Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IJMBRARTICLE
IJMBRARTICLE
IJMBRARTICLE
net/publication/327106720
CITATION READS
1 1,717
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Female factor infertility: Laparoscopic evaluation at a public health facility in Ilorin, Nigeria. View project
Impact of home based follow-up care on clinical outcomes and quality of life of hypertensive patients in Nigeria View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Kabir Adekunle Durowade on 19 August 2018.
ABSTRACT
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the creative commons Attribution 4.0 licence
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0) which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the
original work is properly cited.
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
152
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
The following categories of people were were doctors (47.8%) while nurses constitute
excluded from the study; those who were not 23.4% of the participants. The other socio-
members of staff, patients, students, demographic characteristics are as shown on
administrative staff and other support staff. A table 1.
total of 184 study subjects were recruited for the
study. Selection of subjects for the study was by Table 2 describes the general knowledge of the
consecutive selection of consenting individuals. respondents about routine medical check-up. All
Ethical approval was obtained from the Ethics (100%) the participants knew about routine
and Research Committee of the institution. medical check-up and their source of knowledge
being the respective academic/professional
Evaluation of study subjects training they received while 51.1% believe that it
A structured questionnaire was designed for the should be done every 6months, 46.2% were of
study which was used to collect the the opinion that it should be done yearly.
demographic data and the responses of the Majority were of the opinion that blood pressure
participants on the subject matter. The subjects check, blood glucose check, urinalysis and lipid
were initially interviewed to ensure that they profile tests should be part of routine medical
fulfill the set inclusion criteria for the study. The check-up. Half (50%) of the respondents believe
nature and scope of the research was explained that medical check-up should be funded by the
to the subjects and a written informed consent employer, 31.0% feels it should be by the
was obtained before they were recruited. All the individual while 19.0% believe it should by
participants understood English and there was health insurance.
no need for translation.
When asked about the benefits of routine
Informed consent medical check-up, the respondents gave
Informed consent was obtained from all the multiple perceived benefits: 78.8% believe that it
study participants and Ethical Approval was can help to detect undiagnosed diseases, 66.3%
obtained from the Ethics and Research believe that it can detect risk factors for
Committee of the institution. diseases, 56.5% believe that it promotes
longevity while 60.9% believe that it can prevent
Statistical analysis untimely or sudden death.
The data obtained was analyzed using the
Statistical Package for the Social Sciences The attitude of the respondents towards routine
(SPSS) version 21.0 computer software medical check-up was also determined in this
package (SPSS Chicago Inc. IL U.S.A). study. A total of 92.4% (170 out of 184) of the
Descriptive statistics used included frequency respondents had gone for a routine medical
tables, means and standard deviations. The check-up, 81.2% of whom had it done because
statistical significance of the findings was they believe it is important for their health while
determined using appropriate statistical tests. 35.9% had a medical check-up done for pre-
2
The non-parametric test, chi-square (χ ) test, employment purpose, 8.2% had it done for travel
was employed for the analysis of qualitative purpose, 19.0% had it pre-marital reasons and
variables. A p-value of less than 0.05 was 1.6% had it done based on the advice of a
considered as statistically significant. health worker. The remaining 14 (7.6%)
respondents who had never had a medical
RESULTS check-up done gave various reasons which
included; “I consider myself healthy” (64.3%), “I
A total of 184 respondents participated in the just never thought about it” (50.0%), “I don’t
study; 101 (54.9%) males and 83 (45.1%) have enough money” (28.6%), and “I just don’t
females. The age range of the participants was have time for it” (21.4%).
22–63years with a mean (±SD) of 35.73±7.718.
Majority (74.5%) of the respondents attained Table 3 depicts the perception and attitude of
tertiary level of education, 22.8% had the respondents towards compulsory pre-
postgraduate education while only 2.7% had just employment medical screening. 83.2% (153 out
secondary education. Most of the respondents of 184) of the respondents believe that pre-
153
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
employment medical screening should be the respondents had been screened for. 89.1%
compulsory while the remaining 16.8% (31 (164) had been screened for HIV, 81.5% (150)
respondents) do not believe it should be for Hepatitis B virus and only 42.4% (78) for
compulsory and their reasons are as shown in Hepatitis C virus infections.
table 3. There was a statistically significant
relationship between the level of education (p < DISCUSSION
0.001) and the designation (p= 0.006) of the
respondents and their attitude towards All the respondents in this study were aware of
compulsory pre-employment medical screening the importance of routine medical check-up and
as shown in Table 4. There was no such its potential benefits. This can largely be
significant relationship in the age, sex, religion or attributed to the fact that majority of the
tribe of the respondents (table 4). respondents were educated, having up to
tertiary level of education and beyond. Another
Table 5 depicts the practice of routine medical reason is because this study was conducted
check-up by the respondents. 33.7% of the among health workers in a tertiary health
respondents undergo routine medical check-up institution and these are people who are at the
every 6months and 34.8% every year. For forefront of medical care and are very
dental check-up, 22.8% undergo it every knowledgeable about the importance of
6months while 20.6% undergo it every year. The preventive medicine which is what routine
frequency of blood pressure and blood glucose medical check-up is all about, to identify the risk
checks is as shown on table 5. factors of diseases early before they manifest or
cause complications. Routine medical check-up
The experience of the respondents during helps to detect undiagnosed diseases, promotes
routine medical check-up is shown on Table 6. longevity and prevents sudden or untimely
More than three-quarters (78.2%) of the death.
respondents who had had a routine medical
check-up done had it done in a tertiary hospital The respondents being health care workers who
while only 9.4% had theirs done in a primary are knowledgeable could explain why majority of
health centre. Majority (88.8%) of the them had a medical check-up done before in the
respondents funded their medical check-up bill past (92.4%) for various reasons. Majority of
by themselves while 16.5% had theirs funded by them had the check-up done based on their
their employers and so they didn’t have to pay personal belief that it is important for their health
for the tests. The range of the estimated (81.2%) as against the other major reason which
expense of the medical check-up was N0 – was that of pre-employment purpose (35.9%).
N30,000 with a mean±SD of This means that pre-employment medical
N5,233.00±5,725.00. screening rate is low among the respondents,
which may be due to the fact that the health
The various tests done during the check-up are institution in which they are working did not
as shown on table 6. Blood pressure check, make it compulsory or the institution does not
fasting plasma glucose and urinalysis were the have in place an effective pre-employment
most common tests done during the medical medical screening programme for her staff.
check-ups with a frequency of 65.3%, 51.8% Even though majority of the respondents
and 40.0% respectively. All the 170 (100%) (83.2%) believe that pre-employment medical
respondents who had had a medical check-up screening should be compulsory for various
done found the obtained results beneficial; 58 good reasons, only some of the respondents
(34.1%) of whom were referred to see a actually had their medical check-up done for
specialist based on the results of their tests pre-employment purpose (35.9%). The fear of
while the remaining 112 (65.9%) did not require stigmatization or job loss if found unfit were
any specialist consultation. Forty (69.0%) of some of the reasons given by the respondents
those referred to see a specialist were very who oppose compulsory pre-employment
regular with their clinic appointments, 14 medical screening.
(24.1%) were fairly regular while 4 (6.9%) were
not regular. Figure 1 depicts the major infections
154
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
155
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
156
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
Figure 1: Bar chart showing the major infections the respondents had been screened for
(N = 184)
157
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
Yes No
2
n = 153 n = 31 ᵪ p
Age group (in years)
Less than 30 29 (78.4) 8 (21.6) 3.356 0.500
30 – 34 44 (81.5) 10 (18.5)
35 – 39 26 (89.7) 3 (10.3)
40 – 44 31 (79.5) 8 (20.5)
45 and above 23 (92.0) 2 (8.0)
Sex
Male 85 (84.2) 16 (15.8) 0.162 0.687
Female 68 (81.9) 15 (18/.1)
Marital Status
Single 41 (74.5) 14 (25.5) 4.203 0.122
Married 107 (87.0) 16 (13.0)
Divorced/ Separated 5 (83.3) 1 (16.7)
Level of Education
Secondary 1 (20.0) 4 (80.0) 18.805 <0.001
Tertiary 112 (81.8) 25 (18.2)
Post - graduate 40 (95.2) 2 (4.8)
Religion
Christianity 142 (83.0) 29 (17.0) 0.021 0.884
Islam 11 (84.6) 2 (15.4)
Tribe
Yoruba 132 (83.0) 27 (17.0) 3.947 0.267
Hausa 2 (50.0) 2 (50.0)
Igbo 10 (90.9) 1 (9.1)
Other 9 (90.0) 1 (10.0)
Designation
Consultant 22 (95.7) 1 (4.3) 26.188 0.006
Resident 37 (94.9) 2 (5.1)
Medical Officer 20 (76.9) 6 (23.1)
Pharmacist 9 (90.0) 1 (10.0)
MLS 6 (75.30) 2 (25.0)
Physiotherapist 3 (75.0) 1 (25.0)
Radiographer 4 (80.0) 1 (20.0)
Nurse 36 (83.7) 7 (16.3)
Comm. Health Ext. Worker (CHEW) 8 (80.0) 2 (20.0)
Medical Record Officer 5(71.4) 2(28.6)
Health Attendant 1 (20.0) 4 (80.0)
Other 2 (50.0) 2 (50.0)
158
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
159
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
160
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
[1]
Akande et al. in a study in 2004 at the the tests done regularly as required. This could
University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital, Ilorin, be due to the cost implication of some of the
Nigeria on 274 hospital workers on the practice tests which would make the respondents to
of periodic medical examination, reported that perform only those they can afford and if found
82.8% of them had had a medical examination to be normal they may not wish to repeat the
done since being employed in the hospital. tests regularly as required. Another reason could
20.6% of them had the medical examination be due to lack of a standard protocol of the tests
done for pre-employment purpose and only expected to be done during a routine medical
14.1% of them had a pre-employment medical check-up at the institution where the check-up
examination done before assumption of duty. was done.
This pre-employment screening rate obtained
12years ago is much lower than what was In this study majority of the respondents had
obtained in this study. their check-up done in a tertiary hospital and it
was funded mostly through out of pocket
[15]
In another study by Opeodu et al. in 2014 at payment since the average estimated cost from
the University College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria this study was N5,233 which is relatively not too
on 110 members of staff in the dental clinic on expensive.
the practice of comprehensive medical check-
up. 58.1% of the respondents had their medical It is interesting to note from this study that
check-up done as part of a mandatory pre- majority of the respondents had been screened
employment requirement while 27.6% had it in the past for HIV infection much more than
done as a result of personal concern for their Hepatitis B virus infection and to a much lesser
health. extent Hepatitis C virus infection. This is a
reflection of the level of awareness of the
In this study, the respondents with a higher level respondents, a sub-set of the larger society,
of education and designation were strongly in about these viruses. The awareness campaign
support of compulsory pre-employment medical in Nigeria for HIV infection is much more than for
screening and this was found to be statistically the other viruses, despite the fact that the
significant. Consultants are the highest in rank Hepatitis B virus is far much more prevalent in
among health care workers, they have Nigeria than HIV and it is also much more highly
postgraduate qualifications that make them the infectious and causes more morbidity and
most knowledgeable and experienced health mortality than HIV. It is also vaccine preventable
personnel and this explains the reason why they and HIV is not.
value the importance of compulsory pre-
employment medical screening more than the In this study, all the respondents who had had a
other health workers. medical check-up done found the obtained
results beneficial and some of them were
The respondents have a good knowledge of the consequently referred to a specialist based on
various important tests that should be done the findings. This further confirms the
during a routine medical check-up which importance of a routine medical check-up in
includes blood pressure check, blood glucose diagnosing disease conditions for which
check, lipid profile, urinalysis, individuals may not yet be symptomatic thereby
electrocardiography, chest radiograph, serology preventing or reducing the morbidity and
(HBsAg, Anti-HCV and HIV), electrolytes, urea mortality that could have resulted.
and creatinine, prostate specific antigen (for
males), mammography and pap smear (for CONCLUSIONS AND
females). These tests are expected to be done RECOMMENDATIONS
every 6months to 1year. Eye examination and
dental check-up are believed to be part of Early identification of abnormalities in
routine medical check-up. However, only some asymptomatic individuals through routine
of these tests were done by the respondents at medical check-up will aid prompt intervention if
the time of their check-up and only some had need be, thus preventing or reducing attendant
161
Oguntoye et al.: Routine medical check-up by health workers
complications that could have ensued. This 6. Wolinsky F.D. and Arnold C.L. A different perspective on
health and health service utilization. Annual Review of
would reduce the overall morbidity and mortality Gerontology and Geriatrics 1988;8:87-101.
associated with different disease entities and 7. Wolinsky F.D. and Johnson R.J. The use of health
improvement in the health related quality of life services by older adults. Journal of Gerontology: Social
and the overall well-being of individuals. Routine Sciences 1991;46:S345-S357.
8. Rosenstock I.M. Why people use health service. Milbank
medical check-up is a useful avenue for
Memorial Fund. The Milbank Quarterly 2005;8:1–32.
assessing the baseline health indices of 9. Waldron I. Sex differences in illness incidence, prognosis
individuals. It is extremely beneficial and should and mortality: issues and evidence. Soc Sci Med
be encouraged. 1983;17:1107–1123.
10. Cleary P.D, Mechanic D and Greenley J.R. Sex
differences in medical care utilization: an
Awareness about the importance of routine empirical investigation. Journal of Health and Social
medical check-up amongst health workers is Behavior 1982;23:106-119.
remarkably high but it may not be so in the 11. Bertakis K.D, Azari R, Helms L.J and Robbins J.A.
Gender differences in the utilization of health care services.
general population, therefore there is a need for Journal of Family Practice 2000;49:147-152.
a community based study and public 12. Béland F. Utilization of health services as events: an
enlightenment on this topic. Pre-employment exploratory study. Health Serv Res 1988;23:295-310.
medical screening should be made compulsory 13. Alakija W. Some factors affecting utilization of health
services provided for the students of the University of Benin,
for all employees by their employers without
Nigeria. Family Practice 1988;5:36-39.
constituting a financial burden on them by 14. Nabalamba A and Millar W.J. Going to the Doctor.
ensuring that they are all enrolled under the Health Reports 2007;18:23-35.
national health insurance scheme. 15. Opeodu O.I and Gbadebo S.O. Medical services
utilization: experience of members of staff in a tertiary Dental
Clinic. International Journal of Sciences: Basic and Applied
Facilities for a routine medical check-up should Research 2014;13:68-78.
also be made available at secondary and
possibly primary health facilities and individuals
who have established abnormal results should
be referred to the appropriate specialist for
further evaluation and care. Finally, there is also
a need to further enhance public awareness doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.14194/ijmbr.6.3.5
about the Hepatitis B virus which is vaccine
How to cite this article: Oguntoye O.O, Yusuf M,
preventable and highly prevalent in Nigeria.
Durowade K.A. Perception and practice of routine
medical check-up by health workers at a tertiary
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT health facility in South-West Nigeria. Int J Med
Biomed Res 2017;6(3):151-162.
Special thanks to the House Officers and Residents of
Internal Medicine Department for their support towards Conflict of Interest: None declared
making this research a success.
REFERENCES
162
Submit your next manuscript to any of
our journals that is the best fit for your
research