Professional Documents
Culture Documents
University of The Philippines Bachelor of Arts in Communication Research
University of The Philippines Bachelor of Arts in Communication Research
A Study on the Online Information Mechanism used by the City Disaster Risk Reduction
Thesis Adviser:
Date of Submission
June 2016
Thesis Classification:
c) To give open access to the above-mentioned work, thus allowing “fair use” of the
work in accordance with the provision of the Intellectual Property Code of the
Philippines (Republic Act No. 8293), especially for teaching, scholarly, and
research purposes.
by
PERSONAL DATA
EDUCATION
For my mother,
Angela Aquino.
I love you.
ABSTRACT
Aquino, R. (2016). In the Know with CDRRMO: A study on the online information
mechanism used by the City Disaster Risk Reduction Office of Cagayan de Oro for flood
Mass Communication.
The study looked into the online information mechanism of CDRRMO during flood
disasters. Communication plays an essential role in bridging the gap between the
scientists and the people. By understanding how its users perceived the warning messages
and the warning signals found in the CDRRMO FB page and how they think they would
respond, the study concluded that information dissemination is indeed a crucial and an
important step in an early warning system. The knowledge and the flood experience, of
users have an influence on their behavior and intention. Results showed that among the
warning messages, they would prefer having an advisory that had an actual photo of the
situation. Regardless of the warning signal raised, users would still seek for more
information from people around them just to confirm. At the end of this paper is a
suggested communication plan that can be used by the CDRRMO for their information
dissemination mechanism, so that in times of disaster protective action can take place.
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page i
Biographical Data iv
Acknowledgments v
Abstract vi
List of Tables x
List of Figures xi
I. INTRODUCTION 1
A. The Philippines 4
B. Warning System 6
C. Warning Communication 7
D. Social Media 12
E. Warning Response 12
F. Synthesis 15
G. Research Gap 16
viii
A. Conceptual Framework 17
B. Operational Framework 19
IV. METHODOLOGY 21
D. Research Instrument 23
E. Data Analysis 23
G. The Researcher 24
A. Summary 44
B. Conclusion 44
BIBLIOGRAPHY 49
ix
APPENDICES 54
LIST OF TABLES
8 Summary of Responses-Consistency 36
9 Summary of Responses-Clarity 37
LIST OF FIGURES
Mindanao has low-lying areas that are prone to flooding. A study done by Tongco on
mitigating flood losses in 2011 revealed that metropolitan CDO is susceptible to floods
from prolonged and heavy rains, which drain into the several independent basins in the
CDO boundary.
always alert and prepared in times of flood disasters. The local government of CDO and
its various concerned stakeholders should be aware of the city’s vulnerability to flooding.
timely, accurate and reliable manner that people will quickly respond to. These days, the
social media, more than the conventional forms like newspapers, connect people in an
online environment using spontaneous, two-way and multiple dialogues (Dufty, 2014).
there is a huge growth in social media usage, which is occurring particularly in South
America and Southeast Asia. This is because of an increasing worldwide access to the
Internet via smartphones, where wealth remains a factor (Pew Research Center, 2014).
disasters. For example, an American Red Cross study (American Red Cross, 2012) found
that eight percent (8%) of all respondents have downloaded a smartphone app that could
help in a disaster or emergency. Twelve percent (12%) of survey respondents have used
weather event (Dufty, 2014). The type of emergency information that they had sought
It is in this context that this study aims to look into how social media sites may
This study wants to find out how users of the Cagayan de Oro (CDO) City
Disaster Risk Reduction Management Office (CDRRMO) Facebook (FB) page uses it as
a. socio-demographic characteristics
FB page
The 10-year Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) was first planned in Kobe,
Hyogo, Japan in January 2005 to help reduce disaster losses in all different sectors. The
HFA outlines five priorities for action and offers guiding principles and practical means
for achieving disaster resilience. Its goal is to substantially reduce disaster losses by 2015
During an international conference in 2015, speaker Cumiskey said that there has
Communication plays an essential role in bridging the gap between scientists and the
people. Information dissemination is a crucial yet important step in a system where the
message plays its purpose. Without the people understanding the message clearly in an
By looking into the perception of the residents in the local flood warning
information system of the CDO local government, this study seeks to contribute to
improving strategies and methods for a more efficient and effective flood
communication.
II. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
This study looks into the role of online media as a channel used for information
disasters and has been studied by scholars in multiple perspectives but this study
This part of the study will look into the early warning system (EWS) but,
messages, risk channels and the use of social media for flood information dissemination.
This portion will also review studies on their influence on the behavior and flood
A. The Philippines
The Philippines is one of the areas on earth most exposed to natural disasters. As
an archipelago with rapid urbanization in most of its coastal areas, it is also exposed to
the consequences of climate change. Between 15 and 25 tropical cyclones or storms enter
the Philippine Area of Responsibility (PAR) in a year and out of these storms, 6 to 9
make landfall (Groupe U.R.D, 2013). The northern part of the archipelago is by far the
most exposed.
Philippines occupies the top spot in the list of countries with the most number of disasters
in 2011. Out of the 302 natural disasters worldwide, 33 happened in the Philippines alone
ranking third and affecting over 11.7 million people as shown in Figure 1.
5
Among the top five reported disasters that affected the population, tropical
cyclones affected 10.3 million people according to the CDRC database in 2011 as shown
in Figure 2 below. The two most devastating that hit the Philippines were Tropical Storm
Sendong (Washi) and Typhoon Pedring (Nesat) particularly in Cagayan de Oro and Iligan
cities. Washi was the 19th tropical cyclone that entered the PAR in 2011. It was a
combined effect of heavy rain in the upstream of the CDO river basin from the evening of
December 16 until the morning of December 17. High tide, steep topography and debris
B. Warning System
An early warning system (EWS) is a tool that helps disseminate meaningful and
warning in the short term but contributes to an increased awareness and preparedness of
the people in the long term (Perrson, 2015). An EWS should have all these four key
respond to the warnings received (Cumiskey, 2015; Perrson, 2015). Failure in one of the
components will mean failure in the entire system; there is then therefore a need to
Studies show a weak communication link between scientists and the general
public, such that ordinary citizens – especially the ones living in vulnerable areas - are
unable to properly utilize available warnings and forecasts from scientists in government
agencies (Perrson, 2015). People do not always respond immediately to early warning
7
signals, instead they find other (more understandable) information in order to “confirm”
C. Warning Communication
several supporting processes that form a chain with outcomes and end up with a feedback
This system, as shown in Figure 3, describes the flow in an EWS which begins
with detecting flood then disseminating flood information and then using the warning
information which will depend on the assessment of the receiver, and the most crucial
part which is formulating feedback from the performance which then goes back to the
While the EWS begins with gathering scientific information through modeling
and prognoses to determine if flood is nearing, communication is also taking place during
organizations. Since these are technical messages, they may only be understood well only
transmission and decoding phases before they are disseminated or else they may cause
believe that individuals who have received risk information will act on it immediately.
But it must be considered that warning response is a social process, meaning that the
receiver will still deliberate the messages. Afterwards, they start assessing the risks,
which are influenced by prior experiences and their immediate environment (Perrson,
2015). It is important to note that the EWS system is not linear, rather, an integrated
system and that there is always a need to look into the several key processes.
2. Risk Message
For effective messages that are to be addressed to the public, three essential things
are the following: source, content and style. Table 2 shows the criterion, which includes
3. Source
Source credibility is crucial to whether people will believe what they hear on
emergency warnings. People have different opinions on whom they consider credible;
4. Content
People are concerned about four things when it comes to warning messages which
are the following: what they are supposed to do, what specific time will the disaster arrive
and what time should they start evacuating, which particular areas of CDO should take
protective action and what possible consequences could happen and how they could
5. Style
10
Statements should be clear. The simpler the words used; the better they will be
understood. It should be specific, accurate, and not ambiguous; something the public
could grasp and imagine that they can actually “do.” The message should be certain with
a clear source of authority and should be consistent throughout the message (Demeritt,
2014).
6. Risk Channels
There are plenty of ways to disseminate information to the public and each one
A case study on the 2014 flood in Bangladesh tried to incorporate the youth as
primary risk communicators since technology has become a vital tool for implementation.
Several channels for information dissemination such as the voice message broadcast
(VMB) were used to transmit forecast information to 300 people including government
officials, NGOs and volunteers. Water levels of flood were collected, translated and
disseminated by trained people and sent to the public via short messaging service (SMS).
Although 70% of the population in Bangladesh had mobile phones, there was still a need
to train the people on better communication. It also looked into the need to adjust
message length, frequency, and the need to increase volunteer groups (Cumiskey, 2015).
they found out that people in Ireland would prefer direct contact in terms of giving
warning on flood preparation; and websites were the least preferred method as shown in
Table 3 below. There is then no “best” form of communication and may even vary
because it better convinces them that they are at risk and they are more likely to take
action. Simply put, repeat the warning several times (Demeritt, 2014).
Another emerging channel is social media, which is defined as ‘all the devices
and platforms that allow users globally to virtually create and share information with
each other’ (Brooks & Gupta, 2013). “Platforms” are the virtual spaces that allow users to
come together, create and share information. “Devices” are the computing technologies
that enable users to access the platform (Brooks & Gupta, 2013, p. 18 as cited by Dufty,
2014). It emerged out of the Web 2.0 revolution that promotes interoperability, sharing,
and multiple-way communication. It first started in MySpace but expanded in 2004 when
FB was discovered (Dufty, 2014). According to eMarketer in 2013, one in four people on
earth has started using some form of social media regularly (eMarketer, 2013). FB was by
far the most popular social media site as of 2013 with over 800 million users worldwide.
Twitter (the fastest growing social media site) was second with over 220 million users
worldwide, then LinkedIn (100 million) and MySpace (80 million) (Dufty, N. 2014).
12
D. Social Media
dissemination. On the other hand, social media can create opportunities for two-way
dialogue and interaction among organizations, the public, and individuals (Bortree &
Seltzer, 2009 as cited in START, 2012). Shown below is a list why the public uses social
E. Warning Response
As shown in Figure 4, when one is exposed to a flood risk, three things could
happen. The first one is awareness. It means that an individual adapts to the information
or knowledge he/she has already known. Second is worry. It is the emotional reaction to
an individual when he/she is exposed to a certain risk, which will increase his/her
initiative, to prepare for the flood, which is the third part or preparedness. (Raaijmakers et
There are four influences to flood risk perception (De Maeyer, et al., 2011), which
are the following: (1) Demographics - Risk appears to favor men over women. Those
who own a house over those who rent perceive higher risk. People with lower educational
attainment show higher level of risk. Age has also shown a positive correlation to
disasters. (2) Location - Those who live in one-story houses located in low-lying areas
are more vulnerable to floods and thus perceive higher risk. Hazard proximity of the
home especially near the coastal areas also increases risk perception. (3) Knowledge - In
a study conducted in Kenya, those who were in high risk areas were more aware of
traditional flood knowledge compared to those in low risk areas. Researchers conclude
14
that this is brought about by previous flood experience (Nyakundi et al., 2010). (4) Prior
experience - Those who have a direct experience of recent floods are more aware of the
hazard and have a higher risk perception (De Maeyer, et al., 2011).
Delaware, and New Jersey, including suburban New York city that included seven
domains to measure awareness and preparedness (Baker et al., 2012). This included the
following:
a. Objective storm and warning knowledge (e.g., knowledge of storm strength, time
flood insurance;
2. Flood Preparedness
individuals to effectively anticipate, respond to, and recover from, the impacts of likely,
costly, societies who continually try to implement projects for prevention, preparedness
and vulnerability reduction towards disaster have greater chances of surviving in the
future, especially at a time when climate change has taken its toll (Perrson, 2015).
F. Synthesis
There are many researches that focus on how organizations manage information
during disasters (START, 2012). It has also evolved into studying various information
dissemination channels including social media. One study concluded that it is because of
community interaction, and support for the public during disasters. These features are not
There are several factors that affect the flood preparedness of the public; one of
these is flood warning perception. This process begins from flood detection up until how
residents respond to warning. In between this flow is the communication process playing
social media has been used for flood warning information dissemination in the
Philippines, there is a need to evaluate and look into this phenomenon and how it may
G. Research Gap
There are many research studies on flood disasters and even on the aspect of
communication but only a few have been done on the use of social media specifically the
use FB for flood communication. These studies on social media and flood disasters are
16
mostly in Asian countries but not much has been done in the Philippines. This research
would like to add to the emerging and growing literature on studies of social media and
A. Conceptual Framework
This study considers action as the result of an individual’s intention and behavior
and Icek Ajzen’s theory formulated in 1975 which states that a person’s behavior is
voluntary and is determined by his/her intention to perform that behavior, believing that
Fishbein and Ajzen believe that two factors affect intention: attitudes and
subjective norms. Attitudes are what a person believes which may be positive or negative
and subjective norms are the social pressures an individual feels to perform or not
perform specific behaviors. However, preceding the action and the influences of attitude
message prior to deciding what action to take and therefore, reasoned action. This model
shows that the content of the messages trigger both the intention and behavior of the
public which is affected by four variables which are the following: (1) background factors
include demographics, prior experience, knowledge - where the use of the online media
comes in; (2) beliefs, attitudes and perception of warning messages - according to the
theory of reasoned action, beliefs come in three types: behavioral beliefs or their beliefs
about the consequences as well as their judgments which may be either positive or
negative, normative beliefs which are subjective norms or beliefs about how individuals,
groups or the society expects them to behave, and control beliefs or how they would
actually behave; while attitude and perception are their judgments towards the given
warning messages.
B. Operational Framework
message, which pertains to the FB page of the CDRRMO particularly, the content and
design of its FB page (i.e., authority and accuracy, purpose and content, currency and
design, organization and ease of use). Moreover, the study looks into how the
characteristics of the users of the CDRRMO FB page affect their intention and behavior.
Specifically: (a) Background factors which are: gender, age, barangay address in CDO,
prior flood experience and media use in getting flood updates. (b) Attitudes, beliefs and
perception of the warning messages found in the CDRRMO FB page through respondents
grammar and style. This then leads to an action or their perceived warning response. The
respondents stated various responses to warning signals found in the CDRRMO FB page
particularly: do nothing, form own assessment of flood risk, seek advice and/or
information, take steps to minimize water entry into property, protect personal property
information and inform the public about an incoming typhoon. It contains the
Attitudes, Beliefs and Perception of Warning Messages – These are the ratings to
according to criteria
signals
21
IV. METHODOLOGY
understand the information mechanism during flood disasters. To describe the content of
the CDRRMO FB and its flood dissemination mechanism, the FB page was analyzed
using content analysis; it made use of a checklist in evaluating websites from the
University of Maryland (i.e., authority and accuracy, purpose and content, currency and
design, organization and ease of use). The researcher then gathered five types of warning
messages found in the CDRRMO FB page which are the following: General Flood
Advisory, City Flood Advisory, Flood Flow Advisory, Typhoon Track Advisory and
Photo Advisory. The respondents then rated each warning message from one (very poor)
to five (very good) using the six categories: factual information, action advice,
consistency, clarity, alerting function, and message construction. Lastly, aside from the
warning message are the three types of warning signals found in the CDRRMO FB page.
The respondents were then asked to give their perceived warning response from the list of
actions (i.e. do nothing, form own assessment of flood risk, seek advice and/or
information, take steps to minimize water entry into property, protect personal property
and help other people; see Appendix C) based on the three warning signals: yellow,
The core variables of this study are the CDRRMO FB page, background factors,
attitudes, beliefs and perception of warning messages and perceived warning response.
22
These variables are directed towards users of the CDRRMO FB page and how they
perceive the warning communication used by the CDRRMO. These are manifested in
Concepts/Variables Measures
Use of FB as an Content and design of • Authority and Accuracy
information the CDRRMO FB page • Purpose and Content
dissemination • Currency and Design
mechanism
• Organization and Ease of use
Characteristics of Background Factors: Gender, Age, Barangay Address in
CDRRMO FB users • Socio-demographic CDO, Prior flood experience and Media
characteristics use in getting flood updates
• Prior flood experience
• Media characteristics
Attitudes, Beliefs and Extent of respondents’
Perception of Warning agreement/disagreement with
Messages • Factual information
• Action advice
• Consistency
• Clarity
• Tone
• Alerting function
• Message construction
Perceived Recommended action corresponding
Warning Response to warning signal:
• Do Nothing,
• Form own assessment of flood risk,
• Seek advice and/or information,
• Take steps to minimize water entry
into property,
• Protect personal property,
• Help others,
23
Purposive Sampling was employed to select respondents. Among the users of the
CDRRMO FB page, which were 2, 077 based on the likes of the page, respondents were
selected. The respondents should be residents of CDO. A total of 120 respondents were
asked to answer the survey (see appendix A). Two males and two females for a total of
four focus interviews were also done among the respondents for an in depth analysis.
D. Research Instrument
The research instruments used in this study are the online survey using
Google docs (http://goo.gl/forms/lUV7LW7PFQ) and the focus interview guide for the
CDRRMO - Cagayan de Oro FB page users (see Appendix B). The purpose of the survey
was to gauge the media usage of the FB users, how they found out about the CDRRMO
CDO FB page and what they think about the warning messages posted through a Likert
scale. This will help obtain the background of each FB user and their perceptions of the
FB page. To further understand the data, selected key informants from FB users of the
CDRRMO - CDO FB page were requested for an interview. The focus interview guide
was used to gain more insight on the questions found on the survey questionnaire.
E. Data Analysis
The researcher used simple descriptive statistics (simple means and percentage
distributions) for the quantitative data analysis. As explained by Fishbein and Ajzen’s
model of reasoned action, a person’s background factors as well as her/his beliefs affect
intention and behavior. In this case, the researcher profiled the users of the CDRRMO FB
page and analyzed their ratings on their perception of the flood warning messages using
scoring equivalents which are as follows: low for those who scored the category 1-2,
24
medium for those who scored 3, and high for those who scored it 4-5. The mean scores
were computed after the ratings were analyzed. Their perceived warning responses were
Data gathering was limited to only one type of online media used by the
only channel of communication being used online. The study is limited only to the
perception of the warning messages posted by the CDRRMO on the FB page and does
not include other activities that the CDRRMO covers. The respondents are also limited
for three reasons. First, respondents were only users living in CDO and not in the nearby
cities. Since the CDO river is the catch basin of floodwater whenever there is a typhoon,
it makes CDO more vulnerable to flood compared to other nearby cities. Second,
informants are varied in terms of age. FB pages are open to the public and anyone of any
age has the liberty to follow. Lastly, informants are not at all representative of certain
G. The Researcher
The researcher is a resident of CDO and has been residing in the area for almost
23 years. During her years of stay, she only witnessed a typhoon that brought huge
devastation to her city once. Realizing that flood disaster management was not much of a
priority, she took the initiative of evaluating efforts of the government of CDO after
Figure 8 shows how the CDRRMO FB page looks like. Like how all FB pages,
the CDRRMO FB page has its own name and logo. Its official name is “Cdrrmo –
CDO.
In order to describe the CDRRMO FB page, the researcher looked into how the
contents of the page reflected the quality and accuracy of websites using the parameters
presented by the University of Maryland in 2014 (see Appendix D). The main points for
evaluating the CDRRMO FB page were the following: Authority and Accuracy, Purpose
26
and Content, Currency or the regularity of updates on the website and lastly, Design,
The author of the site is the head of the CDRRMO of CDO, Mr. Verner
Monsanto. They use FB as their main channel for information dissemination, made use of
the Official Logo of the City and indicated that they are a “Government Organization”.
Hence, the FB page can be said to be high in terms of authority and accuracy.
The FB page serves as the CDRRMO’s official organization website for public
service information. Its purpose is to inform and spread awareness to the residents about
the efforts being done by the local government in preparing for disasters. It provides
balanced, objective and factual information. For example: “Nihunong na ang ulan ug
Talakag ug Libona. NORMAL LEVEL ang mga suba ug tributaries sa CDO karong
orasa.” (Rain has stopped in CDO and skies are slowly clearing up. There is no rain in
Lindaban, Mampayag, Manolo Fortich, Talakag and Libona. The CDO river and its
tributaries have been raised to normal level at this time). It also provides the necessary
contact details in case there is a need to contact the admin of the FB page.
3. Currency
The website was last updated 24 hours ago at the time this part of the thesis was
written. The site is well maintained, as evident by the regular updates. The feedback
mechanism through FB messaging is used regularly. Hence, the FB page can be said to
Since the site is already a page template of FB, then the page is easy to read and
navigate. It is, however, poorly organized in terms of how they post updates. There is no
order of when, how or what they post. For example, if there is no typhoon during that
The CDRRMO page included varied posts but for this study, the focus shall only
There are five types and each one will be presented below.
The General Flood advisory is first issued by the Department of Science and
The City Flood Advisory is issued by the local government after being given
warning and advisory by the DOST and the PAGASA (Figure 10).
28
The local government also issues the Flood flow advisory. It is a photo of the
CDO terrain map to find out which areas are being affected by heavy rains or are already
flooded.
The Photo Advisory is a photo of the actual flood level in the city. This will give
.
31
The Typhoon Track Advisory is also a photo that traces the whereabouts of the
typhoon. The date and time are specifically posted. Color codes are being used in order to
Information on the page also contained perceived warning responses to the three
types of warning signals which are in the CDRRMO FB page namely: yellow, orange and
red. Each type of warning signal was elaborated by the CDRRMO as shown below.
1. Socio-demographic characteristics
Online survey respondents totaled 120, with females (64) slightly outnumbering
males (56). Actual ages ranged from 20 to 55, with mean age being 25 years old.
Most of the respondents were from Barangay Carmen, followed by Balulang and
Macasandig; all three areas were highly damaged during Sendong in 2011.
About 77.5% of respondents said that they use social media to get flood updates,
particularly posts on FB. Some, still tune in to radio announcements for information
while there are also those who rely on text messages for updates. In terms of using the
CDRRMO FB page, almost all of the respondents said that they only check for updates
when there is an incoming flood. There is a notion that people do not always immediately
respond to warning signals and still have to look for sources and confirmation before they
can say that they really are at risk and should be prepared.
Radio Announcement 90 75
Neighbors 34 28.3
Government official
3 2.5
knocking on the door
Floodline 3 2.5
Others 11 9.2
*Multiple responses
which was Typhoon Sendong in December 2011 followed by Typhoon Pablo, which
The respondents were asked to rate each advisory based on five categories, 1
being very poor or the lowest and 5 being very good or the highest. The researcher tallied
the ratings of all the respondents by frequency but classified their ranking accordingly.
Those who ranked the advisory on that category under 1-2 belong to low, those who
ranked it 3 belong to medium and those who ranked it 4-5 belong to high. Afterwards,
Photo Advisory scored highest with a 3.89 mean score, which means that it
provides good and sufficient factual information. For this type of warning message, the
respondents were given a perspective of the current situation through a photograph of the
flood along with the facts, bringing in a sense of truthfulness in seeing the evidence of the
flood level. Overall, the provision of factual information in all CDRRMO advisories is
General Flood
14 44 62 120 3.50
Advisory
City Flood
6 40 74 120 3.69
Advisory
Flood Flow
12 43 65 120 3.55
Advisory
Typhoon
Track 8 32 80 120 3.80
Advisory
Photo
5 30 85 120 3.89
Advisory
Photo Advisory still scored the highest with a mean score of 3.75 meaning that it
provides substantial information on what action to take. After finding out the water levels
and the current situation through the photo, given a set of instructions by the CDRRMO,
they can already gauge what they should do next. Overall, in giving provision on what
Photo Advisory ranked highest with 3.68 as its mean score. Respondents are
neutral on the consistency of the way the warning messages are composed. But since this
advisory has a photo attached to it, users can still tell the consistency between the picture
and the warning message itself. Most users cannot understand the Flood Flow Advisory,
which scored the lowest mean of 3.33 since it contains a terrain of mostly tributaries
around CDO, which makes it difficult to identify where the flood is at the moment.
Overall, with a mean score of 3.49 for consistency in its advisories, CDRRMO did
average work.
The Typhoon Track Advisory scored highest with a mean score of 3.68 in clarity
of information. Just like the consistency of the warning messages, respondents feel
neutral on its clarity. This warning message gives an actual update of the progress of the
typhoon at a certain time. Overall, the CDRRMO has a mean score of 3.5 making it
The alerting function of Typhoon Track Advisory with a mean score of 3.73 is
good. With its provision of the time and an update of the speed of the typhoon, users can
38
actually feel the sense of urgency on the warning message itself. Overall, its alerting
Typhoon Track Advisory scored the highest with a mean score of 3.70 meaning
that it is good with message construction. With a photograph beside a warning message,
it is easier to comprehend and understand. Overall, the CDRRMO has a mean score of
Typhoon 8 39 73 3.70
Track
Advisory
Photo 6 40 74 3.69
Advisory
Both the Photo Advisory and the Typhoon Track yielded good results from
respondents with a mean score of 3.73. What is similar to these advisories is on the way
the warning messages gave the respondents a perspective of the current situation.
Furthermore, the Flood Flow Advisory looks like a map with labels and colors
that really seemed unclear. It is supposed to show where the flood levels are in the area
yet the respondents could not tell exactly where the floodwaters are starting to rise.
The City Flow Advisory, which is similar to a General Flood Advisory, shows
more connection to the respondents, as it was clear in its warning message as well as its
consistency with the facts. It has a strong appeal to the respondents since this warning
Overall, the warning messages produced by the CDRRMO - CDO posted on their
FB page are reliable since they all come from and are verified by the DOST and
PAGASA. Second, they should have a photograph or a visual representation that will
allow its readers to believe and make sense of the situation, which was why the Photo
Advisory scored highest in almost four categories. Third, the warning message should be
constructed formally using direct and simple words such that anybody could understand
When the warning signal yellow is raised, majority or 67.5% respondents report
to form their own assessment about the flood. Since the yellow signal means “READY”,
it is only normal for residents to assess their own situation since flood is possible.
Do nothing 0 0
*Multiple responses
When the orange warning signal is raised half of the respondents would choose to
do three things: seek advice and/or information, take steps to minimize water entry into
property and protect personal property. The orange warning signal is on a “GET SET”
status which means that the rain is very hard and flood is threatening; thus, respondents
41
would perceive doing precautionary measures just in case and possibly even move out to
be sure of safety.
Do nothing 3 2.5
*Multiple responses
When the warning signal red is raised, majority of respondents would protect
personal property (move the car up to a higher place, unplug electric wires, pull up the
furniture). This also means finding ways to stay out of danger and create getaway areas in
case water comes in the house and cause serious flooding. Half of respondents (about
55%) also said that they would take steps to minimize entry of flood into property and
would still seek for advice and/or information given that almost all of these respondents
42
have had prior flood experience. But despite that, half of the respondents or 56.7 %
Do nothing 3 2.5
*Multiple responses
factors such as demographics, location, knowledge and prior experience. Only 2.5% will
do nothing on a red signal, which could be because of their location as a factor as they
might be living in the upper area of CDO. But almost all respondents would definitely do
something at the least, which is to form their own assessment when given a warning
signal. This may be because of prior experience as a factor. When one is exposed to a
43
risk, in this case, Typhoon Sendong in 2011, it somehow increases their initiative to
For all the three warning protocols, about 40-55% of respondents would still seek
for advice and information from other sources even if the warning signal raised was
already red and the warning message already demand for forced evacuation.
VI. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION
A. Summary
This study was conducted in order to look into the role of online media
CDO. It evaluated the users of the CDRRMO – CDO FB page and looked into their
perceptions on the five types of warning messages and the perceived warning
data and was supported by interviews. FB posts are the most widely used medium to
get information on flood disasters and among the advisories posted on the FB page,
the photo advisory and the typhoon track were the most favored. Among the three
warning signals, their perceived warning response at all times is to seek for advice
and/or other information despite the warning given. Prior experience to flood was a
major factor in their response and this must have prompted why they had to verify
information and seek more advice. Overall, the CDRRMO CDO FB page is very
helpful but it must be more aggressive in terms of reaching more people since
respondents find out about it only through referral from those who work there or
B. Conclusion
information, the more you convince them to believe in the warning message. The
CDRRMO must not limit itself to using one medium for information dissemination. A
focus on social media must be given especially in this age of technology and
45
development, where it allows people to communicate and interact with each other more
effectively (Bortree & Seltzer, 2009 as cited in START, 2012). But with the influx of
information, it is quite difficult to fully comprehend which one is true and credible,
reason enough for CDRRMO to make use of efficient media in creating warning
messages and focus on the three categories: source, content and style. To capture
attention, it must come from reliable sources, make use of pictures and be direct to the
point in stating the facts. The most popular social media site is FB in 2013 with over 800
million users worldwide (Dufty, 2014). It remains to be the largest social media site today
2014, it states that Facebook has developed a disaster specific tool called Safety Check
Feature, which allows its users to let others know that they are in a safe place. This is just
one of those innovations and there are plenty more of opportunities that will revolutionize
the way flood disasters will be communicated in the future. FB pages, if used efficiently
and effectively can reach thousands of users and the CDRRMO, as the responsible
governing body for disasters in the city, has the capacity to do so.
VII. IMPLICATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The researcher prepared a communication plan as a result of this study. This will
The goal is to provide a better communication system through FB that will give
residents of CDO an up-to-date, real time and reliable flood updates in the city through
the following objectives: (1) have more residents follow the CDRRMO FB page; (2)
instigate the need for residents of CDO to be aware of the various warning messages and
warning signals posted on their FB page; and (3) enable CDRRMO to produce flood
The residents of CDO generally have this insight or concern whenever there is an
incoming typhoon in the city: “we [residents of CDO] know the urgency whenever there
is rain in the city but we are not that sure of the information that we receive about the
typhoon….”and in order to address this concern, this communication plan shall give the
The key message of this campaign is, “Be in the Know with CDRRMO!”and in
(When it comes to information about flood, you are sure with CDRRMO).
Five activities will be launched for the campaign: (1) media launch - not all
residents of CDO know that there is a special department in the government that handles
disaster risk affairs in the city more so an FB page that they officially use to disseminate
important information about flood in the city. In order to raise awareness and gain more
47
following on their FB page, there will be a media launch that will be held in several areas
in CDO especially in public parks to reach more people and let them know of the services
provided by the CDRRMO. The launch will also partner with schools as well as
barangays; (2) flood risk 101 - back to basics on educating the residents on flood
warnings and signals as well as disaster drills to ensure the right knowledge and actions
for safety in cases of typhoons in the city; (3) inquiry system – there will be a designated
person aside from the admin to check up on the FB page that will answer questions,
feedbacks or queries sent via FB message. This will establish communication ties with
the residents of CDO and ensure that the residents are making use of the information
being posted on the FB page; (4) flood advisory template – since there are about five
types of warning advisories on their FB page, it is most likely to cause confusion among
residents. Thus, in order to be straightforward and precise, there will be a flood advisory
template where all the important details and other information residents need to know are
available that is written down in a concise yet understandable way. There should also be
an official hashtag that residents could click on to get related information during
typhoons such as #CDRRMOinCDO and #BantayBahaCDO. This will also help monitor
those who need help or other related news that happened before, during and after a
typhoon. And lastly (5) live stream - to see is to believe, they say. FB recently launched
their LIVE app button as seen in Figure 17. It means that anywhere, as long as there is
Wi-Fi, people could see you wherever you are and whatever you’re doing in real time.
This will help CDRRMO officers better give live status updates about the typhoon to
But before plans are executed, there should be a SWOT analysis in order to
anticipate the positive and negative points of this campaign. For this campaign, its
strengths are the following: (1) keep the residents aware and in the know of CDRRMO
activities; (2) help residents be alert in cases of typhoons in the city; (3) make the
residents feel secure since there is an actual inquiry system that they can contact in cases
of disasters. Its weaknesses are: (1) there is limited internet access in some areas in CDO;
(2) no assurance that residents will be reminded of the CDRRMO page for flood updates;
(3) online data can be misinterpreted/misused by some users and lastly (4) since there is
only one medium of communication, there is also a limited reach to users. Its
opportunities are the following: (1) possible increase in the number of followers and
potential reach of audience on FB; (2) be given notice to create an official CDRRMO
website designed for disaster risk information for the city; and lastly (3) have potential
partnerships with local NGOs. The only possible threat could be the misuse of
Aaltonen, J., Bonaiuto, M., Bradford, R., De Dominicis, S., Langan, S., O’Sullivan, J. &
http://www.nat-hazards-earth-syst-sci.net/12/2271/2012/nhess-12-2271-2012.pdf
Baker, E., Broad, K., Czajkowski, J., Meyer, R., & Orlove, B. (2012). Risk Perceptions
18_EJB-etal_RiskPerceptions-Sandy.pdf
Bird, D., Ling, M., & Haynes, K. (2012). Flooding Facebook – the Use of Social Media
https://riskfrontiers.com/pdf/flooding_facebook.pdf
Brooks, H. & Gupta, R. (2013). Using Social Media for Global Security. John Wiley &
https://books.google.com.ph/books?id=wVUWPEHUEwkC&pg=PA18&dq=all+t
he+devices+and+platforms+that+allow+users+globally+to+virtually+create+and
+share+information+with+each+other&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjI9MP_s5r
NAhULH5QKHSwyBpMQ6AEIHDAA#v=onepage&q=all%20the%20devices%
50
20and%20platforms%20that%20allow%20users%20globally%20to%20virtually
%20create%20and%20share%20information%20with%20each%20other&f=false
Cumiskey, L. (2015). Case Study: Flood Early Warning Systems. Retrieved from
http://www.un.org/waterforlifedecade/waterandsustainabledevelopment2015/pdf/
Lydia_CumiskeyGDG.pdf.
Chan, J. (n.d.). The Role of Social Media in Crisis Preparedness, response and recovery.
Retrieved from
http://www.oecd.org/governance/risk/The%20role%20of%20Social%20media%2
0in%20crisis%20preparedness,%20response%20and%20recovery.pdf.
Dufty, N. (2014). A Review of the Value of Social Media in Countrywide Disaster Risk
http://www.preventionweb.net/english/hyogo/gar/2015/en/bgdocs/inputs/Dufty,%
202014.%20A%20Review%20Of%20The%20Value%20Of%20Social%20Media
%20In%20Countrywide%20Disaster%20Risk%20Reduction%20Public%20Awar
eness%20Strategies.pdf.
De Maeyer, P., Kellens, W., Neutens, T., Vanneuville, W., & Zaalberg, R. (2011). An
Analysis of the Public Perception of Flood Risk on the Belgian Coast. Risk
DOI:10.1080/17477891.2014.924897.
Emergency Management. (2014). Facebook Debuts Safety Check Feature For Disasters.
Check-Feature-Disasters.html.
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/29
1087/scho0509bqbn-e-e.pdf
Khyn, H. (2008). Situational Crisis Communication Theory: Its Use In A Complex Crisis
http://swfound.org/media/82620/public%20response%20to%20disaster%20warni
ngs%20-%20dennis%20s.%20mileti.pdf
52
Nyakundi, H., Mogere, S., Mwanzo, I. & Yitambe, A. (2010). Community Perceptions
10.1108/DPM-07-2014-0140
content/uploads/2009/08/PDR-2011.pdf
Cagayan de Oro River Basin. Mindanao Journal of Science and Technology, 12,
content/uploads/2014/12/10.-IECT0916.pdf
Orr, P. & Twigger-Ross, C. (2009). Delivering Benefits Through Science. Retrieved from
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/29
1010/scho0909bqyh-e-e.pdf
http://www.start.umd.edu/sites/default/files/files/publications/START_SocialMed
iaUseduringDisasters_LitReview.pdf
53
(GIS). Asian Journal of Business and Governance, 1 (1), 103-113. Retrieved from
http://asianscientificjournals.com/publication/index.php/ajobg/article/view/146
https://www.utwente.nl/cw/theorieenoverzicht/Theory%20clusters/Health%20Co
mmunication/theory_planned_behavior/
http://www.lib.umd.edu/binaries/content/assets/public/usereducation/evaluating-
web-sites-checklist-form.pd
54
APPENDIX A
Interview Guide
3. Whenever there's a typhoon or a possible flood incoming in the city, what would you
do?
10. What do the following signs mean and what would you do if the signal was raised to
that warning?
a. White (normal)
b. Yellow
c. Orange
d. Red
11. How do you think can the CDRRMO FB page improve it communication system?
55
APPENDIX B
Online Survey
HELLO! May I ask you to answer a survey? Don't worry; all your answers will be kept
confidential.
* Required
2. Are you: *
Male
Female
6. Did you have any previous flood experience with the floods listed below? * please
Sendong (2011)
Pablo (2012)
Agaton (2014)
Onyok (2015)
Other:
7. Which of the following do you use to get flood information in the city? *
Posts on Facebook
Radio Announcement
Mobile Patrols
Neighbor
Government Facebook Page
Text Message
Phone call from a Government Official
Loud hailer on the street
Government Official knocking on the door
Floodline
Other:
57
Yes
No
https://www.facebook.com/cdrrmo16513
Yes
No
10. How did you find out about the CDRRMO Facebook page? * please check all
that applies.
Referred
Search engine (Google, Yahoo, etc.)
Related pages on Facebook
Other:
11. How often do you check the CDRRMO Facebook page for flood
information/updates?
Once a month
Twice a month
Once a week
Every other day
Everyday
Only when there is flood incoming
Other:
58
For the next questions, please refer to the samples of warning messages posted by the
Please rate the given warning message based on the categories by putting a check
mark on the column of your choice, with 1 as the lowest and 5 as the highest.
14. Consistency
Mark only one oval.
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
15. Clarity
Mark only one oval.
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
16. Tone
1 2 3 4 5
Very
Poor Very Good
59
1 2 3 4 5
Very
Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very
Poor Very Good
For the next questions, please refer to the samples of warning messages posted by the
CDRRMO on their Facebook page.
Please rate the given warning message based on the categories by putting a check
mark on the column of your choice, with 1 as the lowest and 5 as the highest.
Warning Message #2: City Flood Advisory
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
60
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
21. Consistency
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
22. Clarity
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
23. Tone
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
61
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
Please rate the given warning message based on the categories by putting a check
mark on the column of your choice, with 1 as the lowest and 5 as the highest.
1 2 3 4 5
Very
Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very
Poor Very Good
62
28. Consistency
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
29. Clarity
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
30. Tone
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
For the next questions, please refer to the samples of warning messages posted by the
Please rate the given warning message based on the categories by putting a check
mark on the column of your choice, with 1 as the lowest and 5 as the highest.
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
35. Consistency
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
36. Clarity
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
64
37. Tone
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
For the next questions, please refer to the samples of warning messages posted by the
CDRRMO on their Facebook page.
Please rate the given warning message based on the categories by putting a
check mark on the column of your choice, with 1 as the lowest and 5 as the
highest.
Warning Message #5: Typhoon Track Advisory
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
42. Consistency
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
43. Clarity
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
44. Tone
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
66
1 2 3 4 5
Very Poor Very Good
Do Nothing
Form own assessment of flood risk
Seek advice and/or information
Take steps to minimize water entry into property
Protect personal property
Help other people
48. If the warning message posted by the CDRRMO on their Facebook page had a
warning on YELLOW status, which of the following would you do? *
Check all that apply.
Do Nothing
Form own assessment of flood risk
Seek advice and/or information
Take steps to minimize water entry into property
Protect personal property
Help other people
49. If the warning message posted by the CDRRMO on their Facebook page had a
warning on ORANGE status, which of the following would you do? *
Check all that apply.
Do Nothing
Form own assessment of flood risk
Seek advice and/or information
Take steps to minimize water entry into property
Protect personal property
Help other people
67
50. If the warning message posted by the CDRRMO on their Facebook page had a
warning on RED status, which of the following would you do? *
Check all that apply.
Do Nothing
Form own assessment of flood risk
Seek advice and/or information
Take steps to minimize water entry into property
Protect personal property
Help other people
68
APPENDIX C
APPENDIX D