Sl.

Designer’s AE's
A.E's Comments (31/07/2020) Status
No. Response(-) Acknowledgement

Comments on Miscellaneous Drawings.

 Retaining wall (For height – 4.5m,

G)
5.0m, 5.5m, 6.0m, 8.0m)-
Noted & corrected Okay
1. Please mention proper drawing no. and in revised
date in title block. drawings.

Noted, note of safe SBC mentioned in

2. Safe bearing capacity is not mentioned
bearing capacity drawing is 10 t/m2,
in drawing. Please add a note for SBC in considered in whereas 12t/m2 has
drawing. design is added. been considered in
design note (For 8m
height). Please Check.

3. Dimension detail is wrongly mentioned Noted & corrected. Not incorporated.

in “DIMENSION DETAIL” table. (For 6m Please check.
& 5m height retaining wall only)
Noted, detail X is Okay
4. “Detail X” is not shown in drawing. added in drawing.

5. Thickness of retaining wall at top is not Noted & Okay

mention. mentioned in
revised drawings.

6. Provide Ld length for bar mark 1 beyond Noted & corrected Still Ld missing in
theoretical curtailment point. in revised drawings reinforcement drawing.
whereas required. Please check.

7. Crash barrier height should be as per Noted & corrected Okay

IRC:5-2015. in revised
drawings.
Factor of safety Okay
8. Factor of safety against sliding is less
against sliding is
than 1.25. Please check. 1.25 for seismic
case and 1.5 for
normal condition,
as per IRC-6-2017
clause 219.5.4
retaining wall need
not to be check for
seismic condition.
Check and found Maximum base
9. Maximum base pressure is more than
maximum base pressure for 8m height
safe bearing capacity. Please check. pressure is less retaining wall is still
than gross base more than 10 T/m2.
pressure, please Please check.
specify for which
height structure fail
in base pressure.
Sl. Designer’s AE's
A.E's Comments (31/07/2020) Status
No. Response(-) Acknowledgement

Comments on Miscellaneous Drawings.

1. Dynamic increment due to backfill & due 1. As per IRC-6-2017 Okay

to surcharge should be considered in Clause -219.5.4,
Dynamic
design.
increment need to
consider for
bridge, but need
not to be consider
other component
like wing wall &
retaining wall.

2. Please submit geotech report. Geotech report for

all MNB is already Okay. Please forward
submitted on dated the mail to us.
10 june 2020 to mr.
somenath Ghosh,

3. Cantilever retaining wall has been Scheme finalize as

proposed for 8m height, whereas discussed with Okay
Counterfort retaining wall will be contractor.
economical.

4. Crash Barrier

5. Please provide crash barrier height as Noted & corrected

in revised Okay
per IRC-5 2015.
drawings.
Cantilever Return Wall

a. Please mention soil properties in design Noted &

mentioned in Okay
note which is to be considered for
revised design
calculation of earth pressure.
report.
Noted, drawing is Okay drawing will be
b. Dimension drawing of cantilever return provided in finalized after getting
wall is missing. Please provide. variants it was compliance of widening
missed along with culverts.
revised drawings.