Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jurnal Kedokteran Dan Kesehatan Indonesia: Indonesian Journal of Medicine and Health
Jurnal Kedokteran Dan Kesehatan Indonesia: Indonesian Journal of Medicine and Health
95
Meiyanti et al. Antibiotic susceptibility of salmonela...
pasien dengan diare, patogen enterik terisolasi and their inappropriate use in humans.3 The
terdiri Shigella (11,4%), Salmonella (6,6%) dan rapid and continuous occurrence of antibiotic
Vibrio (2,7%). resistance in enteric pathogenic bacteria to first-
Hasil: Uji kepekaan antibiotik pada spesies line antibiotics for the treatment of diarrhea
Shigella beberapa antibiotik seperti ampisilin, has caused various problems and concerns in
kloramfenikol, tetrasiklin dan, trimethoprim- developing countries.1,4
sulfamethoxazole menunjukkan tingkat resistensi In developing countries the diarrhea-
yang cukup tinggi (25% -100%), sedangkan causing enteric pathogenic bacteria, such as
ceftriaxone, ciprofloxacin, norfloksasin dan Salmonella, Shigella and Vibrio, still constitute
asam nalidiksat yang tampaknya masih efektif an important public health problem.4 Although
(resistensi tingkat 0%). Salmonella non-tifoid Salmonella infections are self-limiting, i.e. the
memiliki pola resistensi yang sama seperti orang- patient recovers after a time without specific
orang dari Shigella, khususnya terhadap ampisilin, treatment, the disease may be severe and fatal,
tetrasiklin, kloramfenikol dan trimethoprim- so that antibiotics are needed. 5-7 In addition,
sulfametoksazol Namun, untuk S. typhi ditemukan there are reports from various countries of
bahwa semua antibiotik masih efektif. Vibrio increased resistance rates and the occurrence
adalah resisten terhadap ampisilin (tingkat of multiresistance in Salmonella.8 In cases of
resistensi 100%), sedangkan antibiotik lain yang infections caused by Shigella, high mortality
masih efektif. rates have been reported as well as malnutrition
Kesimpulan: Dapat disimpulkan bahwa untuk and growth disturbances in children as a result of
setiap enterik yang patogen pola resistensi the disease.9 Shigellosis is related to poor hygiene,
antibiotik harus ditentukan. Penggunaan poverty and crowded housing. In the last few
antibiotik harus didasarkan pada uji kepekaan decades Shigella species have shown changes
antibiotik. in antibiotic susceptibility patterns. These
bacteria progressively show resistance to various
INTRODUCTION antibiotics primarily used in the treatment of
Antibiotic treatment against bacterial diarrhea.10 They are resistant to conventional
infections is generally an important factor in antibiotics such as ampicillin, tetracycline, and
reducing the morbidity and mortality rates. trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole but generally
However, excessive and incorrect use of are sensitive to fluoroquinolones.9
antibiotics for the treatment of disease may For cholera, antibiotic treatment is important
increase the occurrence of bacterial resistance because it may reduce the frequency of diarrhea
to these antibiotics.1,2 This results in reduced and the volume of stools excreted by the patient.8
benefits and efficacy of antibiotics commonly For more than 30 years tetracycline had been the
used in therapy, thus causing serious problems, drug of choice for the treatment of cholera. To
such as a longer course of the infectious disease date no significant numbers of Vibrio cholerae
and unnecessary exposure of the patient to drug resistant to this antibiotic have been found in
toxicity. Indonesia. In contrast, increased resistance
Antibiotic resistance may cause inappropriate rates to several antibiotics have been found
selection of antibiotics at the start of treatment, in V. parahaemolyticus.9 For patients with
as antibiotic administration is done empirically. diarrhea in developing countries, laboratory
The results of the treatment are unsatisfactory investigations, comprising bacterial culture and
due to of the ineffectiveness of the antibiotic antibiotic resistance test, are rarely performed,
against already resistant bacteria. This problem because of the high cost of the investigations.
becomes important because of increased Patients usually receive antibiotic treatment
prevalence of resistance againts antibiotic drugs on the basis of clinical signs and symptoms of
commonly used in the treatment of infectious diarrhea without laboratory confirmation.
disease. The development of antibiotic resistance The purpose of this study was to determine
is accelerated by the use of antibiotics in animals the antibiotic resistance patterns of several
96
JKKI 2016;7(3):95-101
diarrhea-causing enteric bacteria that are four days the bacterial population would have
frequently found in Indonesia, particularly decreased, presumably resulting in a false
Salmonella, Shigella and Vibrio. Understanding negative. Rectal swab was placed in Cary Blair
the antibiotic resistance patterns of these transport medium and stored in a refrigerator
pathogens is important, because it may guide until transported to the laboratory. The samples
empirical treatment in the framework of were transported under cold conditions by
reducing inapproriate antibiotic use. placing them in a thermos bottle. On arrival
at the laboratory the rectal swabs were plated
METHODS onto MAC, SS, XLD and TCBS. The agar plates
Study subjects and location. This study were incubated aerobically at 37°C for 18-24
was conducted on patients with diarrhea who hours. Suspected colonies were picked and
attended Community Health Center, South grown in biochemical media for identification
Jakarta, Indonesia, from September 2011 until and characterization.12,13 Serological tests for
May 2013. Diarrhea was defined as three or more confirmation were done on each bacterial
loose stools during the previous 24 hours.11 species isolated using specific antiserum (DIFCO,
Informed consent and patient information. Becton Dickinson, Sparks, MD).
Before sample collection, signed informed
consent for voluntary participation in the study Antibiotic susceptibility testing
was requested from the patient or guardian Bacterial isolates were subsequently
(in case of a child). After obtaining consent, a subjected to antibiotic susceptibility testing
clinical questionnaire was completely filled out against ampicillin (Am), chloramphenicol (C),
by study personel. Information on personal data tetracycline (Te), trimethoprim sulfamethoxazole
and the disease of the patient was recorded (Sxt), ceftriaxone (Cro), ciprofloxacin (Cip),
by health personel appointed for this task, norfloxacin (Nor) and nalidixic acid (Na), The test
followed by collection of a stool specimen. The was performed using the disk diffusion method
data collected from the subjects comprised age, in accordance with the guidelines of Clinical and
gender, clinical signs and symptoms, and stool Laboratoy Standards Institute.14 The antibiotic
samples or rectal swabs for bacterial culture disks used in this test were obtained from Becton
and antibiotic susceptibility testing Dickinson and Company, Cockeysville, MA, USA.
Escherichia coli ATCC 25922 and Staphylococcus
Bacteriological procedures aureus ATCC 25923 were included in the test
Media. as control strains. The test result was read by
The culture media used in this study consisted measuring the inhibition zone demonstrated
of xylose-lysine-deoxycholate agar (XLD), by the culture. Determination of sensitive,
MacConkey agar (MAC), Salmonella-Shigella agar resistant or intermediate was in accordance
(SS), and thiosulfate citrate bile salts sucrose agar with established standards. 14
(TCBS). All media were obtained from DIFCO,
Becton Dickinson, Sparks, MD, and prepared RESULTS
according to previously described methods 12,13 Overall, 150 rectal swab specimens were
collected from patients with diarrhea of all ages
Study material and culture process without regard to disease severity. From these
Rectal swab was collected from patient with rectal swabs the isolated enteric pathogenic
diarrhea who attended the Community Health bacteria consisted of Shigella (11.4%), Salmonella
Center. The sample was taken irrespective of (6.6%) and Vibrio (2.7%) species. Shigella
disease severity (mild, moderate, or severe). strains isolated were S. dysenteriae (0.7%), S.
Rectal swab was collected at the time of flexneri (6.7%), S. sonnei (2.7%) and S. boydii
attendance and before administration of (1.3%). Salmonella sp isolated consisted of non-
antibiotics. Care was taken to collect the swab typhoid Salmonella and S. typhi, with percentages
before the fourth day of illness, since after of 5.3% and 1.3%, respectively. The remaining
97
Meiyanti et al. Antibiotic susceptibility of salmonela...
isolates were species of Vibrio, namely Vibrio by other investigators.15 In our study, the non-
non-O1 (2.0%) and V. parahaemolyticus (0.7%) typhoid Salmonella species obtained were on
(Table 1). average resistant to four first-line antibiotics
Results of suceptibility test showed variable that are commonly used in therapy and 20%
resistance among the various bacterial isolates. of these were even resistant to nalidixic acid
Of the Shigella species, S. flexneri showed (Table 1). However, only a small percentage
the highest resistance rate (80%-90%) to of the non-typhoid Salmonella were resistant
ampicillin, chloramphenicol, tetracycline and to chloramphenicol, an antibiotic that had
trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole. S. sonnei and previously been the drug of choice for Salmonella
S. boydii were mostly resistant to tetracycline infections, particularly S. typhi.
and trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (75%- S. typhi species which we isolated did not
100%), while all S. dysenteriae tested (100%) show resistance to the eight antibiotics tested,
showed resistance to chloramphenicol and as they were sensitive to all. However, because
trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (Table 1). For of the extremely small number of isolates that
non-typhoid Salmonella, resistance to ampicillin we obtained, viz. only two (1.3%), this does not
and tetracycline comprised more than half constitute a general picture of the antibiotic
(62.5%) of the isolates, however many were still sensitivity status of S. typhi in Jakarta. On the
sensitive to chloramphenicol and trimethoprim- other hand, the report of Ochiai et al17 stated
sulfamethoxazole (75% and 87.5%, respectively). that in Indonesia, with an S. typhi isolation rate
For S.typhi no isolates were encountered that of 3.31%, no antibiotic-resistant S. typhi was
were resistant to the antibiotics tested. Vibrio found, as is the case with China. This situation
cholera was not found in this study, but of the is very different from that of S. typhi from
Vibrio non-O1 and V. parahaemolyticus that were Vietnam, Pakistan, and India, where many S. typhi
isolated, all were resistant to ampicillin (100%) isolates are already resistant to antibiotics, and
but sensitive to the other antibiotics. even show multidrug resistance (MDR), i.e. to
ampicillin, chloramphenicol and trimethropim-
DISCUSSION sulfamethoxazole, the percentages being 7%
Resistance to antibiotics may result in in India and up to 65% in Pakistan17. The
changes in virulence of microorganisms and presence of MDR accompanied by resistance
poor response to empirical antibiotic treatment, to fluoroquinolones and nalidixic acid, which
because the microorganisms are already resistant is developing rapidly in Vietnam, results in
to the antibiotic in question. Infections caused by problems and difficulties in the treatment of
antibiotic-resistant microorganisms tend to lead typhoid fever. In 2004 it was reported that
to a longer or a more severe course of the disease, isolates of S. typhi in Vietnam, which in the
in comparison with infections by bacteria that previous five years had a resistance rate of 87%
are still sensitive to antibiotics. to nalidixic acid, in that year had a resistance rate
In recent years an increased incidence of up to 97% 18. Patients with S. typhi infections
of infections have been reported, and also resistant to nalidixic acid show a poor clinical
multiantibiotic resistance by non-typhoid response with a therapeutic failure rate of up to
Salmonella. 15,16 They stated on the basis of their 36% accompanied by a prolonged fecal carrier
study results that of all isolated non-typhoid state. Although in South Vietnam MDR in S.
Salmonella serotypes, S. Newport was the most typhi has been reportedly high in the last 13
resistant to tetracycline, although it was still years or more, there are reports that in other
sensitive to the other antibiotics tested. The regions isolates of S. typhi are encountered that
majority of the multiresistant serotypes were are again sensitive to chloramphenicol, although
S. Typhimurium and S. Hadar. Overall, among in general in other Asian countries the MDR rate
the isolated and tested non-typhoid Salmonella of S. typhi is still high. 17-19
species in the study of Bukitwetan et al16 many During the last few years no cholera
were multiresistant, as had also been reported epidemic has been reported in Indonesia and
98
JKKI 2016;7(3):95-101
the prevalence of cholera is not high, namely of these bacteria is developing progressively in
around 3%. In spite of that, cholera, which causes Asian, African and Latin American countries.9
acute diarrhea, is still considered to be a health The study of Kosek et al 9 reported that overall the
hazard in the under-fives, particularly babies isolates of Shigella obtained (63%-83%) were
younger than 1 year of age 20 . In our present already resistant to ampicillin, chloramphenicol,
study no V. cholerae O1 was found. This may trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, tetracycline
have been due to an inadequate sample size and erythromycin, but were in general still
that did not allow the isolation of V. cholerae sensitive to quinolones and ceftriaxon. Similar
O1, whose current incidence tends to be low, antibiotic resistance patterns of Shigella have
namely only 0.5/1000/year 20. Other isolated also been reported by other investigators.21-23
Vibrio species were V. cholerae non-O1 (2.0%) In our study, among the isolates of Shigella
and V. parahaemolyticus (0.7%). Both Vibrio that we obtained and of which we tested the
species are in general still sensitive to all tested antibiotic sensitivity, all showed resistance
antibiotics, except ampicillin, to which they were to the main antibiotics, i.e. ampicillin,
fully resistant (100%). Agtini et al20 reported chloramphenicol, tetracycline and trimethoprim-
that in a survey conducted in Jakarta, >90% of sulfamethoxazole. However, different
isolates of V. cholerae O1 were still sensitive to serotypes had different sensitivity patterns.
trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole, tetracycline, All Shigella serotypes were already resistant
and chloramphenicol, besides fluoroquinolones. to trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole except for
However, although they successfully isolated non- S. flexneri (90% resistant), the other serotypes,
cholera bacteria, Agtini et al 20 in their reports did namely S. dysenteriae, S, boydii and S. sonnei,
not mention the antibiotic sensitivity patterns were all (100%) resistant to trimethoprim-
of these bacterial species. Antibiotic resistance sulfamethoxazole (Table 1). Of the four serotypes
of V. cholerae non-O1 and V. parahaemolyticus that could be isolated, S. flexneri and S. sonnei
was reported by Tjaniadi et al 21. It was stated showed multi-antibiotic resistance, namely
that antibiotic resistance in V. cholerae non-O1 to ampicillin, chloramphenicol, tetracycline
was from year to year clearly increasing in and trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole. To other
frequency with regard to antibiotics commonly antibiotics such as the quinolones ciprofloxacin,
used in the treatment of diarrhea in Indonesia. norfloxacin, nalidixic acid, and also to ceftriaxone,
According to the report 21, V. parahaemolyticus all Shigella isolates were still sensitive.
also showed an increasing frequency of antibiotic The survey conducted by Agtini et al20 in North
resistance, although its pattern was slightly Jakarta reported that more than 73% isolates of
different from that found in V. cholerae non-O1. S. flexneri were resistant to the four antibiotics
V. parahaemolyticus was still sensitive to most as in our study. Apparently during the last few
of the antibiotics, except for a few number (3- years there have not been many changes in the
15%) that were resistant to tetracycline and antibiotic sensitivity patterns of S. flexneri and
chloramphenicol, while to ampicillin all isolates other Shigella species in Jakarta. Because of the
(100%) were already resistant. This situation high frequency of antibiotic resistance of Shigella
is similar to that found in our study, so that it species to those four antibiotics, they cannot be
may be stated that in the last 10 years there used anymore for the treatment of shigellosis.
have not been many changes in the antibiotic Although there are recommendations to give
susceptibility pattern of V. parahaemolyticus. antibiotic treatment to shigellosis in children,
Shigella is the main cause of diarrhea leading the main concern is the selection of antibiotics
to high mortality in developing countries and to be given in the treatment, in view of the great
consistently associated with the syndrome of number of resistant Shigella species. The use of
clinical dysentery, prolonged diarrheal episodes fluoroquinolones in children with shigellosis
and persistent diarrhea.9 Episodes of dysentery is still controversial, and therefore alternative
are also a risk factor for malnutrition and growth drugs should be looked for. According to the
disturbances in children. Antibiotic resistance report of Herwana et al 24 and our own study
99
Meiyanti et al. Antibiotic susceptibility of salmonela...
100
JKKI 2016;7(3):95-101
101