Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mother's Journey Towards Oblivion-By Suryan Iyer - On Alzheimer's/Dementia
Mother's Journey Towards Oblivion-By Suryan Iyer - On Alzheimer's/Dementia
Mother's Journey Towards Oblivion-By Suryan Iyer - On Alzheimer's/Dementia
Oblivion
A narrative from a caregiver about life around an
Alzheimer’s / Dementia patient
SURYAN IYER
1
Copyright @ 2020 by Suryan Iyer
E-mail: suryanpk@gmail.com
2
This book is dedicated to my wife, whose support and
sacrifice made it possible for me to take care of our
mother during the most difficult period in our life when
she was suffering from Alzheimer’s disease.
3
Disclaimer: The contents of this book are my own
views and thoughts based on my personal experience,
which may not be entirely accurate from a medical
perspective. Hence, it may be read only as such.
4
Alzheimer’s / Dementia
5
as they are closely associated with the progress of the
disease which affects their beloved person’s lifestyle
and personality. It is common for caregivers to develop
depression and exhaustion at some stage during the
progression of the disease.
6
Prologue
7
in a very capable manner, including the upbringing of
her children. She could also be a tough taskmaster if the
situation so warranted.
8
I have seen some literature wherein people close to
Alzheimer’s patients have narrated their experiences.
Alzheimer’s is often described as a very cruel disease
which causes mental agony and suffering to the
caregivers, perhaps more than what the patient suffers.
9
Backdrop
10
during her final days, though it was only for a short
term and not very severe as it was in my mother’s case.
11
Early days
13
financial needs of the family. On the contrary, it could
have worsened the stress levels of my mother as she
had to support my father in the day-to-day running of
the shop along with her household responsibilities.
15
caring for her children with practically no room for
herself. Her life was bonded to a few familiar people
and limited to the four walls of her home during the
earlier days.
16
A birth and two deaths
18
decision - my brother had suffered enough; he was now
released from the burden of earthly sufferings.
19
Within a short span of four years, we had lost two
members of the family and suddenly my mother was
almost alone in the house. The children, who used to be
with us during their younger days, had already moved
on when they grew older and got busy with their own
lives.
20
A Gulf job
21
loneliness could have affected her in many ways which
I had not anticipated.
22
Annual Visits
23
short, in her small circle of influence, she was having a
sense of purpose, combined with power and authority.
26
purposes. With all these, Amma found herself in a
situation where she had nothing much to do. Moreover,
all along she was used to the village life (where she had
her own social circle of influence) and it was difficult
for her to adapt to the urban culture. In our native place,
she used to have a number of people to interact with
and socialise. Here, no such facility was available and
this was one aspect I had totally omitted to consider
when we decided to settle down at Coimbatore.
27
I shall now try to narrate some specific instances of
behavioural changes so as to make the readers
understand a very important fact about Alzheimer’s /
Dementia. If you find some strange and unexpected
behavioural changes in someone close to you, or if their
attitude and approach towards you or other family
members is changing for no reason, such symptoms
could be an indication of the onset of some health
problems. Such changes may not be intentional and
would need a very sympathetic and careful handling
though it would require lot of patience and conviction.
28
Mood swings and delusions
Even then, Amma was adamant and told him that it was
not her concern. He was totally taken aback by now,
and after Amma had gone to the temple, he did the
cooking by himself. When Amma returned from the
temple (after having lunch there), he was about to have
his lunch. Even then, Amma didn’t enquire anything
about his lunch or made any amends to serve him food.
At that time, he had no clue about this strange
behaviour and could not realize that this actually could
be the symptom of an imminent health problem.
32
cooking may be progressing when she may move out
for something and then she may not remember about
the kitchen for a long time. Luckily, nothing serious
had happened on such occasions except for the spoiled
food or the blackened vessel.
34
Uncertain days at Riyadh
35
Even with very good facilities provided by my
employer, I was finding it difficult to continue working
in Riyadh because of the family issues. I started
thinking about returning to India and as days
progressed, I began finalizing my exit plans from Saudi
Arabia. Finally, in March 2007, I tended my resignation
as I decided to wind up and return permanently to India.
36
family and then work for two or three months in
Riyadh.
37
A surprise trip and a sudden decision
As the days passed by, though I was with Amma all the
time, it didn’t help much to keep her happy as she was
entering the advanced stages of Alzheimer’s. My
presence did help her in being calmer and more
comfortable during the early days after my return.
However, day by day, she was showing stronger
symptoms of the disease.
41
Hallucinations
42
almost forgotten the peaceful environment in our family
during this period. To my understanding, this stage
could be classified as early stages of Alzheimer’s.
According to doctors, medical help during these stages
can provide some relief. However, it is an accepted fact
that no medical treatment can stop the progress of
Alzheimer’s / Dementia, though some medicines can
help to provide relief for some of the symptoms such as
depression, lack of sleep, anxiety etc.
.
43
Scare at Bangalore
44
Suddenly, she was very upset and started behaving in a
very strange manner. Her words and behaviour implied
that she had gone into an imaginary world where she
was probably at the village home of her parents. It
seems her mind had travelled into her childhood days.
What she had seen there was something terrifying for
her. Her house was being vandalized / ransacked by
some strangers and her parents were helpless in
protecting their property. She started shouting and
yelling for help, requesting someone to call her brother
to save the situation. (Her brother was always a source
of support to her during all her difficult days).
45
what was going on. He locked the door and didn’t allow
Amma to go out. Amma was furious and she became
even more upset that these ‘strangers’ were holding her
locked up. She could not realize that it was her daughter
and son-in-law who were near her at that time.
46
with my niece. They reached her home and Amma was
almost calm by then. She was given something to drink
as she was very tired by that time after the agonizing
experience. After some time when she had some rest,
Amma was back to normal but she could not remember
what had happened sometime back. Nobody wished to
remind her about the matter too. This was our first
experience of Hallucination.
47
She realizes her problem
49
She eagerly agreed to this suggestion. I told her
immediately “Ok, let’s go and meet the doctor. Let’s go
now itself”.
50
I made the appointment for the next day itself because
I didn’t want to delay the matter anymore.
51
The diagnosis
52
We got the scanning reports back to the doctor and it
was officially confirmed. Amma was suffering from
Alzheimer’s.
53
We visited the clinic several times during the next few
months. In fact, more than the patient, it was me and
my wife who were interviewed regularly by the
psychologist and the psychiatrist. They gave us some
counselling sessions, advising us in general about how
to cope up with the challenging situation as the days
progressed from bad to worse. They did help us in
preparing ourselves better to meet the tougher days that
were awaiting us. At a certain stage, they had advised
us that we need not bring Amma with us as it could not
serve any purpose.
54
Amma’s case beyond that stage. I could understand his
feelings. He was finding our meetings becoming more
emotional and personal while serving no positive
purpose. That was the last time I went to the
psychiatrist.
55
The train journey
She could not realize that she was in a train and was
under the impression that she was kept locked in a
strange house. Despite the efforts of my sister to
explain that they were travelling in a train (including
my Brother-in-Law and the other passengers nearby in
the compartment), Amma could not be convinced. The
situation continued like that for quite some time.
However, she became very tired soon after and fell
asleep. (All such situations of hallucinations used to
make Amma totally exhausted and physically tired).
57
By the time she woke up, she had forgotten everything
about the night’s incident. The remaining part of the
journey was eventless, and they reached home in the
afternoon.
58
other family members too. I realised that it was not
proper to keep Amma at Mumbai any longer. So, I
asked my sister to bring her back to Coimbatore. This
time I arranged for their travel by air as we could not
forget the difficult experience during the previous train
journey.
59
Fading memories; forgotten routines
60
activities. Earlier she used to get easily upset, and there
were numerous occasions when she would be agitated.
These types of mood swings began to subside and she
was gradually becoming subdued. She could be seen
sitting quietly lost in a world of herself. She stopped
taking interest in anything around her; her normally
favourite duties like cooking and housekeeping were
gradually forgotten. Soon, she was totally disconnected
from the daily activities including her own personal
routine.
61
only a few words at a time. I think meeting with them
was the final occasion when she truly recognized
someone and could engage in some kind of meaningful
communication. Amma’s elder brother also came to
visit her after few months. However, she could not
recognize him at all.
62
Her mind is no more with her
63
she could not hold herself up and could not stand even
with support from others. She was quickly moving
towards being totally bedridden. I had already learnt
that such disabilities are symptoms of patient entering
the final stages of Alzheimer’s/ Dementia.
65
her with some soothing words; but it was not of much
help. Some medicines were prescribed to help her sleep
better though these were also not of much use.
66
Sundown Syndrome
67
of their memories about the present including day-to-
day happenings as well as people who are around them.
Over a period of time, most of the facts and people from
the present as well as the recent past are forgotten. Still
they can retain memories from early days such as
events, surroundings and people from their childhood
to a good level of detail. The main problem with such
memories is that they seem to visualize themselves
living in those days. It appears that they tend to behave
as if they are re-experiencing some part of their
childhood days once again.
68
learning the numbers in their class rooms through
rhyming lessons (such class room sessions are quite
common in our village schools; I can hear the same
rhyming tunes from our neighbourhood primary school
even now). After some time, she would start counting
backwards from 100 to 1 and by the time this exercise
is finished, she would be too tired. Though she was
panting and sweating, she would not stop without
completing the full sequence. She would be so pleased
to complete the exercise which we could feel from her
voice as she completed the counting.
69
World of emptiness
71
quiet. In the previous stage it was quite difficult and
emotionally draining to take care of her when she was
in an agitated and restless state of mind; especially
when she used to make demands for taking her home
since we were helpless with such requests. Now, we
had to only ensure that the daily routine like cleaning
and feeding was done at regular times and there was
nothing much to do in between as she was mostly
silent. She wouldn’t even know if she was hungry. It
was for us to make sure that we fed her at regular
intervals.
72
Caregiver’s mental strain
73
was responsible for the family tensions during that
stage. By the time we all learnt that Amma was an
Alzheimer’s patient, my wife had undergone lots of
suffering and mental agony. This was also the main
reason why I took the decision to quit my job, as
narrated earlier. At least from that time onwards, I
wanted to take over and relieve her from all the trouble
she was having during those three years when I was
away at Riyadh.
74
strain and emotional drain for close relatives, especially
for those who are continuously attending to an
Alzheimer’s’ patient. It is a very tough fate for close
relatives to experience the drastic behavioural changes
of a beloved person. The strange mannerisms,
quarrelsome attitude, restlessness, accusatory approach
etc. can be a mind boggling experience. In the later
stages, as the patient slips into the most tragic state of
losing his / her mind and memory, such an experience
can be very hard to accept. I was no exception and I
was feeling very depressed. During a certain period, I
was even reluctant to meet or interact with people.
Signs of depression were all around me.
75
I have to mention the total support from our domestic
helper and her son. I should not actually use the word
helper; the mother and son were like part of our family
(and that relation still continues). Both were very
dedicated and always willing to help in anything and
everything. The son had been a regular part of our
family even before his mother joined us. He had
become almost like a son to my mother. When she was
alone at Panamanna (during my gulf job), he used to
give her constant support and company. He was also
taking care of the farming activities in our farm land
after my father’s demise. Both of them, as well as their
family members were very helpful to us during the
difficult phases of Amma’s health problem. Our
neighbours were also very supportive wherever
required. This is one great quality of the villagers; they
would be there to help during difficult times, without
any reservation or expectation.
76
difficult times, your close ones are also having their
own problems making the situation still worse and not
being able to help each other as much as they may
wish).
77
Renovating a temple, refreshing a mindset
78
When I was working in the Gulf, she had arranged for
renovation of the “Sopanam” area (the main entrance
with steps) of the “Sreekovil” (the equivalent of
‘sanctum sanctorum’ where the Lord resides) of the
temple. At present, the outer structure of the temple
known as “vilakkumadam” was in a very dilapidated
state and in urgent need of repairs.
80
manner and much better than what we had originally
planned for, we all felt it was God’s blessings that
really made it possible.
81
Back to Coimbatore
The temple work was over and soon after this event I
decided to shift Amma to Coimbatore so that we could
be with my wife and son. My son was getting ready to
prepare for his CA Finals. He had cleared the Inter
exams in first attempt and was about to finish the
mandatory articleship training. I wanted to be near my
son and wife during this important period of his studies.
By now, Amma was oblivious to her surroundings and
whether it was Coimbatore or Panamanna, it made no
difference to her. Since she had become quiet and
passive, we felt we could manage to take care of her in
Coimbatore itself.
82
Days of oblivion
83
took care of such symptoms immediately and never
allowed it to become a real problem.
At this stage, She was mostly quiet and slept / dozed off
for long periods. Still, I would sit with her when she
was awake and talk to her about something, though she
could not understand or respond to whatever was being
told.
84
Flashing memory
85
it was a very rare occasion when she was very clear in
her communication. Of course, it lasted just for that
minute only after which she was silent again.
87
Life is a mixed bag
89
she used to visualize him as the baby from the younger
days. She would ask him to come and sit on her lap as
he used to do when he was a four-year baby. It was
very embarrassing for our son who was 17 / 18 years
old then. It was quite difficult for him to understand
that Amma was in a world of delusion and her vision
was that of a very different period.
90
unfortunate events we had witnessed during the last
decade, I had always managed to retain my composure
without becoming overly emotional. But at that
moment of joy, I broke down with a sudden outburst of
emotions which I could not control anymore. My wife
and son were taken aback and didn’t know what to do
at this. I think it was my wife’s sister who showed some
presence of mind to console me and bring me back to
my senses.
91
Final days
The next two days were very critical. We knew that she
was having difficulty in breathing because of the
phlegm formation. Most of the people close to us from
our native place came to meet her. Our nearby relatives
were also visiting her daily. All of them were of the
opinion that she was too weak and the end was near.
Looking at the symptoms, the elders who had
experience in such matters felt that she might be
waiting for some unfulfilled wish to be completed.
There was a suggestion that since Amma was very fond
of our native place, she might have a subconscious
desire to breathe her last in our village home. There was
a discussion about such happenings in the past where
the end was prolonged and the soul would not leave the
body until such wish was fulfilled.
93
On the morning of September 30th, The Doctor came
again as promised, and by that time, there were sure
signs that the end was near. He confirmed this fact and
at that moment, I raised our thought of shifting her to
our native place if that would mean the fulfilment of the
last wish which she could not pronounce. The doctor
agreed to the suggestion telling us that it was a good
idea; the only thing left for us to do was to fulfil any
such wishes as that could give us some sentimental
satisfaction. A travel at that stage didn’t matter; she was
anyway fast moving towards her last moments.
94
(Amma’s younger brother and wife were in the US
during that time with their children; for him, it was a
great period of distress as he could not be near her
during those final days. He was the main source of
support and comfort to her throughout her life).
95
The last trip
96
We reached Panamanna by around 5.00pm and already
I could sense that her breathing was becoming
shallower as we approached our home. All those people
who were close to us in the village were waiting for our
arrival and they helped in shifting her to her bed. She
was settled down in the bed and everyone went inside
to meet her. She was very calm by now and the only
sign of life was the mild breathing. My sisters, brother-
in-law and niece were attending to Amma as I went out
to settle the payment for the Ambulance. In one or two
minutes, someone shouted from Amma’s bedside
asking me to come inside.
By the time I went in, she was breathing her last. We all
offered her the customary thulasi theertham, Ganga
theertham etc while chanting the names of God. She
was leaving the world of agony and pain to join her
husband and son in their heavenly abode.
97
just a sentimental feeling, but at times we cannot
explain such astounding events.
98
Epilogue
On the 13th day after the demise, when all death related
rituals are over, we have the practice of performing a
“navagraha homam” which is symbolic of resuming
normal life after the tragic event. On that day, after the
poojas were over, our ‘Acharya’ gave a speech
explaining the significance of death related rituals, the
belief related to life after death and how the soul
continues its journey towards its final destination. He
also mentioned how well the children of the deceased
took care of their elderly mother and offered words of
consolation intended to bring us out of the sorrowful
state.
99
attention for such a long period to take care of his
mother”.
$$$$$$$$$
100
Annexure
Patient’s diet
101
In case of terminally ill patients, they may not have any
appetite or hunger and it is quite possible that they may
refuse food at some stage. It could be an indication of
the inevitable and their body may not require food
anymore. It is meaningless to force-feed such patients. I
have seen people doing this just to show that they are
caring for their beloved ones. Many a time, such
patients may be able to consume food only in liquid
form. In such cases, if we force-feed solid food, there is
always a risk of food particles entering the lungs which
could result in serious problems like pneumonia. (In
many cases of terminally ill patients, especially those
suffering from Alzheimer’s / Dementia, the end comes
through the inevitable pneumonia which cannot be
helped anyway).
Body Hygiene
102
leakage can be avoided. Diapers need to be changed
frequently depending on the situation. The body should
be cleaned during each change of diaper. As far as
possible, giving body bath (perhaps only sponge bath /
towel bath may be possible if the patient cannot be
moved at all) at least once in a day is very helpful in
avoiding any skin-related problems such as rashes, bed-
sores etc and to prevent infections. A caregiver should
not hesitate or feel bad about cleaning the private parts
of a patient as these are areas where infections can
create big problems if cleanliness is not maintained. A
bed ridden patient, especially one suffering from
Dementia would not know /cannot do anything about
her own personal hygiene.
103
While visiting bed-ridden patients, I have noticed bad
odour from the patients’ room many a time. This is a
clear indication that body hygiene is not properly
ensured for such patients. It needs dedicated service and
nursing care to avoid such situations. Smell is not only
depressive; it means the patient’s skin may be in
contact with urine / stool which is not properly cleaned.
This could result in skin rashes or bedsores quite easily.
104
bedsores. However, it is always better to seek medical
advice in severe cases.
Also watch out for ANTS! They can create trouble for
bed ridden patients. Ants are attracted to the body smell
and in case of inert patients, the ants seem to know that
there is a chance of food and they can come in big
numbers to attack. The poor patient may not even be
aware of their bites as he/she might have lost the sense
of pain. In Amma’s case, I had faced this problem. It
had happened in a matter of few minutes when I had
gone to the kitchen for cooking some food. When I
came back, her foot was covered with something in
black colour. When I looked closely, it was a big bunch
of ants that were greedily biting on to her skin. I
couldn’t believe how so many of them could reach
there so quickly. By the time I removed them all, the
105
skin was gone for almost two square inches on the foot.
Thereafter, I used to keep water-filled basins under the
four legs of her cot so that ants could not get in.
106
I may not be right from the medical ethics point of view
and some people may argue that they would prefer to
try all medical options to keep their beloved person
alive despite the hopeless health condition. My personal
view is that forced procedures should not be used to
keep the patient alive in such situations. It is a good
idea in the recent legislation to allow a person to record
his wishes and directions as to how he should be treated
in such a situation. Of course, the procedures should be
simple and transparent, while it is also important to
ensure that such procedures are not abused.
107
understand the problem, that itself will help to
minimize the impact. Further, if we can manage to take
care of the patient without being too emotional about
the situation, it could help. I know that is the most
difficult part. It is not easy to see a close person in such
a helpless condition where she is not even remembering
you and is not in a position to do anything by herself. It
is still more frustrating when you know that there is no
cure for the disease.
108
helps as you are not constantly reminded about your
beloved one’s sad plight.
109
If we can avoid being alone, it could help. A pleasant
social lifestyle and close association with people near
and dear to you can do lots of good; at least to slow
down the progression of the disease.
111
everyone and even if I am alone, I shall find peace
within myself. This could help to minimize my
demands thus avoiding the chances of developing an
adamant attitude. Finally, with a positive state of mind,
it may be easier for me to manage the later stages of life
in a graceful manner.
$$$$$$$$$$$
112
Closing note:
E-Mail: suryanpk@gmail.com
113