Professional Documents
Culture Documents
History and History of Education Relevan PDF
History and History of Education Relevan PDF
website: www.yusufmaigida.com.ng
m-phone: +234 (0) 803 234 5719
Abstract
The teaching and learning of history in Nigerian schools have been observed to be
going into extinction; as if there is no need for the younger generation to be aware
of their cultural backgrounds. This paper is intended to highlight the relevance and
relationship existing among history, history of education and historiography to
teacher preparation. Having recognized teachers as vanguards and elements of
salvaging the situation, the need to have the knowledge of history of education in
advancing the Nigerian education is considered paramount. The why of teaching
history is considered indispensable to human existence and societal sustainability.
The various goals of teacher education were critically examined. The roles of
teacher are discussed extensively focusing on the functions of instruction,
socialization, evaluation and motivating pupils, maintaining control, and generally
creating an environment for learning, as well as seeking judicious combination of
enthusiasm and fair-mindedness and others. Ultimately, a ten-point item was
provided to manifest the relevance of history and history of education. The
conclusion emphasises the importance of training and retraining of teachers.
Introduction
A review of history teaching in Nigeria has left us with the manifestation that the
subject is fast going into extinction and in itself becoming a subject of the past,
as it is often referred to, as the subject where the past is studied. At one time in
the country, history as a school subject was completely expunged from the
syllabus as if there was no need for people to understand or know their history
and that of the society in which they live. Sequel to this removal, some experts
and professionals rose to the challenges by salvaging history teaching and
learning from being relegated to the background and leading to the reintroduction
of the subject in the curriculum of secondary schools in Nigeria, but still offered
as optional subject, particularly at the senior secondary and not at all in primary
and junior secondary as it used to be.
The feat of bringing History back into the school syllabus was achieved
under the auspices of the Historical Society of Nigeria who took the bull by the
horns and did everything, including consultation with relevant Government
agencies that matter. The body met the Minister of Education and Alhaji Shehu
Shagari, then President of Nigeria with the submission of memoranda drawing
attention to the dangers and consequences of the Nigerian citizens, not knowing
their history. As Ikime (2006) recounts, nothing came out of this initial effort.
However in 2002, President Obasanjo announced the return of History to our
school syllabus.
Furthermore, he argued that “historical events have created all the basic
human groupings - countries, religions classes and all the loyalties that attached
to these”.
2
occasion by contributing meaningfully to addressing the situation. The situation
may be positively addressed through workshops, seminars, advocacy campaign,
implementation of conference communiqué and formulating policy for back-up.
Researches are also best conducted to solve the problems with the results of such
researches being utilized by policy-makers for salvaging the situation.
Conceptual Clarifications
History
The word ‘history’ and the word ‘story’ both came from the same Greek word
‘historia’ and which was grafted into the English language many hundred years
ago. Ward (1960:11) says that English people took this one Greek word and made
two different English words out of it, because they wished to express two different
ideas of history and story.
In actual fact, every African society has stories about its great chiefs,
warriors and past heroes and heroines; how they fought and led their people.
These stories constitute the beginning of history, because they are about real
people, and because the elders who tell them believe them to be true, but they
often contained things which are hard to believe, and often they do not seem to fit
well together.
In view of this, stories are not always accounts of the true events, but a
fiction which, when they are told or read, they are amusing and interesting. For
example, Ward (1960:1) renders a beautiful story of how the elephant got its long
trunk as follows:
3
Once upon a time elephant had a short nose. One day
he went to the river to drink, and a crocodile caught
him by the nose. The elephant friend, the snake
caught hold of him and the crocodile was not able to
pull the elephant into the river; but the elephant’s
nose was pulled out until it became a long trunk,
since then, all elephants have had long trunks.
The above story is an interesting story to tell or read, but is not real reason
why elephants have long trunks. Another example may be a newspaper report of
the police who discovered a murder, and perhaps sometime later we may read
that someone had been tried for the murder and found guilty. That is a fact; it is
the truth. But we may buy a book which tells us the story of a murder, and how a
clever policeman found out the man who did it. Not a real murder, not a real
policeman. However, a story that the writer has invented is a fiction. History
therefore, is about real people, real event or occurrence.
Academically, history is a discipline that deals with human actions in the
past, pursued by interpretation of evidence for the sake of human knowledge. It is
commonly used to connote the entire human past as it actually happened.
Education
In the New Encyclopaedia Britannica (2002), education is thought of as the
transmission of values and accumulated knowledge of a society. And, in his own
way, Jimoh (2004:15) defines education as the totality of the experiences made
available to the individuals in order to make them develop rounded
personality(ies) and be useful to themselves and their communities. The position
of Gerald (2006) on the concept of education is that it developed from the human
struggle for survival and enlightenment, and that it may be formal or informal.
4
Generally, education should be viewed as the transmission of culture from
one generation to the other for the purpose of continuity in the values and
traditions promoted by the society for useful and productive living of its members.
History of Education
The synergy of the concepts above, that is history and education produced
another concept of focus, that is history of education. Having given that history is
the study or reconstruction of the past, and that education is the transmission of
values and accumulated knowledge of a society, history of education is then given
by Osokoya (1989), as an academic field which concerns itself with the study of
how societies have transmitted culture from one generation to another. He goes
further to say that it is also a study of how education became a tool for problem
solving activity and its evolution down the ages. However, Gerald (2006) says that
history of education can be explained as the theories, methods, and
administration of schools and other agencies of information from the ancient
times to the present.
5
conception could be likened to history of Sango in Yoruba history where some
people regard Sango as god (of thunder), while others see him as just a historical
legend.
The second stage of evolution of history teaching was the coming of the
Europeans. It was believed that the Europeans brought Western education to
Nigeria so as to evangelize. Christianity was basically the tool of evangelization
and all that the colonial masters introduced into education were the teaching of
the 3Rs, that is, reading, writing and arithmetic. This made it impossible for the
teaching of history as a subject at that time because the contents of the
curriculum were drawn from passages in the scripture. At that time, history as a
subject did not exist in the curriculum. Because of the absence of history in the
curriculum of early Christians, no methodology could be ascribed to its teaching.
The third stage in the evolution of history teaching in Nigeria was the time
when indigenous writers of history appeared on the scene. This was around the
19th century. Those indigenous writers wrote about the laws, customs, proverbs
and history of specific places in Africa such as West African history and so on.
Prominent among these writers were Otunba Payne and Samuel Johnson. They
were motivated to document history to preserve the culture of the people for
posterity and to prevent it from going into extinction. In addition to this, they
could have been motivated probably because they wanted to react against the
assertion that Africans had no history before the coming of the Europeans.
The decisions of the indigenous writers to focus on writing about Africans
meant that these writers were out to debunk the assumptions that since there
were no written records in Africa, which was translated by Europeans to mean
that Africa had no history. In this regard, whatever the laudable motivation that
spurred these indigenous pioneers to write history books where their
contributions were even ignored in some secondary schools for failing to recognize
indigenous books, yet history appeared in their curriculum. Samuel Johnson in
the preface to his book in 1897, castigated fellow Africans for taking more pride in
studying foreign history than their own history when he said “Educated natives of
Yoruba are well acquainted with the history of England and with that of Rome
and Greece, but of the history of their own country they know nothing
whatsoever”.
6
From the above statement, it has been observed that though, a particular
kind of history had been advocated but the systemic approach to obtain
satisfactory outcome from the study of our history (knowing something about our
heritage) had to be inferred.
The fourth stage of history teaching began with the Government
intervention in educational matters. This was at the later part of the 19th
century. The teaching of history was ushered in as a result of the introduction of
some Educational Ordinances or Codes. The Ordinances were issued between the
later part of the 19th century and the early part of the 20th century. The
enactment was for Government to direct all educational policies and to supervise
all educational institutions by inspection or other means.
One of the first things observed in the ordinance was the layout of the
levels of education as primary, secondary and teacher training. The second was
the schedules under which specific subjects in the curriculum were listed. For
example, the schedule for secondary school contains the following statement:
The subjects of instruction should include English, Mathematics, Practical
Mathematics, History, Geography, Religious Knowledge, Hygiene and for girls,
domestic science; so also in the higher classes, are the second language,
elementary science or commercial subjects. The subjects were to be taken in
preparation for Cambridge Examinations, the forerunner of the West African
School Certificate Examination.
Though secondary schools were few in number at that time, the subjects on
the curricula reflected the type of staff available and the type of training that
could be provided. Consequently, subjects like history which appeared on the
syllabus were taught based on the fact that teachers were available. The subject
was taught without any specific aims and methods recommended for teaching.
The content of history and objectives which history teaching were meant to fulfill
were left to syllabus makers to determine. Instead, the type of history that
teachers were made to teach included the General Knowledge of English History
and Egba History.
Though the content of history at that time consisted of both foreign and
local history, but more emphasis was placed on foreign history. The preference for
foreign history at the expense of African history was questioned by the Phelps-
Stokes Report of 1922 that “why should the history and Geography of Europe and
7
America receive more attention than that of Africa itself?” This question which
was asked from Somervell by the Nigerian history teachers during his tour of
West Africa on behalf of the Colonial Government in the early thirties was critical.
Question asked by the history teachers – Do African schools really need to have
history books written especially for them? We need our own ‘local’ history books,
written by local experts. Somervell reacted to this question and advised that
charity should begin at home and that African history should be taught in African
schools. It is necessary to state categorically that the full implications of teaching
and learning of history in schools have not been in the secondary school
curriculum for a long time. The content has evolved gradually into what it is
today, having in it the relevance of learning indigenous history.
The last stage in the evolution of history teaching began in the sixties when
history of West Africa was included in the School Leaving Certificate Examination
syllabus. The inclusion of history in the examination syllabus demands a
thorough knowledge of the aims, content and techniques to be adopted to achieve
effective teaching and learning. In view of the above history teaching and learning
in Nigeria witnessed different epochs in scope, nature and characteristics. With
the historical account of how history teaching in Nigeria came to where it is
today, it is strongly believed that history will again take its rightful place of
relevance and recognition; so long the teachers and other educational
stakeholders can be proactive about its development.
Historiography
8
Historiography, according to Conal and Michael (1988) is "the study of the
way history has been and is written—the history of historical writing. For
instance, when you study 'historiography' you do not study the events of the past
directly, but the changing interpretations of those events in the works of
individual historians.
The Teacher
The teacher is a person whose profession is teaching, especially but not limited to
a school. On the other hand, Penguin English Dictionary (2001) defines teacher
as a person who instructs another in a subject, skill, among others. Similarly,
Encarta Dictionary (2006) takes the teacher as somebody who teaches, especially
as a profession. On the other hand, the teacher is considered as anything that
teaches an occurrence, idea, or an act from which something may be learned e.g.
“experience is a teacher”. The writer as a teacher understands ‘teacher’ to be
anyone who is professionally equipped with the skills, knowledge and
resourcefulness to impart knowledge into others, consequently influencing the
behaviour of learners.
10
produce highly motivated, conscientious and efficient classroom
teachers for all levels of our educational system;
encourage further the spirit of enquiry and creativity in teachers;
help teachers to fit into social life of the community and the society at
large and enhance their commitment to national goals;
provide teachers with the intellectual and professional background
adequate for their assignment and make them adaptable to changing
situations;
enhance teachers’ commitment to the teaching profession.
11
impact in the lives of his students, and positively contribute to societal
development. And, for the goals of teacher education to be possibly and
practically realizable, there is the need for the knowledge of history of education.
The Relevance
History promotes the understanding of our heritage by exploring the society; that
is, what the society is, how it grows, the way it works and what it has achieved.
History also helps to know what the societies had been like in the past as well as
how their evolution could give us the clue to the factors that operate in them, the
currents and forces that move them, the motives and conflicts, both general and
personal that shape events.
This aspect is most accurately illustrated with information provided in
Sherman and Kirschner (1976:4) that “when the leading professors of education
in major colleges and universities were polled at the beginning of the last century
concerning the subjects most essential in the education of teachers, 90%
nominated the history of education”.
Nevertheless, the significance of history of education in teacher preparation
is such that anyone who will teach others, as a teacher must have been equipped
with the knowledge, skills and understanding of what to teach, especially as it
concerns history and education to forestall or prevent occurrence or reoccurrence
of nagging educational problems. In this regard, Ward (1960:22) posits that a bad
teacher of history can waste time by teaching his class lists of names and dates
without helping them (students to understand).
Similarly, underscoring the relevance of History and History of Education;
Kosemani (2011) noted that history helps to promote understanding through the
acquisition of relevant information. Well ordered information increases students’
understanding of historical events and happenings of their time. Adequate
understanding promotes education. Education in this sense is not mere
regurgitation of facts but ‘what is left when one has forgotten all that one has ever
learnt’.
12
i. The study of the past would help modern educators or teachers to become
more aware of the implications of the various issues involved in education
ii. It will increase the ability of educators to influence educational policies
under which they are operating, for which their knowledge of the past they
can now offer alternative for actions.
iii. Only by studying the history of other civilizations can we become aware
that the principles upon which our own is founded are peculiar and unique
iv. The knowledge of the past brings us acquaintance with the thoughts of
men who differ from ourselves not being uncivilized or less civilized, but in
being differently civilized, we are thus made conscious that civilization is
relative to societal values.
v. A study of the past enables us to analyze the present critically and
objectively.
vi. The basic problems of education are persistent and perennial and they
must be solved by each generation and from one culture to the other. The
accumulated solutions constitute a historical laboratory which can in
several ways serve those concerned with the problems of education. History
of education will allow us to be familiar with how educational thinkers have
responded to the social demands of their times.
vii. People concerned with the improvement of teaching can learn such from a
study of the way in which effective and great teachers have actually taught
their pupils.
viii.Educators will no longer be at the receiving end of educational policies
formulated by others. Rather, they will be in a position to assist in
formulating more adequate polices which will be implemented by them in
the classroom.
ix. History of education offers a personal intellectual education for the teacher.
x. The teacher can develop greater confidence in his ability by becoming
familiar with the roots of education.
Relationship
The relationship that history has with history of education can be gleaned from
the functions of history, thus;
i. History studies the past to shape the present and make projection into a
promising future.
ii. History makes careful inquiries into the past (events/occurrence, situation
or things) to determine the cause and effect of historical occurrence.
iii. History records, archives or holds the memory of places/things/events said
and done for subsequent referencing.
iv. History enables man to extend his knowledge and imagination to judge the
present events and prognosticate, that is, learning from experience and
experience as the best teacher of man.
Conclusion
The FRN (2004), stresses that all teachers in educational institutions shall be
professionally trained. The document also affirms that teacher education
programmes shall be structured to equip teachers for effective performance of
their duties. This then means that the knowledge of history of education is
indispensable for teachers to be able to effectively perform their duties. The
teacher’s knowledge of history of education is indeed synonymous to having the
potentials to influence and initiate positive developmental changes in the self and
the society.
References
Bailyn, B. (1960) Education in the forming of American society: needs and
opportunities for study. Chapel Hill: University of North Caroline press.
Brown, N.G. (1967). Living history. education for development: a guide for teachers
in Africa. London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd.
Carr, E.H. (1971) What is history? Harmondsworth: Penguin Books. Pg.106
Conal, F. and Michael, J. S. (1988). The Methods and Skills of History: A Practical
Guide.
Daniels, R. V. (1972) Studying history, how and why. New Jersey: Prentice Hall,
Inc. (2nd Edition) Publishers.
Davidson, B. (1959). Old Africa rediscovered. London: Gollancz. Pp. 61-62
Federal Republic of Nigeria (2004) National policy on education. 4th Edition. Lagos:
NERDC Press
Hoyle, E. (1969). The role of the teacher. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Historiography
Ikime, O. (2006) History, the historian and the nation: the voice of a Nigerian
historian. Ibadan: Heinemann Educational Books (Nigeria) Plc
Jimoh, S. A. (2004). Islamic education in Nigeria: An Overview. In S. A. Jimoh
(ed.) Foundations of Education. IIorin: Indemac (Nigeria publisher) Ltd.
Kosemani, I. C. (2011). Teaching method in history. Unpublished Lecture Manual.
University of Port Harcourt.
Osokoya, I. O. (1989). History and policy of education in world perspective. Ibadan:
AMD Publishers
Penguin (2001). The new penguin english dictionary. Software – Librios Research
Ltd. 1998-2001
Plumb, J. H. (1971). The death of the past. Boston: Houston Mifflin Co. PA.
Furley, O. W. and Watson, T. (1978). A history of education in East Africa. USA &
Nigeria: NOK Publishers International Ltd.
Sherman, R. R. and Kirschner, J. (1976) Understanding history of education.
Cambridge & USA: Schenkman Publishing Co.
The New World Encyclopedia (2008) “Historiography” Web Source
http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Historiography - 23/05/2011.
16
The Penguin Dictionary (1979). Electronic software. Librios research Ltd version
1.20.2
Ward, W. E. F. (1960). A history of africa. London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd.
17