Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10 - Chapter 3 PDF
10 - Chapter 3 PDF
10 - Chapter 3 PDF
CHAPTER- 3
SYNTHESIS OF BIOFUELS
3.1 Introduction
The research deals with synthesize oil from seeds by mechanical method using
screw expellers and novel method of oil extraction using microwave energy. This
research aims to compare the oil extraction on four different processes, namely
conventional single screw, modified single screw, twin screw and microwave heating.
For extraction of oil from seeds, seeds were cleaned and dried under sun. Figure
3.1 (a) shows the whole pongamia pinnata seeds and Figure 3.1 (b) shows the crushed
pongamia pinnata seeds. The average length, width and thickness of seeds were 25.29
mm, 15.58 mm and 7.88 mm respectively. The geometric mean diameter and sphericity
were 14.55 mm and 0.57 mm respectively. The seeds were fed to the single screw
expeller at constant rate and crushed flakes were obtained. Both whole seeds and crushed
seeds were used as feedstock.
Figure 3.2 (a) shows photographic image of a single screw oil expeller used in
this study. Figure 3.2 (b) shows the schematic view of the single screw expeller setup for
oil extraction. Figure 3.2 (c) shows the screw shaft in the single screw expeller. Figure
3.2 (d) shows the details of the design of the single screw used. The single screw oil
expeller used mainly consists of the following four sections namely feeding section
(hopper), screw shaft, barrel (screw housing) and drive assembly. A 5 HP, 3 phase motor
with 15 amps drives the expeller.
43
Hopper
Belt Drive
Feed Control
Housing
Oil Outlet
Figure 3.2 (b) Schematic of the Single Screw Oil Extraction Setup
44
Flight
Tapered
Shaft
Tapered Shaft
Figure 3.2 (d) Detailed Design of the Screw of the Single Screw Expeller
Seed cake is obtained after oil is expelled from seeds. Figure 3.3 shows the
pongamia seed cake which serves as a good organic and natural manure.
45
Oil expelling technology in India is still in traditional state. There is a need for
advancement in technology. Hence newer concepts have been proposed. Concept
generation began with solution requirements and target specifications. Based on this,
various product concepts were generated out of which most suitable concept was
selected. A five step method has been adopted for concept generation process.
In this approach, initially complex problem was broken down into simpler sub-
problems. Solution concepts were identified for sub-problems by internal and external
search procedures.
Problem was understood and broken down into sub-problems wherever necessary
as follows:
Motor drives the progressive screw shaft using transmission system for axial
movement of material in screw press.
Experts: collection of inputs from technical experts on technologies for oil expelling.
Use of reverse screw flight at suitable position in the shaft increases retention
time.
Concept 1 comprises of use of existing method i.e. single screw expeller for oil
extraction from seeds.
This concept comprises of two screw shafts with the top shaft placed similar to
shaft in existing expeller. After material conveys through top shaft, it would move to
48
bottom shaft due to gravity. It is expected that material stays in the system for a longer
duration increasing yield. Schematic of this concept is as shown in Figure 3.5.
Hopper
Screw Shaft 1
Screw Shaft 2
Drive
Assembly
Twin screw expeller uses two intermeshing screws which exerts high pressure on
material for oil extraction from seed mass. This method is in use in various other
applications. 3D model and top view of meshing twin screws is as shown in Figure 3.6(a)
and (b) respectively.
49
Screw Shaft 1
Screw Shaft 2
Figure 3.6 (a) CAD Model of the Twin Screws of the Twin Screw Expeller
Screw Shaft 1
Shank
Screw Shaft 2
Figure 3.6 (b) Schematic Top View of the Twin Screws of the Twin Screw
Expeller
The above steps were reviewed in terms of productivity and oil yield for various
concepts developed.
50
It is the process of evaluating concepts with respect to needs and other criteria,
comparing the relative strengths and weaknesses of the concepts and selecting one or
more concepts for further investigation, testing or development. Thus number of concepts
would be narrowed down.
There are various methods for selection of a concept among many. The methods
vary in their effectiveness and include the following:
External Decision: Concepts are turned over to the customer or some other
external entity for selection.
Intuition: The concept is chosen by its feel. Explicit criteria are not used. The
concept just seems better.
This involves use of concept screening decision matrix. Following steps were
used during this process.
A simple table matrix was created and the inputs i.e. concepts and criteria were
entered on the matrix. The selection criteria were considered and listed along the left
hand side of the screening matrix.
A Relative score of ‘Better than’(+), ‘same as’(0), or ‘Worse than’(-) was placed
in each cell of the matrix to represent how each concept scores in comparison with the
reference concept for each criterion.
After rating the concepts, the number of ‘better than’, ‘same as’ and ‘worse than’
scores were summed up and the sum for each categories were entered in the lower rows
of the matrix. Next, the net score was calculated by subtracting the number of ‘worse
than’ ratings from the ‘better than’ ratings. Once the summation was completed, the
concepts were ranked based on the score. The concept screening matrix for the generated
concepts is shown in Table 3.1.
52
At this stage, there was a better understanding of each concept and its relative
merits. Thus decision was taken on selection of concepts for further refinement and
analysis. The number of concepts selected for further review would be limited depending
on the resources such as money, time and personnel. Consequently, concept 2 and 3 were
selected.
Based on the review of the results obtained from these steps, modified screw
expeller and twin screw expeller were taken up for further development as they are
promising concepts for mechanical extraction of oil.
Figure 3.7 (a) shows the modified single screw oil extraction setup. Figure 3.7 (b)
shows the detailed design of the modified single screw and Figure 3.7 (c) shows the 3D
assembly model of modified screw. The modified single screw has one thread of the
screw in the reverse direction. During the crushing process, seeds flow along the forward
screw path. When the material faces the reverse screw flight, some part of the material
gets pushed back. This increases the residence time of the seeds inside the barrel thus
53
increasing the crushing. A step down in the diameter at reverse section helps the seeds to
flow over the reverse screw. If the position of reverse flight of the screw is at the
discharge end, then it would lead to jamming of screw. If the reverse flight of the screw is
positioned towards the feeding end, then its effect is limited as expelling process takes
place at the cage bar assembly, located near discharge end. Thus, the reverse flight
section of the screw is positioned in the mid-section of the single screw.
Belt Drives
Reverse Thread
Oil Outlet
Figure 3.7 (a) Schematic of the Modified Single Screw Oil Extraction Setup
Figure 3.7 (b) Detailed Design of the Modified Screw for the Single Screw
Expeller
54
Reverse Screw
Feed Control
Hand Wheel
Figure 3.7 (c) 3D Assembly of Reverse Worm Screw Shaft
The designed worm shaft (Screw Conveyor) provided with a single reverse screw
thread near the discharge end was fabricated in VMC 850, a 4-axis CNC machine as
shown in Figure 3.8 (a). The screw thus fabricated is shown in Figure 3.8 (b).
Machining
using VMC
Work Piece
Tapered Shaft
Reverse Thread
Screw shaft in expeller was replaced with fabricated screw and trials were
conducted for expelling oil from pongamia seeds.
55
Splined to Shaft
Co-rotation
Conveying Elements
Counter-rotation
Conveying Elements
Kneading Elements
Thus rapid customization of the screw elements can be done to get good results.
Twin screw expellers are superior to single screw counterpart in the following aspects.
1. Set of screws inter-penetrate in a twin screw expeller. Also screw elements such
as kneading elements, reverse screw etc. can be configured to provide the required
force.
2. Processing parameters such as temperature, speed of screw and flow rate can be
altered leading to superior control of process in a twin screw expeller. Single
screw expellers have lower degree of control of process parameters.
3. Stroke of double screw exerts force on the feed while in single screw expellers
resistance between barrel and screw is used to exert force which could result in
slipping and surging.
4. Screw wear could be compensated by screw speed in a twin screw expeller which
is not possible in a single screw machine.
57
5. Screw flight of a shaft removes the particles of the feed from supplementary flight
in a twin screw expeller. Single screw expellers have dull spots wherein particles
not transmitted would stick to screw.
Higher productivity.
Easier maintenance.
For the purposes of the present study, twin screw extrusion process was evalauted
as an option for extration of oil from pongamia pinnata seeds considering it’s
advantages. Detailed design of the twin screw expeller used for oil expelling and twin
screw expeller used in this research is shown in Figure 3.11 (a) and (b) respectively.
58
Hopper
Feed Motor
Barrel
Drive
Assembly
Details of splined screw shaft and screw elements fixed on shaft for carrying out
oil extraction are shown in Figure 3.12 (a) and (b) respectively. Figure 3.13(a) and (b)
show the views of segmented barrels assembly with oil filter.
Material for both screw and barrel are alloy steel. They are subjected to hardening
and nitriding to resist corrosion and wear. Screw profile comprises of conveying,
kneading and reverse screw element segments. The segmented screws can be taken out of
spline shaft. Based on the process requirement, they can be rearranged. This gives
flexibility to arrange the elements as per requirement. The detail of the screw is as given
in Table 3.2.
Top View
Orthographic Views of the Oil Filter
Right
Views Side
of the View of Barrel, Oil Filter andFront
Assembly View
Oil Bin
Orthographic Views of the Assembly of Barrel, Oil Filter and Oil Bin
Barrel
Oil Filter
Oil Bin
SCREW DIA, mm Ø 40
ROOT DIAMETER, mm Ø 26
L/D 20
There are 5 barrel segments; barrel segment 1 does the function of feeding. Top
vent holes for removal of moisture are provided at barrel segments 3 and 4. Barrel
segments 2-5 are provided with heaters and oil filter plates at the bottom. A volumetric
feeder of screw type is integrated to expeller. The principle of this feeder is to deliver
constant volume of feed material using a screw shaft. Feeder comprises of a variable
drive AC motor and a gear box. Conveying elements move the material, while kneading
elements kneads the feed material. Reverse screw elements presses the feed material.
Figure 3.14 shows the conveying, kneading and reverse screw elements used in the
research. Table 3.3 list the screw elements adopted in the twin screw setup.
Conveying
Element Reverse Kneading
Element Elements
Figure 3.14 Conveying, Kneading and Reverse Screw Elements used in Twin
Screw Machine
64
Table 3.3 Screw Element details adopted in the Twin Screw Setup
SCREW PROFILE
RH SHAFT LH SHAFT
SCREW SCREW
SIZE BARREL SIZE
ELEMENTS ELEMENTS
15 mm SPACER 15 mm SPACER
Ø 40 X 54 SE(R) Ø 40 X 54 SE(L)
THROAT BARREL
Ø 40 X 54 SE(R) Ø 40 X 54 SE(L)
Ø 40 X 54 SE(R) Ø 40 X 54 SE(L)
Ø 40 X 54 SE(R) Ø 40 X 54 SE(L)
Ø 40 X 54 KBR Ø 40 X 54 KBL
Ø 40 X 36 KBR Ø 40 X 36 KBL
Ø 40 X 36 SE(R) Ø 40 X 36 SE(L)
VENT OPEN
Ø 40 X 27 SE(R) BARREL (OIL Ø 40 X 27 SE(L)
FILTER)
Ø 40 X 18 SEL Ø 40 X 18 SER
Ø 40 X 36 SE(R) Ø 40 X 36 SE(L)
Ø 40 X 36 KBR Ø 40 X 36 KBL
Ø 40 X 54 KB(R) Ø 40 X 54 KB(L)
Ø 40 X 54 KB(R) Ø 40 X 54 KB(L)
Ø 40 X 18 SER Ø 40 X 18 SEL
Ø 40 X 27 SEL Ø 40 X 27 SER
Ø 40 X 27 SE(R) Ø 40 X 27 SE(L)
OIL FILTER
Ø 40 X 12.8 SER Ø 40 X 12.8 SEL
65
Oil extraction using mechanical methods were successfully carried out. Further
innovative method of oil extraction using microwave radiation has been proposed.
The microwave oven used in this study is Sanyo EM-C6786V Microwave Oven
with the operating frequency of 2450 MHz [128]. The conceptual design of microwave
assisted oil extraction is as shown in 3.15 (a). The layout of the microwave assisted oil
extraction system developed is as shown in the Figure 3.15 (b). Pongamia pinnata seeds
when exposed to microwave radiation will get heated up due to the presence of polar oil
molecules. Due to intense heat, oil will vaporize. In the condenser, the oil vapors get
converted into oil by giving heat to the coolant flowing in the glass tube. The oil flows to
the vacuum flask and gets collected in it.
Model EM-C6786V
Dimensions (W x H x D),
Volume 30 X 10-3 m3
3.6.1.3 Condenser
A Graham condenser with spiral coil coolant jacket was used as shown in Figure
3.18. Spiral coils provide higher contact area. The inner coil ends can be connected to
hoses or glassware. Two ends of outer coil were connected to hoses for the flow of
coolant [129]. This is a counter flow condenser which has effectiveness higher than that
of a parallel flow condenser. Owing to the high temperature of oil vapours that need to be
condensed in the proposed system, counter flow condenser has been selected [130]. Also
Logarithmic Mean Temperature Difference for counter flow heat exchanger is more than
LMTD for parallel flow heat exchanger leading to higher heat transfer rate [131]. The
specifications of the coiled Graham condenser are as given in Table 3.5.
Exhaust Port
Cooling
Water Outlet
Cooling
Water Inlet
Vapour Inlet
Port
Figure 3.18 Coiled Graham Condenser (300 mm Jacket)
69
Cooling Jacket:
Outer Diameter 40 mm
Length 300 mm
Model PDF2-75
Power 373 W
It is glass conical flask with cork for air tightness [132]. There is an inlet at the
top for collection of condensed oil in the flask. A side bent tube is provided for
connection with diaphragm pump. Inlet piping was drawn into vacuum flask preventing
oil flow into membrane pump which could cause damage to pump. The conical flask used
in this study is shown in Figure 3.20.
71
2 holes were drilled at microwave oven’s top of as shown in Figure 3.21(a) for
tubing of 2-neck flask. Different sized rubber corks were used and necessary silicone tube
hoses were connected. Condenser was connected to flask for collection of oil mass. Other
side of suction was connected to diaphragm pump for creating the negative pressure
gradient in the system. Thus oil vapour from the 2-neck flask flows to condenser and oil
droplets gets collected in the suction flask. The system thus fabricated is shown in Figure
3.21(b).
Powdered seeds were placed in the 2-neck flask and kept in the microwave oven.
Power and duration was set and system was switched on. Due to microwave radiation,
temperature in the oven cavity increases resulting in release of oil vapour which flows to
the condenser due to pressure gradient formed by the diaphragm pump. Vapors of oil get
converted into liquid in the shell of the condenser by transferring heat to the flowing
coolant in the condenser’s glass tube. Finally oil gets collected in the vacuum flask
72
Hose Pipe
Outlet
to Condenser
Rubber Cork
Oven Top
Figure 3.21 (a) Connections on the Top Surface of the Microwave Oven
Graham Condenser
Microwave
Oven Diaphragm Pump
Suction Flask
Raw oil needs to be free of floating impurities and sediments. Oil needs to be
clear and unadulterated. External impurities getting into oil could add to process
difficulties. Hence oil produced was pumped through filter cloth of filter press for
separation of seed particles from the oil. Filter press shown in Figure 3.22 comprises of
six plates of 6” x 6”. 100 micron filter cloth is used in the oil filter press.
73
Oil Inlet
Filter
Cloth
3.8 Transesterification
Methanol
Recovery Tank
Catalytic
Reactor
Washing Unit
Esterification
Unit Transesterification
Unit
Temperature
Gauge
Pump
Mahua and calophyllum biodiesel were blended with diesel with 0%, 10%, 20%,
30%, 40%, 60%, 80% and 100% for comparison of performance results with pongamia
biodiesel blends with diesel in same proportions. The mahua and calophyllum seeds are
shown in Figure 3.24 and 3.25 respectively.
Viscosity of the fuel was measured using viscometer shown in Figure 3.26 (a).
Viscosity is the resistance to fluid flow at a given temperature. Kinematic viscosity takes
fluid density into account and is measured by noting the time taken for liquid flow
through the orifice of capillary tube under gravity. This time is directly converted to
kinematic viscosity by using a simple calibration constant for the tube. Flash point of the
fuel was found out using apparatus shown in Figure 3.26 (b). Density of the fuel was
measured using hydrometer shown in Figure 3.26 (c). Hydrometer is the instrument used
for measuring relative density. It is made of glass and contains a scale for direct
measurement.
Copper strip corrosion test is used to determine corrosion level caused by sulphur
and acidic compounds in the fuels on equipments containing copper and its compounds
(brass and bronze) which are sensitive to these compounds. For conduction of this test, as
per ASTM D130, the copper strip after polishing was immersed in biodiesel bath
contained in the bomb apparatus as shown in Figure 3.26 (d). The bomb apparatus in turn
was kept vertically in the water bath and water bath was heated for 3 hours at 50±1 C.
Then copper strip was removed and compared with standard to make sure that no rusting
or black spots were observed.
76
Water Bath
Heater
Temperature
Display
Viscometer Tube
Control Buttons
Handle
Stirrer
Temperature
Display
Biodiesel
Indicator Lamps
3.10 Summary
Oil was synthesized from seeds using mechanical methods and microwave
assisted method. Transesterification of oil was carried out for blending with diesel to
conduct engine performance tests.