Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ethics+ +Law+Webinar+& 40 ONLINE+COPY& 41
Ethics+ +Law+Webinar+& 40 ONLINE+COPY& 41
Webinar
Common Ethics & Law
Question Topics
Gifts
Fraser guidelines Confidentiality
Gillick competence Coroner referral
Section 2/3/4/5/136 Consent to treatment
Jehovah’s Witness Refusal of treatment
DVLA restrictions Privacy
Child protection
Death certificates
The General Medical Council (GMC) sets out good medical practice
guidance for doctors.
Which ethical principle means promoting what is in the patient’s
best interests?
A. Autonomy
B. Beneficence
C. Non‐maleficence
D. Justice
E. Judicial precedent
The General Medical Council (GMC) sets out good medical practice
guidance for doctors.
Which ethical principle means promoting what is in the patient’s
best interests?
A. Autonomy
B. Beneficence
C. Non‐maleficence
D. Justice
E. Judicial precedent
Good Medical Practice: Ethical Principles
(blood or food)
A 14 year old girl comes requesting emergency contraception. Her
current sexual partner is 15 years old. She does not want her
parents to know she is sexually active.
What is the SINGLE most appropriate action?
● Section 136
● Section 2
● Section 3
● Section 4
● Section 5 (2)
● Section 5 (4)
The Mental Health Act (1983)
Evoked to treat psychiatric illness in non‐consenting patients.
● Applied by police
● Lasts 72hrs
The Mental Health Act (1983)
Evoked to treat psychiatric illness in non‐consenting patients.
• Lasts 72 hours
• 72 hours duration
• Lasts 6 hours
The Mental Health Act (1983)
Evoked to treat psychiatric illness in non‐consenting patients.
• 28 days duration
If she can’t remember you or the conversation you had does she still have capacity?
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 defines lack of capacity in the following way:
Five principles:
1) Everyone has capacity until it is established that they lack it
2) You must do everything you can to facilitate decision making
3) A person should not be judged to lack capacity because they make an unwise
decision
4) An act/decision done under the act must be in their best interests
5) It must be least restrictive to their rights and freedoms
Mental capacity
Capacity is about the ability to take a particular decision at the time it needs to be
taken. It is decision-specific and time-specific.
Mental capacity
If she can’t remember you or the conversation you had does she still have
capacity?
Capacity is about the ability to take a particular decision at the time it needs to be
taken. It is decision-specific and time-specific.
Mental capacity
● When they meet the criteria laid out in the advanced decision - these may be
quite specific
Advanced decisions
Verbally vs written?
Advanced decisions
In this case
Confidentiality
1) With consent
2) Disclosure is to the benefit of a patient that lacks capacity
3) Required by law
4) In the public interest
Confidentiality
There are lots of laws that require disclosure - infectious disease, social care,
terrorism, road traffic act, gun/knife crimes
HOWEVER you should be satisfied it is required by law and only disclose relevant
information
Yes - in this case you should gauge if disclosure is in their best interests e.g.
disclosure for social care
This section of the Data Protection act means that information can be disclosed in
certain circumstances but does not compel disclosure
A 29 year old man is admitted to ITU with severe hypoxia for mechanical
ventilation. He is found to be HIV positive and is diagnosed with Pneumocystis
jirovecii pneumonia following a bronchoalveolar lavage. Despite full medical
therapy he dies. You are asked to complete his death certificate. His boyfriend, a
law student, comes to see you and begs you not to put HIV on his death certificate
as his family did not know he was gay. He says he knows the patient would not
want his family to know and you’re meant to keep things confidential. That
shouldn’t have changed just because he is dead. How should you proceed?
A. Refer to the Coroner
B. Complete his death certificate: 1a) Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia
C. Complete his death certificate:
1a) Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia, 1b) human immunodeficiency virus
D. Complete his death certificate:
1a) Human immunodeficiency virus, 1b) Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia
E. Inform his family of his diagnosis before completing the death certificate
A 29 year old man is admitted to ITU with severe hypoxia for mechanical
ventilation. He is found to be HIV positive and is diagnosed with Pneumocystis
jirovecii pneumonia following a bronchoalveolar lavage. Despite full medical
therapy he dies. You are asked to complete his death certificate. His boyfriend, a
law student, comes to see you and begs you not to put HIV on his death
certificate as his family did not know he was gay. He says he knows the patient
would not want his family to know and you’re meant to keep things confidential.
That shouldn’t have changed just because he is dead. How should you proceed?
A. Refer to the Coroner
B. Complete his death certificate: 1a) Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia
C. Complete his death certificate:
1a) Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia, 1b) human immunodeficiency virus
D. Complete his death certificate:
1a) Human immunodeficiency virus, 1b) Pneumocystis jirovecii pneumonia
E. Inform his family of his diagnosis before completing the death certificate
Death Certification
2) contributing conditions
Which of these is NOT a reason to refer to the Coroner?
Or more briefly:
● You don’t know why they died
● You haven’t seen them in the last 14 days
OR you haven’t seen their body
● Situational - violent, accident, suicide, neglect, industrial
● Operative - post-op or related to a termination of pregnancy
● Retained against their will - Police custody, MCA, MHA, DOLS
A 46 year old man has been seen by you in the oncology outpatient
department a number of times. He has completed his treatment and
you inform him that his follow up imaging is disease free. He is
extremely grateful and offers you a designer watch as a gift.
What is the SINGLE most appropriate action?
You should refuse gifts where they could be perceived as an abuse of trust,
and must not put pressure on patients or their families to make donations to
other people or organisations.
● Seizures + epilepsy
A. 3 months
B. 6 months
C. 12 months
D. 18 months
E. Ban from driving
A 28-year-old woman has a tonic-clonic seizure lasting 3 minutes.
This is her first seizure, which does not appear to have been
precipitated by an acute event. Serum electrolytes, an ECG and CT
head are normal. How long should the patient refrain from driving?
A. 3 months
B. 6 months
C. 12 months
D. 18 months
E. Ban from driving
DISEASE CAR LICENCE HGV LICENCE
First unprovoked 6 months if fit 5 years if risk of
seizure with a low rate free/medical review recurrence is <2% per
of recurrence annum
6 months during
treatment changes
DISEASE CAR LICENCE HGV LICENCE
Epilepsy 1 year if fit free / medical 10 years if fit free off
(2 or more seizures) review medication
DISEASE CAR LICENCE HGV LICENCE
Acute Coronary 1 month if untreated 6 weeks if symptom free
Syndrome and no inducible
1 week if treated with ischaemia on exercise
stent and normal LV tolerance test
DISEASE CAR LICENCE HGV LICENCE
Insulin-controlled Notify DVLA may drive if Banned
diabetes mellitus no visual impairment
and aware of
hypoglycaemia
Other ethical scenarios
Complaints
Your Questions
Quick Tips:
Child (<18 years) can’t choose to die
Thank you
GOOD LUCK!!!