Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Water Chiller Vs Rooftop Air Conditinoner by TA
Water Chiller Vs Rooftop Air Conditinoner by TA
BOM DKE
No Doc.Name Doc.No Rev Type of Doc Date issued
Rev
1 A Main cable trench : Cable trench routing layout 790-12-MAX-700-E-600 D DWG 8-Jul-13
2 A 33/6kV Single line diagram 790-12-MAX-700-E-000 D DWG 5-Jul-13
QUANTITY
Item No. Description SPECIFICATION Unit Estimate REMARK
Actual
(Spare 10%)
B Cable Termination
1. CCB
(m2/person) (L/s.person)
Miscellaneous Spaces
Main entry lobbies 10.0 5.5 Ashare 62.1-2013
Office space 20.0 8.5 Ashare 62.1-2013
Conference/meeting 2.0 3.1 Ashare 62.1-2013
Miscellaneous Spaces
Computer (not printing) 25.0 10 Ashare 62.1-2013
Educational Facilities
Science laboratories 4.0 8.6 Ashare 62.1-2013
Computer lab 4.0 7.4 Ashare 62.1-2013
Free offce 5.0 8.6 In fact
Other 5.0 8.6 In fact
HVAC SOLUTION COMPARISION-WATER CHILLER VS ROOFTOP SYSTEM
1 FUNCTIONALITY
Water cooled chiller system is a comples system, include: water Rooftop system is simplier than chiller system, it include rooftop air conditioner
chiller, cooling tower, condenser pump, chilled water pump, Air located at the roof of building and the air duct from the unit to conditined area.
handling unit, duct and pipe system.
System use water cooled water chiller to cooled water from 12 oC to System use rooftop air conditioner with direct expansion coil to cooled the air and
7oC. The cooled water (7oC) will be pumped to AHU to cool the air distribute to conditioned area via air duct system.
in air conditioned area. There are two water loops in the system: the
chilled water loop from the chiller to AHU and the cooling water loop
from cooling tower to chiller. The cooled air will be moved from AHU
to air conditioned room by the fan in the AHU via air duct system.
2 INSTALLATION
Hight installation cost Lower installation cost than chiller system
Requires a professional contractor for installation because the Easy to installation
system is complex and included many equipment and materials.
Need technical area for chiller, pump, cooling tower and AHU. Saving more space than chiller system, just need space for roof top unit on
the roof of building.
4 CAPITAL COST
Higher capital cost than Rooftop system Lower capital cost
5 POWER COMSUMTION
Lower power consumption Higher power consumption than chiller system
(Estimate forsubstation with 1 x Water chiller: 1 x 65 kW Rooftop Air Conditioner: 2x 70 kW
300 kW cooling capacity) 1 x Cooling tower: 1 x 2 kW
1 x Chilled Pump: 1 x 6 kW
1 x Cooling Pump: 1 x 8 kW
2 x AHU: 2 x 10 kW
Total power consumption: 101 kW Total power consumption: 140 kW