Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Modelo de Rev
Modelo de Rev
PII: S0049-0172(18)30254-3
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.semarthrit.2018.07.010
Reference: YSARH 51378
Please cite this article as: Anaı̈s Dartevel , Benjamin Chaigne , Laurence Moachon ,
Florian Grenier , Nicolas Dupin , Loı̈c Guillevin , Laurence Bouillet , Luc Mouthon , Levamisole-
induced vasculopathy: a systematic review, Seminars in Arthritis & Rheumatism (2018), doi:
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.semarthrit.2018.07.010
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service
to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo
copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please
note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and
all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Anaïs Dartevel1,2, Benjamin Chaigne1, Laurence Moachon3, Florian Grenier4, Nicolas Dupin5,
systémiques autoimmunes rares d’Ile de France, DHU Authors (Autoimmune and Hormonal
T
Paris (AP-HP), Paris, France;
IP
2
Service de Médecine Interne, Centre national de référence des angiœdème (CREAK),
CR
Universités des Alpes-Grenoble 1, 38041 Grenoble, France;
3
US
Service de Pharmacologie, Hôpital Cochin, AP-HP, and Université Paris Descartes,
Hôpital Cochin,
27, rue du Faubourg Saint-Jacques,
75679 Paris Cedex 14, France.
CE
Abstract
Methods. We performed a systematic review searching MEDLINE for articles published from
1972 to 2016.
Results. We retrieved 357 references and abstracts and selected 111 articles. Levamisole-
induced vasculopathy was reported in 192 patients, with a female predominance (n=122,
63.5%). Median [interquartile range] age was 44 [38-50]. Skin was the most frequently
involved organ (n=182, 94.8%). Cutaneous lesions were mostly on the face (n=136, 70.8%),
T
especially the ears. Purpura (n=131, 68.2%) was the most reported cutaneous lesion. Organ
IP
involvement included acute renal failure (n=24, 12.5%), and pulmonary involvement (n=20,
CR
10.4%). Anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies (ANCAs) were found in 167/178 patients
US
patients (43.2%). Anti-phospholipid (APL) antibodies were found in 93/137 patients (67.9%).
AN
Leukopenia was detected in 69/138 patients (50%). Skin biopsies identified vasculitis and
thrombotic vasculopathy in 73/148 (49.3%) and 62/148 (41.9%) patients, respectively. The
M
outcome was favourable in 116/134 patients (86.6%), but relapses were reported in 33
skin involvement, ANCA and/or APL antibody positivity, leukopenia, vasculitis or vascular
PT
2
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Introduction
States as an anthelmintic agent. Because of its immunomodulatory properties, it was also used
arthritis, and solid tumors. Levamisole was withdrawn from the market in the United States in
2000 and in Canada in 2003 because of side effects including agranulocytosis, vasculitis and
T
leukoencephalopathy [1-3]. It is still used in veterinary clinics in the United States and South
IP
America.
CR
Since 2003, levamisole has also been used to adulterate cocaine. Levamisole reduces the cost
of cocaine preparation [4] and increases the release of norepinephrine in peripheral tissues
US
and dopamine in the brain thereby improving neurotransmission in the central nervous system
AN
[5, 6] and increasing the effects and duration of cocaine [5,7]. Furthermore, aminorex, an
increasing. In the United States, levamisole has been detected in 70% of cocaine seized by
customs in 2009 [10] and up to 88% of urine samples of cocaine users [11,12]. In Europe
ED
also, levamisole has been increasingly found in 85.3% of cocaine lots [13]. More recently, in
with cocaine intake have been reported since 2003, thereby implicating levamisole in the
occurrence of these symptoms [15-18]. Indeed, when levamisole was used as a medical
AC
treatment, side effects such as vasculopathy and/or autoimmune manifestations were reported
in 0.5% to 3% of patients [19,20,21]. These side effects were mainly purpura and/or
3
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
with levamisole intake, both as adverse events following its use as a drug or as a result of its
immunological and histological aspects as well as prognosis and treatment of this condition.
T
Selection of articles
IP
We searched MEDLINE via PubMed for articles of research, with no restriction on language
CR
or publication type, that were published from January 1977 to July 2016 and investigated the
US
and between cocaine and purpura, vasculitis, or ANCAs. For articles reporting levamisole
AN
consumption as a cocaine adulterant, only those published after December 2002 were selected
because cocaine was adulterated with levamisole only after 2003. Articles reporting vascular
M
myocardial infarction because cocaine is directly responsible for these complications, which
were reported long before 2003. Other exclusion criteria were lack of clinical information,
PT
Data collection
For all articles included, we collected data with a standardized form, including age, sex, past
AC
(group 2).
4
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Statistical analyses
Data are reported as number (%) or median (interquartile range [IQR]). Statistical analysis
involved using GraphPad Prism 6 (GraphPad, La Jolla, CA, USA). Differences between
patient groups were compared by Student t test for continuous data and Fischer exact test for
categorical data. All tests were two-sided, with p <0.05 considered statistically significant.
T
Results
IP
Selection of articles
CR
Among the 357 articles retrieved, 126 were selected on the basis of the abstract (118 in
English, 7 in Spanish and 1 in Italian) (Figure 1). We excluded 22 articles associated with
US
cocaine consumption and 5 to hematological complications. A further 15 were excluded
AN
for insufficient clinical data or already reported (n=9) or unclear cause of vasculitis or
vasculopathy etiology (n=6). Overall, 111 articles were selected for the analysis, reporting
M
193 patients including one reported in 2 separate manuscripts. One of the cases reported in a
Characteristics of patients
individual of unreported sex), mostly children with nephrotic syndrome. Median [IQR] age
was 11 [10-31]. Symptoms appeared between 1 and 44 months after the initiation of
AC
levamisole. All patients were on levamisole at the time of symptom onset, except one who
Group 2 (recreational consumption) consisted of 179 patients (116 females, 54 males and 9
individuals of unreported sex). Median [IQR] age was 45 [40-50]. Data on cocaine
consumption modality were not available for 96 patients. Various cocaine consumption
5
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
32.6%), crack and intranasal administration (n=1/83, 1.2%) and intravenous administration
(n=1/83, 1.2%).
Among patients in group 2, cocaine was detected in 95/105 (90.5%); in urine for 85 (89.5%)
and in hair for 2 (2.1%), with no mention of the type of sample tested for 8 (8.4%). In group
T
2, 45/54 patients (83.3%) were positive for levamisole, detected in urine or serum for 37
IP
(82.2%), in the cocaine lot for 5 (1.1%) and in hair for 2 (4.4%). One patient who was initially
CR
negative for levamisole was positive during follow-up.
US
The most frequent clinical symptoms, related to skin involvement, were observed in 182
AN
patients (94.8%). Skin lesions were mainly purpura (n= 131, 68.2%), which were necrotic or
retiform. Other skin lesions were necrosis without evidence of purpura (n=29, 15.1%), blisters
M
(n=42, 21.9%), ulcerations (n=34, 17.7%), livedo (n=7, 3.6%) or papules or erythematous
plaques (n=22, 11.5%). Different types of lesions could coexist. Skin lesions most frequently
ED
involved the face (n=136, 70.8%), prominently the ears (n=119, 62%), although cheeks
(n=35, 18.2%) and the nose (n=23, 12%) could also be involved. The lower limbs (n=135,
PT
70.3%), upper limbs (n=99, 51.6%) and trunk (n=51, 26.6%) were also frequently involved.
CE
Arthralgias were reported in 55 patients (28.6%), arthritis in 8 (4.2%) and ear, nose and throat
(ENT) involvement in 29 (15.1%) with midline destruction, rhinitis and/or oral or tracheal
AC
ulcers.
Organ damage was less frequent, with renal insufficiency in 24 patients (12.5%) and
6
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
An inflammatory syndrome, with increased C-reactive protein (CRP) level, was detected in
48/57 patients tested (84.2%), with median [IQR] CRP level 21.5 mg/l [9.8-74.3].
Leukopenia was the most frequent haematological abnormality, found in 69/138 patients
(50%), with median [IQR] leukocyte and neutrophil counts of 3.3 g/l [2.4-4.8] and 1 g/l [0.5-
2.4], respectively. Neutropenia was reported in 57/132 patients tested (43.2%), including 13
(9.8%) with agranulocytosis. These abnormalities were associated with anemia in 17 patients,
T
with median [IQR] haemoglobin count 8.9 g/l [6.7-9.9], and associated with
IP
thrombocytopenia in 2 cases, with median [IQR] platelet count 103 g/l [100.5-105.5].
CR
Autoantibodies were identified in most patients (Table 3). ANCAs were detected in 167/178
US
indirect immunofluorescence (IF) assay. ANCA specificity was studied by enzyme linked
AN
immunosorbent assay in 118 patients. Anti-myeloperoxydase (MPO) and anti-proteinase 3
(PR3) Abs were frequently associated (n=51/118, 43.2%); anti-MPO Abs alone were
M
identified in 38/118 patients (32.2%) and anti-PR3 Abs alone in n=18/118 (15.3%).
Among the 137 patients tested for APL Abs, 93 (67.9%) had at least one of these
ED
(42.3%) and anti-ß2-glycoprotein1 (anti-ß2GP1) Abs in 11 (8%). Seven patients (5.1%) were
PT
triple positive, 24 (17.6%) had both anti-cardiolipin Abs and lupus anticoagulant, and 4 (3%)
CE
In all, 75/144 patients (52.1%) were positive for anti-nuclear Abs (ANA). Reported
AC
antigen and anti-DNA Abs (n=1), anti-histone Abs (n=2), anti-Smith Abs (n=1) and no
7
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
within the normal range for 58 (66.7%); C3 and C4 levels were decreased for 14 (16.1%); C3
level was decreased and C4 level normal for 4 (4.6%); and C4 level was decreased with
Cryoglobulin was detected in 12/63 patients (19%) and found weak (n= 1), detectable (n=2),
trace (n=1), and positive (n=8). In all, 10/12 patients with cryglobulin underwent hepatitis C
T
virus (HCV) serology and 2 were positive, including 1 with negative HCV PCR findings and
IP
1 in whom PCR was not performed. Among patients with cryoglobulinemia, 4 had cutaneous
CR
vasculitis, 6 thrombotic vasculopathy without vasculitis and 1 unspecific cutaneous histology
US
Among 60 patients tested, none had evidence of HIV infection. Two of 64 patients (3.1%) had
AN
unspecified “positive” hepatitis B virus serology and 8/70 (11.4%) positive HCV serology.
Except for the 2 patients positive for cryoglobulin, HCV PCR results were not reported.
M
Pathology study
In all, 148/192 patients (77.1%) had skin biopsies. Two dominant patterns were identified:
ED
patients, APL Ab status was available. Strikingly, 35 patients (56.5%) were positive for APL
Abs. For eight patients; results were interpreted as compatible with pyoderma gangrenosum,
AC
with dermal neutrophil infiltrates; for 5 of these patients, vasculitis lesions were also
were identified, without evidence of vasculitis. Indirect IF assay was performed for 21
biopsies and was positive for immunoglobulins (Igs) and/or C3 deposits in 16 (76.2%)
8
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Among 24 patients with acute renal failure, 13 underwent renal biopsy. Crescentic
no deposits seen on IF assay, and 1 showed IgG, IgM and C3 deposits on IF assay (IF data not
specified for others). One biopsy identified immune-mediated glomerulonephritis with IgG
membranous nephropathy with IgG, IgM, C3 and C1q deposits. The last one showed
T
glomerulonephritis with thrombotic microangiopathy.
IP
Treatment and outcome
CR
Information on treatment and/or outcome was available for 151 (78.6%) and 134 (69.8%)
patients, respectively. Overall, 28 did not receive any treatment or received only symptomatic
US
treatment (the treatment did not include surgery), and 85 received corticosteroids; 15 received
AN
only corticosteroids. Prednisone was the most frequent corticosteroid prescribed. The median
[IQR] starting dose was 60 mg/d [40-81.3]. Treatment was in general brief.
M
cyclophosphamide (n=13, 8.6%), rituximab (n=2, 1.3%), methotrexate (n=2, 1.3%) and
thalidomide (n=1, 0.7%). For 2 patients, the type of immunosuppressant prescribed was not
PT
Skin surgery was performed in 21/151 patients (14%) because of severe decaying lesions.
AC
Surgery consisted of skin graft in 15 patients (10%), debridement in 14 patients (9.3%), and
amputation of the nose and leg in 1 patient (0.7%) Debridement was associated with skin graft
9
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Antibiotics were prescribed for 23/151 patients, combined with corticosteroids in 8 and with
pentoxifylline).
discontinued in 54/65 (83.1%); 18 of these did not receive any additional medication and had
T
a favourable outcome.
IP
The evolution was favourable for 116/134 patients (86.6%), with regression of clinical
CR
symptoms. Three patients (2.2%) died, including one with early necrotizing pneumonia. Two
patients died during follow-up: 1 of overdose (2 years later) and another who underwent
US
dialysis who died of cerebral haemorrhage (several months later). Among the 24 patients who
AN
presented acute renal insufficiency, 10 (41.7%) recovered; in 7 (29.2%), chronic renal
insufficiency developed; and 3 showed relapse after reexposure to levamisole (no data
M
Other complications included persistent skin lesions in 5/134 patients (3.7%) without
ED
dependence in 1 patient (0.7%), and amputation due to worsening of the skin lesions in 1
PT
patient (0.7%).
CE
Overall, 33/134 (28.4%) patients showed vasculopathy relapse. When levamisole had been
10
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Discussion
Levamisole is the most frequent cocaine adulterant, and its use is increasing [22]. Indeed, the
proportion of cocaine lots containing levamisole has increased during the last few years, along
T
characterized by skin involvement, especially necrotic purpura located in the ears, leuko-
IP
neutropenia, ANCAs and/or APL Abs and good prognosis on levamisole disruption.
CR
Cocaine consumers are more often men between 18 and 25 years old [23]. Middle-aged
women are not the most frequent cocaine consumers, so we show a sex and age susceptibility
US
for the development of levamisole-induced vasculopathy. This susceptibility was not found in
AN
medical consumers of levamisole but could be explained by the main indication for
levamisole, nephrotic syndrome, which mainly concerns young boys. In our series, ENT and
M
epistaxis, necrotizing ulcerative lesions, extensive crusting, and septal perforation [24, 25] as
well as alveolar haemorrhage, pneumonia, interstitial pneumonia, and pulmonary edema due
PT
with cocaine intoxication spectrum but appears to be more prevalent in middle-aged women.
In this study, patients with levamisole-induced vasculopathy had striking antibody status.
AC
Indeed, ANCA specificity was frequently positive for both anti-MPO and anti-PR3 Abs,
which is unusual [28,29]. As well, in patients with ANCA-associated vasculitis (AAV), the
detection of APL Abs is also very rare. To the best of our knowledge, this association was
reported once [30]. In our review, 67.9% patients were positive for APL Abs. Therefore,
double ANCA specificity and/or positivity for APL Abs in patients with AAV could be
11
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
considered a “red flag” for cocaine intake and should lead practitioners to confirm it.
highlight two main patterns from biopsies of patients with levamisole-induced vasculopathy:
T
especially granulomatosis with polyangiitis (GPA) and microscopic polyangiitis (MPA).
IP
Diagnosis of levamisole-induced vasculopathy can be difficult because of a half-life of
CR
levamisole of about 6 hr [31]. Our series highlights differences between levamisole-induced
vasculopathy and AAV, which can be used as red flags to differentiate these conditions. For
US
example, skin involvement is less common in GPA and MPA than in levamisole-induced
AN
vasculopathy, whereas renal, pulmonary and peripheral nerve involvement are more frequent
in GPA and MPA, and ear involvement has not been described in MPA [28,29]. Among
M
vasculopathy and rare in AAV. Moreover, skin lesions are often severe in levamisole-induced
ED
amputation associated with skin wound and only one case of skin graft for leg ulcers were
PT
neutropenia, which is not common in GPA and MPA [28,29]. Finally, levamisole-induced
Our work has some limitations, related to its retrospective nature and common to every
literature review. Some data were missing in publications. We cannot exclude the possibility
levamisole was not sought and/or not reported for most of the cases. Moreover, when
12
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
investigated, because of its half-life, some tests could have been falsely negative, which
the best of our knowledge, our series is the largest of levamisole-induced vasculopathy cases.
We cannot exclude that APL Abs were only transient because their status was not checked 12
weeks later in most cases, as recommended for APL syndrome [33]. For the rare cases in
which ALP Abs were later checked, these were often negative (n=8/10, 80%).
T
In conclusion, levamisole-induced vasculopathy is predominantly seen in middle-aged women
IP
and shows skin involvement, especially ear purpura and necrotic lesions; leuko-neutropenia;
CR
and ANCAs with double specificity and/or APL Abs. Levamisole must be considered in this
presentation because stopping levamisole exposure is essential for remission. When ANCA
US
vasculitis is suspected, we must ask patients about cocaine consumption and if necessary, test
AN
them for cocaine and levamisole presence in hair.
M
Acknowledgements
The autthors want to thank the patient association “France Vascularites” for its support.
ED
PT
CE
AC
13
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
References
2. Williams GT, Johnson SA, Dieppe PA, Huskisson EC. Neutropenia during treatment of
3. Thompson JS, Herbick JM, Klassen LW, Severson CD, Overlin VL, Blaschke JW, et al.
T
Studies on levamisole--induced agranulocytosis. Blood. 1980 Sep;56(3):388–96.
IP
4. Auffenberg C, Rosenthal LJ, Dresner N. Levamisole: a common cocaine adulterant with
CR
life-threatening side effects. Psychosomatics. 2013 Dec;54(6):590–3.
5. Raymon LP, Isenschmid DS. Letter to the editor: The possible role of levamisole in
US
illicit cocaine preparations. J Anal Toxicol. 2009 Dec;33(9):620–2.
AN
6. Chang A, Osterloh J, Thomas J. Levamisole: a dangerous new cocaine adulterant. Clin
7. Tallarida CS, Egan E, Alejo GD, Raffa R, Tallarida RJ, Rawls SM. Levamisole and
aminorex in human urine samples by GC-MS after use of levamisole. J Pharm Biomed
CE
10. Nationwide Public Health Alert Issued Concerning Life-Threatening Risk Posed by
14
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
11. Lynch KL, Dominy SS, Graf J, Kral AH. Detection of levamisole exposure in cocaine
Apr;35(3):176–8.
12. Buchanan JA, Heard K, Burbach C, Wilson ML, Dart R. Prevalence of levamisole in
urine toxicology screens positive for cocaine in an inner-city hospital. JAMA. 2011 Apr
27;305(16):1657–8.
T
13. Eiden C, Diot C, Mathieu O, Mallaret M, Peyrière H. Levamisole-adulterated cocaine:
IP
what about in European countries? J Psychoactive Drugs. 2014 Dec;46(5):389–92.
CR
14. Dziadosz M, Klintschar M, Teske J. Letter to the editor--Consumption of levamisole in
15.
US
cocaine preparations. J Forensic Sci. 2015 Mar;60(2):538.
Reduct J. 2009;6:30.
M
16. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Agranulocytosis associated with
ED
cocaine use - four States, March 2008-November 2009. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly
17. Lee KC, Ladizinski B, Federman DG. Complications associated with use of levamisole-
contaminated cocaine: an emerging public health challenge. Mayo Clin Proc. 2012
CE
Jun;87(6):581–6.
AC
18. Espinoza LR, Perez Alamino R. Cocaine-induced vasculitis: clinical and immunological
Sep;13(7):602–3.
15
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
11):1057–8.
21. Rongioletti F, Ghio L, Ginevri F, Bleidl D, Rinaldi S, Edefonti A, et al. Purpura of the
22. Caudevilla F, Ventura M, Fornís I, Barratt MJ, Vidal C, Lladanosa CG, et al. Results of
T
an international drug testing service for cryptomarket users. Int J Drug Policy. 2016
IP
Sep;35:38–41
CR
23. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration: Results from the 2013
US
24. Trimarchi M, Bertazzoni G, Bussi M. Cocaine induced midline destructive lesions.
AN
Rhinology. 2014 Jun;52(2):104–11.
500.
ED
26. Tseng W, Sutter ME, Albertson TE. Stimulants and the lung: review of literature. Clin
illicit drug use: features and mechanisms. Chem Biol Interact. 2013 Dec 5;206(3):444–
51.
AC
28. Almouhawis HA, Leao JC, Fedele S, Porter SR. Wegener’s granulomatosis: a review of
clinical features and an update in diagnosis and treatment. J Oral Pathol Med. 2013
Aug;42(7):507–16.
16
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
31. Trehy ML, Brown DJ, Woodruff JT, Westenberger BJ, Nychis WG, Reuter N, et al.
T
32. Santana ANC, Takagaki TY, Barros JM, Antunes T, Parra ER, Capelozzi VL, et al. Re:
IP
giant leg ulcer in Wegener’s granulomatosis treated with plasmapheresis and skin graft.
CR
Dermatol Surg. 30(8):1182–3.
33. Miyakis S, Lockshin MD, Atsumi T, Branch DW, Brey RL, Cervera R, et al.
US
International consensus statement on an update of the classification criteria for definite
17
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Abbreviations:
Antibodies: Abs
Anti-ß2-glycoprotein1: anti-ß2GP1
T
Anti-nuclear : ANA
IP
Anti-phospholipid: APL
CR
C-reactive protein: CRP
Hepatitis C: HCV US
AN
Human immunodeficiency virus: HIV
Immunofluorescence: IF
Immunoglobulin: Ig
ED
Myeloperoxidase: MPO
PT
Proteinase 3: PR3
CE
AC
18
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Legend to figures
T
IP
CR
US
AN
Figure 1. Flow chart of the search for articles reporting levamisole-induced vasculopathy.
M
ED
PT
CE
AC
19
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
T
Arthralgia 55 (28.6) 3 (23.0) 52 (29.1)
IP
Arthritis 8 (4.2) 0 (0) 8 (4.4)
CR
Myalgia 14 (7.3) 0 (0) 14 (7.8)
Midline destruction US
10 (5.2) 0 (0) 10 (5.6)
AN
Oral or tracheal ulcers 15 (7.8) 0 (0) 15 (8.3)
20
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
T
Necrosis without purpura 29 (1.1) 1 (7.7) 28 (15.6)
IP
Blister 42 (21.9) 4 (30.8) 38 (21.2)
CR
Ulceration 34 (17.7) 1 (7.7) 33 (18.4)
Livedo US
7 (3.6) 1 (7.7) 6 (3.4)
AN
Location
21
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
<0.
ANCAs 167/178 (93.9)
7/9 (77.8) 160/169 (94.7) 05
Indirect immunofluorescence:
T
<0.
cANCAs only 5/167 (3)
IP
2/7 (28.6) 3/158 (1.9) 05
CR
pANCAs and cANCAs 30/167 (18) 0/9 (0) 30/158 (19.9) ns
ELISA
Anti-MPO and anti-PR3 Abs 51/118 (43.2) 0/2 (0) 51/116 (44) ns
M
ANA positivity or titers > 1/80 75/144 (52.1) 3/9 (33.3) 72/135 (53.3) ns
ns: non-significant
22
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
T
IP
CR
US
AN
M
ED
PT
CE
AC
23