Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Women's Studies International Forum


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/wsif

Intergenerational encounters in the struggle for abortion rights in Argentina T


Barbara Sutton
University at Albany, SUNY

ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT

Keywords: The year 2018 was a milestone for the abortion rights movement in Argentina. After longstanding activism, a bill
Abortion to decriminalize and legalize abortion was debated in Congress for the first time. Although the bill was ulti-
Activism mately defeated, the parliamentary debate energized a movement determined to overhaul punitive abortion
Age legislation. A notable feature of this growing movement has been the coalescing of different generations of
Argentina
activists. Based on interviews with activists supporting the demand for “legal, safe, and free abortion,” this
Feminism
Generations
article examines intergenerational dynamics, dialogue, and transmission in the abortion rights movement, with
implications for activist discourse and strategy. While work on generations often focuses on conflict and tensions
among activists of different age groups, this article highlights solidarity, convergence, and mutual recognition.
This emphasis not only reflects a particular moment of a movement on the rise, but also serves to ponder key
aspects of movement change and continuity.

The year 2018 was a milestone for the abortion rights movement in whose time has come (Gutiérrez, 2018). These political developments
Argentina. After longstanding activism, a bill to decriminalize and le- also stirred public conversations about abortion like never before,
galize abortion was debated in Congress. While the bill was ultimately bringing into the open this historically silenced issue.
defeated in the Senate—after approval in the Chamber of Deputies—the A notable feature of this growing movement in Argentina has been
parliamentary debate energized a movement determined to overhaul the coalescing of different generations of activists. Established feminists
punitive abortion legislation. Since 1921, the Argentine Penal Code has have been fighting for abortion rights for decades, yet the influx of a
defined abortion as a crime carrying prison penalty, with few excep- young generation of activists and supporters has gained increasing
tions (rape or danger to life or health). Yet abortion criminalization has visibility. Marching, chanting, dancing, and using their painted bodies
not effectively prevented the practice: It has been estimated that ap- as a canvas for protest messages, teenagers and young women were
proximately 372,000–522,000 abortions happen annually in present in the numerous demonstrations and actions during the lead-up
Argentina.1 Illegality pushes those who need an abortion into clan- to the debate in Congress. Members of this activist generation also
destinity, exposing them to preventable morbidity and mortality risks, protested in their schools, appeared in the media, and spoke in front of
and reinforcing stigmatization.2 Even non-punishable abortions have legislators (Alcaraz, 2018; Elizalde & Mateo, 2018). This participation
been difficult to access due to uneven regulations and implementation, offers hope for the renewal and vitality of the abortion rights move-
unnecessary judicialization of cases, conscientious objection by health ment, and feminism more generally.
practitioners, restrictive interpretations of the law, and other obstacles As different generations meet and interact, potential for both ten-
(ANDHES et al., 2018; Ramos, Romero, & Ramón Michel, 2014).3 In sion and cooperation emerges. This raises questions regarding the di-
this context, abortion rights activists have creatively and persistently rection of the abortion rights movement as well as the broader dy-
advanced the cause of abortion decriminalization and legalization. In namics of feminist transmission. While work on generations often
recent years these efforts showed tangible results both in the form of a focuses on conflict, disidentification, and tensions among activists of
historic parliamentary debate and in the massiveness of a movement different generations, this article highlights solidarity, convergence,

E-mail address: bsutton@albany.edu.


1
These are estimates based on a study by Mario and Pantelides (2009). Due to the illegality of the practice, the numbers provided can only be approximations to the
actual incidence of abortion. Furthermore, estimates have not been regularly updated.
2
See e. g. Chaneton and Vacarezza (2011), Sutton (2014), ANDHES (2018). For a more global perspective on trends and consequences of illegal and/or unsafe
abortion see Guillaume and Rossier (2018).
3
Groups such as Lesbians and Feminist for the Decriminalization of Abortion (LyFDA) and the Network of Socorristas (first responders) have helped ameliorate the
risks of clandestine abortions by providing information and support on how to safely have an abortion with the pharmaceutical misoprostol (See McReynolds-Pérez,
2017; Burton, 2017).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wsif.2020.102392
Received 6 September 2019; Received in revised form 17 April 2020; Accepted 3 July 2020
Available online 15 July 2020
0277-5395/ © 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

and mutual recognition. This does not mean an absence of disagree- Drawing on the social movement literature, Elizabeth Borland
ment, but that at particular historical moments—when the force of a (2014: 85) outlines the connection between age, generation, and co-
movement is widely felt after years of patient political con- hort: “Both generational units and cohorts are determined by a similar
struction—narratives about coming together may become particularly time of entry into the social life of a group; this is often shaped prin-
salient. In this context, I ask: What are the contributions of long-term cipally by chronological age, but it is important to recognize it is not
and newer participants to the abortion rights movement? What lessons always the case.” In terms of social movement entry, some activists who
can we learn from the vibrant exchanges between activists of different are relatively young may have more years of activist experience than
ages and levels of experience? “late bloomers,” older participants who joined the movement later in
Based on interviews with activists variously associated with the life (Tripp & Gage, 2018). Still, age/generation/cohort can be relevant
struggle for “legal, safe, and free abortion” in Argentina, this article for understanding factors in activists' perspectives and movement par-
addresses intergenerational dynamics and dialogue in the abortion ticipation, such as personal exposure to particular historical events and
rights movement, with implications for activist discourse and strategy. political debates, or the specific stakes for different generations of
These debates and actions in Argentina hold regional significance in certain political issues (Fine, 2006; Whittier, 1995; Winch, 2014).
Latin America, and can be of interest to other places, such as the United As in other movements, generational attitudes can be a source of
States, where abortion is legal but increasingly under fire. conflict and disagreement within feminism. This is also shaped by in-
tersecting social statuses such as race-ethnicity, class, gender, sexual
1. Interactions between feminist generations orientation, religion, and other vectors of difference and inequality.
Scholars writing about feminism in different countries—including
Generational belonging matters to social movement participation, United States, Australia, and Great Britain—have considered genera-
including women's and feminist movements. It is an important, though tional tensions; for example, Third wave feminists' disidentification
imperfect, indicator of the goals, concerns, tactics, and challenges of from and critique of Second wave feminists (Bulbeck, 2010; Henry,
different groups of activists (Whittier, 1995, 1997). Narratives about 2004) or “inverted disidentification” dynamics by which older activists
feminist history or the current state of feminism often include implicit differentiate themselves from younger ones, as in the case of a Slut
or explicit references to different generations, for example, to address Walk protest in the United States (Reger, 2015: 93). In a study of
differences in interests and modes of political engagement across time. “Women of a Certain Age” (Foster, 2015), veteran feminists of the
This is not surprising given that attention to generations helps chart Second wave in the United States, lamented “a rise of individualism
movement continuity and change, as new generations build on the among younger generations, as well as the lost feeling of energy, pro-
contributions of their predecessors, reject or modify some of their mise and solidarity that came with mass mobilization” (74). Alison
premises, and introduce novelty to feminist organizing. Winch (2014) refers to generational divisions among women in the
Discussions of feminist generations also intersect with popular and context of economic inequalities fostered by neoliberalism in the United
scholarly references to different “waves” of activism (First wave, Kingdom, and Cullen and Fischer (2014) speak of generational dissen-
Second wave, Third wave, and more recently, Fourth wave feminism).4 sion among Second, Third, and Fourth wave activists in Ireland. Em-
Although the waves metaphor has been widely used, including in dif- phasis on generational conflict—often magnified in the media—is il-
ferent countries, it has also been disputed. For instance, in No Perma- lustrated by Chilla Bulbeck's (2010: 23) comment: “It appears that each
nent Waves, Nancy Hewitt (2010) summarizes some of the problems generation of feminist daughters finds it necessary to commit matricide
with the waves' characterization of feminism in the United States, such to make space for their version of gender relations and political acti-
as the waves model's inability to adequately capture the heterogeneity vism.”
of movement participants and struggles, the exclusion of important In her study of age dynamics among feminists in Argentina,
movement experiences that fall in between “wave” years, and the Elizabeth Borland (2014) describes shifts over time in activist narra-
tendency for members of each new wave to see themselves as im- tives, from those highlighting concern about young women's low par-
proving and superseding the previous ones, while also enacting erasures ticipation in the movement in the late 1990s, to those emphasizing
of sorts. Becky Thompson (2002) critiques the way in which particular “distance and conflict” among activists of different generations around
women's experiences (e.g. white women's) have been taken as main 2002–2003, to those alluding to “respect and recognition” around
points of reference in typical chronologies of the Second wave. This 2011, in the context of a growing movement for abortion rights (85).
periodization, Thompson shows, looks different when centering the Sources of generational tension included those related to power dis-
experiences of multiracial feminists. Kimberly Springer (2002: 1063) parities in the movement, differences over whether men should be
concludes that the “wave model perpetuates the exclusion of women of welcomed in feminist events or not, conflict about language and activist
color from women's movement history and feminist theorizing. Still, as strategies, and older feminists questioning whether young feminists
it is so deeply embedded in how we examine the history and future of were willing to “learn from their collective past” or “wanted to reinvent
the women's movement, it remains useful for internal critique.” While a the wheel” (96). Interestingly, and moving in the direction of the
contested framework, references to feminist waves continue to be used findings in this article, in the later years of Borland's analysis, inter-
as a shorthand to differentiate generations of activists and in relation to generational mutual recognition becomes more prominent.
conflicts, commonalities, and continuities among feminists of different Writing about “Feminism, Generation, and Intersectionality,” Alison
age groups, cohorts, and generations (Aikau, Erickson, & Pierce, 2007; Winch (2014: 8) notes: “Generational differences within feminism are
Dicker & Piepmeier, 2003). also opportunities for dialogue.” Even when these differences translate
into conflict, feminist scholar Sarah Maddison points out that conflict is
not necessarily negative, but is “a form of engagement” that can enable
4
Common descriptions of feminist “waves”—for example, in the United learning from each other (Madisson and Grey 2010, 488). Depending
States—roughly locate the First wave in the mid-19th to early 20th century on how differences are navigated, they can also be opportunities for
period; the feminist rising of the 1960s and 1970s is often referred to as the
garnering the knowledge, talents, and perspectives of diverse groups of
Second wave; and the interventions of young feminists in the 1990s became the
people in a movement. Sometimes differences can be the impetus for
Third wave. In the new millennium, the feminism associated with the digital
age is sometimes described as constituting a Fourth wave. The “waves” char- cooperation, particularly when movement members perceive that they
acterization and periodization, however, have been subject of considerable need each other, that concerted action by a diversity of constituents can
debate and critique. While I refer to this literature because it relates to dis- move their cause forward. Otherwise, and in the words of Luisa, a
cussions of age and generation, I do not use “waves” categories to analyze the young feminist activist in Argentina, “How are we going to be one
abortion rights movement in Argentina. million in the streets?” In this vein, this study examines instances of

2
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

intergenerational recognition, cooperation, and solidarity—including One central development for the abortion rights movement in
the contributions of each group—illuminating a critical dimension of Argentina was the launching of the National Campaign for the Right to
abortion rights activism. Legal, Safe, and Free Abortion (hereafter, the Campaign) in 2005
(Zurbriggen & Anzorena, 2013).5 The Campaign grew over the years,
2. Abortion rights activism in Argentina gaining the support of around 500 organizations by 2018. A key aspect
of the campaign is its “federal” character, which means that it has re-
In order to understand the dynamics and impact of the con- presentation across the country's territory. It also spurred myriad in-
temporary abortion rights movement in Argentina, it is important to itiatives to advance abortion rights in various provinces, and has helped
consider the historical influences, ideological strands, and political mobilize activists and supporters of different ages and levels of ex-
events that shaped its development. While this activism finds ante- perience in feminist organizing. While there are core points that the
cedents in the feminist organizing of 1970s, it had to wait until the end different organizations adhere to (i.e. the demand for abortion decri-
of the last military dictatorship (1976–1983) to more fully develop in minalization and legalization), a multiplicity of strategies and dis-
the following decades. One of the prominent spaces for debate and courses have flourished under the broad umbrella of the Campaign. The
organizing after the return of democracy has been the annual National product of sustained and strategic organizing, this coalition includes
Women's Encuentros (Meetings). This massive gathering of women members of feminist and women's movement groups as well as human
started in 1986, growing in numbers of participants as time passed. In rights, labor, student, LGBT, and cultural and professional organiza-
the Encuentros, women from all walks of life discuss a wide array of tions, among many others.6 The Campaign presented to Congress its
topics of personal and political concern (Alma & Lorenzo, 2009). Re- own abortion legalization bill several times since 2007, having to lobby
productive rights, and abortion in particular, received increasing at- legislators to obtain their signatures and support so that the bill could
tention over the years of Encuentros, particularly since the mid-1990s, move through committee and be discussed. When Congress finally de-
helping generate multiple frames for abortion decriminalization and bated the issue in 2018 it was a cause for celebration. The Campaign
legalization (Sutton & Borland, 2013). Regional-level gather- also made inroads with the broader society, and the triangular green
ings—particularly the Latin American and Caribbean Feminist En- kerchief populated the streets, subways, plazas, universities, govern-
cuentros—also provided impetus to the cause, for instance, through the ment buildings, and other public spaces.
designation of September 28 as the day for the decriminalization of In addition to efforts to change the law, the abortion rights move-
abortion in the region and the organizing that happens around this ment also includes activists who have addressed the concrete aspects of
activist date (Bellucci & Mitidieri, 2017; Sternbach, Navarro- the practice of abortion—either by helping ensure safe abortions and/or
Aranguren, Chuchryk, & Alvarez, 1992). by offering reproductive and sexual health education and advocacy.
For a long time, abortion was not only considered taboo, but poli- The group Lesbians and Feminists for the Decriminalization of Abortion
tically dismissed as the concern of a reduced number of feminists. This opened a hotline in 2009 providing information on abortion procedures
started to change after 2001 during a severe economic and political using the pharmaceutical misoprostol (McReynolds-Pérez, 2017).
crisis that catalyzed widespread mobilization, including by members of Members of the Network of Socorristas (first responders), formed in
popular assemblies, poor and unemployed workers' movements, worker 2012, have been accompanying and supporting people in need of an
cooperatives, and many others. Women—and among them femin- abortion (Burton, 2017). Health professionals friendly to the movement
ists—were active participants in this activist rising, and abortion was have also organized themselves since 2014 in the Network of Profes-
increasingly included in the discussions and demands of a broader set of sionals for the Right to Decide, providing assistance with abortions
movements (Di Marco, 2011). During the first years of the new mil- permitted by the law (Red de Profesionales, n.d.).
lennium abortion rights organizing started to gain strength. The 2003 Activists in Argentina have advocated for abortion legalization
National Women's Encuentro in Rosario was a watershed moment, as using a multiplicity of discursive frames. They have made claims based
activists created discussion spaces specifically dedicated to strategies to on public health and human rights, bodily rights and personal au-
decriminalize and legalize abortion. A multitude of women also dis- tonomy, social and economic justice, the defense of women's lives, and
played their support for abortion rights by donning what would become as a pragmatic response to the inefficacy of the abortion ban, among
the symbol of the movement: a triangular green kerchief. Interestingly, others.7 They also hold the state responsible for the preventable deaths
this symbol is reminiscent of a white kerchief worn by a group of mo- of women as a result of botched abortions, making important connec-
thers of people “disappeared” by the dictatorship—known as Mothers tions to a visible movement to end violence against women, under the
of the Plaza de Mayo. The Mothers are notable in a lineage of women's rallying call Ni Una Menos (Not One Less) since 2015 (Cavallero, Gago,
activism as well as in the human rights movement in Argentina. Ad- Varela, Barón, & Mitidieri, 2018). The abortion rights movement also
ditionally, in recent years Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo leaders showed has some overlaps with the LGBT movement, including longtime acti-
their support for abortion rights. Connections between these move- vists and organizations that have questioned gender binaries and het-
ments are visually represented in generational terms in a widely cir- eronormativity, and advocated for the rights of people with diverse
culated drawing by artist Mariana Baizán, which depicts a Mother of gender identities and sexual orientations. In this vein, the Campaign has
the Plaza the Mayo—the emblematic white kerchief partially covering revised ingrained assumptions about who is the subject of abortion,
the woman's grey hair—sitting alongside a younger woman who wears increasingly adopting language that includes not only (cis heterosexual)
the abortion rights green kerchief around her neck (Mariana Dibuja/ women, but anybody with the “capacity to gestate,” such as trans men,
Página, 2019). queer, non-binary, and gender non-conforming individuals.8 The
A foremost feminist cause, the demand for abortion decriminaliza-
tion and legalization in Argentina has been nourished by multiple
5
streams of feminist, leftist, LGBT, and human rights activism and dis- “Free” here is the translation of gratuito or free of charge.
6
course (Bellucci, 1997; Tarducci, 2018). While feminist organizing, The Campaign is not directed by a particular organization, but aims at a
horizontal way of organizing, with key decisions made in plenary meetings of
including for abortion rights, is propelled by activists of different gen-
activists from various organizations or independently participating in the
erations, it is in the current context that young activists joined the
Campaign. A rotating “Articulation Committee” composed of activists re-
movement in more substantial numbers (Elizalde & Mateo, 2018; Seca, presenting different constituencies and places, implements the general in-
2019). Feminist pioneers and other long-term activists have paved the itiatives and decisions of the Campaign.
way for abortion rights mobilization, and young activists have “made 7
For an analysis of different frames' prevalence, content, and significance, see
this cause their own,” playing an important role in the contemporary Sutton and Borland (2013), Sutton and Borland (2019).
movement (Tarducci, 2018: 431). 8
By 2019, the Campaign's abortion legalization bill reflected a growing

3
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

Campaign's abortion legalization claims are inscribed within the activism, law projects, artistic interventions, education initiatives,
broader field of sexual and reproductive politics, under the motto “Sex parliamentary lobbying, media appearances, and mass mobiliza-
Education for Choice, Contraception to Prevent Abortion, Legal Abor- tions—activists have also raised the consciousness of politicians and
tion to Prevent Death” (Educación Sexual Para Decidir, Anticonceptivos civil society about abortion as a matter of public concern. A taboo topic
Para No Abortar, Aborto Legal Para No Morir).9 for decades, abortion came out in the open at unprecedented levels.
The movement grew quantitatively and transformed qualitatively,
and this was evident not only in the massive presence of activists and
supporters in the streets, but also in the variety of new groups that 3. Research during extraordinary times
emerged or that declared themselves in support of abortion rights.
Among the notable features of the 2018 abortion rights mobilization In 2018, I arrived in Argentina at the height of abortion rights
were the following: (1) the festive atmosphere and proliferation of mobilization. A bill to legalize abortion had just been approved in the
performances that characterized many public gatherings and demon- Chamber of Deputies and was slated to be debated in the Senate. In this
strations, (2) the ways in which the cause was taken up not only by context, I was able to join the mobilization as well as conduct inter-
obviously political organizations, but also adopted by diverse in- views with activists supporting abortion legalization. These included
dividuals and other groups such as collectives of poets, actresses, visual some core Campaign organizers as well as more loosely connected ac-
artists, and acrobats, (3) the convergence of activists of different gen- tivists who contributed to the movement in a variety of ways, from
erations, with a notable influx of young activists joining more estab- documentation of events, to artistic production, coalitional efforts, and
lished feminists, and (4) the increased presence of the legal abortion organization of activities to raise awareness of the ubiquity and per-
demand in the digital space, particularly social media (Laudano, 2018). sonal dimensions of abortion. At the time of my research, the impact of
During the vigils that preceded the approval of an abortion legalization the movement could be felt in everyday life. People wore the green
bill in the Chamber of Deputies (June 13–14, 2018), and the Senate's kerchief while riding public transportation; traces of the movement
rejection of the proposed legislation (August 8–9, 2018), demonstrators could be seen in the streets in the form of banners or graffiti; and ac-
flooded the streets in massive numbers despite inclement weather. tivists appeared in talk shows and news programs on TV and the radio.
Activists from all walks of life and from different ages and generations The topic erupted in conversations with family and friends; and edu-
came together to support this cause like never before. cational, artistic, and protest events proliferated at an increased pace.
Even though the movement is not devoid of tension over strategy, This article is primarily based on 22 interviews conducted in the
discourse, political party lines, and other social, regional, and political second half of 2018, which built on and updated research I conducted
cleavages, it appears that the Campaign's strategy of creating a space in 2014, including 19 interviews with Campaign activists.10 While the
that can hold many groups and types of activism has enabled movement first round of interviews is not incorporated in this article's analysis, my
growth. When conflicts have arisen, activists have reminded themselves previous research affected this study in two ways: (1) It shaped my
to go back to the agreements that hold the coalition together, as em- knowledge and interpretation of abortion rights activism in Argentina,
bodied by the Campaign motto. The “big tent” strategy of the Campaign and the Campaign specifically, and (2) It influenced who I interviewed
perhaps also facilitated intergenerational organizing and coexistence, in 2018, as I aimed to hear new voices and avoided going back to the
as different groups preserve their identity and autonomy while also same activists (though I did have informal conversations with some
coalescing around the main claim for abortion rights. While at first former interviewees, particularly longtime activists).11 I contacted ac-
sight abortion decriminalization and legalization may seem a relatively tivists who were in leadership positions as well as others I met in
narrow focus, it is partly what allows members of diverse groups to movement events or were referred to me by interviewees or other
coalesce (Sutton & Borland, 2019). At the same time, the abortion rights feminists.12 I aimed to talk with activists with diverse perspectives and
cause is connected to a much broader set of claims and analyses related experiences, with different kinds and levels of involvement in the
to sexual/gender oppression and social justice. These linkages have movement. Interviews were conducted in Spanish, following a semi-
been articulated not only by long-term activists, but also by a new structured format based on a questionnaire about movement partici-
generation that came of age with certain achievements by the women's, pation discourse, strategy, obstacles, and successes. Among other things
feminist, and LGBT movements already in place. we discussed issues pertaining to the involvement of different genera-
The current context includes a variety of progressive policies sup- tions of activists, which became an important locus of analysis.13
porting sexual and gender rights, which were the focus of previous During this and previous periods in Argentina, I also gathered activist
activist efforts. When it comes to abortion rights advocacy and access, documents and attended movement public events (e.g. street demon-
some key developments include not only the launching of the Campaign strations, festivals, performances, exhibits, panels), which helped me
in 2005 but also the popularization of misoprostol as a method for self- contextualize interview data and provided a broader sense of the
induced abortions, a Supreme Court decision in 2012 clarifying the
interpretation on non-punishable abortions, the creation of public 10
Key findings from this research are presented in Sutton and Borland (2018,
health protocols and Consejerías (Counseling) pre and post abortion, 2019).
and legislation pertinent to closely-aligned or overlapping movements 11
Of the people I interviewed for the present study, six activists were in their
(e.g. on violence against women and LGBT rights). Activists have also 20s, eight were in their 30s, three were in their 40s, three in their 50s, and two
led social media initiatives with trending topics on abortion rights in their 60s. In my previous study, I had fewer interviewees in their 20s and
claims, and have established connections at the regional and more more in their 60s and 70s.
global levels. Through different strategies—advocacy, litigation, digital 12
Most interviewees have been activists who reside in Buenos Aires, in-
cluding the capital and its metropolitan area, which on the one hand is the most
populous region and the site of the national government, but on the other hand,
this means more limited information on experiences in very different parts of
(footnote continued) the country.
13
recognition of multiple subjects of abortion rights (See Campaña, 2019). For an Interviews were transcribed and analyzed with a focus on emergent pat-
analysis of the process and tensions surrounding this topic, see Sutton and terns and themes. For the purpose of this article, passages addressing genera-
Borland (2018). For a critique of arguments that center (cis) women and do not tional dynamics and references to different age groups were identified, in-
sufficiently include trans identities, see Pérez and Radi (2018). See also Alcaraz ductively coded, and interpreted by me, relating them to the context of
(2018) for a discussion of trans issues in relation to abortion. movement events I witnessed or participated in, knowledge gained from my
9
Among other things, this motto is inscribed in the green kerchief that has previous studies, and the relevant literature. In order to keep confidentiality,
become the symbol of the abortion rights movement in Argentina. the names of interviewees were changed to pseudonyms.

4
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

“pulse” of the movement. activists who are relatively new to the abortion rights movement. Still,
My participation in activist events blurs the lines between the aca- age is important in terms of the memory and experience of specific
demic and the political. At times this participation blends research in- political events in the country's history (e.g. the dictatorship, feminist
terests, emotional attachments, activist camaraderie, bonds of friend- activism during the democratic transition, the first National Women's
ship, and personal investment in feminist struggles. I am originally from Encuentros, the economic and political crisis of 2001, and so forth).
Argentina, and maintain significant ties to the country, but as an aca- With regards to abortion, age also affects whether the need for an
demic based in the United States, my political participation in abortion might be a possibility in a specific person's life. That is, for
Argentina is more limited. Nevertheless, my presence for extended some activists the legal status and accessibility of abortion can affect
periods over the years, and my ongoing contact with people in the them more directly than others based on reproductive age.
country, has kept me connected. I participated in many activist in- The interviews with activists of different ages and levels of in-
itiatives in Argentina during almost two decades, and this feminist volvement in abortion rights activism reveal how they were thinking
rising was one I did not want to miss. Among the significant activist about generational contributions to the movement, the politics of coa-
spaces in which I participated in 2018 was the demonstration and vigil lition-building, and the dynamics of feminist knowledge transmission.
surrounding the Senate debate of the abortion legalization bill (August Activists interviewed in 2018 highlighted cooperation, multidirectional
8–9). I had the opportunity to experience this massive and historic learning, and an ethics of care and mutual recognition. This partly
event, and in fact, I unexpectedly became a featured speaker in one of mirrors the popularization of the term sororidad, a concept often heard
the Campaign's panels. This illustrates my positionality as a researcher in feminist activist circles and demonstrations during 2018, and which
who is not a detached observer but whose knowledge has been enriched denotes solidarity among women.14 Sororidad conveys women's poli-
through participation in and desire to contribute to feminist causes. tical ability to stand up for each other, to have each other's back, and to
The political and personal investments I have outlined also marked work across differences toward a common vision. Luisa applied the idea
my scholarly choices and analyses, as I was deeply moved by the re- of sororidad to how women of different ages have come together. Sonia
markable events I was witnessing. This also prompted me to pay at- also explained, “We are many generations that are part of the Cam-
tention to how activists were coming together, including inter- paign. There are compañeras [sister activists] who are very, very senior
generationally. While in previous work I have looked more closely at and there are compañeras who are very, very young, and then there are
instances of tension among movement participants, my interest in ex- those of us in the middle, let's say, right? So they all have a space within
ploring convergence and cooperation partly reflects this extraordinary the Campaign.”
moment. How did activists interpret these developments, and how does this
intergenerational work matter to abortion rights activism and politics?
4. Generations in context: interactions and contributions The following sections focus first on the groups that have received more
attention—the “históricas” and the “pibas”—and then highlights the
Relations between generations of feminist activists have not been ones “in the middle.” In the discussion about each group, I incorporate
devoid of tension, and as Borland (2014: 91) points out, in earlier not only what members of the group say about their own generation but
periods the “Specter of Extinction” due to insufficient youth participa- also what they say about each other in relation to abortion rights ac-
tion hovered over the feminist movement. Abortion rights activism in tivism and feminism more generally. At stake is the ability of activists to
this new context conveys a different story. First, the visible participa- create a broad-based movement that transcends age boundaries and
tion of young feminists in large numbers put to rest the concerns about that is able to successfully push for social change.
movement renewal and continuity. Second, in various events, and as
recounted in interviews with activists, different generations of activists 5. Históricas, pibas, and activists in the middle
were interacting, supporting each other, exchanging different types of
knowledge and sensibilities, and generally coalescing to advance the 5.1. Históricas
cause of abortion decriminalization and legalization. Borland's study of
feminist generations in Argentina shows growing instances of recogni- Becoming unlikely “rock stars” in 2018, members of this group—-
tion and expressions of respect toward older activists in the later years particularly the most elderly activists—have been acclaimed in rallies,
of her study (around 2011), and as we shall see, this theme is further given the media spotlight, and mentioned in Congressional speeches.
confirmed in the context of the 2018 dynamics. These women, sometimes also referred to as “pioneers,” are seeing
Much of the recent attention to generations in Argentina, particu- decades of feminist efforts finally coming to fruition. Three key themes
larly in journalistic accounts and public debate, highlights two groups: emerge in activist narratives with respect to this group: persistence,
(1) The históricas – women with a long-term history of participation in recognition, and transmission. Each of this may have personal re-
abortion rights activism and in feminism more generally, including percussions for individual activists but also hold broader political sig-
women around 60 to 80 plus years old, and (2) The pibas – girls and nificance.
young women, particularly activists in their teens, but also in their early
20s. There is also the group of activists that falls somewhere in the
5.1.1. Persistence
middle and who approximate one or the other group in terms of age, but
The ability to persevere is a necessary quality for political struggle,
have received less rhetorical attention in the public discussion of gen-
as success is usually not immediate and staying for the long haul might
erations, despite being a central part of the movement. These groups
be required (Downton & Wehr, 1998; Sutton, 2018). This has certainly
should not be understood as rigidly demarcated or homogeneous, and
been the case for abortion rights activism in Argentina. As Celia
future studies might fine tune some of the specificities within each
(64 years-old) pointed out, the abortion rights struggle requires “pa-
grouping, including generational differences within the broad cate-
tience, because it takes many years” to make progress on a cause that
gorization.
defies ingrained political and cultural power structures. Activists have
While age proximity helps place activists in different groups, age
recalled how few they were in early events, how they had to present the
categories do not fully do justice to the experience and trajectory of
Campaign bill multiple times before it was finally debated, the efforts to
specific activists. Thus the general categories delineated blur on the
edges, with some activists being closer to one or another group based on
their movement participation history. There are relatively young acti- 14
For and extended explanation of the concept, see Lagarde y de los Rios
vists with many years of activism under their belts, and who partici- (2009). In Argentina, this concept even made it to mainstream media, con-
pated in milestone events related to abortion rights, and some older sidered the “word of the year” (Himitian & Vallejos, 2018).

5
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

build coalitions, or the times of gathering signatures at a little table set through the incorporation of youth in large numbers:
up in a sidewalk. For many históricas, the struggle for abortion rights
And I believe that at some point they were somewhat reticent to
long preceded the Campaign, and they carry the memory of the wider
[movement] massiveness, because of how … of how it was … it was
feminist movement.
always their struggle. And they were afraid of being coopted, etc.
The históricas' persistence and tenacious organizing, including by
And then there was a point when they became fascinated, and now
women who are now in their 70s and 80s, is noticed by the younger
they are amazed about the pibas and adolescence, and there are
cohorts, as exemplified by Eva, an activist in her late 20s:
beautiful situations of a lot of admiration from the pibas.
For me there is like … a whole generation of senior women who are
This passage points to potential tensions related to generational
[…] the ones who founded the Campaign and are pushing these
transformations in the movement—as increased numbers of young
things forward. For a long time, with a lot … a lot of willpower
people might also entail changes in activism, which might or might not
especially. Without resources, without the support of great leaders.
be welcomed by older participants—and yet it ultimately underscores
Through sheer grit [todo a pulmón]. And they get to old age seeing
the rewards accrued both in terms of the recognition of the older ac-
that what they did, triumphed, was successful. That they won the
tivists' trajectories and the positive encounters between generations.
battle … I mean, it really makes me happy that that happened to
them.
5.1.3. Transmission
Interestingly, while at the time of the interview the fate of the While new generations might bring transformation (Whittier,
abortion legalization bill was uncertain, this passage expresses a shared 1997), intergenerational transmission can contribute to movement
sense in the movement that a measure of success had been achieved continuity. It allows to learn from past strategies and to move into the
through what activists called “the social decriminalization of abortion.” future with a sense of legacy. Older activists have an important role to
That is, though abortion was still largely performed in clandestinity and play in this regard, as they are in a position of passing on feminist
banned by law, the topic of abortion was now out in the open, in public memory and knowledge. Paola reflected on the perspective that inter-
conversation. Increasing numbers of people were willing to defy its generational exchanges allow:
stigmatization by wearing the green kerchiefs both during protests and
The viejas [elderly women] in the campaign, as we say, are women
everyday activities; and public opinion polls also showed majority
who have a lot of experience, and they tell you […] that they were
support for decriminalization (Vazquez Laba, Palumbo, & Puglia, 2018;
fighting for abortion when nobody was even talking about it. Thus,
Paladini, 2018). The massiveness of the movement and the support it
they can transmit a very interesting experience […] And that is
enjoyed by many sectors of society—universities, professional organi-
amazing. To be able to understand the struggle as a process is
zations, activist groups, artist collectives, journalists—added to a
something that never happens to us in history, because we never
phrase that was heard often during the time of the congressional de-
recognize what happened before. We always feel that we have ar-
bates: “We have already won” (nosotras ya ganamos). This was a tribute
rived, that we are discovering gunpowder […] And if one had the
to the perseverance of the historic activists.
ability to always recover history then we would not make many
mistakes. What is happening in terms of intergenerationality is very
5.1.2. Recognition
interesting in that sense.
After a long period of activism, the históricas not only started to see
their efforts paying off, but also became more recognized. Rita, who is Here the possibility of transmission goes together with recognition
younger than some iconic históricas, still had decades of participation and a willingness to learn from those who pioneered current political
in feminist activism and was placed in close proximity to this group. causes. Activists from younger generations identified the importance of
She expressed a sense of awe at the leaps of the movement as well as at the históricas in carving out and solidifying the arguments and princi-
the recognition that activists like herself were getting. She recounted ples that sustain the contemporary struggle for abortion rights. Engaged
her surprise when she discovered a media article referencing her as a in many forms of feminist transmission, the históricas are living re-
pioneer: “That struck me a lot, for example. That struck me. When I saw positories of feminist knowledge: they have the memory of critical
myself in that article, I said, ‘Ah [sound of amazement]. It is true.’” events in the history of the movement and the country, they possess
Implicit in the statement is a kind of disbelief that others would re- theoretical and practical understanding of the issues surrounding
cognize her contributions, only to reassure herself that in fact, “It is abortion politics, and through their participation in the Campaign they
true,” she indeed participated in the early efforts of the movement. She experimented with different ways of conceiving and engaging in poli-
remembered the times when merely 2 or 3 activists were disseminating tics. Celia, a longtime activist, clarified that they do not hold a mono-
information in a public space in her province. This is quite a contrast poly on feminist knowledge (She said: “there are young people who
with the massive numbers of people gathering in 2018 in plazas, next to know a lot more than I do in many fields”). However, from her per-
government buildings, or marching in the streets in support of abortion spective, a central task of the older generations is to emphasize over
rights. The históricas—along with many “in the middle”—have this and over that this struggle “has a long history.” Celia related that
long-term perspective about the growth of the movement. perhaps one motivation for this reminder is the históricas' concern to
Paola, an activist in the intermediate group, also reflected on the “not be erased with one stroke.” While this comment appears to be
movement's rise, the overdue recognition of the históricas, and inter- about recognition, Celia showed that it is more than that, elaborating
generational mutuality. She recalled how the day of the abortion le- on concrete lessons from past political experiences that need to be taken
galization vote in the lower house, one of the históricas was recognized into account in the present. Juliana, an activist “in the middle,” high-
by the pibas in the midst of the multitude: This older activist “had gone lighted the transmission work of the históricas: “Many of them today
to rest at night, and the teenagers recognized her, and they created a walk side by side with all the other generations that assume this
path for ... because it was impossible to walk due to the amount of struggle as their own—they are the ones who opened the way. They are
people there were there. They created a path for her to reach the the ones who nourish us, teach us, allow us to give an enormous depth
banner, people who do not know her on a daily basis, and yet recognize to each of the discussions and thus build the solid arguments that we
her ... that they are there because she fought at some point.” Paola's have today to demand this right to legal abortion.”
narrative highlights the recognition of the older generation's legacy, but The role of “teachers”—not only ascribed to the históricas but also
for this to happen, the young ones also had to find a space in the to the generation “in the middle”—is important for intergenerational
movement. Paola perceived an initial ambivalence from older activists transmission. The transmission of knowledge happens sometimes in-
about the expansion of the movement, which was partly achieved formally, but also in more structured spaces, such as public lectures or

6
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

cátedras libres, classes open to the public in universities. Emma, a young more gender inclusive in ways that may come less easily to those from
college student, expressed gratitude to older activists in reference to older generations. Language transformation was an important area
this learning process: contestation in the activism and public discussions unfolding in 2018. A
key innovation involved the incorporation of the letter “e” to break
The compañeras help us a whole lot. They teach us a lot of things
femininity/masculinity binaries signified by the letters “a” and “o” in
that maybe due to impulsiveness, wanting action, we overlooked.
many gendered words in Spanish. The use of the masculine “o” as a
And well, there are also the compañeras of the Campaign who have
universal, to encompass feminine and masculine subjects, has been
been there many more years ago, who were our educators […] We
challenged for years. Yet recently there has been increasing recognition
not only carry their struggle with them […]. But they also remain
of how non-binary, trans, and gender non-conforming identities con-
teachers and we replicate their learnings. We also found it very
tinue to be invisibilized. Hence, the letter “e” to modify words that are
gratifying to have them there so they can give us a lot of light and
gendered masculine or feminine.
teach us a whole lot.
Within the abortion rights movement, changes in gender-related
Transmission of knowledge and strategy does not only operate in a language and discourse have manifested in activists' speech—for ex-
one-way direction—from older to younger activists—but is part of a ample, using the gender-inclusive “e” in public appearances—as well as
dynamic dialogue and exchange between generations. Young activists in the process of revision of the Campaign's bill, with references to not
learn “a whole lot” from older ones, but also challenge more experi- only “women,” but also to anyone with “the capacity to gestate” no
enced activists to change and adopt new ways of understanding the matter the gender/sexual identity. According to Emilia, a 21-years-old
issues and performing their activism. activist who strongly supports these transformations, “to change lan-
guage is to broaden ideas […] to include those who do not feel part of a
5.2. Pibas binary logic. And we need new constructions of sexual freedom, that is
not stigmatized, that is not constrained.” She adds that language
“Pibas” is a slang term used in Argentina in reference to girls and changes such as the use of the “e” are also a form of “pedagogical de-
young women; in the abortion rights and feminist movement it is used colonization,” given that some invoke the Spanish Royal Academy's
to refer to the younger female/feminine-identified participants.15 The rejection as a reason to avoid using inclusive language.
pibas have greatly contributed to the growth of the movement. This Manuela, a 59-year-old activist relatively new to the abortion rights
young generation has been in a position to capitalize on decades of movement, reflects on generational differences regarding gender-in-
accumulated feminist discourse and interventions, for example, at the clusive language:
National Women's Encuentros, and around 15 years of the Campaign. But there are things about the lexicon that people of my age have a
This generation may take for granted many of the freedoms of de- harder time with. I find this thing about “chiques” [instead of chicos/
mocracy, and they grew up in the context of progressive legislation chicas – guys/gals] very funny now. And I have fun talking with the
passed in the post-dictatorship period. They have also been exposed to younger girls, I talk to them with … with “e” in everything. “Let's go
the legacy of various movements and activist organizations. Many to the pilete,” [instead of pileta – swimming pool] and we laughed.
young women responded to the call of Ni Una Menos in 2015, parti- There are people who get angry with that lexicon. […] But I think it
cipating in massive demonstrations in repudiation of gender violence, is very funny. It's a fun way to make you think there's another
and feminicide more specifically. possibility. […] Language is alive and changes all the time. It is good
Young activists grew up in a context of evolving public conversa- when that content is incorporated into the social discussion. […]
tions on gender and sexuality that went hand-in-hand with laws passed Someone says “chiques” and someone laughs, someone gets angry,
in the new millennium, for example, on sex education (2006), marriage someone uses it with a sense of approval.
equality (2010), and gender identity (2012). Many in this generation
are demanding, as their right, the effective implementation of the Whereas Manuela seems amused by the new uses of language, she
Comprehensive Sex Education law provisions. This marks a genera- does take the critique seriously and recognizes the value of new ways of
tional difference, with implications for the future, as studies note the naming. As she points out, not everyone—including in the move-
imprint of youth socialization later in life as well as the persistence of ment—is enthusiastic about these changes. Some may also stumble
core activist beliefs (Fine, 2006; Whittier, 1997). Young people today when trying to adapt, or they may offer their own critique. Celia, an
are participating in political discussions that were absent decades ago. experienced feminist activist, supports the use of gender inclusive lan-
Still, the current context is in large part the legacy and result of older guage, but admits: “I can't do it, I can't speak at all with the ‘e.’ I have a
feminist activists' efforts as well as pioneer LGBT activists who have really hard time with it…I agree with it. But I also think that those who
challenged gender and sexual normativity, and who have also con- cannot incorporate it are not necessarily excluding, discriminating. It is
tributed to the contemporary abortion rights movement. Many of those a change; a change in language is an important cultural change and it is
who are growing up in this context are embracing these gains and going to take a long time.” As both Celia and Manuela indicate, lan-
taking them to the next level. With regards to young activists in relation guage and culture are not static, and there can be resistance to mod-
to the abortion rights movement, the following three themes stand out: ification. In the accounts of abortion rights activists, one can see dif-
the call for sexual and gender inclusivity in language, energetic action ferent attitudes toward and levels of fluency in relation to gender
and physical occupation of space, and a festive style of protest. inclusive language. While generational differences are not the only
division lines in this regard, in 2018 it became clear that the difficulties
that Celia alluded to had been overcome by various young activists,
5.2.1. Sexual and gender inclusivity: language transformations including high school students, who fluidly spoke with the “e,” for in-
Language is one key arena of gender and sexuality struggles, which stance, in media appearances.16 One question to further consider is
is also related to attitudes, practices and interactions. Many young ac- whether these language changes have gone hand in hand with sig-
tivists have comfortably pushed the boundaries of language to make it nificant transformations in embodied practices, interactions, and so-
cial/sexual relations.
15
Interviewees in this study generally talked about pibas (or variations of the
term), and sometimes used the more formal and generic terms jóvenes (youth),
16
adolescentes (adolescents) or chicas (girls/young women). On occasion, the word For an example of young activists' use of gender-inclusive language in
pibes was used, which is the masculine universal slang term for children/young media appearances, and a journalistic account about the phenomenon, see
people. Schmidt (2019).

7
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

5.2.2. Energetic action and physical occupation of space 5.2.3. Festive protest
It is not only discursive innovations but also energetic action that The style of participation of activist youth is also helping to trans-
the young activists contribute to the abortion rights movement. form abortion politics, and feminism more generally. Florencia, of the
Different interviewees noted the “strength,” “endurance” (aguante), intermediate generation, noted that “somehow feminism was stagnant
“energy,” and commitment to action and to “hold” protest spaces that here, we could not get it out of a place that was not good, it was not
have characterized many of the interventions of young activists. In the celebratory.” The influx of new activists injected feminism, and abor-
words of Ramiro, from the middle generation, the “pibitas [young tion rights activism specifically, with a different affective tone. The
pibas] in high schools continue the struggle [of the históricas] carrying “green tide” in 2018 was rather festive. In street protests and activist
it with the strength that only young women have, women and youth events during that year—from Green Tuesdays to the vigils surrounding
who are super empowered.” Older activists also recognized the im- the congressional debate—young activists readily adopted the green
portance of sustaining movement presence in public spaces and men- kerchief, using it on their heads, wrists, backpacks, torsos, and necks.
tioned that, to a large extent, this was accomplished thanks to the They experimented with different styles and ways of displaying the
availability and stamina of young activists. They also highlighted young symbol. They painted their eyelids or lips in bright green or inscribed
activists' rebellious stance, reflected in their vocal questioning of the creative designs on their faces: green straight lines, stars and dots, and
social order and through irreverent forms of embodied protest. In the many other shapes, often enhanced with green glitter. As I was saying
words of Juliana, of the intermediate generation, the pibas “show us not goodbye to Alba (27 years old) she asserted: “The Fourth wave is going
only which way the discussion should go but how to engage with this to be green, glittery, and Latin American!” Besides pointing to the re-
struggle. Which is on the streets, clearly. In a very determined way, that gional significance of the events unfolding in Argentina, and the cen-
is, without negotiation. And considering that with each success we are trality of abortion politics (symbolized by the color green) to con-
bringing up everything for discussion.” While young people are not the temporary feminism, this statement highlights the festive and
only ones to engage in radical forms of questioning, and the commit- performative character of the emerging “glittery” feminist protest. The
ment to street protest is not new, previous iterations of the abortion festive style of youth protest also rubs, even literally, onto activists from
rights movement lacked the numbers of activists and public displays of older generations, as some also started to add green glitter or other non-
support that was evident in 2018. Young activists helped “sustain street traditional decorations to their faces during protests.
actions,” engaged in bold interventions such as occupying high schools, The glitter, the body painting, and the generally joyful quality of the
and readily displayed their green kerchiefs in their everyday life. young participants in the green tide is more than a style of protest. It
Referring to the contributions of the pibas, Sonia (30 years old) also transforms the stigma associated with abortion, as protesters not
appreciated the presence of pibas in events held by the Campaign's only display the green kerchief with pride and without fear, but exu-
during weekly “Green Tuesdays”: berantly celebrate their right to freedom, their resistance, and their
lineage as the “granddaughters of the witches that you could not burn”
Well, on Green Tuesdays there was a festival and so on at the door of
(as some of the protest signs and songs declared). According to Paola,
Congress, and that happened for two months, and that was sus-
an activist “in the middle,” this approach helps shift the terms of the
tained, mainly, and not only by the Campaign obviously—the
abortion rights debate from one focused on “abortion to prevent death”
compañeras from the Campaign who were organizers—but also by
to one that sees abortion as a life-affirming option for those who can
the pibas […] I think that the Campaign has that wonderful aspect,
make the decision:
which is that the same space can be shared by all generations.
And now we are talking a lot about legal abortion in order to enable
Florencia, an activist in the middle, contrasts the recent swelling of
choice. And that feminism invites us to think of a life that is free,
feminist events—in large part due to the presence of young people—-
that is happy. It has to do with joy and hope, which makes it possible
with the relatively small number of activists in past feminist marches in
to also start talking about autonomy, about desire. Then it seems to
which she had participated: For example “in a November 25 march
me that during these 2–3 months there has been a big change in the
[International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women] we
debate, and especially because of the prominence of the pibas, of the
did not even fill a block, we were the same ones [....] Then, with this ...
adolescents, who do not just speak of the women who died due to
vitality that I think younger people bring, a lot is gained, intensity is
clandestine abortion, but speak of les17 [the] people with the ca-
gained, potency is gained, action is gained.”
pacity to gestate, they talk a lot about desire, my body, exposing the
The energy of the young activists is complemented by the experi-
body, covering it with glitter. They have a very clear idea in relation
ence of older generations. This is recognized by Emma (21 years old)
to desire, and from those spaces they are also transforming the de-
who not only spoke about her activist group's powerful work capacity
bate.
(prepotencia de trabajo), and how they are like “little tractors,” and
“engines,” but also how “that was not sufficient to do everything we Paola's observations point to the deeper meaning that the form of
did.” She reflected on how they needed the older generations “with political protest carries. Form and affect are entwined, shaping political
their knowledge, with their ... with their connections, with their net- discourse and the terms of the debate on abortion (Vacarezza, 2018).
works, with their already-held discussions. There were a lot of discus- The festive embodied protest of young activists helps advance argu-
sions we still needed to have. And they were able to be that linkage ments that older activists also agree with—for example on sexual au-
between the energy and the need to put… Well, [to say] ‘Let's create a tonomy—but that are sometimes downplayed for strategic reasons (for
foundation. Let's ... Let's make a plan. Let's join together.’ Pah! Like that. example, sensing greater societal willingness to entertain public health
Like ‘let's come down back to Earth, too.’” arguments as opposed to those based on women's sexual freedom). The
Activist praxis is about the blend between thought and action. massive and festive activism for abortion rights that surrounded the
Young activists have been engaged in spaces of reflection and some parliamentary debate of the abortion legalization bill has shaped the
young leaders have eloquently spoken to the media and members of new social context for the reception of abortion rights arguments in
congress, evidencing thoughtful consideration of the issues surrounding contemporary Argentina.
abortion. In other words, it is not just “action” that young activists offer
to the movement. At the same time, energetic action and the commit-
ment to physically occupy space is an important contribution to abor-
tion rights activism, and has been essential to make the abortion
struggle visible. 17
Les is a gender-inclusive innovation applied to the plural “the,” which in
official Spanish would be las or los (feminine or masculine respectively).

8
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

5.3. In the middle In addition to the public-facing work of activists “in the middle,”
Daniela, who is in this group, illustrated much of the behind-the-scenes
The generation “in the middle” is comprised by a broad swath of work carried out by these activists. Referring to the vigil on the occa-
abortion rights activists who have played a crucial role in the move- sion of the parliamentary debate during June 13–14, 2018, she re-
ment, yet have received less rhetorical attention in public discourse counted the massive demonstration in the streets adjacent to Congress
than the pibas or the históricas. In fact, there is not a distinctive gen- as an “incredible” event, with significant logistical demands for acti-
erational label for them other than pointing to their position in relation vists: There were “compañeras who did not sleep for 48 hours [….] who
to other generations. As Guillermina (43 years old) pointed out, it is not were there at dawn, that is, the day before. Yes, at the dawn of the
that activists in the middle are totally invisible. Many have evident previous day setting up the stage, together with those who brought the
organizational roles during protests, appear in the media, lecture at stage. Like that, arranging the sound system ... Everything, everything.”
universities, or speak in other public fora. However, when different Daniela and others talked about the complex logistical work of or-
generations are referred to, this group seems to be somewhat invisible, ganizing mega events such as the demonstrations that took place out-
or perhaps taken for granted, seemingly defined in relation to the other side of the National Congress during the parliamentary debates. For
groups. Here I highlight three themes that apply to the intermediate example, the June 13–14 demonstration reportedly mobilized around
generation and that helps understand their position in the abortion one million people (e.g., Zanellato, 2018). Besides the political activ-
rights movement. As will be discussed, these are activists whose efforts ities of the event, activists had to organize security, communications,
have been vital to making things happen; they often have to balance and countless details that are easy to take for granted by those who
competing responsibilities; and they have served as a bridge between participate or watch from the sidelines and who only see the results of
generations of activists. this painstaking work.
Logistical aspects can also be arenas of generational friction.
5.3.1. Making things happen Guillermina an activist in her early 40s narrated the tension around the
Activists in the middle do much of the work that keeps the abortion move to cut down political content during one of the Green
rights movement going. Through their organizational skills and ded- Tuesdays—which would be aired through a live microphone (radio
ication, they substantially contribute to the advancement of the cause. abierta)—in favor of festival activities such as live music. She pushed for
They coordinate event logistics, sustain networks, disseminate in- the inclusion of more political content and noted the generational di-
formation, speak to the media and politicians, teach, theorize, strate- vide: It was “music that I had never heard in my life, in my life.” She
gize, and assist others. This is not to say that activists from other gen- added that one of the históricas also commented “What's this?” Those
erations do not contribute in some of these ways, but I highlight this advocating for reducing the radio abierta time “explained that street
aspect to underscore the important work of this group vis-à-vis their [presence] was maintained with the pibas…Who would stay there
relative invisibility in generational terms, and to show how their acti- every Tuesday for two months, with the cold and discomfort that the
vism finds both synergy and conflict with their paid and carework re- streets generate? What will you give them, a declaration that makes
sponsibilities. Many of these activists' contributions are behind the them fall asleep?” Here we see that issues having to do with genera-
scenes and some are front stage. Their activism sometimes blends with tional preferences percolated into logistics, and ultimately while
their jobs and professions, for example, as teachers, university pro- Guillermina was not altogether convinced by the arguments offered,
fessors, or health care workers, but it can also present competing de- she also recognized the contribution of the young ones occupying the
mands and risks to their employment. streets and struggled to fit everything into the schedule.
Elisa, one of the históricas, positively described the contributions of These examples illustrate the intermediate generation's logistical
activists in the middle, pointing to how their movement trajectories contributions to both ongoing activist work and to activist “peak”
were also shaped by key political moments and emblematic women's events, which include navigating potential conflicts—generational and
movement spaces. Specifically she referred to the 2000s period, pre- otherwise. These actions tap into finely-tuned organizational skills,
sumably in relation to the rising activism that surrounded the political ability to implement plans, and a work capacity that draws on years of
and economic crisis of 2001 (Borland & Sutton, 2007). She also men- experience in other realms of life. One question that emerges is how this
tioned the National Women's Encuentros, which have been important activist work fits with other demands in these activists' lives, particu-
political venues for the development of abortion rights discourse and larly given the gendered division of labor in society and in relation to
strategy in Argentina. increased economic insecurity and inequality in the context of neoli-
beralism.
[T]he intermediate generation is very good. No, I think it is really
good because many of those chicas [young women] started being
5.3.2. Balancing responsibilities
pibas too, we would say, no? And today they are between 30 and
The intense organizational work of movement participants “in the
40 years old, so to speak, no? They went to the first Encuentros of
middle” is sometimes in conflict with other demands in their lives, such
women in the 2000s, no? And many of them, for example, actively
as childcare and job obligations. Activism becomes a third shift, which
participate… These professionals have created new things. The
can be hard to balance in relation to other responsibilities that are
Network of Professionals for the Right to Decide is basically made
necessary but are hard to set aside, particularly when they provide
up of those compañeras.
essential economic sustenance. This is an aspect that was emphasized
The network that Elisa refers to is composed of professionals in by Daniela (37 years old) when referring especially to activists who are
health care who say “Count on us” to those who may need to interrupt in their 30s and 40s:
their pregnancies (for instance, for cases that fall within the exceptions
I mean, we are all precarizadas [in precarious economic conditions],
to penalization). That is, aspects of their activism happen through and
with two or three jobs; or without work, unemployed; or skipping
are intricatelly connected to their professional practice. Additionally
work to be able to guarantee the [movement's] activities, or those
they “participated in hundreds of workshops, panels, debates, discus-
who are teachers losing leave time, even asking for leaves with debt
sions about budgets, about techniques, during the green Tuesdays, in
[....] We are the workers, like the most active part of society, we are
schools, labor unions, neighborhood assemblies, social organizations,
university courses, on television, and mobilizing during 13J and 8A”
(Red de Profesionales, n.d.).18 This extensive list shows significant in-
terventions in multiple spaces, in this way shaping understandings, 18
June 13 and August 8 of 2018, when the Chamber of Deputies and the
discourse, and mobilization for abortion rights. Senate respectively debated an abortion legalization bill.

9
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

giving it a thousand percent. That's what's happening. And things with whom we organized politically.” Ramiro (41 years old), is also in
related to work are very present for all of us. [....] I mean, we are all the intermediate generation, but he chose to highlight the role of fellow
workers and we are at risk in each of the activities we do, going to activist women in their 30s and 40s, mentioning that “they have the
meetings … I mean … It's like … We're like the invisible threads, training and sharp eyes to revisit the históricas, and they can read the
behind everything that's happening. So we were saying, “Well, strength of the pibas. Then they can coordinate an estudiantazo (student
where is it visible?” In that […] at the end of the month we do not protest), which sometimes is difficult to accord between generations
make any money [no cobramos nada]. that are so far apart, so these compañeras, who play the role of vertex to
some extent, are fundamental. They are the true political troopers of
Besides remunerated work, unpaid care work can also limit the
this Campaign [laughs].” Thus activists from the intermediate genera-
availability of some members of this age group. For instance, Sandra
tion can potentially foster cooperation through their proximity to and
(31 years old) attended the vigil surrounding the legalization bill debate
understanding of different age groups.
in the Congress lower house. The whole debate extended to about 22
hours. Thus, at some point Sandra had to return home to care for her
6. Conclusion
small baby. Family obligations have not prevented her from intense
movement participation. Still, one can see the struggle to balance these
The abortion rights movement in Argentina is nourished by different
various responsibilities. During our interview, Sandra sometimes had to
generations of activists who have mobilized together toward a common
interrupt her narration to tend to her baby, including when she re-
goal. Although critically analyzing tensions and conflicts between dif-
counted her efforts to straddle motherhood and activism during the
ferent groups is important, this article's emphasis on generational
vigil:
contributions, convergences, and solidarity not only reflects a particular
I was in Congress till 4:30–5 in the morning, trying to hold on as moment in the movement, but also serves to identify key aspects of
much as possible. And then, well, for reasons beyond my control I movement change and continuity. While there are certainly overlaps
had to return [laughs], and I was here. I was here with my mom, between the challenges and contributions of different groups, inter-
with my baby. And it was like … both of us jumping up and down views with activists highlight longtime activists' persistence, the ways
with joy because [the lower-house bill] passed. [Sound of baby in which their efforts are currently recognized by other generations,
crying in the background]. I am going to bring him. [Speaking to the and how they have contributed to feminist transmission by passing on
baby:] Come here, sweetie. Come here … there, there now. Have a little knowledge and movement memory. On the other end of the age spec-
bit of milk, a little bit of milk [drawing him to her breast]. Son, you trum, young activists push for greater sexual and gender inclusivity,
distract me from the topic … [with tender voice]. contribute to the movement through energetic action and public space
occupation, and perform a festive style of protest. The activists “in the
Similar challenges are mentioned by Dalia (40 years old), who had
middle” have been central to making things happen, contributing
been a leader in the Campaign, but who had to scale down her activism
multiple forms of knowledge and skills, and often having to balance the
due to the combination of work obligations and becoming a single
competing demands of activism, paid employment, and/or unpaid care
mother. She points out that it can be hard to keep the same level of
work. They leave their own imprint in the movement, through their
involvement over a long period: “To be in those places of exposure and
participation in various organizational layers, and also operate as a
sacrifice has personal costs, work-related costs, economic costs.” She
bridge between generations.
describes the struggle to reconcile her employment demands and acti-
One of the lessons from the movement events during 2018, and its
vist duties: “Every week I would give a talk in this university, in that
longer history, is the importance of intergenerational dialogue, co-ex-
university, in that other place, in that barrio, in that prison, in that
istence, and organizing for abortion rights activism to move its goals
radio show. Well, today I cannot sustain that.” While activists “in the
forward. This is also essential in a struggle that promises to continue.
middle” are not the only ones who may have competing obligations
Even if abortion is decriminalized and legalized in the near future,
(e.g., one of the younger históricas talked about her exhaustion from
activists who support abortion rights feel that they cannot let their
intense activism in combination with two jobs), perhaps certain life-
guard down. Several activists anticipated the hurdles that can be ex-
cycle events, combined with their position doing much of the move-
pected even in a scenario of legal abortion. The difficulties to secure
ment organizing and logistical work, made these conflicts particularly
abortions that fit within the current legal exceptions prefigure what is
apparent.
to come. Additionally, if a transnational consciousness teaches us
anything is that anti-abortion opponents can significantly curtail this
5.3.3. Bridging generations right even in places where abortion is legal, as has been the case in the
In addition to contributing to movement discourse and logistics, United States, for example. The active involvement of different gen-
activists in the middle also help bridge generations. They are inheritors erations of activists is then critical not only to legalize abortion, but also
of past struggles; they make a political mark of their own; and they also to defend this right and make it an effective reality in the long run.
connect with young activist through their teaching and organizational Argentina's abortion rights movement's achievements in 2018 hold
activities. In this way, they are in a position to serve as translators of the promise of intergenerational learning and multidirectional trans-
sorts between the históricas and the pibas. Members of this inter- mission, as well as diffusion of feminist ideas. These intergenerational
mediate group have shared or personally remember important political encounters are not always smooth, and there is potential for substantial
moments of the country, and sometimes trace their first steps in acti- disagreements and misunderstanding. However, in the context of a
vism to spaces led by the históricas. At the same time, some of these movement on the rise, and under the broad structure of the National
activists—particularly those who are on the younger side—share some Campaign for the Right to Legal, Safe, and Free abortion, activists from
affinities with the perspectives of the pibas. different generations recognized each other, worked together, and
Florencia, one of the activists “in the middle,” saw her generation as made a significant political impact. The widespread participation of
bridging the propositions of younger feminists and the legacies of the different age groups demonstrates that abortion rights matter to society
históricas. While younger than the históricas, Florencia has been long as a whole—not just to a handful of feminists, not just to women, and
enough in the feminist scene in Argentina to be able to critically con- not just to people of reproductive age. Abortion has become an im-
sider both the movement's contributions and its limitations. Referring portant and recognized political issue. Through multiple strategies and
to the newer feminist generations, she suggested that “we can articulate a living discourse for abortion rights, activists from different genera-
those [feminist perspectives] with some of the things we learned from tions helped take abortion out of the shadows, spreading the idea that
the históricas, who are not merely figures to name for us, but persons this practice should be clandestine no more.

10
B. Sutton Women's Studies International Forum 82 (2020) 102392

Funding 3340.
Henry, A. (2004). Not my mother’s sister: Generational conflict and third-wave feminism.
Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
At the writing stage, this project benefited from the support of the Hewitt, N. A. (Ed.). (2010). No permanent waves: Recasting histories of U.S. feminism. New
Rockefeller Foundation Bellagio Center Academic Writing Residency. Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Himitian, E., & Vallejos, S. (2018). Cronología de la sororidad: Por qué es la palabra del
año. La Nación, December 19https://www.lanacion.com.ar/2203707-cronologia-
Declaration of competing interest sororidad-que-es-palabra-del-ano.
Lagarde y de los Rios, M. (2009). Pacto entre mujeres: Sororidad. Aportes, 25, 123–135.
Laudano, C. (2018). Aborto y redes: El debate por #Abortolegal. Sociales en Debate,
None. 14(Marea verde. Lo que el debate nos dejó)https://publicaciones.sociales.uba.ar/
index.php/socialesendebate/article/view/3350/2747.
Acknowledgments Maddison, S., & Grey, R. (2010). New feminist generations: The inter-generational con-
versation continues. Australian Feminist Studies, 25(66), 485–492.
Mariana Dibuja/Página. 2019. Facebook post, July 25. https://www.facebook.com/
I thank the activists in Argentina who shared their views, analyses, mariana.dibuja/posts/muchas-gracias-planetae-y-elizabeth-coronel-por-la-
and experiences with me, as well as the following scholars who pro- entrevista-espero-haya-salido/2297635926957315/.
vided helpful feedback on different versions of this article: Nayla Mario, S., & Pantelides, E. A. (2009). Estimación de la magnitud del aborto inducido en la
Argentina. Notas de población, 87, 95–120.
Vacarezza, Elizabeth Borland, Lisette Balabarca-Fataccioli, Gwen McReynolds-Pérez, J. (2017). No doctors required: Lay activist expertise and pharma-
D'Arcangelis, Silvia Mejía, Óscar Pérez, and two reviewers for Women's ceutical abortion in Argentina. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 42(2),
Studies International Forum. I am also grateful for the conversations 349–375.
Paladini, E. (2018). Despenalización. Clarín. Agosto 4 https://www.clarin.com/politica/
about the project with Constanza Tabbush, Alexandra Adams, and nuevas-encuestas-aborto-horas-arranque-debate_0_rkAj4JusG.html.
Bahia Shehab. Pérez, M., & Radi, B. (2018). Algunos casos de mala praxis retórica y crímenes de lesa
argumentación en los debates contemporáneos sobre aborto. Relámpagos. https://
relampagos.net/2018/05/14/algunos-casos-de-mala-praxis-retorica-y-crimenes-de-
References lesa-argumentacion-en-los-debates-contemporaneos-sobre-aborto/.
Ramos, S., Romero, M., & Ramón Michel, A. (2014). Health care providers’ opinions on
Abogados y Abogadas del NOA en Derechos Humanos y Estudios Sociales (ANDHES), abortion: A study for the implementation of the legal abortion public policy in the
et al. (2018). Acceso al aborto en Argentina. Informe conjunto remitido al Comité de province of Santa Fe, Argentina. Reproductive Health, 11(72)https://doi.org/10.1186/
Derechos Económicos, Sociales y Culturales (Comité DESC) de las Naciones Unidas 1742-4755-11-72.
para la cuarta evaluación periódica del país, September 11. https://www.cels.org.ar/ Red de Profesionales por el Derecho a Decidir. n.d.. “Quiénes somos.” https://www.
web/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/20180911_Aborto_ComiteDESC.pdf. redsaluddecidir.org/quienes-somos/#.XTGTmuhKg2w.
Aikau, H. K., Erickson, K. A., & Pierce, J. L. (Eds.). (2007). Feminist waves, feminist gen- Reger, J. (2015). The story of a slut walk: Sexuality, race, and generational divisions in
erations: Life stories from the academy. Minneapolis: Minnesota University Press. contemporary feminist activism. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, 44(1), 84–112.
Alcaraz, M. F. (2018). ¡Que sea ley!: La lucha de los feminismos por el aborto legal. Ciudad de Schmidt, S. (2019). A language for all. The Washington Post. December 5 https://www.
Buenos Aires: Marea. washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2019/12/05/teens-argentina-are-leading-charge-
Alma, A., & Lorenzo, P. (2009). Mujeres que se Encuentran: Una Recuperación Histórica de gender-neutral-language/?arc404=true.
los Encuentros Nacionales de Mujeres en Argentina. Buenos Aires: Feminaria. Seca, M. V. (2019). “Estamos haciendo historia”: Activismos juveniles por el derecho al
Bellucci, M. (1997). Women’s struggle to decide about their own bodies: Abortion and aborto en Mendoza (Argentina). In M. Larrondo, & C. P. Lara (Eds.). Activismos
sexual rights in Argentina. Reproductive Health Matters, 10(November), 99–106. feministas jóvenes: Emergencias, actrices y luchas en América Latina (pp. 79–98). Buenos
Bellucci, M., & Mitidieri, G. (2017). Genealogía del 28 de septiembre, día de lucha por el Aires: CLACSO.
aborto legal. LATFEM, September 15https://latfem.org/genealogia-del-28-de- Springer, K. (2002). Third wave black feminism? Signs, 27(4), 1059–1082.
septiembre-dia-de-lucha-por-el-aborto-legal/. Sternbach, N. S., Navarro-Aranguren, M., Chuchryk, P., & Alvarez, S. E. (1992).
Borland, E. (2014). Age dynamics and identity: Conflict and cooperation among feminists Feminisms in Latin America: From Bogotá to San Bernardo. Signs, 17(2), 393–434.
in Buenos Aires. In L. M. Woehrle (Vol. Ed.), Intersectionality and social change Sutton, B. (2014). “More than reproductive uteruses:” Women and the politics of abortion
(Research in social movements, conflicts and change). 37. Intersectionality and social in Argentina. In S. Poggio, & M. A. Viteri (Eds.). Cuerpo, educación y liderazgo político:
change (Research in social movements, conflicts and change) (pp. 83–106). Emerald. Una mirada desde el género y los estudios feministas. Quito: FLACSO Sede Ecuador,
Borland, E., & Sutton, B. (2007). Quotidian Disruption and Women’s Activism in Times of University of Maryland, Latin American Studies Association.
Crisis, Argentina 2002-2003. Gender & Society, 21(5), 700–722. Sutton, B. (2018). Surviving state terror: Women’s testimonies of repression and resistance in
Bulbeck, C. (2010). Unpopularising feminism: “Blaming feminism” in the generation Argentina. New York: NYU Press.
debate and the mother wars. Sociology Compass, 4(1), 21–37. Sutton, B., & Borland, E. (2013). Framing abortion rights in Argentina’s Encuentros
Burton, J. (2017). De la comisión al socorro: Trazos de militancia feminista por el derecho Nacionales de Mujeres. Feminist Studies, 39(1), 194–234.
al aborto en Argentina. Descentrada, 1(2), 1–17. Sutton, B., & Borland, E. (2018). Queering abortion rights: Notes from Argentina. Culture,
Campaña Nacional por el Derecho al Aborto Legal, Seguro y. Gratuito (2019). Proyecto de Health & Sexuality, 20(12), 1378–1393.
Ley de Interrupción Voluntaria del Embarazo. http://www.abortolegal.com.ar/ Sutton, B., & Borland, E. (2019). Abortion and human rights for women in Argentina.
proyecto-de-ley-presentado-por-la-campana/. Frontiers: A Journal of Women Studies, 40(2), 27–61.
Cavallero, L., Gago, V., Varela, P., Barón, C., & Mitidieri, G. (2018). Argentina’s Tarducci, M. (2018). Key arenas in the struggle for abortion rights in Argentina. Salud
Anticapitalist feminism. Interview by Cinzia Arruzza and Tithi Bhattacharya. Translation Colectiva, 14(3), 425–432.
by Karen Domínguez BurkeJacobin. September 2 https://www.jacobinmag.com/2018/ Thompson, B. (2002). Multiracial feminism: Recasting the chronology of second wave
09/argentinas-anticapitalist-feminism. feminism. Feminist Studies, 28(2), 337–360.
Chaneton, J., & Vacarezza, N. (2011). La intemperie y lo intempestivo: Experiencias del Tripp, W. B., & Gage, D. N. (2018). Late bloomers: Differential participation among first-
aborto voluntario en el relato de mujeres y varones. Buenos Aires: Marea. time, mid-life protesters. In P. G. Coy (Vol. Ed.), Research in social movements, conflicts
Cullen, P., & Fischer, C. (2014). Conceptualising generational dynamics in feminist and change (Research in social movements, conflicts and change). 42. Research in social
movements: Political generations, waves and affective economies. Sociology Compass, movements, conflicts and change (Research in social movements, conflicts and change)
8(3), 282–293. (pp. 221–242). Emerald.
Di Marco, G. (2011). El pueblo feminista: Movimientos sociales y lucha de las mujeres en torno Vacarezza, N. L. (2018). Perejil, agujas y pastillas. Objetos y afectos en la producción
a la ciudadanía. Buenos Aires: Biblos. visual a favor de la legalización del aborto en Argentina. In D. Busdygan (Ed.). Aborto:
Dicker, R. C., & Piepmeier, A. (2003). Catching a wave: Reclaiming feminism for the 21st Aspectos normativos, jurídicos y discursivos (pp. 195–212). Buenos Aires: Biblos.
century. Boston: Northeastern University Press. Vazquez Laba, V., Palumbo, M., & Puglia, M.d.l. N. (2018). La Argentina anti-punitivista
Downton, J., & Wehr, P. (1998). Persistent pacifism: How activist commitment is de- que supimos conseguir. Anifibia. http://revistaanfibia.com/ensayo/argentina-anti-
veloped and sustained. Journal of Peace Research, 35(5), 531–550. punitivista/.
Elizalde, S., & Mateo, N. (2018). Las jóvenes: Entre la “marea verde” y la decisión de Whittier, N. (1995). Feminist generations: The persistence of the radical women’s movement.
abortar. Salud Colectiva, 14(3), 433–446. Temple University Press.
Fine, T. S. (2006). Generations, feminist beliefs and abortion rights support. Journal of Whittier, N. (1997). Political generations, micro-cohorts, and the transformation of social
International Women’s Studies, 7(4), 126–140. movements. American Sociological Review, 62(5), 760–778.
Foster, J. E. (2015). Women of a certain age: “Second wave” feminists reflect back on 50 Winch, A. (2014). Feminism, generation and intersectionality. Soundings: A Journal of
years of struggle in the United States. Women’s Studies International Forum, Politics and Culture, 58, 8–20.
50(May–June), 68–79. Zanellato, R. (2018). Aborto legal: 13 hechos que marcaron un semestre histórico. La
Guillaume, A., & Rossier, C. (2018). Abortion around the world. An overview of legis- Nación, August 9https://www.lanacion.com.ar/espectaculos/aborto-legal-13-hechos-
lation, measures, trends, and consequences. Population-E, 72(2), 217–306. que-marcaron-un-semestre-historico-nid2160514.
Gutiérrez, M. A. (2018). Feminismos en acción: El debate de la ley de Interrupción vo- Zurbriggen, R., & Anzorena, C. (Eds.). (2013). El aborto como derecho de las mujeres. Otra
luntaria del embarazo. Sociales en Debate, 14(Marea verde. Lo que el debate nos dejó) historia es posible. Buenos Aires: Herramienta.
https://publicaciones.sociales.uba.ar/index.php/socialesendebate/article/view/

11

You might also like