118041-CT-RHA TANCA DEWANA-JURNAL-compressed PDF

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Head and Skull Base Features of

Nine Egyptian Mummies: Evaluation


with High-Resolution CT and
Reformation Techniques
Heidi Hoffman 1 OBJECTIVE. CT is an indispensable imaging tool in the evaluation of Egyptian mummies
Patricia A. Hudgins because it can noninvasively generate large amounts of data. We applied current CT imaging and
postprocessing techniques to methodically survey the head and skull base features of nine Egyp-
tian mummies in the hope of providing paleopathologic and radiologic information.
MATERIALS AND METHODS. Nine Egyptian mummies were evaluated on helical
CT using 1-mm axial scans obtained from the skull vertex to the mid cervical spine. System-
atic evaluation of the skull and intracranial contents, paranasal sinuses, craniocervical junc-
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

tion, orbits, temporal bones including the middle and inner ears, teeth, and superficial soft
tissues was undertaken. Reformatted and volume-rendered images were generated.
RESULTS. CT findings indicated that the intracranial contents of the nine mummies var-
ied tremendously. Destruction of the anterior skull base structures in mummies without in-
tracranial contents suggested a transnasal, transethmoidal approach to excerebration. A large
amount of expensive embalming material within the skull of one mummy suggests that he
may have been a royal pharaoh. A cleft palate deformity was identified in a child mummy.
Temporal bone analysis revealed one case of asymmetric mastoid air cell erosion and dehis-
cence, which is strongly suggestive of prior mastoiditis. Craniocervical junction abnormali-
ties and ossicular chain disruption in several mummies were attributed to postmortem
damage. The orbital structures had intentionally been removed in several mummies. Dental
disease was ubiquitous among the adult specimens.
CONCLUSION. The systematic evaluation of the head and skull base of mummies with CT
can provide insight into the life, disease, death, and postmortem treatment of these ancient Egyptians.

E gyptian mummies are “biologic


museums” [1] that contain a
wealth of information about the
life and death of an ancient population. Al-
tion of CT data so that images can be
generated in multiple planes and in three-di-
mensional formats, further expanding the
abilities and uses of CT. Our goal was to per-
though the cranium and its contents were ac- form a comprehensive, systematic review of
corded no specific value by the ancient multiple components of the face, head, and
Egyptians, the heads of mummies have been a skull base of nine Egyptian mummies using
source of fascination and scientific interest for thin-collimation CT imaging and advanced
many previous investigators. Radiologists, oto- reconstruction techniques.
laryngologists, surgeons, and orthodontists We reviewed the integrity and appearance
have published focused studies about various of the skull and intracranial contents, cranio-
features of the skull base, sinuses, nasal cavi- cervical junction, skull base, paranasal sinuses,
Received November 7, 2001; accepted after revision ties, temporal bones, and dentition of ancient temporal bones, middle and inner ears, orbits,
December 20, 2001. mummies based on radiologic and endoscopic dentition, and superficial soft tissues. To our
Presented at the annual meeting of the American Society evaluations [2–8]. knowledge, a broad yet systematic evaluation
of Neuroradiology, Boston, April 2001. CT has become the primary means of of these structures in a collection of mummies
1
Both authors: Department of Radiology, Emory University studying these embalmed individuals because this size has not heretofore been published in
Hospital, 1364 Clifton Rd., N.E., Atlanta, GA 30322. Address of its ability to noninvasively, thus nonde- the radiology literature. In this investigation,
correspondence to P. A. Hudgins.
structively, reveal both internal and superfi- we hoped to show that advanced CT can pro-
AJR 2002;178:1367–1376
cial structures while providing excellent vide substantial information about the anat-
0361–803X/02/1786–1367 spatial and contrast resolution. Current post- omy, pathology, and postmortem treatment of
© American Roentgen Ray Society processing algorithms enable the manipula- these ancient Egyptians.

AJR:178, June 2002 1367


Hoffman and Hudgins

Each set of images was systematically evaluated in


the axial, coronal, and sagittal planes for integrity of
the skull and skull base (anterior, central, and poste-
rior); the presence or absence of intracranial contents;
the morphology of the paranasal sinuses; and the ap-
pearance and condition of the craniocervical junction,
dentition, orbits, temporal bones, middle and inner
ears, and soft tissues of the face. Detailed multiplanar
and two- and three-dimensional volume-rendered im-
ages of the head and face were methodically gener-
ated on-site at a workstation (Advantage Windows
[version 3.1]; General Electric Medical Systems).

Results
The Skull, Skull Base, and Sinuses
The calvarium was intact in eight of the nine
mummies in the collection. In one of the child
mummies (mummy 5), a complex, sagittally
oriented, partially depressed fracture of the left
parietal skull with resultant diastasis of the
lambdoid sutures was revealed. We could not
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

determine whether this fracture occurred before


A B or after death, but no evidence of callous forma-
tion to suggest bone healing was found.
Fig. 1.—Male mummy from 21st Dy- Because the brain held no particular value to
nasty who was older than 18 years at the Egyptians and was a potential source of pu-
death. Defects of ethmoidal sinuses
are depicted in multiplanar and three- trefaction after death, the brain was traditionally
dimensional formats. removed from a corpse before embalming and
A, Coronal reformation from CT scan burial [9–12]. Historical accounts by Herodotus
obtained at level of cribriform plate
shows destruction of ethmoid air cells describe the insertion of a curved metal hook
and roof of ethmoidal sinuses (arrows) into the nostril of a corpse and the removal of
along path of postmortem excerebra- the cranial contents via a transnasal, transeth-
tion.
B, Sagittal CT scan shows transnasal
moidal approach [11]. Four of the mummies in
passageway of brain removal (arrow) our study had skull base abnormalities reflect-
in plane that allows better conceptual- ing this means of excerebration. In these four
ization of location, length, and appear- specimens, the ethmoidal sinuses were either
ance of defect.
C, Three-dimensional reformation from partially or completely destroyed (Fig. 1). The
CT scan of defect of ethmoidal sinuses side of traumatic penetration was variable:
(arrows) shown in B provides another right-sided destruction in two mummies from
compelling perspective of this abnor-
mality.
the 19th Dynasty, left-sided destruction in a
child from the 25th or 26th Dynasty, and bilat-
eral destruction of the ethmoidal sinuses in the
other child from the same era. Although the de-
fects were evident on CT scans obtained in the
traditional axial plane, sagittal and coronal re-
formations were illustrative in further showing
the location and extent of the bony abnormali-
ties. Using volume-rendering algorithms, we
C
generated three-dimensional images that pro-
ble 1). The approximate age at death of each vided additional perspectives of these defects.
Materials and Methods
mummy was based on prior bone evaluations. Axial CT of the skull of the child with the
Between October 1999 and May 2001, nine in- All mummies were evaluated on a helical CT
calvarial fracture showed a bony fragment
tact Egyptian mummies, including two children, scanner (General Electric Medical Systems, Mil-
that had been displaced into the posterior as-
were individually transported from the Michael C. waukee, WI) with 1-mm axial images from the
Carlos Museum on the Emory University campus skull vertex through the mid cervical spine. The pect of the skull (Fig. 2A). The morphology
to the Department of Radiology for whole-body scanning parameters were 70–100 mA/sec, 120– of this fragment was difficult to conceptualize
CT and radiography. The mummies are thought to 140 kVp, and a pitch of 1.0; no gantry tilt was on images obtained in the axial plane; this
be from various eras on the basis of the accompa- used. The number of axial images generated per finding was more easily identifiable as a
nying coffins and other Egyptologic evidence (Ta- mummy ranged from 126 to 218. piece of sphenoid bone on three-dimensional

1368 AJR:178, June 2002


CT of the Head and Skull Base in Egyptian Mummies

Radiologically and Historically Based Estimates of the Demographic large amount of resin, an embalming fluid (Fig.
TABLE 1 3). Two different densities within this hardened
Information for the Nine Mummies Studied
molten mass are clearly depicted, suggesting
Mummy Sex Age at Death (yr) Era Time Period
either that the fluid was poured in two different
1 Female 20–40 21st Dynasty 1085–945 BC installments or that it had layered into sedi-
2 Unknown a 20–35 21st Dynasty 1085–945 BC ments before hardening into a solid mass. A
3 Female >35 21st Dynasty 1085–945 BC small amount of resin was identified in only
4 Unknowna 2 25th or 26th Dynasty 747–525 BC one other mummy: one of the children from the
5 Unknowna 5 25th or 26th Dynasty 747–525 BC 25th or 26th Dynasty.
6 Male >30 Roman period 305 BC–AD 323 The brain was left in situ in the remaining
five mummies, a finding that contradicted tra-
7 Unknown a >18 21st Dynasty 1085–945 BC
ditional accounts of mummification. Although
8 Male >45 19th Dynasty 1320–1200 BC
varying in appearance, the brain typically atro-
9 Unknown a 20–35 21st Dynasty 1085–945 BC
phied and settled in the dependent (posterior)
a
We were unable to definitively determine the sex. Mummies 4, 5, 7, and 9 are thought to be males. portion of the skull (Figs. 4–6). Residual dural
linings were also evident in three of the five
mummies, thus confirming that no attempt
reformations (Fig. 2B). Although invasion Intracranial Contents was made to remove the brain.
and destruction of the ethmoidal sinuses were The brain was absent from the four mum-
apparent, the brain appears to have been re- mies with traumatic anterior skull base defects. Craniocervical Junction
moved more aggressively in this child than in Although the cranial vault was primarily empty The craniocervical junction was abnormal in
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

the other mummies via a posteriorly oriented, in three of these mummies, approximately half three of the nine mummies studied. The abnor-
transsphenoidal approach. of the cranium of mummy 4 was filled with a malities included rotary subluxation and disloca-

A B

Fig. 2.—Skull of child mummy from 25th or 26th Dynasty who was approximately 5 years old at death. Sex of child could not be definitively determined.
A, Axial CT image shows amorphous bony fragment (straight arrow) in dependent portion of skull. Also note small amount of resin poured within cranium (r) and depressed
fracture of parietal skull (curved arrow), which may have been related to death of this child.
B, Volume-rendered shaded-surface–display CT image better depicts shape of bony fragment (arrow) seen within posterior calvarium. This fragment appeared to repre-
sent portion of sphenoid bone, which was likely displaced during process of brain removal.

AJR:178, June 2002 1369


Hoffman and Hudgins

tion (Fig. 7). Although the cases of rotary the adult male mummies were seen (Fig. 9A), terior midline alveolar process of the maxilla and
subluxation were evident on images obtained in in addition to discontinuity of the adjacent cor- did not appear to extend into the posterior palate.
the traditional axial plane, craniocervical dislo- tical bone at the occipitomastoid confluence. Evident on contiguous axial images and those
cation was best illustrated on the reformatted reproduced in a three-dimensional format, this
coronal images. Dentition abnormality is believed to represent a mild form
Extraction sockets, fractured teeth, and of a cleft palate (Fig. 11). Volume-rendered
Temporal Bone and Middle and Inner Ears periapical radiolucencies were identified in shaded-surface–display images suggested that
The external auditory canals were normal in all seven adult mummies to various degrees. this child also may have had a cleft lip.
all nine mummies. Remarkably, despite up to Dental caries was suggested in only two of
3000 years of elapsed time, the fragile middle the adult mummies. Mild to moderate erosion Orbital Structures
ear ossicles were pristinely preserved bilater- of the cusps of the molars and premolars was The atrophied remains of the extraocular
ally in three of the mummies (Fig. 8). The os- seen in two of the adult male mummies. muscles and optic nerves were identifiable in
sicular chain was disrupted in six of the nine of These abnormalities were difficult to appreci- six of the nine mummies (Fig. 12). The defini-
the mummies studied. Abnormalities ranged ate on the axial images but were readily ap- tive identification of the globe was more vari-
from ossicular subluxation and dislocation to parent on images obtained in the sagittal able, and the lenses were distinctly seen in
the complete absence of all ossicles. The inner plane and on the three-dimensional reforma- only one mummy (Fig. 13).
ear, including the otic capsule and cochlea, tions (Fig. 10). In one male mummy, the right orbital
vestibule, and semicircular canals, was normal The two pediatric specimens had unerupted structures were absent, and fractures of the
in all the specimens. teeth, the pattern of which helped establish the adjacent lamina papyracea were detected.
Mastoid air cells in eight of the nine mum- approximate ages at the time of death as 2 and These findings suggest that the removal of the
mies were well pneumatized and normal in ar- 5 years. orbital contents was intentional. In two other
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

chitecture bilaterally. Asymmetric sclerosis, A thin, corticated bony defect was revealed in mummies, the orbital structures were also ab-
erosion, and dehiscence of the lateral right the paramedian hard palate of one of the child sent and embalming debris was present in the
mastoid air cells and sigmoid plate in one of mummies. The defect primarily involved the an- empty bony orbits.

Fig. 3.—Cranial contents of male mummy from 19th Dynasty, potentially a pharaoh, Fig. 4.—Intracranial contents of female mummy from 21st Dynasty. When left intact,
who was more than 45 years old at death. Axial CT image of skull shows replace- brain (large arrow) typically atrophied and fell within dependent portion of skull.
ment of brain tissue with resin (embalming fluid), which fills approximately 50% of Meningeal linings (small arrow) can also be identified, evidence that no attempt was
skull. Two different densities are clearly present within this molten resin mass, sug- made to remove intracranial contents.
gesting fluid was poured in two different installments or, alternatively, layered into
precipitates before drying. Small amount of resin (arrowhead) is also present in
right maxillary sinus. Also note near-complete absence of ethmoid air cells, reflect-
ing transethmoidal approach for excerebration.

1370 AJR:178, June 2002


CT of the Head and Skull Base in Egyptian Mummies
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

Fig. 5.—Intracranial contents of female mummy from 21st Dynasty (different specimen Fig. 6.—Intracranial contents of male mummy from 21st Dynasty who was more than 30
from Figure 4) who was between 20 and 40 years old at death. Sagittal CT image re- years old at death. Axial CT image reveals markedly atrophied, heterogeneous brain
veals atrophied brain (straight arrow) within dependent posterior cranium. Note (large arrow) within dependent skull. Small arrow denotes meningeal linings, evidence
linen (curved arrow) within oropharynx; linen was likely placed postmortem to help that no attempt was made to remove intracranial contents.
restore facial contours to corpse.

Fig. 7.—Craniocervical junction of male mummy from 21st Dynasty who was ap- Fig. 8.—Temporal bone of male mummy from 21st Dynasty who was approximately 20–
proximately 20–35 years old at death. Coronal reformation from CT scan shows sub- 35 years old at death. Note normal middle and inner ear structures, including malleolar
luxation and dislocation at C1–C2 and C2–C3 levels, which were suspected on axial head and body, short process of incus (arrow), and lateral semicircular canal
acquisitions but could be confirmed on high-resolution reformations. This injury (arrowhead). Only three of nine mummies had such well-preserved temporal bones.
likely occurred postmortem.

AJR:178, June 2002 1371


Hoffman and Hudgins

Fig. 9.—Mastoid air cells of male


mummy, possible pharaoh from 19th
Dynasty, who was more than 45
years old at death.
A, Axial CT image of right temporal
bone shows demineralization of mas-
toid septations as well as focal dehis-
cence of mastoid bone and sigmoid
plate (thick arrows). Opacification
within air cells likely results from in-
tracranial embalming fluid. This pat-
tern of dehiscence likely represents
premorbid bone erosion, possibly from
mastoiditis. Note defect at occipito-
mastoid confluence (thin arrow). We
speculate this defect may reflect site
of treatment attempt.
B, Axial CT image of contralateral
(left) mastoid and sigmoid plate re-
veals intact bony architecture.

A B
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

A B

Fig. 10.—Dental images of male mummy from 21st Dynasty who was approximately 20–35 years old at death.
A, Sagittal CT image obtained through left mandible shows concavity of cusps of preserved mandibular teeth. These changes are thought to result from sand and grit in diet.
B, Volume-rendered shaded-surface–display image again shows cusp erosions (arrow).

1372 AJR:178, June 2002


CT of the Head and Skull Base in Egyptian Mummies

Facial Soft Tissues destruction of the bony and cartilaginous intracranial contents. A wad of resin-soaked
Study of superficial soft-tissue features structures of the nose in four mummies. In linen was placed over the left side of a child’s
with both standard and three-dimensional im- three of these mummies, this damage was likely nose after the cartilaginous structures had been
aging methods revealed complete or partial related to traumatic transnasal removal of the destroyed (Fig. 14). The three-dimensional
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

A B

Fig. 11.—Probable midface congenital deformity, cleft palate, in child mummy from 25th or 26th Dynasty who was approximately 5 years old at death. Sex of mummy could
not be definitively determined.
A, Axial CT image shows bony cleft (straight arrow) in midline. Also note right nasal pledget (curved arrow), either linen or resin, that was placed to restore natural facial
contours in this child mummy.
B, Shaded-surface–display reformation shows cleft.

Fig. 12.—Orbital structures in female mummy from 21st Dynasty who was approximately Fig. 13.—Orbital structures in male mummy from Roman period who was more than 30
20–40 years old at death. Axial CT image shows atrophied and degenerated orbital con- years old at death. Axial CT image shows collapsed globes and lenses (arrow).
tents including extraocular muscles, fascia, and other orbital structures (arrows).

AJR:178, June 2002 1373


Hoffman and Hudgins

reconstruction of one mummy showed a de- Discussion expensive aromatic embalming fluid derived
formity of the nose (Fig. 15); this finding re- The systematic review of the skull and its from trees that was used in the mummification
flects the underlying nasal and maxillary associated structures of nine Egyptian mum- process during several dynasties. The contrast
sinus fractures depicted on the axial images. mies yielded information of historical and sci- resolution inherent to CT enabled the identifica-
This image also nicely shows that the orbits entific interest. There was evidence of tion and characterization of two different densi-
in this woman are sunken, apparently having intentional excerebration in four mummies. As ties of the embalming fluid, a detail that was not
been removed. alluded to in ancient historical accounts and more evident on the radiographs of the skull. This
Three-dimensional reconstructions of an- recent scientific investigations [4, 6, 13–17], a finding suggests that the resin either was poured
other mummy also revealed a deformity of the transnasal, transethmoidal approach into the into the cranium in two different installments or,
pinna of the right ear (Fig. 16), a detail that cranium was typically used. In this collection alternatively, was composed of different sedi-
was difficult to appreciate on images obtained of mummies, it is unclear whether there was a ments that precipitated before drying into a mol-
in the standard axial plane. preferential side, or nostril, through which the ten mass. A growing body of evidence in the
Volume-rendered images were remarkably Egyptians approached the skull base. The Egyptology literature and radiology literature
similar to the true appearance of the mummies. mummies from the 19th Dynasty and 21st Dy- supports the hypothesis that this particular male
nasty had right-sided defects; one child from mummy lived during the 19th Dynasty of the
Other Findings and Normal Variants the 25th or 26th Dynasty had left-sided bony New Kingdom and is of royal lineage, perhaps
Careful study of the head and skull base fea- destruction, whereas the other child from the the lost body of Ramesses I, the first ruler of the
tures of the nine mummies resulted in the detec- same era had bilateral defects. Interestingly, 19th Dynasty. The large amount of expensive
tion of normal variants and other incidental the child with bilateral defects had a wad of embalming fluid found in the skull and else-
findings. Linen packing was identified in the resin-soaked linen over the left nostril, raising where in the body of this individual corresponds
oropharynx or hypopharynx of three mummies the possibility that this site was the site of trau- with known New Kingdom mummification
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

(Fig. 5). This material was probably strategically matic entry. Irrespective of the side of the de- techniques and further supports this theory.
placed to restore the lifelike contours to the face fect, all defects could be identified on images In four of five mummies from the 21st Dy-
and soft tissues of the neck. A small resin-coated obtained in the axial plane; however, these de- nasty, the brain was left intact. Although this
pledget was present in the right nostril of one of fects were best conceptualized on images ob- practice may indicate that the deceased were
the child mummies (Fig. 11A). tained in the sagittal plane and as part of a of a lower social status, this trend suggests that
Other normal variants included a large pneu- three-dimensional image. mummification techniques were simplified
matized frontal sinus, concha bullosa, several A finding of particular interest was the pres- during this time period, because evidence of
cases of nasal septal deviation, and one high- ence of a large amount of resin within the skull brain removal has more typically been found
riding jugular bulb. of one of the adult male mummies. Resin was an in mummies from earlier periods.

Fig. 14.—Facial features of child mummy from 25th or 26th Dynasty who was ap- Fig. 15.—Facial features of female mummy from 21st Dynasty who was more than 35
proximately 2 years old at death. Sex of infant could not be determined. Volume-ren- years old at death. Volume-rendered shaded-surface–display image eerily displays
dered surface–display reformation shows wad of linen (arrowhead) over left nares. sunken orbits, abnormal facial contours, and fractured teeth that closely replicate this
This detail was better appreciated on three-dimensional images, which can provide female mummy’s true appearance. Reformations are complementary to direct axial ac-
Egyptologists with additional information about mummification techniques. quisitions and reveal detail that could only be imagined otherwise.

1374 AJR:178, June 2002


CT of the Head and Skull Base in Egyptian Mummies

Fig. 16.—Soft-tissue facial struc- niocervical junction was evident on standard


tures in male mummy, possible 19th axial images, reformatted images in the coronal
Dynasty royalty, who was more than
45 years old at death. Volume-ren- plane better showed dislocation of the cranio-
dered shaded-surface–display ref- cervical junction.
ormation shows absence of large The utility of advanced CT imaging and
portion of superior cartilaginous
pinna. postprocessing techniques was further high-
lighted by the application of volume-rendering
algorithms in the evaluation of soft tissues.
Contour abnormalities of the face that were
difficult to appreciate on images obtained in
the axial plane were readily apparent on three-
dimensional images.
Several authors have dedicated book chapters
and journal articles solely to the study of ancient
Egyptian teeth [2, 3, 5, 19]. The mummies in
our collection, like those studied before them,
overwhelmingly suffered from varying degrees
of dental and periodontal disease. Ancient
Egyptians suffered greatly from antemortem
tooth loss [19], as evidenced in our study by a
large number of empty sockets. These findings
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

Egyptologists and the general population been previously described, most notably by may have resulted partly from periodontal dis-
alike are interested in the afflictions and possible Brothwell and Sandison [18] who in 1967 re- ease, which was also present in most of the
causes of death of these ancient people. Al- ported seven cases of mastoiditis in Egyptian adult mummies in this study. Evidence of gen-
though speculative, our findings identify a po- remains. The apparent bony destruction in the eralized tooth cusp attrition was present in two
tential contributor to or cause of death in two of mummy in our collection suggests a process mummies. Apparently widespread in ancient
the nine mummies studied. A complex, partially that was chronic and recurrent. The reason for Egypt, tooth cusp attrition has been attributed to
depressed skull fracture in a child mummy raises Ramesses I’s brief 2-year reign and presumed the large amount of coarse, erosive grit and sand
the possibility of a traumatic antemortem head hasty demise is a mystery. If this mummy is in in the diet of most Egyptians. The easy identifi-
injury. The absence of callous formation, indi- fact the royal pharaoh, one might speculate cation of these abnormalities on sagittal and
cating there was not enough time for bone heal- that almost 3000 years ago an episode of acute three-dimensional images again highlights the
ing to occur, suggests the relative acuity of the untreated mastoiditis could potentially be a importance and utility of multiplanar, multidi-
trauma. The location and appearance of this source of intracranial or widespread infection mensional CT.
skull fracture are not likely to have been related and subsequent death. Of additional interest is Evaluation of the teeth revealed the presence
to brain removal, because brain removal is ac- the discontinuity of the cortical bone posterior of a mild form of cleft palate in one of the child
counted for by traditional skull base and sinus to the mastoid abnormality at the occipitomas- mummies. To the best of our knowledge, this
fractures. Furthermore, it is less likely that this toid confluence; this finding raises the possi- abnormality has rarely been reported in the
fracture resulted from postmortem mishandling bility that interventional efforts were attempted Egyptology literature. Although the defect is
because only one other fracture (of the distal fe- to facilitate healing of the condition. confined to the alveolar ridge and is seemingly
mur) was identified in this specimen, whereas Examination of the temporal bone and mid- mild, this child may have experienced eating
mummies that are indiscriminately handled typi- dle ear revealed either disruption or the absence and speech difficulties and an increased predis-
cally have innumerable fractures throughout the of the ossicular chain in six mummies. Similar position to infection.
entire bony skeleton. These fractures usually re- findings were reported by Yardley and Rutka [4] The orbital structures were primarily intact,
flected previous attempts by vandals to steal or using CT scans and direct otoscopic examina- albeit atrophied, in six of the mummies in this
unwrap mummies in the hopes of finding jewels, tions. Given the absence of associated temporal collection. The meningeal sheath of the optic
which were often wrapped beneath the linens. bone abnormalities in all but one of these mum- nerve could be identified to varying degrees, as
This same child had a piece of the sphenoid mies (the one with possible mastoiditis), we could the atrophied extraocular muscles and
bone displaced into the posterior skull. Three-di- have also concluded that these fragile ossicles their fascial sheaths. The unilateral absence of
mensional reformations of this bony piece were were disrupted in the postmortem state and are orbital structures in one mummy, who also had
helpful in establishing its shape and identity. not indicative of antemortem pathology. ipsilateral lamina papyracea fractures, strongly
The other, and potentially more noteworthy, To our knowledge, the craniocervical junc- suggested intentional and traumatic removal of
finding that may be related to morbidity, if not tion of mummies has not been studied. Evi- the orbital contents. Only three of the five mum-
mortality, was the discovery of evidence of dence of either dislocation or rotary subluxation mies thought to be from the same dynasty had
mastoid disease in the potential male pharaoh. of the craniocervical junction in three mummies intact orbital structures; this finding suggests
The asymmetric sclerosis, erosion, and dehis- was found. Because these mummies also had that mummification techniques varied during
cence of the mastoid air cells in this adult male innumerable other fractures, these abnormalities the same era, possibly reflecting the different
strongly suggest prior inflammatory mastoid are also thought to reflect postmortem mishan- social or financial status of the deceased. The
disease—that is, mastoiditis. This condition has dling. Although rotary subluxation of the cra- globes were difficult to identify, and the lenses

AJR:178, June 2002 1375


Hoffman and Hudgins

were distinctly identified in only one well-pre- eralized variance in mummification tech- 8. Motamed M, Alusi G, Campos J, East C. ENT as-
served male mummy, which suggests that these niques. This study affirms that radiology—in pects of the mummification of the head in ancient
Egypt: an imaging study. Rev Laryngol Otol Rhi-
structures were probably vulnerable to the harsh this case, advanced CT imaging and postpro-
nol 1998;119:337–339
effects of the embalming process. cessing techniques—is an indispensable tool 9. Harris JE, Wente EF. An X-ray atlas of the royal
Our CT findings indicate that despite a dif- in the multidisciplinary investigation of Egyp- mummies. Chicago: University of Chicago Press,
ference of 3000 years and different cultures the tian mummies. 1980:5, 11–15, 19, 168–169
general anatomy and morphology of the skull 10. Andrews C. Egyptian mummies. Cambridge,
and skull base have not changed significantly MA: Harvard University Press, 1990:16
References 11. Dunand F, Lichtenberg R. Mummies: a voyage
over the last 3000 years. Normal variants seen
1. Harris JE, Weeks KR. X-raying the pharaohs. through eternity. New York: Abrams, 1994:31–32
on present-day head CT scans—including large New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1973:21 12. Brier B. Egyptian mummies: unraveling the se-
pneumatized sinuses, concha bullosa, deviation 2. Leek F. Observations on the dental pathology crets of an ancient art. New York: William Mor-
of the nasal septum, or a high-riding jugular seen in ancient Egyptian skulls. J Egypt Archael row, 1994:60–62
bulb—were all seen among this collection of 1966;52:59–64 13. Herodotus of Halicarnassus. The histories: book
ancient people. 3. Nickol T, Germer R, Lieberenz S, Schmidt F, II. New York: Penguin, 1972
Wilke W. An examination of the dental state of an 14. Vahey T, Brown D. Comely Wenuhotep: computed
In conclusion, CT is a highly effective,
Egyptian mummy by means of computer tomog- tomography of an Egyptian mummy. J Comput As-
nondestructive method of studying the head raphy: a contribution to ‘dentistry in ancient sist Tomogr 1984;8:992–997
and skull base of Egyptian mummies. Exqui- Egypt.’ Bull Hist Dent 1995;43:105–112 15. Marx M, D’Auria SH. CT examination of eleven
site anatomic details can be revealed while 4. Yardley M, Rutka J. Rescued from the sands of time: Egyptian mummies. RadioGraphics 1986;6:
leaving the specimen intact. A standard thin- interesting otologic and rhinologic findings in two 321–330
collimation helical technique produced images ancient Egyptian mummies from the Royal Ontario 16. Baldock C, Hughes SW, Whittaker DK, et al. 3-D
Museum. J Otolaryngol 1997;26:379–383 reconstruction of an ancient Egyptian mummy
of good resolution and quality. These images
American Journal of Roentgenology 2002.178:1367-1376.

5. Melcher AH, Holowka S, Pharaoh M, Lewin PK. using X-ray computer tomography. J Roy Soc
can be further manipulated and reviewed in Non-invasive computed tomography and three- Med 1994;87:806–808
coronal, sagittal, and three-dimensional for- dimensional reconstruction of the dentition of a 17. Pickering RB, Conces DJ, Braunstein EM, Yurco
mats to generate images in the most informa- 2,800-year-old Egyptian mummy exhibiting ex- F. Three-dimensional computed tomography of
tive and illustrative plane for viewing. Using tensive dental disease. Am J Phys Anthro 1997; the mummy Wenuhotep. Am J Phys Anthro
these imaging techniques for the methodic 103:329–340 1990;83:49–55
evaluation of the skull and skull base of nine 6. Gaafar H, Abdel-Monem MH, Elsheikh S. Nasal en- 18. Brothwell D, Sandison AT. Diseases in antiquity.
doscopy and CT study of Pharaonic and Roman Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas, 1967:464–473
Egyptian mummies yielded information of
mummies. Acta Otolaryngol 1999;119:257–260 19. Harris JE, Wente EF. Dental disease in the royal
historical, paleopathologic, and general inter- 7. Thekkaniyil JK, Bishara S, James M. Dental and mummies. In: Harris JE, Wente EF, eds. An X-ray
est, including evidence of congenital defects, skeletal findings on an ancient Egyptian mummy. atlas of the royal mummies. Chicago: University
antemortem disease, causes of death, and gen- Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2000;117:10–14 of Chicago Press, 1980:328–345

1376 AJR:178, June 2002

You might also like