Structural Study 3 - 2008

You might also like

Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 5

CEE 262 Spring 2008

III. Cables:
The George Washington Bridge

www.nwa.nl

Figure 1: The George Washington Bridge, New York City

The George Washington Bridge crosses What is a Suspension Bridge?


the Hudson River between New York A suspension bridge is one in which the
City and New Jersey. Built in 1931 and bridge deck is supported with cables that
designed by Othmar Ammann, the are suspended between two large towers.
bridge was the longest span in the world Attaching the deck to the cables are
when it was completed. The length suspenders. The suspenders transmit the
between its two towers is 3,500 ft. loads from the deck to the cables.
Classified as a suspension bridge, the Because of the great number of
bridge was built with one deck. In 1961 suspenders, we can approximate the
a second deck was added below the gravity loads: the dead load of the bridge
original to increase its capacity.i Both deck and the live load from the traffic
decks are still in service today. carried by the bridge, as a uniformly
distributed load, q (lb/ft or k/ft) on the
cable. Gravity loads are the dominant
load in this structure. Wind loads will
not be considered in this study.

1
CEE 262 Spring 2008

Tower Reactions
Loads are transmitted from the cables to Example: Reactions at the Towers of
the towers. The applied gravity loads on the George Washington Bridge
the cable are acting downward; therefore
the towers need to resist these forces
with upward reactions. The vertical
reaction, V (lbs or k) at each tower is:

q*L
V = Figure 3: Elevation of the George Washington
2 Bridge

where q is the uniformly distributed load Determine: The vertical and horizontal
applied to the bridge (lbs/ft or k/ft) and reactions at each tower of the George
L (ft) is the length of the main span of Washington Bridge. See Figure 3.
the bridge.
Given:ii
In addition, the loads on the bridge act to The dead load of the bridge, qDL =
pull the tower tops toward each other; 39 k/ft
therefore the towers need to resist these Ammann’s estimate for the live load on
forces with reactions that act to keep the the bridge = qLL = 8 k/ft.iii
towers vertical. The horizontal reaction, The main span, L = 3,500 ft.
H (lbs or k) at each tower is: The sag of the cable, d = 325 ft.
q * L2 Solution:
H =
8*d
Step 1 -- Calculate the total load acting
where d is the sag of the cable (ft) at on the bridge:
midspan. Sag at a location is the vertical
distance from the top of the towers to the q = q DL + q LL = 39 k/ft + 8k/ft = 47 k/ft
cable. At midspan, the sag is greatest. Step 2 -- Calculate the vertical reaction
Once again q is the distributed load and at each tower:
L is the length of the main span. See
Figure 2 below. q * L 47 k/ft * 3,500 ft
V = = = 82 ,300 k
2 2

Step 3 -- Calculate the horizontal


reaction at each tower:

q * L2 47 k/ft * (3,500 ft ) 2
H = = = 221 ,400 k
Figure 2: Loaded Cable with Reactions 8*d 8 * 325

What is a Cable?

2
CEE 262 Spring 2008

A cable is a flexible structural element If a cable takes on a form like that


that resists applied loads in tension. shown in Figure 5, and the tensile forces
Because a cable is only able to take axial are in line with the main axis of the
tensile forces, it adjusts its form in cable, then the direction of the tensile
accordance with the applied loads to force is constantly changing. The tensile
achieve this behavior. For example a force increases as the slope of the cable
cable that has a single point load, Q increases and therefore is greatest at the
applied at midspan takes on the shape supports. For our purposes we’ll
shown in Figure 4. consider the tensile force at the midspan
as an approximation for the force in the
cable at any location.iv At the midspan of
the bridge the cable is horizontal and
therefore the tensile force is in the
horizontal direction. This tensile force is
equal (in magnitude and direction) to the
horizontal reaction, H at the tower. We
Figure 4: Cable Shape Under a Point Load will use this tensile force to calculate the
tensile stress, ft in the cable. See Figure
Figure 5 shows the form (a parabola) 6:
that a cable takes on under a uniformly
distributed load, q, like that of a
suspension bridge.

H
ft =
A
Figure 6: Cable Under Tension
Figure 5: Cable Shape Under a Uniformly
Distributed Load Example: Stress in the Cables of the
George Washington Bridge
Other forms can be created by altering
the loads applied to the cable. Determine: The stress in the cable of the
main span of the George Washington
Tensile Stress Bridge and the efficiency of the cable.
Recall from the first structural study: “I.
Columns: The Washington Monument,” Given: There are four cables each with
that an axial load is directed along the an area, A= 800 in.
main axis of the structural element. For Recall that the horizontal reaction, H =
columns the loads were compressive. 221,400k
For cables the loads are tensile. The Ammann used an allowable stress, fallow
resulting stresses are also tensile and of 82 ksi for steel cable.
we’ll refer to them as tensile stresses, ft.

3
CEE 262 Spring 2008

Solution:
-A: cross-sectional area [in2]
Step 1: Calculate the total cross- -d: sag [ft]
sectional area of the cables -ft: tensile stress, [psi] or [ksi]
-H: horizontal reaction at tower and
A = number of cables * Aonecable tensile force in cable, [lbs] or [k]
-L: main span length [ft]
A = 4 * 800in2 = 3,200in2 -q: distributed load, [lbs/ft] or [k/ft]
-qDL: distributed dead load, [lbs/ft] or
Step 2: Calculate the tensile stress in the [k/ft]
cables:v -qLL: distributed live load, [lbs/ft] or
[k/ft]
H 221 ,400 k -V: vertical reaction at tower, [lbs] or [k]
ft = = = 69 .2ksi
A 3,200 in 2
Summary of Equations
Step 3: Calculate the efficiency of the
cables: Vertical Reaction at Tower:

ft 69 .2ksi q*L
Efficiency = = = 0.84 V =
f allow 82 ksi 2

The Form of a Suspension Bridge Horizontal Reaction at Tower:


2
q*L
H = is the main equation for a q * L2
8*d H =
suspension bridge. It represents the 8*d
transformation of vertical forces into
horizontal reactions and is dependent on Tensile Stress:
the chosen form. The load applied to the
bridge is defined by q*L while the form H
ft =
of the bridge is defined by the ratio of A
the main span to the sag, L/d.vi While
the equation permits you to calculate the Notes
tensile force in a cable given certain
parameters, span (L), sag (d), and the i
David P. Billington, “History and
distributed load (q), the choice of these Aesthetics of Suspension Bridges,”
parameters, is ultimately made by the Journal of the Structural Division, ASCE
designer. These choices dictate how the Vol. 103, no. 478 (August 1977): 671-
forces are resisted in the structure and 687, with discussions.
influence the aesthetic of the bridge
ii
The values used in this analysis are
taken from Power, Speed, and Form;
Engineers and the Making of the
Twentieth Century, by David P.
Billington and David P. Billington Jr.,
Summary of Terms

4
CEE 262 Spring 2008

Princeton University Press, Princeton, Since the area required comes directly
2006, p. 166 and 167. from the allowable stress in the cables,
ft = fallow and the efficiency is 1.
iii
Ammann realized that the likelihood of
vi
all the lanes on the bridge being The Innovators; The Engineering
completely full with the heaviest Pioneers who Made America Modern,
vehicles decreased as the span of the by David P. Billington, John Wiley &
bridge increased and as more lanes were Sons, Inc., New York, 1996, p. 7, 9 and
added. With these considerations in 12.
mind he developed a series of equations
that reduced the live load that the bridge
needed to be designed to carry. The live
load, qLL, before reduction was 46k/ft.
Ibid., p. 166
iv
At other locations the cable will not be
horizontal and the tensile force will
consist of horizontal and vertical force
components. These components need to
be combined together to find the tensile
force, T acting along the axis of the
cable at a particular location. H, the
horizontal force component, is constant
across the entire length of the cable, but
V, the vertical force component,
increases as the slope of the cable
increases. H and the resulting tensile
stress, ft, are adequate approximations
for the cable.
v
Ammann calculated the maximum
tensile force, T, in the cable (which
occurs at the tower closer to the New
York side) to be 261,000 k. Using this
force (rather than the force at midspan)
and fallow = 82 ksi he calculated a
required area of 3,190 in2 (rounded to
3,200 in2).

T
f allow = therefore,
A

F 261 ,000 k
A= = ≈ 3,200 in 2
f allow 82 ksi

You might also like