Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stories of Entrepreneurship: Case Study
Stories of Entrepreneurship: Case Study
2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
Case Study:
Stories of Entrepreneurship
By Hina Abidi, Farhan Shafiq, Rimsha Arshad, Maria Pirwani & Ahmed Hassan1
Abstract
Entrepreneurship is impera ve for growing economies in mes of environmental uncer-
tain es. Pakistani mentality is undergoing a change and more and more educated people are
looking at business of their own rather than a “naukrii. This bold ini a ve by a few is likely to
mo vate young budding professionals to follow suit. Entrepreneurship is all about iden fying
a business opportunity and adding color to it to sound compelling. Idea has replaced finances
as an engine to entrepreneurial spirit. Another factor that stands out is the ability of making
calculated risks and being persistent in your struggle. Entrepreneurial character also helps
in making you successful. The need of me is to allow small and medium enterprises SME
to grow dispropor onately to double the GDP growth of the countryii. This is a story of five
entrepreneurs who surmounted the odds and build their enterprise into successful businesses.
Keywords: Idea genera on, Entrepreneurship, Team effort, Timmons model, Entrepreneur-
ial character.
1
All authors are students of MBA, PAF-KIET who have compiled these case studies.
Case Study 67
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
in the upper middle class Punjabi-family in Ka- What kind of environment, and target cus-
rachi. She graduated in business administra- tomers?
on in the year 2004 from Karachi University.
Ms. Naina started her career as an assistant All these ques ons had to be deliberat-
marke ng manager at Expon Pvt. Limited. ed thoroughly and systema cally addressed.
Later she moved to AIG Insurance as a depu- Living in Karachi, she was fully aware of
ty director marke ng. During this period the “Bha a mafia” which could bring a new
opportuni es kept on knocking on her door business like hers to dust in no me. A er
which she en-cashed by joining Adamjee In- delibera ons and discussions with family
surance in 2008 as the head of the depart- members, she narrowed down the vicinity
ment. of her new business to the surrounding of
Malir Cant. Factors such as low rent, less
In 2009, she got married and took a short compe on and difficulty for mafia to enter
break from work. On resump on in 2010, she in the cantonment had contributed to final-
was promoted to posi on of the vice presi- ize this area for her new business.
dent of retail and micro insurance.
The next step that took lot of delibera-
Despite her blossoming career she decid- on was the kind of food to be served to the
ed to open a café called “Spasso”. One of the customers. Ini ally she wanted to provide
mo va ng factors to turn to entrepreneur- “desi” Pakistani food. But prior to making
ship was her childhood dream to run her own the final decision she carried out a short sur-
business which she shared with her husband. vey on the habits and ea ng preference of
To her surprise, she found him suppor ve and the consumers of Malir and adjoining areas.
encouraging. This is how “café Spasso in Malir The major finding was that the residence of
Cantonment came into my life” exclaims Ms. the Malir prefers ea ng in cafés which was
Naina the in-thing in those days.
A Jump from Insurance to Food That being decided, the next step was se-
Soon she learned that there is a huge dif- lec ng a theme for the café. As she was ful-
ference between “working for others” and ly aware that while ea ng out people gives
working for yourself”. She was not a pro- strong considera on to the environment as
fessional chef but she loved cooking and well. Malir cantonment is a suburban area
sharing different dishes with her family and that lacks in social life. Thus she decided
friends. Addi onally, she also enjoyed the that the environment of her Café would pro-
experience of dinning out. All these mo vat- vide fun and social interac on to youngsters
ed her to go in the food business. However, and families. The name of the café “Spasso”
the more difficult ques ons those s ll both- in Italian language means fun which is also
ering her were: what kind of food? Where? the theme of her restaurant.
68 Case Study
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
stan she gave special deals to the customers. feren a on in hor culture sector by intro-
These efforts played a cri cal role in the de- ducing hot bin & mist houses for propaga on
velopment and maintenance of brand loyalty. of Decius plant. Subsequently, he ventured
into manufacturing and set-up a plant of liq-
The most surprising aspect of her venture uefied gas cylinder, where he stayed for one
was change of percep on and a tude. Like year. He even tried his luck in poultry busi-
most people her percep on was that a fe- ness and created differen a on by making
males in this male dominated market cannot incubators for quail breeding. However, his
survive. But once ventured into the business des ny forced him to migrate to the United
she learned that being a female gave her add- Kingdom (UK).
ed advantage in the market. So her advice to
female entrepreneur is “do not hesitate and SA HeaƟng & Plumbing Background
think people will not take you seriously in the Mr. Shafiq a er migra on to UK acquired
market. In fact, the country has a lot of respect a diploma in Hea ng and Plumbing program.
for women. All you need is courage and confi- While pursuing his diploma, he realized that
dence to talk with the man and they will listen the plumbing business in England unlike Pa-
to you”. The Café ran successfully for 3 years kistan has huge poten al and is considered
but then was shut down for reasons other a respectable profession.
than business.
The shortage of cer fied engineers in
Shafiq Alam’s SA Plumbing and UK prompted him to venture into this busi-
HeaƟng UK ness. As luck would have it, he established
Contributor: Farhan Shafiq a company with the name of SA HEATING &
Mr. Shafiq Alam due to persistent strug- PLUMBING where SA stands for Shafiq Alam.
gle in his life and vision to be an entrepre- Ini ally he hired four tradesmen and regis-
neur achieved greatness in life. He joined tered his company in 2010 in Manchester,
PAF a er matricula on but con nued en- UK.
hancing his educa on while s ll in uniform;
he completed his BA from Karachi University In the beginning, he concentrated on
in 1976 and LLB in 1986. He migrated to UK small domes c household sector compris-
for greener pastures and today is the owner ing of Pakistani and Indian migrated families
of SA hea ng and plumbing in Manchester, se led in Manchester. He provided them
UK. discount, and they reciprocated by referring
customers to his company. By providing cus-
History of Entrepreneurial AcƟviƟes tomized services efficiently and competent-
Mr. Shafiq commenced his professional ly he generated a loyal customer base.
career as a director in Techno World Pvt. Ltd
a unit in hor cultural sector, Islamabad. Be- Financial Resources:
ing entrepreneurial by nature he created dif- He started his business with a net per-
70 Case Study
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
sonal saving of Rs.40, 000/= plus loans from tory that everyone in their life gets opportu-
Banks. He even collaborated with his com- ni es. What is required is to recognize them
pe tors who also helped his company to and give the best shot without being afraid
grow. He treated his staff as partners, and of failure.
upgraded their competencies by sending
them on training. During the period 2010- Arshad Zia’s Zain CommunicaƟon
2014, the company’s monthly revenue was Contributor: Rimsha Arshad
as high as pounds 10000 with a profit mar-
gin of up to 50%. IntroducƟon
Muhammad Arshad Zia was born in 1964
SA Hea ng and Plumbing is now well in District of Toba Tek Singh (Punjab). He be-
poised to compete with leading compe - longed to a poor Punjabi family. Since his
tors like JP Plumbing and gas, Castle proper- childhood, he had a passion to be successful
ty services and Piccadilly plumbing. He has entrepreneur. He always was short of resourc-
also diversified company’s por olio by ven- es due to his modest background but he nev-
turing into domes c hea ng system design, er felt depressed. He believed – “If you strive
domes c oil Installa on, building drainage you’ll thrive!” As early as age six, he used to
and residen al sprinkler installa on services sell sta onery to pay his school fees. Thus
throughout his educa on career he did dif-
QualiƟes of Entrepreneur ferent odds jobs to meet all the educa onal
Shafiq Alam has excelled as an entrepre- expenses. In 1979, he moved to Karachi and
neur since he remained focused on his vi- was selected in Technical Appren ceship pro-
sion and goal. In order to achieve his goal gram of PAF. A erwards, he acquired Technical
he kept on venturing on different jobs and Associate Engineering Diploma from School of
business. He was not deterred by his earlier Electronics at PAF Korangi Creek Base. He also
failures and kept venturing into newer ave- remained associated as an Instructor in the
nues. His level of confidence remained unaf- same school for a while. In 1985, he complet-
fected by his earlier disappointments. Being ed his B-Tec. in Telecommunica on from NED
a migrant, he could play safe by op ng into University. He won many awards for his aca-
regular employment but he s ll took calcu- demic prowess. He remained associated with
lated risks by se ng his own business. One PAF during all this period and re red in 1992.
of the traits prominent in his character is be-
ing self-starter and not afraid to take risks. In Business Ventures
fact, his internal mo va on remained strong Zain Communica on Services is a B2B Busi-
and gave impetus to his energy. His leader- ness rendering best quality services since 23
ship revolves around by using a par cipa ve years for Installa on of PABX Systems, CCTV
approach in running his business. Cameras, Computer Networking, Apartment
Security Intercom Systems and Laying of Tele-
His percep on of failure was an opportu- phone Underground Cable (Copper and Fi-
nity for success. One can learn from his his- ber).
Case Study 71
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
72 Case Study
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
His business model also generated em- 4. Imbalance in Model. The beauty of Tim-
ployment and in 2013, Zain Communica on mons Model revolves around the chang-
has a workforce, which includes 7 high pro- ing focus from one factor to another. In
file engineers and 22 technicians the ini al stages, “opportunity” remained
the focal point and he iden fied the type
Timmons Model of service, market iden fica on and cus-
The Timmons Model helps in understand- tomer iden fica on and refined the busi-
ing an entrepreneur’s efficiency in managing ness idea. Later he developed the team
and balancing the under men oned factorsiv: and lastly the resources. He periodically re-
1. Opportunity. Being expert in his field, he viewed his priori es and kept changing his
analyzed the Industry in depth and found focal a en on amongst the three factors;
hidden opportuni es that his compe tors always trying to balance the three factors.
lacked knowledge and technical exper se
in Telecom field. He iden fied the gap in Entrepreneurial QualiƟes
the market in 1992 and exploited it. Crea vity, persuasive communica on and
benevolent leadership quali es stand out in
2. Resources. Ini ally, he had limited re- the case of Arshad Zia. He was an excellent
sources including finances and material. communicator which helped him in nego -
His ini al investment in office and staff a ons and interac on with clients. He dis-
remained sparse, but he wielded them played crea vity and competency by doing a
into an effec ve team. Since he had job in Navy which others could not do it, due
technical exper se, he judiciously invest- to which he earned recogni on as well.
ed into high quality equipment at good
terms. He mustered finances at compet- Passionate: A er his re rement, he had
Case Study 73
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
employment offers in leading companies like mary school to support his educa onal ex-
PIA, PTCL, Siemens, Indus Motors and Paki- penses.
stan Steel Mills. His self-belief, competen-
cy, confidence and convic on to work inde- Risk Manager: Arshad took and managed
pendently mo vated him to go for his own risk throughout his business. He risked in en-
business. Working for himself was his passion tering a compe ve market with limited In-
and dream and convic on, which he eventu- vestments. He also took risk and successfully
ally achieved. The importance of this trait is repaired the Navy’s equipment, which others
validated by coverage made on David Leppan declined. In fact, he managed risks without
who due to his passion was able to setup five showing despera on or recklessness. His ad-
businessesv. vice to budding entrepreneur is-
“Money is everywhere, you can earn through
Innovator: Based on Industry Analysis, he employment as well
found that his compe tors were charging cost- as building your own business, facing and figh ng
ly services and their equipment was neither these challenges would sa sfy you more
rather than ge ng employed as you will prac ce
sophis cated. He thus was able to penetrate
what you have learnt.
in the market by providing be er services
So, believe in yourself, Struggle and Prac ce.”
with sophis cated equipment at compe ve-
ly low price.
Ms. Khadija Hanif Chagani Fashion
Competent/Challenging: The turning Outlet
point was his successful comple on of Navy’s Contributor: Maria Abdul Rehman Pirwani
equipment repairing assignments which oth- An Entrepreneur is someone who creates
ers could not oblige; is a proof for his compe- a business with a new idea. This carries a high
tence. He earned credibility by consistently risk since one is not sure whether it would
solving customer’s needs. give acceptable return on investment. Entre-
preneurs need to have a good understanding
Solve Value Driven Needs: Arshad know- of their markets. They should also understand
ing that the small businesses could not afford the needs of the customers and modify their
expensive telecommunica on devices and products accordingly. This is an example of
modern equipment due modest budgets. He one such person who succeeded to achieve
ini ally targeted these small firms and provid- this: Khadija Chagani.
ed be er quality services than compe tors at
a compe ve price. This compe ve advan- Ms. Khadija Hanif Chagani is presently in
tage paid dividends in long run. mid twen es. Her early educa on is from St.
Peters High School. She did her gradua on
Dedicated/Hard Worker: Since his child- and post-gradua on from Ins tute of busi-
hood, he had been a dedicated and devoted ness Management (IoBM). She interned at
person who did different odd jobs since pri- many marke ng firms but with me, she re-
74 Case Study
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
alized that her passion actually is to introduce the fashion industry and did not have to run
something new in the fashion industry. about to generate finances for her enterprise
since her family encouraged her immensely
Her transforma on to fashion industry was and supported her all the way.
not abrupt. She did everything systema cally.
Her vision, “Provide the best quality to clien- She started her business as a lone ranger
tele at a reasonable price. Fashion should be through social media as it is cost effec ve. She
for everyone :)” was what she really decided to used non-professional models and also man-
do. Addi onally her mission statement “Grow aged everything herself including hair make-
my brand bigger with me while keeping val- up, and photography. Based on fashion indus-
ue and quality intact.” really reflects how she try trend she uploaded her first brand online
will achieve her vision. With these credos as in 2010.
the guiding principles, her long-term objec-
ves are finding a mul brand store fit for her Knowing the importance of innova ve suc-
label, having a grand photo shoot with a team cess in every business she kept on changing
of one of the best models in Pakistan’s fash- her product-line. She brought innova on in
ion industry and taking it from thereon. The her product through change in colors, designs
short-term objec ves were to create hype of the embroidery according to the fashion
about her work and about the quality and trends and changes in pa erns as per demand
cuts, she offers. of the market. She also ensured that a touch of
Pakistani culture always remain prominent to
SWOT provide a nostalgic appeal. She also empow-
Khadija knew that all women desire to ered the customers to mix and patch designs
dress-up well. She ini ally developed a val- from the designer’s catalogs. She used the so-
ue proposi on for Pakistanis living abroad. cial media intelligently for the marke ng for
The market abroad is a diverse with a high her brand by using the Face book, instagram
purchasing power that is interested in latest and Whatsapp. Her average hits crossed over
designs and quick deliveries. Though the mar- 10000 during the first year that encouraged
ket is highly compe ve, yet there are s ll her and reinforced her convic ons that she
segments where supply is not adequate. The would succeed. She usually blogs her new
market is highly compe ve. Compe tors re- trends when fashion journalists review the
siding in Karachi as well as other ci es notable clothing line. Although she commenced with
Farah, Lakhani collec ons, Samiha Allure de- mass marke ng strategy through the social
signers and Shaheen couture are well estab- media but since 2014, she has focused on
lished in the market and will not allow others to niche marke ng. Her segment comprised
to enter this market. She thus decided to pen- of young housewives and teenagers who are
etrate in the market of expatriates by crea ng mostly residing in Americas and Middle East-
awareness of her brand through social media. ern countries. Her dresses are mostly a mix
Her strength lie in being well informed about of casuals and party-wear. Her fashion outlet
Case Study 75
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
has succeeded and since 2010, her profits are popular amongst expatriates.
touching Rs .2 million in 2013.
Since her business revolves around the
Since she exports ready-made garments cardinal principals of quality, prompt delivery
abroad, she concentrated on an indigenous and flexibility, therefore she concentrated on
supply chain system. Her customers order building a flawless supply chain system. Her
online and she manages to keep them in the nego a on skills with courier services and
loop un l the garment is ready. She collects clients helped her to build her goodwill and
25% of the price on order stage (there is no later agents of word of mouth promo on. As a
prior advance collec on policy for new cus- person, Khadija is passionate, polite and hard-
tomers). She nego ated favorable deals with working.
the courier services that pick up the consign-
ments from her residence. The client issues Although she did not face the ini al finan-
the full payment through online transfers cial crunches, which each entrepreneur faces.
and cheques before the consignments are She did not overspread her equity. Her ini al
dispatched from Pakistan. On delivery, she effort was to curtail expenses, therefore, she
obtains a confirma on through email. Most exploited her crea vity and talent to direct
of her customers have turned into word of her own shoots, but she contracted the best
mouth conduits to further her business. photographers to appeal to the clientele. Her
self-confidence is another quality that needs
She is using a skimming pricing strategy men on; she had no experience of running a
since her dresses are perceived as good quality bou que but was bold to pursue her dream.
and customized according to the needs of the
clients. At the manufacturing end, she deals The ini al concept of the shoots were
with the skilled labor firmly ensuring that the “Keeping It Regal”. It was an indoor shoot, the
ar sans use their skills to the sa sfac on of clothes were fusion with exquisite cuts, mixes
clients. She is naturally blessed with good aes- of so , bright tones were used from the pal-
the cs about fashion since from early age she e e, and the embellishment was rather royal.
was cu ng and s tching her own clothes.
Her Message
QualiƟes of Khadija Chagani Her crea vity, skills and hard work made
The individual characteris cs of an entre- her successful today and she is now a well-
preneur give impetus to business. Khadija is known brand in the society. An entrepreneur
well educated who understands the intricacies must have these quali es for penetra ng a
of business and marke ng since her educa on growing market. Luck accompanied with intel-
in business groomed her for a profession that ligence holds promise for budding entrepre-
turned out to be an important ingredient for neurs like Ms. Khadija Chagani. Her message
success. She knew how to communicate with hopefully will inspire, “I am confident and
her clients and u lized a medium that is quite love what I do. Be updated. Be informed and
76 Case Study
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
be humble and polite. With a lot of hard work served that the waste management industry
and li le pa ence I achieve my goal when was at a boom during mid. 80’s. Out of the
the me is right .” Her social media link: top 10 Fortune 500 companies, four were of
h ps://www.facebook.com/Khadija.Chagani waste management. He realized that this field
has more to say. was virtually unknown in Pakistan and there
would be a great demand for this kind of
Asif Farooki’s Waste Busters work. He thought of contribu ng towards the
Contributor: Ahmed Hassan society more as an entrepreneur than work-
Entrepreneurship can be carried out in ing for someone. Since he has the exper se of
hundreds of domains. But if one combines waste management so he decided to start a
it with societal needs consumer supports in- full-scale waste management company hence
creases so does the chances of success. Waste Buster was founded in 1996 in Lahore
with the vision of ‘A Cleaner Tomorrow’.
EducaƟonal/Professional Background of the
Entrepreneur The environmental analysis revolved
Mr. Asif Farooki did his O’ and A’ Levels around uniqueness of concept in Pakistan. The
from Atchison College, Lahore. In late 70s, government and society’s need for hygienic
he completed his Bachelors in Civil Engineer- cleanliness. Business is not capital intensive
ing from Northern Illinois University, USA. and cheap/unskilled labor is plen ful. The
Therea er he did his MBA in Environmental risks were to educate public and government
Engineering with specializa on in Waste Man- bodies to allow private en es to venture in
agement from the same University, in 1985. this sector. The trash could be converted into
A er the comple on of his studies, he worked cash by recycling
as a consultant in the field of Waste and Envi-
ronmental Management with the World Bank, Waste Busters
Asian Development Bank, Japan Interna on- Waste Busters is a professional waste man-
al Coopera on Agency (JICA) and the United agement and recycling company. It collects all
Na ons Development Program (UNDP). He is kinds of waste including households, munic-
a member of the Pakistan Environmental Pro- ipal, commercial and industrial waste, trans-
tec on Council, Solid Waste Associa on of Pa- ports it to the recycling facili es, and recycles
kistan, Interna onal Solid Waste Associa on, the waste into useful products such as fer liz-
and Ins tute of Waste Management U.K. He er, composite, fuel and plas c products, which
is also serving as an advisor to the Ministry is an essen al ingredient in waste gasifiers.
of Environment. He has an outgoing and per-
sistent nature, which serves as a catalyst for Waste Busters provide services of Door to
any business venture. Door waste collec on, Debris Removal, In-
dustrial Waste Collec on, Hotel/Restaurants
The Start up waste management, shredding facility for un-
While doing his Masters in USA he ob- wanted documents & incinera on, Janitorial
Case Study 77
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
services, Hospital waste management, fumi- Waste Busters, Caritas Pakistan and many
ga on services, bio-remedia on process for other small-scale waste management com-
be er waste disposal and Recycling. Today panies.
Waste Busters major clients include Nestle,
KFC, Unilever, WWF, Mitchells, CUPOLA, Shell, Team
Tetra Pak, Packages Ltd. and DHA etc. Ini ally it was a one-man show and Mr.
Asif managed the whole business but with
Risk- an essenƟal part of the Business the span of me, he employed a worthy
Risks have always been a part of busi- team of over 300 employees including man-
ness. Being a risk taker in business is not the agers, labors, cleaners, drivers etc. He as an
same as being reckless. Mr. Asif took some entrepreneur properly structured the team,
risks which were needed for this business and selected the right type of person to head
but he was confident that he will cope with his departments. Waste Busters has now ad-
them. Waste management was something equate resources in shape of pick-up trucks/
new in Pakistan in the mid 90’s. Therefore, dumpers, cleaning implements and machin-
it was risky to start a venture, which does ery for recycling.
not exist in Pakistan. He faced strong oppo-
si on from the local government who did Managing Finances
not like that a private en ty encroaching Banks are generally reluctant to give loans
into their territory. Addi onally, the public to new business as they don’t have credit
was not at all coopera ve; they thought that history. Ini ally like other entrepreneurs, Mr.
it may be a fraud or it is the responsibility Asif also explored the op on of obtaining
of government to collect and recycle waste. funding form banks but was not successful.
They were not ready to dole out any money He thus invested all his savings for this busi-
for the services. The banks did not fund the ness. His Friends and family also supported
capital cost for this business. However, Mr. him in his endeavor. A er some accomplish-
Asif did not give-up and remained persistent ments, he was able to get corporate spon-
in educa ng people about the hygienic con- sors. The startup cost for a small opera on
cept of business. can be as low as Rs. five million. However,
he went for full-scale opera ons with a recy-
CompeƟtors cling plant of US$ 12 Million.
Compe on is as inevitable in business
as death and taxes are in human existence. He provides franchising opportunity to
Even if your business is innova ve someone people in order to get funding. The basic
will imitate and beat you at your own game. condi on for franchising was an investment
Although Waste Buster has a formidable of Rs. 500,000. The company provides train-
market image but has intense compe on ings, promo on campaigns, na onwide me-
with Lahore Waste Management Compa- dia campaign, awareness campaigns, bro-
ny (LWMC), Zephyr Waste Solu ons, Petro chures and leaflets to the franchisee. Profit
78 Case Study
Market Forces Vol. X, No. 2
College of Management Sciences December 2015
References
i
Saqib, M. O., 2012, “ Young Entrepreneurs at Work”, DAWN, EBR Nov27- Dec 02
ii
Amanullah, S. 2014, “ Lessons in History for a Be er Future”, The Express Tribune Pakistan, Jul 14
iii
Abbas, H. 2013, “ Doing Business in Pakistan: Learn from sub-na onal peers”, Tribune, 08 Oct
iv
Spinelli, S. and Adams, R., 2008, New Venture Crea on: Entrepreneurship for the 21st Century, 9th edi on.
v
Jessop, S. 2014, “ A serial Entrepreneur’s Key Trait: Passion”, Interna onal New York Times, Oct 13
vi
Schwab, K. 2013, “ On the Innova on of Na ons”, Interna onal New York Times, Dec 16
Case Study 79