Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Temperature Measurement When High Speed Machining Hardened Mould/die Steel
Temperature Measurement When High Speed Machining Hardened Mould/die Steel
Abstract
When turning and face milling hardened (>30 HRC) mould/die steels, it is necessary to use conventional ceramic or polycrystalline cubic
boron nitride (PCBN) tool materials. The use of high speed steel and cemented tungsten carbide (WC) tooling for this application is
precluded due to their relatively low hot hardness values. In recent years, however, the mould and die industry has begun to utilise solid WC
ball nose end mills for the high speed machining (HSM) of hardened steel cavities. Economic tool lives have been reported at high
rotational speeds/feed rates.
The paper details the use of 6 mm diameter solid, TiCN coated WC ball nose end mills for the HSM of a hot work tool steel, AISI H13,
hardened to 52 HRC. Tests were performed on a Matsuura 20 000 rpm high speed machining centre and temperatures were measured using
thermocouple and infrared techniques. Recorded tool /workpiece interface and chip temperatures were relatively low (200±4008C) and
increased with higher cutting speed, when using worn rather than new tools and with the workpiece inclined at 608 to simulate ®nishing
operations on the side of die cavities. # 1999 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.
Keywords: High speed machining; Temperature measurement; Tool steel; Tungsten carbide
1.1. High speed machining Salomon [1] proposed that there was a peak cutting
temperature at an intermediate cutting speed and that when
High speed machining (HSM) was ®rst reported in 1931 cutting speed was increased from this point, there was a
by Salomon [1]. One de®nition is that the process ``involves reduction in temperature, see Fig. 1(a). Since this claim,
machining at considerably higher cutting speeds and feed most of the literature has concluded that there is no corre-
rates than those used in conventional machining'', however, sponding reduction in temperature at higher cutting speeds.
it is most commonly used to describe end milling at high McGee [7] suggested that temperature increased with
rotational speeds. The process has been adapted to a wide cutting speed up to a maximum which was equal to the
range of applications. In the aerospace sector, HSM is used melting point of the workpiece, see Fig. 1(b). No tem-
to remove large volumes of aluminium quickly and to perature reduction occurred at higher cutting speeds.
produce thin walled sections in wings [2±4]. This explains why there is no ®xed limit to the cutting
One of the more recent applications of HSM is in the speed when machining aluminium alloys (other than
manufacture of moulds and dies from hardened tool steels that imposed by machine tool considerations). The melting
[5,6]. Cavities can be produced from solid in the hardened point of these alloys (up to 6608C) is lower than the
state using HSM, rather than via the more traditional route: temperature at which cemented carbide and ceramic tool
machining in the soft condition followed by electrical dis- materials begin to lose their strength and wear rapidly.
charge machining (EDM), grinding and/or hand ®nishing. Conversely, Trent [8] stated that ``it is in the cutting
of iron, steel and other high melting point metals and
*Corresponding author. Tel.: +44-121-414-4175; fax: +44-121-414-
alloys that the heat generated becomes a controlling factor''.
3541 Here the limit on cutting speed is a function of the cutting
E-mail address: r.c.dewes@bham.ac.uk (R.C. Dewes) tools used.
0924-0136/99/$ ± see front matter # 1999 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 9 2 4 - 0 1 3 6 ( 9 9 ) 0 0 1 1 6 - 8
294 R.C. Dewes et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 92±93 (1999) 293±301
Fig. 1. Graphs of temperature vs. cutting speed: (a) Salomon's curve; (b) McGee's curve.
Fig. 2. Machining sequence when using the implanted workpiece thermocouple [12].
Fig. 3. Agema Thermovision 900 system with IR camera (right) and Fig. 4. Sandvik 1020, 6 mm diameter TiCN coated carbide cutter.
system controller (left).
because the tool/workpiece interface is obscured. Errors can coated with titanium carbonitride, TiCN). Consequently,
also result as a consequence of using an incorrect emisivity 6 mm diameter 1020 tools, shown in Fig. 4, were used
value. for the present work. Cutters had four ¯utes with a positive
When using high speed steel or WC tools with an iron/ helix angle of 308. A tool overhang from the collet of 30 mm
silicon binder, phase transformations in the tool material can was employed.
be used to deduce the temperature to which the tool has been The workpiece material used was AISI H13 hot work tool
subjected and produce isothermal maps [15]. Optical micro- steel at a hardness of 52 HRC. It was obtained with a
scopy is utilised to compare sections of the cutting tool with chemical composition of 0.38% C, 1.00% Si, 0.34% Mn,
standard specimens. The disadvantages of this method 5.00% Cr, 1.3% Mo and Fe balance. Not surprisingly, AISI
include the limited types of cutting tool materials that can H13 is not a standard thermocouple material categorised
be used and the manufacture of standard specimens which under British Standard BS1041, therefore, a calibration bar
must be very carefully prepared. was designed, see Fig. 5. For the machining trials, a work-
The aim of the present work was to determine cutting piece block 80mm55mm35 mm was electrical discharge
temperatures when high speed ball nose end milling har- wire machined into two separate pieces as shown in Fig. 6.
dened die steel, in order to explain the successful use of The design allowed insertion of thermocouple wires in the
tungsten carbide (WC) cutters for this operation. Tempera- gap while giving suf®ciently high clamping force to hold the
tures were measured using the workpiece/Te¯on-coated assembly in place during machining.
constantan thermocouple and infrared techniques previously Two diameters (0.075 and 0.5 mm) of Te¯on-coated
outlined. constantan wire were obtained from Omega Engineering,
2. Experimental
rejected. It was decided that the most suitable heating machine was not equipped with in®nitely variable table
method was to use an oxygen±acetylene torch. feeds. By looping the thermocouple wire in the manner
shown in Fig. 7, each test was effectively replicated a
2.3. Equipment ± infrared technique number of times.
Tests on the Matsuura machining centre involved both the
Equipment consisted of an IR camera and a system thermocouple and infrared techniques, see Table 2. All tests
controller, see Fig. 3, borrowed from the UK's Engineering were performed using the thermocouple technique, however,
and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC). The due to limited equipment availability, the infrared technique
controller was a dedicated microcomputer set up speci®cally was limited to tests 5 ± 10. Resources did not allow a full
for use with the camera. It consisted of a processor unit, factorial experiment to be performed, therefore, it was felt
VGA video monitor, mouse and keyboard with specialised that most information could be gained in the time available
system controls for image handling. The software was menu by investigating four variables: cutting speed (tests 1 ± 3),
driven and was contained in a windows environment. The tool wear (tests 3 ± 10), angle of the workpiece (tests 3 ± 6)
camera was designed to operate at wavelengths in the infra- and axial/radial depth of cut. In order to simulate the actual
red spectrum (8±12 m). The temperature ranges selected machining of a mould or die cavity, the workpiece was
for this work were 0±2508C and 100±6008C. The emissivity clamped both horizontally and at 608 to the horizontal while
level used was 0.82. Interchangeable lenses were available maintaining a constant cutting speed by varying the rota-
for the use with the scanner. In this case, a 408x208 resolution tional speed. Fig. 9 illustrates the interface cutting speed at
lens was used which had a minimum focal length of 0.3 m. workpiece angles 08 and 608 when using a 0.5 mm depth of
cut. Table 2 classi®es roughing, semi-®nishing and ®nishing
2.4. Machining parameters cuts depending on the depth of cut applied. During all tests,
dry cutting was employed and feed was ®xed at 0.1 mm/
In the tests on the Cincinnati milling machine, only the tooth.
thermocouple technique was used. Fixed parameters
included the angle of workpiece (08), down/climb milling, 2.5. Experimental procedure ± thermocouple technique
dry machining, use of a tool with 0.3 mm maximum ¯ank
wear and an axial/radial depth of cut of 0.5 mm. The effect The calibration experiment involved a number of steps.
of feed per tooth and cutting speed were evaluated, see The 0.075 mm diameter thermocouple wire was silver sol-
Table 1. Feed per tooth values are approximate because the dered into hole A on the calibration bar, see Fig. 5. The bar
Table 1
Test parameters on the Cincinnati milling machine
Table 2
Test parameters on the Matsuura machining centre
Fig. 11. Calibration results and equations for multimeter and oscilloscope.
Fig. 13. The effect of workpiece angle and tool wear on interface
temperature. Fig. 14. Effect of axial and radial depth of cut on interface temperature.
300 R.C. Dewes et al. / Journal of Materials Processing Technology 92±93 (1999) 293±301
4. Conclusions
[9] M.P. Groover, G.E. Kane, A continuing study in the determination of [16] R.C. Dewes, D.K. Aspinwall, High speed machining of hardened tool
temperatures in metal cutting using remote thermocouples, J. Eng. steel using cemented carbide tooling, in: Proceedings of the Third
Ind. (Trans. ASME) 93(2) (1971) 603±608. International Conference on Progress of Cutting and Grinding,
[10] A.H. Redford, B. Mills, S. Akhtar, Temperature - tool life relation- Osaka, Japan, vol. 3, (1996) pp. 217±222.
ships for resulphurised low carbon free machining steels, CIRP [17] P.M. Braiden, The calibration of tool/work thermocouples, Proc. in:
Annals 25(1) (1976) 89±91. Proceedings of the Eighth International MTDR Conference,
[11] P. Lezanski, M.C. Shaw, Tool face temperatures in high speed Manchester, UK, Perganon, Oxford, (1967), pp. 653±666.
milling, J. Eng. Ind. (Trans. ASME) 112(2) (1990) 132±135. [18] G. Barrow, A review of experimental and theoretical techniques for
[12] W. Chen, A report of the research on surface integrity of hardened assessing cutting temperature, CIRP Annals 22(2) (1973) 203.
steel following face milling, School of Manuf. and Mech. Eng., [19] B.T. Chao, K.J. Trigger, An analytical evaluation of metal cutting
University of Birmingham, UK, (1994). temperatures, Trans. ASME, 73, (1951) p. 57.
[13] G. Boothroyd, Temperatures in orthogonal metal cutting, Proc. Instn. [20] R.C. Dewes, D.K. Aspinwall et al., Tool wear and surface integrity
Mech. Engrs. 177(29) (1963) 789±802. observations during the high speed milling of hardened die steel, in:
[14] J.P. Kottenstette, Measuring tool-chip interface temperatures, J. Eng. Proceedings of the International Conference on Design and
Ind. (Trans. ASME) 108(2) (1986) 101±104. Production of Dies and Moulds, Istanbul, Turkey, (1997).
[15] P.A. Dearnley, E.M. Trent, Wear mechanisms of coated carbide tools,
Metals Technology, 9 (1982) 60±75.