Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

ACTA O P H T H A L M O L O G I C A 64 (1986)623-631

Characteristics of corneal endothelial cells


in Fu c hs’ heterochromic cycl itis

Hannu I. Alankol, llkka Vuorrel


and K. Matti Saari2

Department of Ophthalmology1 (Head: H. Forsius),


University of Oulu, Oulu
and Department of Ophthalmology2 (Head: K. M.Saari),
University of Tampere, Tampere, Finland

Abstract. We studied the corneal endothelial cells in With specular microscopy it is possible to investi-
14 patients (6 men and 8 women, ranging in age from gate non-invasively the cells of the corneal endo-
15 to 70 years) with unilateral Fuchs’ heterochromic thelium in vivo (Laing et al. 1975; Bourne &
cyclitis (FHC) by means of specular microscopy. The Kaufman 1976). Specular microscopy has been
healthy fellow eyes of the patients served as control
used to study the corneal endothelial cells in acute
material. Two affected eyes had undergone an intra-
and chronic iridocyclitis (Setala 1979a; Olsen
capsular cataract extraction before specular micro-
scopy. In one patient, the cyclitic eye also had glaucoma. 1980a, 1981). Olsen (1981) found typical changes
Changes of the endothelium characterized by intra- and in the specular appearance of the endothelium in
intercellular dark bodies, larger dark defects spanning anterior uveitis. These changes disappeared com-
several endothelial cells and bright irregular patchy pletely with other signs of inflammation. In spite
areas crossing cell borders on the specular reflex were of the qualitative changes seen, quantitative ana-
found in all eyes with FHC. lysis did not reveal any significant endothelial cell
Individual cell analysis did not reveal any significant loss in eyes with acute anterior uveitis (Setala
differences in the endothelial cell density, cell area, 1979a; Olsen 1980a, 1981). On the other hand,
coefficient of variation for cell area, cell perimeter, cell
chronic severe iridocyclitis with mutton-fat keratic
shape and in the number of endothelial cell apices
precipitates (Setala 1979a) or recurrent attacks of
between unoperated cyclitic and healthy fellow eyes.
T h e mean cell density was 4.9% lower in the unope- anterior uveitis with elevated intraocular pressure
rated eyes with FHC than in the control eyes. A signifi- (Olsen 1980a) lowered the corneal endothelial cell
cant negative correlation was observed between the density.
patients’ age and the cell density both in the healthy and Fuchs’ heterochromic cyclitis is a clinical entity
the cyclitic eyes. On the other hand, the correlation characterized by a chronic, quiet cyclitis with
between follow-up period and cell density was not minimal flare and cells in the anterior chamber,
statistically significant in the cyclitic eyes. Although small, white keratic precipitates and delicate inter-
FHC does not seem to accelerate significantly the age- posed feathery filaments, diffuse stromal atrophy
related cell density reduction, the magnitude of the cell
and patchy loss of the iris pigment layer, a change
loss found in the two operated eyes (45.5% and 49.8%)
of colour of the iris, absence of posterior syne-
and in the eye with glaucoma (45.2%) may indicate
altered tolerance against endothelial traumas in this chiae, vitreous opacities, development of compli-
disease. cated cataract and occasionally a secondary glau-
coma (Fuchs 1906; Kimura et al. 1955; Loewen-
Key words: corneal endothelium - Fuchs’ hetero- feld & Thompson 1973). Abnormal iris vessels
chromic cyclitis - morphometry - specular microscopy with a small filiform haemorrhage occurring after
- uveitis. paracentesis (Amsler & Verrey 1946) and ischae-

623
mia and leakage of the dye in iris fluorescein changes of the iris were confirmed by infra-red
angiograms (Saari et al. 1978a; Berger et al. 1980) transillumination stereophotography (Saari et al.
have also been observed. 197813) in all cases. Simultaneous bilateral fluores-
Since there are reports on endothelial cell cein angiography of the iris (Saari et al. 1978a)
changes in some forms of uveitis and occurrence showed fluorescein leakage of the iris vessels in all
of long-standing keratic precipitates and slow of the cyclitic eyes. Each patient had a complicated
tissue destruction but no detailed information of cataract, in one patient (Case 12) so dense that the
the corneal endothelium in FHC, we decided to ocular fundus could not be seen. One patient
study whether there are also changes in endothe- (Case 3 ) had had elevated intraocular pressure in
lial cell moiphology in this disease. the cyclitic eye treated by pilocarpine and epine-
phrine for 5 years before specular microscopic
examination. Two patients (Cases 13 and 14) had
Material and Methods undergone intracapsular cataract extraction of
the heterochromic eye 4 years (Case 13) and 5
Our study material consisted of 14 patients with years (Case 14) before specular microscopic exa-
Fuchs’ syndrome (Table 1). There were 6 males mination. In Case 13 the operation was compli-
and 8 females, ranging in age from 15 to 70 (mean cated with a small rupture of the lens capsule, and
36.5) years. The follow-up period after the first in Case 14 small filiform haemorrhage occurred
ocular examination varied between 2 and 14 when the anterior chamber was opened. Vitreous
(mean 6.7) years. Eleven patients had hetero- opacities were seen in eight patients (Table 1). All
chromia. The cyclitis was unilateral in all cases; eyes had clear corneas.
the right eye was affected in 7 cases. All affected We photographed the central corneal endothe-
eyes showed signs of a quiet, chronic anterior hum of both eyes in all patients using a modified
uveitis with small, grey-white keratic precipitates, Bio-Optics LSM-76-2A small-field contact specu-
and rarefaction of the iris stroma with changes in lar microscope and Kodak Tri-X film. To reduce
the relief of its anterior surface. The atrophic image blurring caused by rapid eye movements

Table I.
Summary of clinical data in 14 cases of Fuchs’ heterochromic cyclitis.

Follow-up Keratic Aqueous* Atrophy Com-


Case Cyclitic Hetero- Vitreous
Sex Age period preci- of plicated opacities*
No. years eye chromia*
years pitates* Flare Cells Iris* cataract”

1 M 45 2 L.E. + + - - + + +
2 M 15 4 L.E. + + + + + + +
3 F 48 10 L.E. + + + + + + -
4 F 38 14 L.E. + + f - + + +
5 F 32 6 R.E. + + + - + + +
6 F 17 2 R.E. + + + + + + +
7 F 23 5 RE. + + + + + f +
8 F 31 5 L.E. - + + - + + -
9 M 17 10 L.E. + + + + + + -
10 F 70 13 RE. + + + - + + +
11 F 39 6 R.E. - + + + + + +
12 M 45 4 RE. - + - - + + ..a
1 3b M 49 9 R.E. + + + + + + -
14b M 44 4 L.E. + + - + + + -

* +, Designated symptom was present; -, symptom was absent.


a T h e vitreous could not be seen due to dense cataract.
b I n Cases 13 and 14 the cyclitic eye had undergone intracapsular cataract extraction before specular microscopy.

624
the original flash unit of the microscope was parameter quantitizing the cell shape. This di-
replaced by one with shorter flash duration. From mensionless, size and orientation independent
3 to 22 (mean 10) photomicrographs were taken parameter, called ‘shape deviation’, indicates the
from the central corneal endothelial mosaic in deviation of cell shape from that of the equilateral
each eye. The photographic negatives were en- hexagon expressed in per cents. If the cell is an
larged to 8 x 24 cm paper prints. The magnifica- equilateral hexagon in shape the value of the
tion was controlled by copying a micrometer scale parameter is zero. If the cell is rounder or more
photographed with the specular microscope on elongated than the reference shape, this para-
the prints during the enlarging process. Average meter gets correspondingly higher positive or
cornea-to-print magnification used was 577 times. negative values (Alanko 1983). In normal eyes
We made the qualitative evaluation of the spe- most of the cells are slightly elongated and the
cular photomicrographs according to the guide- distribution of the cell shapes is skewed to the left
lines presented by Laing et al. (1979). The quanti- towards elongated cell shapes (Alanko et al., un-
tative cell features were determined in all cases published data). In all cases the contralateral
using a microcomputer-based individual endothe- healthy eye was used for control. The possible
lial cell analysis described earlier in detail by effect of FHC on the corneal endothelium was
Alanko (1983). For each eye 60- 100 (mean 94.3) evaluated only in those cases which had not
endothelial cells were analyzed combining data undergone any intraocular operation (Cases
from 2-7 (mean 4) specular photomicrographs. 1-12).
The following characteristics of the endothelial To test the differences between the means of
cells were determined: mean cell area, coefficient the analyzed parameters we used the paired t-test.
of variation for cell area, endothelial cell density For the linear correlations Pearsons’ correlation
calculated from mean cell area, mean cell peri- coefficients were calculated. We considered a
meter, mean number of apices per cell and a value of P < 0.05 to be statistically significant.

Fag. 1 .
Case 7 : Central corneal endothelium of the healthy left eye (top) and of the right eye with Fuchs’ syndrome
(bottom). Small, dark intracellular spots are more clearly visible in the healthy eye The cyclitic eye shows many
inter- and intracellular dark bodies, smaller than one cell diameter and probably presenting invading inflammatory
cells. I n some areas the cell images are blurred. Cell density: top, 2547 cells/mm2;bottom, 2540 cells/mm2.One scale
division = 10 pm.

40 Acta Ophthal. 64.6 625


Fig. 2.
Case 3: Central corneal endothelium of the healthy right eye (top) and of the left eye with Fuchs’ syndrome and
secondary glaucoma (bottom). The cyclitic eye shows a large dark defect over 100 pm in diameter and with brighter
central portion, presumably caused by keratic precipitate, and irregular bright patches (arrows). Note elongated cell
shapes in the cyclitic eye. Cell density: top, 2810 cells/mm*; bottom, 1541 cells/mm2. Shape divations: top, - 1.6%;
bottom, -4.7%. One scale division = 10 pm.

Results across the endothelium and often located at the


cell boundary intersections (Figs. 1 and 3). 2)
Qualitative evaluation of the corneal endothelial large, dark defects with ill-defined boundaries
photomicrographs of the unoperated eyes (Cases and occasional bright central reflex, and spanning
1 - 12) showed altered appearance of the endo- several endothelial cells were seen in some frames
thelium in all eyes with heterochromic cyclitis as (Fig. 2). 3 ) bright, irregular, randomly positioned
compared with the healthy fellow eyes. In cyclitic patchy structures acrossing the cell borders (Fig.
eyes areas were seen where the cell boundaries 2).
were not so well defined as in the healthy eyes Qualitative evaluation of the corneal endothel-
(Fig. 1). The endothelial cells in the healthy eyes ial photomicrographs of the two eyes which had
were approximately of the same size and shape. In undergone intracapsular cataract extraction (Ca-
the cyclitic eyes distinct pleomorphism was ob- ses 13 and 14) showed similar inter- and intra-
served only in Case 3 (Fig. 2) and in the operated cellular projected dark bodies and bright irregu-
eyes (Fig. 3). Occasionally, small, dark central lar patchy structures which were also seen in the
bodies were seen in eyes with FHC but not as unoperated eyes. However, the endothelium was
clearly as in the fellow eyes (Fig. 1). Laing et al. pleomorphic, and the cell size was markedly en-
(1979) proposed that these sharp, well-defined larged as compared with the contralateral healthy
dark bodies present the bases of the endothelial eye (Fig. 3).
cilias. Means of analyzed cell parameters of the un-
Typically, three groups of specular defects operated cases (Cases 1-12) are presented in
could be distinguished in cyclitic eyes: 1) dark Table 2. We found no statistically significant dif-
bodies, approximately 5 to 15 km in diameter and ferences in cell densities ( P = 0.332) and cell areas
round to oval in shape were randomly positioned ( P = 0.599) between the affected eyes and the

626
healthy fellow eyes. The frequency distributions Discussion
of cell areas in the cyclitic eyes and the normal
ones skewed similarly to the right (Fig. 4). Neither The results of this study showed that the typical
did we find any statistically significant difference specular microscopic findings in FHC include
when we compared the shape parameter, shape intra- and intercellularly located blackout areas,
deviation, in the cyclitic and healthy eyes ( P = larger dark defects spanning several endothelial
0.052). In both groups the distribution of cell cells and bright, irregular patchy areas super-
shapes skewed to the left towards elongated cell imposed on the cell images. However, these find-
shapes (Fig. 5). ings are not pathognomonic to FHC. Some of
Individual cell analysis showed 45.5% (Case 13) these specular microscopic changes have been
and 49.8% (Case 14) cell loss in the eyes which had observed earlier in anterior uveitis. The most
undergone intracapsular cataract extraction as frequent changes, intra- or intercellular dark
compared with the contralateral healthy eyes. In bodies, resemble those described by Olsen (1981)
the unoperated eyes (Cases 1-12) the mean cell in acute anterior uveitis. Also other authors have
density was 4.9% lower in the cyclitic eyes than in reported analogous specular defects in eyes with
the healthy ones. There was a negative correlation uveitis (Laing et al. 1979; Hartmann 1981; Bigar
between the patient’s age and the cell density both 1982; Hirst et al. 1982; Hirst & Stark 1983). Laing
in the healthy eyes (r = -0.58, P < 0.05) and in et al. (1979) presumed that they represent invad-
the cyclitic ones (r = -0.76, P < 0.01), whereas ing inflammatory cells. Hirst et al. (1982) stated
the difference between these correlation coeffi- that these blackout areas correspond most closely
cients was not statistically significant ( P > 0.4). to the scanning electron microscopic observation
The correlation between the follow-up period and of white blood cells on the endothelial surface.
the central corneal endothelial cell density in the The larger dark defects seen in this study, cover-
cyclitic eyes was not statistically significant (r = ing several endothelial cells and occasionally
-0.29, P > 0.1). showing brighter central portion were similar in

Fig. 3 .
Case 14: Central corneal endothelium of the healthy right eye (top) and of the cyclitic left eye after intracapsular
cataract extraction (bottom). The operated cyclitic eye shows inter- and intracellular dark bodies. The cell size is
markedly enlarged. Cell density: top, 2823 cells/mm2;bottom, 14 17 cells/mm*. One scale division = 10 pm.

40* 627
Cell features Affected eyes Fellow eyes

There was no statistically significant (P > 0.05) difference in cell features


between the affected eyes and the fellow eyes.

appearance to those identified as precipitates by (1978) cites a study by Hirabayashi in which no


Olsen (1981) and Hartmann (1981). The cause of endothelial cell density changes were found in
the third type of the endothelial changes, the eyes with Fuchs’ syndrome. In our study the
bright patches, is not quite clear. Those bright, degrease of the mean cell density in the cyclitic
irregular areas crossing cell borders may present eyes was 4.9%,a value similar in magnitude to
leucocytes attached loosely on endothelium (Bigar that of 0.7% found by Setala (1979) in 35 patients
1982), endothelial pigment deposits (Laing et al. with unilateral uveitis.
1979; Bigar 1982), or they may be reflexes from Matsuda et al. (1985) observed elongation of
the fine cotton-wisp filaments crossing between endothelial cells surrounding fresh endothelial
the keratic precipitates. defects. In this study evaluation of the cell shapes
Although the observations in qualitative ana- did not reveal any significantly elongated cells in
lysis were typical and altered specular appearance cyclitic eyes, which would indicate reparation of
was seen in all cases, the individual cell analysis endothelial defect in process.
did not reveal any significant differences in the Complicated cataract is frequently found in
analyzed endothelial cell parameters between the eyes with FHC (Kimura et al. 1955; Kimura 1978;
cyclitic and healthy eyes. Our results are in good Liesegang 1982). Kimura (1978) suggested that
agreement with the earlier brief notes on an after cataract surgery corneal oedema occurs
unaltered endothelial cell density in eyes with more easily in patients with FHC than in normal
FHC. Neubauer (1980) reported a cell density of subjects. In another study 29.4% of patients who
2800 cells/mm2 in one case with FHC. Kimura had underwent a cataract operation developed

628
501
40

<=100150 250 350 450 550 650 750 850 =>950


Cell area, square micrometers
Fig. 4 .
Frequency distribution of cell areas in healthy eyes (solid line) and in unoperated eyes with Fuchs’ syndrome (dotted
line). I n both groups the cell area distributions are skewed similarly to the right toward large cell areas.

c o r n e a l o e d e m a (Liesegang 1982). In this study opacities in t h e posterior cortex or subcapsular


two patients had u n d e r g o n e intracapsular cataract r e g i o n of t h e lens i n t h e cyclitic eye. In t h e
extraction 4 and 5 years before specular micro- o p e r a t e d eyes t h e cell loss was 45.5 and 49.8%
scopic examination, and all o t h e r patients h a d with an endothelial cell density o f 1417 and 1718

VI
-aJ
c

U
4-
0
aJ
0
0
-I-
C
W
U
L
aJ
(L

r - ~1 ~ - I 1 I I
< =-20 -15 -10 -5 0 =>+5
Shape deviation, percents
Fig. 5 .
Frequency distribution of cell shapes in healthy eyes (solid line) and in unoperated eyes with Fuchs’ syndrome
(dotted line). I n both groups the distributions are negatively skewed toward enlongated cells shapes.

629
cells/mm2, respectively. The endothelial cell loss Acknowledgments
found in our two cases is higher than the cell loss
This study was supported in part by grants from the
of 4-25 % reported after intracapsular cataract
Silvia - ja kudospankkisaatio Foundation, the Medical
extraction (Drews & Waltman 1978; Olsen 1980b) Research Foundation of Oulu and the Finnish Eye
and is closer to the values seen after intraocular Foundation (Dr Alanko); and the Medical Research
lens implantation (Bourne et al. 1981),but still far Council of the Academy of Finland (Dr Saari).
from the decompensation limit which may lie
somewhere around 300 cells/mm2 (Waring et al.
1982).
In the present study the greatest endothelial
cell loss in the unoperated cyclitic eye, 45.2%, was
seen in a patient with elevated intraocular press- References
ure treated with pilocarpine and epinephrine for
five years before specular microscopy. Also the Alanko H (1983): Microcomputer analysis for corneal
cell shapes were elongated in the cyclitic eye, endothelial cell morphology. Acta Ophthalmol
(Copenh) 61 : 229-239.
which may indicate recent endothelial damage. In
Amsler M & Verrey F (1946): Heterochromie de Fuchs
this case the endothelial cell density may have et fragilite vasculaire. Ophthalmologica 111: 178-
been reduced by elevated intraocular pressure, as 181.
earlier observed in acute glaucoma (Setala 1979b; Berger B B, Tessler H H & Kottow M H (1980):
Bigar & Witmer 1982) and/or by the long-term Anterior segment ischemia in Fuchs’ heterochromic
topical epinephrine therapy (Waltman et al. cyclitis. Arch Ophthalmol98: 499-501.
1977). However, the highest intraocular pressure Bigar F (1982): Specular microscopy of the corneal
of 36 mmHg measured in this case was lower than endothelium. Dev Ophthalmol 6 : 1-94.
the mean intraocular pressure at admission in the Bourne W M & Kaufman H E (1976): Specular micro-
above mentioned studies. Although few, the pres- scopy of human corneal endothelium in vivo. Am J
Ophthalmol81: 319-323.
ent cases with marked cell loss may indicate that
Bourne W M, Waller R R, Liesegang T J & Brubaker R
the endothelium is more vulnerable to equivalent F (1981): Corneal trauma in intracapsular and extra-
corneal damages in eyes with FHC than in normal capsular cataract extraction with lens implantation.
ones. Arch Ophthalmol99: 1375-1376.
I n spite of the altered specular appearance Drews R C & Waltman S R (1978): Endothelial cell loss
of the endothelium, Fuchs’ syndrome seems not in intraocular lens placement. J Am Intraocul Im-
significantly accelerate the endothelial cell loss plantSoc4: 14-16.
caused by normal aging. However, our results Fuchs E (1906): Uber Komplikationen der Hetero-
may suggest decreased resistance to endothelial chromie. Z Augenheilkd 15: 191-212.
traumas, a finding that prompts carefulness when Hartmann C (1981): Die indirekte Spiegelmikroskopie.
Eine neue Technik zur in vivo Untersuchung der
intraocular is done in this disease.
Hornhautruckflache. Ophthalmologica 183: 177-
Keratic precipitates may disappear after catar- 186.
act extraction or may persist even 35 years post- Hirst L W, Robin A L, Sherman S, Green W R, D’Anna
operatively (Norn 1968; Loewenfeld & Thomp- S & Dunkelberger G (1982): Corneal endothelial
son 1973). In this study the two aphakic patients changes after argon-laser iridotomy and panretinal
still showed specular microscopic changes similar photocoagulation. Am J Ophthalmol93: 473-481.
to those seen in other cyclitic eyes. Hirst L W & Stark W J (1983): Clinical specular micro-
Our study indicates that FHC causes corneal scopy of corneal endothelial rejection. Arch Ophthal-
endothelial changes similar to those seen in some mol 101: 1387-1391.
other forms of anterior uveitis. In this study Kimura S J (1978): Fuchs’ syndrome of heterochromic
cyclitis in brown-eyed patients. Trans Am Ophthal-
ocasional inflammatory cells were seen to infil-
mol Soc 76: 76-89.
trate the corneal endothelium. Our findings sup-
Kimura S J, Hogan M J & Thygeson P (1955): Fuchs’
port the recent hypothesis that in FHC there is a syndrome of heterochromic cyclitis. Arch Ophthal-
true inflammatory component of immunologic mol54: 179- 186.
origin, although a degeneration or an abiotrophy Laing R A, Sandstrom M M &. Leibowitz H M (1975): In
might be the initial triggering event (O’Connor vivo photomicrography of the corneal endothelium.
1985). Arch Ophthalmol93: 143-145.

630
Laing R A, Sandstrom M M & Leibowitz H M (1979): Saari M, Vuorre I & Nieminen H (1978a): Fuchs’
Clinical specular microscopy. 11. Qualitative evalua- heterochromic cyclitis: a simultaneous bilateral fluo-
tion of corneal endothelial photomicrographs. Arch rescein angiographic study of the iris. Br J Ophthal-
Ophthalmol97: 1720-1725. mol62: 715-721.
Liesegang T J (1982): Clinical features and prognosis in Saari M, Vuorre I & Nieminen H (1978b): Infra-red
Fuchs’ uveitis syndrome. Arch Ophthalmol 100: transillumination stereophotography of the iris in
1622-1626. Fuchs’ heterochromic cyclitis. Br J Ophthalmol 62:
Loewenfeld I E & Thompson H S (1973): Fuchs’ 110- 115.
heterochromic cyclitis: A critical review of the litera- Setala K (1979a): Corneal endothelial cell density in
ture. I. Clinical characteristics of the syndrome. Surv iridocyclitis. Acta Ophthalmol (Copenh) 57: 277-
Ophthalmol 17: 394-457. 286.
Matsuda M, Sawa M, Edelhauser H F, Bartels S P, Setala K (1979b): Corneal endothelial cell density after
Neufeld A H & Kenyon K R (1985): Cellular migra- a n attack of acute glaucoma. Acta Ophthalmol
tion and morphology in corneal endothelial wound (Copenh)57: 1004-1013.
repair. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 26: 443 -449. Waltman S R, Yarian D, Hart W J r & Becker B (1977):
Neubauer L (1980): Endothelbefunde bei Erkran- Corneal endothelial changes with long-term topical
kungen des vorderen Augenabschnittes. Ber Dtsch epinephrine therapy. Arch Ophthalmol 95: 1357-
Ophthalmol Ges 77: 497-501. 1358.
Norn M S (1968): Cataract extraction in Fuchs’ hetero- Waring G 0 111, Bourne W M, Edelhauser H F &
chromia. Acta Ophthalmol (Copenh) 46: 685-699. Kenyon K R (1982): T h e corneal endothelium. Nor-
O’Connor G R (1985): Doyne Lecture. Heterochromic mal and pathologic structure and function. Ophthal-
iridocyclitis. Trans Ophthalmol SOCUK 104: 219- mology 89: 531-590.
231.
Olsen T (1980a): Changes in the corneal endothelium
after acute anterior uveitis as seen with the specular
microscope. Acta Ophthalmol (Copenh) 58: 250-
256.
Olsen T (1980b): Corneal thickness and endothelial Received on June 16th, 1986.
damage after intracapsular cataract extraction. Acta
Ophthalmol (Copenh) 58: 424-433. Author’s address:
Olsen T (1981): Transient changes in specular appear- Hannu I. Alanko, M.D.,
ance of the corneal endothelium and in corneal Department of Ophthalmology,
thickness during anterior uveitis. Acta O p h t h a h o l University of Oulu,
(Copenh) 59: 100-109. SF-90220 Oulu 22, Finland.

63 1

You might also like