Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 - Review of Lietrature
2 - Review of Lietrature
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.1 INTRODUCTION
It is mandatory to review the literature available with respect to the area of the
research study. Measuring the performance of the corporate sector has always been
an area of controversies from the point of view of the government, shareholders,
prospective investors, creditors, employees and any other stakeholder. Several
studies have been undertaken to evaluate the financial performance in the corporate
sector through financial statement analysis (FSA). This chapter presents some of
the examples of various studies conducted by financial analysts.
Desal (2000), has assessed that capital structure of Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd., for 10
years from 1980-81 to 1990-91 and found out that the real value of the equity
shares has been far below their book value and also inconsistent during the entire
period of study. He has found out that the company’s capital structure was
imbalanced and over capitalized financial plans has continued for a long period of
time, preventing the company from earning profits. In his study, though he has
discussed on various models of prediction of sickness, he has applied Altman’s Z
score model and has identified that from the year 1980-81, till the latest year 1990-
91, Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd., has been scoring less than the minimum cut off value
of 2.675 as suggested by Altman. He has also applied Argent’s score system for a
subjective evaluation of defects in management and accounting mistakes and
symptoms. He has concluded by analyzing the reasons for the sickness of the
company.
Georege Gallinger (2000), has examined the frame work of financial statement
analysis in terms of five parts. The first part of his study has focused on “Return-
on-assets performance”. It has examined the profitability of Salton company. He
has examined the components related to return on sales and asset management in
depth. According to him, inefficient asset management will result in destroyed
market value of the company and will probably cause financial distress problems
which may even result in bankruptcy. He has also revealed that if the weighted
average cost of capital on a before - tax basis exceeds the return-on-asset, the
company would need to improve the performance through higher return on sales,
increased asset turnover or both.
Ganesan (2001), has selected state bank group (8 units) and 19 private sector banks
as sample to identify the determinants of profits and profitability. The empirical
examination of profit function shows that interest cost, interest income, other
income, deposits per branch and credit to total assets proposition of priority sector
advances and interest income loss are the significant determinants of profits and
profitability of Indian public sector banks. The study has also identified the fact that
banking sector reforms and individual bank’s policies towards directed investments
and direct credit Programmes have played a significant role in improving the profits
and profitability of banking sector.
Sathis Chandra (2001) has made a case study on “Trade Credit and Company
Liquidity” with special reference to steel authority of India Ltd., and Tata Iron and
Steel Ltd., to find out if more liquid companies give relatively more net trade credit
in squeeze years. Ratio analysis and multiple regression analysis have been
employed. Liquidity has been taken as the independent variable and inventory
turnover ratio, inventory holding period, debtors’ turnover ratio and average
collection period have been taken as independent variable and the relationship has
been measured.
Dyal Bhatnagar and Chandra Shekhar (2001), in their study have made an
attempt to measure the financial performance through MVA analysis. For the
purpose of research, a total sample of 56 companies listed on Bombay Stock
Exchange (BSE) were drawn and classified into five industrial categories. The data
pertains to ten years viz. 1988-89 to 1997-98. The multiple regression modal was
used to explore as to which of the Independent variables viz., Economic Value
Added (EVA), Earning Per share (EPS), Return on Capital Employed (ROCE), Net
present Value (NPV) Capital Productivity (CP) and Labour Productivity (LP) was
more capable of explaining movements in share prices in each industry. The
analysis revealed that EVA was the most significantly related variable with MVA.
In case of infrastructure Industry Capital Productivity (CP) was most significantly
related to MVA. The analysis with regard to miscellaneous industry revealed that
both EPS and EVA were significant variables which explained movements in
MVA.
G. Sundarsana Reddy (2003), In his study an attempt has been made to access an
evaluation of financial performance of paper industries in Andhra Pradesh to
Evaluate the Financing Method to analyse the Investment pattern and utilization of
fixed assets to ascertain the working capital conditions, to review the profitability
performance and to suggest measures to improve profitability.
G.Sudarsana Reddy (2003), Finance is the nerve centre and lifeline of any
economic activity and is, therefore, omnipresent in every sphere of economic and
business life. It plays an extremely crucial role in the continuity and growth of a
business. Financial Management has been viewed as an integral part of overall
management. An enterprise, which commits itself to an activity, requires finance.
No business firm can be promoted, established and expanded without adequate
financial resources. Success and survival of a business firm depends on how well
its finance function is managed. The firm may have abundant resources – human
and physical, but if the available funds are not properly utilized for the benefit of
the firm. It will come to an early end. So, the finance manager has to utilize the
available funds for the benefit of the business firm. Every effort should be made to
render the finance function as effective as possible. Successful financial
management of a business firm is manifested by certain benefits, like increased
profitability, raising share prices, regular dividends to shareholders, attractive
remuneration to employees and in short, the all-round progress of the company.
Financial performance analysis constitutes the approach to judge the effectiveness
of the finance function of the firm.
Reddy and Patkar (2004), have attempted to make a comparative study on SBI
and CAN bank factors of working capital and liquidity management factoring,
based on the following objectives. 1) To study the size the composition of working
capital 2) to evaluate the liquidity management through ratio analysis and 3) to
examine the relationship between liquidity and profitability. It is concluded that the
higher liquidity is maintained in CAN Bank correlations which is inversely related
with other. It implies that as the liquidity increases the profitability decreases.
Narware, P.C. and Vivek Sharma (2004), conducted a study based on the
objectives to assess the efficiency of the liquidity management of the company of
HPCL and to examine the liquidity position of the company by training measure of
cash and bank. It was observed from the analysis that the liquidity position of the
company is very poor and the liquid assets were not sufficient in meeting short term
liabilities. In sum, the liquidity management of HPCL in very poor and is not
satisfactory.
Rafiq Dossani - Stanford University (2004), The paper explains the evolution of
India’s software industry - Domestic entrepreneur emerges as the key factor for
origination, survival and innovation, in a hostile industrial policy environment. The
maturing of the industry required a shift to a supportive government policy.
Maturation was also critically enabled by the modularization of the programming
function through new technologies. These changes favoured domestic firms that
provided programming services. Later policy and technological changes induced
transnational entry and led to higher value - added output. The paper shows that
technologically sophisticated industries can develop even when many conditions
typically present elsewhere are missing. We provide conditions under which this
may happen and show their effect on subsequent developments.
Royal Danish Embassy (2004), The economic outlook for India is positive. A
growth rate of above 8% was achieved by the Indian economy during the year 2003
-04 and it reached 6.9% in 2004 - 05. Growth in the Indian economy has steadily
increased since 1979. In fact, the Indian economy has posted an excellent average.
GDP growth of 6.8% since 1994 -Many factors are behind this robust performance
of the Indian economy in 2004 - 05. High growth rates in industry & service sector
and world economic environment provided a back drop conducive to growth of the
Indian economy. Another positive feature is that prices have been relatively stable.
Chalam G.V and Prasad A. (2006), in his study, an attempt has been made to
measure the overall financial performance of sample of nine selected primary
agricultural co-operative societies in west Godavari District in Andhra Pradesh
have been taken. To measure the financial performance of Jeelugumilli,
Reddygangapovaram, Krishnaropeta, Jangareddygudem, Nallajerla, Pothavaram,
Pulla, Lakshmaneswaram and Mogalturu societies for the period 1993-94 to 2003-
2004 statistical tools such as mean, correlation and standard normal distribution
were used. In his study, sixteen variable been selected, in the first instance for the
purpose of construing the scale. The performance of those societies, which get a
scale value of 1, are poor, whereas those that get a scale value of 3 are good; a scale
value of 2 indicates satisfactory performance. Based on the above criteria,
Nallojeria, Pulla and Mogaltur societies are good. Jellugumilli and
Lakshmaneswaram societies are satisfactory. Reddyganapovaram, Krishnaraopeta,
Potavaram and Jangareddygudem societies are poor.
Sushma Vishnani and Bhupesk Kr Shah (2006) 81, have made an empirical study
of 23 Indian Consumer Electronics Industry for assessing the impact of working
capital on profitability during the period 1994-95 to 2004-05. The impact of
working capital on profitability has been examined by computing co-efficient of
correlation and regression analysis between profitability ratio and working capital
ratio. The correlation analysis of industry - wide pooled data revealed a very weak
positive correlation and that too not at all statistically significant. Thus, it may be
concluded that there is no uniform correlations (positive or negative) between
liquidity and profitability in industry as a whole; rather it varies from company to
company in the respective industry. The regression analysis of industry wide
pooled data revealed a positive association between liquidity and probability. It
indicated that if current ratio varies by 1 time, return on capital employed shall
increase by 1.58 per cent. However, statistical significance as well as magnitude of
the regression equation was very poor which makes it less reliable. Thus, it may be
concluded that there is no uniformed relationship (positive or negative) between
liquidity and profitability in industry as a whole; rather it varies from company to
company in the industry.
N.R. Parasuram (2006), has made an attempt identify and study the movement of
key financial parameters and their relationship with profitability of automobile
industry he also made an attempt to and the study whether the key identified
parameters move in a synchronous way going up and coming down with basic
profitability parameters. The Two wheeler and three wheeler industries chosen and
all comparably profit making companies have been taken as the sample, for study
for the period of 2002 to 2004. The data have been taken from the figures supplied
by prowess database. On the basis of this data a trend parameter is calculated for
the year 2005. The actual figures in respect of the year 2005 are compared with the
trend parameter by way of T-test. So, on the base of the analysis, the broad
conclusion is that the parameters are consistent within a wide horizon and with the
growth that companies have achieved, the parameters have also responded in a
synchronous manner.
Sanjay J.Bhayani (2006), in his study an attempt has been made to study the cost
component of cement units under the study. For the purpose of analysis of cost
component, all component cost has been calculated as percentage of sales. A study
has been made by using data form financial statements of top five cement
companies of India, viz., Gujarat Cement, Ambuja Cements Ltd. (GALL), Dalmia
Cement Ltd. (DCL), Madras cement Ltd., (MCL), Indian Cements Ltd., (ICL) and
Shree Cements Ltd., (SCL). The data of total cost in various cement companies
under study have been rearranged and classified under the following heads, Raw
materials and stores consumed salaries and wages, indirect taxes, power and fuel,
depreciation, administrative selling and distribution and other expenses and
financial charges. He found out from his study that the most influencing factor in
cost structure of cement industry is power and fuel cost. The portion of this cost in
total cost was 21 per cent, where the portion of raw materials and cost and selling
and distribution and other cost in total cost structure were 19.27 per cent 16.60 per
cent respectively. So it can be concluded that to improve the profitabi1ity of units
there is a need to give proper attention towards this cost by Corporates. The closest
view of analysis showed that the average cost in almost all element of GACL was
closer to the average of industry.
Jyoti Gupta (2006), “The Indian economy is dominated by family owned groups”.
These include the recently created companies in the software industry and also
industrial groups with a long history. These groups are characterized by their
diversity of activities and their ability to maintain their control over all the
companies they manage. The objective of this research is to analyze the
performance of the different companies managed by the family and compare them
with other companies in the same sector group. The idea is to test whether they
create incremental value for their shareholders. The research is intended to be both
cases based and empirical in nature.
Subash Chander and Priyanka Aggarwal (2007), in their study, an attempt was
made to identify the determinants of growth of select companies in drugs and
pharmaceutical industry in India. It is based on a sample of 50 firms drawn from
the list of companies in drugs and pharmaceutical industry given in the prowess
database developed by Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE). It covers a
period of ten years from 1995-96 to 2004-05. The growth of firms is measured in
terms of growth in average total assets and average in total sales. Interest to study
the determinants of growth, ten explanatory variables was chosen for empirical
investigation. Multiple regression analysis is used to develop a model to identify
the determinants of growth of firms in this industry. The results revel that size,
advertising expenditure, age, efficiency ratio, profitability and research and
development are statistically significant in determining the growth of firms in drugs
and pharmaceutical industry.
Siddharth Mahajan and Mainak Sarkar (2007), in his study, an attempt has been
made to compare the financial performance of three Indian companies, Tata motors,
Maruti and Mahindra & Mahindra with two MNCs, Honda and Hyundai. Ten ratios
have been used. There are four profitability ratios, four liquidity ratios and two
solvency ratios. The profitability ratios used are profit margin, asset turnover,
return on assets and return on equity. The liquidity ratios, used are current ratio,
quick ratio, debtor turnover and inventory turnover ratio. The solvency ratios used
are debt to equity ratio and interest coverage ratio. In profitability ratio, the profit
margin is roughly the same for the Indian companies and for the MNCs.
The asset turnover and return on assets of the MNCs are roughly double that of
Indian Companies. This indicates that the MNCs are more efficient at utilizing their
assets to generate profits. However, the return on equity of the Indian Companies is
about ten times that of the MNCs. In liquidity ratios, the current ratio, the quick
ratio and the inventory turnover ratio are roughly the same for the Indian
Companies and for the MNCs. This indicates that the Indian companies and the
MNCs both follow similar practices and have similar performance in working
capital management of inventories. In solvency ratios, the debt to equity ratio of the
Indian companies is about one-and-half times that of the MNCs. This is because the
Indian Companies use much less equity capital that the MNCs. Also the interest
coverage ratio of the MNCs is about four times that of the Indian Companies. This
is because the MNCs use more equity financing and less debt financing.
Rathore and Pinki Rai (2007), have made an effort to analyse the financial
performance of Air India limited from the year 2002-03 to 2004-05. To analyze the
financial performance of Air India Limited the following parameters have been
taken for the study: (a) capital structure (b) working capital (c) profitability position
and (d) operating performance. They found from their study that working capital
was showing negative trend and profitability position of the company was showing
tremendous fluctuating trend during the study period. The operating performance of
the company during the study period was not satisfactory because of percentage of
change in operating cost was more than the percentage of change in operating
profit. To improve the financial performance of Air India Limited they suggested
that the best way to manage and run the airlines is partial or full privatization and
give them full autonomy in their functioning.
RBI study (2007), an attempt was made to study the financial performs of 1064
large non-government public limited companies (each with paid-up capital of Rs.1
crore and above) during 2005-06 based on their audited annual account closed
during April 2005 to March 2006. The consolidated result of the study revealed
continuous improvement in the performance of the companies viewed from the
growth in sales, value of production, gross profits, profits after tax, profits retained
and net worth in 2005-06 when compared to 2004-05. The profitability and profit
allocation ratios like profit margin and profit after tax to net worth also increased
during the year under review. External sources of funds played an important role in
financing the asset formation during the year 2005-06.
Ali Ghanbari and More (2007), in their study an attempt has been made to
empirically tests the strength of the relationship between EVA and MVA in Indian
Automobile Companies for the period between 2001 to 2005. Five independent
variables [EVA, ROA, ROCE, EPS and NOPAT] have been chosen to analyze their
impact on one dependent variable (MVA). Through correlation analysis, it has been
observed that MVA is positively correlated with EVA and all other financial
indicators, but only the correlation between MUA, and EVA and NOPAT are
significant at 1 per cent level. The co-efficient of correlation of MVA with EVA
and NOPAT were 0.7408 and 0.7271 respectively. It indicates that EVA was the
most explanatory measure and more closely associated with MVA than the other
performance measures such as EPS, NOPAT, ROA and ROCE.
Laurie Cohen and Amal El-Sawad (2007), “An examination of UK and Indian
financial service employees’ accounts of themselves and one another”, this article
is about employees’ lived experiences of off shoring. Focusing on the accounts of
individuals in a financial services company operating in the UK and in Mumbai,
India, it examines the ways in which respondents constructed and positioned
themselves in relation to one another in the stories they told. They argue that in
their accounts of their respondents mobilized discourses of culture and cultural
difference to describe and justify this positioning, with particular reference to ‘the
language barrier’, work ethics and notions of competence.
Mathur, Somesh Kumar (2007), Indian IT industry - India’s software and services
exports have been raising rapidly. The annual growth rate ranges between 20 - 22%
in IT services and nearly 55% in IT - enabled services (ITES), such as call centers,
Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and other administrative support operations.
Together they are predicted to grow at 25% pa till 2010. The IT industry is highly
export oriented and the exporters are predominantly Indian. The Indian BPO’s
(ITES) are moving up the value chain, handling high end data for airline
information, insurance, banking sector and mortgage companies, enterprise
resource planning among others. Some of the companies have already moved into
significantly higher value added segments such as mission critical applications,
development and support, product design, HR Management, knowledge process
outsourcing for pharmaceutical companies and large complex project.
Dr. S. Kasturi Rangan (2008, in his study an attempt has been made to identify
the factors determining the profitability of the banks through partial correlation co
efficient for the period from march 2000 to 2007. The banks were categorized into
5 different groups for the purposes of analysis. The group in which banks were
divided are: Nationalized bank group (NB), State Bank group (SB), Old Private
sector banks (OP), New generation Private Sector banks (NP) and Foreign banks
group (FB). The financial position of a total of 74 banks have been considered for
the study the profit was taken as the net profit reported by the banks in their
published accounts submitted to the RBI and the major determinants of profitability
of a bank are: Internet Spread, other income and Operating expenses. It can be
concluded from the study that the negative correlation between operating expenses
and profits and the high degree of association between interest spread, other income
and profits in the case of foreign banks, state bank group, and nationalized banks
indicate that these banks should concentrate on improving the interest spread and
other income rather than on cost cutting measures. In the case of old generation
private sector banks, the high degree of correlation between profit and other income
suggests that these banks should concentrate on generating non-operational income
in order to boost their profitability. Cost plays a significant role in the profits in the
case of new generation private sector banks. Hence these banks should concentrate
on cutting cost to improve profitability.
S. Dharma Lingam (2009), In his study an attempt has been made to access an
evaluation of financial performance of large scale cement industry in India
examining in terms of profitability liquidity financial health and value creation to
its share holds. The Scope of Financial Performance is very wide and the study is
based on accounting Information.
Nasscom Survey (2009), Nasscom announced the findings of its annual survey on
the performance of the Indian IT - BPO services sector for FY - 2008 - 09 and
outlook for FY - 2009 -10. According to the finding, the IT sector reached US$58.8
billion in FY 2008 09 in revenue, up from US$52 billion in FY 2007 - 08.
S.Kalaiselvi (2009) The Indian IT industry has not only been among the fastest
growing industries globally, it has played a key role in transforming India from a
largely inward looking economy to an emerging knowledge power that is today
perceived as being one of the most dynamic and entrepreneurial in the world. In
1991, the IT industry was oldest sized, employing 12000 persons and contributing
an insignificant incremental contributor to GDP, with 6 % coming from the sector.
Around 95 present of the absolute growth in foreign exchange inflows in the
service sector during this period is estimated to have come from the IT and BPO
industries alone.
K.Srinivasa Rao (2009), “Indian capital market spread of equity culture”, The
term ‘Capital Market’ refers to all the facilities and the institutional arrangements
for borrowing and lending long-term capital. In other words “it is the centre or
arrangement that provides facilities for buying and selling of long-term financial
instruments such as shares and debentures”. Capital market may be defined as the
mechanism which co-ordinates the demand and supply forces of long-term capital.
It deals in shares, debentures and bonds of corporations and securities of the
government. The term “Equity Culture” refers to the practice of buying equity
shares either in primary market or in secondary market.
N. Murugan (2010)108, in his study an attempt has been made to ascertain a study
on financial performance of the select Sarvodaya sanghams in Tamil Nadu to the
Productivity status of the sanghams in terms of Inventory, Current assets turnover,
Working Capital turnover, Debtors turn over, Creditors turnover, Capital fund turn
over, fixed assert turnover and total asserts turnover ratio.
Jayesh Kariya and Karishma Nagar (2010), Over the last two decades,
Information Technology and enabled Services (‘ITS’) sector has been quite
instrumental in driving India’s economy and growth. This is primarily due to the
liberalization of Foreign Direct investment policy, granting of Income - tax benefits
to foreign exchange earning to entities in this sector, availability of skilled work -
force and the cost advantage of such operations in India. Dependent upon the
import of high- tech products and component, the historical performance of the
hardware sector, however, had not been less commendable before. Brunner (1991)
had shown how successive policy regime helped the Indian computer hardware
industry achieve maturity in terms of technological competence. The domestic IT
industry which was earlier dominated by the hardware sector has been rapidly
shifting towards software. The share of hardware, which was about 60 per cent in
1994 - 95, has dipped to 46% in 1998 - 99. This has been accompanied by a sudden
spurt in growth of software industry.
A review of literature has been made to establish the validity of the research topic
‘Financial Statement Analysis of National Aluminium Company Limited. Various
theories pertaining to profits, profitability, liquidity, bankruptcy and value added
measures, propounded by various financial analysts have been reviewed for the span of
more than one decade in this chapter to find out the research gap.
References