Energy Management

List of documents and Technical Comments Air-Insulated Medium Voltage Switchgear

Project Name: 33KV switchboard for LRF,Karakhendra

Attachment to our Offer Reference / Revision: -
Document revision: R0 Dtd: 14/05/20

List of documents received

Document number or reference, Drawing Revision index No. of
Item Document name Dated
number and/or date pages
1 Gen Spec 8
2 Tech Spec 7
3 SLD 1

Our offer is in accordance with the intent of the above listed specifications. Where deviation has occurred or clarification is deemed necessary, correspondent comment is made on below table.
Comment to
Msknan's reply
above document Section Clause Page no. Specification requirement  Deviation / Clarification Maknan's reply dtd 18.05..2020 Siemens Reply dtd 21.05.2020
dtd 26.05.2020
- item no.

Tech Spec 2.3 Voltage and Frequency variation Frequency & Voltage variation will be as per IEC. Ok Point closed

Tech Spec 5.5 PT on withdrawable chesis We have considered fixed type line PT. Ok Point closed

Relay Coordination at site shall be in

SIEMEN’s scope We shall configure the relay at site as per
Tech Spec 8.7 Relay setting calculation Relay setting calculation will not be in our scope. based on the parameter given by setting provided by Rungta Mines Ltd. Relay OK
Rungta Mines testing will not not be in Siemens scope.
Karakhendra.

We have not considered recommended spare. Please

Tech Spec 10.1 Commissioning spare/2 years recommended spare check the list of commissioning spare enclosed with Ok Point closed
this offer.

No of man days
Erection,testing,commissioing will not be in our
Erection supervison on chargable basis will be finalize
scope. We can do supervision on man-day basis. Please inform number of man-days to be
Tech Spec 10.2 Commissioning assistance may be during
Please inform number of man-days to be considered. considered for supervision
recommended finlization of
Testing Kits to be arranged by Rungta Mines Ltd.
order

IAC is offered as 31.5KA/1 Sec. Doors will not have

Gen Spec 4.1.2 Internal Arc Classification Ok Point closed
gasket.

General
Painting procedure Painting procedure will be as per Siemens standard. Ok Point closed
Comment

Offered panels shall be as per given specification,

clarification/ deviation listed below and enclosed
No of man days
scope of supply (BOQ/BOM). Loading/ unloading of
Erection supervison on chargable basis will be finalize
General material at site, storage of material at site, HT panel Please inform number of man-days to be
Scope C may be during
Comment erection, testing and commissioning is not considered considered for supervision
recommended finlization of
in our scope. However, if required, we shall depute our
engineer at site for supervision activities on per diem order
rate.

Unrestricted Template: TECO_EN_REV02.xlt

Page 1 of 3
File stored at: C:\Users\Mitali\Desktop\Clarification_21.05.2020
 Energy Management
List of documents and Technical Comments Air-Insulated Medium Voltage Switchgear

Project Name: 33KV switchboard for LRF,Karakhendra

Attachment to our Offer Reference / Revision: -
Document revision: R0 Dtd: 14/05/20

.
Only fully assembled switchboard shall be offered for
inspection of routine tests. We shall submit test
certificates of bought out items and no separate tests
shall be conducted on these equipments at our works.
General
Inspection and Testing C Inspection shall be carried out as per our standard Ok Point closed
Comment
quality assurance plan(attached for your ref). Any type
test is not considered in our scope. However, we shall
submit type test reports for type tests carried out on
similar product. Any stage inspection is not envisaged.
We have not considered any tests at site.

We have not considered power cables, cable glands,

cable supports, cable lugs, termination kits, sealing
material for cable entry, etc in our scope. We shall
General
Power Cable Termination C only provide cable termination facility in offered Ok Point closed
Comment
panels.
Note: Offered panel is suitable for direct cable
termination. So, cable support is not required.

General Trip-circuit supervision is an in-built feature of

Trip-Circuit Supervision Relay C Ok Point closed
Comment numerical relay, hence separate relay is not offered.

Offered panels are type tested with following design:

For 33kV 8BK80: Frame - 2.0 mm, High Voltage Door -
2.0 mm, Low Voltage Door - 2.5 mm, Pressure Relief
Gen Tech Flaps - 1.0 mm, Partitions between compartments -
4.1 Sheet metal thickness C Ok Point closed
Spec 2.0 mm, Shutters - 1.0 mm, Partitions between panels -
2.0 mm, Bottom Plate - 2.0 mm, Rear Side Covers -
2.0 mm, End Covers - 2.0 mm. Structure shall be of
bolted type.

Incomer Cable size-1R-3CX300sq XLPE

(UE) (33KV).
General
Power cable Size C Please confirm power cable size. Out going Trfo feeder-3CX240 sq mm Point closed
Comment
XLPE
Outgoing Capacitor bank-3CX240sq mm
We are considering 1 no cable earthing truck
General
Earthing truck C We have not considered any earthing truck Consider earthing truck & 1 no bus earthing truck without Ok
Comment
annunciation

Don't consider any auxiliary relay for

General We have not considered VAA33 relay for any outgoing transformer
Transformer auxiliary relay VAA33 C Noted ,point closed
Comment feeder. since we will consider the same in
ICOG Panel.

General We have not considered BPT panel. We have

LPT C Consider Line PT for incomer Noted ,point closed
Comment considered fixed type LPT for incomer

Kindly consider voltage

We have not considered voltage
General Voltage protection/neutral displacement protection for protection/neutral
C protection/neutral displacement protection Noted ,point closed
Comment capacitor feeder displacement protection for capacitor
for capacitor feeder. Please confirm
feeder.

General We have considered ammeter/voltmeter

Class of meter C Ok Point closed
Comment with class-1 & MFM with class-0.5

Unrestricted Template: TECO_EN_REV02.xlt

Page 2 of 3
File stored at: C:\Users\Mitali\Desktop\Clarification_21.05.2020
 Energy Management
List of documents and Technical Comments Air-Insulated Medium Voltage Switchgear

Project Name: 33KV switchboard for LRF,Karakhendra

Attachment to our Offer Reference / Revision: -
Document revision: R0 Dtd: 14/05/20

General We have considered TTB for metering CT

TTB C Ok Point closed
Comment only

Offered VCB is not suitable for furnace duty.

It is suitable for M2 duty (10,000 operation)
General
Furnace duty C and 30 nos short circuit operation . Supply & Consider Normal VCB. Point closed
Comment
installation of R-C circuit etc will not be in
our scope.

Surge arrester type (Oblum make)-

General
Surge arrestor details C Please share surge arrestor specification MCOV Noted ,point closed
Comment
:30KV,Rated:36KV,model SPF-SS

Unrestricted Template: TECO_EN_REV02.xlt

Page 3 of 3
File stored at: C:\Users\Mitali\Desktop\Clarification_21.05.2020