Replies to comments on Civil Rehabilitation Drawing for Collection cum Equalization Tank (D001) Phase -I

Item Doc.Page/Clause
No Referencew No.

2 C-1624-01-CI-DWG-1001-
39 CIVIL REHABILITATION
DRG FOR COLLECTION CUM
EQUALIZATION TANK
(D001) PHASE-I R3
Civil Rehabilitation Drawing for Collection cum Equalization Tank (D001) Phase -I R3

Consultant (CH2M) Comments

As the treatment unit is still filled with water the depth of tank is still not confirmed.
CH2M Comment (22.01.20): Mark Water level in drawing. Confirm the volume and
detention time of the tank.
Please do actual distance and incorporate in Civil GA.
CH2M Comment (14.02.20): As per drawing received in transmittal 209, the
dimensions were typical and were not matching to actual dimensions. Although the
updated drawing received via mail 13 Feb 20 has correct measured dimensions.

Details of rehabilitation work for periphery wall are not shown in GA.
CH2M Comment (22.01.20):
Update the same w.r.t recent decisions at sites.
CH2M Comment (14.02.20): As per drawing received in transmittal
209, CH2M raised issue of water carrying capacity wall above RCC. Although the
updated reply received via mail 13 Feb 20 mentions that Weep holes (100 NB PVC
pipe) in the brick wall at the level of 5.8 (Top of pipe) at a distance of 1 m all over
the periphery of tank. So that, rain water pressure will not be there on the wall.

Mention the slope of the retaining wall.

CH2M Comment (22.01.20): Provide actual dimensions and remove typical
remarks from drawings.
CH2M Comment (14.02.20): Dimension updated as per mail received
13 Feb 20.

Show details of inlet pipe from distribution chamber to collection cum equalization
tank.
Show the distance of inlet pipe from either of the tank edges.
CH2M Comment (22.01.20): Noted
Provide overall section across tank in other sheets. Mainly for sectional elevation for
mixer platforms.
CH2M Comment (14.02.20): Noted

Provide top level of mixer platform.

Provide steps for accessing mixer and pump platforms from FGL.
CH2M Comment (22.01.20):
Provide stair details.
CH2M Comment (14.02.20): Noted

CH2M Comment (22.01.20): Please confirm the FGL at site.

CH2M Comment (14.02.20): Noted

CH2M Comment (22.01.20):

Please confirm extension of wall shall not be used for retaining effluent of
equalization in tank.
CH2M Comment (14.02.20): As per mail received 13 Feb 20, Noted
CH2M Comment (22.01.20):
Provide M/s WILO vetted document stating the available mixer quantity is enough
and mark the influence zone/ mixing pattern in GA.
CH2M Comment (14.02.20): Awaiting the document.
CH2M Comment 3rd comment (4.6.20): Contractor has submitted vendor
approved drawing on mail dt. 18th Feb 20.
e -I R3

Consultant (CH2M)
Contractor Reply Descision
(Open/Closed)
The depth is measured now at site. It is matching with the drawing. Closed

Reply to 2nd Comment: dimensions are verified at the site.

These are matching.

Ok, marked up with separate hatching. Reply to 2nd comment: As per had Closed
site
discussion with MIDC (SE), brick wall to be made of height of 1600 instead
of 1.1 mtr. The
bottom wall thickness is revised to 380 mm. Above brick wall railing will
be provided.

Ok, Added Closed

Reply to 2nd Comment: Ok revised as per

05.02.2020 meeting.

Ok added Closed
Replies to 2nd comment: Ok, separate section is added in the drawing.
Mechanical GA is also submitted along with the civil GA.

Ok added Closed
Replies to 2nd comment: Ok
Details added.

Replies to 2nd comment: FGL is Closed

6.1. Drawing is revised.

Replies to 2nd Comment: Water level of 5.0 will be maximum water level, Closed
whereas RCC top is 5.3. the Brick wall is above to that of 5.3. So, extension
of wall shall not be used for retaining the effluent of equalization tank.
Replies to 2nd Comment: Earlier discussion had been done and quantity Closed
had been arrived to 6 based on the tank geometry.
Mechanical GA is sent to Wilo for further approval.
We will submit the once we received the drawing from the vendor.
AEEPL Reply- Submitted