Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development of Ice Abrasive Waterjet PDF
Development of Ice Abrasive Waterjet PDF
Development of Ice Abrasive Waterjet PDF
net/publication/319279377
CITATIONS READS
0 1,041
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Joško Valentinčič on 31 August 2017.
ABSTRACT
Purpose: Abrasive water jet (AWJ) cutting uses mineral abrasive to cut practically all
materials. In ice abrasive water jet (IAWJ) cutting, the ice particles are used as abrasive.
IAWJ is under development with the aim to bridge the gap in productivity between the
abrasive water jet (AWJ) and water jet (WJ) cutting. It is clean and environmentally friendlier
in comparison with AWJ, while its cutting efficiency could be better than WJ.
Design/methodology/approach: The main challenge is to provide very cold and
thus hard ice particles in the cutting zone, thus cooling the water under high pressure is
utilized. Further on, two approaches to obtain ice particles in the water are studied, namely
generation of ice particles in the cutting head and generation of ice particles outside of the
cutting head and adding them to the jet similar as in AWJ technology. In this process it is
essential to monitor and control the temperature occurring in the system.
Findings: To have ice particles with suitable mechanical properties in the cutting process,
the water have to be precooled, ice particles generated outside the cutting head and
later added to the jet. The results show that, contrary to the common believe, the water
temperature is not significantly changed when passing through the water nozzle.
Research limitations/implications: The presence of ice particles was only indirectly
identified. In the future, a special high speed camera will be used to study the influence of
process parameters on ice particle distribution.
Practical implications: IAWJ technology produces much less sludge (waste abrasive and
removed workpiece material mixed with water) than AWJ technology which is beneficial in
e.g. disintegration of nuclear power plants. IAWJ technology has also great potential in the
food and medical industries for applications, where bacteria growth is not desired.
Originality/value: The paper presents the latest achievements of IAWJ technology.
Keywords: IAWJ machining; IceJet; Cryogenic gas; Ice abrasive
Reference to this paper should be given in the following way:
J. Valentinčič, A. Lebar, I. Sabotin, P. Drešar, M. Jerman, Development of ice abrasive
waterjet cutting technology, Journal of Achievements in Materials and Manufacturing
Engineering 81/2 (2017) 76-84.
76 Research paper © Copyright by International OCSCO World Press. All rights reserved. 2017
Volume 81 • Issue 2 • April 2017
1. Introduction
1. Introduction properties (e.g. hardness) of ice particles and consequently
machining ability is temperature dependent [6]. Generally,
Abrasive water jet (AWJ) machining process uses machining ability of ice particles increases with decreasing
a high speed water jet for acceleration of very hard abrasive temperature.
grains thus enabling the removal of work piece material.
The high speed waterjet is generated by pushing the water
under high pressure, up to 600 MPa, through the water
nozzle of a small diameter (from 0.08 mm to 0.4 mm) were
the potential energy is transformed to kinetic energy,
achieving supersonic speeds of the formed water jet. The
process is universal as it is possible to machine almost any
kind of material regardless of its composition, structure,
hardness or other physical properties. This makes it possi-
ble to machine different materials that cannot be machined
by traditional machining processes. AWJ machining tech-
nology has received considerable attention from several
domains of production industry due to this competitive
advantage.
In AWJ machining, the quantity of waste abrasive
material produced is huge compared to the quantity of
removed workpiece material. Handling of this sludge is Fig. 1. Phase diagram of ice for the range of water pressu-
usually not critical since abrasive material is non-toxic, but res and temperatures of interest [2]
in e.g. disintegration of nuclear power plants the quantity
of sludge plays an important role. Ice abrasive water jet Monitoring the temperatures at the inlet and outlet of
(IAWJ) technology, also named IceJet, uses ice grains the precooling system for in-process ice particle generation
instead of mineral abrasive that melt away after the system is reported [7]. The water was cooled from 25°C to
machining. The technology has also great potential in the -20°C. The dynamic characteristics of an ultra-high pres-
food and medical industries for applications, where the sure fine jet using the high speed camera was measured as
temperatures during cutting are desired to be as low as well as the properties of droplets using the Phase Doppler
possible to prevent bacteria growth. Only by precooling the Anemometry (PDA) [8]. It was discovered that at the
water under high pressure before the cutting head, the pressure of 200 MPa and a water orifice diameter of
temperatures on the cutting front are below 20°C [1]. It is 0.25 mm, the diameters of water droplets at the distance of
expected that the capability of IAWJ technology would be 90 mm from the orifice range from 75 µm at the middle
between pure WJ and AWJ technology. of the jet and 200 µm at the edge of the jet. This size is
The water can be cooled below 0°C at high pressures appropriate as the granulation of the most frequently use
and still remain liquid, with its lowest temperature of mineral abrasive of mesh #80 has in average the same size.
-22.1°C at pressure of 215.7 MPa [2] as shown in the phase This means that the bigger the droplet, the smaller the
diagram of water in Figure 1. velocity of the droplet. For IAWJ technology utilising in-
In [3] and [4], the effectiveness of the use of ice parti- process ice particle generation it is important to freeze
cles as a substitute for mineral abrasives is demonstrated. slower and bigger droplets as they spend more time in the
Investigation on application of ice powder for material mixing chamber and therefore they are longer the contact
processing is reported as well [5]. Among other the study with cooling media. Additionally, bigger droplets are at the
involved investigation of water freezing and formation of edge of the jet and are therefore better exposed to the
water, ice and air jet stream for cutting and cleaning purpo- cooling media.
ses. As reported in [4], one of critical issues is that when The other option is to generate ice particles outside of
ice particles come in contact with the surrounding air and the cutting head in a suitable vessel and adding them to the
relatively hot jet of water, they are melted too fast. The waterjet in a similar manner as in AWJ technology. In this
temperature of the water jet is therefore a critical parameter paper, both ice particle generation systems are evaluated. In
that should be monitored and controlled. It is important to both cases, water under high pressure, i.e. after the high
consider the temperature of ice particles, since mechanical pressure pump and before the cutting head was precooled
to -10°C. Further on, the areas of the main temperature down to -25°C. High pressure pipes where water flows
build up were identified. from the high pressure pump to the cutting head were bent
into a coil and submerged in the glycol. The temperature of
the cooling medium was regulated in order to achieve the
2.
2. Work
Work methodology
methodology desired temperature before the cutting head. Pipes leading
from the heat exchanger to the cutting head were thermally
In order to perform the water temperature measu- insulated using 20 mm thick insulating foam (Armaflex,
rements on our IAWJ prototype, a custom made 2-axis Armacel, DE). Thermocouples were positioned as shown in
AWJ cutting system was designed and assembled in the Figure 3 to monitor the temperature.
laboratory of the authors and is shown in Figure 2. It is
equipped with a high pressure direct drive pump (P-2040,
Omax, USA), with maximal pressure up to 280 MPa and
flow rate of 3.2 l/min. The cutting head (Allfi, AT) was
connected to the high pressure pump using two high
pressure pipe lines controlled by two 3-way valves V2 and
V3 and a check valve V4, so that the water could be
directed either directly to the cutting head or through the
heat exchanger unit, positioned in between as shown in
Figure 3.
2.2. In-processice
2.2. In-process iceparticle
particle generation
generation
2.4. Temperaturemeasurements
2.4. Temperature measurements
2.3.
2.3.Ice
Iceparticle
particlegeneration
generationoutside thethe
outside cutting
cutting
headhead
Acknowledgements
4. Conclusions
4. Conclusions
References
References
A holistic view on the IAWJ prototype machine is
[1] M. Jerman, H. Orbanić, M. Junkar, A. Lebar, Thermal
presented. The water temperature measurements on diffe-
aspects of ice abrasive water jet technology, Advances
rent parts of the system have been used to identifythe
in Mechanical Engineering 7/8 (2015) 1-9, doi:
places of heat generation.
10.1177/1687814015597619.
While the heat generation on the cutting front cannot be
avoided, the results show that cooling the water under high [2] H.T. Liu, E. Schubert, Piercing in delicate materials
pressure lowers the jet temperature in a linear fashion. The with abrasive-waterjets, International Journal of Ad-
water under high pressure is heated only during its vanced Manufacturing Technology 42/3-4 (2009) 263-
compression in the high-pressure pump; afterwards, its 279, doi: 10.1007/s00170-008-1583-5.
temperature is changed (usually cooled) only by the heat [3] E. Geskin, L. Tismenetskiy, F. Li, Development of Ice
exchange with the ambient air through the pipe walls. Jet Machining Technology, NJIT, 8th American Water
Flowing through the pressure regulating valve had no effect Jet Conference, Houston, TX, 26-29 August 1995,
on the temperature. No heat generation in the water nozzle 671-680.
could be observed as it was covered with frozen conden- [4] P. Truchot, P. Mellinger, R. Duchamp, Development
sation during the tests at -10°C. The temperature can be of a Cryogenic water jet technique for biomaterial
lowered even further; however, stability of the process processing applications, 6th American Water Jet Con-
worsens when approaching -20°C, especially when using ference, 17-19 August, Houston, TX, WJTA, Omni-
water nozzles with smaller diameters as a result of lower press: paper 3-G, 1991, 473-480.
flow rates. [5] D.V. Shishkin, Development of Icejet machining
It was found that water temperature is not significantly technology, NJIT, Thesis, 1999.
changed when passing through the water nozzle. If the [6] P. Hoobs, Ice Physics, Clarendon Press, Oxford,
water is cooled before the water nozzle, then theWJ England, 1974.
temperature remains low as well, meaning that theice [7] F. Bach, T. Hassel, C. Biskup, N. Hinte, A. Schenk,
particles could be formed inside. However, according to the F. Pude, In-process generation of water ice particles
revised literature, because temperatures were above -20°C, for cutting and cleaning purposes, BHR Group, 20th
the ice particles formed in such a waywould not have International Conference on Water Jetting, 20-22
adequate mechanical properties for machining purposes. October 2010, Graz, Austria, 275-283.
[8] Y.L. Wang, M.G. Yang, B. Gao, C. Kang, B. Chen, New Frontiers of Instrum. and Methods for Electrical
Measurement of ultra-high pressure waterjet, 20th and Electronic Measurements; 13th TC21 Interna-
International Conference on Water Jetting, 20-22 tional Workshop on ADC Modelling and Testing,
October 2010, Graz, Austria, 317-328. Joint Session, Proc. Florence, Italy, 2008, 761-766.
[9] M. Jerman, H. Orbanić, A. Lebar, I. Sabotin, I. [12] A. Lebar, M. Junkar, A. Poredoš, M. Cvjeticanin,
Etxebrria, A. Suárez, M. Junkar, Presentation of the Method for online quality monitoring of AWJ cutting
IceJet prototype development, Proceedings of the 13th by infrared thermography, CIRP Journal of Manufa-
International Conference on Management of Inno- cturing Science and Technology 2, 2010, 170-175.
vative Technologies, September 2014, Fiesa, Slovenia, [13] M. Jerman, H. Orbanić, I. Etxeberria, A. Suarez, M.
26-33. Junkar, A. Lebar, Measuring the water temperature
[10] M. Jerman, H. Orbanić, A. Lebar, I. Sabotin, P. changes throughout the abrasive water jet cutting
Drešar, J. Valentinčič, Measuring the Water Tempe- system, 2011 WJTA American Waterjet Conference,
rature Changes in Ice Abrasive Water Jet Prototype, 19-21 September, Houston, TX, 2011, 12-20.
Procedia Engineering 149 (2016) 163-168, doi: [14] R. Kovačević, M. Hashish, R. Mohan, M. Ramulu,
10.1016/j.proeng.2016.06.651. T.J. Kim, E.S. Geskin, State of the Art of Research
[11] M. Annoni, L. Cristaldi, M. Faifer, M. Norgia, Orifice and Development in Abrasive Waterjet Machining,
coefficients evaluation for water jet applications. 16th Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering
IMEKO TC4 International Symposium on Exploring 119/4B (1997) 776-785, doi:10.1115/1.2836824.