the dyes in the fabric were very low (the
for the calibrating samples. The recognition rate and concentration was lower than 0.1% in many cases33)
rejection rate refer to the number of samples in and leading to no visible difference in the FT-IR spectra
out the area of the model. as a result of a weak absorption of the dyes, which is
PCR and PLS are both data description and dimen- shown in Figure 1. The above results indicated that it
sion reduction methods,30,31 which are widely used to was difficult to use infrared spectroscopy to identify the
deal with large datasets, such as spectra data. The per- chemical- and plant-dyed fabrics.
formance of established models is evaluated using two As the dye information has been included in the IR/
prime parameters, which are the correlation coefficient NIR spectra, the NIR modeling method has the poten-
(R2) and the root mean square error of prediction tial to classify the different dyed fabrics. The raw NIR
(RMSEP).18,32 R2 indicates the relationship between spectra of the six different dyed cotton fabrics and the
the actual results and the predicted values, which rep- spectra after SG 1st-Der pretreatment are shown in
resents the prediction performance of the model. In Figure 2. The SG 1st-Der preprocessed spectra retain
addition, the RMSEP values show the prediction accur- and strengthen the information of the raw spectra.
acy of the models. To classify the different species of There were also no obvious differences between the
our samples by PCR and PLS regression, some rules six spectra, which indicated the dyed cotton fabrics
were set up as described in Table 1. The samples that could not be identified directly from this figure. To
come from different species were assigned to different solve the problem, classification models based on
values (1, 2, 3, . . ., n). Then PLS and PCR models were chemo-metrics were developed.
constructed based on these values. If the predicted
value of the sample was inside the 0.5 error area
(0.5) of one number, this sample was identified to
SIMCA classification
the relevant species. An optimized classification model was successfully con-
In this study, the values of the six species were assigned structed using the SIMCA method. Table 2 shows the
as follows: 1: CR; 2: CY; 3: CB; 4: PR; 5: PY; 6: PB. results of the calibration model for the six different
types of samples. The results showed a 100% internal
recognition rate and 100% rejection rate for CR, CY,
Results and discussion CB, PY and PB, while PR had a 100% recognition rate
and 99% rejection rate, demonstrating that the model
Spectra of plant- and chemical-dyed samples can identify the dyed fabrics with high accuracy.
Figure 1 shows images of the bleached and six different Then 69 samples were used to validate the precision
dyed cotton fabrics (a) and their FT-IR spectra (b). of the model. Table 3 shows that all the CR, CY, CB,
Table 1. Algorithm for classifying samples of different species using partial least squares/principal component regression
Sample CR CY CB ... PB
Figure 1. Photographs (a) and Fourier transform infrared spectra (b) of bleached and dyed cotton fabrics. CR: chemical-dyed red
fabrics; CY: chemical-dyed yellow fabrics; CB: chemical-dyed blue fabrics; PR: red plant-dyed cotton fabrics; PY: yellow plant-dyed
cotton fabrics; PB: blue plant-dyed cotton fabrics.
Figure 2. Raw near-infrared spectra (a) and Savitzky–Golay first derivative spectra (b) of six kinds of dyed cotton fabrics.
CR: chemical-dyed red fabrics; CY: chemical-dyed yellow fabrics; CB: chemical-dyed blue fabrics; PR: red plant-dyed cotton fabrics;
PY: yellow plant-dyed cotton fabrics; PB: blue plant-dyed cotton fabrics.
Table 2. Classification performance report using the soft independent modeling of class analogy method
Material CR CY CB PR PY PB
Table 3. Identification results of the soft independent modeling Table 4. Inter material distance of the soft independent
of class analogy method modeling of class analogy model
Figure 3. Partial least squares (a) and principal component regression (b) model regression figure of calibration set. PC: principal
component; RMSEE: root mean square error.
Figure 4. The correlations between predicted value and specified value for partial least squares (a) and principal component
regression (b) models in the prediction set. RMSEP: root mean square error of prediction.
Sample CR CY CB PR PY PB
Sample size 9 9 9 15 15 12
Classification value 0.5–1.5 1.51–2.5 2.51–3.5 3.51–4.5 4.51–5.5 5.51–6.5
Prediction value 0.89–1.20 2.01–2.22 2.76–3.14 3.87–4.19 4.72–5.19 5.64–6.17
Recognition no. 9 9 9 15 15 12
Recognition rate 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
CR: chemical-dyed red fabrics; CY: chemical-dyed yellow fabrics; CB: chemical-dyed blue fabrics; PR: red plant-dyed cotton fabrics; PY: yellow plant-
dyed cotton fabrics; PB: blue plant-dyed cotton fabrics.
Li et al. 7
Sample CR CY CB PR PY PB
Sample size 9 9 9 15 15 12
Classification value 0.5–1.5 1.51–2.5 2.51–3.5 3.51–4.5 4.51–5.5 5.51–6.5
Prediction value 0.96–1.24 1.95–2.26 2.81–3.18 3.85–4.19 4.76–5.17 5.58–6.16
Recognition no. 9 9 9 15 15 12
Recognition rate 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
CR: chemical-dyed red fabrics; CY: chemical-dyed yellow fabrics; CB: chemical-dyed blue fabrics; PR: red plant-dyed cotton fabrics; PY: yellow plant-
dyed cotton fabrics; PB: blue plant-dyed cotton fabrics.
Figure 5. Score values of all samples with different principal components (PCs) using partial least squares regression: (a) PC ¼ 1;
(b) PC ¼ 2; (c) PC ¼ 3; (d) PC ¼ 8. CR: chemical-dyed red fabrics; CY: chemical-dyed yellow fabrics; CB: chemical-dyed blue fabrics;
PR: red plant-dyed cotton fabrics; PY: yellow plant-dyed cotton fabrics; PB: blue plant-dyed cotton fabrics.
different dyed cotton fabrics samples, and which PC separated from chemically dyed cotton fabric (CY,
can choose to identify the species better. It was found CB). PR, PY and PB of plant-dyed cotton fabric were
that plant-dyed cotton fabrics (PR, PY, PB) and che- also well separated, while CY and CB were the only two
mical-dyed cotton fabrics (CR, CY, CB) can be sepa- that were still unseparated. CY and CB were well sepa-
rated using PC 1. By choosing PC 2, the CR can be rated when PC 8 was chosen, while the other samples
8 Textile Research Journal 0(00)
were mixed again. As a result, combining PC 8 was the 6. Khan AA, Iqbal N, Adeel S, et al. Extraction of natural
best for identifying all the samples. dye from red calico leaves: gamma ray assisted improve-
ments in colour strength and fastness properties. Dyes
Pigm 2014; 103: 50–54.
Conclusion 7. Silva PMdS, Fiaschitello TR, Queiroz RSd, et al. Natural
dye from Croton urucurana Baill. bark: extraction, phy-
In this study, six species of dyed cotton fabrics, namely sicochemical characterization, textile dyeing and color
CR, CY, CB, PR, PY and PB, were qualitatively iden- fastness properties. Dyes Pigm 2020; 173: 107953.
tified by using NIR spectroscopy and the SIMCA iden- 8. Benli H and Bahtiyari MI. _ Use of ultrasound in biopre-
tification method. The model recognition rate and paration and natural dyeing of cotton fabric in a single
rejection rate were both higher than 95%. PLS and bath. Cellulose 2014; 22: 867–877.
PCR were also created to classify the six species using 9. Li H and Du Z. Preparation of a highly sensitive and
a quantitative analysis method. It was found that the stretchable strain sensor of MXene/silver nanocompo-
correlation coefficient between the calibration set and site-based yarn and wearable applications. ACS Appl
the prediction set of the two models was greater than Mater Inter 2019; 11: 45930–45938.
99%; the PLS model was more accurate and concise. 10. Kamel MM, El-Shishtawy RM, Youssef BM, et al.
Ultrasonic assisted dyeing III. Dyeing of wool with lac
The overall results indicated that it is feasible to iden-
as a natural dye. Dyes Pigm 2005; 65: 103–110.
tify cotton fabrics dyed with plant dyes and chemical 11. Souissi M, Guesmi A and Moussa A. Valorization of
dyes using NIR spectroscopy combined with pattern natural dye extracted from date palm pits (Phoenix dac-
recognition methods. tylifera) for dyeing of cotton fabric. Part 1: optimization
of extraction process using Taguchi design. J Clean Prod
Declaration of conflicting interests 2018; 202: 1045–1055.
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with 12. Kamel MM, El-Shishtawy RM, Youssef BM, et al.
respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this Ultrasonic assisted dyeing. IV. Dyeing of cationised
article. cotton with lac natural dye. Dyes Pigm 2007; 73: 279–284.
13. Sun X, Yuan H, Song C, et al. A novel drying-free iden-
tification method of cashmere textiles by NIR spectros-
Funding copy combined with an adaptive representation learning
The authors disclosed receipt of the following financial sup- classification method. Microchem J 2019; 149: 104018.
port for the research, authorship and/or publication of this 14. Shi D. Identification of woollen fabrics dyed by yellow
article: This work was supported by the National Natural vegetable dyestuffs. Wool Text J 2018; 46: 33–37.
Science Foundation of China (51903131), the Natural 15. Liu W. Study on discrimination of several natural dye on
Science Foundation of Shandong Province (ZR2019Q silk fabric. Master Thesis, Zhejiang Sci- University,
EM007 & ZR2017BEM045) and the Special Foundation of CHN, 2016.
‘‘Taishan Scholar’’ Construction Program. 16. Jiang W, Han G, Via B, et al. Rapid assessment of con-
iferous biomass lignin–carbohydrates with near-infrared
ORCID iDs spectroscopy. Wood Sci Technol 2014; 48: 109–122.
17. Via BK and Jiang W. Nonlinear multivariate modeling of
Guangting Han https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5320-5400
strand mechanical properties with near infrared spectros-
Xianbo Li https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8904-3298
copy. Forest Chron 2013; 89: 621–630.
18. Haffner FB, Mitchell VD, Arundale RA, et al.
References Compositional analysis of Miscanthus giganteus by
1. Bhuiyan MAR, Islam A, Ali A, et al. Color and chemical near infrared spectroscopy. Cellulose 2013; 20:
constitution of natural dye henna (Lawsonia inermis L) 1629–1637.
and its application in the coloration of textiles. J Clean 19. Tong J, Xiang W, Lei P, et al. Prediction of tree species
Prod 2017; 167: 14–22. composition in fine root mixed samples using near-infra-
2. Bechtold T, Mahmudali A and Mussak R. Natural dyes red reflectance spectroscopy. Plant Biosyst 2016; 150:
for textile dyeing: a comparison of methods to assess the 412–419.
quality of Canadian golden rod plant material. Dyes Pigm 20. Hans G, Kitamura R, Inagaki T, et al. Assessment of
2007; 75: 287–293. variations in air-dry wood density using time-of-flight
3. Velho SRK, Brum LFW, Petter CO, et al. Development of near-infrared spectroscopy. Wood Material Science &
structured natural dyes for use into plastics. Dyes Pigm Engineering 2015; 10: 57–68.
2017; 136: 248–254. 21. Mayr G, Hintenaus P, Zeppetzauer F, et al. A fast and
4. Oktav Bulut M and Akar E. Ecological dyeing with some accurate near infrared spectroscopy method for the deter-
plant pulps on woolen yarn and cationized cotton fabric. mination of cellulose content of alkali cellulose applicable
J Clean Prod 2012; 32: 1–9. for process control. J Near Infrared Spectr 2015; 23:
5. Mohammad Shahid S-u-I and Faqeer M. Recent advance- 369–379.
ments in natural dye applications: a review. J Clean Prod 22. Xu F, Zhou L, Zhang K, et al. Rapid determination of
2013; 53: 310–331. both structural polysaccharides and soluble sugars in
Li et al. 9
sorghum biomass using near-infrared spectroscopy. multivariate data analysis. Sensors (Basel) 2013; 13:
BioEnerg Res 2014; 8: 130–136. 8916–8927.
23. Jiang W, Zhou C, Han G, et al. Classification and iden- 29. Pieszczek L, Czarnik-Matusewicz H and Daszykowski
tification of plant fibrous material with different species M. Identification of ground meat species using near-
using near infrared technique—a new way to approach infrared spectroscopy and class modeling techniques -
determining biomass properties accurately within differ- aspects of optimization and validation using a one-class
ent species. Front Plant Sci 2017; 7: 2000. classification model. Meat Sci 2018; 139: 15–24.
24. Zhou C, Han G, Via BK, et al. Rapid identification of 30. Horikawa Y. Assessment of cellulose structural variety
fibers from different waste fabrics using the near-infrared from different origins using near infrared spectroscopy.
spectroscopy technique. Text Res J 2018; 89: 3610–3616. Cellulose 2017; 24: 5313–5325.
25. Zhou C, Han G, Gao S, et al. Rapid determination of 31. Şahin S, Demir C and GüçerŞ. Simultaneous UV–vis
cellulose content in pulp using near infrared modeling spectrophotometric determination of disperse dyes in tex-
technique. BioResources 2018; 13: 6122–6132. tile wastewater by partial least squares and principal com-
26. Jiang W, Via BK, Han G, et al. Near infrared monitoring ponent regression. Dyes Pigm 2007; 73: 368–376.
of untreated and chemically delignified wood. J Near 32. Yang Z, Xiao H, Zhang L, et al. Fast determination of
Infrared Spectr 2014; 21: 485–493. oxides content in cement raw meal using NIR-spectro-
27. Via BK, Zhou C, Acquah G, et al. Near infrared spec- scopy and backward interval PLS with genetic algorithm.
troscopy calibration for wood chemistry: which chemo- Spectro Acta A 2019; 223: 117327.
metric technique is best for prediction and 33. Ju-sun ZXTT-mF. Online control of dyeing rate for
interpretation?. Sensors 2014; 14: 13532–13547. cotton fabric with reactive dyes. Dye Finish 2015; 41: 1–5.
28. Kong W, Zhang C, Liu F, et al. Rice seed cultivar iden-
tification using near-infrared hyperspectral imaging and