Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Collated - AIIGM ASGT - Riunione 29.09.2015
Collated - AIIGM ASGT - Riunione 29.09.2015
Collated - AIIGM ASGT - Riunione 29.09.2015
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM Introduction
ed k) safety features of the sources to ensure quality k) …to ensure the quality of gases…
158 of the gases according to specification.
(see resolutions of comments Prague meeting,
October 2014, comment n. US 016)
AIIGM 1 ed This part of ISO 7396 does not apply to filling cylinder bundle systems.
001 systems for transportable cylinders and
transportable cylinder bundle systems
ASG Contents, Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
150 3.3
AIIGM 3.4 ed …used to fill high pressure storage vessels. ...high-pressure reservoir(s).
031
ASG 3.4 Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
032
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 1 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 3.9 Ed Use better wording Replace “liquid state” with “liquid phase”
039
Note to Entry: Examples of gas-specific connectors Examples of gas-specific connectors are quick
are quick connectors, screw-threaded connectors, connectors, screw-threaded connectors, diameter-
diameter-indexed safety system (DISS) connectors indexed safety system (DISS) connectors, non-
and non-interchangeable screw-threaded (NIST) interchangeable screw-threaded (NIST) connectors
connectors. and sleeve indexed system (SIS) connectors.
ASG 3.18 Ed Consistency with other clauses Add reference to SIS connectors
025
ASG 3.20 Ed Consistency with official terminology Replace “93/42/EC” with “93/42/EEC”
026
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 2 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 3.31 Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
028
ASG 3.32 Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
030
ASG 3.40 Ed Use better wording Replace “liquid state” with “liquid phase”
033
AIIGM 3.46 ed gas produced by an oxygen concentrator unit gas for medicinal use produced by an oxygen
034 whose concentration is within the limits specified in concentrator whose concentration is within the
the relevant pharmacopeial monograph limits specified in the relevant pharmacopeial
monograph
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 3 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
pressure regulator(s)
ASG 3.63 Ed Consistency with definitions Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
037
AIIGM 4.3.2 (*) ed NOTE 1 Criteria for the selection of metallic and Add ISO 11114-1 to Normative references or
041 non-metallic materials are given in ISO 15001, ISO Bibliography.
11114-1 and ISO 11114-2
Add ISO 11114-2 to Normative references or
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 4 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
Bibliography.
ASG 5.1.1 a) Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
043
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
continuously
reserve source(s)
when both the primary and secondary sources of
supply are unavailable; (see resolutions of comments Prague meeting,
October 2014, comment n. IT 090)
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 6 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM 5.3 ed Supply systems with cylinders, cylinder bundles or high-pressure reservoir(s)
047 bundles, or high pressure storage vessel(s)
ASG 5.3 Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
048 5.3.1 7 times
5.3.2
5.3.3
AIIGM 5.3.1 ed A supply system with cylinders, cylinder bundles, bundles or high-pressure reservoir(s)
049 or high pressure storage vessel(s) shall comprise:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
automatic changeover. Each bank shall have its bundles or high-pressure reservoir(s)
cylinders, cylinder bundles, or high pressure
storage vessel(s) connected to a manifold with its
own pressure regulator. Except for air, vent valves
shall be vented outside of the building.
AIIGM 5.3.3 ed Except for banks with only one cylinder, cylinder
051 bundle, or high pressure storage vessel, a non-
return valve shall be installed at the manifold end bundles or high-pressure reservoir(s)
of each flexible connection between the cylinder,
cylinder bundles, or high pressure storage
vessel(s) and the manifold.
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 5.4.1 a) Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
053 5.4.1 b)
ASG 5.4.2 Ed In the field, situations where a brittle material Add the following at the beginning of clause
054 is placed downstream of a vaporizer are very 5.4.2:
rare, as pipelines are made almost Where materials subject to cold embrittlement
exclusively of copper and stainless steel. An are used downstream of the vaporiser
ingress of cryogenic liquid is very rare. system……
AIIGM 5.5.1.1 ed a) a supply system with cylinders, cylinder bundles
055 or high pressure storage vessel(s) as specified in
5.3; high-pressure reservoir(s)
ASG 5.5.1.1 a) Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
056
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM 5.5.2.5 ed b) a bank of cylinders, cylinder bundles, high cylinders, cylinder bundles or high-pressure
060 pressure storage vessel(s); reservoir(s);
AIIGM 5.5.2.5 NOTE 2 ed a) one compressor unit with one reservoir, one
061 conditioning unit and two banks of cylinders,
cylinder bundles or high pressure storage
vessel(s);
high-pressure reservoir(s)
b) two compressor units with at least two
reservoirs, two conditioning units and one bank of
cylinders, cylinder bundles or high pressure
storage vessel(s);
high-pressure reservoir(s)
ASG 5.5.2.5 Ed The first “fitted” is redundant Delete the first “fitted” and amend as follows:
062 Note 4 c) a dew-point sensor with an alarm and
display …..
ASG 5.5.2.5 b) + Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
063 Note 2 a)
and b)
AIIGM 5.5.2.6 NOTE 1 ed one compressor unit with one reservoir, one
064 conditioning unit and one bank of cylinders,
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 10 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM 5.5.2.12 ed The inlet of the ambient air for compressors shall
058 be located where there is minimal contamination
(e.g. from internal combustion engine exhaust,
vehicle parking, access areas, healthcare facility
waste and disposal systems, vacuum system
exhausts, vents from medical gas pipeline or
anaesthetic gas scavenging systems, ventilation
system discharges, chimney outlets)
AIIGM 5.5.2.13 ed A supply system with compressors intended to (single-stage pipeline distribution systems cannot
059 supply a single-stage pipeline distribution system have line pressure regulators!)
shall include at least two permanently fitted line
pressure regulators. The design flow of the line pressure regulators
pipeline distribution system shall be supplied with
at least one line pressure regulator isolated for
maintenance.
The instructions for use and maintenance shall line pressure regulators
specify how the permanently fitted l i ne pressure
regulators are intended to operate.
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 11 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
reservoir(s).
ASG 5.5.3.3 Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
067 a), b) and c)
AIIGM 5.5.3.4 ed d) a synthetic medical air reservoir fitted with a medical air
068 pressure-relief valve, a pressure gauge and a
means of purging;
AIIGM 5.5.3.7 ed Means shall be provided to purge the synthetic medical air
069 medical air reservoir.
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 13 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 5.6.2 Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
072 b) and c)
AIIGM 5.6.3 ed Secondary source of supply (see ISO/FDIS amended in Prague meeting)
073
delete or reservoir
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 14 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 5.6.3 Ed Use the correct term, i.e. “source of supply” Amend as follows:
074 If the secondary source of supply consists of
an oxygen concentrator, it shall include the
same components as the primary source of
supply.
AIIGM 5.6.4 Reserve source of supply (see ISO/FDIS amended in Prague meeting)
075
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 15 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 5.6.4 Ed Use the correct term, i.e. “source of supply” If the reserve source of supply consists of an
076 oxygen concentrator, it shall include the same
components as the secondary source of supply.
AIIGM 5.6.5.1
ed NOTE 1 These valves are taken from the values…. Pharmacopoeia
077 European Pharmacopeia.
Each oxygen 93 storage vessel or group of oxygen Each oxygen 93 reservoir or group of oxygen 93
93 storage vessels shall: reservoir(s)
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG Contents, Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
151 5.6.7
ASG 5.6.7 Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel(s) with reservoir(s)
081 3 times
ASG 5.6.7 Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace storage vessel with reservoir
082 Note
ASG 5.6.7 d) Ed Consistency with definition 3.56 Replace vessel with reservoir
083
AIIGM 5.6.8.3 ed The oxygen analyzer and automatic isolating valve oxygen 93 reservoir
084 on the oxygen storage reservoir shall be located
upstream of the oxygen storage reservoir. oxygen 93 reservoir
ASG 5.6.8.3 Second Ed Use the correct term Replace “oxygen storage reservoir” with “oxygen
085 sentence 93 reservoir”
2 times
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
known composition.
AIIGM 5.6.9 ed Local filling of permanently attached high pressure oxygen 93 high-pressure reservoir(s), acting as
087 oxygen 93 reservoir(s), acting as reserve reserve source of supply.
reservoirs.
ASG 5.6.9 First line Ed Use the correct term Replace “oxygen reservoirs” with “oxygen 93
088 reservoirs”
Third line “pure” is redundant
AIIGM 5.6.9.1 ed a) Means shall be provided to ensure that the filling reserve high-pressure reservoir(s)
089 of high pressure reservoirs does not affect delivery
of oxygen 93 to the pipeline distribution system. (see resolutions of comments Prague meeting,
October 2014, comment n. DE 188)
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 18 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM 5.6.9.2 ed The following safety measures shall be provided 5.6.9.2 The following safety measures shall be
090 implemented:
a) means (e.g. a non-return valve) to ensure that
there is no back flow to the oxygen concentrator (see ISO 14971 for terminology, the measures are
supply system. “implemented”, not “provided”)
—a power sensor;
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 5.6.9.2 c) Ed Use better wording Replace ,” it may give rise to” with “to activate”
091
ASG 5.6.9.2 d) Ed Use the correct term Replace “compressor” with “high pressure
092 Last booster compressor”
sentence
ASG 5.7.3 Ed Consistency with the notes in 7.2.2, 7.2.3 and Use the following text:
094 7.2.4
NOTE
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 20 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM 5.8.2 (*) ed The ambient temperature in rooms for supply for supply systems in rooms
096 systems shall be maintained in the range of 10°C
to 40°C.
AIIGM 6.1 ed The control panel, the monitoring, and the alarm monitoring
097 system shall be designed in accordance with IEC
60601-1-8.
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 21 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM 6.4 ed NOTE 5 ppm V/V is the value specified in the The monograph in the European Pharmacopoeia is
099 European Pharmacopeia Medical Air monograph. called “Medicinal air”
0.001%
European Pharmacopoeia Medicinal Air monograph
ASG 6.4 After g) Ed Use the correct term Replace “oxygen” with “oxygen 93”
100
ASG 6.4 Ed One of the two items is redundant Keep k) and delete l) or keep l) and delete k)
101 k) and l)
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 22 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM 6.6 (*) ed d ) temperature of any air compressor exceeding d ) temperature of any air compressor exceeding
102 the threshold defined by the manufacturer. the threshold defined by the manufacturer;
f) for systems supplied from oxygen concentrator f) for systems supplied from oxygen concentrator
supply units, an oxygen concentration below 90%. supply units, an oxygen concentration below 90%;
AIIGM 7.2.2 NOTE 2 ed NOTE 2 The following factors will contribute to the These requirements are applicable also to single
103 pressure change: performance of l i n e pressure stage distribution systems; delete “line”
regulators, pressure drop in the pipeline
downstream of the line pressure regulator and performance of pressure regulators
pressure drop across the terminal unit.
pressure regulator
AIIGM 7.2.3 NOTE 2 ed NOTE 2 The following factors will contribute to the These requirements are applicable also to single
104 pressure change: performance of l i n e pressure stage distribution systems; delete “line”
regulators, pressure drop in the pipeline
downstream of the line pressure regulator and performance of pressure regulators
pressure drop across the terminal unit.
pressure regulator
ASG 7.3.1 Ed Use better wording Add “requirements” before “shall be met”
105
7.3.1 d) Delete “it” and add “the low pressure flexible
connection” at the beginning of the sentence
AIIGM 7.4.1 (*) ed The instructions for use and maintenance shall
106 specify how the two permanently fitted pressure
regulators are intended to operate. line pressure regulators
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 23 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 8.1.6 Ed This valve is a main shut-off valve (see e.g. Replace “An inlet shut-off valve” with “A main
107 item 2 in Figures A.23, A.24 and A.25 shut-off valve”
AIIGM 8.3.1 ed All terminal units in the pipeline system other than
108 those provided only for emergency, system test
purposes or maintenance of components (e.g. line
pressure regulators) shall be on the patient side of
an area shut-off valve (upstream for vacuum).
AIIGM 8.3.10 ed No area shut-off valve shall be fitted downstream 8.3.10 No area shut-off valve shall be fitted
109 of the sensor activating the emergency pressure downstream of the sensor activating the emergency
alarm. pressure alarm.
AIIGM 10.1.2 ed NOTE ISO 5359 2008 does not include marking or oxygen 93.
002 colour coding for Oxygen 93.
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 24 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 10.1.2 a) Ed In ISO 5359:2014 DAM1 and in ISO Delete the note.
003 Note 18082:2014 DAM1 marking for oxygen 93 is
defined.
AIIGM 10.2 ed NOTE 1 ISO 5359 2008 does not include marking oxygen 93.
004 or colour coding for Oxygen 93.
ASG 10.2 Ed Colour coding is not defined in ISO Amend the note as follows:
005 Note 1 5359:2014 DAM1 and in ISO 18082:2014
DAM1 NOTE 1 ISO 5359:2014 DAM 1 does not include
colour coding for Oxygen 93
AIIGM 11.1.2 ed Pipeline components which ar e l i abl e t o come Pipeline components which ar e l i abl e t o come in
007 in contact with the actual gas shall meet the contact with the actual gas shall meet the
cleanliness requirements of EN 13348 and ISO cleanliness requirements of EN 13348 or ISO
15001 and be supplied protected from 15001, as applicable (see 4.3.6 e 4.3.7) , and be
contamination prior to, and during, installation. supplied protected from contamination prior to, and
during, installation.
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 25 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
or, at least:
ASG 11.1.12 Ed Use better wording Replace “Allowance shall be made for expansion
006 and contraction of pipelines” with
AIIGM 12.4 ed n) test of the quality of oxygen 93 produced by oxygen 93 produced by supply systems with
011 oxygen concentrator unit(s) (see 12.6.14); oxygen concentrator(s)
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG 12.4 After p) Ed Consistency with clause 12.6.17 Add the following new dash item:
012
AIIGM 12.6.1 ed d) combined test for leakage and mechanical d) combined test for leakage and mechanical
013 integrity of vacuum pipeline systems. integrity of vacuum pipeline systems (see 12.6.1.7).
It shall be proved that there are no cross- It shall be proved that there are no cross-
connections between pipelines for different gases connections between pipelines for different gas
or vacuum. services or vacuum services.
ASG 12.6.5.1 Second Ed SIS connectors should also be referred to Add mention of SIS connectors as in the title
020 sentence
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 27 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM 12.6.11 ed NOTE 1 The test methods are given in the relevant Pharmacopoeia
014 Pharmacopeia monographs.
AIIGM 12.6.13 ed NOTE 1 The test methods are given in the relevant Pharmacopoeia
015 Pharmacopeia monographs. Alternative methods
of analysis may be used.
AIIGM 12.6.14 ed NOTE 1 The test methods are given in the relevant pharmacopoeia
016 pharmacopeia monographs. Alternative methods
of anaysis may be used. analysis
AIIGM 13.3.2 ed the minimum and maximum oxygen the minimum and maximum oxygen
022 concentrations delivered by the oxygen concentrations delivered by the
concentrator unit(s) at the system design flow compressor unit, proportioning unit and
under the ambient conditions specified by the oxygen concentrator unit at the system
healthcare facility; design flow under the ambient conditions
specified by the healthcare facility;
starting procedure of the oxygen concentrator starting procedure of the compressor unit,
unit(s) if applicable; proportioning unit and oxygen
concentrator unit if applicable
starting time of the oxygen concentrator unit(s) if starting time of the compressor unit,
applicable. proportioning unit and oxygen
concentrator unit if applicable
ASG 13.3.2 Ed Use better wording Add the article before all dash items, if
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 28 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
023 required
ASG Annex A Sentence Ed The figures are 26, from A.1 to A.26 Replace A.44 with A.26, 2 times
111 before Replace A.25 with A.26
Table A.1
and title of
Table A.1
ASG Annex A Table A.1 Ed All figures are identified as e.g. A.1, A.15, etc. Use the same method of identification of the
112 In the first column they are referred to as e.g. figures all through the document, A.1 or A1
A1, A15 etc.
ASG Annex A Table A.1 Ed Vacuum is not medical , is vacuum only ! Delete “medical” before “vacuum”
113 Draw. Ref.
2 times
A22
ASG Annex A Figures Ed The titles of the figures shall be as the titles See the proposed change for each figure
114 given in Table A.1. The titles in Table A.1 are
correct (except for vacuum). Amend the titles
of some figures as proposed below.
ASG Annex A Figure A.1 Ed Typing error Delete “and” between “manifold” and
115 title “systems”
ASG Annex A Figure A.4 Ed The cryogenic storage vessel systems are Make “system” plural after “cryogenic storage
116 title two. vessel”
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 29 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG Annex A Figure A.5 Ed The supply system is for medical air Use the titles given in table A.1
117 title
ASG Annex A Figure A.6 Ed The supply system is for medical air. Use the titles given in table A.1.
118 title Reservoir should be plural “reservoirs”
ASG Annex A Figure A.7 Ed Reservoir should be plural “reservoirs” Use the titles given in table A.1.
119 title
ASG Annex A Figure A.8 Ed Consistency with table A.1 Delete the brackets for “optional”
120 title
ASG Annex A Figure A.9 Ed The title is not complete Use the titles given in table A.1.
121 title
ASG Annex A Figure A.10 Ed The title is not complete Use the title given in table A.1.
122 title
ASG Annex A Figure A.11 Ed Amend the content of box I Change “medical air reservoir” into “air for
123 title tools reservoir” or simply “air reservoir”
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 30 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG Annex A Figure A.12 Ed Amend the content of boxes I Change “medical air reservoir” into “air for
124 title tools reservoir” or simply “air reservoir” 2
times
ASG Annex A Figure A.13 Ed Amend the content of boxes I Change “medical air reservoir” into “air for
125 title tools reservoir” or simply “air reservoir” 2
times
ASG Annex A Figure A.16 Ed The last “systems” should be singular Use the titles given in table A.1.
126 title “system”
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Consistency with the content of the boxes in Delete “Medical gas”
127 Item A the Figures concerned
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Consistency with the content of the boxes in Delete “Medical gas” and “cylinder bindles”
128 Item B the Figures concerned
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Consistency with the content of the boxes in Delete “Medical gas”
129 Item D the Figures concerned
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Consistency with the content of the boxes in Delete “Cryogenic storage vessel”
130 Item E the Figures concerned
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 31 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Consistency with the content of the boxes in Delete all items in brackets
131 Item H the Figures concerned
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Consistency with the content of the boxes in Delete “Synthetic medical air” and change
132 Item K the Figures concerned “analysis system” with “analyser”
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Consistency with the content of the boxes in Delete all items in brackets
133 Item N the Figures concerned
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Consistency with the content of the boxes in Change “reserve supply source” with “reserve
134 Item BB the Figures concerned source of supply”
ASG Annex A Table A.2 Ed Only the first letter shall be capital Change Pressure Switch into Pressure switch
135 Item 12
ASG C.3.3.2 For Method Ed Vacuum is not medical, is vacuum only ! Delete “medical” before “vacuum”
147 2
d)
ASG C.3.3.2 For Method Ed Vacuum is not medical, is vacuum only ! Delete “medical” before “vacuum”
148 3 2 times
c) The pressure should be expressed in kPa Add the vacuum level in kPa
with the corresponding value in psi in
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 32 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
and brackets.
d) The vacuum level should be expressed in Add the vacuum level in kPa
kPa with the corresponding value in “inHg” in
brackets.
ASG C.3.14.2.2 Ed Use the correct term Add “concentration” to the title
142
ASG C.3.14.2.6 New clause Ed Consistency with clause 5.6.5.1 f) Add the following new clause:
144
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
ASG C.3.14.2.7 New clause Ed Consistency with clause 5.6.5.1 g) Add the following new clause :
145
C.3.14.2.7 Sulphur dioxide concentration
ASG C.3.17 New clause Ed Consistency with clauses 12.4 q) and 12.6.17 Add the following new clause:
146 C.3.17 Verification of restart of after
power supply failure (see 12.6.17)
ASG Annex D Form D.1.2 Ed Consistency with clauses 12.4 q), 12.6.17 and Add a line referring to 12.6.17 and C.3.17.
136 C.3.17 Amend the title of Form D.1.2 by adding
12.6.17
A dedicated form is not needed.
ASG Annex D Form D.10 Ed Consistency with other clauses Add reference to SIS connectors in the second
137 column and in the title
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM H.1.1, H.1.2 ed Oxygen concentrators may be used for supplying H.1
153 oxygen 93 to a medical gas pipeline system as a
substitute for medical oxygen. As oxygen 93 is not
covered by a Pharmacopoeia monograph in all
territories, regional or national regulations might
prevent its use as a replacement for medical oxygen
oxygen.
oxygen
AIIGM H.5.2.2.1 ed This situation has already been recognized for the
154 supply systems for air and nitrogen for driving
surgical tool: three sources of supply are not tools
necessary; two are sufficient (see 5.5.2.5).
AIIGM H.5.5.2.1, ed A monograph on medical air has been published There are two different monographs on medical air
155 5.5.2.2 and by the European Pharmacopoeia Commission in the European Pharmacopoeia: “medicinal air”
5.5.2.4 (EPC) [36] and “synthetic “medicinal air”
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 35 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM H.6.6 ed The subcommittee heard persuasive arguments for (See H.5.5.2.7)
157 both locations.
There are persuasive arguments for both locations.
ASG Annex I Table I.1 Ed Use better wording Replace N/a with “Non applicable”
138
AIIGM Annex J ed a) from 90% to about 100% when oxygen is used cylinders, cylinder bundles or high-pressure
139 in cylinders, high pressure reservoir(s) or cryogenic reservoir(s)
vessels within the secondary and the reserve
sources of supply.
AIIGM Annex J ed - consideration about potential risk arising if non- if gas-specific connectors
140 interchangable connectors for oxygen and oxygen
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 36 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
AIIGM K.2.1 ed - synthetic medical air manufactured using a synthetic medical air is not defined
161 proportioning system;
- synthetic medical air manufactured using a
proportioning system
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 37 of 38
Template for comments and secretariat observations Date:2015-09-18 Document: FprEN 7396-1 Project:
MB/ Line Clause/ Paragraph/ Type of Comments Proposed change Observations of the
NC1 number Subclause Figure/Table comment2 secretariat
1 MB = Member body / NC = National Committee (enter the ISO 3166 two-letter country code, e.g. CN for China; comments from the ISO/CS editing unit are identified by **)
2 Type of comment: ge = general te = technical ed = editorial
Page 38 of 38