Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Digital Simulation of Industrial Fluid Catalytic Cracking Units: Bifurcation and Its Implications
Digital Simulation of Industrial Fluid Catalytic Cracking Units: Bifurcation and Its Implications
Digital Simulation of Industrial Fluid Catalytic Cracking Units: Bifurcation and Its Implications
00
Printed m Great Britain. C 1990 Pcrgamon Press plc
S. S. ELSHISHINI
Chemical Engineering Department, College of Engineering, Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt
and
S. S. E. H. ELNASHAIE+
Chemical Engineering Department, College of Engineering, King Saud University, Riyadh, PO Box 800,
Saudi Arabia
Abstract-The mathematical model for fluid catalytic cracking units developed earlier (Elnashaie, S. S. E. H.
and El-Hennawi, I. M., 1979, Chem. Engng Sci. 34, 1113-1121) has been used, after introducing some
modifications, to simulate two industrial units. The model results were found to be in good agreement with
the plant data. It was found that the plants operate at the middle unstable steady state and that the yield can
be increased to its maximum value by manipulating some of the operating variables. A parametric study has
been conducted to investigate the effect of some parameters on the operating middle steady states,
bifurcation behaviour and gasoline yield.
‘Author to whom all correspondence should be addressed. The reaction network, kinetic rate constants and
On leave from the Chemical Engineering Department, Cairo heats of reaction are given below (Weekman, 1968,
University, Cairo, Egypt. 1969; Weekman and Nate, 1970; El-Hennawi, 1977):
553
554 S. S. ELSHISHINI and S. S. E. H. ELNASHAIE
k,
f
1
(- AH,) = [4100 + f0,100(CO,/CO, + CO) (1 -x1 -x,)(1 - CORR)
+ 3370(H/C)] x 2.326 kJ/kg MG
(6) Excess air is used in the regenerator. The two industrial fluid catalytic crackers con-
sidered are of the model IV type (with U-bends). The
MODEL DEVELOPMENT two units vary in input parameters which lead to
The modeldeveloped earlier by Elnashaie and El- different output parameters. Table 1 gives the plant
Hennawi (1979) is used after introducing the following data for the two commercial FCC units. Additional
modifications into it: plant data common to both units are given in Table 2.
(1) The volumetric gas flow rates in regenerator and SIMULATION PROCEDURE
reactor are taken as the average between the inlet and The model was fitted to the first FCC unit using
outlet values. In the regenerator, the increase in the correction factors for the frequency factors. The modi-
number of moles is due to incomplete oombustion of C fied frequency factors k’,,, = l.Sk,,, k;, = OSk,,, k;,
Digital simulation of industrial fluid catalytic cracking units 555
Unit 1 Unit 2
2.5 k,,. Of course, these correction factors will vary It is clear from Table 3 and Fig. l(a) and (b) that
fyom one catalyst to another, depending upon the type both units are operating at the middle unstable steady
of catalyst, its activity, age and the type of feedstock state and both are not operating at their maximum
used as well as the combined feed ratio (Farag and gasoline yield.
Tsai, 1987). To make sure that these correction factors
are not just empirical numbers that fit only this
FCC unit at these specific operating conditions, the Parametric study
model, with the correction factors, has been used The units being operated at the middle unstable
without any modifications to simulate the second steady state, it is expected that the steady-state re-
FCC unit which has a very similar catalyst with sponse of the system to variation in operating con-
almost the same activity and age and a very similar ditions will be somewhat unusual as has been shown
feedstock. previously (Elnashaie et al., 1972; Elnashaie and El-
The success of this second simulation ensures to a Bialy, 1980) for a much simpler system. Therefore, a
large extent that the developed model is a reasonably detailed parametric investigation of the unit was
general representation of these FCC units. However, carried out using the present model, in order to gain a
the catalyst activity should be regularly checked to deeper insight info the behaviour of this rather com-
ensure the validity of the pre-exponential factors used plex system. It is obvious that the optimization prob-
in the simulation. lem in the neighbourhood of the unstable middle
steady state will be different from that in the neigh-
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION bourhood of the stable high-temperature steady state.
Comparison of model results with plant data There will also be an obvious trading between the
Figure l(a) shows the heat function vs reactor tem- gasoline yield of the system and its stability, i.e., in
perature for units 1 and 2 and Fig. l(b) shows the some cases, higher yields correspond to an operating
corresponding unreacted gas oil (x1) and gasoline point closer to the critical bifurcation point.
yield (x2). Table 3 gives the values of the output The parametric study is simplified by the fact that
variables obtained from the model results and from the x1, x2 vs Y diagrams do not change with variations
plant data for units 1 and 2. It is clear that the in F,, YfO or Ylc; the only changes being in the
agreement is quite good. operating temperatures of the reactor and regener-
The simulation can be improved if more accurate ator. For any operating temperature the correspond-
kinetic data are provided for the same kinetic scheme ing x1 and x2 can be obtained from the same curves
and can be improved further if the kinetic scheme was [Fig. l(b)]. The parametric investigation presented
extended to include separate routes for the formation here will be confined to FCC unit 1 with its xl, x2 vs Y
of coke and light gases. diagram shown in Fig. l(b).
556 S. S. ELSHISHINI and S. S. E. H. ELNASHAIE
5 2.0-
EfSects of gas oilfeed temperature. Figure 2(b) shows
k that for the middle steady state the increase in the gas
x
oil feed temperature (Y,,) from 450 to 527 to 539 K
causes the dimensionless reactor temperature to de-
crease from I.76 to 1.56 to 1.07. This increase in YIG
causes a decrease in conversion and an increase in
gasoline yield (x2) from 0.314, to 0.3857 to 0.3971
[Fig. l(b)]. The opposite response of the middle steady
state compared to the response of the other steady
Vaporization t*mp states is again evident.
ot 90s oil
4.C)-
INDUSTAIAC UNIT 1
0.80
2.CI-
0.c )-
- 2.1Il-
Vaporization temp.
- 4.t .
0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.c:-
-.-.- TtG : 450 ‘K
D1MENSIONLESS REACTOR TEMPERATURE(Y)
----- TtG = 527 OK
_ T,G = 539 ‘K
Fig. 1. (a) Heat function for units 1 and 2; (b) conversion and 2.CI-
gasoline yield for units 1 and 2.
0.CI-
Effect of catalyst circulation rate. Figure 2(a) shows
that, for the middle steady state, the reactor temper-
ature (Y) decreases from 1.75 to 1.56 to 1.5 as the
catalyst circulation rate (F,) increases from 44.302 to - 2.t I-
88.605 to 177.21 kg/s. The corresponding conversion
(1 - x1) decreases while the corresponding gasoline
Vaporization tcmp-of gas oil
yield (x2) increases from 0.314 to 0.385 to 0.41 - 4.1 I_ I/- l I
[Fig. l(b)]. It is clear from Fig. 2(a) and (b) that the 0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00
response of the middle steady state to the change in DIMENSIONLESS REACTOR TEMPERATURE(Y)
any parameter is opposite to the response of the other
steady states (Elnashaie et al., 1972). This fact is of Fig. 2. (a) Effect of catalyst circulation rate on heat function
great importance with respect to the optimization and for unit 1; (b) effect of gas oil feed temperature on heat
control of FCC units and will be discussed in full detail function for unit 1.
4.0
-.-,- Da = 0.1 m
---- 0;~ 0.2m
_---
Fc z88.605 kg/s
2
(a)
L I
-.-.- 0 8’ 0.1 m
---_ Dg = 0.2 m
- De = 0.3m
3 (b)
F, ~88.605 kg Is
(d)
.--.-.
- --_-‘=-_~~-_.,._.~.-._.,
-6,
I
Fig. 3. (a) Effect of catalyst circulation rate on the bifurcation diagram of Y vs Y,,; (b) effect of catalyst
circulation rate on the bifurcation diagram of X, vs Y,,; (c)effect of D, on the bifurcation diagram of Y, vs
Y,,; (d) effect of D, on the bifurcation diagram of X,, vs Y,, (1 = low-temperature steady state, 2 = middle
steady state, 3 = high-temperature steady state).
558 S. S. ELSHISHINI and S. S. E. H. ELNASHAIE
Efict of Da on the bf&rcation behaviour. In the conditions of maximum gasoline yield and suggestions
developed model the bubble diameter was taken as a have been given to improve the gasoline yield without
constant value throughout the bed and is calculated getting into a formal optimization investigation yet.
from (Fryer and Potter, 1972)
D,=
(u - Um,)ffm,
(H - H,,)0.711 gi” 1’ cso
NOTATION
and was found to be 0.1 m. For this bubble diameter gasoline, respectively, in output
(and smaller) the dense-phase conditions and the stream, kg/m3
conditions at the exit of the bubble phase are quite concentration of gas oil and gasoline,
close. However, for larger bubble diameters, the dif- respectively, in the dense phase of the
ference is appreciable. The effect of bubble diameter reactor, kg/m3
on bifurcation is investigated to measure the sensit- c Al/V C.42, concentration of gas oil and gasoline,
ivity of the system to bubble diameter and the pos- respectively, in input stream, kg/m3
sible need to incorporate more rigorous means of CFR combined feed ratio, total feed/fresh
calculating an average value for the bubble diameter feed
or the need to take bubble size variation along the DL? bubble diameter, m
height of the reactor. Figure 3(c) and (d) show the HCO heavy cycle oil, kg/s
bifurcation diagrams for the dense phase for different H, H,, bed height (expanded and at mini-
average bubble sizes. Figure 3(c) shows the increase in mum fluidization), m
the range of the multiplicity region as D, increases KC rate constant for coke combustion re-
whereas Fig. 3(d) shows the corresponding gasoline action, m3/kmol s
yield. It is clear that the system is quite sensitive to K,, K,, K, rate constants for reactions 1
bubble diameter. For the middle steady state, as D, (m3/kg s), 2 (l/s) and 3 (m3/kgs)
increases from 0.1 to 0.2 the gasoline yield in the dense LCO light cycle oil, kg/s
phase increases also, but a further increase to D, = 0.3 Rc coke make rate (@[a,~: exp
causes a decrease in the dense-phase gasoline yield. ( - ~4 Y) + azX2 exp ( - r2l VII
For the high-temperature steady state as D, increases gas constant, kJ/kgmol K
xZD decreases. The effect of D, on the bifurcation reactor dense phase temperature, K
behaviour based on the exit reactor conditions (dense air and gas oil feed temperature, re-
phase + bubble phase) is quite complex and will be spectively, K
discussed in a forthcoming paper dealing entirely with reactor and regenerator temperature,
the effect of hydrodynamic parameters on the per- respectively, K
formance of FCC units. T,,, To reference temperature and gas oil
An improvement in the model simulation of the vaporization temperature, respect-
industrial units can be achieved by obtaining a more ively, K
accurate experimental estimate of the average bubble u superficial gas velocity in the bed, m/s
size. Taking into consideration bubble variation along u m/ minimum fluidization velocity, m/s
the height of the bed will complicate the model Xl, X2 exit dimensionless concentration of
considerably and is not expected to affect the predic- gas oil and gasoline (x, = CR,/CA,/,
tion of the model in comparison with a model using a X 2 = CAZICAl/~
good estimate of constant average bubble size (Fryer XlDI XZD dimensionless reactor concentrations
and Potter, 1972). of gas oil and gasoline, respectively, in
dense phase
Xl/Y x2.f dimensionless concentration of gas
oil and gasoline in the feed
CONCLUSIONS
XL3 amount of coke burnt/total amount of
The model developed has proved to simulate the coke
industrial data quite well. It was found that the reactor y, y, exit reactor and regenerator dimen-
is operated at the middle unstable steady state for both sionless temperature, respectively (Y
industrial FCC units investigated. The verified model = T.sIT,/, YG = TG/TrI)
has been used in a parametric investigation that has YD reactor dense phase dimensionless
shown that the response of the middle steady state to temperature (TJT,,)
variation in the input parameters is opposite to that of y/mY” dimensionless air feed temperature
the high-temperature steady state. The bifurcation and gas oil vaporization temperature,
investigation has shown that the multiplicity region is respectively
quite large and has uncovered the regions of sensitivity heat of reaction for the cracking reac-
near the bifurcation points. It has been shown that the tions, kJ/kg
commercial units are not operating at their optimum heat of combustion of coke, kJ/kg
Digital simulation of industrial fluid catalytic cracking units 559