Huawei Wi-Fi 6 AP Tolly Test Report (AP7060DN AirEngine 5760-10) PDF

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

#219151

October 2019
Commissioned by
Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.

Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point


Performance Evaluation and Feature Validation

Executive Summary
With the official launch of the Wi-Fi 6 standard, future-proof WLAN infrastructure should be Wi-Fi 6 compatible. Comparing to Wi-Fi 5 WLAN access
points (APs), Wi-Fi 6 APs provide greater bandwidth, higher concurrent users, lower latency and other benefits.
Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd. commissioned Tolly to evaluate the performance, capacity, interoperability and IoT integration of its Wi-Fi 6 access
points (AP7060DN, AirEngine 5760-10, and AirEngine 5760S-10). The Huawei AP7060DN is the first Wi-Fi 6 access point tested by Tolly and is the
fastest access point evaluated by Tolly to date.
Performance tests on the AP7060DN access point showed single-client throughput of 3.5Gbps with a Wi-Fi 6 client, bridging throughput of 3.8Gbps
between two AP7060DN access points on the 5GHz radio, multimedia application support for 400 concurrent Wi-Fi 6 users, user capacity of 1,024
users, as well as a 15% performance improvement for multiple Wi-Fi 5 clients communicating with the new, Wi-Fi 6 AP. Tests also demonstrated
Huawei Wi-Fi 6 APs’ interoperability with all previous generation Wi-Fi clients, IoT application integration, VR acceleration, and auto guided vehicle
(AGV) roaming optimization.

The Bottom Line


Huawei AP7060DN Wi-Fi 6 WLAN Access Point:

1 Delivered 3.5Gbps single client wireless throughput on the 5GHz radio

2 Delivered 3.8Gbps wireless bridging throughput on the 5GHz radio between two AP7060DN access points

3 Provided multimedia application support for 400 concurrent Wi-Fi 6 users

4 Provided 15% multi-client performance improvement over Wi-Fi 5 access point with the same Wi-Fi 5 clients

5 Demonstrated compatibility with 802.11a/b/g, Wi-Fi 4 (802.11n), Wi-Fi 5 (802.11ac) and Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) clients

6 Supported 512 Wi-Fi clients per radio and 1,024 Wi-Fi clients per access point

7 Provided power and data interfaces to mount the IoT (Internet of Things) module besides the AP for IoT application integration

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 1 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

four spatial streams, the Spirent test tool


Test Results - recorded consistent 3.5Gbps wireless Huawei
downstream UDP throughput between the
AP7060DN Huawei AP7060DN and the client. This
Technologies, Co.,
makes the Huawei AP7060DN the fastest Ltd
Single Client access point that Tolly has ever tested.

Wi-Fi 6 WLAN
Throughput Access Points
The Wi-Fi 6 standard boosted the single Performance Tested 

radio performance to multi-gigabit per
second. To evaluate the performance of the
Evaluation July
Huawei Wi-Fi 6 access point, the 2019
AP7060DN, Tolly engineers used one
Spirent MX2 Wi-Fi test module as the single
client to be wirelessly connected to the
Huawei AP7060DN. With 4x4 MIMO and

Huawei AP7060DN Wireless LAN Performance - Single Client


5GHz Radio, 4x4 MIMO, Four Spatial Streams, 160MHz Bandwidth, UDP, Downstream
(as reported by Spirent TestCenter 4.93)

10GbE Link
5GHz Radio
Ethernet Client Wi-Fi 6 Client
Emulated by Spirent TestCenter Emulated by Spirent TestCenter

Wireless Throughput

0 3.6
3.5Gbps

Note: The wired Ethernet client and the AP were not directly connected. One Layer 2 PoE switch was in between.

Source: Tolly, July 2019 Figure 1

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 2 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

unidirectional traffic between the two


AP Bridging laptops.

Throughput The Huawei AP7060DN’s 5GHz radio


demonstrated consistent 3.8Gbps wireless
To evaluate the maximum performance of throughput in the test.
the Huawei AP7060DN, engineers bridged
two AP7060DN access points to test their
5GHz wireless performance.

Two Huawei AP7060 access points used the


5GHz radio as a bridge to pass traffic
between them. As shown in Figure 2, two
laptops were connected to the two AP7060
access points using 10GbE cables.
Engineers used the iPerf tool to pass

Huawei AP7060DN Wireless LAN Performance - Bridging


5GHz Radio, 4x4 MIMO, Four Spatial Streams, 160MHz Bandwidth, UDP, Unidirectional
(as reported by iPerf)

10GbE Link 10GbE Link


5GHz Radio 5GHz Radio

iPerf Server iPerf Client

Wireless Throughput

0 3.8
3.8Gbps

Note: The wired Ethernet client and the AP were not directly connected. One Layer 2 PoE switch was in between.

Source: Tolly, July 2019 Figure 2

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 3 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

than the high end Huawei Wi-Fi 5


User Capacity Multi-User AP7052DN. See Figure 3 for detailed results.
Huawei AP7060DN provides one 2.4GHz
radio and one 5GHz radio. Tolly engineers
Performance The Huawei Wi-Fi 6 AP7060DN is not only
future-proof but also able to provide
verified that the AP7060DN supported Wi-Fi 6 Clients instant improvement over the Wi-Fi 5
1,024 Wi-Fi clients/users on a single AP with access points.
512 Wi-Fi clients/users on each radio. Engineers used the Spirent test tool to
Huawei AP7060DN is the largest user emulate 400 Wi-Fi 6 clients. The Huawei
capacity access point that Tolly has ever AP7060DN provided multiple Mbps
tested. wireless throughput on each client. The
AP7060DN’s performance is able to support
Compatibility with multimedia applications on all 400 Wi-Fi 6
clients.

Previous Generation Wi-Fi 5 Clients


Wi-Fi Wi-Fi 6 clients are not widely available at
this time. However, the Huawei AP7060DN
Tolly engineers used one Windows laptop still demonstrated advantage with current
and configured the NIC (network interface Wi-Fi 5 clients comparing to Wi-Fi 5 APs.
controller) to be 802.11b, 802.11a, 802.11g,
802.11n (Wi-Fi 4) 2.4GHz/5GHz and Tolly engineers used 40 Apple MacBook Pro
802.11ac (Wi-Fi 5). The laptop was able to laptops (Wi-Fi 5, 3x3 MIMO, 3 spatial
connect to Huawei AP7060DN’s Wi-Fi streams) as the clients. The Huawei
network in all modes. AP7060DN delivered 14.4% to 15.6%
higher aggregated wireless throughput

Huawei AP7060DN vs. AP7052DN Multi-user Performance


5GHz Radio, 40 Wi-Fi 5 Clients, Downstream
(as reported by Ixia IxChariot)
+14.4% +15.6%
600
Throughput (Mbps)

450

300

150

0
TCP UDP


 

Note: 40 Apple MacBook Pro laptops (Wi-Fi 5, 3x3 MIMO and 3 spatial streams) were used as the clients.

Source: Tolly, July 2019 Figure 3

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 4 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

card can then provide IoT solutions (e.g.


IoT (Internet of E Ink price tag). See Figure 4 for example.

Things) Integration
The Huawei AP7060DN provides an
interface on its side. The Huawei IoT
module can be mounted beside the AP and
use the interface to provide power and
data connection to any third-party IoT card
inserted into the module. The third party

Huawei AP7060DN Wi-Fi 6 Access Point with the IoT Module

E Ink Price Tag - managed by


AP7060DN the IoT card in the IoT module

IoT Module

Note: The IoT module is mounted beside the Huawei AP7060DN. Third party IoT card (e.g. RFID reader, Zigbee gateway, etc.) can be inserted into the IoT
module to have network data communication and power support from the AP7060DN. An E Ink price tag IoT solution is displayed in the picture.

Source: Tolly, July 2019 Figure 4

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 5 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

APs are typically mounted on a ceiling, so WLAN APs (for bluetooth capable models,
Serial Port Connection accessing with a traditional serial cable can including the AP7060DN) support two
be complicated. Tolly engineers verified modes: bluetooth can be always on, or
via Bluetooth that Huawei wireless access points support automatically turned on after CAPWAP
serial port access with a mobile device’ tunnel fails. See Figure 5.

When the wireless access point bluetooth. In the “CloudCampus APP”
malfunctions and loses communication mobile app, engineers selected a nearby
with the wireless access controller, Huawei WLAN AP, accessed the serial port,
administrators need to access the wireless and executed CLI commands. Huawei
AP’s serial port and troubleshoot. Wireless

Serial Port Connection via Bluetooth

Following screenshots are from the CloudCampus APP


mobile app on an Android phone

Select the AP to connect


(Lab environment
Bluetooth Serial Port Tool
there were many nearby
bluetooth-enabled APs)

Source: Tolly, July 2019 Figure 5

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 6 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

VR Acceleration AGV Roaming Test Environment


The Huawei AP7060DN WLAN access point
is optimized for virtual reality (VR)
applications. Tolly engineers used one Pico
VR headset which was connected to one PC
via Wi-Fi, to play one VR game. Captured AP 1
packets demonstrated that the round trip
latency between the PC and the VR headset
was below 7ms for all packets, even in an AP 2
environment with co-channel interference
and more than 50% channel usage rate.
The VR gaming experience was smooth
without lagging.

AGV Roaming
Optimization
Automated Guided Vehicles need to use
Wi-Fi access to obtain jobs and interact
with the control system. Since AGVs are
always moving, fast and reliable roaming is
critical for the entire system. In the test, one
Quicktron AGV travelled between two
Huawei AP7060DN access points back and
forth. In the 5 minutes’ testing time, the
AGV roamed 29 times. The AGV’s log
reported that the average roaming time
was 18.23 ms for each roaming process.
Meanwhile, the ping test from the
management server to the AGV did not
have frame loss during the entire test.
 Source: Tolly, July 2019 Figure 6

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 7 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

Test Results - IoT (Internet of


AirEngine 5760-10 Things) Integration
Tolly engineers tested Huawei AirEngine The Huawei AirEngine 5760-10 provides a
5760-10 WLAN AP. Detailed results are are USB port on its side. The Huawei IoT
following. Test results also apply to the module can be mounted beside the AP and
AirEngine 5760S-10 model. use the interface to provide power and
data connection to any third-party IoT card
Single Client inserted into the module. The third party
card can then provide IoT solutions (e.g.
E Ink price tag).
Throughput
Tolly engineers used one Spirent MX2 Wi-Fi VR Acceleration
test module as the single client to be
wirelessly connected to the Huawei The Huawei AirEngine 5760-10 WLAN
AirEngine 5760-10. The Spirent test tool access point is optimized for virtual reality
recorded consistent wireless downstream (VR) applications. Tolly engineers used one
UDP throughput between the Huawei Pico VR headset which was connected to
AP7060DN and the client: 5GHz radio one PC via Wi-Fi, to play one VR game.
throughput 984Mbps; 2.4GHz radio Captured packets demonstrated that the
throughput 482Mbps. round trip latency between the PC and the
VR headset was below 7ms for all packets,
even in an environment with co-channel
User Capacity interference and more than 50% channel
usage rate. The VR gaming experience was
Huawei AirEngine 5760-10 WLAN AP
smooth without lagging.
provides one 2.4GHz radio and one 5GHz
radio. Tolly engineers verified that the
AirEngine 5760-10 supported 512 Wi-Fi
clients/users on a single AP with 256 Wi-Fi
clients/users on each radio.

Compatibility with
Previous Generation
Wi-Fi
Tolly engineers used one Windows laptop
and configured the NIC (network interface
controller) to be 802.11b, 802.11a, 802.11g,
802.11n (Wi-Fi 4) 2.4GHz/5GHz and
802.11ac (Wi-Fi 5). The laptop was able to
connect to Huawei AirEngine 5760-10’s Wi-
Fi network in all modes.

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 8 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point


Tolly Verified Features and Performance

AP7060DN
 3.5Gbps Single User Throughput (5GHz Radio)

 3.8Gbps Wireless Bridging Throughput (5GHz Radio)

User Capacity: 512 users per radio;



1,024 users per access point

Compatible to Previous Generation Wi-Fi Standards



802.11b802.11a802.11g802.11n (Wi-Fi 4) 2.4GHz/5GHz and 802.11ac (Wi-Fi 5)

 Support 400 Wi-Fi 6 Clients with Multimedia Applications

 15% Performance Improvement over the Wi-Fi 5 AP in the Multiple Wi-Fi 5 Clients’ Test

 IoT Integration

 AP Serial Port Connection via Bluetooth

VR Acceleration
 Less than 7 ms round trip latency between the PC and the VR headset in an environment with co-channel interference and
more than 50% channel usage

Automated Guided Vehicle (AGV) Roaming Optimization



18.23 ms Average Roaming Time for Each Roaming Process

AirEngine 5760-10 and AirEngine 5760S-10

Single User Throughput: 984Mbps (5GHz Radio)



482Mbps (2.4GHz Radio)

User Capacity: 256 users per radio;



512 users per access point

Compatible to Previous Generation Wi-Fi Standards



802.11b802.11a802.11g802.11n (Wi-Fi 4) 2.4GHz/5GHz and 802.11ac (Wi-Fi 5)

 IoT Integration

VR Acceleration
 Less than 7 ms round trip latency between the PC and the VR headset in an environment with co-channel interference and
more than 50% channel usage

Source: Tolly, July 2019 Table 1

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 9 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

iperf3 -s -p 5004

Test Methodology iperf3 -s -p 5005
Multi-Client Performance (Wi-Fi 5)
Forty Apple MacBook Pro laptops were
AP7060DN The iPerf client laptop ran five iPerf
instances with the following commands:
used as the Wi-Fi 5 clients and stayed at the
same places during the test. Test was run in
One Huawei AC6005 was used for iperf3 -c 192.168.0.22 -i 2 -t 10000 -u -b 1G a shielded room.
management. AP7060DN worked in the -l 1470 -p 5001

iperf3 -c 192.168.0.22 -i 2 -t 10000 -u -b 1G For the TCP test, each client had two pairs
direct forwarding mode. Software version
-l 1470 -p 5002
 of down streams with 80 total pairs. For the
VRP V5.170 V200R010 was used. The
iperf3 -c 192.168.0.22 -i 2 -t 10000 -u -b 1G UDP test, each client had three pairs of
AP7060DN access point was powered by
-l 1470 -p 5003
 down streams with 120 total pairs.
one PoE switch using the 802.3bt standard.
iperf3 -c 192.168.0.22 -i 2 -t 10000 -u -b 1G
-l 1470 -p 5004
 VR Acceleration
Single Client Throughput
iperf3 -c 192.168.0.22 -i 2 -t 10000 -u -b 1G One Pico VR headset was connected to the
One Spirent SPT N4U chassis with two -l 1470 -p 5005 Wi-Fi service hosted by the Huawei WLAN
modules were used as the test tool. The
access point. The WLAN AP was in the local
10GbE Ethernet module acted as the wired Test was run in a shielded room to avoid
forwarding mode. To create co-channel
side server and the MX2 802.11AX 2.4GHz/ interference from other sources. The two
interference, engineers used another PC
5GHz module acted as the wireless client. AP7060DN access points were bridged
and another WLAN access point which
The wireless client was connected to the using the 5GHz radio. They were less than 1
operated on the same channel as the AP
Huawei AP7060DN’s 5GHz radio with 4x4 meter away from each other.
under test and ran background traffic.
MIMO, 4 spatial streams and 160MHz
bandwidth. Then engineers used the User Capacity
Spirent TestCenter to create unidirectional
Tolly engineers used the LANforge WiFIRE
AirEngine 5760-10
traffic from the wired server through the
test tool developed by Candela One AC6605 WLAN access controller was
10GbE switch and the AP7060DN to the
Technologies to emulate 1,024 Wi-Fi clients. used for management, one Huawei
wireless client. UDP traffic with 1500-byte
Half of the clients were connected to the AirEngine 5760-10 WLAN access point was
frame size was used. Spirent TestCenter
2.4GHz radio of the Huawei AP7060DN under test in the local forwarding mode
recorded consistent 3.5Gbps throughput.
while the other half were connected to the with the VRP V5.170 V200R019 software
Since all wired connections were 10GbE
5GHz radio. All 1,024 Wi-Fi clients stayed version.
connections without any other traffic, the
connected to the AP7060DN.
downstream wireless throughput between
The 5GHz single client/user throughput test
the AP7060DN and the wireless client
(Spirent MX2 module) was 3.5Gbps.
Multi-Client Performance (Wi-Fi 6) used 2x2 MIMO and 80MHz bandwidth;
the 2.4GHz single client/user throughput
Tw o S p i r e n t M X 2 8 0 2 . 1 1 A X 4 -
Test was run in a shielded room to avoid test used 2x2 MIMO and 40MHz
Ports\MX2-11AX-2 modules were used on
interference from other sources. The bandwidth.
Spirent SPT N4U Chassis with eight total
wireless client was less than 1 meter away ports (four 5GHz ports and four 2.4GHz Other tests used similar methodology as
from the AP7060DN. ports). Each 5GHz port emulated 60 4x4 AP7060DN’s tests.

MIMO clients with four antennas and
AP Bridging Throughput 80MHz bandwidth. Each 2.4GHz port
The iPerf server laptop ran five iPerf emulated 40 4x4 MIMO clients with four
instances with the following commands: antennas and 40MHz bandwidth. Total 400
iperf3 -s -p 5001
 clients (240 5GHz ones and 160 2.4GHz
iperf3 -s -p 5002
 ones) were emulated. All clients were
iperf3 -s -p 5003
 connected to the Huawei AP7060DN with
Wi-Fi.

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 10 of 11


Huawei Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) WLAN Access Point #219151

About Tolly Test Equipment Summary


The Tolly Group companies have been
delivering world-class ICT services for Vendor Product Web
over 30 years. Tolly is a leading global
provider of third-party validation 

SPT N4U Chassis
services for vendors of ICT products, 

Spirent MX2 802.11AX 2.4GHz/5GHz Module
components and services. 

TestCenter 4.93 https://www.spirent.com
You can reach the company by E-mail
at sales@tolly.com, or by telephone at
+1 561.391.5610.
Ixia IxChariot
Visit Tolly on the Internet at:
https://www.ixiacom.com
http://www.tolly.com

Terms of Usage
This document is provided, free-of-charge, to help you understand whether a given product, technology or service merits additional
investigation for your particular needs. Any decision to purchase a product must be based on your own assessment of suitability
based on your needs. The document should never be used as a substitute for advice from a qualified IT or business professional. This
evaluation was focused on illustrating specific features and/or performance of the product(s) and was conducted under controlled,
laboratory conditions. Certain tests may have been tailored to reflect performance under ideal conditions; performance may vary
under real-world conditions. Users should run tests based on their own real-world scenarios to validate performance for their own
networks.
Reasonable efforts were made to ensure the accuracy of the data contained herein but errors and/or oversights can occur. The test/
audit documented herein may also rely on various test tools the accuracy of which is beyond our control. Furthermore, the
document relies on certain representations by the sponsor that are beyond our control to verify. Among these is that the software/
hardware tested is production or production track and is, or will be, available in equivalent or better form to commercial customers.
Accordingly, this document is provided "as is", and Tolly Enterprises, LLC (Tolly) gives no warranty, representation or undertaking,
whether express or implied, and accepts no legal responsibility, whether direct or indirect, for the accuracy, completeness, usefulness
or suitability of any information contained herein. By reviewing this document, you agree that your use of any information
contained herein is at your own risk, and you accept all risks and responsibility for losses, damages, costs and other consequences
resulting directly or indirectly from any information or material available on it. Tolly is not responsible for, and you agree to hold Tolly
and its related affiliates harmless from any loss, harm, injury or damage resulting from or arising out of your use of or reliance on any
of the information provided herein.
Tolly makes no claim as to whether any product or company described herein is suitable for investment. You should obtain your
own independent professional advice, whether legal, accounting or otherwise, before proceeding with any investment or project
related to any information, products or companies described herein. When foreign translations exist, the English document is
considered authoritative. To assure accuracy, only use documents downloaded directly from Tolly.com. No part of any document
may be reproduced, in whole or in part, without the specific written permission of Tolly. All trademarks used in the document are
owned by their respective owners. You agree not to use any trademark in or as the whole or part of your own trademarks in
connection with any activities, products or services which are not ours, or in a manner which may be confusing, misleading or
deceptive or in a manner that disparages us or our information, projects or developments.

219151 ivcofs29 yx-20191011—VerR

© 2019 Tolly Enterprises, LLC Tolly.com Page 11 of 11

You might also like