Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 s2.0 S2212827117305292 Main
1 s2.0 S2212827117305292 Main
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia CIRP 58 (2017) 175 – 180
Abstract
In several fields of mechanical engineering internal precision geometries are applied. For this, application requirements like high shape
accuracy, sufficient stability, high wear resistance or an increase of life time have to be fulfilled. However, there is also a demand on quick and
precise manufacturing processes that are flexible in machining various internal geometries. Electrochemical machining (ECM) is a process
which meets these requirements. This process allows surface structuring and shaping of metal components with high shape accuracy
independently of the materials strength and hardness [1].
This study presents investigations on a developed process design for manufacturing internal precision geometries by pulsed electrochemical
machining (PECM) with help of multiphysics simulations. The peculiarity of this process is the shaping of the workpiece by the lateral working
gap. Multiphysics simulations were carried out to understand the respective interactions between several physical phenomena. Especially, fluid
dynamical effects are described in detail within the developed model. Furthermore, Joule heating and cathodic hydrogen formation are
included. The fluid flow ensures the removal of heat and hydrogen and a continual supply with fresh electrolyte, respectively. The electrical
conductivity of the electrolyte is modeled as a function of hydrogen volume concentration and temperature. Hence, both effects, Joule heating
and hydrogen formation, influence the current density distribution which in turn determines the material removal.
©©2017
2017TheThe Authors.
Authors. Published
Published by Elsevier
by Elsevier B.V.
B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of The 16th CIRP Conference on Modelling of Machining Operations, in the
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
person of the
Peer-review Conference
under Chairs
responsibility Prof. J.C.
of the scientifi Outeiroofand
c committee TheProf. G. Poulachon.
16th CIRP Conference on Modelling of Machining Operations
Keywords: Electrochemical machining (ECM), Finite element method (FEM), Multiphysics Simulation
2212-8271 © 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of The 16th CIRP Conference on Modelling of Machining Operations
doi:10.1016/j.procir.2017.04.021
176 Matthias Hackert-Oschätzchen et al. / Procedia CIRP 58 (2017) 175 – 180
2. Model Description
Table 1. Definition of material parameters feed rate needs to be added here since the coordinate system is
Domain ߷ [kg/m³] ߪ [S/m] λ [W/(m·K)] cP [J/(kg·K)] fixed at the cathode and hence moved with its feed rate.
Boundary 6 is defined as a pressure outlet with ൌ ͷǡͷ.
I ߷ୣ (ϕEl,T) ߪୣ (ϕEl,T) 0.599 3877
The production of hydrogen occurs on the cathode surface
II, VI 7600 ͳǤͻ ή ͳͲ 21.5 410
(boundary 16) and is modeled by equation 4.
III 7900 [8] ͳǤ͵ ή ͳͲ [8] 15 [8] 500 [8] ܯୌ
Ȱୌమǡ ൌ െ మ ܬመ
IV, V 1410 [9] 10-10 0.31 [9] 1500 [9] ʹܨ
(4)
Domain I is defined as a fluid which is a dispersion with a Here, the normal hydrogen mass flow density Ȱୌమǡ
dynamic viscosity of 1.042 mPaήs. The continuous phase of depends on the normal electric current density ܬመ .
the dispersion is an aqueous sodium nitrate (NaNO3) Furthermore, ܯୌమ is the molar mass of hydrogen and F is the
electrolyte with a NaNO3 mass fraction of 8%. The dispersed Faraday constant.
phase is represented by small slip-free hydrogen bubbles. The Another significant phenomenon of the ECM process is
dispersion is regarded as a continuum. That means, the
heat transfer. Thus, the energy equation is solved for fluid and
detailed fluid structure with single bubbles is neglected.
solid domains. Joule heating is regarded in the fluid and solid
Instead, the hydrogen volume fraction ߶ୌమ and the electrolyte
domains as well as on the electrode-electrolyte interfaces. On
volume fraction ߶୪ ൌ ͳ െ ߶ୌమ are regarded. The effective the latter Joule heating occurs due to an electrochemical
density ߷ୣ of the dispersion is defined by equation 1. potential drop at the interface, the overpotential. The ambient
ܯୌమ temperature of 20 °C is defined on boundaries 4, 8 and 10.
߷ୣ ൌ ߶୪ ή ͳͲͷʹǤͷ ߶ ή Electrodynamics is modeled in a simplified way using a
ଷ ʹ ܴܶ
(1) pseudo-direct current approach. That means, the stationary
form of the equations of electrodynamics is used to determine
Here, is the fluid pressure, ܶ the temperature, ܯୌమ ൌ
the electric current density during the pulse-on time. During
ʹǤͲʹ g/mol the molar mass of hydrogen gas and ܴ the
pulse-off time the electric current density is defined to be zero.
universal gas constant. As it can be reasoned from equation 1
The ground potential is defined on boundary 4. The boundary
the Laplace pressure is neglected. The electrical conductivity
condition electric insulation is used on boundaries 5, 6, 7, 9
ߪ of the dispersion is defined by equation 2.
and 10. In this study the potential differences at the interfaces
ଷ
ܶ ଶ are considered in a simplified way by defining an effective
ߪୣ ൌ ൬ͳǤͶ ൬ െ ʹ͵Ǥͳͷ൰ ͵ͻǤͻ൰ ή ߶୪
ͳ
working potential ߮ො on boundary 8, which is the process
(2) voltage during pulse-on time reduced by the overpotentials of
For this, experimental studies were performed to determine cathode and anode according to Table 2.
the electrical conductivity of the pure electrolyte as a function ߮ො ൌ ܷ െ ܷ୭ୡ െ ܷ୭ୟ
of the temperature T. The influence of the dispersed gas (5)
bubbles on the electrical conductivity is taken into account by The values of the overpotentials Uoc = 1 V and Uoa = 5 V
multiplying the electrical conductivity of the pure electrolyte were defined according to experimental results. A summary of
ଷȀଶ
with the term ߶ ୪ [6, 7]. Domain II represents the solid the electrodynamic boundary conditions is given in table 2.
workpiece. The material properties defined in this domain are Table 3 summarizes the regarded machining parameters.
based on a powder-metallurgical material named SAM 10.
Domain III represents the cathode which is made from Table 2. Boundary conditions in the interface electric currents for the
stainless steel 1.4301. Domain IV represents the clamping boundaries numbered in figure 3
element of the replaceable disk and domain V the lateral Boundary Definition
insulator of the cathode. Both components are made from 1-3 Axis of symmetry
polyoxymethylene (POM).
5-7, 9, 10 ܬመ୬ ൌ ͲȀ
;
4 ߮ො ൌ Ͳܸ
2.2. Physics
8 ߮ො ൌ ܷ െ ܷ୭ Ǣܷ୭ ൌ ܷ୭ୡ ܷ୭ୟ
The fully coupled model developed in this study is built up
using the COMSOL Multiphysics Bubbly Flow Interface. Table 3. Machining parameters of the regarded PECM process
Turbulence is modeled with the k-ε turbulence model. The Boundary Definition
Reynolds number in the front working gap is ܴ݁ ൎ ͵ͶͲͲ vf Feed rate 1 mm/min
which is relatively low. Hence, in this study the results of the U Voltage 14 V
k-ε turbulence model are to be regarded as an approximation
cI Duty cycle 0,8
of a realistic flow field. On boundary 10 the flow inlet was
defined with a normal inflow velocity ݑ . ܸሶ୪ Electrolyte flow 8 l/min
ሶ
ܸ୪ pOut Outlet absolute 5,5 bar
ݑ ൌ ݒ pressure
୍ܣ୬
(3) TU Ambient Temperature 20 °C
The flow rate ሶ୪ is set to 8 l/min and AIn corresponds to
the cross-sectional area of the predrilled bore. The cathode
178 Matthias Hackert-Oschätzchen et al. / Procedia CIRP 58 (2017) 175 – 180
3. Results of the Simulation which reduces the effective flow cross-section. Near the
workpiece a wall jet is formed. This wall jet exceeds the
In figure 4 the result of the pseudo-stationary simulation of lateral working gap and sucks fluid from the upper side of the
the turbulent fluid flow is shown by means of a streamline cathode disk. Due to the presence of gas bubbles in the wall
false color rendering. The false color represents the flow jet the density of the mixture is reduced. In the experiment this
velocity. can lead to buoyancy force and support the formation of the
vortex which fills the area above the cathode disk.
When performing electrochemical machining Joule heating
occurs during the process. The released heat is removed from
the simulation domain by the fluid flow through boundary 6 as
well as by heat conduction through boundaries 4 and 8.
Figure 6 shows the temperature field in a detailed view of the
working gap.
Fig. 5. Streamline false color rendering in a detailed view of the velocity field
within the working gap Fig. 7. False color rendering in a detailed view of the electrolyte volume
concentration within the working gap
It can be seen that the flow velocity maximum is located in
the working gap entering area. Along the gap the flow velocity The fluid enters the working gap with a volume
decreases. At the transition from the front to the lateral concentration of ca. 100 % electrolyte. However, at the
working gap there is a curvature and a widening of the gap. cathode surface hydrogen is formed and partially displaces the
This leads to the detaching of the flow in the area of the lower electrolyte. This mixture flows further through the gap and an
cathode rounding. As a consequence of this a vortex is formed accumulation of hydrogen occurs. The minimum of the
Matthias Hackert-Oschätzchen et al. / Procedia CIRP 58 (2017) 175 – 180 179
electrolyte volume concentration is in the front working gap the current density decreases to a value of about 30 A/cm² as a
and has a value of 86 %. The minimum occurs in the area of a consequence of the increased working distance. In the area of
pressure minimum which causes a reduction of hydrogen the working gap exit above the cathode values of less than
density. In the lateral working gap a significant reduction of 10 A/cm² can be observed.
the electrolyte volume concentration can be observed. Here, In the pseudo-stationary model of this work material
the influence of the vortex is obvious. The vortex reduces the removal is not considered in detail. That means, the model
convective removal of hydrogen. After exiting the working geometry is not deformed depending on a material removal
gap the hydrogen is transported upwards by the wall jet. model. However, it is revealing to regard the normal current
According to equation 2 the electrical conductivity of the density on the anode surface, since in real ECM processes it
electrolyte is influenced by the temperature and the volume significantly influences material removal. Not at least the
concentrations of electrolyte and hydrogen, respectively. This material removal rate can be modeled as a function of the
can be seen when regarding the field of the effective electrical normal current density [5]. Figure 10 shows a scheme of the
conductivity shown in figure 8. geometry which divides the anode surface into 4 sections.
The effective electrical conductivity of fresh electrolyte Section A corresponds to the surface of the pre-drilled
that enters the front working gap with a temperature of 20 °C bore. Section B and Section C are the workpiece surface in the
is 7.27 S/m. The formation of hydrogen leads to a front working gap and lateral working gap, respectively.
progressively decreased effective electrical conductivity near Section D corresponds to the surface of the machined bore.
the cathode surface with a minimum value of 6.55 S/m. The arc length L is defined as a tangential boundary
Another local minimum is observed in the area of the vortex coordinate on the workpiece surface, starting inside the pre-
within the lateral working gap. This is caused by a decreased drilled bore and increasing upwards.
electrolyte volume concentration in the vortex. Near the anode In figure 11 the normal electric current density on the
surface there is an increase of the effective electrical workpiece surface is plotted against the arc length L. The
conductivity due to higher temperatures which are a result of sections defined in figure 10 are highlighted. Furthermore, in
Joule heating. A maximum of 8.62 S/m can be observed in the the figure the characteristic current density of 11 A/cm² is
curvature of the anode. marked. This value corresponds to the passivation limit of
Based on the field of the effective electrical conductivity SAM 10 with the regarded NaNO3 electrolyte. That means,
shown in figure 8 electrodynamics is calculated. Figure 9 below this normal current density value no material removal
shows the magnitude of the current density in a detailed view occurs.
of the working gap.
In the area of the pre-drilled bore the magnitude of the Fig. 11. Resulting normal current density along the workpiece surface as a
current density is lower than 10 A/cm². At the entrance of the function of the arc length L shown in figure 10
front working gap the magnitude of the current density rises
up to about 100 A/cm² and remains nearly constant within the It can be seen that inside the pre-drilled bore the normal
front working gap. In the lateral working gap the magnitude of current density is below 11 A/cm². Hence, no material
dissolution takes place. About 0.3 mm below the edge of the
180 Matthias Hackert-Oschätzchen et al. / Procedia CIRP 58 (2017) 175 – 180
bore the normal current density increases and exceeds the In continuative research work the developed model will be
passivation limit at L ൎ 14.7 mm. In the transition area to the validated experimentally regarding the total pressure drop and
front working gap the current density rises steeply. In section hydrogen mass flux. Therefore a commercial machine tool of
B the maximum value of the normal current density is type PEMCenter 8000 from PEMTec SNC (Forbach, France)
ca. 100 A/cm². In this section the bulk of the material will be applied. Furthermore, the model can be extended for
dissolution occurs. Inside the front working gap the normal predicting the surface conditions of the machined workpiece
current density slightly rises until ܮൎ ͳ. This variation based on the normal electric current distribution and the
is due to the fixed geometry in the pseudo-stationary model. In microstructure of the workpiece material.
a model incorporating geometry deformation a constant
normal current density would appear in the equilibrium status Acknowledgements
of the front working gap as a result of geometry deformation.
In the transition area to the lateral working gap, section C, a This project is funded by the Federal Ministry of
steep drop of the normal current density can be observed. The Economics and Technology, following a decision of the
low value leads to a slower material dissolution in the lateral German Bundestag.
working gap. At ܮൎ ͳͻǤʹ the normal current density falls
below the passivation limit. References