Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AnimationMentor TipsTricks Beginners PDF
AnimationMentor TipsTricks Beginners PDF
By Shawn Kelly
Animation Supervisor, Industrial Light & Magic
Co-Founder, Animation Mentor
ANY background is going to be
helpful in SOME way. I’ve met
animators who were fighter pilots,
detectives, maintenance workers,
engineers, architects, soldiers,
bartenders, and athletes.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 6
watch them move from pose to pose, In order to bring a character to life, there
or climb up onto the stage, etc. In fact, is almost nothing more important than
I think I’d say that considering the sad having a collection of interesting actions
state of the animation program I was and acting choices we’ve observed and
attending at the time, I probably learned either committed to memory or written
more about body mechanics during the down or sketched. These actions we’ve
spaces between figure drawings than I set aside to remember are our secret
did in any of my “animation” classes! weapons in the creation of memorable
character performances.
That said, it isn’t absolutely necessary. In
fact, you know what kind of background In light of that, just about any life
would be helpful for an animator who is experience you have may come in handy
just starting out? during your animation career!
Yours! That’s right! ANY background I would say that any artistic experience
is going to be helpful in SOME way. you can have, whether it’s studying
I’ve met animators who were fighter photography, visiting museums, or
pilots, detectives, maintenance even reading comic books -- these are
workers, engineers, architects, soldiers, all more immediately helpful to you as
bartenders, and athletes. All of these an animator than your memory of the
people bring their unique backgrounds drunk who spilled everyone’s drinks one
and knowledge base to their work, and night when you were tending bar. The
these life experiences inform the acting drunk may come in handy at some point
decisions of their characters, the stories down the line as you craft a performance
they will tell, and the style of their work. that takes place in a bar, but the artistic
growth you’ve experienced in the first
As animators, observation is one of the three examples is something that you’ll
most important aspects of what we do. be able to use from Day 1 as you jump
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 7
into animation.
Animation students who don’t have any
So sure, any art background is helpful to artistic background at all may need to
the animator, and obviously I think that work a little harder to make up for it,
figure drawing classes, in particular, can but it’s simply no longer necessary to
be very beneficial, but I’ve met too many have the drawing skills that many of our
incredible animators now who have next animation heroes possess.
to no art background at all to be able to
say that it’s completely necessary. What’s necessary is that you have a
passion to learn animation and a hunger
While an art background, used properly, to seek that knowledge out anywhere
will be an advantage for any animator, and everywhere.
the computer has removed the absolute
need for draftsmanship. Keeping a What’s necessary is a keen sense of
character “on-model” is no longer an observation throughout your daily life,
issue, at least as far as maintaining the and the ability to learn from what you
mass goes. (Taking the facial animation are observing. What’s necessary is the
and acting choices off-model is still as ability to apply those observations to
big a problem and challenge as it ever your work, and to accurately recreate
was, though!). Being able to draw an and exaggerate the life you see around
accurate turntable of a character is a you. What’s necessary is the patience to
fantastic and enviable skill, but as our plan your work out, and the tenacity to
computer tools get more and more be detail-oriented enough to completely
robust, there is increasingly room in finish it. What’s necessary is the desire to
the ranks of the world’s animators for find criticism of your work and to grow
animation artists who have never picked from what you hear.
up a pencil for serious drawing.
THAT’s the stuff that’s absolutely
Of course, if you want to pursue 2D necessary. If you’re missing any of the
animation, obviously that means you above, you might as well give up right
WILL need strong draftsmanship and a now -- you aren’t going to make it as
well-rounded background in traditional an animator. I’m sorry. That’s the stuff
art, but the question I get is usually you can’t live without. Everything else
referring to a career in 3D animation, is gravy. Sometimes the gravy really
which is a different story all together. makes the dish, though - something we
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 8
shouldn’t ignore. In other words, your ice-cream sundae might be delicious, but it
might not be able to compete with your neighbor who actually put the cherry on
top, you know?
I do think that you can make a pretty darn good sundae without any art background,
but if our goal as animators it to never stop learning (which it SHOULD be), I’d
encourage all of you to study any and all aspects of art in any way you can.
And if you become an animator having no art background at all, then guess what?
Which I guess means you have an art background now! Cool, huh?
Shawn :)
v
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 9
Who Is Cut Out for
Animation?
Answer: YOU!
By Shawn Kelly
Animation Supervisor, Industrial Light & Magic
Co-Founder, Animation Mentor
I learned that something my
grandfather once told me was
very true: simply “following your
dreams” isn’t enough -- you have to
aggressively and proactively HUNT
your dream down.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 11
© Disney / LucasFilms
When I was in high school, I wanted to unbelievably make it into ILM after
work on Star Wars more than anything years and years of training, networking,
in the world, and they hadn’t even and working at smaller studios. I
officially announced that there would learned that something my grandfather
be more Star Wars movies. It was just once told me was very true: simply
rumors, but I made it my goal to get to “following your dreams” isn’t enough --
ILM. ILM was where I wanted to work, you have to aggressively and proactively
period. In light of that, every single HUNT your dream down.
decision I made was based on “does this
decision take me one step closer to ILM People spend their entire lives “following
or take me a step away from it?” If it was their dreams” and the vast majority of
the former, then that’s what I did, no them never arrive. If you want to get
matter what kind of burden it created on into your dream studio, you have to be
my time, my social life, schooling, etc. better than that. You have to be a hunter.
I worked my butt off to somehow
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 12
If you can combine a true passion for willing (or able) to make the sacrifices
learning animation with the tenacity necessary to completely immerse
necessary to hunt down your dream job, themselves in their art.
then I have zero doubt that someday
I’ll see your name in the credits of my For me, it was a great life lesson, and one
favorite TV show, a video game that I’ve I feel happy and lucky to have learned,
been lost in for weeks, or at the end of so I figured I should pass it along...
a film in a packed theater. It might not
happen right away, and you’ll probably I also want to add that I’m not merely
have to slowly build experience and talking about joining Animation
your reel as you work your way up Mentor. I realize that many of you aren’t
through smaller studios, but if you just in a situation where you can join the
never let go of that dream, and base your school right now -- that’s fine! Seek out
decisions on it, you CAN make it come other ways to hunt your dream down.
true. There are a lot of free online resources
that can at least help get you started,
I know, because I’ve been there. And the such as forums, online animation and
hard truth is that I saw plenty of people art communities, and blogs. There
who could have tried harder. Back when are great books out there such as The
I was in school, I saw plenty of students Illusion of Life and The Animator’s
leave the animation lab at 10 p.m. to go Survival Kit. There are fantastic
play video games or hit a club or go to making-of documentaries on any
sleep. The people who stayed in that lab number of your favorite DVDs.
until it closed at 2 a.m. EVERY NIGHT
are largely the people who have their Seek that stuff out and soak it up! Do the
dream jobs right now. best hunting you can with whatever is
at your disposal right now, and take that
We made animation our LIFE, and put first step that brings you even the tiniest
everything else on hold. Could it be a bit closer to your goal, whatever it may
coincidence that those are the people be.
who ended up with the jobs everyone
else wanted? I don’t think so. I think it Best of luck!
ended up coming down to who wanted
those jobs the most, and who was Shawn :)
v
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 13
What’s the Role
of an Animator?
By Shawn Kelly
Animation Supervisor, Industrial Light & Magic
Co-Founder, Animation Mentor
At any medium-large studio (including They’re right. It will.
games, TV, or feature films), an animator
is hired to animate. Not to create But I guess it boils down to you deciding
textures or model characters or light what kind of job you are looking for,
scenes. Most bigger studios recognize and what kind of career you are going to
that these are all skills that take decades attempt. There is nothing wrong at all in
to truly master, and that the true path to deciding to be a generalist, and continue
beautiful imagery onscreen is to fill the to learn about all aspects of this stuff
studio with expert specialists. In other called Computer Graphics. There are
words, most studios aren’t too hung up many jobs, especially junior-level jobs at
on finding people who “know a little smaller-to-medium-sized studios, where
about a lot of different disciplines.” Most generalists are specifically sought out
features and games studios are looking and encouraged.
for an artist who “knows a LOT about
ONE discipline.” However, I can’t tell you how rare it
is for a generalist to get a job as an
It’s the pairing up of these experts that animator at a major feature studio
results in the truly memorable work or large game studio. Almost every
you’d see in any blockbuster film or professional animator at that level has
A-list game. Of course, there is nothing decided to focus at least MOST of their
wrong with dabbling in all the different time on animation, even if they also
disciplines available to you as a CG enjoy other disciplines deep down...
artist, but we generally recommend
that once you’ve found which discipline Before I end that thought, though, it’s
you are the most interested in -- be really important to point out that if you
it animation or modeling or lighting are new to the industry, getting a junior
or rigging or textures or whatever -- job as a generalist can be one of THE
once you’ve found your “true calling,” best ways to break into this business.
your best bet is to put the rest of that
stuff aside and focus as much time as Getting your foot in the door of a studio
humanly possible on becoming a true and getting *any* kind of professional
expert in whatever that chosen field is. experience is invaluable, and will help
you make connections, learn the ropes,
Many people will say that this will limit meet people to learn from, and will look
your job opportunities, and guess what?
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 15
great on your resume.
If you aren’t getting to spend most of your time at work actually animating and
growing as an animator, then my advice is to work hard, do a great job, and then go
home and animate your brains out and practice as much as you possibly can in your
spare time. Read animation books, get involved in online animation communities,
meet up with some animation student friends and watch some animated films
frame-by-frame and talk about what you see...
Getting a job where you aren’t doing *exactly* what you hope to be doing doesn’t
mean that you have to stop striving towards your dreams of working as an animator!
It’s more than common for animators to have to work their way up, and slowly climb
that ladder until they finally get their dream job.
It’s very rare for that to happen overnight, so don’t automatically turn your nose up
at jobs that aren’t exactly what you hoped for. Just don’t let that job stop you from
continuing to move forward.
Shawn :)
v
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 16
Questions About the
Animation Job Market
By Shawn Kelly
Animation Supervisor, Industrial Light & Magic
Co-Founder, Animation Mentor
Hello from the other side of the planet! miss so far -- but I’m still open to trying
some more places! You can never taste-
As I write this, I’m in Singapore for six test too much fried chicken!
weeks to help train some animation
apprentices and am having the time of This is actually my second trip to
my life. What’s more fun than visiting Singapore, and during the two trips I’ve
an exotic location, meeting new friends, eaten some truly bizarre things -- or
reuniting with old friends, and getting to at least bizarre to my American eyes:
talk about animation all day?! It isn’t all chicken-foot soup (which is exactly what
Happy-Go-Lucky-Land - I *am* really it sounds like), century eggs (pickled
missing my family, my US friends, my robin’s eggs, or something?), durian
ILM work, and especially my incredibly (AAAAAAAAAA! Just run away! Sorry,
understanding wife, but home is just two Singapore -- I know you love it, but
weeks away at this point, so I’m on the holy moly, my white-trash taste buds
home stretch! just cannot handle the horror of the
Durian “fruit”), and a grape-sized fish
Singapore is amazing, by the way. Really eyeball that my friend Snowy convinced
friendly people, it’s super safe, the streets me to eat. Meanwhile, she’s completely
are shockingly spotless, and I’ve met disgusted by the concept of eating a
some really talented people here... banana!
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 18
ask around to other sources, because cards, web-based video games, crime-
my experiences certainly aren’t all- scene recreation, automobile safety
encompassing, and are largely limited to simulations, 3D motion “rides” at
the feature animation and vfx animation amusement parks, teaching, and have
niches... also put their artistic talents to use in a
variety of graphic design, illustration,
QUESTION:What types and marketing jobs.
of jobs are available to
animators? (I’m assuming So yes, there’s definitely a variety of jobs
out there, and everyone has their own
character animation in film/
preferences of what they enjoy the most.
TV isn’t the only possibility)
Which jobs are in the most As for demand, that’s very difficult to
demand and which are in answer, as all of the above industries
the least demand? What are fluctuate considerably, often in a very
the best job market cities in cyclical pattern. For example, sometimes
the U.S./Canada (abroad as (such as for the last few months), the
well)? Do you have to move visual effects industry hits a slow patch,
to a big city to get a job? and it can be very difficult to get (or
keep) a job. And then, often just a few
months later, the demand for animators
What jobs are available to animators is suddenly huge as a bunch of films get
– it’s right to assume that the industry green-lit and studios scramble to fill
is much larger than simply “film/TV” animation positions. Demand is very
jobs. Character animators have found difficult to predict, but especially when
work in many companies and studios, you don’t have a lot of experience, it can
doing – among other things: character be difficult to find a job at times. That’s
animation for feature animated films, for sure.
character animation for visual effects
films, a huge variety of TV shows, TV I would generally advise greener
commercials, in-game video game work, animators to not expect their first few
cinematic video game work, bringing jobs to be the most glamorous, but
to life architectural CAD fly-throughs, those jobs will often be terrific learning
Internet flash animation, online greeting experiences as you climb the ladder to
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 19
your dream job! realistically is still years away and
would only work for certain mediums,
The best job-market cities would be I suppose we’ll be able to work from
difficult to nail down as well, because wherever we want!
the animation industry is growing a lot
in Europe, India, and Southeast Asia That’s the dream, anyway, because I
right now, as well as in Mexico and a BADLY want to animate a transformer
number of other countries. Traditionally, while sitting on some sand with my feet
the big animation cities have been LA, in a warm ocean! :)
Northern California (San Jose and San
Francisco Bay Area), London, Paris, Ahhhhh... someday.... OK, maybe that’ll
New York, Vancouver, etc. However, never happen, but I can dream, can’t I?!
Oregon, Florida, and Texas all have
strong animation markets these days, Hope that answers all your questions!
as do cities in India, New Zealand,
Australia, and of course all over Asia. Shawn :) v
Singapore’s industry is growing quickly
as well, and many governments (such
as Singapore’s) are making a concerted
effort to support and fund a home-
grown animation industry.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 20
6 Animation
Demo Reel
DOs and DON’Ts
By Don Kim
Director, Storyboard Artist, Animation Supervisor
Nelvana Limited
Mentor, Animation Mentor
Getting your first job in the animation the next demo reel. That’s why it is so
industry can be quite intimidating and important to make as strong an impact/
challenging. Networking and checking first impression of your work as you can
out job boards will get you started, but to potential employers.
it’s your demo reel and portfolio which
will be the deciding factor if you move Being a Director and having worked
to the next stage of the hiring process. as an Animation Supervisor, I have
In most cases, the person(s) reviewing reviewed many many demo reels
your reel has an immense amount of (actually too many ). What I can tell
material to review and make judgments you is, after a while, mediocre work
on. There is no time to think too long begins to blend together and you find
or hard about the degree of someone’s yourself skipping through reels or only
talent and skill set before moving on to watching a few seconds of the start of
Alumnus, Philip To’s 2010 Animation Mentor Demo Reel. Don Kim was his mentor for Advanced
Acting back in 2007. Philip won an Annie Award in 2010 for his work in Monsters vs Aliens:
Mutant Pumpkins from Outer Space. He currently works at Disney Feature Animation.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 22
the reel because of the quality of the is what you are going to leave them
work. You want to always put your with so they remember you. Obviously,
best work forward to give that ‘WOW the animation in between is also very
FACTOR’. This will grab the attention important, but typically it’s a good idea
of the person reviewing your reel and to start and end with your strongest
make them want to watch more. work.
Below are a few do’s and don’ts regarding DON’T : Don’t muddy your reel
putting together an effective demo reel. with over the top titles, transitions and
underscore. Clarity is very important,
DO : Only include your best work! you want to highlight your animation
You might have some sentimental and make those moments read as best
attachment to particular shots in your as possible. Where there are acting
past work, but you need to be brutally shots with dialogue, I would personally
honest when reviewing for you demo not include any underscore that is not
reel. It’s also a good idea to have a present in the original scene, where
colleague review your work to give you you have a bunch of action shots edited
more of an objective point of view. But, together, a bit of subtle music might be
bottom line, your demo reel should nice to string the shots together.
ONLY include your BEST work.
DO : Be mindful of what shots you
DON’T : Please do not have a 5 to edit together and how each shot relates
10 min demo reel, this is way too long. to the shot before and after, in terms of
Again, those individuals reviewing your performance (acting vs action) and also
work have a limited amount of time to timing (fast vs slow). Obviously, you are
review a vast number of reels. Keep your not telling a story through the sequence
reel between 1-2 mins tops. Less is more, of shots in your demo reel, but it can still
and only putting in your best work have a sense of rhythm and highs and
should cut down the length of your reel. lows. For example you could have a few
DO : Begin and end you reel with action heavy shots in a row then go into
your killer shots. You want to ‘wow’ a slower acting driven scene to create
them right off the start to keep them contrast and break up your reel, creating
engaged and wanting to see more. Then rhythm and variety in the beats. This
end with another amazing shot, this can potentially make your reel feel more
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 23
Alumnus, Wira Winata’s 2014 Demo Reel. Don Kim was his mentor for Animation
Basics and now he’s rocking it at Blue Sky Studios!
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 24
Shawn Kelly
Answers 5 Burning
Questions About
DEMO REELS
By Shawn Kelly
Animation Supervisor, Industrial Light & Magic
Co-Founder, Animation Mentor
Animation Mentor co-founder and them all. Here are five more excellent
Industrial Light & Magic Lead Animator questions on demo reels and the
Shawn Kelly answers five great student animation job market.
questions about demo reels and gives
advice on applying for studio animation How much do you guys
jobs. And he should know—he’s been at weigh a demo reel along
ILM for more than 20 years! with a resume and cover
letter from an applicant?
In this webinar, Shawn critiqued some
Like for example, let’s say
student demo reels and talked about do’s
and don’ts, creature animation, and what a person has a great reel
studios are looking for when they review but not much experience on
reels. their resume?
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 26
least 90% of getting the job. using someone else’s work on your demo reel or
Knowing someone at a studio lies on the resume will travel around the entire
may help with getting an industry in flash.
interview, but it isn’t going
to get you a job unless your That said, if the demo reel is amazing, most
demo reel wows people. studios aren’t going to care much at all about any
lack of experience on your resume.
However, once I’ve seen
and liked a reel, then I’m
extremely interested in
reading the cover letter I never even glance at
and the resume. It’s a great a resume until I’ve seen
way to get to know the
the demo reel. The reel
applicant a little bit and get
an idea of their interests and is always going to be at
background. Take care with least 90% of getting the
your cover letter and resume job.
as well—if it’s rife with
spelling or formatting errors
it shows a lack of attention to Is it smart to frequently show a
detail, the exact opposite of studio your work even without a
what studios would want in job posted on their website?
an artist.
Shawn: It’s never a bad idea to send an updated
Always be 100% truthful reel to a studio, regardless of whether or not they
about your experience on the have openings posted. There’s a fine line, though,
resume as well or those lies between keeping them updated and becoming
will very likely come back a pest to the recruiters, so I’d say to only send
to haunt you. Remember, an updated reel when you really feel that you’ve
this is a small industry, and improved it and added new content (a new shot).
the recruiters all know each Hiring needs can change really fast at studios, so
other and all experienced it’s always good to be on their radar. If you apply
animators have friends at and they aren’t hiring right then, at least you’re
tons of other studios, so getting yourself into the queue of artists they
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 27
may turn to when the show Studios are looking for animators who can bring
suddenly needs animators or something special to a shot. Artists who can
a new project starts ramping “plus” the direction they are given and take even
up. a “small shot” to a higher level and make it sing.
However, at a studio, you will be given direction
Is story more and it’s often very specific direction. It’s rare that a
important than the junior animator at any studio would be expected
physical mechanics to come up with a shot idea out of whole cloth.
99.9% of the time, you’ll be animating a shot
of a shot? Is having
that has already been somewhat thought out and
a funny idea
you’re executing the vision of the Director while
important too? How bringing what you can of yourself to it.
important would
that be?
Physical mechanics are
Shawn: No, the physical what are most important,
mechanics of a shot are
much more important than
and frankly, strong
the storytelling on a demo physical mechanics are
reel. That isn’t to say that the much harder to find on
storytelling isn’t an important
part of the equation as well,
a demo reel than strong
though. Your shots need to storytelling skills.
make sense, and the more
entertaining and emotionally
sincere the performances are,
In light of that, the physical mechanics are what
the better your demo reel will
are most important, and frankly, strong physical
be. That said, you might have
mechanics are much harder to find on a demo
the best acting performance
reel than strong storytelling skills.
ever, but if the character
looks floaty and wrong when
As far as “funny,” goes, it doesn’t hurt to
she walks around, the shot is
have some humor on your reel, but it isn’t a
ruined.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 28
prerequisite to getting a job. It doesn’t rather showing most of the same content
have to be funny, specifically, but the in a different order.
reel should be as entertaining to watch
as possible. The order you describe isn’t a bad idea
for your “generic demo reel” to have on-
The “holy trinity” of demo reels would hand that most studios could watch and
be strong body mechanics, entertaining get excited about. Alternating between
storytelling, and sincere emotional character and creature work does give
changes in the characters. Everything you a chance to get any studio, no
else, such as lip sync, music, etc., is still matter their chosen style, interested in
important, but is the icing on the cake if your work.
you’ve already nailed those first three.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 29
Tailor your reel to the job you are applying for
and the studio you are applying to!
studios are not in the majority. Not the chosen studio typically works in.
by a long shot. The vast majority of I usually recommend putting your
studios are happy to see whatever your second-best shot first, your best shot
best work is, and know that “style” last, and everything else in between,
just comes down to exaggerating the but I would switch that up if that would
same principles in different ways. mean placing realistic shots at the
Exaggeration is really the only difference beginning of a reel sent to Pixar or Blue
between “realistic” and “cartoony.” Sky, for example, both of which might
Both styles are using exaggeration, but still be interested in seeing that work,
in different ways and very different but are much more interested in your
amounts, but it’s all built on the same stylized work.
foundation.
Remember, tailor your reel to the job
That said, more and more games and vfx you are applying for and the studio you
and commercials studios really badly are applying to!
want to see some creature animation on
your demo reel. They are still eager to
see your more stylized work as well, but How important is rendering
it’s getting harder to get a job at many (I your demo reel vs. just
might even say “most”) studios without playblasting? My school tells
some animal and/or creature work done us to render everything, but
in a more realistic style. I see professional reels all
the time with just playblasts.
As for the order of shots, you definitely
want to grab their attention right off the
bat and leave them excited at the end. Shawn: Playblasting is totally fine. I’ve
That means bookending your reel with never met an animation supervisor
your best work, and ideally starting who cares at all if something is nicely
the reel off with the type of work that lit on a reel. The only time it can matter
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 30
is if lighting or particle work helps tell the story of the shot. Other than that, I’d say
playblasts are totally fine. When we are looking at reels, we are looking at the body
mechanics and the acting performances, and I couldn’t care less if something has
textures or is lit.
That said, if you do have some nicely lit shots, it doesn’t hurt the reel at all to include
them, of course! v
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 31
6 Tips from
Recruiters Who Look
at YOUR Animation
Demo Reel
By Animation Mentor
Animation Mentor Alumnus Siggurdur Orri Thorhannesson’s Demo Reel, he currently works at Framestore and
recently worked on Guardians of the Galaxy
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 33
animation demo reel should not be progressively worse. Including
longer than one or two minutes. everything you’ve ever worked on can
take you from a possible “yes” to a very
2. Don’t put everything clear “no.”
you’ve ever done in your
demo reel. Recruiter’s Tip: Recruiters would
rather see 2-3 really strong performance
Representing every shot you’ve ever shots than everything you’ve done in
worked on can actually work against school.
you. Recruiters don’t want to see
everything you’ve done – including 3. Unique acting is King.
your bouncing ball exercises. Recruiters
regularly cite instances where the Tailor your demo reel to the studio
demo reel starts off strong and then you are applying to and take note of
loses steam because the work became those studios known for great acting.
Check out this playlist from The New York Times Magazine’s series, “14 Actors Acting”. Javier Bardem, Matt
Damon, Jennifer Lawrence and many more famous actors silently act their scenes and the emotion reads beautifully.
A nice study of facial and body movements for animators.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 34
Recruiters at character- character backstory, and determine what quirks
driven animation studios like or mannerisms they have that are unusual and
DreamWorks Animation, non-cliché. Observe, act, plan, and animate.
Blue Sky Studios, or Pixar
Animation Studios, really 4. Know your audience. Tailor your
hone in on unique ideas and demo reel to the studio you are
non-cliché acting choices. applying for.
Recruiter’s Tip: When we say interesting acting choices and
Take acting classes. Why? unusual ideas are what recruiters look for,
So you can learn acting it doesn’t mean you should animate a gory
methodologies and embody “serial killer” shot for a studio like Pixar or
the character you are trying DreamWorks. Take a look at the body of work
to bring to life. You are a the studio does and tailor your animation shots
unique person so if you can for that studio. They don’t want you to mimic
feel it, you can animate it. their style but to use your best judgement on the
Don’t be cliché. type of audience they cater to. Stay away from
anything that could be considered offensive.
Another option is to observe
your family, your friends or
great actors that are masters
at understanding their bodies
and facial muscles so they
“become” the character they
are playing. There are tons
of video references of great
actors who talk about their
approach in developing a
character and what type
of mannerisms they create
to make that character George Clooney, Sandra Bullock and many more actors
seem believable. The same comment on what they thought was the best acting
performances in the past decade and highlight unique
methodology can be used acting choices from The New York Times Magazine series
for animators – build the “Screen Tests”.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 35
For example, the
demographic for recruiters
are mostly women, so you
might not want an animation
shot that will offend women
in your demo reel.
Recruiter’s Tip:
Everyone has a different type
of sense of humor. Stay on Animation Mentor Alumnus Nicole Ridgewell’s Demo Reel,
the safe side when choosing she was a Pixar Intern and is now working at Walt Disney
your shots for your demo Animation Studios.
Recruiter’s Tip:
5. Make sure your
demo reel link • Online streaming videos are preferable
works. • Create a your own Vimeo channel
• Showcase your demo reel in HD
Sometimes it’s the simple
• If they like your reel they will look at other
things that cost you the job.
videos in your Vimeo channel even if its a
Don’t overlook the details
work in progress.
when you submit your demo
reel to a studio. When you
give them a URL to look at, 6. Be aware of trends.
make sure all the links on the
Be cognizant of animation trends and dialogue
page work. If its password
shots that have been used by thousands of people.
protected, make sure you give
Recruiters tell us that they see a lot of “death” or
them the right password. As a
somber scenes. Five years ago, this type of shot
rule, recruiters are very busy
might have been rarer in animation but it has
people, so make it easy for
become more mainstream. Vary your dialogue
them to view your work.
choices to showcase that you can animate range
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 36
Animation Mentor Student Tim Rudder and his unique take on this dialogue performance
Recruiter’s Tip:
Animate something unexpected. With current pop culture trends swaying towards
dark themes as seen on The Walking Dead, Breaking Bad, or even Game of Thrones
… they are getting tired of the brooding anti-hero … unless there is a unique twist
to it of course. Be the unique storyteller that you were meant to be.
These tips are meant to be guidelines because in the end, “one size doesn’t fit all.”
Every studio is different so experiment, don’t give up, and keep working on your
demo reel so you can land that job! You can do it! v
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 37
PART II
The Working Life
of an Animator
What is it
like to be a
PIXAR animator?
A Q&A with Mentor Nate Wall
By Nate Wall
Animator, Pixar Animation Studios
Mentor, Animation Mentor
Ever wonder what it’s like to work at animating, drawing, or studying. In the
Pixar? Of course your do! That’s why we afternoon I may show the anim leads a
chatted with Pixar Animator Nate Wall polish pass of my shots that have been
to hear all about it. Nate has worked finaled by the director. Or I might take
on some of our very favorite movies like the opportunity to show shots to the
Finding Dory, Inside Out, and The Good director in walk-thrus, which is what
Dinosaur. Not bad, eh? Read on to learn we call a smaller, less intense version of
what it’s like to live the dream! dailies. Then wrap up for the day with a
last push on my work. I might try a new
idea quickly that came from review, or
Animation Mentor: What’s
perhaps just make some last tweaks to
a typical day like for you at
what’s been the main project of the day.
Pixar? Boom. Click. Head home.
Nate Wall: Typically the day will
AM: Can you explain what
start about 8 o’clock, with coffee. It’s nice
to see friendly co-worker faces around dailies are? Is it something
and we’ll usually chat a bit before unique to Pixar? And why
jumping into work. Pixar’s animation would you say it’s a good
dailies happen most days in the morning way to start work?
in one of the larger screening rooms,
and it’s a good way to start work. Nate: Dailies may be the most
Might have another meeting at some amazing and valuable part of the job,
point during the day, but most of the honestly. The generic version: dailies are
rest of my time I spend in my office the animation department’s opportunity
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 40
Running sequence animated by Nate Wall
to meet with the director and show our directors that engage with this process.
work. But it is much more. And no, it Because the director of course has the
isn’t unique to Pixar, generally speaking. final say, guiding the process along the
However, I previously worked at other way, and is responsible for every detail
studios, and can say that the animators of the movie. But if I had to sum it up, I
and department leadership have forged suppose I would say what defines Pixar’s
Pixar’s dailies into something special. animation dailies is humility. It is, after
all, incredibly humbling to show your
It’s a raucous, inspiring affair. Anyone in work to a room full of brilliant artists,
the room can (and everyone does) give and with the same humility those same
notes, speak up with ideas and opinions, artists show their work with the same
and all of it is in service of the shot and openness to ideas and improvements,
the story. Egos are naturally checked at and with the same humility the directors
the door, because we’ve all agreed to let and producers open themselves to the
creativity fly around that room until we group’s ideas and passions—because we
find what will make the shot into its best all just want to make a great film. And
version. it works, with immense satisfaction, for
everyone involved. But humility is the
We are also lucky to have such generous key. We all serve the story.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 41
Regarding emotions, it can be a wild ride as
you invest yourself in your work and yet stay
open to any and all criticism. And you do that
because you either trust—or you know first
hand—that every shot can be better and the
more you listen and see with other artists’ eyes
the better you will become.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 42
Nate Wall’s Shots from The Good Dinosaur. (Audio Not Included)
the hero is riding his stag to escape Nate: Hahaha. Many of them. I
a sudden ambush from samurai who don’t really want to call out anything
were attacking a village, and one of the in particular, at risk of putting some
samurai lets loose an arrow in the hero’s film under a microscope. However, I’d
direction. Pretty simple, but the shot say it’s frequent that I watch my shots
is unreal. How exciting the animator once they are “finaled” and wish I could
made that arrow fly at camera. You see have them back. Which is natural,
it release from the bow, then lose it for right. As an artist your eye improves
a second as it arcs away left, then back over time from experience and hard
right suddenly, and the hero just barely work. So it is natural that you would
dodges it across his shoulder. Stuff like see your past work and have a new and
that. better understanding of how you would
improve it now. How does the song go?
AM: In your work, what is “I wish that I knew what I know now,
one shot you wish you could when I was younger.” Yeah, it’s like that.
have back to do again?
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 43
AM: So, what’s the biggest AM: Leads nicely into my
challenge you’ve faced on a last question: Why DO you
project at Pixar? do this?
Nate: Whew. Well. The easy and Nate: I guess the most honest answer
boring answer is time. There’s never is that I love the process. Don’t get me
enough time it seems. But I’d say for wrong, I love films and love seeing the
me personally the biggest challenge final product, but it’s the process that
has been balancing my time and effort keeps me doing it every day. Which
with my emotions, and sometimes my is a good thing, because I don’t think
anxiety. Honestly, this job comes with working only for the final product
the pressure to stay sharp and do good would be enough. This work can be
work. In other words, it’s a job, not daunting—in its scope, density, and
a side passion project you can spend relentless attention to detail. Not to
years on at your leisure, which is where mention the volume and sharpness of
professionalism comes in. skills required to do the job at all.
Regarding emotions, it can be a wild But then again, the final product is part
ride as you invest yourself in your of it. When I was younger someone
work and yet stay open to any and all asked me why I wanted to make
criticism. And you do that because you animated films, and my answer then
either trust—or you know first hand— was that I wanted to make something
that every shot can be better and the meaningful for MY kids to watch.
more you listen and see with other She replied that was a silly reason for
artists’ eyes the better you will become. making art a career, which I suppose
And yet our department has never from a purely pragmatic perspective
wavered in its support of the time my is correct. And I took that to heart for
family needs, which is just to say that I a few years, until it became absolutely
work with good people who know my obvious that animation is a real voice in
best work will always shine when life is the world. Films, TV, games, advertising:
balanced. That’s a testament to this job, these things are LOUD and can say a
and in that case we’re pretty lucky to get lot. Anyway, what I’ve learned in the
to do this. Animation I mean. everyday grind is that it was important
to me, in whatever I did, to have
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 44
something meaningful to say. And in animation that can take shape by virtue of
collaboration at the film level, or just on the shot level where we work to make every
performance, every bit of motion and design meaningful to the audience. So for me
that last bit defines what we do (and why) as animators, and it’s a lucky thing to work
at a place that fully supports those lofty goals. v
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 45
Yair Gutierrez
Q&A
From Animation Mentor to
Captain America: Civil War
By Yair Gutierrez
Animator, Industrial Light & Magic
Alumnus, Animation Mentor
Talk about a student success story! Yair Gutierrez: My journey to
Animation Mentor alumnus Yair Industrial Light & Magic started all the
Gutierrez is killing it at Industrial Light way back in my childhood. Growing
& Magic, where he was a part of the up watching movies like Jurassic Park
team nominated for an Annie Award and Terminator 2, I was completely
for Captain America: Civil War! We mesmerized by the incredible work
caught up with Yair to ask the important done by ILM. Back then I didn’t really
questions: How freaking awesome is ILM? care about the movie making process,
What advice do you have for aspiring but that totally changed after I saw the
animators? And are you Team Cap or first Transformers movie. I remember
Team Iron Man?! Enjoy! very vividly, walking out of the theater
and telling myself, somehow someway
Animation Mentor: Let’s I want to work making movies. I was
do this! Tell us about your completely blown away.
journey from Animation
I then started researching and looking
Mentor to Industrial Light &
for a way to get into the industry, but
Magic and why you decided
I had no idea what field to pursue. I
to become an animator. enrolled into art school, which is where
I found my passion for animation,
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 47
and also learned about the character become an animator. I feel so blessed
animation program at Animation and thankful to work with all these
Mentor. I decided to enroll at AM wonderful people!
mainly for the fact that I was going to
be learning directly from animation AM: From what animation
professionals. I went through the shot have you learned the
Animals and Creatures classes as well most? And tell us why!
as the Character Animation Program.
I learned so much while taking the Yair: There are a few shots from
courses, but I also met so many talented which I’ve learned tons of new things,
and amazing people, some of whom I either about body mechanics or even
work with today. about my workflow and how to be more
efficient. But if I had to pick one shot, I
Fast forward a few years, and I was would have to go back to the very last
lucky enough to work on Transformers: shot I worked on while at Animation
Age of Extinction, alongside the people Mentor, which is also the first shot of my
who directly influenced my decision to demo reel. Up to that point, it was the
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 48
most complicated and the longest shot ILM is the people I get to work with.
I had ever attempted. I learned about Everyone here is extremely talented and
the importance of planning a shot and friendly, which makes for an amazing
having an overall idea of where you work environment. I would not change
want the shot to go way before you set it for anything. I feel super lucky to work
your first key. at such an amazing place!
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 49
familiar with the character
than I already was. All for the
sake of research! It was a very
intimidating project to take
on but it was also a lot of fun!
By Zach Parrish
Animator, Disney Animation Studios
Alumnus, Animation Mentor
that animation was what I wanted to do.
Zach Parrish starts off our Where are I went to the Savannah College of
they now? blog series as we take a look Art and Design and graduated with a
back at our alumni and past students BFA in Animation. I started attending
to see how everyone is doing. We were Animation Mentor at the end of my time
lucky enough to get a hold of Zach who at SCAD and I was in the middle of class
attended Animation Mentor in 2008 1 when I was hired as an Apprentice at
and look at where he is today – he’s the Rhythm & Hues Studios on Alvin and
Head of Animation (HOA) for Big Hero the Chipmunks. I continued my studies
6 at Disney! Wow and what an amazing with Animation Mentor during the
accomplishment! Read about how he production of Alvin and The Incredible
got there, his advice for students, and Hulk. I stayed at R&H for a year and a
how Glen Keane taught him a big lesson half before switching to Sony to work
in humility. Be inspired, enjoy, and go on Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs
animate! (mostly due to my Animation Mentor
work). I worked on Cloudy and Alice
ANIMATION MENTOR: Tell in Wonderland at Sony before hearing
us about your journey. How about Tangled (then Rapunzel) at
did you get to where you Disney. I was fortunate enough to get
hired at Disney as the last animator on
are today?
Tangled.
ZACH: Well, it all started the day I
was born. 7 lbs 8 oz… I kid. I wanted After Tangled, I worked on the Prep
to do animation since I was a kid. I and Landing short as well as Prep
grew up on Disney movies and Warner and Landing 2 before applying to be
Brother cartoons. I always said I was an Animation Supervisor on Wreck-
going to “draw cartoons” when I grew It Ralph. I was given an amazing
up. I fell a little off the wagon during opportunity to fill that role and worked
high school, but after seeing Mr. Bobby on Ralph for a year and a half. At the
Beck’s work (as well as his colleagues) end of Ralph, I applied to be the Head of
in Monsters Inc. and realizing that there Animation on Big Hero 6. I was paired
were actual people out there making me with Patrick Osborne to share the role
feel for a one eyed, green ball, I knew before he was selected to direct his story
“Feast.” I continued on as the solo Head
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 52
of Animation on Big Hero 6, and the Animation is all about communication
rest is history. in a variety of ways, but the
biggest challenge for me has been
Bored yet? Did I even answer the communicating with my teammates
question? Short answer: by doing a LOT either in giving or receiving feedback/
of animation and a LOT of learning. notes in a clear, respectful manner while
maintaining my personality and passion
ANIMATION MENTOR: What for the craft. I think it is an important
personal roadblocks did you lesson for all students to learn, because
overcome to get there? it doesn’t matter how talented you are, if
you are a jerk, no one will want to work
ZACH: There have been so many with you.
roadblocks along the way that it is
difficult to pick a few out of the herd. I ANIMATION MENTOR: What
think the biggest roadblock that I still is a typical day like for a
am not sure I have overcome completely professional animator and
is the fear of failure. Every transition in how does that differ from
my career has been laden with the fear being head of animation?
of failure. I struggled at the beginning
with not being good at animation right ZACH: A typical day for an animator
away. I still struggle today with the feat at Disney is from 9am – 7pm with an
that I might not know what I am doing. hour for lunch. Obviously, this varies
I think all of the early failures in my from animator to animator as it isn’t a
education and career have given me a hard rule. A typical day could consist of
confidence and a comfort with that fear issuing; a meeting with the Animation
and with failure. Supervisors, Head of Animation, and
Director(s) where the animator is
I think Ed Catmull’s mantra of “Fail assigned their new shots and walked
fast. Fail often.” is a valuable one. Every through the specifics that the Director
stumble and every “mistake” is a lesson and Anim Leads would like to see and
in hiding. the subtext/emotion of the scene. We
also have meetings called Rounds and
Another valuable hurdle to overcome Dailies where the animators gather to
has been the power of communication.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 53
Disney’s Big Hero 6 production crew wrap photo
show their shots to the Anim Supes/ Animation is also responsible for
HOA (rounds) or to the Anim Supes/ representing the animation department
HOA and Director(s) (dailies). In to all other departments on the show.
these meetings the goal is to give Therefore the HOA and the Animation
notes to better clarify the point of the Supes are in meetings from Workbook
shot, the emotion and subtext of the Turnover (hand off from Story to
performance, or to simply give notes Layout) through Layout and Editorial,
on how to push poses/timing/spacing/ as well as tracking the shots after they
entertainment. Typically, an animator leave Animation through Lighting. This
will show their shots in Rounds to get gives the animation leads the context
the notes of the supervisors before of the scenes so that they might offer
addressing those notes and showing in performance ideas during layout as well
Dailies. The rest of our days are filled as be able to give advice to the animators
with animating (I swear we sit and do while they are on the floor at animator’s
some of this), video reference, research desks or in Rounds. Rounds and Dailies
(YouTube cat videos), ping-pong, pool, take up a large portion of the day as it is
and socializing. the best way for the HOA to support the
crew of animators. Other responsibilities
The day of a Head of Animation is throughout the day for the HOA also
fairly similar, except the amount of time include planning, bidding (how long will
available for animating and socializing a shot take to animate), casting (who
is considerably less. The Head of will animate the shot), and interfacing
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 54
with top level show leadership. on Tangled. I had been cast a wide
That answer was really straight forward variety of shots on the show, but John
and boring! I am sorry. I swear it is and Clay wanted to test me to see
all a lot of fun! We mostly just laugh where I would break. They gave me two
and make fun of each other and do shots of Rapunzel crying over Flynn
animation all day. It is great! as he dies. Flynn says “You were my
new dream” which was animated by
ANIMATION MENTOR: What Frozen HOA Lino DiSalvo, and I had
was the most rewarding the counterpart shot of Rapunzel saying
shot you’ve ever animated? “And you were mine.” That shot was a
huge challenge for me. I had never done
Why, and what did you learn
a crying character (not well anyways),
from it?
and definitely never a crying female
ZACH: The one shot that jumps to character. I put a lot of myself into the
mind is a single shot I got to animate shot and spent a lot of time crying in
Zach’s subtle facial animation on Rapunzel’s “And you were mine.” shot
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 55
the reference room (for reference I
swear!). My first pass was completely ANIMATION MENTOR: What
over animated. I pushed everything to was the most rewarding
a point where I could easily see what experience you’ve had in
I was doing, but the directors and the animation? Why, and what
anim supes all felt like it was too much.
did you learn from it?
I worked and reworked the shot and
learned so much about the subtlety of ZACH: I think the most rewarding
facial animation. part of working in the animation
industry is the relationships that are
The most rewarding part was when forged in the fires of production. The
Glen Keane stopped my shot during people I have been fortunate enough
dailies and started framing through it. to work alongside have constantly
He kept saying, “wow” and then went challenged me in my animation
on to explain how he was jealous. He
told me that I was doing things with the skill set as well as my perspective
forms in the face that he always tried to on story-telling, film-making, and
do in hand drawn animation but was communication. I am constantly
difficult to accomplish because of the inspired and entertained. The best
medium. To be told I had accomplished feeling is going to the wrap party and
something that THE Glen Keane was watching the work of your friends and
impressed by was a huge moment in afterwards being able to celebrate the
my career. I also learned a big lesson experience with them. I frame through
in humility. Glen is arguably the best animation everyday and learn little
animator of all time and he was humble tricks about overshoots or overlap
enough to show appreciation for others’ or exaggeration. I chat with other
work. animators and learn about workflow,
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 56
tools, or teamwork. Every day the people me personally, clarity is king. When
around me are a lesson in some aspect we see a reel where the phrasing of
of the animation industry and that is the the shot is overlapped and cluttered, it
most rewarding part of the job. definitely gives us pause. Clarity spans
into posing/staging, timing, spacing,
phrasing, etc. Every principle can be
ANIMATION MENTOR: What examined under. “is this the clearest way
is the most common pitfall to show the SUBTEXT of my acting?”
you see students have and
what advice can you give
them? ANIMATION MENTOR:
When you attended
ZACH: I feel like I commonly see Animation Mentor, what
students getting lost on the subtext of was that experience like for
the scene they are animating. I think you? How did it help further
too often students try to animate with prepare you?
a capital “A”. I was prone to this mistake
as well. I would push my animation way
further than it needed to go because ZACH: I can honestly say that I would
it was easier to see the arcs and the never be where I am today if it were not
spacing, and when I did a really cool arc for my time with Animation Mentor. I
or squash and stretch it felt like I was had been animating for a few years and
really showcasing my prowess of the had a really good education at SCAD,
principles. However, I think the more when I started Animation Mentor.
impressive thing to see in a student reel
is the ability to restrain the overacting However, I was doing a lot of things in
and the over animating and to make my animation without knowing WHY
the performance feel real/believable. I was doing them. I knew things looked
I am not saying, only do subtle shots wrong, but I didn’t have the verbiage or
on your reel. I am saying to really dive the eye to understand why.
deep into the “WHY” of the shot and
then think about the most clear way to Class 1 of Animation Mentor provided
communicate that part of the shot. For me with so many of those eureka
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 57
moments. I finally understood definitively the difference between timing and
spacing. I could verbalize why my shots looked wonky, and I used that knowledge
in my interview with Rhythm & Hues. I dissected my demo reel and told them
what I would improve on all of my shots with my new found understanding of the
principles.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 58
ILM London’s
Chris Hurtt Q&A
Animating for Live Action vs.
Animated Films
By Chris Hurtt
Animator, Industrial Light & Magic London
Mentor, Animation Mentor
Chris had fun figuring out how to animate Cogsworth face in 2017’s Beauty and the Beast
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 60
but at the same time have life and attention paid to doing the research up
embody Sir Ian’s delivery. A great front on a shot-by-shot basis.
challenge you don’t get everyday.
AM: What are the major
AM: How about for The differences for animators
Jungle Book? What did you working on live action film
work on, and what was your VFX vs fully-animated films?
favorite character or shot?
Chris: It’s a good question, but I want
Chris: I worked mainly on Bagherra to start off by saying that the similarities
and a bit on the baby elephant that far outweigh the differences. It’s really
Mowgli bonds with. Two Disney re- just a question of style, with obviously
makes in a row! Next, Pocahontas. VFX being pretty much set in a photo-
Hahaha. realistic style. The differences can be
more acting and creative freedom with
For The Jungle Book it was non-stop Feature Animation vs. being a bit more
video reference research 24/7. Before tied to either Pre-Vis, Motion Capture,
we even starting setting keyframes, you Live-Action Reference, or the live-action
would present an edit of all your takes of plate in VFX—and the technical needs
video footage taken from the Internet. to make it look real.
Usually you would string together
several clips to make an edit of the entire That being said, I love variety, and
performance you were going for. It was probably my favourite type of project
a hugely successful approach, as the is something like Paddington that is
animation director and director could full character animation but with the
see your ideas before you had spent any believability of VFX realism.
time animating.
Then when you starting keying you AM: What’s the most
knew you were close to the right path challenging shot you’ve ever
and could work with confidence and animated, and what did you
also be quite fast. Most first passes learn from it?
looked really good because of the
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 61
Working as an animator means a constant variety of new challenges. You can be a flying whale one
day, a talking brain, a super-hero or a cute bear. Here I’ve taken 1 shot from almost every project I’ve
worked on a cut them in sequential order. They may not but the best, or longest shots I did, but they
in some way encapsulated the spirit of each project for me.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 62
Chris: There are a few
unique challenges to VFX.
One is, your shot may go
until the end of the show.
Feature animation shots
tend to last a few weeks at
most, whereas VFX shots
can all stay unfilled until
the last month. So having
the stamina to keep
working on something
almost endlessly is a big Here is a favourite shot from G-Force and a string of takes I did for the
one. video reference. See if you can guess which take is used in the end. (Its
kinda a trick question as I used two sections of two clips!) One of the
things I like about shooting reference is you can get in so many ideas in
An eye for realistic timing, so little time. Here I was able to see 8 possibilities in 1 min of my time.
weight, and motion is
another. It’s probably the
biggest thing VFX anim
work, which has more leeway to cheat things. Also
supervisors look for, even
making the animation playblast look very pretty is
above nice acting in a
something that’s becoming more and more expected,
character animation shot,
so some basic modelling, lighting, camera work, and
because that final polish
pre-vis type skills can help. v
on realism can be quite
tricky and go on longer
than feature work.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 63
PART III
More Tips for
Beginners
8 Things
Maya Noobs
Should Know
By Animation Mentor
So, you’ve always wanted to learn
1. How 3D space works and
animation. You’ve heard of this software
package called “Maya” and that it is the
how it is represented by the
industry standard for 3D animation. computer.
Friends and advisors have told you to
Real life exists in 3D, but our computers
download the free trial of Maya to get
screens are 2D. Maya, like many 3D
an idea of how it works. But there’s one
software packages, represents 3D by
big problem: you’ve never worked in 3D
using 3 axes: the X, Y, and Z axes. The
before, you have no idea what in the
intersection of these axes is called
world to do with this software package,
the origin and is represented by the
and you can’t manage to open a file, let
coordinates (0,0,0). Think back to the
alone start to animate something. You’re
classic Super Mario Bros. video game.
hit by a wave of panic and self-doubt;
Mario’s world is represented entirely in
you start to wonder if you should even
2D space, aka. the X-Y plane, X for the
be thinking about being an animator
horizontal line (ex. the bricks Mario
anymore. Sound familiar? We’ve all been
walks along), and Y for the vertical axis
there. Good news: we’re here to help! Read
(ex. short Mario vs tall Mario).
on to learn the 8 things you need to know
when you open Maya for the first time.
Now, imagine how you would bring
Mario into the 3D universe. You would
- The Animation Mentor Crew
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 66
need to add a 3rd dimension, which is list of Maya hotkeys and then go ahead
where the Z-axis comes in to play. The and give ‘em a try.
Z-axis is how you build out Mario’s hat,
the tip of his nose, or the bristles of his 3. Google is an even better
mustache. friend than hotkeys.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 67
Screenshot of a .ma file opened in WordPad; you can see how a savvy coder can read the
script, find an error, fix it with some keystrokes, and save your animation!
standard software for animation – after essentially saves your scene as a text file
15+ years, thousands of animators have of commands. This allows you to open
worked on countless films, shows, video the file in a text editor, such as WordPad
games, and various other projects. If or Notepad, and edit the scene directly
you need help in Maya, chances are very within the script of the file. This is handy
high that someone else has experienced if your file ends up corrupted and you
the same thing and posted about it on want to try to restore it using scripts. By
the internet. contrast, saving as a “.mb” file strips out
the text information and compresses it
4. .ma vs .mb files – What into numeric values, reducing your file
are they and why do they size, but making it impossible to edit
matter? the script from a text editor. “.mb” is the
default saving method established by
In Maya, you have the option to save Maya, so if you do not anticipate editing
your scene file as either “scene.ma” your scene from the text file, “.mb”
or “scene.mb”. “.ma” stands for “Maya should work just fine for you.
Ascii” and “.mb” stands for “Maya
Binary”. There’s no difference to the
visual look of your scene based on how
you save it. The difference lies under the
hood. Saving your scene as a “.ma” file
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 68
5. Save! Save! Save! 6. What the heck is a NURB,
exactly? And how is a NURB
The saying goes, “It’s better to have it different from a polygon?
and not need it, than need it and not
have it.” The same idea applies to saving NURBS and polygons are both ways
your work Maya. We’ve heard from you can create objects in Maya. NURBS
students time and time again…it’s 1 stands for Non-Uniform Rational
o’clock in the morning, they’ve been B-splines and are great for creating
refining a scene for hours, and then, objects with smooth curves and
wham, Maya crashed and they lost all of surfaces. Polygons can be thought of
their work! If only they had been saving more as a mosaic of pieces assembled
versions the whole time, they would together to create your object. Take the
have lost only minutes of work instead simple objects below:
of hours. Trust us. SAVE YOUR WORK.
On the left, a simple NURBS sphere has been modified into a bowl, with smooth curves forming the shape of the
bowl; on the right, a simple polygon has been modified into a dumbbell, which has harder lines. NURBS are great to
model a complex shape and then convert it to polygons. Textures are easier to map on polygons rather than NURBS.
It really depends on what you are trying to do. Industry standard tends to lean toward polygons rather than NURBS.
Figure out what works best for your project.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 69
7. Use the different views to space.
refine your choices.
8. There’s more than 1 way
Maya offers you different ways to view
to do just about everything.
your object in 3D space. You can look
at it from above, below, in front of, In many software programs, there’s
behind, or from the side of your object. at least three ways to save your work:
By default, Maya provides you with the File > Save menu; Ctrl + S; or
perspective and orthographic cameras clicking a Save icon. Likewise in Maya,
(front, side, top, and a free-moving there’s multiple ways to do several
perspective camera). Use the perspective commands. For example, you can add
view to view your object from all a NURBS object by either using the
angles, and use the side, front, and Create>NURBS Primitives>Sphere
top orthographic views to examine a menu OR by selecting the Surfaces
flattened version of your work (basically, tab and clicking the Sphere icon. This
you just see two of the axes). You can may be confusing at first, after all, with
also view your objects in wireframe, so many options, how can you ever
shaded, textures, or lighting views and decide which is the “right” way. Here’s
high, medium, or low resolutions, which a secret: it’s up to you! As you grow
can be toggled on or off via hotkeys. The as an animator, you’ll start to learn
different views allow you to get a good which workflow works best for you.
look at what you are doing, and to refine Experiment and play; learn and grow. v
the placement of your object in 3D
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 70
Getting
Everything Done:
Time Management for
Animators
By Boola Robello
Senior Animator, MPC
Mentor, Animation Mentor
You have a full time job, you have kids will create the time you need for that
to pick up, and your homework is due specific goal.
tomorrow! What do you do?!
First let’s start with some facts. A
24 year veteran animator and mentor, standard professional animator’s
Clarence “Boola” Robello, offers his workday is 8-10 hours a day depending
industry advice on managing time so you on which studio you work for. The 12-
can do everything you need to do without 14 hour day is during our crunch-time/
the stress. We guarantee you that there’s overtime where we are working towards
something here you can put into action the final end date to finish the project.
right away. Let’s get organized! That is a lot of hours of animating every
day and therefore quite a bit of practice
- The Animation Mentor Crew on the job. As an animation student part
of your commitment is to get in as many
hours of practice as you can to achieve
Time Management. It is your goal of becoming a professional
something everyone struggles with. animator.
Whether you are a college student, a
busy professional, a parent, or in this Over the years instructing here at AM,
case an aspiring animator, everyone I’ve seen many students struggle with
struggles to find the time to get to the managing their time to complete their
things they want to work on. Finding assignments successfully. What I am
the time is the wrong way to look at it. about to offer in this post is what I
You have to make a point to make the have told every single student who has
time. If you want to be in shape, you taken my class. Those that followed this
make time to go to the gym. If you want “workflow” and stayed focused and
to have a relationship you make time for committed to their schedule improved
your partner. If you want a family you extremely well within a 12 week course
make time to spend with them. If you at AM. They really made leaps and
want to become a professional animator, bounds in their work because of their
you have to make the time outside commitment to themselves. I am not
of your animation classes to advance exaggerating as I have seen student’s
yourself further. To say it all another animation go from mediocre at best,
way, you have to make a schedule that to “wow can this be the same student?”
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 72
I know this schedule works not only remains a dream. This is the doing part
because of my students’ success with of making it happen for yourself. Before
it, but because it is the exact schedule you close down the computer, submit
I made for myself when I was working your work into the Public Review areas
on my goal of becoming an animator. It of AM or animation forums of your
takes a lot of dedication and discipline choice for critiques.
to attain your goals in life and if you’re
willing to do that, then here is what I You follow this same pattern the next
did, what other successful students have day, except now you should have
done, and what I suggest you do too! feedback from peers and those forums.
Especially if you are a student at AM as Remember some of these peers are
this will work for every single class. working professional animators too, so
you address the repeating notes because
Monday – Friday those are the notes everyone is agreeing
on as they are clearly seeing it in your
If you work full time or go to school full work. Address those notes and then
time, when you get home eat dinner move onto the ones you personally agree
and decompress a bit. If you have will make your work stronger.
homework get that done. If you’re not in
college and are a working professional If you do this right you will effectively
looking to become an animator, then be putting in at least 4-6 hours a day
get onto your animation homework of animating time on your assignment.
immediately. You lock yourself in What you are trying to do here is
your studio and you animate until it is replicate the hours put in at a studio. If
time for you to turn in for the night. a professional animator animates 8-10
Nothing else exists during this time. hours a day, by you putting in 4-6 hours
No television, no phone conversations, a day on your assignment you are at
no texting, no distractions of any kind! least reaching a half-day of their full day
Only animation. This is your time. Pure of work!
concentration. You are working on your
skills and it needs to be honed. If this Saturday
is your dream then to make it a reality
you have to do something about it. If you do not have any personal/family
Action needs to happen otherwise it just plans, treat Saturday as a full 8-10 hour
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 73
work day animating your assignment. amount of hours for at least 6 days
Submit your work at the end of the straight. Remember, it is the closest
evening for your Mentor’s critique. At way to simulate the working hours of a
the very latest submit first thing Sunday professional animator. Now of course
morning. things in life will come up and adjust
this schedule. Just bend and flow with it
If you do have plans treat it like as best you can, but get back on track as
Monday-Friday. If the plans are in the soon as it passes.
evening reverse it all where you are
animating in the day and then you can In order to make it in this business
go out at night. you have to really pay your dues to get
there. We all did. This exact workflow
Sunday schedule is how I became an animator
very quickly. It made my work take
This is your day off with the exception significant steps forward and therefore
to watch the AM video lecture and take get noticed when the time came. This
detailed notes. kind of dedication and discipline that I
learned from martial arts training will
If you do not work or have school, and bring you the results you are searching
you are home Monday – Friday, then for. Look at it all this way, if your goal
I would treat that as a full workday, is to become a professional animator,
animating all day for 8 hours a day. If then you need to seriously practice like
this is your case you could potentially we do. This is the kind of passion and
take both Saturday and Sunday off, dedication we bring to our work in the
simulating the actual working week of films and projects that have inspired
a professional animator (not on crunch you to become an animator. It is not
time). impossible to do this, but it does take a
lot of hard work and a lot of dedication
At first glance this workflow may seem on your part. You have to put in your
like common sense, but you would be time and pay your dues. It will not
very surprised how many people never happen just because you attend a certain
see it this way! This workflow will help school, learn a few quick tips and tricks,
you keep your time managed properly, and animate an hour here or there. If
and will get you animating the most you are willing to truly practice hard
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 74
and improve and grow from your mistakes, while never giving up on your dream,
then there is only one outcome that is certain. But it all starts with how you manage
your time. If it is important to you, then make the schedule, follow it, and go make
your dream become your reality.
I sincerely hope this has been helpful for you. I wish you all the best in your goals
and life. v
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 75
How to Maximixe
Your Poductivity
As an Animator
By David Tartt
Owner, RMAL
Mentor, Animation Mentor
Animation is a time-consuming art quality animation?
form—there’s just no way around it.
Something that many people don’t Below I’ll list some ideas and tips that
understand when they first get into I’ve personally found incredibly helpful.
animation is that the quality of a shot
is directly related to available time. So Creating Focus, or Flow
what do you do when time is limited?
How do you squeeze the most productive The psychological state of “focus”, or
time out of your week? Learn top time “flow”, is a time where you are incredibly
management tips from David Tart, focused on your tasks and able to get a
animator for Toy Story, Monster’s Inc., maximum amount of great work done.
and Finding Nemo! When you achieve this level of focus,
time is no longer relevant. You may
The level of detail, the amount of have experienced this state yourself – it’s
planning, and the implementation in when you’re working on a specific task.
a complex program like Maya all take You look up at the clock and an hour
time, especially if you want to create or two has passed, but it felt like only
great-looking work. 10 or 15 minutes. Psychologists have
researched this state of mind thoroughly
Something that many people don’t and identified it as one where we are
understand when they first get into at our peak level of productivity. Our
animation is that the quality of an ability to create, to problem-solve, and
animated shot is directly related to crank out good work is at it’s maximum
available time. For instance, an animator potential.
who’s responsible for finishing 4 seconds
of animation per 50 hour week is going Research shows that it can take between
to create much better looking animation 10 and 15 minutes to achieve the flow-
than an animator who’s responsible for state, while it can take only a minute
finishing 40 seconds per week, even if to end it. This means that you want to
they have essentially the same level of plan your work time so that you have
skill. minimal interruptions, because these
interruptions terminate flow.
So time, and how you use that time, will
be directly related to the quality of your For instance, if you set aside 3 hours to
finished shots. So how can you squeeze work on your animation but stop
more time out of a week to create better
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 77
working to check your email, Mentor requires anywhere from 10 to 40
make a facebook post, shop hours per week. Take a good hard look at that
online, talk to a friend, get some calendar, then block out sustained chunks
coffee, etc. eight times during of no less that two-hours each. Let friends
that 180-minute period, you will and family know that you won’t be available
have spent 80 to 120 minutes during those periods.
of potential flow-state in less-
than-productive conditions.
Sure, you’ll still get stuff done
but nowhere near as much you
would have without those breaks.
Creating Work
Spaces on Maya
By Michelle Meeker
Mentor, Animation Mentor
“At any time I still expect that the
no-talent police will come and arrest
me.” -Mike Myers
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 86
Do the work
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 87
Get comfortable with being easy way out and make someone’s great
uncomfortable work about your inadequacies. Use the
inspiration to aim higher and make your
If you’re taking risks, you’re going to be work stronger.
uncomfortable. Insecurity is all about
being uncomfortable. This is not a bad Lastly, reach out to other artists. This
thing. I know when I’m uncomfortable, can be as simple as telling a classmate,
I can use this feeling to push me to work “I really enjoyed how you handled
harder and be more aware that I’m in your assignment.” Think about what
the fight. Security and confidence can someone’s kind words have meant to
breed comfort. If you’re comfortable you in the past…especially from people
in what you’re creating…you’re not that you aren’t related to. Even better is
pushing yourself. Don’t fool yourself finding a group of people creating stuff
into thinking comfort and confidence and go hang with them. Your fellow
equals security. creators understand the feelings of
insecurity and can support you to keep
Stop comparing your creating. When you support others it
journey to others can also help you by pulling you out of
your “I Suck Hamster Wheel”…even if
Notice I didn’t say stop comparing your only for a few moments.
work. You do need to look at where your
work ranks compared to others. This Until…you are once again greeted by a
is a reality of becoming a professional now good friend.
artist. But don’t use this comparison
to freeze you in your tracks. Use their “Why hello, Insecurity. Let’s do the
work to inspire you and to aim higher work.” v
in your own work. As you are inspired,
remember to stay on your own path. You
are not here to make copycat work. Also,
remember that social media has skewed
real life. You have no idea how much
sweat went into a final product or how
much they thought their work was sub
par up until the final pass. Don’t take the
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 88
Be Brave
7 Ways to Overcome Your Insecurity
By Dana Masson
Mentor, Animation Mentor
Today, studio owner and beloved mentor about this when I was acting, and I
Dana Boadway-Masson touches on the attended dozens of auditions, and got
topic that every animator struggles with. rejected from most of them.
Throughout her career, Dana has had the
great fortune to work alongside some of The reality is that there are hundreds
the most talented creative professionals of animators out there, and many
in the world. But as we all know, creative people vying for the same positions.
work is always a struggle, and the ability If you gave up after your first couple
to innovate comes with a plethora of fears of rejections, you’d never make it as
and insecurities needed to overcome. In an animator. You’ll probably send out
her post, Dana shares the lessons that many applications before you finally get
have helped her deal with insecurity a response. The thing to remember is
directly and maintain that sense of that there are lots of factors that come
innovation in the ever-changing world of into play when it comes to getting that
animation. response – the quality of your work is
only one of those. You should always
- The Animation Mentor Crew be looking to improve the quality
of your work and your reel, but you
can’t and shouldn’t take rejections or
Hey all! I’m here to talk to you guys non-responses personally. They could
about confidence, insecurities, and some be looking for a particular style of
of the situations where these things animation for their project that you
come into play most when working in don’t have on your reel, if you’re not
the animation industry. from their area they could be looking for
a local resident because of tax laws or a
THICK SKIN / HANDLE short project duration, they could have
REJECTION others who have personal connections
within the studio that have similar reel
This is one of the first situations you’re quality to yours – and the studio will
likely to encounter when you’re trying generally go with people who come
to get your first job(s) and get some personally recommended by people they
experience, but it’s something that will trust. Something I realized once when I
happen throughout your career, even went to a group audition, where we all
once you’re established. I first learned had to do our monologues in front of
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 90
each other, is that most people are really YOU will be that person that comes
mediocre at what they do. If you work personally recommended, and in turn
hard, apply yourself, and keep at it, you you’ll be able to recommend others once
can and will become better than most. you’ve built relationships and you’ve got
This is why being passionate about what the trust of YOUR studio.
you do is so important. It keeps you
moving in spite of rejection. As a mentor of mine from my school
days told me, “Take any job you can get
PERSISTENCE in a studio, even if it’s running for coffee.
It’s a LOT easier to get where you want
Keep putting yourself out there! The to go from INSIDE a studio than from
more exposure you get, the better the the outside.”
chances that you’ll get that first job that
will set you on your path. And once If it takes time to get that first job, use
you’re in, you’ll start getting to know that time to get feedback from peers
people, and networking, and one day and keep working on and improving
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 91
your reel! Yes, you can send updated Your eye for your own work, and the
reels to studios. As they see your work work of others will change and improve
improving and evolving, they will keep with increased experience. I remember
you in mind for upcoming projects. having a GIANT leap in my ability
Many studios will keep your reels on file to ‘see’ very subtle quality differences
over time. in animation once I worked on my
first feature film and spent an hour or
ABILITY TO TAKE so each day in Dailies, watching the
CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM director give animators feedback on
their shots. I learned a whole new visual
When you’re getting feedback on your language all of a sudden, and it was like
reel, no matter who it’s from, you a revelation. Sometimes only after you’ve
have to remember that this feedback had a revelation like this, can you truly
comes from places of various levels of understand what was missing in your
knowledge and experience. You don’t work before. You’ll have lots of “ah-HA!”
have to feel offended by any of it, and moments throughout your career, over
you don’t have to use all of it if you don’t years and years of honing your skills.
want to, either. Sometimes a person’s
individual sense of style will also affect PRESENTING YOURSELF IN
what kind of comments they give you – THE RIGHT WAY
they can often be very subjective. Also,
when you ask someone for comments, You don’t have to pretend to be
they may only give you ideas of things something that you’re not, but a studio
they think should be changed, and they will generally be looking for people
may NOT include positive comments, who can work well with their team.
even if they had positive reactions to Presenting yourself in a friendly and
your work. personable way in an interview is
important. Your animation skills are
If you’re lucky enough to get feedback really the main key to your success, but
from a studio you’ve applied to, and you over time, if you are a jerk to others
really want to work at that studio, you in your studio, and disrespectful, your
should take those suggestions and run skills won’t get you much farther.
with them, and re-submit your work.
Part of the studio experience and
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 92
working on a project with others is your ability to communicate well, get along with
your colleagues, and play off of each other to get interesting performances from
the characters you’re working with. You’ll be spending a LOT of time with these
people, so personalities are important when forming a team. I’ve met some of my
best friends working in studios! And conversely, I’ve met the occasional person
who I really clashed with. The trick is to be able to put forth your best effort to
work together and make compromises and act respectful even when you don’t like
someone. It will happen on occasion, but for the most part, I’ve really enjoyed my
co-workers. There have been some times when I’ve started off not liking or being put
off by someone, but after getting to know them better, came to at least respect their
position, or even become very good friends with them. So staying open, receptive
and friendly in the studio can not only help the production move forward well,
but it can open doors to better work relationships, and sometimes even lifelong
friendships.
Being able to deal with various kinds of personalities in a studio will also be key
down the road when you end up with an opportunity to be a lead or a supervisor.
You’ll not only have to get along well with and motivate everyone on your team, but
you might have to manage disputes between THEM as well.
FLEXIBILITY
This is a transient industry. Chances are pretty good that you won’t be at the same
studio for longer than a couple of years, and as little as a couple of weeks or months.
There are some situations where you can make a pretty long career stretch at one
place, but it’s more the exception than the rule. You’ll be working in different studios,
in different cities, in different countries, with different software, for different leads
and different directors, on projects with different styles. You’ll need to learn how to
adapt in many ways to new situations.
You’ll need to adapt your workflow to meet the needs of different types of
productions, too. Television series, for instance, have a much higher animation
quota, with less time for attention to detail – compared to feature film, which has
a much lower quota, but the level of detail and refinement (and the number of
controls on a character!) is very high. One of the GREAT parts of being an animator
is how many different kinds of work your skills can be applied to. It keeps things
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 93
interesting! Right now I’m working on problems, and figure out solutions that
some character animation for a fine will help the production run smoothly.
art installation – something I’ve never The more you can learn how to deal
done before! And that’s after 15 years with your computer on your own, the
of experience on just about every type easier things are. Yes, studios have IT
of production you can imagine. There people to help with issues, but it’s great
will always be something new to try. It’s to be able to work your way through a
awesome! problem quickly on your own, rather
than having to wait for someone else to
INNOVATION & PROBLEM come and help you.
SOLVING SKILLS
There will also be times when you’ll
The nature of working with computers have a shot you’re working on that’s got
and software, even in an artistic field, a particular challenge – like multiple
means you’ll have to solve technical characters and constraint animation
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 94
that you have to work out a
solution for that will work
within the studio pipeline,
or coordinating with a rigger
to create certain things in
a character rig that will
make the shot work better.
Learning how to deal with
these things on your own
makes you a valuable asset
to a team with a deadline. It
also will be a skill that will
serve you well if you have
aspirations of becoming a
lead or a supervisor one day.
There will be lots of problem
solving that you’ll need to
do when you’re casting shots
and planning out a sequence looking shots in the production you’re working
for your team. on, and you want to get amazing stuff for your reel
over time. You were hired because of your ability
BALANCE to be creative and entertaining. YET… you will get
BETWEEN calls on your work that you completely disagree
‘OWNING’ YOUR with, and you just KNOW would be better if you
did it your own way. Well, when it comes down to
WORK, AND
it, the director’s vision is the one that everyone on
DOING WHAT IS
the team needs to work towards, whether you agree
ASKED OF YOU BY with it or not. It can be frustrating at times, but if
A DIRECTOR OR each animator went off and did their own thing,
LEAD the project would lack cohesion and consistency.
There may be a subjective viewpoint that you don’t
You are an artist. You are share with a director. Sometimes you’ll click with
invested in your work. a director and “get” them with no problem at all,
You want to have GREAT and sometimes you’ll need to learn what it is that
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 95
they’re looking for and how to apply In the end, when you’re working at a
that to your work for that particular studio, you’re working on someone
project. Yes, there generally is room else’s project, so you have to do a certain
for you to put your own creative spin amount of adapting to their needs, and
on a shot. Most directors do want their checking your ego at the door.
animators to contribute their ideas, and
explore possibilities for entertainment. Every aspect that I’ve discussed in this
But where you are looking at your one article involves having the guts to put
shot or sequence of shots in detail, the yourself out there, with the knowledge
director has their eye always on the big that there could be criticism and/or
picture, and your idea for a shot may not rejection. The victories can be very
always fit the bigger story arc or energy. sweet, but at times your confidence
You have to find that fine line between can take quite a bruising. But if you’re
creativity and following direction, and passionate, and persistent, and have a
walk it like a tightrope. good work ethic, you can overcome the
down times and work your way back
When you have an idea for adding to a positive place. The more you can
something unexpected to a shot, take those ‘negative’ events, learn from
the thing you need to be good it and then let it go and move forward,
at is presenting that idea. Your the better off you’ll be. I still go through
communication in your planning and this all the time, even after a decade and
blocking better be 100% clear and a half!
concise! If the director doesn’t “get it”
at first glance, it won’t be approved Failures are, after all, an opportunity to
for you to move forward with it. If it learn. It doesn’t mean you’re finished,
gets rejected, you have to be okay with it means you’re growing. And the folks
moving forward with the direction who are the very best at what they do
you’re given. If you continue to work have a large string of failures in their
on something that wasn’t approved, it past. The difference between those
will be considered disrespectful of the people and the ones who didn’t make it,
director’s valuable time. You need to is they just didn’t let it hold them back. :)
be able to let it roll off your shoulders,
and try again another time, whether - Dana v
you agree with the assessment or not.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 96
6 Most Common
Mistakes
of Beginning Animators
By Jane Cassidy
Animator, Pixar Animation Studios
Mentor, Animation Mentor
Alumnus, Animation Mentor
We asked Animation Mentor Grad, to thoroughly understand shot briefing
Pixar Animator, and current mentor notes before beginning your shot. Instill
Jane Cassidy to share the common the habit early of following notes and
mistakes she sees time and time again understanding shot direction. As a
from beginning animators. Here’s your result, you will enjoy a long and healthy
comprehensive list of what NOT to do as career in animation.
a beginning animator.
2. Not using AMP
So you are thinking about entering
the field of animation — it can be a In a class of nine students, I find at
daunting task. If you’re already enrolled least half the students will not utilize
in Animation Mentor, you have taken AMP. It is crucial that you check in your
the first step. I took that same step work using AMP, as this allows your
seven years ago, and as a student, I mentor to pull up your work and “look
made plenty of mistakes. Now that under the hood” so to speak. Some
I am teaching at Animation Mentor, mentors like to pull up your work and
hopefully my perspective from both tweak your animation during class. The
sides allows me to guide you away from overwhelming feedback is that these
these common pitfalls. demonstrations are extremely helpful.
It allows you the students to see how a
1. Not Following the professional animator would solve the
Syllabus problem in a live step-by-step demo.
Assignments may seem straightforward, Make sure to set up AMP before the first
but I have had quite a few students week of class. Not only does it speed
turn in the wrong assignment, be it up your learning curve, but it benefits
the incorrect exercise or the incorrect everyone else as well. We are all in this
format. Typically reading the syllabus class to learn together!
can easily prevent this.
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 98
3. Underestimating how 4. Not giving or asking for
hard animation is, not feedback
putting in enough time
Too many beginning animators make
Too often I see beginning students this mistake. Too often we feel like we
underestimate how much effort each are not good enough or experienced
assignment requires. Even a bouncing enough to give other animators
ball can take a few days if you are just feedback. The truth is, you are good
starting. It may look easy, but once you enough. It is through looking at other
start to move keys around and start to people’s work that we develop our eye.
animate, panic and stress can set in. It is through viewing and discussing
other people’s work that we develop a
I went through a similar experience community, a sense of togetherness.
when I was a student. What helped It bolsters the idea that we all have
me the most was going in anticipating something to learn from each other.
how hard it was going to be, how much Plus, it’s a fantastic way to get inspired.
work I was going to have to put in. The
more space you create for yourself to Don’t be afraid to look up fellow
do great work, the more room you’ll students’ workspaces. Comment on their
have to make mistakes, make iterations, work or just say hello, even if they are
and break through natural plateaus that in a different class than you. This is how
come with mastering any craft. And we build our community and establish
especially as the assignments get more connections.
complicated toward the end of class, a
walk cycle for example will require even Specifically, challenge yourself to leave
more time. five people feedback each week. Add
them to your buddy list. As you get
So have a good idea of how many hours more comfortable, add more people to
each assignment will take and plan that list—the more the merrier. Also,
accordingly. The more effort you put in, don’t forget to put in a Peer Buddy
the more your mentors can help you get request during your first week. You
to wherever it is you want to go. will be paired with an upperclassman,
which will be another source of support
for you. Take advantage of all the
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 99
community Animation Mentor has to
offer. It will push you further than you
could ever imagine.
5. Taking feedback
personally, worrying too
much about grades
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 100
like directors have different ways of “sneaky” walk.
conducting. Some may not praise your
work as much as others, but this is My mentor told me this was way too
not because they don’t appreciate your complicated, so I kept the excited walk
work, or have something against you as and used all my time to perfect it. Here
a person. It comes down to giving you is the simplified version.
a fair and truthful critique directed at
the work, not you the animator. To be a My advice is to stick with the simplest
professional animator means you have option. Focus all your time and energy
to have thick skin, but it also means into making that simple animation
you’re lucky enough to be part of a team, spectacular. Don’t waste your time
a group of people focused on putting out putting in fancy lighting. It is always
the best work possible. better to have solid, simple animation
with extra time left at the end of the
6. Not keeping it simple week, as opposed to having an over-
complicated storyline and rushing to
I see a lot of students over-complicating finish your assignment at the end of the
their assignments. I should know, as I week. Just remember, “KISS”—Keep It
was one of them. Here is an example Simple Stupid! v
of over-complicating a walk cycle
assignment by yours truly. I started with
the “excited” walk. After that I decided
to add some bird droppings, and then a
Copyright 2018 © by Animation Mentor. All rights reserved. This ebook may not be reprinted or distributed in electronic, print, web, or
other format without express written permission. For education purposes only. 101
Our
Courses and
Workshops
Animation Mentor offers 12-week courses
and 6-week workshops on a wide variety
of animation disciplines. Whether you’re
looking to focus your skill set, build out your
generalist skills, or just try something new—
we’ve got you covered. If you’re a beginner,
our core Character Animation Courses will get
you started on your journey to becoming a
professional animator.
Character Animation Courses
12-Week Courses
Prerequisites: AN05
Creature Animation
Courses
12 Week Courses
WCL01
Creature Animation:
Locomotion
Learn the essence of animal and creature
locomotion—how a creature runs, walks, senses,
stops, and turns. Challenge yourself to animate
believable creatures with the help of top creature
animators who’ve worked on Guardians of the
Galaxy, Game of Thrones, Star Wars, and
more!
WCF01
Creature Animation:
Fight or Flight
Learn how to train your own dragon and
animate fight scenes like the pros! This
advanced workshop takes your skills to the
next level by teaching you how to integrate
believable creature animation with live-
action background plates. Learn what
makes a good action sequence, with tips
on planning and pacing physical animation
— and learn how to work effectively with
live-action footage.
Workshops
6 Week Courses WMAYA01
Maya Workshop:
Animation Basics
This is where it all starts! This workshop
is designed especially for beginners. Get
comfortable with the Autodesk® Maya® user
interface and the basic software tools for
animators and set yourself up for success in our
Character Animation Courses!
WTOON01
Cartoony Animation
for 3D Animators
Push your 3D skills by drawing simple 2D
animation sketches and learning to exaggerate
your animation! You’ll start with hand-drawn
master studies of great animation to start
learning effective cartoony techniques. You’ll end
up creating a simple cartoony animation following
the traditional workflow and then re-creating that
animation and workflow on a 3D character.
WSBOARD01
Storyboarding
Fundamentals
Round out your animation skills by learning the
foundation for staging, clarity, and emotion for
visual storytelling! Learn why “Story is King” in
Storyboarding Fundamentals with Mike Kunkel,
who has pitched stories for Walt Disney Studios
and Nickelodeon. Create your own simple short
story and board it to completion.
WGA01
Game Animation
Fundamentals
Want to know how to break into the game
industry? Now’s your chance to learn from
pro game animators who will help you learn
the essential techniques, workflow, and tools
necessary to get your animation skills ready for
the game industry. Learn the Maya to Unreal
Engine 4 workflow and use your game controller
or keyboard and watch your animation come to
life in real gameplay!
WGA02
Game Animation
Combat Attacks
Animate and watch your gameplay come to life!
Tailored for animators with an understanding
of body mechanics, Game Animation: Combat
Attacks gives you the opportunity to work with
pro game animators. You’ll learn the unique
techniques and processes required in the gaming
industry and use the Maya to Unreal Engine 4
workflow to animate two characters within a pre-
made game level. Get ready for battle!
WVISDEV01
Visual Development:
Principles of Design
Vis Dev Artists—also called Concept Artists—
determine the tone and mood for all the
characters and environments in a film, TV show,
or game. Visual Development Artists have a huge
impact across the entire entertainment industry,
from animation, to live-action films, to video
games, and beyond! In this workshop you’ll get
started with the basics.
WDPAINT01
Introduction to
Digital Painting
The character, creature, environment, and
background designs that determine the look
and feel of your favorite movies, TV shows,
and games all started with a painting! Learn the
basics of what makes a successful painting and
how to apply these skills to your own career path.
Storytelling is essential in any visual medium,
and you’ll learn to use your digital paint brush to
share your own characters and stories.
WPREVIS01
Previsualizaton Basics
for Animators
Previs Artist starts with rough building blocks—
just the storyboards or script—which they
interpret into a 3D space. In this workshop, you’ll
learn how animation and camera work are used
to help take a project all the way from script to
screen! You’ll also end up with 15–30 seconds of
animation for your demo reel.
Your Destiny.
Character Animation Workshops and
Courses Creatures
Start your epic animation journey Focus or round out your animation
with Character Animation Courses knowledge and learn new skills in less
and learn from the pros at Pixar, time with our 6-week workshops.
DreamWorks Animation, and Industrial
Light & Magic.