Professional Documents
Culture Documents
"Frankenstein Or, The Modern Prometheus ": The Gothic in Mary Shelley's
"Frankenstein Or, The Modern Prometheus ": The Gothic in Mary Shelley's
Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
July 2018
Contents
1 Introduction
2 Development
2.3 Alienation
3 Conclusion
Bibliography
0
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
1. Introduction
In this paper, it will be discussed whether the Gothic characteristics are displayed in
the piece of fiction called Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus. As David Punter describes,
“When thinking of the Gothic novel, a set of characteristics springs readily to mind: an emphasis
on portraying the terrifying, a common insistence on archaic settings, a prominent use of the
supernatural, the presence of highly stereotyped characters and the attempt to deploy and perfect
techniques of literary suspense are the most significant.” (Punter 1) The aim of the analysis is to
discover if the different Gothic conventions are present in the novel and how they are featured,
as well as the exploration of different topics of importance for the analysis of the novel. In order
to explore the Gothic in the novel, five topics will be considered in detail. The first topic will be
Nature and the Sublime, the second one will be Industrialization vs Nature, then the concept of
Alienation will be also analyzed, the fourth topic will be The monster as the Other and lastly,
Traditional Gothic elements in the story will be examined. To fulfil this objective, ideas
presented by authors such as David Punter, Ronald Carter , Proshanta Sarkar, Kelly Hurley and
Michael Gamer will be considered. Some information about the author and the novel can be
found below.
1
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
The novel’s author is Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley; She was born in London, in 1797.
Mary Shelley’s father, William Godwin, was a radical political philosopher and her mother,
Mary Wollstonecraft, had radical views as well: She was a feminist writer who wrote A
Vindication of the Rights of Woman (1792), one of the earliest works of feminist philosophy.
Some days after Mary Shelley was born, Mary Wollstonecraft died of health complications.
Mary was self educated and she could speak and read five languages. She published her first
poem at the age of ten. Mary married poet Percy Bysshe Shelley on 30 December 1816 in
London and it was him who suggested the idea of writing ghost stories one evening at the Villa
Diodati as a writing competition: As a result, Mary created this masterpiece, inspired by German
horror stories. Her most famous piece of work is the one we are going to explore, Frankenstein;
However, she also published Lodore (1835), Faulkner (1937), Mathilde (1959), Valperga or the
Life and Adventures of Castruccia, Prince of Lucca (1823), The Last Man (1826),The Fortunes
Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus narrates the horror that arises after scientist
Victor Frankenstein artificially creates a living creature. The protagonist, Doctor Frankenstein, is
obsessed with the idea of gaining control over life and death and that obsession marks him
forever, “In creating life and imagining how a ‘new species would bless me as its creator and
2
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
source’, he is seeking to usurp the role of God. He is also, however, seeking to usurp the role of
women, and such an unnatural birth, the text suggests, can only have unnatural consequences.”
(Punter, Byron 199) What starts as something similar to a miracle, ends bringing horror and
chaos to Frankenstein’s life, “Frankenstein believes he has found the secret of creating life, but
his creation turns out to be a destructive monster which no one, not even Frankenstein, can
control.” (Carter 265) The theme of this monster’s creation corresponds with Punter’s definition
of Gothic fiction, “...'Gothic' fiction is the fiction of the haunted castle, of heroines preyed on by
unspeakable terrors, of the blackly lowering villain, of ghosts, vampires, monsters and
werewolves.” (Punter 1)
As regards its structure, the novel contains a series of framed narratives; It is written in
first person to enhance the sense of reality and the narrators are three: Robert Walton, Victor
Frankenstein and also his creation himself. Also, it contains letters, for instance from Elizabeth-
2. Development
Gothic fiction was named “dark romanticism” as it shares many characteristics with literary
Romanticism but a sense of horror or terror is added. One of those features that both genres have
in common is the importance of nature. In addition, “Gothic Literature put a spin on the
Romantic idea of nature worship and nature imagery.” (Carter 266) The concept of ‘Nature’ was
3
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
a central part of 18th and 19th Century English literature as there was a desire of returning to the
past caused by the anxiety of a newly industrialised city- the idea of industrialization will be
explored later in this paper. In this literary genre- and in this novel especifically- mountains,
forests and lakes give the reader a connection to nature and purity.
Gothic literature is usually set in foreign places that “...serve to distance the horrors from the
world of the reader...”(Punter Byron 26) In the case of Frankenstein, the story takes place in
different foreign cities and a variation of breathtaking landscapes are presented: Geneva, the
Alps, the Arctic among others. This has a connection with what Balbao Pithan describes,
“Spanish, French , Italian scenarios suit brilliantly the purposes aimed at by authors who picture
sublime mountainous landscapes, Catholic Church and Inquisition matters, not to mention the
extra intensity offered by foreign places and character names.” (Balbao Pithan 12) In the novel,
the importance of Nature and the idea of the Sublime are remarked along the whole story
throughout Victor Frankenstein’s eyes, “ I discovered more distinctly the black sides of Jura, and
the bright summit of Mont Blanc; I wept like a child: ‘Dear mountains! My own beautiful lake!
How do you welcome your wanderer? Your summits are clear; the sky and lake are blue and
As it was mentioned before, Mary Shelley presents not only the beautiful aspects of
Nature but also the Sublime ones. As Carter defines them, Sublime experiences, “….are
excessive ones, in which we encounter the mighty, the terrible and the awesome. Gothic, it is
clear, is intended to give us the experience of the sublime.” (Carter 266) Victor Frankenstein
expresses how nature makes him feel better, “I remained two days at Lausanne, in this painful
state of mind. I contemplated the lake: the waters were placid; all around was calm; and the
4
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
snowy mountains, `the palaces of nature,' were not changed. By degrees the calm and heavenly
scene restored me, and I continued my journey towards Geneva.”(Shelley 81) In the quotation,
the scientist declares that the lake and mountains have a strong power that can heal him and calm
him down. Within Victor’s speeches, there are many instances in which the the idea of Nature
In another instance of the narration, Victor also describes how Nature can change his
emotions, “The sea, or rather the vast river of ice, wound among its dependent mountains, whose
aerial summits hung over its recesses. Their icy and glittering peaks shone in the sunlight over
the clouds. My heart, which was before sorrowful, now swelled with something like
joy…”(Shelley 112) His experience with the Sublime, which is transcendental and extraordinary,
makes him joyful and he expresses- in different instances of the story- how powerful he thinks
Nature is: “When happy, inanimate nature had the power of bestowing on me the most
delightful sensations. A serene sky and verdant fields filled me with ecstasy. The present season
was indeed divine; the flowers of spring bloomed in the hedges, while those of summer were
already in bud; I was undisturbed by thoughts which during the previous years had pressed upon
me, not withstanding my endeavour to throw them off, with an invincible burden.”(Shelley 76)
By means of a repetitive and full descriptions of Nature, Mary Shelley presents a noticeable
resemblance to pantheism.
As explained above, the Sublime is also present when the terrible is encountered. In
Carter’s words, “Along with nature having the power of healing, Gothic writers gave nature the
power of destruction. Frankenstein is full of the harsh reality of nature. Many storms arise in the
novel, including storms the night the Creature comes to life.”(Carter 266) An example of this
5
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
use of nature is presented to the reader during Victor’s journey to his brother’s funeral, “Yet, as I
drew nearer home, grief and fear again overcame me. Night also closed around; and when I
could hardly see the dark mountains, I felt still more gloomily. The picture appeared a vast and
dim scene of evil, and I foresaw obscurely that I was destined to become the most wretched of
human beings…”(Shelley 82) In this part of his speech, Victor expresses his fears at a point of
the journey in which he cannot see the mountains he is familiar with. He continues, “The storm
appeared to approach rapidly, and, on landing, I ascended a low hill, that I might observe its
progress. It advanced; the heavens were clouded, and I soon felt the rain coming slowly in large
drops, but its violence quickly increased.” (Shelley 82) After this description of the weather, he
discovers something that affects him in a negative way: The monster- his own creation- is the
murderer that killed his little brother, William. It must therefore be recognized that within Gothic
fiction, Nature and the Sublime have an extraordinary power that can be destructive as well as
healing.
The idea of Nature is contrasted with the artificiality that brings the chaos. According to
David Punter, “The Gothic novel began to emerge at a time when the forces of industrialization
were transforming the very structures of society.”(Punter Byron 20) The period in which Gothic
fiction took place was an era in which Britain was dealing with the technological and scientific
advancements of the Industrial Revolution as well as the circulation of ideals and principles from
6
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
The French Revolution, and those ideals and principles were seen as a threat. These historical
developments had an immense effect on society and the intellectual, political, social, and creative
environment in England.
The scientific, industrial, and intellectual progress during the 18th Century was a
motivation to many authors who found it to be a move away from nature. As regards Shelley’s
novel, Punter points out, “Frankenstein can be seen to set out for the first time the concern that
dominates Gothic’s engagement with both science and industry over the following centuries: the
disruption of accepted notions of the human.”(Punter Byron 21) This disruption goes hand in
hand with a revision of human values accepted so far, “Science [...] remains ever since updated,
always providing polemic subjects that range from responsibility (a great issue in Frankenstein)
At a time in which only women or a God were able to create life, the author presents a
man, Victor Frankenstein, who defies life and death’s limits creating a rational being. As
Yue-ting Chen explains, “he is challenging God with a sublime atmosphere and this horror and
terror thing is gothic indeed.”(Chen 253) The fact that the main character in the novel defies
religious ideas is not isolated from the historical context as “With the advent of the Industrial
Revolution people's mind had been progressively turning from religion to science as a better
form to explain phenomena so far covered in mysticism.” ( Balbao Pithan 119) Victor
Frankenstein is presented as a scientist who is not a religious man. In addition, in some instances
of the novel, he is described as a cold person who lacks human feelings, “All men hate the
wretched; how, then, must I be hated, who am miserable beyond all living things! Yet you, my
creator, detest and spurn me, thy creature, to whom thou art bound by ties only dissoluble by the
7
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
annihilation of one of us … Remember that I am thy creature; I ought to be thy Adam, but I am
rather the fallen angel” (Shelley 113). This description of the creator in conjunction with Adam’s
reference, conforms the notion of Victor as a person who is distant from the accepted religious
values, and “... the lack of religious consciousness (although one can never discard the possibility
of religious implication through its very absence) permitted Victor to challenge God's privilege
as Creator turning the novel, therefore, into a cautionary tale about the dangers of unchecked
scientific progress…” ( Balbao Pithan 122) In this way, the artificial being that Victor creates is
considered a figure that reminds the reader that the laws of Nature should not be violated and it is
observed in the novel, for instance, as “Nature takes its revenge on Frankenstein by depriving
him of his both mental and physical health while doing his research.”(Sarkar 31)
2.3 Alienation
As regards scientific progress, Punter declares, “Discoveries in the sciences only served
to aggravate a sense of alienation and further disturb notions of human identity.”(Punter Byron
20) In Gothic fiction, “Scenes of extreme threat and isolation – either physical or psychological –
are always happening or about to happen.” (Bowen 2014) and this state of alienation is observed
in Victor, who wants to conquer death and life with the use of science. To achieve that goal, he
must stay away from the civilization, “In a solitary chamber, or rather cell, at the top of the
house, and separated from all the other apartments by a gallery and staircase, I kept my
workshop of filthy creation; my eyeballs were starting from their sockets in attending to the
details of my employment.”( Shelley 55) Although he wanted to isolate himself to work on his
8
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
secret project, he is not entirely happy in that context, “I must absent myself from all I loved
while thus employed. Once commenced, it would quickly be achieved, and I might be restored to
Proshanta Sarkar states that “Mary Shelley‟s Frankenstein is the very power glass
through which we can have the glimpse how society alienates people because of their certain
characteristics which usually do not fulfill the desired and decisive taste of the society.”(Sarkar
1) A scientific discovery as the one aimed by Victor, would have altered society and, for that
reason, he knows his project must be a secret one. The project being secret cooperates with the
creation of a Gothic atmosphere in the novel, in which the reader is exposed to suspense and
then, horror.
In the story, the most horrific things happen when a character is isolated from society. As
it was explained, the “prototypical Gothic scientist” (Punter Byron 20), creates the monster while
being alone and nobody could supervise or advise him. Victor Frankenstein embodies the idea of
alienation in the novel but also some other characters as the monster itself. However, the creature
does not decide to be isolated from society: he wants to have friends, a family and a father and
son-like relationship with Victor. It is only when he feels rejected and lonely when he starts
being evil, “There was none among the myriads of men that existed who would pity or assist me;
and should I feel kindness towards my enemies? No: from that moment I declared everlasting
war against the species, and, more than all, against him who had formed me, and sent me forth to
this insupportable misery.”(Shelley 163) The wedding day episode is another example of the
alienation that brings the chaos. During the day, Elizabeth exclaims, “What a divine day! How
happy and serene all nature appears!’ (Shelley 238) It seems that the couple is protected by
9
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
nature- a central concept in Gothic literature previously considered in this paper- but then, Victor
describes a new situation, “Suddenly a heavy storm of rain descended. I had been calm during
the day, but so soon as night obscured the shapes of objects, a thousand fears arose in my mind.“
(Shelley 240) After the dramatic shift in the narrative by means of the change in weather,
Elizabeth is left alone, “ I earnestly entreated her to retire, resolving not to join her until I had
her wedding night and, as a consequence, the monster attacks her and kills her. It must therefore,
be recognized that alienation is a main theme within Gothic fiction that, in this piece of literature,
fields throughout history. Hegel was the first one: he developed his slave-master relationship
concept and introduced the idea of the Other. Simone De Beauvoir also wrote about this idea in
The Second Sex ( 1949) in which she describes how women are the Other to men. Michel
Foucault also considered Othering/Otherness a concept strongly connected with power and
knowledge.
refer to an individual or group who has been or is being marginalized from another, that is being
“othered”.( Reinoso Genoni 526) This concept is also used in literary studies and, in the case of
Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus, t he Other is the creature created by Victor. When the
10
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
scientist creates the creature, he expects him to be the owner of beautiful features. However, as
the final result is not the expected one, he is horrified at the monster’s appearance: “...I had
selected his features as beautiful. Beautiful! Great God! His yellow skin scarcely covered the
work of muscles and arteries beneath; his hair was of a lustrous black, and flowing; his teeth of a
pearly whiteness; but these luxuriances only formed a more horrid contrast with his watery eyes,
that seemed almost of the same colour as the dun-white sockets in which they were set, his
shriveled complexion and straight black lips.¨( Shelley 23) With this description, he is
classifying his creation as the Other, differentiating the monster from human’s appearance. He
reinforces this idea comparing his creature to a daemon, “A flash of lightning illuminated the
object, and discovered its shape plainly to me; its gigantic stature, and the deformity of its aspect,
more hideous than belongs to humanity, instantly informed me that it was the wretch, the filthy
daemon, to whom I had given life.” (Shelley 83) As the creature is a monster, a daemon, he is
left alone and it becomes alienated. As it was already mentioned, the monster wants to be loved
but people are scared of him because of their instant judgments based on appearance. Given the
fact that the monster is a rational being who is capable of the use of language, the rejection is a
social critique: society judges people on the superficial aspects. The critique is explicit when the
monster meets William, “Suddenly, as I gazed on him, an idea seized me that this little creature
was unprejudiced and had lived too short a time to have imbibed a horror of deformity.”( Shelley
170) The monster, who was once a noble creature who used to help people, becomes a monster
in the moral sense because of the lack of love and compassion, “But it is true that I am a wretch.
I have murdered the lovely and the helpless; I have strangled the innocent as they slept and
11
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
grasped to death his throat who never injured me or any other living thing. “(Shelley 275) In this
way, the Other becomes evil, leading to the justification of the scientist’s attempts to kill it.
The work of Kelly Hurley shows that “...Gothic [...] has been quite variously
defined in terms of plot...” ( Hurley 191). Because of this importance on the plot, it is necessary
to analyze the elements presented within the story. The novel contains an abundance of the
“classic” Gothic elements, the Sublime being the most prominent one in the story, which is also
linked to the idea of Nature as a major issue in the character’s life. As the concept of the Sublime
and the importance of Nature were explored in this paper before, some other elements of Gothic
fiction as dreams, the supernatural and the pursued protagonist will be analyzed.
A recurrent element in Gothic fiction is the use of dreams -or rather nightmares- to
anticipate future events or to explore the character’s emotions. As it is explained in “A Glossary
of Literary Gothic Terms” by Douglass H. Thomson, “Dreams dredge up these deep emotions
and premonitions that reflect tellingly upon the dreamer, what one might conceal during waking
hours but what emerges in sleep to haunt and arouse the dreamer. It is most likely due to this
heightened emotional state that dreams are used so often within Gothic Literature.”( Thompson
8) When Victor is in his laboratory creating the monster -the night the monster comes to life- the
scientist has a disturbing dream, “I thought I saw Elizabeth, in the bloom of health, walking in
the streets of Ingolstadt. Delighted and surprised, I embraced her; but as I imprinted the first kiss
12
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
on her lips, they became livid with the hue of death; her features appeared to change, and I
thought that I held the corpse of my dead mother in my arms; a shroud enveloped her form, and I
saw the grave-worms crawling in the folds of the flannel.”(Shelley 59) As Gamer explains, “This
nightmare [...] shows Shelley providing a stunning account of Victor’s extreme psychological
state, one which anticipates the insights of Freud into dreaming, death, and the family.”(Gamer
101)
The supernatural is another example of the most notable characteristic of Gothic novels.
Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus, the unnamed monster is the supernatural factor as its
creator does not explain how he could create life out of inanimate body parts. The procedure is
simplified by the scientist, “With an anxiety that almost amounted to agony, I collected the
instruments of life around me, that I might infuse a spark of being into the lifeless thing that lay
at my feet.”(Shelley 58) The supernatural, in this case, is associated with the lack of explanations
which is traditionally used in Gothic fiction as the rational explanation of the scientific procedure
is provided by Frankenstein but the “spark of being” -which is the major issue of the creation-
remains a mystery.
Also, important for the Gothic plot is the concept of The Pursued Protagonist.
Thompson defines it as, “ the idea of a pursuing force that relentlessly acts in a severely negative
manner on a character. This persecution often implies the notion of some sort of a curse or other
form of terminal and utterly unavoidable damnation…” (Thompson 21) In the novel, the
monster threats and pursues the protagonist. The scientist escapes in horror and disgust as soon
as the creation opened its eyes, “ He might have spoken, but I did not hear; one hand was
13
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
stretched out, seemingly to detain me, but I escaped and rushed downstairs.”(Shelley 59) He
escapes until Victor finally decides to listen to his creation. However, after he breaks a pact -
creating a female monster- he continues avoiding the creature but knowing he is in danger, “And
then I thought again of his words—‘*I will be with you on your wedding-night*.’ That, then,
was the period fixed for the fulfillment of my destiny. In that hour I should die and at once
satisfy and extinguish his malice.”(Shelley 206-207) This situation is also related to another
Gothic element: Revenge. As Thompson has indicated, “Within Gothic Literature, revenge is
notably prominent and can be enacted by or upon mortals as well as spirits. Revenge can take
many forms, such as harm to body, harm to loved ones, and harm to family.”(Thompson 23) In
this case, the monster takes revenge against Victor as he kills his brother William, his couple
3.1 Conclusion
In conclusion, the novel by Mary Shelley is a piece of Gothic fiction as it includes the
main characteristics of the genre. It was analyzed how Mary Shelley presents the different
Gothic conventions to the readers in her novel Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus. The
central concepts of the genre are developed in the story, for instance, the idea of Nature- that has
the god-like power of healing- and also the idea of the Sublime by means of the transcendental
experiences the protagonist Victor Frankenstein retells. The issue “Industrialization vs. Nature”
was taken into account as it is important as regards the plot. In addition, the story seems to have
a moral: defying Nature causes chaotic situations. Alienated characters are part of the Gothic
14
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
narratives and, in this case, the concept of Alienation is explored in relation to different
characters that, when left alone, are in danger or become the cause of a negative action. This idea
can be observed as Victor creates the monster while being alone, or when Elizabeth is killed
while being isolated. Also the monster is isolated from society, that situation being the one that
motivates the creature to change and start being evil. This is closely related to the fourth topic
explored in this paper: The monster as the Other. The definition of Othering/Otherness was
given in order to understand how the monster was treated in the novel. The creature is rejected
from the very beginning of his life by its own creator, who wanted it to have “beautiful” features.
However, as soon as the creation opened the eyes, the scientist got scared and decided to escape.
People escape from the monster just because of the way it looks, which is an example of a social
critique within the novel. Traditional Gothic elements were also analyzed in this paper to decide
whether Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus is or not a Gothic novel, and the main Gothic
elements were found in the novel: dreams -or rather nightmares-, the supernatural, the pursued
15
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
Bibliography
Primary sources:
Secondary sources:
Balbao Pithan, Ana Esther. “The Uniqueness of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein in the Gothic
Carter, Ronald, and John McRae. The Routledge History of Literature in English: Britain and
Chen, Yue-ting. “Frankenstein and the Gothic Sublime.” Journal of Literature and Art Studies,
16
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
2018)
epdf.tips/the-cambridge-companion-to-gothic-fiction-cambridge-companions-to-literature.html.
Jackson, Ronald, and Michael Hogg. “Encyclopedia of Identity.” Google Books, Google, 29
24, 2018).
Punter, David. Literature of Terror. a History of Gothic Fictions from 1765 to the Present Day:
The Gothic Tradition. Vol. 1, Routledge, 2013. (Accessed February 23, 2018).
Sarkar, Proshanta. “Frankenstein: An Echo of Social Alienation and Social Madness. .” IOSR
17
Paola M. Bica
The Gothic in Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein; or, the Modern Prometheus”
www.saylor.org/site/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/engl403-1.3.1-A-Glossary-of-Literary-Gothic-
18