Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Post Construction Repair Guidelines - Welded Enclosure Guideline
Post Construction Repair Guidelines - Welded Enclosure Guideline
Post Construction Repair Guidelines - Welded Enclosure Guideline
Intended for internal Chevron use only; not for distribution to non-Chevron personnel or organizations.
This document is the confidential property of Chevron U.S.A. Inc. Neither the whole nor any part of this document may be disclosed
to any third party without the prior written consent of Chevron U.S.A. Inc. Neither the whole nor any part of this document may be
reproduced, stored in any retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means (electronic, mechanical, reprographic,
recording, or otherwise) without the prior written consent of Chevron U.S.A. Inc.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 1 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
Guideline Contents
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 2 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 3 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
1.0 SCOPE
This guideline provides recommendations for the design, construction, and installation of Carbon and
Low Alloy Steel welded enclosures for piping, pipeline, and ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code,
Section VIII (ASME BPVC VIII) Division 1 and 2 pressure vessels. Acceptable repair types for tanks
are comprehensively covered by API 653.
This guideline compiles industry best practices from construction codes, post-construction standards,
and industry knowledge to ensure that the design and installation of welded enclosures meets industry
best practices across Chevron facilities. In conjunction with this guideline, it is important for the
particular facility to review the applicable code of construction, local jurisdictional requirements, and
perform a risk assessment before undertaking this post construction repair. If the applicable code of
construction or jurisdiction provides guidance or restrictions regarding use of welded enclosures, it must
be used and the guideline can be consulted for items not explicitly addressed. This guideline is not
intended for contractor use.
3.0 APPLICABILITY
This section reviews applicability of welded enclosure repairs to specific fixed equipment, related
industry construction codes, and generally acceptable defect types to be repaired.
3.1 Applications
Welded enclosures are mainly employed on facility piping, and less commonly on pressure vessels or
other large diameter fixed equipment. They are rarely employed on tanks or pipelines. Welded
enclosures are not used on tanks mainly due to impracticality – if welding is allowed, other
well-established methods, such as lap patch repair, are employed. Use of welded enclosures on pipelines
is similarly not common because of availability of other well-established welded and non-welded
permanent repair methods (e.g. encirclement sleeves and composite wraps). It should be noted that
B31.4 and B31.8 pipeline codes condone the use of small welded fittings to encase local degradation as
a permanent repair, a special case that can be employed if necessary.
Welded enclosures are most applicable in locations where a tightly fitting repair such as an encirclement
sleeve or lap patch would interfere with the presence of non-cylindrical geometry. Such configurations
are commonly found on process piping fitted with branches, tees, repads, bleeders, vents, etc. Enclosures
may be desired on pressure vessels at nozzles, and over other local geometries that are difficult to encase
by other means.
Welded enclosures are meant to contain a local leak or a projected future leaking area, by encompassing
the area with a new pressure boundary. They are also commonly designed to structurally reinforce the
equipment being repaired. Unless explicitly stated in the design, welded enclosures should be expected
to carry piping bending loads and axial thrust if the underlying equipment wastes away.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 4 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
In general, welded enclosures are considered temporary repairs. The temporary repair designation is
driven by code and jurisdictional requirements. Although welded enclosures can serve as robust long
term repairs, Chevron ETC aligns with industry best practices and does not recommend using welded
enclosures as permanent repairs. Chevron ETC advises that installed welded enclosures should be
replaced with components compliant with the original code of construction at the next available
opportunity.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 5 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
Notes:
1
B31.4 allows permanent welded enclosures addressing local defects, made from fittings NPS 3 and
smaller.
2
B31.8 allows permanent welded enclosures made from fittings addressing a local defect, without a
stated size restriction.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 6 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
process piping and pressure vessels, as mandated by API 570 and 510. The definition of “next available
maintenance opportunity” does not necessarily imply the earliest possible shutdown window, as many
factors can affect whether the plant can be shut down and the equipment accessed for maintenance. As
such, a reasonable service lifetime should be chosen to last until the selected maintenance opportunity
for the repair, with some contingency for changes in the proposed shutdown schedule.
Is an enclosure an appropriate repair for the identified defect or are there other alternatives?
Is there a risk of burn-through based on the location where the enclosure will land?
Will stagnant fluid be acceptable between the enclosure and repaired equipment? Is accelerated
degradation (deadleng corrosion) expected?
Stagnant process may cool to ambient temperature within the enclosure boundary and pool at low
points. Can this be detrimental to the enclosure or the equipment being repaired? Will gaseous
process condensation be harmful if it occurs? Condensation or accumulation of process water in an
enclosure is commonly the most corrosive and damaging condition that needs to be assessed.
Will the location of the enclosure result in added risks during installation? Is installation of an
enclosure feasible in the desired location?
Will the condition of the equipment being repaired (active leak) require special precatutions for
access and installaiton of the enclosure?
If the welded enclosure encases a flange pair, are the bolts at risk of rapid degradation and failure
due to prolonged exposure to the process?
Are there any additional failure mechanisms introduced with the installation of a welded enclosure?
Is fatigue failure due to cyclic loading a concern? Enclosures introduce corner geometries that can be
more susceptible to fatigue degradation than butt-welded connections.
Will PWHT be required for the installation of the enclosure, and can it be completed safely and
effectively without imposing additional yield level stress onto the equipment? See Section 6.5 for
further discussion.
Will sealant be beneficial in the enclosure design?
— If sealant migrates through the defect and into the process stream, can it damage downstream
equipment (pumps, filters, etc.) or affect the process stream?
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 7 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
— Will the equipment being repaired be detrimentally affected if wall temperature increases to that
of process temperature? An enclosure with sealant may insulate the line, possibly causing
increased corrosion in that location.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 8 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 9 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
Increased complexity of the equipment being repaired will require additional enclosure features and
parts. For example, if the enclosure must encompass an adjoining geometry on the straight pipe (e.g.
high point bleeder vent), the main cylinder may include an branch with a small nozzle and cap. Tees and
elbows would required unique configurations to accommodate the geometry. Although the enclosure
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 10 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
design is limited only by the imagination (and good engineering pracitces), keeping the weight down is
critical in choosing the components to use.
It may be necessary for an enclosure to be injected with sealant to prevent migration of the process into
the annulus. This approach can provide added protection from aggressive process if the material of the
enclosure will be susceptible to rapid degradation. Sealant injection will not provide absolute protection
to the enclosure, so designing for eventual process contact will still be required.
can be taken conservatively as the length of the enclosure, as the connecting edges of the enclosure
provide stiffening for the underlying component. If a more complex shape requires evaluation, FEA may
be employed to solve for the buckling pressure. A conservative margin of 10x against the buckling
pressure should be maintained to arrive at the allowable external pressure. It should be noted that the
injection pressure for the sealant does not necessarily equate to the applied external pressure on the
equipment being repaired due to variable characteristics of sealant products. Accurately measuring the
applied pressure within the enclosure via some secondary means will help with decision making around
exceeding collapse pressure.
5.3.4 Enclosure Weight Impact on the Equipment Being Repaired
The unique geometry of a welded enclosure can add significant weight to the equipment being repaired.
Specifically on a piping system, the loads can be considerable and additional supports may be required.
It is critical to check the impact of this added loading on the piping system and supporting structural
components. Enclosure weight including a process/ sealant-filled annulus should be considered. The
following list provides some guidance on which aspects of the system should be checked, but is not
meant to be exhaustive:
Check the bending stress on pipe due to enclosure weight, piping contents, and pipe weight itself.*
Check shear on pipe due to enclosure weight.*
Check impact of torsion on piping system, if applicable (e.g. enclosure is placed on a branch
deadleg, which imparts torsion on the main pipe run).*
Check loading on adjacent supports to ensure capacity is not exceeded (pipe shoes, spring hangars,
etc.).*
Work with Civil Engineering to check the support structure for overstress (use engineering judgment
for this item. Not necessary for relatively small enclosures).
If the enclosure is located such that it may impact a vessel nozzle, check to ensure the additional
weight is acceptable and does not impart excessive bending stress on the vessel shell. WRC297 or
WRC537 approaches should be used for such a check, and can be executed efficiently using a
software package such as Compress or PV Elite.
*A Caesar II piping stress model can be used to check the imact of enclosure weight on the piping
system.
Maximum enclosure dimensions are not limited by industry codes or standards, and are instead limited
by the manipulation capabilities of the maintenance crew performing the installation and the deadweight
carrying capacity of the equipment being repaired.
The enclosure should be laid out such that interference with surrounding equipment is avoided and the
enclosure can be successfully installed.
If nearby enclosures or patches exist, some separation should be maintained to avoid interaction of the
two geometries and their weld heat affected zones. A new enclosure should be installed such that the toe
of the attachment weld is at least 2*(Inside Diameter*TMIN)0.5 away from adjacent enclosures on piping
and pipelines, and 4*(Inside Radius*TMIN)0.5 on vessels. This set-back distance also applies if an
enclosure is placed in the proximity of a nozzle or other structural discontinuity. If the enclosure must be
placed closer to a structural discontinuity than this limit, advanced analysis techniques (such as FEA)
can be utilized to assess local stress interactions.
If placing the enclosure near a circumferential or longitudinal seam, the welded edge of the enclosure
must be least 6” (150mm) away from the seam. A seam may be covered by the enclosure, but placement
of the edge of the enclosure per the above guidance ensures that interaction with the HAZ will be
minimal.
An enclosure must not be installed on top of an existing patch or enclosure unless thorough analysis is
completed.
Use of 3D modeling software is a very powerful tool for laying out enclosure components on existing
equipment. 3D modeling can help anticipate clearance issues, simulate installation sequences, and
evaluate alternatives before any material is cut or fabricated. Coupled with 3D laser scanning, un-even
surfaces and deviations from construction drawings can be identified early, and plans can be developed
to address them. For complex enclosures, using 3D modeling software is highly recommended.
5.4.2 Cylindrical Components
The minimum thickness of the cylinder shell components should be determined by the standard
cylindrical component design approach (most commonly ASME BPVC VIII Division 1 - UG-27). As
with standard pressure vessel design, the hoop stress in a cylindrical component governs the required
thickness unless the welded enclosure is intended to carry axial loads and bending moments and the
magnitudes are significant enough to govern design. If two cylindrical sections are joined by a full
penetration weld seam, the joint efficiency of the weld seam based on completed NDE should be taken
into account. The cylindrical component calculations provide the thickness in the corroded condition,
and an adequate corrosion allowance must subsequently be added.
5.4.3 Flat Plates/End Plates
A welded enclosure almost certainly will include flat end plates or end caps due to its larger diameter
than the equipment being repaired. Reducer sections may alternatively be employed to make the
transition from the enclosure diameter to the pipe diameter. Large flat end plates are also useful as a
surface for the cylindrical portion to land on, and can allow for onsite adjustments if necessary.
Flat end plates should be designed to ASME BPVC VIII Division 1 UG-34 or other code equivalent.
ASME BPVC VIII Division 1, Figure UG-34 attachment details in sketch e, h, or i are most commonly
used. Sketches “h” and “i” are recommended as they detail full penetration corner joints.
For high pressure applications, a flat plate may not be practical and split end caps or specially fabricated
head components may be used. Conformance to B16.5 or ASME BPVC VIII Division 1 UG-32 for
formed head minimum thickness is an appropriate design approach.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 14 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
5.4.4 Flanges
It is rare for a welded enclosure to include flange components but in some cases it may be necessary.
B16.5 flanges, or custom flanges using the ASME BPVC VIII Division 1 Appendix 2 design approach,
are acceptable, similar to flange components found in pressure vessel design.
5.4.5 Welds
Full penetration welds must be employed at all joints, unless their implementation is impractical or
impossible. If partial penetration welds are used, the combined loading across the weld throat should be
evaluated. Fillet welded connections without partial penetration must not be employed as they are
considered inferior to partial/full penetration welds and can be avoided in most cases.
5.4.6 Opening Reinforcement
Opening reinforcement is another common consideration in a welded enclosure. A common opening is
found in the end plates for piping protrusion. Where an opening exists, opening reinforcement adequacy
must be checked as it would be with a pressure vessel. ASME BPVC VIII Division 1, UG-36 through
UG-42, provides the rules for opening reinforcement to be used for enclosures. Large openings (greater
than 50% of diameter) can be evaluated using Appendix 14. Inadequate opening reinforcement must be
remedied by additional reinforcement, via thickened sections or other means.
5.4.7 Lifting Lugs
Lifting Lugs should be designed to handle the dynamic load of the enclosure weight. Adequate load
carrying capacity must be available in both orientations (weak direction and strong direction) of the lug
and the weldment. This is generally a minor consideration for enclosures as lugs are usually sufficiently
stout for the relatively low component weight.
5.4.8 Vents and Drains
Vents and drains are necessary in most welded enclosure designs to serve multiple functions. Vents and
drains can direct an active leak away from installation personnel during assembly, allow for venting of
gases generated by welding, provide a port for sealant injection, and grant access for leak testing.
5.4.9 Miscellaneous Components
Guidance cannot be provided for all possible unique components of welded enclosures. Most
components resemble or borrow from common piping or pressure vessel design, and can be evaluated
using approaches found in B31.3 or ASME BPVC VIII Division 1. Those that cannot be evaluated with
common approaches should be evaluated by sound engineering design principles (Roark’s formulas for
example) or advanced approaches (FEA).
5.4.10 Design by Analysis
FEA is a very powerful tool for designing an enclosure. Some welded enclosure configurations can only
be successful with unique or unusual combinations of shapes, fittings, and weldments. FEA allows for
the accommodation and evaluation of those unique shapes that would otherwise not fit the formulas
provided in conventional equipment design codes. FEA blends well with the initial layout efforts using
3D modeling, as the laid out 3D model can be rapidly ported into an FEA processor and analyzed.
Using industry-accepted design by analysis approaches is a requirement of employing FEA. See
PVM-DC-6158. Although PVM-DC-6158 focuses on design of new equipment by analysis, most of the
same concepts apply to post-construction design of enclosures. Contact an ETC SME for support if FEA
is required.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 15 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
strength, all of which can lead to premature failure of the bolted connection. The enclosure must be
designed to handle axial load and not rely on the bolts for load carrying capacity, or the bolt material
must be reviewed and approved for prolonged use with exposure to the process. B7 bolts are inferior for
resistance against in-service embrittlement. B7M or alloy bolts should be considered if service is
particularly aggressive relative to corrosion or stress corrosion cracking.
As well, partially enclosed bolts provide leak paths for the process to migrate out of the enclosure. A
common example is encasing a flange leak by landing an enclosure on the outside diameter wall of the
flange pair. Seal welding is commonly employed on the stud-to-nut and stud-to-flange intersection to
prevent process migration, and should be employed if such a leak path exists after partially encasing
bolts.
6.0 MATERIAL
6.1 Enclosure Body Material
The enclosure body material should generally match the material of the equipment being repaired. A
situation may arise where a different metallurgy may be better suited to resist the degradation
mechanism affecting the local area. A material differing from the equipment being repaired must be
evaluated for acceptable strength, ductility, cathodic interaction, thermal expansion, notch toughness,
weldability (including post weld heat treatment) and chemistry. Most importantly, the material chosen
must be compatible with the service. If used, sealant does not provide a guaranteed barrier for process
migration and some interaction with the process may occur. Consult with a Materials Engineer for
unique material selection considerations.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 17 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
External and internal heating elements are required for PWHT to minimize thermal mismatch between
the enclosure and equipment being repaired. Minimizing thermal mismatch ensures complete
penetration of soak temperature at the attachment weld and maximizes residual stress reduction. In most
cases, internal heating supplementing external heating using electric resistance heaters is not possible on
piping or pipelines due to lack of clearance or access. Fired heating of the enclosure annulus may be an
acceptable approach.
It should be noted that in-service equipment cannot be safely heat treated at the required temperatures. If
PWHT cannot be achieved but is required, it is recommended to explore alternatives to welded repair.
6.5 Sealant
If sealant is recommended for use in the enclosure, sealant compatibility with the process for all
expected operating conditions should be reviewed. Maximum and minimum temperatures, process
composition (H2S, amines, chlorides, acid, etc), time dependent issues (exposure over an extended
period), and thermal cycling are some of the considerations that should be discussed with the sealant
company engineer.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 18 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
8.0 WELDING
8.1 Welding While Line is in Service (Avoiding Risk of Burn-Through)
When installation on in-service equipment is necessary, company and industry best practices for hot
work on live equipment must be followed. See PIM600 (Section 670) and PPL800 (Section 5.2.2) for
considerations. Burn-through modeling is recommended where applicable based on best practice
guidelines.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 19 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
10.0 INSTALLATION
10.1 Pre-Installation Activities
When preparing for enclosure installation on in-service equipment, reducing the pressure in the live
equipment is an effective way of lowering the risk of the activity. Performing surface preparation,
excavating defects, and fitting up sections is safer with reduced operating pressure because it results in
higher instantaneous safety margin for the remaining wall of the equipment. Ideally, the equipment
would be out of service and cleaned or inerted before work commences.
If a reduction in bending moment due to dead weight is necessary to meet the allowable stress of the
enclosure design or the piping system adjacent to the enclosure, additional supports should be installed
where required prior to installation.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 20 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
Before fit-up, the defect area should be marked, and re-identified if surface preparation removes the
markings. Especially if the defect is present on the inside surface, accurate location of the defect and the
desired boundary of the enclosure is critical. Given the limited dimensions of the enclosure, small errors
in location can result in insufficient coverage of the defect and negate the benefit of the enclosure.
Mock-up activities can help ensure the field fit-up will go smoothly. Performing practice fit-up steps in
the shop will help identify interferences, surface potential issues, allow for modification of the weld
joints (via buttering or grinding), etc., for efficient installation on the actual equipment. Mock-up
activities are especially critical if installing the enclosure on live equipment when time is of the essence.
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 21 of 22
Guideline – Welded Enclosure Guideline POST CONSTRUCTION REPAIR GUIDELINES
the enclosure itself can be periodically inspected for thinning/degradation and fatigue cracking at the
attachment welds. Monitoring for breach of the underlying pressure boundary can be completed using a
local pressure gauge, instrumentation running to the control house, or via a weep hole (where safe to do
so).
11.0 REFERENCES
April 2014 © 2014 Chevron U.S.A. Inc. All rights reserved. Confidential – Restricted Access 22 of 22