Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 23

20

Communities in Crisis:
Disasters, Group Violence,
and Terrorism

Key Terms Learning Objectives

● Arson Upon mastery of this chapter, you should be able to:


● Assault and battery
● Biologic warfare ● Describe a variety of characteristics of disasters, including
● Casualty causation, number of casualties, scope, and intensity.
● Chemical warfare ● Discuss a variety of factors contributing to a community’s potential
● Critical incident stress debriefing for experiencing a disaster.
(CISD)
● Identify the four phases of disaster management.
● Direct victim
● Disaster ● Describe factors involved in disaster planning.
● Disaster planning ● Describe the role of the community health nurse in preventing,
● Displaced person preparing for, responding to, and supporting recovery from
● Gang disasters.
● Genocide
● Compare and contrast the most common types of group violence.
● Homicide
● Indirect victim ● Discuss a variety of factors contributing to a community’s potential
● Intensity for experiencing group violence.
● Looting ● Describe the role of the community health nurse in preventing and
● Lynching responding to group violence.
● Manmade disaster
● Distinguish terrorism from other types of group violence.
● Mass casualty
● Natural disaster ● Use the levels of prevention to describe the role of the community
● Nuclear warfare health nurse in relation to acts of chemical, biologic, or nuclear
● Posttraumatic stress disorder terrorism.
(PTSD)
● Rape
● Refugee
● Riot
● Scope
● Terrorism
● Triage
● Violent crime
446 UNIT 4 Community as Client

W
hat would you do if your local news station broad- and technologic disasters worldwide. Here is a brief sam-
cast an announcement that your community was di- pling of major disasters that occurred in 2002-2003:
rectly in the path of a hurricane that earlier in the day • January 2002, Ipiales, Columbia—a Boeing 727 crashes
had caused extensive damage and loss of life in a neighbor- into a mountain, resulting in 92 fatalities
ing state? What would you do if you were shopping at a lo- • January 2002, Democratic Republic of Congo—a volcano
cal mall, suddenly heard an explosive noise followed by engulfs the city of Goma; 300,000 to 500,000 people are
shouts and cries for help, then noticed that a pungent odor displaced
was filling the air? What DID you do on the morning of Sep- • February 2002, Ayyat, Egypt—a fire engulfs a crowded
tember 11, 2001, when the world of each American, espe- passenger train and 361 people are killed
cially those in New York City, in Washington, D.C., and on • March 2002, Afghanistan—a series of earthquakes leaves
a plane over rural Pennsylvania, changed forever? What did 1000 dead and 7000 homeless
you do when you heard of multiple terrorist attacks on the • May 2002, Andhra Pradesh State, India—a brutal heat
United States? As distant as some of these scenarios might wave causes 600 deaths nationwide
seem from your own life, disasters, group violence, and ter- • May 2002, Bangladesh—an overloaded ferry capsizes in
rorism are ever-present possibilities, and nurses and other a storm; 300 are drowned
health care professionals have an obligation to respond ap- • June 2002, Western United States—several major wild-
propriately. This chapter will increase your understanding of fires, including the worst fire in Colorado’s history,
the community health nurse’s role in preparing for, respond- with 137,760 acres and 600 structures consumed. In
ing to, and recovering from disasters, group violence, and Arizona, another fire burns 468,638 acres and destroys
terrorism. 400 structures.
• June 2002, China—a coal mine gas explosion kills 111
• June 2002, Russia—the worst flooding in a decade leaves
DISASTERS 93 dead and 87,000 homeless
• July 2002, Ukraine—a jet fighter crashes during an acro-
A disaster is any natural or manmade event that causes a level batic maneuver at an air show, killing 83 people, includ-
of destruction or emotional trauma exceeding the abilities of ing 23 children; it becomes the worst air show disaster in
those affected to respond without community assistance. The history
crash of a private plane over the Pacific Ocean in which no • September 2002, Dakar, Senegal—in one of Africa’s
bodies are recovered and no environmental impact is felt is deadliest ferry accidents, a vessel capsizes in heavy
not a disaster by this definition, because no specific commu- winds, resulting in the loss of almost 1000 lives
nity-based response is required or even possible. Such a • October 2002, Moscow—gas kills 115 hostages in a raid
tragedy may, however, be felt for a lifetime by family mem- on a theater
bers and friends, who need emotional support and possibly • December 2002, Mexico—New Year fireworks explosion
long-term financial assistance. If a plane with 150 passengers kills 28
crashes over land, destroying several homes in its path, the • February 2003, Daegu, South Korea—an arson attack on
community affected is unable to cope with the resulting in- the subway system kills 182 people
juries, deaths, and property destruction without assistance; by • February 2003, Iran—a military plane crash kills 302
the definition used here, this constitutes a disaster. • May 2003, Algeria—a 6.7 earthquake kills more than
The geographic distribution of disasters varies because 2000 people
certain types of disasters are more common in some parts of • August 2003, France—a prolonged heat wave kills 10,000
the world. For example, California is associated with earth- people, mostly elderly
quakes and Florida with hurricanes. Similarly, it is not sur- • September 2003, U.S.—Hurricane Isabel knocks out
prising to hear of drought in Ethiopia or floods in India dur- power to 2 million people
ing the monsoon season. When certain types of disasters are • December 2003, Bam, Iran—an earthquake kills 28,000
anticipated, communities are usually better prepared for people and injures 30,000
them. For instance, California has strict building codes to
prevent destruction of structures in the event of earthquakes,
Characteristics of Disasters
but most California homes lack the basements and insulation
that characterize homes in regions often visited by tornados Disasters are often characterized by their cause. Natural dis-
or winter storms. Similarly, residents of Germany, Austria, asters are caused by natural events, such as the floods in
and Russia are better prepared for blizzards than for heavy western Europe or the earthquakes in Afghanistan in 2002.
rain, which probably explains in part the devastation caused Manmade disasters are caused by human activity, such as
in some communities by floods there in 2002. the bombing of the World Trade Center in New York City in
Because the local media in the United States do not typ- 2001, the displacement of thousands of Kosovars during
ically report on disasters unless there are mass casualties, one their war with Serbia in 1999, or the riots in Los Angeles in
may be unaware of the frequency and variety of both natural the early 1990s. Other manmade disasters include nuclear re-
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 447

actor meltdowns, industrial accidents, oil spills, construction physical injuries, they are likely to have health effects from
accidents, and air, train, bus, and subway crashes. their experience. Some may be without shelter or food, and
A casualty is a human being who is injured or killed by many experience serious psychological stress long after the
or as a direct result of an incident. Although major disasters event is over (Display 20-1).
sometimes occur without any injury or loss of life, disasters Depending on the cause and characteristics of the disas-
are commonly characterized by the number of casualties in- ter, some direct victims may become displaced persons or
volved. If casualties number more than 2 people but fewer
than 100, the disaster is characterized as a multiple-casualty
incident. Although multiple-casualty incidents may strain D I S P L A Y 20–1
the health care systems of small or mid-sized communities, Direct and Indirect Victims of a Disaster
mass-casualty incidents—those involving 100 or more casu-
alties—often completely overwhelm the resources of even
On September 11, 2001, almost 3000 people died in
large cities. Preparedness for mass-casualty incidents is es-
the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center in New
sential for all communities. York City. All of the employees and visitors in the two
The possibility of being prepared is another characteris- buildings were direct victims of this disaster, and the
tic that varies with different types of disasters. For instance, entire population of Manhattan can be considered in-
the path and time of landfall of a hurricane can be tracked so direct victims.
that residents in the storm’s path can be evacuated and fami- Hotels, businesses, and apartments for blocks sur-
lies and businesses can be protected. Communities can also rounding the Twin Towers suffered structural damage,
minimize devastation from flooding by building reservoirs or blown-out windows, and interiors covered with inches
refusing to grant building permits in flood-prone areas, and of powdered cement and other debris. A year after
sandbagging can be used during rainy weather. In fire-prone this disaster, many residents in the surrounding areas
still were unable to return home.
areas, communities can post notices to heighten awareness of
Many rescue workers who were survivors have
fire danger and enforce regulations to cut back vegetation near
lasting psychological effects from their own survival
structures in forested areas. On the other hand, some disasters experiences and from losing close friends and col-
strike without warning. For example, the terrorist attacks in leagues. In addition, many rescuers breathed in the
New York City caught thousands of civilians unaware. They dust in the air for days and now have respiratory dam-
were trapped in buildings with limited escape routes and very age. As a result, their status changed from indirect
little time to retreat to safety. For employees in the Pentagon victim to direct victim.
on 9/11, survival depended on being in the right place at the All people working or visiting Manhattan that day
right time. The number of fires in the western United States in were affected by the closing of the bridges and tun-
2002 was unanticipated and uncharacteristically large, and nels and were stranded in New York City until trans-
control was hindered by heat and high winds. Residents were portation routes opened again, thus becoming indirect
victims.
stranded in rural areas or barred from re-entering their com-
Other indirect victims included children attending
munities for weeks, without any knowledge of whether they
school and living within sight of the Twin Towers.
would have homes when they were allowed to return. They received counseling in school for months, and in
The scope of a disaster is the range of its effect, either some cases years, after the disaster.
geographically or in terms of the number of victims. The col- For 1 year after the attack, volunteer construction
lapse of a 500-unit high-rise apartment building has a greater workers and rescue workers who lost fellow police of-
scope than does the collapse of a bridge that occurs while ficers, paramedics, or firefighters worked 24 hours a
only two cars are crossing. day. First, the efforts were geared to help look for sur-
The intensity of a disaster is the level of destruction and vivors. Shortly after, workers knew that they were
devastation it causes. For instance, an earthquake centered in looking for the bodies or body parts of victims while
a large metropolitan area and one centered in a desert may removing thousands of tons of building pieces. Thou-
sands of people who were involved in the recovery ef-
have the same numeric rating on the Richter scale, yet have
forts can be considered indirect victims.
very different intensities in terms of the destruction they cause.
Family members of the 2833 deceased/or missing
victims, who have been affected for a lifetime, also are
Victims of Disasters indirect victims. Thousands of children lost a parent,
some parents lost multiple children, and, in some
Because disasters are so variable, there is no typical victim
cases, both spouses were lost because husband and
in a disaster. Nor can anyone predict whether he or she will wife both worked in the World Trade Center. The rip-
ever become a victim of a disaster. However, once disaster ples of tragedy extended beyond the borders of the
strikes, victims may be characterized by their level of in- United States, because there were hundreds of people
volvement. Direct victims are the people who experience the working in the Twin Towers from many different coun-
event, whether fire, volcanic eruption, war, or bomb. They tries whose family members are now indirect victims.
are the dead and the survivors, and even if they are without
448 UNIT 4 Community as Client

refugees. Displaced persons are forced to leave their homes the lava of an erupting volcano are agents, as are radiation,
to escape the effects of a disaster. Usually, displacement is a industrial chemicals, biologic agents, and bombs. The Sta-
temporary condition and involves movement within the per- tion Nightclub fire and the apartment deck collapse in
son’s own country. A common example is relocation of Chicago demonstrated that irresponsibility of contractors
residents of flooded areas to schools, churches, and other and inspectors and failure to adhere to safety policies can act
shelters on higher ground. Typically, the term refugee is re- as agents of disaster, resulting in death and destruction.
served for people who are forced to leave their homeland be-
cause of war or persecution. For example, in early 2000, Environmental Factors
thousands of refugees fled Chechnya to escape advancing Environmental factors are those that could potentially con-
Russian troops opposed to the republic’s separatist attempts. tribute to or mitigate a disaster. Some of the most common
Often, the displacement of refugees is permanent. For exam- environmental factors are a community’s level of prepared-
ple, many young people who fled Argentina during the “dis- ness; the presence of industries that produce harmful chemi-
appearances” between 1976 and 1982 did not return when a cals or radiation; the presence of flood-prone rivers, lakes, or
democratic government regained power in 1983. Thousands streams; average amount of rainfall or snowfall; average
of young men and women who protested against the regime high and low temperatures; proximity to fault lines, coastal
in power at the time simply disappeared. waters, or volcanoes; level of compliance with local building
Indirect victims are the relatives and friends of direct codes; and presence or absence of political unrest.
victims. Although these people do not experience the stress
of the event itself, they often undergo extreme anguish from Agencies and Organizations for
trying to locate loved ones or accommodate their emergency Disaster Management
needs. If bodies cannot be found or are unidentifiable, indi-
rect victims experience even greater anguish and may not be Among disaster-relief organizations, perhaps none is as fa-
able to accept that their loved one has died. For example, mous as the Red Cross, the name commonly used when re-
many of the mothers of young Argentineans who disap- ferring to the American Red Cross, the Federation of Red
peared in the 1970s still march daily in downtown Buenos Cross and Red Crescent Societies, and the International
Aires, demanding public acknowledgment of the murders of Committee of the Red Cross. The American Red Cross was
their daughters and sons. Family members of victims from founded in 1881 by Clara Barton and was chartered by the
9/11 in New York City have worked with architects to de- U. S. Congress in 1905. It is authorized to provide disaster
velop a complex of buildings and a memorial that meets the assistance free of charge across the country through its more
expectations of most of the indirect victims and honors their than 1 million volunteers.
loved ones. This is a long and arduous task that, once com- The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA),
pleted, will help with the long healing process. established in 1979, is the federal agency responsible for as-
sessment of and response to disaster events in the United
States. It also provides training and guidance in all phases of
Factors Contributing to Disasters
disaster management.
It is useful to apply the host, agent, and environment model The World Health Organization’s Emergency Relief
to understand the factors contributing to disasters, because Operations provide disaster assistance internationally, and
manipulation of these factors can be instrumental in planning the Pan American Health Organization works to coordinate
strategies to prevent or prepare for disasters. relief efforts in Latin America and the Caribbean. In addi-
tion, various international nongovernmental organizations
Host Factors (such as Doctors Without Borders, the International Medical
The host is the human being who experiences the disaster. Corps, and Operation Blessing), religious groups, and other
Host factors that contribute to the likelihood of experiencing volunteer agencies provide needed emergency care.
a disaster include age, general health, mobility, psychologi- The newest safety-related agency in the United States is
cal factors, and even socioeconomic factors. For instance, el- the Department of Homeland Security. Organized in 2002, it
derly residents of a mobile home community may be unable incorporates many of the nation’s security, protection, and
to evacuate independently in response to a tornado warning emergency response activities into a single federal depart-
if they no longer can drive. Impoverished residents of a low- ment. As a relatively new department, it is undergoing many
income apartment complex in a large city may notice that changes related to its scope of service. In June 2002, the Amer-
their building is not compliant with city fire codes but may ican Public Health Association became concerned because
avoid alerting authorities for fear of being forced to move to some of the responsibilities of the Centers for Disease Control
more expensive housing. and Prevention and the Health Resources and Services Ad-
ministration (such as the cache drugs, medical supplies, and
Agent Factors equipment for emergencies through the National Pharmaceu-
The agent is the natural or technologic element that causes tical Stockpile) were being usurped by the Department of
the disaster. For example, the high winds of a hurricane and Homeland Security. Some experts see this department as frag-
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 449

menting the nation’s broad-based public health system, which Semiannual disaster drills and tests of the Emergency Broad-
may hinder overall responsiveness and compromise the pub- cast System are examples of appropriate activities during the
lic health system (Late, 2002). It is hoped that such serious preparedness phase.
concerns will be addressed as this department evolves. Disaster preparedness activities occur locally, region-
Governments often send their military personnel and ally, and nationally. A town keeps its warning system work-
equipment in response to international disasters. For exam- ing and tests it each month. Sections of the country coordi-
ple, in March 2000, the governments of South Africa, Eng- nate larger warning systems to notify communities in the
land, Germany, France, and the United States, among other path of a tornado or hurricane, and the country has a plan to
nations, responded to the floods in Mozambique with heli- stockpile smallpox vaccine for mass immunization. The Na-
copters, planes, boats, and supplies. tional Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases has tried
When natural or manmade disasters within the United diluting a few of the existing 86 million doses of vaccine and
States are accompanied by civil disturbance, looting, or vio- has tested the diluted dosage on 100 volunteers to see
lent crime, the resources of local police departments may be whether it still works. The results showed that this cache
overwhelmed. In such cases, the National Guard is often alone contained enough to vaccinate everyone in an emer-
called in to restore order. gency. Laboratories have been contracted to make more than
200 million doses in the event that biologic warfare becomes
Phases of Disaster Management a threat. The last case of smallpox in the United States oc-
curred in 1949, and routine immunization was halted in
In developing strategies to address the problem of disasters, 1972, although many doctors refused to use the vaccine even
it is helpful for the community health nurse to consider each before that date. With a largely unvaccinated population,
of the four phases of disaster management: prevention, pre- most people in the nation would need the vaccine. Having the
paredness, response, and recovery. vaccine ready is a demonstration of disaster preparedness.

Prevention Phase Response Phase


During the prevention phase, no disaster is expected or antic- The response phase begins immediately after the onset of the
ipated. The task during this phase is to identify community risk disastrous event. Preparedness plans take effect immedi-
factors and to develop and implement programs to prevent dis- ately, with the goals of saving lives and preventing further in-
asters from occurring. Task forces typically include represen- jury or damage. Activities during the response phase include
tatives from the community’s local government, health care rescue, triage, on-site stabilization, transportation of victims,
providers, social services providers, police and fire depart- and treatment at local hospitals. Response also requires re-
ments, major industries, local media, and citizens’ groups. covery, identification, and refrigeration of bodies so that no-
Programs developed during the prevention phase may also fo- tification of family members is possible and correct, even
cus on strategies to mitigate the effects of disasters that cannot weeks after a disaster. This care of the dead is demanding and
be prevented, such as earthquakes, hurricanes, and tornadoes. time-consuming work that is often overlooked by people un-
The United States has strengthened this phase of disas- familiar with disaster response. Supportive care, including
ter management since September 2001. This can be seen es- food, water, and shelter for victims and relief workers is also
pecially at airports, where airline passengers must now go an essential element of the total disaster response.
through a more rigorous security screening before boarding
the plane. Nonpassengers cannot go beyond the security Recovery Phase
area. Photographic identification is required at two or more During the recovery phase, the community takes actions to re-
points before boarding. Random searches of hand-carried pair, rebuild, or relocate damaged homes and businesses and re-
luggage occur, and passengers are screened with wands that store health and economic vitality to the community. Psycho-
detect metal. In some states, luggage is tested for radioactive logical recovery must also be addressed. The emotional scars
material, police officials with trained dogs patrol the airport, from witnessing a traumatic event may last a lifetime. Both vic-
or people are asked to take their shoes off for examination as tims and relief workers should be offered mental health services
part of the screening process. All of these measures have to support their recovery (see Voices from the Community).
been initiated to prevent a disaster.
Role of the Community Health
Preparedness Phase
Nurse
Disaster preparedness involves improving community and
individual reaction and responses so that the effects of a dis- The community health nurse has a pivotal role in preventing,
aster are minimized. Disaster preparedness saves lives and preparing for, responding to, and supporting recovery from a
minimizes injury and property damage. It includes plans for disaster. After a thorough community assessment for risk
communication, evacuation, rescue, and victim care. Any factors, the community health nurse may initiate the forma-
plan must also address acquisition of equipment, supplies, tion of a multidisciplinary task force to address disaster pre-
medicine, and even food, clean water, blankets, and shelter. vention and preparedness in the community.
450 UNIT 4 Community as Client

health department, the nurse can determine during home vis-


its whether a family has a personal disaster plan and help
VOICES FROM THE COMMUNITY
them develop one if none exists. There are many actions the
nurse can initiate.
“I saw the first plane hit the corner of the World The second aspect of primary disaster prevention is an-
Trade Center and explode from my kitchen window, ticipatory guidance. Disaster drills and other anticipatory ex-
which is 300 feet from the south tower. A blizzard of ercises help relief workers experience some of the feelings of
gray dust obliterated the bright blue of the sky. Paper chaos and stress associated with a disaster before one occurs.
floated through the dust, edges on fire and curling up. It is much easier to do this when energy and intellectual
It was beautiful actually, and I couldn’t take my eyes processes are at a high level of functioning. Anticipatory
off of it. work can dissipate the impact of a disastrous event. The com-
In the aftermath, my life has been completely munity health nurse has a role in these disaster drills through
turned upside down. I lived in that apartment for 25 committee membership, organization of drills at the place of
years. Until mid-May (2002), it was part of a police employment, or activism at the grassroots level to assist in
zone; I’ve been back only to clean up. I have thrown holding community-wide disaster drills on a regular basis.
away all my possessions except for a few pho-
tographs and pieces of art. In effect, I’m starting Secondary Prevention. Secondary disaster prevention
over. I feel a kinship with the legions of displaced focuses on the earliest possible detection and treatment. For
people in this world, made homeless by events be- example, a mobile home community is devastated by a tor-
yond their control. They are incredibly strong and re- nado, and the local health department’s community health
silient. I hope that I will be too.” nurses work with the American Red Cross to provide emer-
gency assistance. Secondary prevention corresponds to im-
Kathleen, New York City resident (Cooper & Ianzito, mediate and effective response.
2002). Nurses at St. Vincent’s Hospital, the closest Level I
Trauma Center to the World Trade Center, prepared to re-
spond to the victims of September 11, 2001, in New York
City. They were expecting major trauma cases, but this area
was quieter than usual. Triage was conducted both on the
Preventing Disasters
streets outside of the emergency department and inside, start-
Disaster prevention may be considered on three levels: pri-
ing the process earlier and routing people for treatment more
mary, secondary, and tertiary. These are applied to a natural
effectively. This system was developed after the 1993 ter-
disaster in the Levels of Prevention Matrix.
rorist attack on the World Trade Center. Because of the total
Primary Prevention. Primary prevention of a disaster devastation of the 2001 disaster, those who did survive
means keeping the disaster from ever happening by taking emerged relatively uninjured and became rescuers of those
actions that completely eliminate its occurrence. This is the they could free from the debris. Both rescuers and survivors
first aspect of primary disaster prevention. Although it is ob- suffered injuries from falling and flying debris outside of the
viously the most effective level of intervention, both in terms buildings, but most of the survivors received less serious in-
of promoting clients’ health and containing costs, it is not al- juries than emergency personnel were expecting. There were
ways possible. Tornadoes, earthquakes, and other disasters many minor injuries, such as smoke inhalation, eye injuries,
often strike without warning, despite the use of every avail- and fractures. In another area, heart attack, burn, and crush-
able technologic device for prediction and tracking. ing injury victims were treated. With organization and pre-
If possible, primary prevention of disasters can be prac- paredness, those needing hospitalization were admitted
ticed in all settings: in the workplace and home with pro- within 45 minutes after being triaged and stabilized. Most in-
grams to reduce safety hazards, and in the community with juries occurred among rescuers, although a few civilians
programs to monitor risk factors, reduce pollution, and en- were also hurt. In the first 4 to 6 hours, 264 victims were seen.
courage nonviolent conflict resolution. Primary disaster pre- On a typical day, that number would have been 40 to 45 dur-
vention efforts should take into account a community’s phys- ing the same time period. In the days after the disaster, some
ical, psychosocial, cultural, economic, and spiritual needs. rescuers found body parts and had to transport them to the
The community health nurse has a role in each of these ar- morgue. Rescuers came to the emergency department suffer-
eas. As a teacher, the community health nurse educates peo- ing from symptoms related to fatigue and emotional distress
ple at home, at work, at school, or in a faith community about (Ostrowski, 2001).
safety and security focused on preventing a disaster. The Nurses from other hospitals offered to help, and volun-
community health nurse can teach community members how teers brought food; the owners of a restaurant and coffee
to protect themselves from the effects of a natural disaster. shop near the hospital closed their doors to the public and
The nurse can be a part of a safety team, if working as a provided free food and beverages for hospital staff. Massage
school nurse or occupational health nurse. If working for a therapists came to the hospital and volunteered to give mas-
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 451

LEVELS OF PREVENTION MATRIX

SITUATION: A natural disaster—tornado.

GOAL: Using the three levels of prevention, negative health conditions are avoided, or promptly diagnosed and treated,
and the fullest possible potential is restored.

PRIMARY PREVENTION SECONDARY PREVENTION TERTIARY PREVENTION

Health Promotion Primary


and Education Health Protection Early Diagnosis Prompt Treatment Rehabilitation Prevention

Health
Promotion
and Health
Education Protection

• Increase community • Community members • Remain in your • Rescue individuals • Remain safe • Educate • Keep
awareness know what to do and position of safety promptly and get during the community recom-
• Increase community where to go, whether until a community appropriate care for immediate members mended
preparation through at home, work, school, all-clear warning those injured as soon recovery period about the immuniza-
education or elsewhere in the signal is sounded as possible • Accept help from need to tions
• Each person is as community or until rescued • The infrastructure of others—friends, enhance current
prepared as possible • Get to safety before • Leave a damaged the community family, and planning • Community
both physically and the impact—southwest building cautiously, becomes/remains community against physical
emotionally corner of a home’s if able and not intact, keeping services damage structures
basement or an seriously injured, community members • Rebuild family from future need
interior room away and do not return safe from hazards lives through natural rebuilding,
from windows and until it is declared such as live wires, counseling and disasters, with infra-
under heavy furniture safe broken gas lines, and other services to based on structure
fallen debris restabilize life experiences planning
physically, with the and sup-
emotionally, current ports that
spiritually, and disaster improve
financially ability to
withstand
natural
disasters

sages. The nurses received tremendous support from strangers quest from the Logan Airport Employee Assistance Program
and peers across the country. This helped them keep up their (EAP) asking for help with crisis counseling for United Air-
spirits as they dealt with the direct victims, while being indi- lines survivors of 9/11. The planes used in the attacks were
rect victims themselves (Ostrowski, 2001). from American and United Airlines, and the community of
employees felt like survivors because they lived while fellow
Tertiary Prevention. Tertiary disaster prevention in- employees were lost in the disaster. Employees were in tur-
volves reducing the amount and degree of disability or dam- moil, and their ability to function was affected. “The terror-
age resulting from the disaster. Although it involves rehabil- ists had taken away their colleagues, friends and sense of se-
itative work, it can help a community recover and reduce the curity” (DiVitto, 2002, p. 21).
risk of further disasters. In this sense, it becomes a preven- The most important interventions the nurses provided
tive measure. were a listening ear and validation that what the employees
Another example from September 11, 2001, comes from were feeling and experiencing was normal, and often essen-
a nurse living in the Boston area who, after that date, began tial, for healthy grieving. Some employees needed to talk
to lose a sense of hope for her future. She often found it dif- about good times, others were quiet and sad, and others ex-
ficult to assist her patients with their needs because of her pressed a fear of flying again but did so with the support of
own insecurities and fears. She and a peer responded to a re- family and friends. All demonstrated courage and an ability
452 UNIT 4 Community as Client

to continue their lives with a sense of strength and hope. D I S P L A Y 20–3


Working with these employees enabled the nurse to recap-
ture the essence and true meaning of her life (DiVitto, 2002). Nurses at Disaster Sites: Help or Hindrance?

Preparing for Disasters On April 19, 1995, 37-year-old Rebecca Anderson, a


Disaster planning is essential for a community, business, or registered nurse working in Oklahoma City, after
hospital. It involves thinking about details of preparation and hearing a televised report of the bombing of the Fed-
management by all involved, including community leaders, eral Building, went to the site wearing jeans and a
health and safety professionals, and lay people. A disaster sweatshirt. Along with firefighters and other rescue
plan need not be lengthy. Two weeks after the April 1995 workers in hardhats and other protective gear, she
was allowed to enter the scene. Within a short time,
Oklahoma City bombing of the Murrah Federal Building by
Rebecca was struck on the back of the head by a
two American citizens, one hospital distilled its 44-page concrete slab that fell from the building’s wreckage.
manual into a 5-page disaster response guide. Such a concise She died 5 days later of massive cerebral edema.
plan should still contain information on the elements dis- Nurses can learn the following lessons from this
cussed in this and the following section. See Display 20–2 tragedy:
for a summary of these elements. • Never enter a disaster scene unless you are di-
rected to do so by an emergency medical techni-
Personal Preparation. Before we discuss the prepara- cian, fire, or law enforcement official.
tion of a disaster plan for a community, we should consider • Contact local hospitals and clinics to offer your
the need for all nurses to address their own personal pre- help; your medical expertise is more useful in the
paredness to respond in a disaster. Display 20–3 describes clinical environment.
the tragic outcome of one nurse’s lack of preparation when • Take courses in first aid and emergency care. Con-
she attempted to provide nursing care at the scene of the Ok- tact your local Red Cross for a list of courses.
lahoma City bombing. Personal preparedness means that the • Contact your local health department to learn more
nurse has read and understood workplace and community about your community’s disaster plan and how you
disaster plans and has developed a disaster plan for her or his can contribute in the event of a disaster in your
own family. The prepared nurse also has participated in dis- area.
aster drills and knows cardiopulmonary resuscitation and
first aid. Finally, nurses preparing to work in disaster areas
should bring copies of their nursing license and driver’s li-
cense, durable clothing, and basic equipment such as stetho- Have earthquakes, tornadoes, hurricanes, floods, blizzards,
scopes, flashlights, and cellular phones. riots, or other disasters occurred in the past? If so, what (if
any) were the warning signs? Were they heeded? Were peo-
Assessment for Risk Factors and Disaster History.
ple warned in time? Did evacuation efforts remove all peo-
As noted earlier in the chapter, the community health nurse
ple in danger? What were the community’s on-site re-
is uniquely qualified to perform a community assessment for
sponses, and how effective were they? What programs were
risk factors that may contribute to disasters. In addition, the
put in place to rehabilitate the community?
nurse should review the disaster history of the community.
Establishing Authority, Communication, and Trans-
portation. In addition to assessing for preparedness, the
D I S P L A Y 20–2 effective disaster plan establishes a clear chain of authority,
develops lines of communication, and delineates routes of
Elements of a Disaster Plan transport.
Establishing a clear and flexible chain of authority is
A disaster plan should address all of the following: critical for successful implementation of a disaster plan. Usu-
Chain of authority ally, the chain is hierarchical, with, for example, the com-
Lines of communication munity’s governmental head (eg, mayor) initiating the plan,
Routes and modes of transport alerting the media to broadcast warnings, authorizing the po-
Mobilization
lice to begin evacuations, and so on. Within each level of the
Warning
organization, the hierarchy continues. For example, at the lo-
Evacuation
Rescue and recovery cal hospital, the hospital administrator may be responsible
Triage for alerting nurse managers to call in additional personnel.
Treatment Flexibility is essential, because key authority figures may
Support of victims and families themselves be victims of the disaster. If the home of the chief
Care of dead bodies of police is destroyed in an earthquake, his or her second-in-
Disaster worker rehabilitation command must have equal knowledge of the community’s
disaster plan and be able to step in without delay.
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 453

Effective communication is often a point of breakdown ers to or evacuating residents from the scene of a forest fire,
for communities attempting to cope with major disasters. Af- then disaster planners should propose widening the road or
ter the terrorist attacks in Oklahoma City and New York City, clearing a second road. Disaster planners must also consider
phone lines were damaged and cellular sites were over- what routes emergency vehicles will take when transporting
whelmed, making communication difficult. Communication disaster victims to local and outlying hospitals or health care
was possible only through handheld radios or by way of workers to the disaster site. What if the chosen routes are in-
couriers on foot. At times of heightened chaos and stress, as accessible because of floodwaters, advancing fires, mountain
well as after physical damage to communication facilities and slides, or building rubble? Are alternative routes designated?
equipment, misinformation and misinterpretation can flour-
Mobilizing, Warning, and Evacuating. In many nat-
ish, leading to delayed treatment and increased loss of life.
ural disasters, local weather service personnel, public works
Again, clarity and flexibility are the watchwords for es-
officials, police officers, or firefighters have the earliest infor-
tablishing lines of communication. How will warnings be
mation indicating an increasing potential for a disaster. These
communicated? What backups are available if the normal
officials typically have a plan in place for providing commu-
communication systems are destroyed in the disaster? How
nity authorities with specific data indicating increased risk.
will communication between relief workers at the disaster
They may also advise the mayor’s office or other community
site, hospital personnel, police, and governmental authorities
leaders of their recommendations for warning or evacuating
be maintained? What role will local media play, both in keep-
the public. Additionally, they may recommend actions the
ing information flowing to the outside world and in broad-
community can take to mitigate damage, such as spraying
casting needs for assistance and supplies? Finally, how will
rooftops in the path of fires, sandbagging the banks of rising
friends and family members of victims be informed of the
rivers, or imposing a curfew in times of civil unrest.
whereabouts or health status of their loved ones? The char-
Disaster plans must specify the means of communicating
acteristics of effective communication during disasters are
warnings to the public, as well as the precise information that
summarized in Display 20–4.
should be included in warnings. Planners should never as-
Closed or inefficient routes of transportation can also in-
sume that all citizens can be reached by radio or television or
crease injury and loss of life. For example, if a single, narrow
that broadcast systems will be unaffected by the disaster.
mountainous road is the only means of transporting firefight-
Broadcast media may indeed be a primary means of commu-
nicating warnings, but alternative strategies, such as police
or volunteers canvassing neighborhoods with loudspeakers,
D I S P L A Y 20–4 should also be in place. In multilingual communities, mes-
Effective Communication During Disasters sages should be broadcast in multiple languages. Not only
homes but also businesses must be informed. Information that
should be communicated includes the nature of the disaster;
To be effective, communication during disasters must
elicit action. Communication that elicits action pro- the exact geographic region affected, including street names
vides information that is if appropriate, and the actions citizens should take to protect
• Believable themselves and their property.
• Current An evacuation plan is an essential component of the to-
• Unambiguous tal disaster plan. The plan should cover notification of the po-
• Authoritative lice, local military personnel, or voluntary citizens’ groups of
• Predictive of the probability of future events (what the need to evacuate people, as well as methods of notifying
is going to happen next?) and transporting the evacuees. A plan should also be made
Effective communication is for responding to citizens who refuse to evacuate. For exam-
• Interactive—it allows for and addresses questions
ple, will police authorities forcibly remove an elderly citizen
• Conclusive—it eliminates room for speculation and
from his home to a shelter? Will evacuation plans include
catastrophizing
• Urgent—conveys seriousness without resorting to household pets? If farms or ranches are in the path of fires or
fear tactics floods, will animals be evacuated?
• Clear, simple, and repetitive
• Characterized by solutions and suggestions for Responding to Disasters
success At the disaster site, police, firefighters, nurses, and other re-
• Personal—it uses people’s names if possible and lief workers develop a coordinated response to rescue, triage,
addresses their real and perceived needs and treat disaster victims.
Finally, because rumors can hinder effective action or
provoke premature action, effective communication Rescue. One of the first obligations of relief workers is
includes rumor control. It provides suggestions for to remove victims from danger. This job typically falls to
constructive activity, reducing time and energy spent firefighters and personnel with special training in search and
on rumor generation and perpetuation. rescue. Depending on the disaster agent, protective gear,
heavy equipment, and special vehicles may be needed, and
454 UNIT 4 Community as Client

dogs trained to locate dead bodies may be brought in (Fig. ber of casualties exceeds immediate treatment resources. The
20–1). Usually, the immediate disaster site is not the best goal of triage is to effect the greatest amount of good for the
place for the disaster nurse, who can be far more effective in greatest number of people. Figure 20–2 shows the four basic
triage and treatment of victims. One of the lessons of the categories of the international triage system, as well as a
World Trade Center bombing was that the greatest need for triage tag.
medical professionals was at the local hospitals, not at the Prioritization of treatment may be very different in a
disaster site. mass-casualty event as opposed to an average day in a hos-
Rescue workers face the logistically and psychologi- pital emergency department. Under normal circumstances, a
cally difficult task of determining when to cease rescue ef- person presenting to a hospital emergency department with a
forts. Some factors to consider include increasing danger to myocardial infarction and showing no pulse or respirations
rescue workers, diminishing numbers of survivors, and di- would receive immediate treatment and have a chance of re-
minishing possibilities for survival. For example, after a covery. At a disaster site, a victim without a pulse or respi-
plane crash on a snowy mountain, rescue efforts may cease
if it is deemed that anyone who might have survived the crash
would subsequently have died from exposure.
Triage. Whereas emergency nurses daily determine
which clients require priority care, the community health
nurse may be at a loss as to where to start when faced with
multiple victims of a disaster. Knowing the principles and
practice of triage allows the nurse to offer her or his nursing
skills most effectively.
Triage is the process of sorting multiple casualties in the
event of a war or major disaster. It is required when the num-

1. Red: Urgent/Critical
Victims in this category have injuries or medical problems that
will likely lead to death if not treated immediately (e.g., an un-
conscious victim with signs of internal bleeding).
2. Yellow: Delayed
Victims in this category have injuries that will require medical
attention; however, time to medical treatment is not yet critical
(e.g., a conscious victim with a fractured femur).
3. Green: Minor/Walking Wounded
Victims in this category have sustained minor injury or are pre-
senting with minimal signs of illness. Prolonged delay in care
most likely will not adversely effect their long-term outcome
(e.g., a conscious victim with superficial cuts, scrapes, and
bruises).
4. Black: Dead/Non-salvageable
Victims in this category are obviously dead or have suffered
mortal wounds because of which death is imminent (e.g., an
unconscious victim with an open skull fracture with brain mat-
ter showing). Life-saving heroics on this group of victims will
only delay medical care on more viable victims.

FIGURE 20–2. Victim triage tag recom-


FIGURE 20–1. Hazardous ma- mended by the California Fire Chiefs Association. There are four
terials suit used by the military and most fire depart- basic categories that are all applied when a medical system is over-
ments. (Photo by Cynthia Tait.) whelmed with victims. (Photo by Cynthia Tait.)
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 455

rations would most likely be placed in the nonsalvageable As stated earlier, a family’s recovery from their loss is often
category. delayed when notification of relatives (indirect victims) is
Mass casualties refers to a number of victims that is not possible because the victims’ bodies are badly damaged
greater than that which can be managed safely with the re- or not found. This was a major problem of the World Trade
sources the community has to offer, such as rescue vehicles Center disaster, in which few of the victims were found. In
and emergency facilities available to serve disaster victims some cases, only minute pieces of tissue were available for
while also meeting the needs of the rest of the community. DNA processing. In other situations, just a piece of jewelry
Frequently in mass casualty occurrences, the broader com- or clothing remained. And for some victims, no remains were
munity needs to become involved, which necessitates calling found.
in rescue vehicles, firefighters, and police officers from
neighboring towns, or the use of neighboring hospitals. This Supporting Recovery From Disasters
adds another layer of disaster management coordination that Disasters do not suddenly end when the rubble is cleared and
must be considered. the victims’ wounds are healed. Rather, recovery is a long,
complex process that often includes long-term medical treat-
Immediate Treatment and Support. Disaster nurses
ment, physical rehabilitation, financial restitution, and psy-
provide treatment on-site at emergency treatment stations, in
chological and spiritual support.
shelters, or at local hospitals and clinics. In addition to direct
nursing care, on-site interventions might include arranging for Long-Term Treatment. Long-term treatment may be
transport once victims are stabilized and managing the pro- required for many victims of disasters, straining the local re-
curement, distribution, and replenishment of all supplies. habilitative-care facilities and resources. Children who were
Disposable items might be in short supply, requiring resteril- victims may have to deal with lifelong disabilities or scars
ization procedures that may be unfamiliar to a nurse not ac- from their ordeal, and families may be without adequate fi-
customed to field work. These procedures may pose a chal- nancial support for their child’s medical care. Elderly citi-
lenge even to an experienced nurse because of the field zens who may formerly have been in excellent health but
environment. The nurse may also manage provision or distri- who sustained serious injuries in the disaster might suddenly
bution of food and beverages, including infant formulas and find that they can no longer live independently and must
rehydration fluids, and arrange for adequate, accessible, and move to a long-term care facility. After floods, landslides,
safe sanitation facilities, either on-site or in a shelter. Finally, fires, or earthquakes, extensive property damage may cause
the nurse often must also arrange for psychological and spiri- some residents or businesses to relocate rather than rebuild
tual care of victims of disasters. on land they now deem to be disaster-prone. A disaster that
Some victims who seem physically uninjured may, in creates numerous victims in a small community may alter the
fact, be suffering from major injuries but be unable to relate entire social fabric of that community permanently.
their symptoms to a relief worker because of shock or anxi-
Long-Term Support. Victims of disasters may need
ety about injured, dead, or missing loved ones. For instance,
funding to repair or rebuild their homes or to reopen busi-
a father pulling debris away from his collapsed house after a
nesses, such as stores, restaurants, and other services needed
tornado may be so worried about a missing child that he does
by the community. Insurance settlements, FEMA funding,
not realize that he has a broken arm.
and private donations may assist in financing community re-
Other victims may be so emotionally traumatized by a
habilitation. Health care workers may be required to assist
disaster that they act out, disrupting efforts to assist them and
victims in filling out necessary paperwork. Immediately af-
other victims and even engaging in dangerous activities. This
ter a disaster, some victims may be unable to concentrate on
may cause relief workers to focus on emotional care; how-
anything beyond fulfilling their immediate needs and those
ever, such victims must be assessed for head trauma and in-
of their family.
ternal injuries, because their behavior may have a physical
Psychological support is often required after a disaster,
cause. If they are physically able, such victims may be given
both for victims and for relief workers. Some individuals
a simple, repetitive task to perform, which serves as both a
may experience posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), a
distraction and a means to restore, to a small extent, their
syndrome that may be marked by flashbacks, nightmares,
sense of control over their environment.
disinterest in daily affairs, hypervigilance, survivor’s guilt,
Care of Bodies and Notification of Families. Identifi- or decreased concentration. The “traumatic event” criterion
cation and transport of the dead to a morgue or holding fa- for PTSD, as set forth in the current edition of the Diagnos-
cility are crucial, especially if contagion is feared. Toe tags tic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, was un-
make documentation visible and accessible. Records of doubtedly met by the coordinated attacks on New York City,
deaths must be made and maintained, and family members the Pentagon, and Flight 93 on September 11, 2001. Less dra-
should be notified of their loved ones’ deaths as quickly and matically, many victims, especially elderly persons dis-
compassionately as possible. If feasible, a representative placed from their homes, may quietly lose their will to live
from each of the area’s faith communities should be avail- and drift into apathy and malaise. Individuals whose belief in
able to assist families awaiting news of missing loved ones. God was unshakable before the incident may now wonder
456 UNIT 4 Community as Client

how God could have let this happen, especially if they have Need for Self-Care. Self-care, including stress educa-
lost a loved one. These victims often require not only em- tion for all relief workers after a disaster, helps to lower anx-
pathic listening but also long-term skilled spiritual counsel- iety and put the situation into proper perspective. Critical in-
ing before they can begin to regain their former faith. In as- cident stress debriefing (CISD) provides victims with
sessing a community’s citizens for counseling needs after a professional debriefing in small groups or individually and
disaster, the nurse should not forget to include children. Of- becomes a mechanism for emotional reconciliation. The
ten, children do not have words to express their feelings or ideal time for CISD is between 24 and 72 hours after the dis-
fears and may act out in ways adults find difficult to under- aster event. Positive effects of CISD include
stand, unless age-appropriate psychological intervention is • Accelerating the healing process
provided. • Equipping participants with positive coping mechanisms
Many studies were generated out of the unprecedented • Clearing up misconceptions and misunderstandings
exposure to trauma in the United States on September 11, • Restoring or reinforcing group cohesiveness
2001. Some researchers examined mental health needs in • Promoting a healthy, supportive work atmosphere
New York State and the public costs of mental health re- • Identifying individuals who require more extensive psy-
sponse after the attacks (Jack & Glied, 2002; Herman, Fel- chological assistance
ton, & Susser, 2002). Others studied immediate psychologi- CISD addresses all components of the human response to
cal reactions and reactions up to 6 months after the attacks. trauma, including physiologic effects, emotions, and cognition.
(Schlenger et al., 2002; Silver et al., 2002) (see Research: Studies have shown that CISD allows individuals to regain a
Bridge to Practice I). sense of normalcy much sooner than those not receiving CISD.

RESEARCH: BRIDGE TO PRACTICE I

Silver, R.C., Holman, E.A., McIntosh, D.N., Poulin, M., • Severity of exposure to the attacks
& Gil-Rivas, V. (2002). Nationwide longitudinal study • Early disengagement from coping efforts
of psychological responses to September 11. JAMA, • Denial
288(10), 1235–1244. Global distress was associated with severity of loss
due to the attacks, early coping strategies and giving up,
On September 11, 2001 the United States experienced which decreased with active coping.
the most deadly terrorist attacks ever to occur on home Conclusions were that the psychological effects of a
soil. The traumatic events affected many people directly major national traumatic event are not limited to those
and the entire nation indirectly. Researchers found this who experience it directly. In addition, the degree of
to be a unique opportunity to examine longitudinally the traumatic response is not predicted simply by exposure
process of adjustment. to or loss from the trauma. “Instead, use of specific cop-
A national probability sample of 3496 adults received ing strategies [seeking social support, active coping, de-
a Web-based survey. The questionnaire focused on stress- nial, behavioral disengagement] shortly after an event is
related symptoms and behaviors that represent adjust- associated with symptoms over time. In particular, dis-
ment or maladjustment; respondents were polled initially engaging from coping efforts can signal the likelihood
and at 2 and 6 months after the event. Seventy-eight per- of psychological difficulties up to 6 months after a
cent (2729 individuals) completed the survey within 23 trauma” (p. 1235).
days of the terrorist attacks; 1069 of the participants who This study suggests that even individuals who are not
resided outside New York City were selected from the directly exposed to a trauma may demonstrate poten-
first wave of respondents. The main outcome measures tially disturbing levels of trauma-related symptoms.
were September 11–related symptoms of acute stress, Symptoms that appear in a large number of indirectly af-
posttraumatic stress, and global distress. Seventeen per- fected people may represent a normal response to an ab-
cent of the U. S. population surveyed outside of New normal event. The study suggests that the use of coping
York City reported symptoms of September 11–related strategies enhances recovery. A community health nurse
posttraumatic stress 2 months after the attacks, and 5.8% needs to be cognizant of this relationship and prepared
reported them at 6 months. High levels of posttraumatic to enhance it in clients who experience a traumatic
stress symptoms were associated with event. Rituals and activities that provide comfort—such
• Being female as participation in faith community rituals, sharing fears
• Marital separation and concerns with family and friends, and talking about
• Pre–September 11 physician-diagnosed depression or feelings with others, lay and professional—are examples
anxiety disorder or physical illness of healthy coping strategies.
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 457

Self-care comes in many forms and is part of a prescrip- Types of Group Violence
tion for emotional healing after a traumatic event. Self-care
is not just for rescue workers but for everyone touched by The problem of family violence is discussed in more detail in
trauma. Keep in mind the following self-care points (Peeke, Chapter 25, school and adolescent violence in Chapter 28, and
2002): workplace violence in Chapter 29. This chapter presents an
• Give yourself time to heal. You need time to adjust. Even overview of group violence and how it affects communities.
though you want the pain to be over immediately, it is
Gang Violence
healthier to realize that this is a long-term recovery
The California Attorney General defines a gang as a loose-
process.
knit organization of individuals between the ages of 14 and
• Ask for emotional support. Talk with family and friends
24 years that has a name, is usually territorial or claims a cer-
around the country. It feels good to be connected with oth-
tain territory as being under its exclusive influence, and is in-
ers. You listen and support one another as you share your
volved in criminal acts. Its members associate together and
feelings.
commit crimes against other gangs or against the general
• Take care of yourself; it will improve your ability to deal
population. Gangs are most commonly involved in drug dis-
with stress. Eat regularly, avoid alcohol, maintain sleep
tribution, aggravated assault, robbery, burglary, and motor
patterns, follow your exercise routine, and embrace each
vehicle theft (Huff, 2002). Some gangs focus on stealing,
day as a gift.
whereas others focus on fighting. Large cities are the most
• Reestablish daily routines. Getting back to your regular
likely to have gang problems, and rural counties are the least
routine is important and gives you a sense of security and
likely.
normalcy.
There are theories on how gangs form. Hirschi’s (2004)
• Use your time wisely. A significant traumatic event gives
social bond theory proposed that criminal behavior results
you an opportunity to reprioritize how you spend your
from the weakening (in youth) of the ties that bind the indi-
time each day. Are you living your dreams and passions?
vidual to society. He believed that the strong subcultural
Traumatic events remind us of our fragile nature and that
bonds insulate the individual from conventional behavior.
each moment should be savored and enjoyed.
Gangs often require members to display symbols of their
• Give something back. Your life goes on. Demonstrate
allegiance to one another. These symbols also serve to iden-
your gratefulness by becoming part of a global healing
tify them to other gangs. They may include certain colors,
process. Donate to charities and give time to causes you
special caps or coats, tattoos, handshakes or other signs, and
have ignored. Seek ways to reach out to those who are in
terminology unique to the gang. Gangs may also require
need of help.
members to participate in rites of passage or “hazing” to test
their loyalty, events that often involve committing a crime.
Gang members usually share the same ethnicity or at least the
GROUP VIOLENCE same belief system. Many gangs today have sophisticated
Web sites and are capable of equally sophisticated crimes
The rates of group violence and violent crime decreased in (Huff, 2002; Miller, Maxson, & Klein, 2001).
many U. S. cities at the end of the 1990s. The actual number Gang members consider themselves family and turn to
of violent crimes peaked in 1993 at almost 4.2 million annu- each other for support. Often, members are searching for emo-
ally. By 1998, that number had dropped to less than 2.8 mil- tional intimacy in the gang as a substitute for a dysfunctional
lion (U. S. Department of Justice, 1999). The U. S. Depart- family that is unwilling or unable to provide that intimacy.
ment of Justice’s National Crime Victimization Survey Gangs also provide discipline and a structured environment to
(NCVS) for 2000–2001 indicated that violent crime had de- young people who, because of absent or unresponsive parents,
creased another 10%, making its incidence the lowest in may have a strong desire for an external locus of authority and
NCVS history (since 1973) (U. S. Department of Justice, a set of predictable rules and regulations.
2002). According to the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s
Uniform Crime Reports, the crime index rate fell for the 10th Riots
straight year in 2000, declining 3.3% from 1999, 18.8% from A riot is a violent disturbance created by a large number of
1996, and 30.1% from 1991 (U. S. Department of Justice, people assembled for a common purpose. It may or may not
2002). However, violent crime is still an emotional and pow- involve criminal activities, such as willful destruction of
erful public issue, often influencing our votes, our choices of cars, stores, and other property; looting (stealing goods); ar-
where to live, work, shop, and vacation, and our decisions son (the deliberate burning of buildings); lynching (execu-
about where and how to educate our children. Indeed, the tion by hanging without due process of law); or physical at-
American Public Health Association (APHA) has worked for tacks on a perceived enemy or on law enforcement officers.
many years to turn the spotlight on violence as a public health Riots often erupt during times of war, political instabil-
issue. Gun violence in particular both a public health emer- ity, racial inequity, and economic injustice. For example, in
gency and a grave threat to an entire generation of young the United States, the decades of the 1960s and 1970s were
adults (USDHHS, 2000). marked by frequent demonstrations against the Vietnam
458 UNIT 4 Community as Client

War, which occasionally escalated from peaceful marches or when a youth gang assaults and rapes a woman jogging on
and protests to full-scale riots. Riots have also been sparked its “turf” after dark.
during protests of racial inequities and are especially com- Both agent and environmental factors can contribute to
mon after announcements of legal decisions that are per- rape. Some of the more common factors are an increased his-
ceived as racist. For example, when the officers accused of tory of childhood sexual abuse among rapists, a patriarchal
assaulting Rodney King in Los Angeles were acquitted in value system in which men are expected to prove their mas-
April 1992, violent riots caused 53 deaths, 2000 arrests, and culinity by dominating or “conquering” women, and an en-
more than 1 billion dollars in property damage. Internation- vironment in which violence is explicitly or implicitly ac-
ally, riots often erupt over sporting events, especially if the cepted or encouraged.
fans are close to the action. Fans storm the field, assault offi-
Homicide. Homicide is the killing of one person by an-
cials, and attack the opposing team after a bad play or deci-
other. Like the rates for group violence overall, the homicide
sion that negatively affects the outcome for their team. Such
rate is declining. In 1980, there were 10.2 homicides for
riots have caused multiple injuries and deaths. Inflated food
every 100,000 people in the United States; by 1998, this rate
prices or inequitable distribution of food or supplies can pre-
had fallen to 6.2 per 100,000 (U.S. Department of Health
cipitate a riot. In 1999, for example, there were widespread
and Human Services, 2000). However, homicide is still the
riots in India in protest of the inflated price and limited avail-
leading cause of death for African-American youth aged 15
ability of onions, a staple in the Indian diet.
to 24 years. Their murder rate is an alarming 25.2 per
100,000 people (compared with 4.3 per 100,000 for white
Violent Crimes by Specific Groups of
youths and 9.9 per 100,000 for Hispanic youths). Even
Perpetrators
though homicide rates in the United States have improved,
Violent crimes are those involving physical or psychological
the rate among males aged 15 to 24 years in the United
injury or death, or the threat of injury or death. These crimes
States is 10 times higher than in Canada, 15 times higher
are often accompanied by destruction to or loss of property.
than in Australia, and 28 times higher than in France or Ger-
For example, armed robbery is considered a violent crime, re-
many (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services,
gardless of whether anyone is injured during the crime.
2000). Studies have shown that factors identified with vio-
Assault and Battery. Legally, assault and battery lence include, but are not limited to “complex interactions
refers to the threat to use force against another person, and between poverty, racism, excess consumption of alcohol,
the accomplishment of that threat. More loosely, assault can the plethora of illegal drugs, dysfunctional familial rela-
be used to refer to any violent attack such as assault with a tions, abuse of children by adults, scarcity of viable em-
deadly weapon or sexual assault. Domestic assault is dis- ployment and resources, lack of effective hand gun regula-
cussed in Chapter 25. tion, inadequate services from schools and other social
One type of group assault that is becoming more preva- agencies, stereotyping between peer groups and between
lent is assault on the homeless. These assaults are usually adults and children, and a general erosion of respect for in-
perpetrated on individual homeless men, often by groups of dividual rights of freedom, security, and responsibility”
three or more young men who beat the victim severely and (Benda & Turney, 2002, p. 7).
sometimes fatally, sometimes for no other reason than that he In addition, the 21st century has already been marred by
asked them for money. Alcohol and drugs are often factors. numerous instances of multiple homicides in schools, uni-
In addition, abuse of the homeless is considered to be a new versities, restaurants, and workplaces. For example, on
and underestimated hate crime (Bacque, 2000). March 1, 2000, a gunman in Pennsylvania went on a shoot-
ing spree at his apartment complex and at two fast-food
Rape. Legal definitions of rape vary, but the key ele-
restaurants, killing two people and critically wounding three.
ments include some form of sexual contact and a lack of con-
In the summer of 2002, a 10-year-old girl in the Bronx, New
sent. Consent is considered lacking under conditions of
York, was fatally struck by a stray bullet after gang members
force, deception, or coercion, or when the victim is a minor
looking for free food and beer crashed a baby’s christening
or is drugged, unconscious, mentally retarded, or physically
party at a church. In the fall of 2002, the areas around Silver
restrained.
Spring, Maryland; Washington, D.C.; and northern Virginia
Different categories of rape are commonly described.
were terrorized by two snipers who randomly killed or in-
One of the most common is date rape, in which the assailant
jured 13 people engaged in everyday activities (see What Do
and victim meet by mutual consent but the assailant forces
You Think? I).
the victim to engage in a sexual act against the victim’s will.
Stranger rape is sudden and usually violent, involving the Genocide. The most notorious historical example of
use of a knife, gun, or violent physical force. Statutory rape genocide, the killing of a group of people because of their
refers to sexual intercourse with a female who has not racial, political, or cultural differences, was the murder of mil-
reached the statutory age of consent; in many states, this age lions of Jews, Catholics, gypsies, homosexuals, intellectuals,
is 14 years. Rape may also be perpetrated by a group, as when and other “undesirables” by the Nazis before and during
a group of college men drug and then rape a female student World War II. Tragically, genocide continues today. Recent
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 459

Dr. James Garbarino, author of Lost Boys: Why Our Sons Turn
WHAT DO YOU THINK? I Violent and How We Can Save Them (1999), observes that chil-
dren “have ample opportunities to see on television and in the
movies how you threaten people, what it means to shoot some-
One of the reasons our national homicide rates are
one, and ample opportunities to learn about revenge and how
going down may be the improvements in emergency
desirable it is in this society. For the nation to be shocked and
care achieved over the past 30 years. Medical tech-
appalled . . . is either a kind of denial or hypocrisy.”
nology has helped to lower the death rate among as-
Simple access to weapons cannot be discounted as a fac-
sault victims by almost 70%, in the process
tor in criminal activity. The United States imposes fewer re-
decreasing the national murder rate. People who
strictions on the manufacture, sale, and licensure of guns than
would have ended up in morgues 20 years ago are
any other industrialized nation and, as a correlate, is faced
now simply treated and released by a hospital, often
with higher rates of gun-related injuries and murders. Many
in a matter of a few days. As good as this news is, it
of the youths involved in school shootings in the United States
artificially improves homicide statistics. Violence is
in the 1990s had easy access to guns that belonged to parents,
still being committed, but the victims survive and do
other relatives, or neighbors. Weapons such as simple bombs
not become homicide statistics.
can be made from instructions found on the Internet. Increas-
ingly, rifles and assault weapons, rather than handguns, are
Associated Press. (2002, August 12). Medical ad-
being used in acts of group violence. These weapons allow for
vances, drop in death rate linked. The Fresno Bee, A5.
more rapid firing of more bullets and tend to cause signifi-
cantly higher numbers of casualties. The murders of 12 stu-
dents and 1 teacher in the 1999 assault on Columbine High
examples include the mass “ethnic cleansings” in Bosnia, School in Colorado, for example, were made possible by the
Rwanda, and Kosovo in the last decade of the 20th century. easy acquisition and use of these more sophisticated weapons
(see Research: Bridge to Practice II).
Factors Contributing to Group
Healthy People 2010 Goals for
Violence
Reducing Group Violence
Violence among specific groups of perpetrators and violence
The Healthy People 2010 document (U.S. Department of
directed toward selected groups of people often has its roots
Health and Human Services, 2000) lists a number of goals for
in the childhood or youth of the perpetrators. These forms of
reducing youth violence, including the following:
violence can be traced to many causes. The U. S. Department
• Reduce physical assaults among people aged 12 years and
of Justice has identified a number of host causes or correlates
older to less than 25.5 per 1000 persons from a baseline in
of delinquency, including feelings of alienation or rebel-
1998 of 31.1 per 1000 persons.
liousness and lack of societal bonding (Wilson & Howell,
• Reduce to 33.3% the prevalence of physical fighting
1993). Environmental factors include
among adolescents in grades 9 through 12, from a base-
• Parental conflict, lack of supervision, child abuse, or in-
line in 1997 of 36.6%.
consistent parenting
• Reduce to less than 6% the prevalence of weapon carry-
• Negative school experiences, including early academic
ing by adolescents in grades 9 through 12, from a baseline
failure and lack of commitment to school
in 1997 of 8.5%.
• Negative peer influence, including peers who engage in
In addition, Healthy People 2010 calls for a reduction in
criminal activity
work-related homicides to no more than 0.4 per 100,000 work-
• Socioeconomic factors, such as high rates of substance
ers, from a baseline in 1998 of 0.5 per 100,000. It also calls for
abuse in the community, living in a high-crime neighbor-
a reduction in workplace assault to no more than 0.6 per 100
hood, and economic deprivation
workers, from a baseline in 1987–1992 of 0.85 per 100.
The roots of youth gang problems are multifactorial.
They may be related to lack of social opportunities, social
disorganization, institutional racism, cultural maladaptation,
Role of the Community Health
deficiencies in social policy, and availability of criminal
Nurse
opportunities. Community health nurses can play a key role in reducing
Additionally, frequent exposure to violence in the news, at group violence by interacting with students, parents, churches,
sporting events, on television programs, in movies, on the In- law enforcement officials, local politicians, and community
ternet, in video games, and in violent pornography has been organizers.
linked to an increase in aggression. Children seem to be espe-
cially vulnerable, and the link seems to be particularly strong if Preventing Group Violence
the subject matter glorifies violence as the ideal and appropri- The typical model for preventing or reducing group violence
ate solution to personal problems (Goode, 2000). For example, includes activities such as assessing the problem, developing
460 UNIT 4 Community as Client

RESEARCH BRIDGE TO PRACTICE II

Schuster, M.A., Franke, T.M., Bastian, A.M., Sor, S., & firearms unlocked, unloaded, and stored with ammuni-
Halfon, N. (2000). Firearm storage patterns in US tion, and 9% kept firearms unlocked and loaded. There-
homes with children. American Journal of Public fore, a total of 13%—some 1.4 million homes with 2.6
Health, 90(4), 588–594. million children—store firearms in a manner accessible
to children.
SAFETY AND HOME FIREARM STORAGE
The percentage of children living in homes with
PATTERNS
firearms increases with the child’s age, from 28% for
The researchers involved with this study used data children younger than 1 year of age to 38% for chil-
from the 1994 National Health Interview Survey dren aged 13 to 17 years. The types of firearms in-
(NHIS) and the Year 2000 Objectives supplement to cluded handguns (53%), shotguns (61%), rifles (65%),
study the presence of firearms in the home and firearm and other types (2%). With the accessibility of firearms
storage patterns among families with children. The increasing in households as children age, loading of
NHIS is an annual survey covering demographics, firearms by older children is a possibility.
health, health care utilization, and insurance. One sec- Community health nurses, of course, do not control
tion of the Year 2000 supplement covers firearms. what goes on in the homes of families with children.
Respondents from the 6990 sample homes with chil- Ultimately, families decide what they believe is best.
dren younger than 18 years of age (representing more We can, however, make sure that when families make
than 22 million children in more than 11 million homes) these decisions, they are informed about the risks asso-
reported that they had at least one firearm (69% re- ciated with firearms and how to reduce those risks.
ported having more than one firearm), with 43% keep- Special efforts may be warranted to address firearm
ing at least one unlocked firearm. Overall, 4% kept safety issues directly with adolescents.

policy based on established objectives, conducting research,


procuring funding, and promoting offender accountability. D I S P L A Y 20–5
For example, an increase in rapes on one university campus
Actions Schools Can Take to Reduce
might prompt the nursing department to facilitate a univer-
Violence
sity-wide open forum to discuss the issue, identify possible
factors, initiate research, and develop solutions. Programs
might include outreach to all students currently enrolled at the Schools can take the following actions to reduce their
risk for violence:
university through dormitory teaching sessions, church-group
• Improve environmental design
activities, involvement of team coaches for university sports, • Install surveillance cameras, metal detectors, and
and even participation by teachers and student advisors. pay phones or dial-free access connections to
Violence can be reduced in elementary and secondary emergency services
schools by increasing supervision and surveillance. Exam- • Increase security personnel
ples of successful actions some schools have taken are listed • Decrease access by outsiders to campus
in Display 20–5. • Institute school-wide safety plans, drills, and codes
Community health nurses can influence the reduction of • Train administrators and teachers to identify poten-
school violence by establishing strong cooperative relation- tially violent or psychologically impaired students
ships between adults and students, recognizing (and helping • Identify students who are associated with gangs
others, such as parents and teachers, to recognize) behaviors • Expel students who are caught with weapons on
campus
that could signal a problem, and identifying situations that
• Suspend or expel students for threatened or real
may predispose teens to violence. The “Six Vs” can be used acts of violence
to help identify teens who may need evaluation, especially if • Institute a policy that allows for searching students
the frequency or intensity of these behaviors increases (Ste- and lockers
ger, 2000): • Hold parents accountable for students’ actions and
• Venting—angry outbursts inappropriate for the child’s make them financially responsible for any damages
age, frequent mood swings, and other behaviors indicat- incurred
ing poor control of emotions
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 461

• Vocalizing—threats by a teen to harm self or others, or An effective school gang-suppression strategy should
use of inappropriate language or profanity include the following:
• Vandalizing—intentional damage of property or a history • Development of guidelines for appropriate teacher and staff
of vandalism, even targeting his or her own property responses to a variety of gang behaviors and delinquency
• Victimizing—teens who see themselves as victims, • Application and enforcement of rules and regulations
whether true or not, become just as prone to violence as that support positive relationships and communication
those who have actually been abused; they blame others among school personnel, parents, students, and commu-
for their problems and do not take responsibility for their nity agencies
actions • Development of parenting and gang-awareness classes
• Vying (for attention)—being involved in gangs or fringe • Establishment of training programs for increasing knowl-
groups, acting out in class, bringing weapons or other con- edge about gangs and the community resources available
traband to school to show others, wearing outlandish or for assistance
banned clothing, or purposefully getting suspended or Finally, although community health nurses cannot pre-
expelled. vent riots, they can be familiar persons in their neighbor-
• Viewing—like actual victims of abuse, young people who hoods, encouraging the sharing of feelings of anger or hostil-
witness the abuse of others are likely to display violent ity or the exchange of information about criminal activities.
tendencies themselves. Also, the nurse is usually familiar with the normal environ-
Community health nurses can become involved through ment in the neighborhood—the flow of people, the degree of
the following actions: friendliness of neighbors and business owners, and the usual
• Speaking about school violence at middle and high school activities. The nurse can use this familiarity to detect when
assemblies, PTA meetings, parenting meetings, neighbor- something feels “unusual.” Part of continuous community as-
hood watch meetings, and church meetings sessment includes gathering such subconscious impressions
• Encouraging parents to involve their children in youth or intuitions. If cues from the community indicate increased
group programs such as the Boy or Girl Scouts, Big tensions or exaggerated negative feelings toward particular
Brothers/Big Sisters, faith community youth groups, and persons or groups, the nurse can share this information with
4-H; donating time to these groups; or, if they do not ex- the proper authorities. Many neighborhoods are served by
ist in the community, working to establish them community centers where there are social workers, educators,
• Participating in local and national crime-prevention neighborhood-watch groups, probation officers, and other
councils community service workers, all excellent resources with
• Joining professional nursing organizations that engage in whom the nurse can share perceptions.
campaigns to reduce violence
• Writing, producing, or promoting public service an- Assessing a Community’s Level or
nouncements that aim to reduce violence Potential for Violence
• Promoting the inclusion of articles about group violence School nurses are in an ideal position to identify behaviors
in local newspapers, community newsletters, and faith- that indicate an increased potential for youth violence and to
based community bulletins initiate age-appropriate therapies. It is crucial to identify
• Offering ongoing anger management and conflict resolu- these behaviors early and to teach others to watch for them
tion courses (National Crime Prevention Council, 2002). The following
To reduce gang membership and associated violence, indicators can be used to identify potentially violent youths:
positive social development starting from infancy and an in- • Depression or mood swings
tensive focus on interactions within the school system are • Obsession with violent or pornographic games, Internet
crucial. The school nurse or community health nurse work- sites, television shows, or movies
ing in education can sponsor programs to nurture social val- • Absence of age-appropriate anger-management skills
ues and ethics and to help students dissociate from delin- • Artwork, writing, or language that displays violence, pro-
quent peers and role models. After-school programs in which fanity, anger, association with gangs, or social isolation
youths have an opportunity to play sports; volunteer with the • Evidence of cruelty to animals
poor, the sick, or the elderly; or challenge their learning in • History of bullying or fighting
math clubs and on debate teams can improve self-esteem and • Self-perception as a victim
reduce the seduction of gang membership. • Obsession with violence or weapons
The community health nurse can also provide proactive All riots begin with an altercation between two or more
leadership in preventing gang activity. Community mobi- people that accelerates out of control. In assessing a commu-
lization and local organization are key components. Addi- nity’s potential for a riot, the nurse needs to be keenly and
tionally, understanding of both the roots of specific gang is- continually aware of interactions among individuals and
sues and the community conditions that contribute to the small groups within the community. In some sharply divided
problem is necessary for finding solutions and alternatives to communities, even disagreements at a school board or town
youth gang involvement. council meeting can escalate into localized riots. In commu-
462 UNIT 4 Community as Client

nities where drug dealing is common, riots between gangs the world. Incidents occurring on U.S. soil such as the bomb-
can occur when drug deals “go bad” or police conduct large ing of the World Trade Center in 1993 and its destruction on
“sting” operations. Communities that are fraught with September, 11, 2001, along with the other terrorist attacks
poverty, high levels of unemployment or ethnic or racial di- that day, have alerted us to our vulnerability and dramatically
visions also experience a high level of tension that can erupt emphasized the need for increased preparedness within our
into violence over seemingly minor events, such as a routine communities. The anthrax scares after September 11 con-
arrest of individuals in a barroom brawl. Even the number firmed that our vulnerability exists in many areas; biologic,
and quality of constructive after-school activities for older chemical, and nuclear terrorist threats are possible.
children and teens can be a predictor of group violence, be- The U. S. Federal Bureau of Investigation defines ter-
cause restless teens who roam neighborhood streets, drink- rorism as “the unlawful use of force and violence against
ing alcohol and “looking for fun,” often end up engaged in persons or property to intimidate or coerce a government,
violent fights and group crimes. The community health nurse the civilian population, or any segment thereof, in further-
has an obligation to assess the potential for group violence in ance of political or social objectives” (Evans et al, 2002).
all of these areas. A terrorist is overzealous and obsessed with an idea. Ter-
rorism and terrorist acts are not new; although the term ter-
Responding to Group Violence rorism can be traced back to 1798, the use of terrorist tac-
Community models for addressing the problem of group vi- tics precedes this date. A highly organized religious sect
olence should involve as many community members as pos- called the sicarii attacked crowds of people with knives
sible. Not only key legislators and law enforcement officials, during holiday celebrations in Palestine at about the time
but also former criminals, current gang members, and youth of Christ. During the French and Indian War of 1763,
and adult offenders should be included. Community reli- British forces gave smallpox-contaminated blankets to Na-
gious leaders, educators, members of social and cultural or- tive Americans. During World War I, the German
ganizations, and criminologists can contribute significantly bioweapons program developed anthrax, glanders,
to the development of effective plans for action that the en- cholera, and wheat fungus as weapons targeting cavalry
tire community can endorse. The community health nurse animals. In World War II, the Japanese tested biologic
also should be integrally involved in these community ac- weapons on Chinese prisoners.
tions to reduce group violence. Three major countries operated offensive bioweapons
programs in recent years: the United Kingdom until 1957, the
Supporting Recovery From Group United States until 1969, and the former Soviet Union until
Violence 1990. Iraq started its bioweapons program in 1985 and con-
Although the community health nurse should leave investi- tinued to develop weapons until 2003. At least 17 other nations
gation and suppression of violent crime to law enforcement are currently suspected of operating offensive bioweapons
officials, an effective interface for community rehabilitation programs (Evans et al., 2002). Bioweapons include such
may involve education, community mobilization, and out- things as mustard gas, materials to create sarin and VX gas,
reach. Comprehensive case management is paramount. Mul- and anthrax.
tiagency cooperation is required to provide needed services Terrorists typically use nuclear, biologic, or chemical
for mental health, drug treatment, family counseling, job (NBC) agents and explosives or incendiary devices to deliver
training and placement, reentry to school or the workforce, the agents to their targets.
formation of more positive social alliances, and expanded Nuclear warfare involves the use of nuclear devices as
economic opportunities. weapons and can take several forms. Terrorists who gain ac-
Counseling is the primary rehabilitative intervention for cess to nuclear power plants could cause a chain of events
victims of rape. It may be necessary not only immediately af- that lead to a meltdown of the nuclear core, thereby releasing
ter the attack but months or even years later, as new re- radioactive particles for hundreds of miles around the site.
sponses and reactions arise. In addition, options for preg- Nuclear accidents have occurred, but no known terrorist at-
nancy prevention and the prevention of sexually transmitted tacks have yet involved the use of nuclear power plants as
disease need to be discussed. Possible exposure to human im- weapons. A terrorist attack using nuclear weapons or de-
munodeficiency virus (HIV) is another harrowing aspect of struction of a nuclear plant would cause multiple and pro-
rape with which women need medical and psychological longed deaths with extensive damage and negative effects
support to cope. for decades.
Chemical warfare involves the use of chemicals such
as explosives, nerve agents, blister agents, choking agents,
TERRORISM and incapacitating or riot-control agents to cause confusion,
debilitation, death, and destruction (Yergler, 2002). Terror-
At the start of the 21st century, the world is a global com- ists in the Middle East, willing to sacrifice their own lives,
munity. This is particularly evident in the increased inci- strap bombs to themselves and detonate the explosives in or
dence and sophistication of terrorist threats and acts around near targets. Others crash vehicles loaded with explosives
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 463

into crowds of people or into a building. Many such incidents duce voter turnout in an upcoming county election, they
have occurred during the war in Iraq in 2003–2004. sprinkled Salmonella bacteria over items on salad bars in lo-
The aircraft used on September 11, 2001, were huge cal restaurants and in the produce sections of grocery stores.
chemical weapons because they were carrying thousands of They hoped that, with a reduced voter turnout, representa-
tons of jet fuel. The success of the mission depended on the tives friendlier to their group would win the election. Their
surprise of the attack, severe damage to recognizable build- attack failed to affect the election and killed no one; however,
ings, and the deaths of many people. The collapse of the 751 people became sick. The media underreported this event
buildings was unplanned. If the planes had been low on fuel, because domestic terrorism was not a topic of concern at that
the damage would not have been as severe. The liquid fuel time in U. S. history.
burned at such a high temperature that the internal structure
of the buildings was weakened. Role of the Community Health
Biologic warfare involves using biologic agents to cause Nurse
multiple illnesses and deaths. Typical biologic agents are an-
thrax, botulinum, bubonic plague, Ebola, and smallpox. Community health nurses need to be prepared for the possi-
These agents could be used to contaminate food, water, or air. bility of terrorist activity. They have a role in primary, sec-
Deliberate food and water contamination remains the easiest ondary, and tertiary prevention.
way to distribute biologic agents for the purpose of terrorism
(Khan, Swerdlow, & Juranek, 2001). In addition, the U. S. Of- Primary Prevention
fice of Technology Assessment has speculated that the release Community health nurses are in ideal situations within
of 220 pounds of anthrax spores from a crop-duster over the communities to participate in surveillance. They must look
Washington, D.C., area on a calm, clear night could kill be- and listen within their communities for anti-group senti-
tween 1 and 3 million people (U. S. Army Chemical and Bi- ments, which might reflect anti-religion, anti-gay, or anti-
ological Defense Command, 1998) (see Chapter 9). ethnic feelings. The nurse should report any untoward ac-
The United States is very concerned about the possibil- tivities accordingly.
ity of biologic warfare or bioterrorism, as nations should be. Nurses should be alert to signs of possible terrorist ac-
The anthrax infections and deaths that occurred after Sep- tivity. Specific indicators of possible chemical or biologic
tember 11, 2001, have added to these concerns. However, it terrorism include unusual numbers of dead or dying animals;
has not been confirmed that these incidents were committed unexplained serious illnesses or deaths; an unusual liquid,
by an organized foreign or domestic terrorist group. They spray, vapor, or odor; and low-lying clouds or fog unrelated
could have been carried out by a single disturbed citizen, who to weather. Unusual swarms of insects might also indicate
would be a terrorist nevertheless, because the outcomes the use of biologic agents for terrorism. “Many nurses cur-
would be the same: fear, death, and destruction. rently employed have little knowledge regarding the poten-
tial pathogens that could be released, or how to respond to a
chemical or biological attack” (Veenema, 2002, p. 63). Less
Factors Contributing to Terrorism subtle forms of terrorism include bombings, mass shootings,
Political factors are the most common contributors to terror- and hijackings, which are more difficult to uncover in time to
ism. Anti-American sentiment runs high in many foreign prevent injury or death (see Clinical Corner).
countries, especially those that perceive the United States as
a threat to their military, economic, social, or religious self- Secondary and Tertiary Prevention
determination. Terrorist acts against American military in- Although prevention of terrorist incidents is primarily the re-
stallations abroad, in airports, in airplanes, at American em- sponsibility of the Department of Defense, the Department of
bassies, and even on American soil have occurred frequently Homeland Security, and public health and law enforcement
in the last decade as an expression of political unrest. The war agencies, community health nurses must be ready to handle
in Iraq in 2003–2004 was based on information about sus- the secondary and tertiary effects of such attacks. Knowing
pected bioterrorism weapons and reports that Iraq was har- the lethal and incapacitating chemical weapons that may be
boring anti-Western terrorists; these two pieces of informa- used by terrorists is important. Many of the communicable
tion resulted in the toppling of the Saddam Hussein political disease organisms that could be used by terrorists are dis-
regime. However, hundreds of military lives were lost, and cussed in Chapter 9 (see What Do You Think? II).
no weapons of mass destruction were found. Realizing that terrorist attacks may result in large num-
Within the United States, violence-prone members of bers of casualties, the community health nurse must be pre-
militia movements, violent antiabortion activists, racial de- pared to act safely, access information rapidly, and use re-
segregation advocates, and other radical groups have per- sources effectively. Specifically, the community health nurse
formed terrorist acts, such as the bombing of health clinics may be called on to provide direct care to victims, to volunteer
offering abortions. In 1984, members of a religious cult, the as a hospital-community liaison, to set up and administer mass
Rajneeshees, lived in Wasco County, Oregon, and followed immunizations, to make home visits to affected families, or
a self-proclaimed guru exiled from India. In an attempt to re- to serve on committees responding to terrorist acts. Formu-
464 UNIT 4 Community as Client

C L I N I C A L C O R N E R

A 1999 shooting at Columbine High School in Colorado after 5:30 PM is 78%. Ethnicity is as follows: 52% Anglo,
left 15 people dead. National attention was focused on 30% Asian, 12% Hispanic, 4% Black, and 2% other.
the issue of violence among teens. The public and the Identified problems among teens include racial divi-
media looked to public health experts for answers to the sion, gang violence, a high school dropout rate of 17%,
problem of increasing violence in this population. Com- and a high incidence of methamphetamine use. The inci-
munity health nurses are among those whose aim is to dence of violent crimes in this community is 28% higher
assess and address the problems surrounding individual than in neighboring communities. Besides organized
and group violence in their communities. sports, there are very few extracurricular activities avail-
Imagine that, as a community health nurse, you have able through the school or within the community.
just been named the head of a multidisciplinary task
force whose objective is to prevent teen violence within QUESTIONS
your community. Your project has been funded for 3
1. Faced with this daunting task, where will you begin
years. Having worked in other nursing roles in your
your efforts?
community over the past 10 years, you have developed
2. With what agencies and individuals will you need to
excellent partnerships with resource persons within your
develop partnerships to maximize the efficacy of the
community. After reading the information about your
task force?
community, respond to the questions that follow.
3. Brainstorm about possible ways to capitalize on the
use of technology in your efforts to reduce the risk of
COMMUNITY INFORMATION
violence in the community.
You are in a desert suburban community of 40,000 indi- 4. How will you disseminate the information you obtain
viduals, who primarily commute to high-tech jobs in a to advance the cause of globalization of public
nearby city. The average household income is $56,000 health?
per year. The divorce rate in the community is 63%. The 5. What ethical issues will you anticipate as you begin
number of teens whose primary caregiver returns home your efforts?

lating, updating, and following a disaster plan is one of the


WHAT DO YOU THINK? II most effective community-based strategies to minimize in-
jury and mortality from terrorism.
Most community health nurses will not be on the front
THE AMERICAN RED CROSS—AMERICAN’S
line of uncovering or immediately responding to terrorist ac-
DISASTER RELIEF AGENCY
tivities, but their skills will be needed with groups, families,
The American Red Cross (ARC) has responded to dis- or individuals who experience a terrorist-related event. Some
asters of every shape and size for more than 100 years. of the activities listed earlier in this chapter to help people
In the 14 months after September 11, 2001, ARC deal with the aftermath of a disaster would also be appropri-
chapters provided shelter or financial assistance for ate if terrorism is the cause of the disaster. In addition, com-
67,000 separate disasters across the country. More than munity health nurses may work with people who need help
2100 licensed mental health professionals are available coping or who want to do something to help.
for ARC assignments. In New York City, as a result of After experiencing a traumatic event such as a terrorist
the September 11, 2001, terrorist attack, the ARC attack, people do not know how to cope. We are warned to
• Opened 49,999 cases expect more attacks. We are told to be vigilant. The terror we
• Served 13,171,855 meals/snacks are fighting is often our own. This is a new experience for
• Made 183,732 mental health contacts most people, and assistance from the community health
• Opened 14 shelters nurse can help them cope effectively. The following 10 tips
• Provided 41,898 relief workers for the disaster were gathered from experts in many fields by Foley (2002)
• Opened 31 service delivery sites and are common-sense approaches to fight anxiety:
• Received $933.2 million dollars in donations • Be a little afraid—a certain level of fear is healthy if you
through June 2002. learn to use it as positive energy. Use your pinch of anxi-
The ARC has spent funds on a family gift program, ety to be more vigilant about your safety and that of your
aid for displaced workers or residents, immediate re- family, especially when you travel, and in taking care of
lief, and direct support, and for other purposes. your health.
• Keep a courage journal—fear immobilizes, and courage
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 465

takes action. Every time you take action, you are getting the fire, flood, bomb, or other cause. Environmental factors are
past fear. Even small steps are an opportunity to build those that could potentially contribute to or mitigate a disaster.
more courage. Every time you take a courageous step— In developing strategies to address the problem of dis-
getting on a plane, opening your mail—write it down. asters, it is helpful for the community health nurse to con-
• Reassure your children. In the act of reassuring your chil- sider each of the four phases of disaster management: pre-
dren, you will reassure yourself. vention, preparedness, response, and recovery.
• Hang out with children. Do things with your children— Primary prevention of disasters means keeping the dis-
most young people carry a charge of positive energy that aster from ever happening by taking actions to eliminate the
is infectious. If you do not have young children, volunteer possibility of its occurrence. Secondary prevention focuses
at a school or read to children at a nearby day care center. on earliest possible detection and treatment. Tertiary preven-
• Cook something hearty, healthy, and large, and invite lots tion involves reducing the amount and degree of disability or
of people in to eat it. The process of cooking is good for damage resulting from the disaster.
the soul. The aromas are good for the soul. And the chop- In addition to assessing for preparedness, an effective
ping and dicing make you feel that you are doing some- disaster plan establishes a clear chain of authority, develops
thing useful and concrete. lines of communication, and delineates routes and modes of
• Give kindness to others. We all need each other now. transport. Plans for mobilizing, warning, and evacuating
Make a point of chatting with the woman at the checkout people are also critical elements of the disaster plan. At the
counter or letting a pedestrian cross the street when you disaster site, police, firefighters, nurses, and other relief
are driving. Wave hello to strangers. You will be amazed workers develop a coordinated response to rescue victims
how much it is true that in giving, we receive. from further injury, triage victims by seriousness of injury,
• Get spiritual. Reach out and participate in your faith com- and treat victims on-site and in local hospitals. Care and
munity or get involved in one, if so inclined. Believing in transport of dead bodies must also be managed, as well as
a power greater than yourself can be comforting. support for the loved ones of the injured, dead, or missing.
• Laugh. Laughter is the best medicine for fear. Spend Long-term support includes both financial assistance and
evenings in good company—group laughter is better than physical and emotional rehabilitation.
laughing alone. Self-care, including stress education for all relief work-
• Get back to nature. Spending interactive time with nature ers after a disaster, helps to lower anxiety and put the situa-
is a remedy for just about any soul sickness. Go to the tion into proper perspective. CISD provides victims with a
park, take a walk, work in your garden. mechanism for emotional reconciliation and healing.
• Find reasons to believe the sky is not falling. All the un- Problems of group violence include school violence,
pleasant facts and figures get our “anxiety juices” flowing. gangs, riots, and violent crimes. A gang is an organization of
Seek out positive people, and read literature that encour- youths that has a name, is usually territorial or claims a cer-
ages positive thinking. Do not feed the “dark side.” Turn off tain territory as being under its exclusive influence, and is in-
the news and opt for a funny movie or an inspirational story. volved in criminal acts.
Community health nurses can make major differences in The roots of group violence are multifactorial and in-
grassroots efforts to bring about change, but on a day-to-day clude inadequate parenting; socioeconomic and racial injus-
basis the little things they say and do with peers and clients tices; exposure to violence in media, cartoons, and pornog-
can make just as big a difference. raphy; and easy access to weapons.
The goals of Healthy People 2010 for reducing violence
include reductions in physical assaults and weapon carrying
SUMMARY by schoolchildren and reduction of work-related assaults and
homicides.
A disaster is any event that causes a level of destruction that The role of the community health nurse in preventing
exceeds the abilities of the affected community to respond and reducing group violence includes effective community
without assistance. Disasters may be caused by natural or organization and program development, as well as policy
manmade/technologic events and may be classified as multi- making to address the family and environmental factors that
ple-casualty incidents or mass-casualty incidents. contribute to increased risk of group violence.
The scope of a disaster is its range of effect, and the in- Terrorism is the unlawful use of force or violence
tensity is the level of destruction it causes. Victims of disasters against persons or property to intimidate or coerce a govern-
include direct victims, those injured or killed, and indirect vic- ment or civilian population in the furtherance of political or
tims, the loved ones of direct victims. Displaced persons are social objectives. Terrorism may be nuclear, biologic, or
those who are forced to flee their homes because of the disas- chemical, including nerve agents and explosive devices. The
ter, and refugees are those who are forced to leave their home- community health nurse should be alert to signs of possible
lands, usually in response to war or political persecution. terrorist activity and prepared to address the secondary or ter-
Host factors that contribute to the likelihood of experienc- tiary effects of such attacks. Preparation includes knowledge
ing a disaster include age, general health, mobility, psycholog- of the effects of specific biologic or chemical agents and how
ical factors, and socioeconomic factors. The disaster agent is to help people cope with the terror they personally feel.
466 UNIT 4 Community as Client

M.S. (2002). Terrorism from a public health perspective. The


ACTIVITIES TO PROMOTE American Journal of the Medical Sciences, 323(6), 291–298.
Foley, D. (2002). Fight terror—your own. Prevention, 54(2),
CRITICAL THINKING
126–133, 174–176.
Garbarino, J. (1999). Lost boys: Why our sons turn violent and
1. Think about your own community and its resi- how we can save them. New York: Free Press.
dents. What are some host factors that might Goode, E. (2000, March 2). Struggling to make sense out of
increase its risk of experiencing a disaster? boy-turned-killer. New York Times. Available at:
What environmental factors might be signifi- http://www.nytimes.com/library/national/science/health/
cant? In each case, identify the likely agent. 030200hth-behavior-children.html.. Accessed 3/24/04.
What interventions could be included in a dis- Herman, D., Felton, C., & Susser, E. (2002). Mental health needs
in New York State following the September 11 attacks.
aster plan to reduce these risk factors?
Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of
2. The nightly news shows that at least 200 peo-
Medicine, 79(3), 322–331.
ple have been injured in an explosion in a Hirschi, T. (2004). Travis Hirschi’s social bond theory. Available
neighboring community. At the disaster site, at: http://home.comcast.net/~ddemeio/crime/hirschi.html.
victims are still being recovered from the Huff, R.C. (2002). Gangs in America (3rd ed.). Newbury Park,
wreckage, and local hospitals are over- CA: Sage.
whelmed with patients who have fractures, Jack, K., & Glied, S. (2002). The public costs of mental health
lacerations, and burns. You want to offer your response: Lessons from the New York City post-9/11 needs
assistance as a registered nurse. How should assessment. Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York
you go about volunteering your services? Academy of Medicine, 79(3), 332–339.
3. Your local high school is complaining of an Khan, A.S., Swerdlow, D.L., & Juranek, D.D. (2001). Precautions
against biological and chemical terrorism directed at food and
increasing gang presence. Members have
water supplies. Public Health Reports, 116, 3–14.
been recruiting and intimidating students,
Late, M. (2002, August). Homeland department plan may
and fights with knives have broken out re- undermine public health. The Nation’s Health, pp. 1, 32.
peatedly in the past month. A random search Miller, J., Maxson, C.L., Klein, M.W. (Eds.). (2001). The modern
of lockers revealed two guns and eight gang reader. Los Angeles: Roxbury Press.
knives, and as many as 25% of students are National Crime Prevention Council. (2002, October 8). Stopping
staying out of school because of parents’ school violence in its tracks. Watch for signs—Take action.
fears of violence. Describe one possible re- Available at: http://www.newsweek.com/ce/ce270a.htm.
sponse of a community health nurse to ad- Accessed on 3/26/04.
dress the problem of gang violence in this Ostrowski, M. (2001). A nurse’s view from ground zero. RN,
situation. 64(11), 35–37.
Peeke, P.M. (2002). Reclaim your peace of mind. Prevention,
4. Access one or more of the Internet sites listed
54(1), 92–97.
in this chapter. Report on the change in sta-
Schlenger, W.E., Caddell, J.M., Ebert, L., Jordan, B.K., Rourke,
tistics for disasters, group violence, or terror- K.M., Wilson, D., et al. (2002). Psychological reactions to
ism since the year 2003. Have rates terrorist attacks: Findings from the national study of
increased or decreased? What factors might Americans’ reactions to September 11. JAMA: The Journal of
be involved in this change? the American Medical Association, 288(5), 581–588.
Schuster, M.A., Franke, T.M., Bastian, A.M., Sor, S., & Halfron,
N. (2000). Firearm storage patterns in U. S. homes with
children. American Journal of Public Health, 90(4), 588–594.
REFERENCES Silver, R.C., Holman, E.A., McIntosh, D.N., Poulin, M., & Gil-
Rivas, V. (2002). Nationwide longitudinal study of
Associated Press. (2002, August 12). Medical advances, drop in psychological responses to September 11. JAMA: The Journal
death rate linked. The Fresno Bee, p. 5. of the American Medical Association, 288(10), 1235–1244.
Bacque, G. (2000). Advocates fear wave of homeless murders. Steger, S. (2000). Killed in school! RN, 63(4), 36–38.
Toronto Star. Retrieved December 15, 2003, from U. S. Army Chemical and Biological Defense Command.
http://projects.is.asu.edu/pipermail/hpn/2000- (1998). Domestic preparedness program: Hospital provider
June/000849.html course. McLean, VA: Booz-Allen & Hamilton, Inc. and
Benda, B.B., & Turney, H.M. (2002). Youthful violence: SAIC, Inc.
Problems and prospects. Child and Adolescent Social Work U. S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2000). Healthy
Journal, 19(1), 5–34. people 2010 (Conference ed., Vols. 1 & 2). Washington, DC:
Copper, M., & Ianzito, V. (2002). One year later…. AARP: U. S. Government Printing Office.
Modern Maturity, 45(5), 88–93. U. S. Department of Justice, Office of Juvenile Justice and
DeVitto, S. (2002). Giving hope, she found hope. Reflections on Delinquency Prevention. (1999, March). Highlights of the
Nursing Leadership, 28(3), 21. 1997 national youth gang survey. Washington, DC: Author.
Evans, R.G., Crutcher, J.M., Shadel, B., Clements, B., & Bronze, U. S. Department of Justice. (2002). National Crime Victimization
CHAPTER 20 Communities in Crisis: Disasters, Group Violence, and Terrorism 467

Survey (NCVS) for 2000–2001. Available at: Late, M. (2002, June/July). Partners improving community safety,
http://www.usdoj.gov/bjs/pub/pdf/cvol.pdf emergency response. The Nation’s Health, p. 4.
Veenema, T.G. (2002). Chemical and biological terrorism: Levy, B.S., & Sidel, V.W. (2000). War and public health.
Current updates for nurse educators. Nursing Education Waldorf, MD: American Public Health Association.
Perspectives, 23(2), 62–71. Lutenbacher, M., Cooper, W.O., & Faccia, K. (2002). Planning
Wilson, J. J., & Howell, J. C. (1993). A comprehensive strategy for youth violence prevention efforts: Decision-making across
serious, violent, and chronic juvenile offenders. Washington, community sectors. Journal of Adolescent Health, 30(5),
DC: U. S. Department of Justice, Office of Juvenile Justice. 346–354.
Yergler, M. (2002). Nerve gas attack. The American Journal of Miller, M., Azrael, D., & Hemenway, D. (2002). Firearm
Nursing, 102(7), 57–60. availability and suicide, homicide, and unintentional firearm
deaths among women. Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of
the New York Academy of Medicine, 79(1), 26–38.
SELECTED READINGS Murray, C.J.L., King, G., Lopez, A.D., Tomijima, N., & Krug,
E.G. (2002). Armed conflict as a public health problem. BMJ,
Chaffee, M., Conway-Welch, C., & Stephens, V. (2001). 324, 346–349.
Bioterrorism in the United States: Take it seriously. The Perez, M.A., Pinzon-Perez, H., & Sowby, S. (2002). The role of
American Journal of Nursing, 101(11), 59, 61. health educators in dealing with biological threats in the
Charles, P. (2001). What I learned at ground zero. RN, 64(12), United States. American Journal of Health Education, 33(4),
42–44. 216–224.
Cohen, H.W., Eolis, S.L., Gould, R.M., & Sidel, V.W. (2001). Slovak, K., & Singer, M.I. (2002). Children and violence:
Hyping bioterrorism obscures real concerns. The American Findings and implications from a rural community. Child and
Journal of Nursing, 101(11), 58, 60. Adolescent Social Work Journal, 19(1), 35–56.
Coleman, E.A., & Kearney, K. (2001). Anthrax: Know the St. John, R., & Giroux, C. (2002). Terrorism and public health:
guidelines for management. The American Journal of Nursing, The little known equation. Canadian Journal of Public Health,
101(12), 48–52. 93(3), 165–166.
Ellickson, P.L., & McGuigan, K.A. (2000). Early predictors of
adolescent violence. American Journal of Public Health, Internet Resources
90(4), 566–572. Action Committee Against Violence: http://www.acav.org
Evison, D., Hinsley, D., & Rice, P. (2002). Regular review: Almanac of Disasters: http://www.disasterium.com
Chemical weapons. BMJ, 324, 332–335. Bioterrorism: http://bioterrorism.straws.com
Firshein, J. (2002). Public health preparedness for disaster: Bioterrorism Resources: www.acponlone.org/bioterro/
Perspective from Washington, DC. Journal of Urban Health: index.html
Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine, 79(1), 6–7. Center for the Study and Prevention of Violence:
Frattaroli, S., Webster, D.W., & Teret, S.P. (2002). Unintentional http://www.colorado.edu/cspv/
gun injuries, firearm design, and prevention: What we know, Citizen Corps: www.citizencorps.gov
what we need to know, and what can be done. Journal of Men Against Domestic Violence (MADV)—Domestic Violence
Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine, Resources: http://www.silicom.com/~paladin/madv/
79(1), 49–59. National Coalition Against Domestic Violence (NCADVE):
Geiger, H.J. (2001). Terrorism, biological weapons, and http://www.healthtouch.com
bonanzas: Assessing the real threat to public health. American National Crime Prevention Council: http://www.ncpc.org
Journal of Public Health, 91(5), 708–709. National School Board Association:
Glasser, J. (2002). Coming to grips with the pain. U. S. News & http://www.keepschoolssafe.org
World Report, 133(10), 2730, 2732. National School Safety Center: http://www.nssc1.org
Keane, A., Houldin, A.D., Allison, P.D., Jepson, C., Shults, J., National Youth Gang Center: http://www.iir.com/nygc/
Nuamah, I.F., et al. (2002). Factors associated with distress in Nursing World: Bioterrorism and Disaster Response:
urban residential fire survivors. Journal of Nursing www.NursingWorld.org/news/disaster
Scholarship, 34(1), 11–17. Partnerships Against Violence Network (PAVNET):
Kennedy, M.S. (2002). Our worst disaster’s first nurse. The http://www.pavnet.org
American Journal of Nursing, 102(2), 102–103. Teens, Crime, and the Community: http://www.nationaltcc.org
Landesman, L.Y. (2001). Public health management of disasters: United Nations Declaration of Human Rights—“A Life Free of
The practice guide. Waldorf, MD: American Public Health Violence”: http://www.undp.org/rblac/gender/
Association. Youth Crime Watch of America: http://www.ycwa.org

You might also like